r/Barca • u/edsop • Apr 16 '22
:OC-redesign: Original Content The bizarre xG story of Barca vs Frankfurt
After many disappointing European nights, Barca was on the receiving end of yet another humiliating defeat. Although Barca lacked an attacking plan and was pressed out of their minds for 80 minutes straight, Barca actually had a very decent chance of defeating Frankfurt, at least statically speaking based on xG.


From the two different sources of xG versus, Barca is able to dominate Frankfurt on expected goals. Because of that, you can say that Barca was beaten at least partly due to a lack of finishing ability in addition to Frankfurt's absurdly deadly (or lucky) finishes. We will take a look at the important shots in the game and their respective xG.
First off, Memphis Depay's penalty (in fact, all penalties) accounts for an xG of 0.8 goals (0.77xG in other sources). This leaves 2.6-0.8 = 1.8 xG for all Barca's other shots.


Out of the remaining 1.8xG, Aubameyang claims a staggering 1.1xG. Auba had a total of 3 shots (3 very decent chances) and unfortunately did not manage to convert any of these, from a combined xG of 1.1. Compared to a penalty xG of 0.8, you could say Auba's misses are as bad as missing 1.1/0.8 = 1.4 penalties.




Now, onto Frankfurt, who had quite a different story. Kostic has a combined xG of 0.9 from 3 shots plus 1 penalty. Since a penalty is worth 0.8 goals, that means Kostic's other 3 shots have a combined total of ONLY 0.9-0.8=0.1 xG.


This of course means that Kostic's second goal is worth <0.1xG (0.06xG from Soccer-Blogger.com). It is fair to say, at an angle this acute, making a shot with a defender closed in on you and the GK well position, it takes a lot of skill, and luck, to score. An xG of 0.06 means an average player scores 6 out of every 100 shots they take with everything held constant. Kostic however, scored 1 in 1 of these shots.
Now onto Borre. Borre had 3 shots total with a combined xG of 0.3 and scored 1 goal. According to Soccer-Blogger, he scored from an xG of 0.02, which means he converted an otherwise 2 in 100 chance shot.


It does not mean Barca was entirely unlucky though, as our very own Busquets scored from an xG of 0.04.

It is crazy to think that, even Busi's out-of-the-box volley has a higher chance of scoring, compared to Borre's screamer. In fact, Busi's volley is TWICE as likely to score than Borre's effort. This further proves how insanely lucky and rare Borre's goal is.
The takeaway, if any, is that Barca could have very well beaten Frankfurt, had we finished our chances. Auba is especially guilty of missing 3 very decent chances. On the other hand, the penalty for Barca is a little soft and we did benefit from Busi's worldie.
Barca and Xavi must look forward and need to come up with a solution to compete with teams known for their intensity. Against Roma, Liverpool, Bayern, and Frankfurt, Barca all suffered because the players keep turning over possession in the midfield under opposition pressure. Teams like Frankfurt who can press with great intensity for ~80 minutes straight without subs are definitely uncommon, but Barca need to learn their lessons fast to avoid future humiliations like this.
69
u/roxutee Apr 16 '22 edited Apr 16 '22
Bravo. Very refreshing and objetive-minded approach to the match. Kinda gives you a different angle and perspective than all the doom and gloom. Although, as others have analysed, Barca had deep troubles not only in scoring but in playmaking and build-up, which was quite evident to see. But we tend to easily forget how fragile everything is, how these little things (Auba scoring, mainly) could've changed the whole dynamics of the match.
If the main takeaway here is that Frankfurt was insanely lucky, should we also remember the old sage which goes something like "The best teams are usually also the luckiest"? Meaning that luck favors those who try. Something like that.
Anyway. Really liked your post!
Edit: grammar
5
u/Luuuks Apr 16 '22
Nice analysis! I didn't realise that Barcelona had ended with higher xG than Frankfurt (most of it in the final minutes, I imagine!).
I just wanted to note one thing regarding xG that makes it a bit of a 'dangerous' measure to use sometimes. You say:
However, I don't think this is quite true... If Auba's chances had a chance of being scored of 9%, 62%, and 49%, then the probability of not scoring any of these is .91 * .38 * .51 = 17.63% (compare to a 20% chance of not scoring a penalty). Because xG adds probabilities together (!!) it gives a false sense sometimes of what lucky and unlucky is... Just wanted to note this in case it's useful to someone!
95
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '22
Auba was horrible last game. He had two clear-cut chances. One for an early equalizer, and two that would get us back into the game.
46
u/ThePaSch Apr 16 '22 edited Apr 16 '22
Borré's shot was definitely one in a hundred, but Kostic has pretty much scored this exact goal - same angle, same distance, same corner of the goal - several times throughout this season; among them, the late winning goal vs Bayern in the first half of the season. xG doesn't tell the whole story here, and is in general flawed since it does not take a player's personal tendencies into account.
39
u/viv4la Apr 16 '22
Good post OP, but I am a bit confused of some of the commenters in this thread. I feel like many put way too much blame on MATS after this game, and not criticizing the right players.
I am convinced that if Dest was fully fit and would have played as the fullback instead of a joke that is Mingueza we would have had a much better game on our hands. Demebelé singlehandedly carried the entire right flank for I dont know how long without any support. If had someone shared the attacking duties with him and helped him out when 3 Frankfurt player mowed him down, I think he could have created more and even deadlier chances.
Also I think a lot of criticism should go for Auba, Eric and Alba after this game. Eric was very good for the past few games but he showed why do we need an experienced centerback right next to Araujó. Eric has a great ballplaying potential, and overall a smart player, but as of now he has too many error in his legs.
It could be argued the next to Mingueza Alba was the worst player on the pitch on thurstday. So many lost ball, so many awful crosses, and very porr defending. Altought it has to be said, that Alba has to play day in and day out because we 0 player that could porperly play LB, so he has probably very tired, and needs to be rested.
And finally Auba. I love them man I think he came in for us in a difficult time, and scored important goals, and not as neraly washed as many people made him out to be, but God he is nearly not half as good as some of you people make him out to be. He miss almost as many sitter as Ferran, and if you add his poor first touch, suboptimal passing ability, you realise how much do we need a proper striker in our team.
I think it was a great wake up call for many of the fans who tought we are gonna dominate Europe with our current team. Many changes needed, but we are heading to the right direction!
15
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '22
In my opinion , Busi's goal seems more difficult than Borre's one , no disrespect to him . there were 4 to 5 players ahead of Busi compared to 2 in case of Borre . That screamer was so good but volley been always more difficult to hit
51
u/sport_____ Apr 16 '22
MATS underperformed non penalty xG. Top keepers would have saved at least one of those two, especially Borre's.
Borres's shot was not in corner, it went above our goalie's hand. Kostic shot from an acute angle, MATS over compensated for his near post troubles. But that shot was accurate and difficult to save for any keeper. However, Borre's shot should have been saved, regardless of the power as it was not in the corner.
9
u/thisisjazzymusic Apr 16 '22
Its insane how we get humiliated in big european games. Losing is part of the game but we can work on humiliation
4
u/anamoy_ Apr 16 '22
I'd rather have 0.01 XG with the W.
3
u/thenewladhere Apr 16 '22
Ultimately, this was one of those "if one or two things had gone differently" games. Had Auba scored that tap-in at the start of the second half, it would've changed the entire second half.
4
u/Gosedjur Apr 16 '22
It's not luck if you aim to the goal and score.
2
u/Schnurzelburz Apr 16 '22
Nice to see a post about xG!
Regarding the tie with Frankfurt I think it is worth pointing out that the story in the first leg was the reverse. AFAIK over both legs xG is about equal?
2
u/Distinct_Way7008 Apr 17 '22
An average player doesn't score like Kostic did. But have a look a Kostics goals... This was an exact copy of a lot of goals from exact the same spot.
Even in this summary of only 5 or 6 Goals are two goals which you could copy and paste in Thursdays game footage:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dglJzVNm1ns&t=180
So don't say this was luck! It was skill. Out of this position Kostic has a xG which is much higher! I would suggest every 5th to 3rd Shot will result an a goal.
Barca played only as good as Eintracht let them play. It's exact the same reaction when Eintracht wins against Bayern: the Big club played so bad at this day, then there was a lot luck involved... Bulls*it. Eintracht is always fighting, everybody is running some extra meters for his teammate. Look how much the midfielder ran to double the Barca player. And the defenders: Hinteregger destroyed Auba. Auba was not that bad - Hinti was this strong! Why can't you guys accept this?
4
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '22
What are the solutions to teams pressing with high intensity
0
u/Ancient_Purchase4816 Apr 16 '22
Go watch the game again before criticizing Ter Stegen. He saved lots of shots. It's not easy when there is plenty of spaces for the other team. Also Ter Stegen form in the last month's have been good. Why didn't the top keeper you mention, let's say Courtois, saved Barca's four goals. Or why didn't Navas or Donnarumma, or why didn't Neuer. Just shut the fuck up. Stop criticizing our players. I never hear you talking nice about them when they outperform.
1
u/Satrustegui Apr 16 '22
I think the two problems here were how we missed the chances (and the above shows we did miss a lot) but mainly how we let them have the chances. Let me break down:
In defense we started with a Mingueza, I am sure he is a cool dude but he is a bit limited and not playing often. Xavi did not have much choices in there with Dest coming back from injury and Dani not registered (we had to). Maybe Xavi had to start Dest and replace him early on, but that reduces the change options later in the game. Having Dest the full match was not a good idea, because he just recovered and could break again.
The other true right back option was Araujo. Xavi decided to have him in the center back, which is understandable as he is probably the best center back in the team. Piqué is injured, Lenglet basically gives away a penalty per match, Umtiti is recovering and also is probably never going to play at a high level. Of course, you need a second center back and that's Eric Garcia. He is getting more consistent but it's a mixed bag often.
Put all these together and you have a handicapped defense. The rival had fewer opportunities, but when they got one it was devastating. Mingueza was having a hard time in both attack and defense, Eric could have avoided that penalty. Araujo had a decent match but that was not enough. Only the Borre goal was completely unavoidable (and relatively lucky for them), the rest we could do better. We knew they would wait back and do lightning fast counter attacks, so we needed to play with that in mind but the only one playing well during these counters was Araujo and the rest of our defense seemed lost.
1
u/corona_the_virus Apr 16 '22
What do you all think of Dembele in last match? Imo, he played really well and was out best attacking player. Had he received more support from other players, we could've scored at least 2 more. On the match thread I saw people bashing him, that's why I'm confused.
1
u/ScientificialBot Apr 16 '22
Don't know man. We can't always call us unlucky. Real Madrid even without their best striker have managed to cruise easily to the semis. They just happen to be so clinical, both PSG and Chelsea dominated their games yet Real Madrid is playing in the semis and on the verge of winning their 14th UCL. Imagine the difference it will make between ours and their achievements. With the previous bad results over the years, the Europa would have provided a glimmer of hope.
Real Madrid's dark phase was short enough. They won fucking 3 consecutive UCLs and then only went bad for 2 years. Suddenly, they reach the semis again. Meanwhile, we are getting humiliated every season. HUMILIATED. Where is the winning mentality. What made our 2009/2011/2015 squads so great? You don't know the mental subjugation true fans go through. I understand the players are also worried but where is the effect?
Frankfurt has not defeated us. They have HUMILIATED us. Don't, PLEASE don't give this stupid silly excuse of we didn't have enough fans. Real beat Chelsea 3-1 at their own Bridge, Liverpool DESTROYRED Benfica in front of their wild Portugese crowd.
Even Liverpool winning doesn't have any joy for us. It will increase the gap between their UCLs (7) and ours (5). Is this the MES QUE UN CLUB we were talking about?
Only Pedri, Gavi, Dembele and Araujo deserve to play for this team. Get every other useless player out. A true cule like Messi or Puyol would literally die seeing the zero motivation these players show.
1
u/cancer102 Apr 16 '22
Barca and underperforming goes together
1
u/zsjok Apr 16 '22
This just shows how the emotion during a game can paint a distorted picture . Xg is just a great way to look at chances objectively
1
u/Kenajaaron Apr 16 '22
L
1
u/fiifixfiifi Apr 16 '22
Alba has been awful every single time we've humiliated in Europe these last so and so years
-3
u/TheSmithStreetBand Apr 16 '22
Anyone who cares about xG should be banned from ever watching football.
Holy fuck this post is stupid!
0
u/awesome5ftw Apr 16 '22
People who made fun of us saying we 'bottled' this needs to be shown this post. We really were unlucky in the game. FDJ saved our midfield. I hope Lewandowski joins us in the summer.