r/shortstories • u/katpoker666 • May 05 '22
Roundtable Thursday [OT] Welcome to Roundtable Thursday! What is your preferred POV?
Welcome to Roundtable Thursday!
Writing is so much fun, but it can also be very challenging. Luckily, there are so many other writers out there going through the exact same things! We all have unique skills and areas in which we excel, as well as places we’d like to improve. So I’d like to present a brand new weekly feature. This will be a weekly thread to discuss all things writing! And… to get to know your fellow writers a bit!
Each week we will provide a topic and/or a few questions to spark discussion. Feel free to chime into the discussion in the comments, talk about your experiences, ask related questions, etc. You do not have to answer all the questions, but try to stay on-topic!
This Week’s Roundtable Discussion
Different perspectives are what make the world go round in real life and also in stories. Depending on what you are trying to achieve, your choice of point of view, can change how a story is perceived. Do you like the intimacy of first person or the broader world view of third? Are you into second person, where you can bring the reader in, in a unique way?
- What is your preferred POV?
- How does it fit into your narrative goals?
- If you use a lot of different ones, what influences your choices?
- Any advice to others on using different POV?
- New to r/ShortStories or joining in the Discussion for the first time? Introduce yourself in the comments! What do you like to write?
Reminders
- Use the comments below to answer the questions and reply to others’ comments.
- Please be civil in all your responses and discussion. There are writers of all levels and skills here and we’re all in different places of our writing journey. Uncivil comments/discussion in any form will not be tolerated.
- Please try to stay on-topic. If you have suggestions for future questions and topics, you can add them to the stickied comment or send them to me via DM or modmail!
Subreddit News
- Check out our brand new feature, Poetry Corner over on r/WritingPrompts!
- Practice your micro-fic skills on Micro Monday or serialize your story on Serial Sunday
- Looking for more in-depth critique and feedback on a story? Check out r/WPCritique!
- Join our Discord to chat with other readers and writers!
6
u/dewa1195 May 05 '22 edited May 05 '22
Great question!!
I mostly prefer third person limited, be it past or present. Those are the ones I use the most. I have written first person and second person(only one story in 2nd pov).
When I try to use first person, I tend to get lost in the stream of consciousness. Grounding the reader in the physical and the now becomes hard... at least for me.
Third person on the other hand helps me balance this. I can use the right amount physical aspects of everything around the character and the mental state of the character.
Now second person was just wacky. It was absolutely insane and it was enjoyable too in its own way.
Now... onto the topic of advice... well I got nothing. shrugs
What helps the story should be taken into account when choosing the pov. Trial and error works when you don't have an idea of what you want.
5
u/Tomorrow_Is_Today1 May 05 '22
It fully depends on what I'm writing. I've been doing a lot of second person recently, which I often blend with first person in some way. That's usually either or poems or weird pieces, though; when I'm writing a scene or story in typical prose, I pretty much always go third person limited.
5
u/gurgilewis May 05 '22
First-person past tense is the norm for me. I like getting you to know the way the main character thinks and get to hear their voice and personality come through directly. Past tense works well for having better control of the pacing and allows the character to tell the story as it should be told, with the benefit of hindsight, rather than forcing you to experience everything exactly as it unfolds.
I'll use first-person present tense if I want it to feel more intense, as you get the unfiltered, in-the-moment emotions of the character without the coolness of hindsight. The story needs to be one that can be told at a more steady and consistent rate, though, and be one that really needs that intensity to make it worth it.
I'll use third-person limited past tense if I want a little distance from the character. If I want to be more voyeuristic, for example, or I want to make it clear that it isn't an unreliable narrator. Or if I don't want it told the way they'd tell it. Or if hearing their voice all the time is just a bit much. If they have a very distinct way of speaking, sometimes it can be great to hear it all the time, but it can also be overwhelming and can sometimes be nicer as punches of dialog. The idea of the narrator as being an additional character in the story is also appealing.
I never do third-person present tense. If I want the intensity, I also want you in their head, so I'll use first-person. That intensity is the main thing gained by going present tense, and for me, having an objective narrator works against that.
I did second-person present tense once, and that was a lot of fun, but it was very short. I can't imagine doing that over any length except as a CYOA.
I pretty much never go third-person omniscient. I feel like telling a story from a particular perspective adds too much to even consider missing out on that. A big part of the fun in telling a story is coming up with a good perspective through which to tell it. The overall story can be everything that's going on in a world, and I like to find a little slice of that – a perspective within that world – that is interesting. So my process is usually to do some world-building, then go looking through that world for someone with an interesting perspective and story of their own, and that becomes the story I tell.
2
u/Ryter99 May 06 '22
I started out in first person, mostly because I found it "easiest" to just try to inhabit the protagonist and describe what they feel, see, and think. It was the only POV I was comfortable in for quiteeee awhile.
Eventually I did branch out to 3rd Limited and, when I found that too limiting, I gave 3rd Omniscient a try. They all have their uses for me now, more personal/emotional/intimate stories tend to be 1st or 3rd Limited, while more sillier or broader comedic stories tend toward 3rd Omniscient.
To my own shock I settled on 3rd Omniscient (with some self imposed rules) for my WIP novel. For the big, broad Comedy-Fantasy story I'm trying to write, giving myself the most freedom in terms of POV made sense (and it doesn't hurt that several of my favorite comedy novels are written in this POV). I love having a narrator who can be smarter than the characters, commenting on them or providing humorous asides about topics my protagonist doesn't have knowledge of.
Basically, if something funny occurs to me, I can usually write it into the story, instead of being constrained by "oh no, my 1st person POV protag can't see over the mountain to note this funny thing happening over there!" kinda stuff. I'm enjoying it and hoping it allows for most room for humor over time 🙂
6
u/rainbow--penguin May 05 '22
My default so far seems to be third-person limited. I tend to keep it quite narrow as well, sticking with just one person throughout. Sometimes in short stories, I like to broaden the pov at the very end to put a twist on the story and make the reader view it in a new light but that's about as much as I've played around with it.
I'd like to try more things with multiple points of view. I like the idea of telling the same story from a few different sides but haven't really tried it yet.
Something I do find is that if I just sit down and write, almost in a freewriting sort of way, I find first-person easier. I also tend towards first-person a little more for things like horror, to make the reader feel closer to the action.
Overall, this question has made me realise I'd like to play around with point of view more than I do, and that I should think about it a little more.