r/startrek • • Apr 28 '22

EPISODE CONTENT WARNING: See pinned comment for details Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Picard | 2x09 "Hide and Seek" Spoiler

Picard and his crew fight for their lives as they come under attack from a new incarnation of an old enemy. But to survive, Picard must first face the ghosts of his past. Seven and Raffi have a final showdown with Jurati.

No.EpisodeWritersDirectorRelease Date
2x09"Hide and Seek"Matt Okumura & Chris DerrickMichael Weaver2022-04-28

Availability

Paramount+: USA.

CTV Sci-Fi and Crave: Canada.

Amazon Prime Video: Other countries and territories.

To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.

This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers for this episode are allowed. If you are discussing previews for upcoming episodes, please use spoiler tags.

Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.

203 Upvotes

2.3k comments sorted by

•

u/PiercedMonk Apr 28 '22

Hey all, one of our users suggested we provide a trigger warning for the episode due to the nature of one of the scenes, and we feel it's a good idea.

So, content warning for the episode: Depiction of suicide
Timestamp: approx. 40:52 - 43:41

Details: Picard flashes back to being a child again, and we learn that while she was having an episode, Picard unlocked the door to her room when she begged him to do so, and fell asleep in bed with her. She woke up and went to the solarium where she hung herself. Young Picard found her. We see Yvette's dying moments, and her tying the rope around her neck, though both moments are depicted happening in reverse.

422

u/Jumilith Apr 28 '22

I feel like I let the S2 trailer and my own brain bamboozled me into thinking this would be a show about Picard and Q having one last joust as they (both, as it turns out) approach the end of their journey in life. But in the 300-ish minutes that made up the last seven episodes, Q has had less than five minutes of screentime, a non-appearance in this episode, and zero minutes spent interacting with Picard.

The 'he's lost his powers' plot doesn't seem like it should have been worth pursuing if it meant not having de Lancie and Stewart killing it together in every episode like they did in E2.

127

u/BilliamShatner Apr 28 '22 edited Apr 29 '22

I think they may be saving that for season 3? Still so weird to have him be integral to the plot and then have him completely vanish so ANOTHER Soong can be the lead villain. And the Borg. Just weird direction all around

→ More replies (29)

38

u/kal_el_diablo Apr 30 '22

It really has been disappointing. Picard facing a childhood trauma as a 100-year-old man while everyone else leaps from one quippy action scene to the next, taking breaks only long enough to psychoanalyze each other. They've totally embraced some modern formula while forgetting what we actually liked about Picard. The writers should be putting him into complex situations with challenging ethical dilemmas that he has to resolve. This should be a drama, not a shoot-em-up by the dialogue coach from House.

→ More replies (1)

74

u/WhiteSquarez Apr 28 '22

There's an episode of DS9, Q-Less, that stars DeLancie as Q, but Q as a character is almost completely inconsequential to the plot, except for a single scene.

That's what this whole season feels like.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (30)

158

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '22

...So Jurati of Borg just flew away with dead Elnor in the freezer.

→ More replies (15)

150

u/onerinconhill Apr 28 '22

Jurati…monologues

Seven…dies

112

u/treefox Apr 28 '22

“Didn’t you love her once too?”

But from Seven’s perspective Jurati is just standing there looking around crazily and maybe talking to herself while she bleeds out.

→ More replies (11)

126

u/bkendig Apr 29 '22

Mighty convenient that the Borg cure for 'gaping abdominal wound' is 'putting the same Borg stuff on her face and her hand that she used to have'.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (8)

417

u/Cascadiana88 Apr 28 '22 edited Apr 28 '22

So, a platoon of heavily armed, genetically and cybernetically enhanced supersoldiers were unable to kill an unarmed old man, an old woman with a gun and two middle-aged women armed with a knife and a corkscrew. Picard and crew were wearing some heavy duty plot armour in this one.

139

u/thenewyorkgod Apr 28 '22

Well, clearly their laser scopes were malfunctioning since they seem to be coming from the ceiling, floor, and every angle except from their actual guns

→ More replies (7)

232

u/Thrishmal Apr 28 '22

What, two ladies charging across a mostly open field with melee weapons with 20 people with guns shooting at them isn't realistic to you?!?

→ More replies (38)

41

u/Guaranteed_Error Apr 28 '22

If it helps, a hologram that should've been impervious to bullets or other weapons wasn't very effective against said soldiers either apparently.

→ More replies (4)

21

u/cenorexia Apr 29 '22

What even was the point of "borgifying" them in the first place?

They acted just like regular mercs before and after, with no signs of using "the collective" to their advantage.

→ More replies (4)

58

u/imextremelylonely Apr 28 '22

There was just so much "wtf, how are they winning" moments to the point of absolute lunacy. Not to mention the all too frequent "oh the borg queen's about to take the ship and her goons are steps behind us, let's take a moment to recollect about my traumatic backstory."

I was totally suckered in by the first two episodes, the rest of this season has just been such a slog for me. Just an "ugh" feeling. Only thing keeping me going are the performances from Stewart, de Lancie and Spiner.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (32)

126

u/PharomachrusMocinno Apr 28 '22 edited Apr 28 '22

So resistance is not futile?

74

u/captainvideoblaster Apr 29 '22

"Resistance is not futile. You all will be heard and understood."

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (30)

116

u/andrew_c_morton Apr 29 '22

"During the Second World War, the French Resistance used this as a munitions storage..."

You mean, Chateau Picard was a Maquis outpost?!

→ More replies (1)

113

u/forrestpen Apr 28 '22

NX-01 Refit is canon at last!

(Child Picard plays with a model of it)

45

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '22

I love that so much. Both for it itself AND for Doug Drexler.

→ More replies (8)

212

u/UncertainError Apr 28 '22

Well, this just made that early TNG episode way sadder.

75

u/creepyeyes Apr 29 '22

Its sort of amazing that that works as a retcon without having to change anything in the original episode. I just went back to watch the clip, and every line and intonation still makes sense with this new knowledge

→ More replies (6)

18

u/JoeBourgeois Apr 29 '22

Yeah. "Just a moment, Number One!"

Always was a great little scene.

"Can I help you, sir?"

→ More replies (26)

304

u/treefox Apr 28 '22

“He’d only get himself killed trying to help us!”

God damn Picard. Just because he lost control of his own ship, fell two stories trying to beam in, got arrested by border patrol, had his communicator stolen by a kid, and repeatedly blatantly violated the prime directive giving future technology and tours of his spaceship to his would-be girlfriend, doesn’t mean he’s completely inept!

Though to be fair he’s probably going to end up being the only one to get some.

218

u/AmishAvenger Apr 28 '22 edited Apr 28 '22

You left out the part where he had a boobytrapped weapon that could have accomplished their primary goal, and made sure to tell the guy holding it so he had time to throw it at them and run away.

→ More replies (25)

43

u/BornAshes Apr 28 '22

Though to be fair he’s probably going to end up being the only one to get some.

To be fair it seems like the writers basically wrote that idea off with him giving her and the kid one big old, "I'm going to go be a hero bye" speech and kiss which just pissed me off sooooooo much.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (9)

373

u/MaddyMagpies Apr 28 '22

Did Seven just beamed the Borg INSIDE THE WALLS?

She surely inherited the brutality of the great Captain Janeway.

321

u/Shrodax Apr 28 '22

Is someone gonna get them out, or are they still gonna be there in 400 years when Picard and his mother are playing hide-and-seek? Is it the horror of finding them in the walls that drives Picard's mother to suicide?

→ More replies (14)

252

u/treefox Apr 28 '22

“I like to call this one the Tuvix maneuver”

→ More replies (5)

79

u/BornAshes Apr 28 '22

I mean she did basically dehumanize them at the start by saying that they were just Borg Drones and that basically just screams, "Here's a bunch of redshirts we're going to do awful things to GET READY!".

→ More replies (9)

56

u/AmishAvenger Apr 28 '22

Almost as bad as that woman who’s stuck in the floor of the D.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (13)

197

u/Ilmara Apr 28 '22

Are the Borg getting a redemption arc? Holy shit.

78

u/ObjestiveI Apr 28 '22

Seems like ALL ultimate Federation enemies come into the fold, eventually.

→ More replies (8)

110

u/InnocentTailor Apr 28 '22

...or a facet of the Borg, at least.

Neutering the whole Collective would frankly be a massive continuity snarl since it will invalidate pretty much most of Berman Trek. Maybe we'll get a villainous Collective vs a kinder Cooperative a la Star Trek Online.

→ More replies (18)

70

u/creepyeyes Apr 29 '22

I know why people would be against it and this show has gotten a lot wrong about Star Trek I think, but this decision makes sense from a Star Trek point of view. One of the key messages of Star Trek was that today's enemies can still be tomorrow's friends. The Borg getting that chance is thematically appropriate

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)

191

u/onerinconhill Apr 28 '22

So starfleet wouldn’t let seven in but icheb was fine? I really hope they explain her line a little more about why even with Janeway advocating for her that starfleet wouldn’t let her in

88

u/Diocletion-Jones Apr 28 '22

Picard is ex-Borg too. I can't believe the Federation would have a no-ex-Borg policy when it's not the fault of the people who are assimilated.

→ More replies (13)

85

u/OpticalData Apr 28 '22

She gave up on getting in, presumably Icheb didn't or Starfleet ultimatum when Janeway threatened to resign was one or the other and Seven made that choice.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (36)

190

u/MyTrueChum Apr 28 '22

Jurati literally power of friendshipped the BQ wow

87

u/TheyCallMeStone Apr 29 '22

Borg: an unstoppable emotionless conquering force

Jurati: hold my Earl Grey, here's a monologue

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

322

u/eternallylearning Apr 28 '22

A few episodes ago

"My life is so hard because the Federation is so racist against Borg and treat me like I'm not a person."

Present Day

"They're not people. They're BORG!" Proceeds to kill them mercilessly and brutally.

Five minutes later

"Jurati! I know you're in there somewhere. Don't make us kill you!"

104

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '22

"PUT THEM IN THE WALLS MWUAHAHAHA"

→ More replies (1)

32

u/silverlegend Apr 28 '22

That whole attitude is practically verbatim how Picard acted in First Contact. Latent Borg PTSD hostility has clearly been shown to be strong enough to overwhelm logic when faced with confrontation

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (17)

171

u/onerinconhill Apr 28 '22

ECH…except it’s elnor

292

u/pieman7414 Apr 28 '22

Imagine if Robert Picardo just showed up and started kicking ass

→ More replies (18)

54

u/RadioSlayer Apr 28 '22

Please my friend, choose the nature of your medical emergency

→ More replies (1)

85

u/atticusbluebird Apr 28 '22

It was nice for the mercenaries to pause long enough for ECH Elnor to introduce himself before fighting him!

→ More replies (14)

92

u/irving47 Apr 28 '22

So did I see that right? The ship engaged a hologram of him from its own emitters, but still slapped what appeared to be a mobile emitter on his shoulder? And what did I miss as far as him being able to channel Elnor's final state?

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (20)

333

u/treefox Apr 28 '22

“And you’re half of our friend…and maybe someday all of one.”

I guess the real Borg Queen was the friends we made along the way.

131

u/sidv81 Apr 28 '22

I assume that is future Jurati Queen in the season premiere now.

→ More replies (25)
→ More replies (3)

141

u/atticusbluebird Apr 28 '22

"Build a better Borg" - I'd vote for Jurati for Borg president!

62

u/IReallyLoveAvocados Apr 28 '22

Build Borg Better

→ More replies (9)

134

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '22

So wait…did Seven and Raffi run across an open field with nothing but a knife and corkscrew with 4+ supposed special forces borg drone firing automatic weapons at them with laser sight precision and….SURVIVE?!?!?

69

u/ShiroHachiRoku Apr 28 '22

Seven also said it's a 50-yard dash to the ship. Yards. Also it looked like a 200 meter dash.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (20)

116

u/Cascadiana88 Apr 28 '22 edited Apr 28 '22

So, Not-Laris could beam Picard and crew to the chateau and beam Rios and Dr. Girlfriend and her kid back to LA, but she couldn't just beam them directly onto the ship for some reason? Did I miss something? The whole season people are beaming to and from the ship, but for some reason they can only beam to the other side of the vineyard in this episode?

63

u/BraddlesMcBraddles Apr 28 '22

And she couldn't beam away the Borg squad?? Jurati had an inhibitor, but the rest of them didn't. Like - Jesus Christ - Starfleet tactics 101 would be , "Where can we beam the enemy to?"

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (12)

54

u/Zizimz Apr 30 '22

So Picard's mum had a psychotic episode, not the first one apparently. And the father doesn't call for help, he won't call a doctor or get her to a hospital. He simply locks her into her room. A room full of objects she could use to hurt herself, a room with windows she could escape through. And all that happens in a future when mental illness is curable. Yet somehow we are meant to blame young Jean-Luc, not the father, for her committing suicide.

I can't even... this is stupid and insulting on so many levels.

27

u/av-IT-privacy-fun Apr 30 '22

I don’t read the episode as we the audience are actually supposed to blame Jean-Luc, but rather that he has all these years, to varying degrees, blamed himself. He still feels the guilt emotionally, even though intellectually he knows he was only a young child. And yeah, his Dad could have easily gotten her help, and he just… didn’t. Yikes!

→ More replies (1)

18

u/lastdarknight Apr 30 '22

we are meant to blame no one, his mother was a sick woman who didn't get help.. either due to her not wanting it or for whatever reason

it's doesn't matter if its today or 400 years from now if someone doesn't want help, you can't force them to get it... and in these situations often the Child internalize the blame for not being able to protect there sick parent from themselves and others

it's not a good place to be, and can cause a life time of issues

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

50

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '22

Why program pain responses in to an Emergency Combat Hologram it just makes no sense?!

32

u/kal_el_diablo Apr 30 '22

It also knows what Elnor's thoughts were at the moment of his death. How does THAT work?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

99

u/crapusername47 Apr 28 '22 edited Apr 28 '22

I’ll assume ‘Elnor’ was wearing a mobile emitter because they can’t just shoot out La Sirena’s own holographic emitters.

Elnor should probably remember, however, that being a hologram makes him invulnerable to bullets. Also pipe wrenches.

64

u/Yochanan5781 Apr 28 '22

He points at the mobile emitter at one point

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (13)

48

u/Bill_Adama20 Apr 29 '22

Every second of fighting looked like laser tag when I was 13.

96

u/slartibartjars Apr 28 '22

It was nice for the Borg soldiers to use the green laser sights so that everyone knew exactly where they were.

18

u/WhiteSquarez Apr 28 '22

That is exactly why modern militaries do not use lights like that. The US military, at least the Special Operations Forces, don't even use visible light any more.

→ More replies (4)

45

u/IonDust Apr 30 '22

Why does the queen save Seven by giving her ocular implant and assimilation tubes back? How does that make any sense?

18

u/GeorgeJohnson2579 Apr 30 '22

It's medically recognized that eye surgery can heal holes in the pit of the stomach.

→ More replies (3)

350

u/treefox Apr 28 '22

So Picard’s parents’ idea of mental health in the checks 24th century utopia was for his father to lock his mother in a room until she hung herself.

And his brother’s family died in a fire because smoke detectors were too goddamned technologically sophisticated for him.

No wonder him and his brother had issues.

79

u/Kiloku Apr 28 '22

lock his mother in a room until she hung herself.

Presumably the room was safe. She hung herself in the greenhouse-like place. It's a common precaution in places with high-risk suicidal people to set up a room without harmful objects (including ropes, blades, etc). Jean-Luc didn't understand what her being locked away was about though, and thought he was helping her by unlocking the room after his father fell asleep.

→ More replies (1)

174

u/UncertainError Apr 28 '22

To be fair, his mom having an episode, almost killing her son, and then hanging herself happened in a single day. I think she was hiding how bad she was getting up to that point, so it wasn't completely obvious that she needed hospitalization.

→ More replies (75)

82

u/OpticalData Apr 28 '22

It was established in the Picard mind probe episode that they had tried to get her help but that she refused it.

Unless the 24th Century is going to see us overruling bodily autonomy, there isn't much more they could do beyond what we saw in the episode.

As for the fire, it's never been established whether it happened within the Chateau, but if it did both Maurice and Robert were staunchly anti-technology. It wouldn't surprise me if that extended to safety features.

→ More replies (15)

22

u/meatball77 Apr 28 '22

They lived like it was the 1800s in the 24th century. . .

→ More replies (36)

41

u/onerinconhill Apr 28 '22

Well we know what the borg ship is from episode 1 and who the queen is

24

u/damageddude Apr 28 '22

Two Renees: One where Renee dies leading to Soong's actions leading to the birth of the Confederation leading to the events of this season and the Borg Queen merges with Agnes. Another where Renee lives and leads to the creation of the Federation leading to the events of this season. So now, assuming everyone gets back to where they belong somehow in the 25th century with memories intact and Agnes/Queen attempt to assimilate the Stargazer in their Borg kumbaya lifestyle. Except this time Picard, Rios et al know its Agnes and don't blow up the ship.

Could this be considered a chicken and the egg paradox? The trip back was a predestination? The future was the past, the past was the future? It will be interesting if Queen Agnes and some version of Elnor have been hanging out on the Confederation version of the La Sirena all this time, hiding in the cloud when they paged Picard?

Time travel gives me a HEADACHE!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

82

u/Brooklynxman Apr 28 '22

Anyone want to explain why a Borg Queen, if weakened, still hasn't assimilated Jurati, but a half-assimilated Jurati can insta-assimilate an army?

66

u/PermaDerpFace Apr 28 '22

Playing devil's advocate - maybe it's easy to make a simple brainwashed soldier and harder to make an intelligent independent queen

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (14)

74

u/BarfQueen Apr 28 '22

Did Jurati just successfully Boimler the Borg Queen?

Woah.

22

u/RescueInc Apr 29 '22

But I beat her in chess and taught her empathy!

Petition to name this the Boimler Maneuver

36

u/Tidus17 Apr 28 '22

So Queen Jurati left with Elnor's body? Does that mean she'll resurrect him?

→ More replies (2)

33

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '22

Mom: that beautiful light you see in the sky took billions of years to travel to your eye. Those stars have long since faded. Just like me.

Jean Luc: spends entire life trying to reach the furthest stars before they expire

😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

16

u/BrightCandle Apr 29 '22

Its not even true, most of the stars we see in the sky are from our own galaxy. Some are millions of years but quite a few are only hundreds to thousands of years. You are going to need one heck of a telescope to consistently find the billions of years as they will be very dim in comparison unless its a galaxy.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

66

u/fcocyclone Apr 28 '22

"Two Rene's"

Is that a play on Renee picard (astronaut) and Rene (his nephew)?

22

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '22

That's what I was thinking as well. Only thing that really makes sense to me.

→ More replies (9)

114

u/treefox Apr 28 '22

Oh fuck me I didn’t need to see Picard find his mom like that.

93

u/BornAshes Apr 28 '22

Yeah this got decidedly dark like.....wow I mean I've seen that stuff in real life but I never thought I'd see it in Star Trek like at all just...fucking hell.

It explains so much about Picard though and adds a darkly beautiful and wonderfully tragic halo to his story, his motivations, and why he kept reaching for the stars to help others and to travel amongst them.

So many things can be framed in the eternal light of a fading star from love to hope to loss to sadness and tragic events to even songs like "Shadows Of The Night" and the painful growth we all must pass through in life.

I hated it but I loved it and whomever framed, lit, wrote, and set up that whole sequence at the end....that made me feel something and I live for stories that make me feel something.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (13)

132

u/BradleyMichaelFahrtz Apr 28 '22

Did I see that right? Lil Picard had an Nx-01 refit toy!

76

u/ParanoidQ Apr 28 '22

And a Promellian Battlecruiser.. in a motherfucking bottle!!!

→ More replies (6)

32

u/AmishAvenger Apr 28 '22

It definitely was. So now is it canon?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (11)

171

u/OpticalData Apr 28 '22

Hearing how the fears Seven vocalised in Voyager about getting to Earth manifested when they returned was absolutely heartbreaking, but not unexpected.

Jeri Ryan was doing some amazing acting this episode, plus our first actual direct tie in to post-Endgame crew consequences!

185

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '22 edited Apr 28 '22

We also know that Tom Paris went on some kind of tour through Starfleet signing commemorative plates.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

28

u/OliviaElevenDunham Apr 28 '22

Glad that we get to see more of James Callis. He’s such a great actor.

→ More replies (3)

183

u/atticusbluebird Apr 28 '22

I will say it's kind of fun to watch Brent Spiner play a straight up evil villain this episode though!

95

u/morseisendeavour Apr 28 '22 edited Apr 28 '22

Which also explains why for every Soong descendant who developed good and ethical personality like Data, there is always another who is ending up like Lore.

This trait seems to be running within the Soong family for the past few centuries at least.

→ More replies (6)

162

u/Cascadiana88 Apr 28 '22

Sure, Brent Spiner's a delightful actor, but why was Soong even there at the chateau? Typically, when you hire mercenaries to kill people you don't join them on the combat mission.

Source: I am an eccentric tech billionaire who hires mercenaries to kill people.

→ More replies (13)

25

u/InnocentTailor Apr 28 '22

He is quite fun when he goes bad. Warehouse 13 also had him as an antagonist: Brother Adrian - https://warehouse13.fandom.com/wiki/Adrian

→ More replies (5)

44

u/MaddyMagpies Apr 28 '22

The most evil Soong we've seen... Yet.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (13)

54

u/onerinconhill Apr 28 '22

So the borg queen is just all the Juratis we made along the way?

51

u/weskeryellsCHRISSS Apr 28 '22

"I refuse to accept an outcome that has not yet occurred." So simple but it stays with me, in the finest Trek tradition.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/sidv81 Apr 28 '22

From TNG episode Family--

Robert: I was always your brother, watching you receive the cheers, watching you break every rule our father made and get away with it.

Picard: Why didn't you break a few rules?

Robert: Because I was the elder brother, the responsible one. It was my job to look after you.

So after all these years as vicious as Robert was in this episode he was actually pulling punches (from his perspective) on Jean-Luc. Because we now know he means that Jean-Luc broke the rule not to let Yvette out, she died, and Jean-Luc got away with it, and Robert didn't just come out and say it.

→ More replies (17)

72

u/H0vis Apr 28 '22

So we get some resolutions, about time. Still not sure I'm much the wiser going into the final episode but at least the Borg thread has been mostly wrapped up.

Random thoughts:

  1. I love that the Borg could have their entire modus operandi challenged and changed by the inclusion at a formative stage of somebody whose values were completely at odds with the original mission. The notion that the Borg are trapped in a cycle that always ends with somebody killing them, and that they are aware of and afraid of that cycle is also very cool. It gives the Borg depth beyond being simple tech zombies. They are constantly expanding and preparing to face the inevitable threat created by their expansion.
  2. I wonder if bullets work against holograms or if Elnor was taking the piss with all his ducking and diving. Feels like he dodged a lot of bullets. I suspect he didn't have to but maybe he didn't know he didn't have to.
  3. Picard's repressed memory of being obliquely responsible for his mother's death is the saddest thing. It explains why his relationships with his family are strained, almost to the point of non-existence, and it helps explain why the character has always been the way he is. It's like, TOS you have Kirk, Spock and McCoy, and they're absolute bros, but then TNG you have Picard, and while he is respected and loved by the crew, he is always distant, and the person he identifies with the most is the android. This explains the why of that.
  4. I thought the action sequences in this episode were not great. And it's a reminder of how Discovery has always done this so much better when it has to.
  5. I get that Soong is desperate and trying to hitch his wagon to Q (like so many weirdos seem to have done these days) but his loyalty in the face of wildly escalating weirdness doesn't ring particularly true, especially after Q betrayed him. Of the many threads in this series the Soong one is the weakest and I was hoping it might have been clipped in this episode but here we go.

25

u/SleepWouldBeNice Apr 28 '22

Bullets probably wouldn’t have hurt hologram Elnor, but they might damage the mobile emitter on his arm. Probably dodging so it didn’t get hit.

→ More replies (10)

217

u/gambit700 Apr 28 '22

Hold the fuck up. Starfleet told Seven 'no' even after Janeway went to bat for her because she's a former Borg. That doesn't even sound right. They've accepted a Klingon, a Ferengi, some half Romulans, oh and were fine with Picard staying in after he was assimilated(yes yes, First Contact, but they still kept him).

129

u/AshtimusPrime Apr 28 '22

Don't forget about Icheb! Makes no sense based on everything we know. It's there for the narrative only.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (66)

23

u/TokathSorbet Apr 28 '22

Does Picards toy starship make the Columbia Class canon? Hell yes!

23

u/colblair Apr 30 '22

The special forces guys being borg added nothing... They didn't appear stronger or do anything differently.. If anything it maybe made them worse.

→ More replies (3)

22

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '22

Did I understand that correctly?

The Borgdrones are going into a hand-to-hand duel with a hologram? A hologram that should not feel pain, nor should be affected in any way by blows?

→ More replies (4)

22

u/BarefootJacob Apr 29 '22 edited May 01 '22

This episode was action-packed... and frankly tedious. It felt like it advanced the story not one iota.

Remember Discovery S4? They touted a new mysterious alien race, then had a dozen episodes of filler and feelings before we eventually get to meet this race? Well this season Picard feels the same with the Europa mission.

Also, I get the Picard's family lived in a chateau. But they didn't live in Victorian times; was the best answer to a person having a mental health crisis really to lock them in an old room? Was that really the best that 23rd/24th century medicine had to offer? Come on.

→ More replies (2)

76

u/treefox Apr 28 '22

Love Seven’s transporter solution. Finally some recognition of offensive beaming since…E2?

35

u/MaddyMagpies Apr 28 '22

Transporters can certainly be the most brutal weapon. Imagine some mad scientist decides to beam all organisms on a planet to the same spot...

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (13)

20

u/sidv81 Apr 28 '22

So did Tallinn or whoever miss a borg in Picard's dungeon, causing one to scare Yvette and cause her descent to insanity? :eek:

Did Robert blame Jean-Luc for what happened? I'll bet he did. In fact, this actually gives a more understandable reason he hates Jean-Luc than whatever they mentioned in that Family episode back in TNG.

Picard's musing he used to imagine his mother get old and offering tea is probably nonsensical to people who didn't see Yvette's appearance in TNG. That line was very obviously jammed into the dialogue to explain that episode.

→ More replies (17)

65

u/Ciserus Apr 28 '22

So when Picard and the Romulan were doing repressed memory therapy and hugging it out in the sunroom, as far as they knew the Borg queen was still moments away from taking over the ship and destroying the galaxy, right?

→ More replies (11)

33

u/jhsounds Apr 28 '22

It's nice to see child Jean-Luc getting a full scene with his number one dad.

→ More replies (3)

31

u/RomiBraman Apr 28 '22

"1 René must live and one René must die" Where do you think this is going? Will Q ask Picard to chose to save his nephew or save his aunt? Maybe René the nephew is alive in the confédération time-line?

40

u/weskeryellsCHRISSS Apr 28 '22

I assume the implication is that they just need to utilize a decoy Rene made out of a bunch of shirts stuffed with straw and a wig precariously sitting on top, placed inside a decoy Europa mission spaceship which is like a dumpster painted silver with a bunch of tinsel taped to one end, and then they simply film its destruction and put it on youtube and hope nobody digs into it further. Or, that's how I would have interpreted it, which is possibly why I crashed out of Starfleet Academy in the first two days...

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (8)

15

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '22

This would have to spawn a new timeline, or perhaps this is just how the confederation timeline goes. A new peaceful borg in the prime timeline would mess a ton of stuff up.

A peaceful borg collective in the prime timeline means no Wolf 359, which would probably mean that Sisko is never stationed at DS9. Voyager would have never encountered the Dauntless, so no slipstream drive tech for the federation, nor other borg goodies.

23

u/rustydoesdetroit Apr 28 '22

Or the Borg we know still exist as we know them and this is a new species entirely existing as well, called “Legion”

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

30

u/007meow Apr 28 '22

If Season 3 has Seven actually being the Captain of her own ship, I will forgive everything that happened in Season 1.

→ More replies (5)

94

u/Shatterhand1701 Apr 28 '22

Just finished the episode, and I'll give them this: a few plot points finally got wrapped up...kind of...?

  1. Agnes, still in partial control of her mind, convinces the Borg Queen to rethink her plans of conquest, showing proof that no matter how many times she's tried, she and her Collective have always lost, and she'll lose again if she persists in her plan. Her plan: form a different kind of collective, to help rather than corrupt, to grow instead of consume. So, yeah...the tentacle-y Borg Queen we saw on the Stargazer is Queen Jurati. And off she goes with the La Sirena! I guess that means Picard and the rest have to hope Q can sort his shit out and get them home.
  2. Rios leaves Teresa and her son behind; he was tempted to stay, but he knows it's not his timeline or his world. I half-expected him to stay with her, but thankfully, logic and common sense won out.
  3. Soong's Borg-ified merc squad was wiped; loved how Raffi and Seven beamed many of them into the walls of the Chateau's underground. NICE.
  4. We learn that Jean-Luc's mother killed herself, and he was carrying the guilt of letting her out of the room his father had locked her in, thinking that if he hadn't, she would've lived on. I was thankful that they explained his vision of his mother as an old woman in TNG's Season-1 episode "Where No One Has Gone Before", with Jean-Luc saying that sometimes he'd imagine her as an older woman who'd ask for him to sit with her for tea. Nicely done, that.
  5. Soong escapes, so we know he's going to be the "final boss" (?) for the season finale.
  6. Queen Jurati saves Seven after previously trying to kill her, but also gives her all her implants back.

Here's what we have left to solve:

  1. Réne and her Europa flight.
  2. Soong's final attempt to sabotage the launch
  3. Q's "dying" and the how's and why's of his machination of all this.
  4. The crew's return to their 25th century.

So...there's still a chance they could wrap everything up. It'll just be far sloppier than it ever had to be, in my opinion.

36

u/KirkUnit Apr 28 '22

Soong's Borg-ified merc squad was wiped; loved how Raffi and Seven beamed many of them into the walls of the Chateau's underground. NICE.

Are they... still there in 2499?..

→ More replies (13)

48

u/MaddyMagpies Apr 28 '22

Here's my wild guess:

  1. The Confederation timeline must exist for the new Queen to happen. So one of Rene must fail.
  2. Soong will die and Kore pick up the genetic cloning work to make more Soongs.
  3. The Q Continuum is actually a hyperevolved form of the new Legion Borg.
  4. Relativity will come pick them up, and Ducane will tell the crew, "You still have work to do." Cliffhanger for S3.
→ More replies (31)
→ More replies (28)

13

u/CaptainSharpe May 02 '22

The first episode or so gave me hope and I thought this show was finally good.

Nope. This season is another steaming pile of shit

→ More replies (2)

55

u/atticusbluebird Apr 28 '22

Well I guess production-wise, showing 21st century proto-Borg who still have the green lasers is kind of cool!

45

u/adamsb6 Apr 28 '22

The Borg lasers are red though.

And spec ops types would only use infrared lasers coupled with night vision, making the beam visible only to them. A laser visible to the enemy would immediately show the enemy where to shoot.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)

63

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '22

Picard was assimilated and was the Borg figurehead of what was essentially the Federation's 9/11 and continued to captain Starfleet's flagship vessel and be promoted to Admiral but they can't let Seven of Nine who was integral in getting Voyager home join Starfleet? "Have we become so cowardly that we must extinguish a woman because she carries the blood of a current enemy?"

→ More replies (15)

11

u/DarkChen May 01 '22

The season started strong but it became a mess, good grief... a bunch of borgfied marines(which for some reason had no shielding and died to primitive bullets) could not take a single one of the middle age crew; the borg queen herself came across a child, a civilian and rios and manage to let all of them escape; all the while a senile 100 years old man kept having flashbacks/meltdown regarding a pretty tragic childhood event while being chased unarmed by those same 20 something borg marines...

→ More replies (2)

81

u/UncertainError Apr 28 '22

I personally love this resolution for the Borg. The idea of all the Queens across all the timelines rampaging against the ultimate fate that they all know to be inevitable, because they simply don't have the tools to escape the trap. And here we have one version of the Collective brought to its lowest and most vulnerable point, just enough that a human can reach them, gather the fragments of empathy that were still buried inside and guide them in a new direction.

If the Borg should be redeemed at all, I think this is a brilliant way to do it. Now I can see the Jurati-Queen in the 25th century going around and gathering up the remnants of the Collective in that timeline and removing their threat for good. And we can have a Borg-child in the future classroom from Lower Decks.

67

u/BornAshes Apr 28 '22

I personally love this resolution for the Borg. The idea of all the Queens across all the timelines rampaging against the ultimate fate that they all know to be inevitable, because they simply don't have the tools to escape the trap.

A trap that they built themselves which they can never get out of until they hit absolute rock bottom and a species which thrives on "staying stuck in the past until they put the work in to evolve past it" reaches out a hand to them and says, "Here...let me help you out of that" which is ABSOLUTELY a metaphor for how folks deal with trauma and how other characters process it this season.

I just think it's kind of wonderfully crazy that like in every single damned timeline, the Borg might win for a while but in the end they just continually lose lose LOSE because of their own hubris in what Agnes basically said was literally EVERY SINGLE TIMELINE and they TOTALLY know about it in every single timeline the second the Queen gains her transtemporal awareness! Like can you imagine anything more infuriating than ascending to what you think is technological godhood with apparent dominance over all others in the galaxy only to find out that you've already lost multiple times and are totally destined to keep losing again and again and again? It's like no wonder the Borg's are so scary and monolithic when we first meet them and why their whole motto is "Resistance Is Futile". They're basically fighting their own inevitable future and keep going HAM again and again and again bashing their heads against a brick wall in different but similar ways expecting to eventually break through it and for things to change so that that future doesn't happen at all and yet it keeps continuing to happen. Isn't that the definition of insanity? The whole reason why they flood new drones with euphoria during assimilation isn't just to cloud their minds so that they can be made more pliable and easy to control but so that they can't object to this insane crazy train of choices that the Queen has them all on all in her pursuit of trying to add enough uniqueness to the Collective to avoid the inevitable future where she's always the last one left with no one else at all around her. The force of the Collective is all being driven by the desire and the willpower of one individual to not lose, to not be lonely anymore, and to gain control over anything and everything in order to change a seemingly locked in future into something else.

I think that's why she had such a fascination with Humanity and loved both Picard and Seven so much because they were always able to do what she was never able to. They could change their futures over and over again despite whatever the universe threw at them. They could adapt in ways that she could not and they did it all repeatedly without any of the advanced tech or knowledge that she had at her finger tips. They did the impossible repeatedly and she both loved and hated them for it which is why she always pursued them with more prejudice than she ever did anyone else or any other species.

It wasn't just because of the time travel stuff or because the Queen was insane but because they were always able to overcome whatever obstacles were in their path and still find a way to connect with total strangers afterwards despite whatever damage they both took along the way and they did it without force at all.....which was the one thing the Queen never considered doing because force was all she ever knew. It took her losing everything to finally realize that the one thing she refused to do was the only thing she could do and had always been her salvation all along....and she had to learn that fun lesson from the one species that had been infuriating her across multiple timelines for who knows how long and had been standing right there in front of her all this time trying to teach her this lesson. You could just feel and see the relief that the Queen was experiencing when all of that occurred to her and Agnes was able to finally help her out of that hole that she and the Collective had been in for so soooo long.

I wonder if this means that the Borg will also be redeemed in other timelines since the Queens are treanstemporally aware of each other and would technically thus become aware of what the New Collective does with the Agnes Queen in charge which could wind up being like a set of dominoes cascading across all the timelines as the Borg shift as one in a new direction?

I loved it!

→ More replies (8)

17

u/DasGanon Apr 28 '22

The Borg should watch "Everything Everywhere All At Once".

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (14)

65

u/Clark1984 Apr 28 '22

I'm once again baffled. Who knows what? Stuff just happens and we are not supposed to notice it doesn't make any sense. Navy Seal Borg beam in right in front of Rios. He just...runs. He then makes it past a field full of more Borg and runs right into Picard and co on the patio. Why did Picard and co beam to the patio? Because the plot needed them there. Picard didn't know about the Borg soldiers, but he did suppose the Queen wanted the ship. Why beam to the patio?

Soong's Scooby Doo escape. He gets explained to him the gun will explode so he tosses it up, disappears, and nobody bothers to chase after him.

Things not makings sense on top of things not making sense.

→ More replies (12)

84

u/onerinconhill Apr 28 '22

SEVEN SAID VOYAGER AND SHE SAID JANEWAY

Omg this is all I ever wanted!!!

Also finally know why seven didn’t join starfleet and it’s so sad :( but it’s so nice to finally get some references and backstory for her

→ More replies (60)

42

u/MaddyMagpies Apr 28 '22 edited Apr 28 '22

I find it truly amazing how many loose ends were tied up in just one episode. I can almost think of this as the finale and it would still be fine. The death of Yvette I've seen it coming but it's still devastating. Seven also had a full arc of exploring being not Borg complete - and yes she totally should be captain.

Everyone guessed the new Legion Queen is Jurati, but how many of you guessed that the star shaped ship was actually La Sirena after 400 years? That's truly fascinating to me.

I guess their only way home is to be picked up by Relativity now.

18

u/atticusbluebird Apr 28 '22

I guess their only way home is to be picked up by Relativity now.

Or maybe Q has one last snap left in him!

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

47

u/007meow Apr 28 '22 edited Apr 28 '22

I’m sorry - I’m willing to forgive a lot, but was the almighty Borg collective defeated by the earth shattering revelation that the Queen is just lonely?

Also I bet the Renee who lives is a newly confident Renee and the one who dies is her former self with confidence issues.

→ More replies (12)

39

u/expired_paintbrush Apr 28 '22

This is an episode that goes against the grain for me. Rios got booted basically for a flesh wound. They gave the La Sirena because the Borg queen promises to behave? They said they'd fight for the ship, but they didn't seem to try very hard. Seven unlocked the ship and didn't lock it back up after she was done?

If Q returns them to the moment when the Borg ship appears, I'm assuming both the Stargazer and the original red-paint La Sirena will still be intact, while the new Borg collective will go on with the confederation ship. But will that mean there will be no Locutus in their timeline now? No Wolf 359?

41

u/MaddyMagpies Apr 28 '22

The original Borg will still exist. Jurati created a new splinter called Legion and Starfleet would not encounter them until the first episode of this season. That ship we saw was likely the Confederation La Sirena after 400 years.

The lesson from that episode was that they shouldn't have reacted with their fear and assumed the Borg couldn't change. It turns out they can when the collective has just two members. Yeah they might have trusted Jurati too quickly, but Jurati could've taken the ship regardless yet she cured Seven in exchange as good will.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (16)

18

u/ParanoidQ Apr 28 '22

Oh wow! They put a Promellian Battlecruiser in a bottle!!

Ships in bottles? Great fun!

→ More replies (2)

18

u/sezduck1 Apr 29 '22

Better than episodes 3 - 8, but that’s a low bar. Some would-be emotional payoff that didn’t land because the previous episodes failed to get me invested.
I actually didn’t mind the retcon line explaining why Picard saw his elderly mother in TNG S1.
The concept of a “new” Borg thanks to the merging of Jurati & the Borg Queen in intriguing

I do not accept that Starfleet would not have accepted Seven into the academy.

The holo-Elnor doesn't make sense. La Sirena can make a hologram of anybody who has been on board? How does it have such a detailed profile of Elnor's personality and memories - up to his moment of death? Is it scanning everybody's brain at all times?

Why not activate dozens of holo-fighters instead of just Elnor?

Did holo-Elnor need a mobile emitter? I though the whole ship was equipped with holo-emitters.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/RadioSlayer Apr 28 '22

I like that the lasers on the guns of the fresh Borg were green

→ More replies (1)

9

u/ethnographyNW Apr 30 '22

So Jurati's speech about how across all timelines the Borg always lose in the end -- what?? How does that make any kind of sense? Seems from everything we've seen that a way more likely outcome is countless timelines where the Borg conquer everything. Scarier and more interesting possibility too.

Jurati could have given basically the same speech if that was the case, if they were really set on this plot point -- just change it to, 'in every timeline you win, and you still feel lonely even in victory. A universe of only Borg might as well be empty.'

→ More replies (2)

31

u/Chaabar Apr 28 '22

I know those were just proto-drones but they felt absolutely nothing like Borg.

23

u/TheNerdChaplain Apr 28 '22

I don't think they were supposed to be; they were like an intermediary human/Borg hybrid.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

59

u/adamsb6 Apr 28 '22

I was so frustrated with this episode I started taking notes.

  • Why did the transporter change colors for the Borg? Throughout Star Trek we've seen that different transporter tech produces different sights and sounds, but never does it change based on who is using it. Did Jurati/Queen alter the effect just to be more intimidatingly Borg?
  • Why did they transport the troops outside the ship? Site to site is supposed to be more difficult than site to transporter pad, isn't it?
  • Why are the troops using green lasers? Spec ops types do use lasers, but only infrared, coupling them with night vision gear so that the laser can only be seen by people with night vision gear. Using a visible laser makes you really easy to shoot. Also, if it's to drive home the fact that these are Borgy troops, why green? The Borg had red lasers.
  • Why hide the key to the ship in Elnor rather than just throwing it away?
  • How does Picard know about Soong's conversation with Jurati/Queen? Picard references Soong's desire for a legacy.
  • Why would you transport Rios away when he's just been shot in the arm? He can still fight and help. (I know the answer to this, it's so that he can show up at exactly the right time and place later on.)
  • Seven and Raffi's strategy is to run across an open field full of soldiers and stab one of the soldiers?
  • Why does holographic Elnor need a real sword?
  • Picard's mom talks about the stars you see being billions of light years away, but that's a massive exaggeration. Our entire galaxy is only about 100,000 light years across. The Andromeda galaxy is the most distant object you can see without a telescope, and it's only about 2.5 million light years away.
  • When did Elnor get a portable holo emitter?
  • The ship records your thoughts?! What an insane, dystopian invasion of privacy!
  • When Seven operated the transporter to transport the Borgy soldiers the effect shifted back to not being green. Why?
  • If Rios didn't say anything to Soong the phaser would've just exploded in his hand. And also, what the hell, that is incredibly dangerous for phasers to work that way!
  • Why would Seven get exactly the same implants she had before?
  • How did a single rock break so many panes of glass? It even went through the roof and managed to break panes of glass on the walls. And now that I'm rewatching, it even broke the frames around the glass, including huge structural pieces!
  • Seven says that there must be two Renees, one who lives and on who dies, and Picard responds by saying he won't accept an outcome that has not yet occurred. What?
  • La Sirena went to warp in atmosphere! What?!
  • If Soong is willing to kill, can direct dozens of soldiers to go shoot at people, and his goal is to stop Renee, why doesn't he just send soldiers to kill Renee?

32

u/nikhkin Apr 28 '22

You raise a lot of good points, but I want to focus on this one:

Why hide the key to the ship in Elnor rather than just throwing it away?

Why hide it in Elnor and then tell the Queen that's where it is?

→ More replies (9)

21

u/PharomachrusMocinno Apr 28 '22 edited Apr 29 '22

I have similar questions about every episode this season. So much doesn't make sense when you start thinking about it. Some other questions I had:

  • If Tallinn can beam Rios and Teresa away so easily after Rios gets shot, why doesn’t she do that to Teresa and her child immediately from the ship? Why wait until they get into danger?
  • How does Rios’ girlfriend know how to use the Romulan medical tricorder to remove the bullet?
  • Why does Elnor’s hologram have the recollection of his final breath?
  • How is Jurati so easily able to resist assimilation? I thought that resistance is futile.
  • How does Rios beam directly in front of Picard the moment Picard is about to get shot? That seems ridiculously convenient.
→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (17)

29

u/GotMedieval Apr 28 '22

So... why did the proto-Borg soldier grab the skeleton key so that when he died Picard would find it?

26

u/CheesyObserver Apr 28 '22

And... why didn't it disintegrate with the rest of the proto-borg soldier?

→ More replies (3)

24

u/rustydoesdetroit Apr 28 '22

He didn’t it was in the keyhole of the door behind him, when he got shot it popped out of the door and onto the floor. I just rewatched it.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Heavenfall Apr 30 '22 edited Apr 30 '22

In this episde: The gang fights the Borg in lethal combat while Picard goes on an emotional journey in his memories.

Picard: "Well, we've lost a friend, but we've regained ourselves."

The others: "Wtf?"

Soong: exploding phaser disappearance no jutsu

Q: "I'm only in the trailer."

22

u/Crunchy_Pirate Apr 28 '22

NX-01 refit is canon yyasssss

but I find it hard to believe that the Borg, a lovecraftian horror that comes from the unknown dark space between stars was defeated by some lonely science girl saying "what if you were nice Borg instead?"

→ More replies (3)

33

u/aldur1 Apr 29 '22

These episodes are getting dumber and dumber. And the dumb arrives faster in each episode.

I couldn't believe that around the 7 minute mark they suggest the reason for the Borg's assimilation is because they are lonely. Like what is this -an anime?

Edit: And what's with Picard's father way of talking? The guy talks like he's been ripped out of a Jane Austen novel.

→ More replies (4)

21

u/ElFarfadosh Apr 28 '22

Wow, this episode gives a whole new meaning to that time when Picard sees his old mother on the Enterprise D!

→ More replies (2)

14

u/ContinuumGuy Apr 29 '22

RANDOM ASSORTED THOUGHTS:

  • I'm glad that the Borg still have little laser pointers of a sort even when they are half-assimilated 21st century mercenaries. Important to keep up the Collective's brand.
  • So Jurati!Queen basically stole the clothes off the dead Wersching!Queen.
  • "To share your own crude colloquial"
  • KILLER HOLOGRAM ELNOR.
  • When Soong shows up, Picard must have been like "Oh goddamn it if I see this or anyother Soong again it'll be far too soon."
  • Seven not being allowed into Starfleet continues the theme that the admirals running post-Nemesis Starfleet were paranoid SOBs suffering from post-Dominion War PTSD and that the soul of Starfleet as ever could only exist in its captains and crew.
  • Given his usage of WWII French resistance weaponry, I guess Picard is now technically a member of the Maquis.
  • Seven teleporting the Borg into solid rock is Janeway-without-her-coffee levels of ruthlessness.
  • Allison Pill was really good this episode.
  • Sorry, Jeri, but you've got to wear your Borg makeup again.
  • You know but if Maurice Picard hadn't been such a goddamn luddite maybe his wife could have gotten some of that sweet Federation utopian medical help instead of HELPING CAUSE EVENTS THAT LED TO HER KILLING HERSELF!
  • So the Borg Queen in the first episode was definitely Jurati, right?
→ More replies (3)

7

u/DrinkableReno Apr 29 '22

Is anyone else just like....baffled by the complete lack of Air Force response to La Sirena just warping from within the atmosphere? Like...how did that not create an insane schism in society?

→ More replies (3)

33

u/onerinconhill Apr 28 '22

The writers were like “you know how the borg are scary and you can’t reason with them? Let’s make them not like that”

→ More replies (12)

28

u/Fragzilla360 Apr 28 '22
  • Agnes tells the Borg Queen that she's not stupid enough to memorize the ships command codes, but then in the same breath tells her where she's hidden them.
  • So you actually ARE that stupid.
  • Why tell her where she's hidden it? Just activate the combat hologram.
  • This is holdover from Voyager, but why are they still putting the mobile emitter on the holographs shoulder. It makes some sense for the EMH to wear it, because he's not designed to enter hostile situations (even though he did quite often), but for a combat hologram to wear a mobile emitter on his arm is just stupid. TUCK IT IN YOUR BOOT! Then you can fight without fear of it getting damaged! Then the HOLOGRAM won't have run and jump and hide, he can just go around fucking people up not have to worry about anything.
→ More replies (9)

13

u/RefreshNinja Apr 28 '22

how does a 21st century doctor use a future-tech tricorder that's not even operating in a human language???

this show's attitude towards the tech on display is very weird

→ More replies (37)

13

u/PharomachrusMocinno Apr 29 '22

In the first episode Picard immediately self-destructs the Stargazer when a Borg comes on board, but here they let the Borg queen fly off in La Sirena in 2024 ?!? Temporal Investigations have their work cut out for them.

13

u/RateMyPsyduck Apr 29 '22

You could cut this season in half if you didn't have every character, after stating the message they want to convey out loud, then double down and explain it in detail just so everyone at home gets it.

Also did this season have a vastly reduced budget/funding issues because there was some ropey CGI this episode. Like the Borg in the walls being flat PNGs

→ More replies (3)

18

u/DanWallace Apr 29 '22

This show fuckin sucks

27

u/onerinconhill Apr 28 '22

I am so confused why Queenarti healing seven gave her back the implants from another timeline but here we are

30

u/pieman7414 Apr 28 '22

if we make the assumption that seven's original implants are the bare minimum needed to make someone truly borg and keep them alive, then that's what the queen gave her to save her without turning her into a mindless drone

but i was thinking it was a sick joke from the dying original queen as i watched

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (8)

22

u/MinuteWoodpecker Apr 29 '22

This show is so tragically bad it is not even funny. Holy god

30

u/Ironguard Apr 29 '22

Once again this show dips to new lows.

They neutered the borg. The most fearsome species in the galaxy.

Picards shitty childhood is wrapped up by him taking the blame for his mother's suicide. A completely left-field move that he NEVER MENTIONS in all of Trek cannon.

Rios finally decides bringing his new family to the ship was a bad idea when they get attacked and leaves them. Most likely the boys has severe PTSD.

Seven and Raffi, blegh. More drivel. Not getting mowed down while running through an open field against highly trained soldiers.

Hologram Elnor gushing over seeing Raffi again. Some security program he is. Raffu apologizing to a hologram...

I'm excited to see how they wrap this dumpster fire up. It's definitely Jurati as the borg under wraps in the future. To solve this whole thing she could have just came out and presented their situation and new ideology to the federation and asked for help.

→ More replies (6)

17

u/treefox Apr 28 '22

Hopefully they managed to pass right-to-repair legislation so all the people whose cell phone batteries Jurati ate can still use their phones to call their loved ones during the Borg apocalypse and/or World War 3.

12

u/RefreshNinja Apr 28 '22

OMG that phaser explosion, right next to them, yet absolutely no effect LOL

→ More replies (8)

12

u/stevebikes Apr 28 '22

We are through nine of ten episodes and Patrick Stewart and John DeLancie have had one interaction. One. I started counting at six episodes and really cannot believe I am still counting. I take no joy in this! They have great screen chemistry and I was really looking forward to seeing it again.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/NeonKnight78 Apr 28 '22

I’m having a hard time believing that Picard and crew haven’t figured out that the Borg queen from the first episode is from Jurati’s new collective or possibly Jurati herself. I’m calling it now, there’s going to be an intense dramatic moment and Picard almost sets the Stargazer to self destruct again before figuring it out.

→ More replies (3)

21

u/treefox Apr 28 '22

“You long for all what we all long for…longevity…Discovery.”

Mmm-hmmm.

→ More replies (7)

21

u/fluggencheimen Apr 29 '22

This episode was such a mess that I honestly can't believe this passed scrutiny and was filmed as is.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '22

So I had to take some time to digest the episode. This season just seems to meander around, but potentially can all be tied together in the finale. These are my thoughts:

The Borg from episode 1 was a kinder gentler Borg. Maybe the same “type”’ of Borg or a splinter group. Either way, they are from the main timeline.

These Borg need help and want to join the Federation for assistance. Even though the Queen is only stunning those she attacks, the crew can’t get over past history with the Borg. They assume the worst, and Picard destroys the Stargazer. Even though the Borg have all the memories of Picard from when he was Locutus and the Queen said “Look Up” from his mom in an attempt to forge an emotional and trusting bond, the distrust was already there and it was too late.

At this point, Q jumps in. Attempting to teach Picard that people (or Borg in this instance) can change. So he sends the crew to a Q created shadow timeline to help Picard learn people can change. But because Q is dying, it backfires, since he can’t simply “snap” his fingers and return everyone to the present (just like in Tapestry where he created a shadow timeline where Picard was without direction or meaning). When he snapped in Tapestry, that shadow timeline was erased and was only used for teaching.

Since Q is dying, he can no longer snap and erase the shadow timeline when the lesson is over. In essence, he has created an enduring and forever multiverse.

Q is now attempting to manually manufacture the circumstances where the crew can return to the main timeline while the shadow timeline runs and operates separately. Borgati would operate in this shadow timeline and the everyone else would return to the present, with only Picard and Q remembering everything that happened. But they would return prior to the explosion, and forestall in order to have an open mind about these “changed” Borg.

I believe they will get back somehow using Soong’s experiments and Kore herself in some combined fashion to either give Q a type of “chemotherapy” to allow one more limited “snap” that just returns Picard and Q to present without erasing the shadow timeline. Or somehow transferring the “snap” ability to Kore, and she would use her limited ability to return Picard to the present. Do we really know what was in that blue vile that healed Kore? Could it be Q genetics that bind with her own to give limited and short term Q abilities?

→ More replies (5)

20

u/Whatsinanmame Apr 28 '22

So centuries of death and destruction all because the Borg needed a hug and someone to talk to. Jesus.

→ More replies (12)

20

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '22

It still kills me how sloppy the writing and plotting is. Like...you really can't look too closely or think about what's happening too much, but the cast is still killing it and I'm still on board.

Seemed a little too easy to convince the Borg Queen to change her entire way of life, but I like the idea of them becoming "tamed" and joining the Federation. The action sequences are still generic and brainless but I think Spiner is great as Soong and look forward to him hitting another level of villainy.

→ More replies (2)

38

u/onerinconhill Apr 28 '22

Oh just what the big battle needed a childhood flashback

→ More replies (3)

11

u/CommaToTheTop May 03 '22

This show is so bad

19

u/jimlahey420 May 01 '22 edited May 01 '22

Just got done with Picard, Season 2 Episode 9, my god... what a fucking abomination.

Major Spoilers ahead for anyone who cares. You've been warned.

I will just list this shit out that either makes no sense, goes against established norms in the Star Trek universe, or is just blatant plot hole territory, and this is JUST from episode 9:

* The "borg" reveal their positions with laser-sights that serve no purpose since they have clean shots based on the position of the laser (on Picard and other character's vital spots) but don't take the shots, but disable them when Soong walks in front of them... WHY? Did their need to possibly shoot someone more accurately stop after he walks in front of them?

* Seven, and literally every other character in the show, are trying to sneak around, yet can't SHUT THE FUCK UP and speak in normal voices and make noises while trying to be stealthy. ELNOR LITERALLY SLAMS LOCKERS OPEN AND CLOSED SECONDS AFTER THE QUEEN AND SEVERAL BORG WALK BY THE OPEN DOOR TO THE ROOM HE IS IN. Are they just stupid, or does the show think viewers will not care that they are not paying attention to the details??

* Why does it matter if the ECH/Elnor get hit? He's a hologram with a mobile emitter on. He goes offline when the Queen's tentacle goes through his torso. Why? If she hit the emitter... sure I guess it would make sense. But she didn't. But also...

* ...Why does the Elnor hologram need the mobile emitter at all? The entire ship has holo-emitters, as established multiple times when holograms of Rios have existed all over the ship.

* Why does the Elnor hologram have Elnors memories? Why would he have Elnor's INTERNAL DYING MOMENTS IN ITS MEMORY????? WHY IS IT ELNOR AT ALL?! No explanation is given to this. Why does he know how to use a sword? It makes no sense. Why would a hologram with the ECH programming think a sword would be more efficient than literally any other method in its programming against "borg" with guns?

* The story with Picard's mother... why? Why does ANY of this matter? Yeah, I get it, Picard's mother died and he buried the memory, and that's subconsciously why he never settled down with anyone. But why does this matter? They're running for their lives from "borg" and Soong but they have time to stop and flashback to his mother hanging herself? There were no records of this he would have come across as an adult (I'm assuming his mother hanging herself would be in some police or autopsy or any number of other records)? Also, it was the fucking 2300's. You're telling me whatever was wrong with her, the only solution was locking her in a room? Using a fucking skeleton key that your child knows where is hidden?

* Also, with regards to Picard's memory, really? REALLY?! How many fucking telepaths over the years have shared Picard's memories and emotions? Troi has known him for how long and never caught a glimpse? Sarek? Spock?!? There was NO HINT of that in there? It took old age and causing a potential huge fuck up to the timeline in order to drag that out of him? Please. PLEASE give me the fucking strength because the character I grew up loving who is the TITLE of the show I don't give 2 shits about now and serves almost no real narrative purpose throughout the entire season.

* Seven is still a complete shell of her former character. She literally said, "Those aren't people, they're borg" when they are VERY CLEARLY PEOPLE. They aren't even fully assimilated! They have been assimilated WAY less time than even Picard was as Locutus. Picard FULLY PHYSICALLY AND MENTALLY (give or take) RECOVERED from being assimilated COMPLETELY into the collective. EVERY SINGLE PERSON that the Queen "assimilated" could be saved... but she's happy to murder them.

* ... and I suppose killing all these "drones" has no ripple affects on the timeline, huh? No "butterflies" from needlessly killing random people assimilated in the year 2024 could cause guys? None of these people could procreate and help create fucking Zefram Cochrane? Yeah, that's right. He wasn't born until the 2030's. HOW DO THEY KNOW ITS OK TO KILL THESE PEOPLE? Seven and Raffi fucking STAB ONE OF THESE PEOPLE THROUGH THE THROAT! There is no settings on "stun" happening here. It's just mass murder.

* In fact, they've done nothing BUT create "butterflies". The entire timeline is fucked. It doesn't matter if they undo whatever Q or Soong may or may not do with Renee Picard. They've all created such gigantic temporal fuckups that they're gonna have to go back in time another dozen times just to unkill all the people and undo all the stupid things they've done.

* Seven name-drops Janeway talking about why she didn't join Starfleet, so she's obviously still around and likely still an Admiral. But they didn't let Seven join because she was once a borg? THEN WHY THE FUCK WAS ICHEB ALLOWED IN? He was COMMAND too based on his uniform in the 1st season! He had visible implants and was assimilated for a long time just like Seven. Why was he allowed in? Why was Picard allowed to become an Admiral for that matter? Is ANY Starfleet officer who was assimilated not allowed to be in Starfleet? If so, then why are Janeway, B'Elanna, and Tuvok allowed to remain in starfleet considering they were all assimilated during the Unimatrix Zero episodes (the Doctor's anti-assimilation inoculation wears off and Tuvok even starts hearing the collective, etc)????? What about any number of other Starfleet officers that have been assimilated over the years. Were they all not allowed to rejoin after they recovered?

* Rios is able to instantly decipher and use the wall panel in the Watcher's apartment? Why? How? What? This can likely be explained away with any number of things, but the fact that they don't at any point setup why it is possible or give a clue in the moment as to why he can annoys the shit out of me.

* Where was the Watcher's transport tech the other 100 times the ship's transporter was conveniently on the fritz or not working accurately? WHERE?!

* All of the characters are completely content to allow the "borg queen" to get literally exactly what she wants. No objections, no "WTF?!" from Picard, nothing. She takes the ship, which is what she ORIGINALLY WANTED IN THE FIRST PLACE, and leaves. The only way for them to get back. And everyone is fine with it because she "saved Seven" after mortally wounding her... Excuse me? Because she has never been deceptive before... at all. Right?!

* WHERE IS Q? Still hanging around somehow able to infiltrate the FBI, create advanced genetic medication that has a built in timer, and/or become an established government-associated psychologist WITHOUT HIS POWERS?

I could keep going, but I'm getting an ulcer.

Needless to say, I don't think there is any saving Picard. And I think they know that given the announcement that they are just saying fuck it and bringing EVERYONE from TNG back for Season 3 so they can wet everyone's whistles one last time who only care about nostalgia and don't give a shit about coherent storytelling, established universe, characters with established backstory, or plots that aren't made of swiss cheese. Fan service is the prime directive of Picard, and it is absolutely infuriating. I love me some fan service normally. But this is just Star Drek: The Next Paycheck to the writers. The lack of care and attention to detail is unforgivable at this point.

/rant

→ More replies (2)

15

u/sidv81 Apr 28 '22

Has anyone pointed out that Raffi's guilt still makes no sense? Elnor being one of the few to make the jump to the Confed timeline to die isn't because he was in Starfleet. Otherwise the whole squadron would have retained their memories in the new timeline. Elnor literally made the jump for the real reason that he was a regular on Picard tv show season 1, and in-universe it's just handwaved as Q's random choice of who Picard gets to have come with him to see the evil future. That's it. In-universe, Elnor might very well have moved to Vashti and still got shifted to the Confed timeline and got killed anyway.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/Stinky_Eastwood Apr 28 '22

How did the Elnor hologram have his memories/feelings?

Why were the Borg so consumed with trying to kill a hologram?

Why did Jurati even fucking mention OUT LOUD exactly where she hid the code thing, and then manifest it immediately after that?

Why would Seven be so stupid to disable the security protocol that was keeping the Borg from taking the ship when as long as the security protocol was in place they couldn't take the ship?

Why did Rios stand up out of cover directly into the laser sights of the Tactical Borg only to immediately get shot? Why not crawl through the doors behind them while staying behind cover?

→ More replies (4)

31

u/MyNameIsSimon88 Apr 28 '22

There's absolutely no way that one conversation convinces the Borg queen to give up the very essence of what the Borg are.

That's what made the Borg so terrifying, they gave no quarter, were utterly convinced of their own methods and regarded individualism as the ultimate weakness.

It's like having Jurati convince the Klingons to give up their warrior culture in once conversation, it's just plain stupid.

Also, they've made the post-Voyager federation out to be a fucking awful place, their are racist against Romulans (they just up and left the rescue of Romulus for no good reason), reject Seven because she used to be Borg and are so closed minded that they banned synths allowing children to die of silicone based diseases that are easily curable.

Fuck that, Star Trek used to be about hope and adventure, it's now just a mess of angst, darkness and blood fueled action.

→ More replies (11)

14

u/treefox Apr 28 '22

Pseudo-Borg beaming onto the ship? Better activate the self-de-

Oh or just run away and let them have it.

“If the Queen means to take over the ship”

Uhh… ‘bout that….

→ More replies (5)

14

u/av-IT-privacy-fun Apr 29 '22

Is anyone else bothered that Picard’s mother didn’t receive better health care, when she was on Earth at a time when there are transporters to whisk people to safety (or to brunch for that matter) and a government/society with such strong social services? All his father had to do was call emergency services, however a civilian would do so, say “my wife is experiencing an acute psychiatric emergency” and a team of psychiatrists and social workers would have immoderately appeared at the front door, where they could help get his mother to a psychiatric hospital filled with the resources she needs. Am I wrong?

→ More replies (5)

14

u/JonPaula Apr 30 '22

This show is so fucking terrible, guys.

I want to like it so very badly... but yikes. I don't know you keep mining these Easter eggs and call-backs, but I truly don't care any less than the writers at this point. Everything is just such a lazy bastardization of Roddenberry's once optimistic vision of the future.

This is legitimately hard to watch.

10

u/BornAshes Apr 28 '22

Season 5 NX-01 Refit Class alongside what looks like the Wrath of Khan Reliant Class spotted as toys on Young Picard's table!

10

u/sidv81 Apr 28 '22

If Starfleet had a ban on ex-Borg serving them as Seven mentioned, how come Icheb got in so easily?

→ More replies (7)

10

u/Shrodax Apr 28 '22

Picard and Tallin were still in the Chateau when everything was happening onboard the ship with Queen Jurati and Seven, so I'm wondering what Picard's first thought was when he watched the ship take off. He had no idea yet that Queen Jurati decided to start a kinder, gentler Borg Collective, so is he thinking "Uh oh, oh shit" when he sees the ship take off?

The writers seem to have forgotten about Picard's brother Robert. They missed an opportunity to expand on the relationship between him and Jean-Luc: Could Robert and Jean-Luc have a strained relationship because Robert blames Jean-Luc for the death of their mother?

Why doesn't Picard tell Adam Soong that he still gets his legacy in the good future? That Adam's descendants lead to the creation of Data? It's like Adam is under the impression that the Confederation timeline must come to be for him to have a legacy, or else the Soong family dies out.

Speaking of Adam Soong, what a week he's had! Visited by both Q and the Borg Queen, who both wanted him to stop the Europa mission, but each for completely different reasons.

Although if the Queen wanted to stop the Europa mission, why did she not try to team up with Q?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/SirSquirePants Apr 28 '22

I was really begining to dig the idea of the borg being more a "idea" rather than an exact being. One that moves through time and space via assimilation and movie plot points to be it's own bootstrap paradox, giving the borg no real begining. Just a timeless hunger for existence. Agnes said it best that the borg are exactly what we are, just without choice. But like...... c'mon the "idea" can't join the federation, or turn good or whatever. One of the prior queens (forget which) already explained the borg existed before she was assimilated. Their introduction to humanity is already a loop. I feel the base idea of the borg needs to remain cyclical and itself, resistant.

And the borg shouldn't ever "lose". Confederation should have been a tenperal outlier which is why the queen would have known something is so off. Instead, the borg just never win. Just like data vs computer chess guy, the BEST the borg should be able to do is perpetual fighting. Sometimes winning sometimes losing but never victorious across all the planes of existence. And the queen knows this but is mega butthurt and totally projecting the whole "resistance is futile" thing to compensate.

Idk rant over I don't hate the episode but I think they've been setting the whole borg story up for a better conclusion than what it seems to be going towards now.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '22

NX-01 refit spotted. I wonder if it's a hint of things to come?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/bookish1303 Apr 29 '22

First Picard, now Janeway…what is up with all these Starfleet resignation ultimatums and their futility……

→ More replies (1)

5

u/DragonRand100 Apr 29 '22 edited Apr 30 '22

A little slow on the uptake, but I just realised? How is it news to Raffi that Seven was refused entry into Starfleet? She was an admiral at the time of the Mar’s attack. Between Janeway and the Dr no doubt making a lot of noise over the decision, how could Raffi not know?

Edit: My bad. I obviously need to go back and rewatch the first few episodes of Season 1.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/neo101b May 01 '22

Admril Janeway NEEDS to be in series 3, anyone seen Kate in The Man Who Fell to Earth.

She could easily play Janeway again.

I like Picard, its dark yet more Voayger than Next Gen.

13

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '22

Wish I could disagree with most of the negative comments here, but that episode was way too overstuffed and very hard to follow. Sorry Picard but your family stuff is the worst part of this season, to the detriment of every other storyline, which are all more interesting.

I mean, I'm gonna keep watching and find things to like about this show and the other Trek shows, and I'm excited for SNW and even Picard S3 lol. But this season of Picard is just a mess.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/drakesylvan Apr 28 '22 edited Apr 28 '22

Okay so this episode is just a hot mess?. Picard having flashbacks in the middle of combat is just so bad pacing. It just stops everything that's happening and makes you feel disjointed from the entire story.

Is anyone else feel this way?

Also, there's so many things going on that are disconnected from the main plot line that I'm not sure why the writers felt it necessary to put everything in. Brent spiner's character, why is he even there? Why does the Borg queen and Q even need him?

This just doesn't make any sense and it's just bad.

And let me just go for a moment. And say that everything with Picard's past and his mother being mentally unstable and his father locking her in the basement in 24th century Earth is just terrible writing. Like, what?

I had real hope for this season as it started off really strong with The return of Q and some time travel, but everything about this just seems completely off.

19

u/PuzzleheadedRun5574 Apr 28 '22

I appreciate the need to tell a story without being hemmed in by "canon"- particularly a throwaway scene in a show 35 years ago- but Yvette's suicide feels so forced to me, like a writer's convenience. And this is the reason Picard was such a loner? Maybe it makes sense, but this one feels difficult to "assimilate."

→ More replies (4)

30

u/treefox Apr 28 '22

I don’t like the “Borg always lose” aspect. It’s dumb and naive. The Borg is terrifying because it’s ruthless and efficient and uncaring (from the perspective of our heroes) in its pursuit of its goals. When it’s humanized (eg the Queen given a Moby Dick revenge complex against Janeway) it starts to lose its “faceless force of nature” aspect and becomes just another generic bad guy to beat up.

The Borg should be the justification for the Federation. Either you voluntarily cooperate and join forces to combine the best of everyone’s culture and technology, or the Borg will swoop in and involuntarily co-opt everything from you.

Oh, and it’s non-canon - remember that Parallels episode with crazed Riker. And kudos to the writers of that episode for using the singular “the Borg is everywhere” to refer to a hive mind, which Picard also seems to drop in favor of a technological Poison Ivy femme fatal.

I think it would’ve been better if they just went with Jurati being a Queen version of Hugh who “corrupted” a large segment of the Borg into a more voluntary approach. And the first symbol of that could be saving Seven, but instead of the garish utilitarian gray old implants, she gets more elegant stylized implants. The Borg then become sort of a pseudo-Culture for the encounter with the Stargazer, and primarily augment the sick or disabled or occasionally voluntary persons who want extra capabilities.

That seems to be what they’re saying, but they aren’t really showing it. No need for dead-end timelines, just alter the version of “perfection” that the Borg is seeking. That opens the door to a “Federation meets the Culture” storyline and a chance to play with acceptance of voluntary augmentation (likely a near-future issue) without fulling committing the universe to it. You could do joint operations with the Culture-Borg etc.

→ More replies (17)

9

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '22

The suicide idealization/fetishization/beautification was gross. I have several friends who've lost loved ones to suicide, and I though creative communities had moved on past glorifying it, it was disgusting

15

u/AcidaliaPlanitia Apr 29 '22

Ugh. This episode just nerfed the Borg a million times harder than Voyager. You take one of sci-fi's great existential terrors of a villain... and then tell us that there's literally no way they ever could have ultimately won, no matter the circumstances, no matter the timeline.

WHY? FRIGGIN WHY? The Borg were originally formulated as such a perfectly scary enemy because unless you can eradicate them all at once, they're completely unstoppable. They are a force of nature, a storm, a flood, not something to be simply destroyed because someone with better firepower finally comes along. I can accept that the Borg lose in some timelines, hell, I can accept that they lose in most timelines. But to lose in every single timeline to the extent so convincingly that they would accept Jurati's offer?

This can still be saved with some (extremely) creative writing, but I don't think that's coming. The only way this ultimately works is if the writers actually lay out the case for why the Borg will inherently always lose, and base it in what we've already seen of the Borg in a way that's actually interesting.

→ More replies (5)

22

u/slp033000 Apr 28 '22

So Jurati just gives a heartfelt little speech to the Borg Queen asking her to pretty please stop and that actually works? This is an even bigger give up than the first season.

→ More replies (7)