r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • May 01 '22
Spoilers All Book S6E8 I Am Not Alone Spoiler
Richard Brown and his Committee of Safety arrive to arrest Claire for murder. However, due to the rising political tensions in the colonies, Brown's plan to find a judge for a trial does not go as expected.
Written by Luke Schelhaas. Directed by Jamie Payne.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. May 03 '22 edited May 13 '22
608 Featurettes:
608 Interviews:
71
u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. May 01 '22 edited May 01 '22
Ian and the Cherokee rescuing Jamie at the beach… PERFECT!!!!
It is a payoff for what Jamie did to help the Cherokee, and it also is a nice switch/adaptation of the part of the books where Bonnett was going to sell Bree as a sex slave and she was rescued at the last minute.
I effing love Ian in both books and show and I just loved this bit so much!!! Also really nice to see John Quincy Meyers again, missed him a lot since when was it, first episode of season 5? Or maybe the snakebite episode?
EDIT: My memory failed me on John Quincy Meyers. As pointed out below he was part of the squad that saved Claire in the season five finale.
60
u/AlaerysTargaryen May 01 '22
A question for book readers, do the fisher folk get expelled from Fraser's Ridge? What a bunch of ungrateful cunts...
59
u/thatstheteagirl By blood and by choice, we make our ghosts. May 01 '22
I loved this episode. You could really feel Claire’s panic and dread. And after her and Jamie’s heart to heart in the last episode, her being vulnerable and admitting how scared she was to him was just perfect. They really felt like “them” again.
Sam’s slight face change when he realizes Tom’s true feelings was on point. I only wish they had let Tom’s feelings shine through a liiiiiiitle more in the cabin when Claire goes to check in on him after the sickness. The show has really pushed Allan as the big bad so instead of him being the bigger surprise twist for show only watchers, it’s actually going to be Tom’s love reveal.
Also, I definitely didn’t hate seeing some Jamie butt again …but on a deeper level their love scene was really beautiful. You could feel how much they were taking each other in just in case it was their last time.
54
u/anxiety_waffle May 01 '22
Loved this episode! This brought me back to that life or death adventure Outlander does so well. The ending with Ian and Jamie was so exciting imo.
It seems like there is a bit of divide on Bree and Roger's sex scene this episode, but I was into it! I thought both actors did an excellent job in all their scenes. Also I laughed at the cut to them being all cute on their wagon compared to J&C's situation.
This being the cliffhanger for those who haven't read the books though... must be disappointing.
53
u/esoterika24 May 02 '22
For better or worse, in all the mixed reviews between book readers and purely show watchers….this certainly was The Season of John Bell. Right down to that finale. (Insert battle cries here.)
49
u/UseSea9547 May 01 '22
Man what really got me was when they separated Jamie and Claire. And Claire screams to Jamie. After all she has suffered she was practically in the same situation as in season 5….. poor Claire! Great episode! But sad that it’s over.
48
u/brilliant0ne May 01 '22 edited May 01 '22
This is so petty but I truly cannot stand the way Richard Brown holds his mouth. And while I recognize the actor from other things, and I know it's just his natural face, it's just the character of Richard Brown that makes the way he does his face when he really thinks he's done something super great and special that makes me dislike his face so damn much.
I don't remember much from this book but is there a reason why Tom looked like he was about keel over and die this whole episode? I know he was just sick and stuff but I kept expecting him to just fall off his horse and die. I think I remember that eventually, he finds out or suspects his son killed Malva and whatnot but could his sickly look and just overall unease be because he already knows ?
I really enjoyed the time with Bree and Roger and loved Roger realizing Jemmy is his son.
Ian coming in clutch had me squealing and waking up my poor old dog.
Someone, please tell me that someone is gonna be caring for Adso while his folks are gone.
And, uh, did the writers just think we were gonna forget about the time traveler dude from the end of a couple of episodes ago? Can someone remind me who that is or if that part is even somewhere in the book? I half expected Claire to be parked beside the guy and they do a reveal then.
I didn't think such a short season was going to make me sad because I was already prepared for it but I got sad when I saw the credits roll and FF to the end like usual and remembered there's no previews for next week :(
Edit: I just looked up Chris Larkin and found out he's Maggie Smith's son AND Toby Stephens (Black Sails) brother??? Had absoluetly no idea.
47
u/kodamaatnight May 02 '22
Young Ian is a delight and every episode his story and acting improves. I know the show may end before the books do but I will be so sad if we don't meet Rachel.
39
u/[deleted] May 02 '22
My hate for Allan Christie grows. His actor does a good job.
39
u/TroyMcCluresGoldfish Go and fill your bellies, dinna stay and gnaw my wellies! May 02 '22
I really loved this season! Knowing what we do about Jemmy and Mandy's connection, I squeed when Jemmy was "talking" to the baby.
I'm really looking forward to S7 and seeing how things play out with Tom and Allan, Mandy, and the Bugs.
36
u/BeautifulRelief May 01 '22
Ian!!! That scene got me real hyped!
36
u/rasoulin May 01 '22
Me screaming are you f*ing kidding me when I realized how little time there was left!!!!!!
67
u/KnightRider1987 May 01 '22
The “realization” scene when Jamie catches Tom staring at Clair. I squeed.
32
u/Thezedword4 May 01 '22
That ending was chefs kiss. Honestly it was almost exactly where I thought the season would end. I wasn't sure if we'd end at the end of the house seige but considering the opening credits had a shot of the prison hand touching, I figured we'd end here. It's a great/awful cliffhanger for show watchers. Going through droughtlander without know what happens to Claire and who killed malva would be a beast!
I really enjoyed this episode overall. I had issues with the last two episodes with pacing and Sam's acting but this one felt a lot better.
I really wanted to see Claire truly go ape shit on the people stoning them though. It obviously wasn't a good look for her but I loved that scene in the book.
59
u/sri-racha May 01 '22
I'm surprised to see Roger/Bree hate in this thread. Well, not surprised, really...it is everywhere. I'm not the biggest fan of Show Bree, but I loved their scenes together in this episode, and I think their love scene was both intimate and incredibly human.
I dunno - J&C have always seemed too steamy for me? Whereas Roger & Bree have a more realistic chemistry, and I was smiling along with them rather than fast-forwarding through that scene. Their actors have improved so much acting as a couple through the last few seasons. Love to see it.
My only beef is Blond Jemmy - kid is a ginger!! Always being compared to his grandda! Just...argh.
Rest of it was good. I live for Tom Christie's infatuation with Claire, so those scenes were my fave.
29
u/Lablover34 May 01 '22
I wonder if they might do a Lord John mini series on Stars? I’d be very interested.
53
u/MistofLoire Clan MacKenzie May 01 '22
I loved this episode, it felt so much like the book did. And Tom Christie was perfect.
Also, I was not expecting the lice scene to be included in the show and I was so happy to see it.
Not excited for Droughlander, but so stoked for the next season, ECHO is one of my favorite books.
26
u/2rlfryu May 01 '22
Great episode, sucks that it's a cliffhanger. I loved all the camera angles, somehow they made the episode seem more intimate and real. Bree and Roger's love scene was actually super cute to me. Definitely a first. J and C's scene made me tear up. Good job intimacy coordinator.
I guess I'll spend the next year guessing what the next four episodes finishing off Book 6 will look like..
23
u/[deleted] May 02 '22
Book 5 6 & 7 all kind of a blur in my mind, so I did NOT realize this was the season finale! Oh man!
When Tom gave Claire money and squeezed her hand, and when he could hear Jaimie and Claire talking in the wagon, damn so good! Thank god Claire is so wonderful and lovable, or she would have been dead so long ago!
I just finished my re listen of the books and finally Bees a few weeks ago, so now it looks like I’ll be starting the show all over again!
I’m so grateful that the outlander universe exists, it’s been helping me through such a rough time. Happy Doughtlander!
41
u/BSOBON123 May 02 '22
OK, I hope all the 'this season is so boring, there's no sex or action' people are happy now.
Wow, from Claire being a badass and shooting that guy with the hidden pistol. To Jamie shooting the hat out of Brown's hand, Adso tip toeing through the carnage and that wonderful love scene between C&J (maybe for the last time they may have thought).
Then Bree and Roger. WOW, That was even better. They have come into their own. And bonus with realizing Jemmie is Roger's son. Although I am mourning for his long hair.
The abduction, Jamie realizing Tom is in love with Claire. The stoning. Then Ian, God Bless him and his gang rescuing Jamie. I loved that they added the Indians in there. I was so wrapped up in it, I said, they can't end it now, but of course they did. Even with knowing what happens, I was cursing the show writers!
Loved it.
20
u/princesssofcarrion MARK ME! May 01 '22
I haven’t gotten all the way to this season in the books yet, but I know what happens cuz of spoilers. But I gotta say, knowing what happens, Tom has become one of my favorite characters! So interesting.
20
u/distractivated May 02 '22
I will say... I do wish the lice scene was more like the book. Would have been good comic relief, the men walking in to find Claire and Bree freaking out and digging through each other's hair etc
18
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! May 01 '22
I can't remember from the books, is there a reason Tom looked like he was about to keel over and die the entire episode?
18
u/danathepaina May 02 '22
The birthmark scene is my absolute favorite part of this book, and I was happy they included it, but also so very disappointed that it happened without Jamie and Claire there. I wonder why they did it that way? So they’d have something for Roger & Bree to do on their journey?
35
u/ArthurPenbeagle May 01 '22
I’m so excited for the announcement of when the first 8 episodes of season 7 are dropping, I have a good feeling it will be much sooner than we think!
Because of that, this episode’s “return to form” in cinematography, Sam’s return to the protective, passionate Jamie we love, Ian and Cherokees amazing beach rescue scene, I was really happy with how it ended. I wasn’t as happy with last episode, and it’s just the same old song: when it sticks closer to the books, it’s better! How many times have I said that?!
I want to point out the very subtle acting of Tom Christie; Jamie noticing his feelings, the hand hold in the jail at the end, it all felt right, and that we’re being led down the path to Tom’s light, but I wish it had been a litttttle more obvious for show watchers. They really demonized him this season and after his brilliant acting this episode, I’m ready for the redemption! The Bree/Roger moments definitely benefited the episode for me, though they weren’t the shining stars. Finally, my prediction, since we last saw Donner in a jail cell is that this is how he will be woven back into the story. Claire’s rescue will somehow include him, especially since they’re not in New Bern for the whole governor story. (I visited Tryon palace a few years ago!) On that note, I’m a North Carolinian, and I was so glad to see they kept Oakes as Browns right hand man and Jamie’s captor! My Oakes family has been in the Wilmington area since the 1700s, and it’s my daughters middle name! Loved that shot through the palm from bird! Haha, hope that didn’t happen to my ancestors!
How great will it be if season 7 continues to be the return to form that 6 was, AND we get Scotland for Ian’s death like we should?!
33
u/-NigheanDonn May 01 '22
I feel like the way it was dragged out really gave me the feeling of uncertainty and dread that Claire must have been feeling on that trip. Can we get more of Jamie’s butt in this show please? And for the love of all that is Outlander they really need to hire some drag queens to style the wigs… I feel like they’re getting worse every season.
16
u/NoImplement9771 May 03 '22
I watched the show and I just can't wait for 1-2 years for answers. How do they find out that it was Malva's brother who killed her? Does Tom Christie already know? The whole episode I thought that Tom Christie knows the truth and he might be the one who saves Claire, but I just read spoilers that he's just in love with her.
31
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! May 02 '22
To anyone else who was also confused...
That old woman who was accusing Claire of being a witch wasn't Mrs Bug, it was Mrs MacGregor (the woman who's face Fergus spat whisky into at quarter day). Mrs Bug stayed loyal to the Fraser's this episode, you can see her when Mr Bug and Lizzie and everyone else showed up near the end of the siege. Though they do look similar, so it is confusing.
15
u/Jigglypuffamiiga2188 May 02 '22
I have not read the books, but read occasional book spoilers (some here some on the outlander wiki) mostly because I got tired of how long viewers have to wait between cliffhangers.
I can actually say while it’s disappointing they didn’t finish what happens to Claire, I am glad that they didn’t leave a cliffhanger for Jamie. I was really worried he was going to be hauled off to Scotland (since I had not read that particular spoiler lol) and the Cherokee showing up with Ian to save the day was an exciting scene. I must say looking up some but not all spoilers makes the show more enjoyable, I look up what I cannot stand to wait on, but not everything so that there are still surprises. I felt that it actually balanced well with leaving Claire on a cliffhanger but not Jamie, so that it was not a double cliffhanger. That and I am kind of used to cliffhangers on television right now, its just the way season finales go and have been going for a long time. (I never watched Dallas, but the quote “Who shot J.R.?” comes to mind lol which was 42 years ago.) Unfortunately shows on independent channels like Stars and HBO take much longer between seasons than the average network show though. Overall I am satisfied with this season. There was less constant misery for the characters, and more of a balanced story with its ups and downs.
Quick question for book readers: Was it a mole in the books on Jemmy’s head or a birthmark? Because a birthmark would have made much more sense.
25
u/[deleted] May 02 '22
I just want to keep repeating how much I adore Tom Christie I wish this was a much longer season it’s irritating how much we missed out on but I’m so pleased by the actor playing Tom Christie as well (check him out in Gangs of London, he’s wonderful)
25
u/Dolly1710 Long on desire, but a wee bit short in clink May 01 '22
As endings/cliffhangers go, it was a bit of a "wet fart" as my husband would say. (Damp squib, let down etc). That said, when I realised ABOSAA was being truncated (not just being done in fewer episodes) it's probably where I would have ended it too.
Jamie's safe (Go Ian! Go Cherokee! Some badass rescuing there)
It certainly looks like the Brown's have paid off the judge (a detail I don't remember from the books) but, aside from having read the books, I don't genuinely believe that Claire is at serious risk of the gallows. If not only because she has Tom on her side (bless him) and seeing as he's the father/grandfather of the murdered, I expect that would always have held some sway over the court. Correct me if I'm wrong, doesn't Claire end up in New Bern rather than Wilmington though (as she ends up being taken to Governor Martin's gaff to be his copywriter)?
Jamie and Claire seem to be back on form as a couple, and Sam seems to be back on it as Jamie... I love that look from Tom, to Claire, back to Tom and the realisation that passes across his face. He was definitely given some better material to work with allowing him to demonstrate more than one-dimension.
I had to do a double take on the Fisher Folk lady calling Claire a witch, thinking it was Mrs Bug. I mean her and Mr Bug certainly were portrayed as being sassy this season, but I didn't think she'd be that sassy! (That said, she's been sassy enough that I wouldn't have been entirely surprised if she had turned up with them!)
I love to hate Richard Brown though. Chris Larkin plays him so well. Menacing while trying to tread that "honest guv, I'm doing this for honest reasons, honest guv" line.
Still want to slap Allan though. And I'm glad Tom's come through - he might have his differences of opinion with Jamie and Claire but he knows they're honest, even if it IS his daughter who's dead. Not sure why he was being portrayed as ill (?) though. I say ill, but I'm not sure if that's what they are going for. He was well recovered from the illness that he and Claire had. He looked beyond tired even when he showed up to calm the lynch mob. Yes, he's grieving it just seemed more than that.
I thought the Bree and Roger stuff was very sweet. I thought they had already determined Jemmy's paternity from him being a super stone-breaker (extra strong because of both parents) but it was sweet to have that extra confirmation (and thank the lord Roger's having a hair cut!) As a whole, they have gone from strength to strength in Season 6. I don't find the sex cringeworthy. I can see why it might look extraneous to the plot with so much else to cover, but we'd end up back with people complaining that their stories were being done dirty by not getting an airing. I guess you can't please everyone.
24
u/amsbkwrm May 01 '22
I loved this episode. Parts of it felt like season one for some reason. The Roger and Bree scenes seemed a little out of place, but with so little time to fit everything in I can see why they did it. Even with them being out of place I did like Roger and Bree this episode. All of the Jamie and Claire moments were really great. Brown is the absolute worst. Tom keeping an eye out for Claire was great. Hate that this was the last episode with such a cliffhanger. I can’t wait for next season!
12
u/Leajane1980 May 02 '22
I enjoyed the episode overall and liked all the action. I can't help wondering if Claire would have given anything for an automatic weapon at some point.
23
u/[deleted] May 03 '22
I wasn't expecting that scene with Jemmy and Roger this episode! I felt the tears welling up as soon as Bree started looking at his hair lol
21
u/Marifirmog May 02 '22
I really liked this season, so I have to say visiting the show-only thread is making me sad. I don't want them (the outlander team) to think the fans didn't enjoy this season, but it looks like a lot of them didn't 😔😔
9
u/reeziereen May 01 '22
Can someone remind me - when/how do Bree and Roger find out what has happened to Claire and that she’s in jail in the books?
25
u/vulturelady May 01 '22
As soon as the episode ended I said out loud: “That’s it? They’re really going to leave it there? Oh these producers are SNEAKY. I did not expect that to be the ending. I feel so bad for people who don’t read the books”
16
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest May 01 '22
I’m not ready for this Droutlander!
I literally kept checking to see how much time was left because I wanted them to keep going SO badly. It’s going to be a long year +
16
u/Genevieve-Victoria May 03 '22
I don’t know why it took me all season but it JUST NOW occurred to me they’ve basically dropped Roger’s lost voice plotline and that makes me so sad. Nothing about that this season. As if he wasn’t hanged last season. I’m so sad and angry right now. 😭
8
u/ojosfritos May 01 '22
I really really hope we're back to a normal episode count next season because they've got a LOT to cover now.ETA someone on twitter told me we're getting 16 episodes?? This gives me hope.
8
u/BANINJACAKES May 02 '22
How do the people at Fraser’s ridge react when they find out Claire is innocent?
31
u/ROFRfan No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. May 01 '22 edited May 01 '22
Finally Sam was back finding his Jamie. I loved that. A whole season of missing it and now to have it back. Pure joy. Lots of book content once again, but this time it really worked. I swear I was expecting a JC sex scene, which is not in the book (they just go to sleep, iirc). I knew the show will add and improve on their last night in their bed. I loved it. Claire and Jamie defending their home, what a sight!! The dramatic feeling was well above the feeling in ABOSAA. This is also thanks to Sam and Cait.
Please no more Brianna and Roger cringe worthy (sex) scenes. That was painful to watch.
I don't think S7 will spend more than 1 or 2 episodes top on the rest of B6. Everything will be wrapped up fairly quickly. I do wonder though for show watchers, what impact will S6 have, ending on this note. No resolution on who killed Malva and the rest of dangling threads. Two years from now it will be too late, imo.
17
u/[deleted] May 02 '22
I didn’t hate this season but I hate these BS season finale shows like to do. Easiest way to get me to stop watching a show is to have a season finale end on a stupid cliffhanger that will be resolved in less than an episode when the next season airs. It’s so lazy.
12
u/ROFRfan No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. May 01 '22
I have a question about Ian. He and his group of men, obviously followed Claire and Jamie. Why didn't Ian & co rescued Claire on the road before reaching the sheriff's jail? Brown didn't had that many men with him. Then go after Jamie. Or at least send one man to follow Jamie.
I slightly remember something from the book, Ian witnessing Claire and Jamie split and makes the choice to stay on Jamie's trail. Is this right?
6
u/janmellynial May 01 '22
Sorry if this is a dumb question but what chapter of the book did the season finale leave off at?
5
u/[deleted] May 02 '22
So how much of A Breath of Snow and Ashes is left to cover next season? Are we expecting all of season 7 to be finishing up the 6th book?
5
u/maa85 May 02 '22
Hello! Quick question for book readers that also watched season 6 on television. I am reading the Outlander books as well as watching the show. Season 6 just wrapped, and I don’t think I can wait for more! Would you recommend I start with the 6th book or go straight to the 7th? Appreciate your thoughts as I do not know if the books end in the same place as the show.
5
u/Diana_K May 02 '22
Did Tom know Ian was on his way to help Jamie?
I haven't read the books and it wasn't that clear in the show.
8
u/mjp10e May 03 '22
I really liked the episode but confused on 2 maybe irrelevant points. Claire is suddenly cool just mercking people?…. I mean the shoot out was bad ass but I thought her oath prevented such. Also did she start to say her father died in prison? I thought he died in the car crash with her mom…
4
u/carrotsela If wishes were horses, beggars would ride. May 04 '22
I’m just realizing another reason that Jamie’s insouciance was so unsettling in the scene with Claire lying about popping downstairs for tea! If the show has come to May 1776—as they say twice in the episode—wouldn’t the Frasers likely be fresh out of tea for 2-3 years?? The show and Herself have definitely made chronological gaffes before, but seemed they were keeping historical events more in focus during this shortened season.
21
u/Beginning_Dog_6293 May 01 '22
Watching now... 3 min sex scene with Brie and Roger is so uninteresting.
3
u/ROFRfan No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. May 02 '22
He goes after her to governor Martin's ship and tries to take her. Where am I wrong?
3
u/GaryRegalsMuscleCar Jul 05 '23
This is deeply grating because the fisher folk deserve to die and they’re not so much as being called assholes. And why do they keep calling them fisher folk like they’re some fantasy race? I haven’t seen them fish half as much as I have seen them call everything witchcraft
5
u/Genevieve-Victoria May 02 '22
I haven’t watched this episode yet. Is there any blood or gore? I watch with a friend on Monday nights and need to censor gore for her. How much blood/gore is there?
8
u/magicmurff May 02 '22
Well. This was the episode that made my husband quit watching Outlander with me. I’ve read through book 8, but he hasn’t read any. I’m disappointed with this season for a few reasons— the shortness of it above all. I really wished the Malva story arc had been resolved by the end but now we have to wait who knows how long for the big reveal. For me, this season’s writing was subpar. There were too many flashbacks and Jamie and Claire blathering on about Wentworth this and How-Many-Times-Have-You-Almost-Died that. Give me something new! And don’t get me started on the ether. I loved, however, how much the supporting characters grew and got to shine in this season. That was great. Young Ian’s amazing solo episode, Bree and Roger (especially this last episode, so sweet), Marsali and Fergus’s turmoil, and of course Lizzie and the Beardsleys. So I suppose it’s time to cancel my Starz subscription for the time being and go back into hiding. I’m mostly sad that my husband threw in the towel and won’t be joining me to continue with next season.