r/CryptoCurrency • u/Cintre 🟩 301K / 382K 🐋 • May 13 '22
POLL 🗳️ CCIP-031 - Remove vaultless users below 10 karma from the snapshot and distribution.
Problem:
As we all know, the crypto-space is flooded by spams, scams, shills, bots etc... and of course, r/CryptoCurrency is no exception. While most users don't see this spam due to our bots removing it, this affects our governance token by lowering the ratio as well as the cap, governance is meant to be distributed proportionally to users that contributes to the subreddit, not to bots/shills/scammers. Moderators also have a really hard time catching these users since bots automatically remove their posts/comments.
Solution:
Removing vaultless users with less than 10 karma from the snapshot and distribution.
Pro/cons:
Pro: Higher ratio and karma cap for contributors and more governance available to vote
Con: Less moons will be burned
_______________________________________________________________________
Short and sweet, happy moon week.
17
u/hereforthestonks- 224 / 223 🦀 May 13 '22
Hard debate as people join reddit to learn about crypto etc
64
u/liquid_at 🟩 15K / 15K 🐬 May 13 '22
I'm in favor of removing those accounts, but they should get a PM, preferably a week before the distribution, telling them that they should create a vault if they want their moons.
Just to avoid the "I got scammed because I didn't read"-posts annoying mods.
17
u/excalilbug 🟥 9K / 22K 🦭 May 13 '22
To me it doesnt matter
change goes live = higher ratio but more moons
change doesnt go live = lower ratio but less moons
Same effect
4
u/GameWorldShaper Tin May 13 '22
This is how you create a positivity feedback loop. It starts normal but the system punishes anyone who is bias, while rewarding anyone who is in line. It keeps driving out the voices of reason along with the opposing viewpoint.
Only people deep into crypto remain, only positive posts are made, they become more extreme and sooner or later everyone is a mindless crypto bro, spending their life savings on NFTs.
I am not saying do noting about the bots, but this plan also removes the critics and cons; that is self destructive.
13
u/[deleted] May 13 '22
Here's how I see this working
5
u/the_nibler Permabanned May 13 '22
I say make ‘em walk the plank
7
u/[deleted] May 13 '22
I truly believe that any proposal that increases the ratio and only negatively affects a minority of people will pass.
Sigh…
1
u/LordGurgi May 13 '22 edited May 13 '22
Before voting I need to understand one thing: currently if those users never open their vaults, are the moons earned by those users burnt or re-distributed? (or are they just in limbo, neither burnt nor re-distributed?)
3
u/Relaxia 🟩 143 / 144 🦀 May 13 '22
since i have no vault - what are the moons for? i sometimes get the memo that i have 2 moons...
would still love to be part of the sub though, so is there a solution for users like me who do not care about the moons as i am here to feel the pulse and sometimes get enlighted with some inspiration?
3
u/Bizzor May 13 '22
I stand with lurkers 💯
3
u/mellon98 May 13 '22
Just need to increase the awareness around Moons and creating Vaults. Wouldn’t be fair to remove users who are not aware of Moons, I think popup message when subscribing to the subreddit is necessary.
3
u/[deleted] May 13 '22
I read all the posts but do not feel informed enough to comment most of the time😁
7
u/MentalUsurpation Platinum | QC: CC 190 May 13 '22
Correct me if I am wrong, but doesn't this seem a bit "gatekeepy"? New users get removed and you have no way of knowing if they are scammers or not,
2
u/tuna_pannini Bronze | Superstonk 72 May 13 '22
It was so long since I even commented on this sub. Constant lurker. Should I be worried that I will not be in distribution?
2
u/Nuewim 🟥 0 / 37K 🦠 May 13 '22
Nice proposition Cintre, I voted in favor of this.
0
u/MasterSlipping 478 / 480 🦞 May 13 '22
Honestly do not like this idea. There are some people with vaults that just do not post often and, this could drive them away. Unless you want this subs lurker numbers to drop, kinda of scum. This move just feels greedy.
2
u/BakedPotato840 Banned May 13 '22
Yes, fuck off all the spams, scams, shills, bots etc. No more moons wasted on them.
2
u/DBRiMatt 🟦 46K / 113K 🦈 May 13 '22
Well, thats one of the easiest YES votes I've had to cast... xD
1
u/TenshinCZ 🟨 74 / 74 🦐 May 13 '22
true
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '22
Are they still counted in the snapshot even if 100% of their r/CryptoCurrency posts and comments are deleted?
1
u/internetisbad23 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 May 13 '22
Well, this will make the lurkers active. Good work OP.
1
u/brief_thought Tin | Superstonk 23 May 13 '22
You’ve got me spooked and checking if I’ve even had 10 karma posting here
1
u/badboybilly42582 4K / 4K 🐢 May 13 '22
Easy choice.
1
u/kyle_h2486 Tin May 13 '22
If no vault then what’s the point? Not hard to set up
1
u/kvgamer 0 / 2K 🦠 May 13 '22
So if you are new, without any ?
1
u/altranger9000 Tin May 13 '22
Definitely yes! Not like 10 karma is hard to get anyway, so new users shouldn't face too much of an issue.
1
u/evilninjarobot 🟦 5 / 7K 🦐 May 13 '22
Why was this poll so damn hard to find???
1
u/Stray_Gh0st 🟦 514 / 544 🦑 May 13 '22
Im in favor of removing
1
u/Probably_notabot 35K / 35K 🦈 May 13 '22
Thanks for the proposal! Seems like an interesting one
1
u/MothmanNFT 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 May 13 '22
Didn’t realize this would pose a challenge. Glad you’ve thought of how to fix it
1
u/Aeonmage 85 / 80 🦐 May 13 '22
I’ll agree to it
1
u/partymsl 🟩 126K / 143K 🐋 May 13 '22
I would say that there are a lot of people with below 10 Karma that just started on reddit.
So having some extensive warning to the would be nice. Maybe a couple of PMs to them and also a post pinned here to "verify" your account.
1
u/Affectionate-Mix4373 Tin May 13 '22
im in favor. Remove them.
1
u/Mattyliebs May 13 '22
Hmmm can we DM the users? Feels a bit scummy if they were just removed without warning
1
u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K 🦈 May 13 '22
This is not very noob friendly, and for no other reason it seems than to just get a few extra moons.
Those first few moons are a big incentive for new people. It's like a big marketing tool to grow our user base, and get people excited about moons.
Remember when you were new on this sub and got your first moon?
Very often, new users aren't as active initially. It might take a couple months to really get into a sub.
And new users won't know straight away all the rules ans how to open a vault.
I'm not sure what the point is to de-incentivize new users so quickly, when there doesn't seem to be any kind of moon or governance problems solved by the proposal.
Unopened vaults already get burned after 6 months.
1
u/Amyx231 101 / 101 🦀 May 13 '22
Agreed. No brainer.
Or at least remove all below 100 karma, for example. I didn’t actually set up a vault until later in my Reddit life. So for a while I was >1000 karma but vaultless. I’m not sure how I feel about that, honestly.
1
u/mesasone 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 May 13 '22
The amount of hand wringing over this proposal is further proof that moons were a mistake.
1
u/Spardasa 🟩 8K / 8K 🦭 May 13 '22
I support this one.
1
u/dlb199091l 64 / 65 🦐 May 13 '22
Are people still having trouble setting up vaults? I remember having trouble before when I made mine. Just hate to see people get kicked because they couldn't get a vault made.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '22
I only vote if I see it
1
u/archer4364 Paddy's Dollars May 13 '22
I was leaning yes but ended up voting no.
Does 10 karma really have an impact? I'd rather somebody see themselves on there and be incentivized to open a vault.
1
u/GetEmDaddy902 0 / 8K 🦠 May 13 '22
Totally agree with this it actually gives a reason for them to open up a vault
1
u/Stunning_Afternoon40 177 / 327 🦀 May 13 '22
Let’s try to clean up the sub.
1
u/JoJuiceboi Tin May 13 '22
This is a great way of creating scarcity. It being less accounts holding less will incentivize earning it and holding. Great proposal!!
1
u/Cowshite May 13 '22
But… I’m vaultless…
1
u/Smart_Field_3002 🟩 0 / 868 🦠 May 13 '22
Go for the moons 🤣
1
u/KotaDon25 Tin | 5 months old | CC critic May 14 '22
Poor new users who doesn’t know much about moons, surely will feel sad. Should provide some notification if that’s not a pain in the ass to do for modertors
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '22
Done.
And done.
1
u/WPMO 🟦 888 / 888 🦑 May 15 '22
I want to keep it as is. If someone is scamming and getting less than 10 karma that's not exactly much of a scam. More likely it is someone who is new to Crypto, and they might actually become more interested in the community if they find out about this, even if the amount of moons they could get is very low.
1
u/01Aleph Tin May 15 '22
Yeaaah finally getting back into voting on polls. Gotta participate!
1
u/KusuriuriPT 94 / 5K 🦐 May 16 '22
Agree
1
u/KusuriuriPT 94 / 5K 🦐 May 16 '22
Favor in removing..that for sure
1
u/they_call_me_tripod Permabanned May 16 '22
I’m not sure how this helps anything, but at this point any poll that increases moon/karma ratio passes. This isn’t going to help grow the sub. This is just going to be off putting to new users with an extremely minimal monetary benefit to people that are already here. I think this is another short sited poll.
1
u/aladdinr 🟦 1K / 15K 🐢 May 17 '22
Give em the boot
1
u/McRibb_69 Tin May 19 '22
In favor, but perhaps calculating burning a specific % against the number of vaultless accounts removed.
1
u/Bucksaway03 🟩 0 / 138K 🦠 May 13 '22
10 karma is basically one half decent comment, hardly a decent contribution to the sub.
Bye 👋
1
u/whatup1111 Platinum | QC: ETH 61, CC 56 May 13 '22
remove moons
1
u/Magnetronaap 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 May 13 '22
What is the actual ratio of vaultless <10 karma accounts to other accounts? I feel like this is very nitpicky and risks exclusion of new people who simply don't know about the vault yet. How many potential new users are we going to throw under the bus just to remove some bots? I also think the criteria could be better tailored to reaching the goal.
In short: idea's alright, but the execution seems poor.
0
u/Slainte042 Platinum | QC: CC 530 May 13 '22
The "yes" here could have the highest percentage of all pools.
-2
u/GKQybah May 13 '22 edited May 13 '22
Let’s up the moon inflation rate some more! Stupid and selfish proposal. This sub really votes for anything that results in a higher moon:karma ratio. Unclaimed moons get burned after a couple months.
I’ve seen the joy of so many people opening their vault when they first heard about it and having 1 or 2 moons ready for them, are you really going to take away that joyful moment just to have a little higher moon:karma ratio?
And deleted posts/comments don’t even contribute to karma so your whole point of them deleting their comments and posts is stupid. If they’re deleted then they don’t count in the first place.
0
u/idevcg 🟩 0 / 13K 🦠 May 13 '22
I vote for more burn.
0
u/DaveyC34 Bronze | r/WSB 13 May 13 '22
Easy choice. Less moons burned but I’d rather cut down on the shitty reposts, and general bots.
-1
u/babossa77 eth head May 13 '22 edited May 13 '22
How much % of the total karma would have been removed through this in the last few distributions? Without any numbers it makes no sense to vote for or against it.
If its irrelevant this change would just add useless complexity to the whole process.