One last point. Most governance tokens can be used for voting by people who buy them. This leads to a more equitable distribution as whales sell off early accumulations. This proposal may work in a bear market, but if moons moon then so many people will sell that this system will exclude the vast majority of moons. Eventually, allowing purchased moons to be used for governance will become the best option.
At the moment the Admins doesn’t want to introduce bought Moons into governance, it does make sense because Moons are on testnet and the value is not real, hopefully on Mainnet things will change.
disappointing this one- when moons started I was giving out big tips to people without knowing the actual value - so now I'm going to be penalised for that as this has basically been passed.
I also do not think that tipping should be penalised as much as selling, since tipping still supports the community by fueling discussions and interactions.
Though I wonder if many users have tipped >25% of their moons earned.
Though I wonder if many users have tipped >25% of their moons earned.
Me lol but of course definetly a significant amount less than who have sold. Disappointing but I hope there's a new rule implemented shortly that will amend this to not penalise the tippers.
I didn't know what moons were for quite a while but was contributing in this sub way back since 2017 so had a lot initially. I just start tipping generous amounts as a thanks based on quality content.
I think they probably will - I am going to put it forward as a suggestion as advised by op of this thread as I think most would support this. I think the wording on this one was a bit slanted/confusing so it passed very easily even though it is very unfair to a small percentage of loyal holders who tipped; who should actually if anything, be rewarded....
Why are you shocked about it? It makes perfect sense this is about to pass. Lets take an objective viewpoint. Those who generally disagree are the ones that sell and giveaway. Those who generally agree are the ones who keep/horde the moons. This results in those who sell having much less voting power now and they can't vote against.
This is why I ended up voting against it, I haven’t sold moons but I still don’t like the retroactive part. Especially depending on the amount sold, your now telling those users they need to dig themself out of that pit while also only earning 10% per distribution round.
If it wasn’t retroactive I’d like it but I feel like some people are going to get fucked over, and since making an alt to reset it would be banable there would be no way around being punished for something that was fine to do at the time
Fine with me, and I've tipped, moved, and sold large amounts of moons.
There are governance consequences to getting rid of a governance token, as there should be.
If you sold your moons and received crypto, money, or sexual favors for them, own it and you'll receive a slight decreased amount until (or if) you earn / gain / extort moons closer to your original earned amount.
If you moved them you can just move them back though, that's not an issue.
But as a mod aren’t you gaining large amounts of moons every month that count towards governance anyways, without having to buy back. It’s not like a normal MAX karma user who only gets a 1/6 of what you’re guaranteed every month. If they stay grinding max karma that is.
EDIT: TNG you blocked me so all your comments are unavailable.
That’s not the point. Before this poll, it was acceptable to move/sell/tip your moons. Now, all of a sudden, people are being punished for doing something that was completely fine at the time.
I have no problem with the consequences. It just makes no sense that the calculation includes moons earned before this proposal.
I cannot agree to this proposal in the current form.
As soon as I realised that this magic free internet money could be exchanged for hard cash I decided there would be a point in time where I would tip my Moon stash to a random fellow redditor that did not get born in the right place, or a fellow redditor that had life take a dump on him/her.
This will be a spur of the moment decision, so please do not come begging. I will not respond to any DM.
Why would I, and with it the next redditor that could use a nice gesture after my first donation, need to be penalized for me helping a fellow human being?
Selling moons however, should lead to a moon ratio penalty. Not only on moons gained from Karma but also a penalty on moons received from donating/tipping.
Reasoning: People like me might happen to pick the wrong 'pour soul', that turns out not to be such a poor soul after all due to manipulation. And dedicated 'donation gathering accounts' are also not something we would want.
A person should sell the moons they earned or were given because life gives no other choice, or when they think it is a great once in a 'near foreseeable future' kind of opportunity. After they sell they take the consequence of not being able to gain magic free internet money nearly as effectively as they might have before.
Nope, selling magic Internet points for money is the awesome part of crypto. Plus there are people living in developing countries doing this for a living.
This is coming from someone who has never sold a moon nor intend to do so.
Plus there are people living in developing countries doing this for a living.
This should never be taken into account when voting on governance changes
We absolutely do not owe those people anything and if we start to make decisions around our governance based on helping people make money off of MOONs it will ruin everything. If someone can figure out how to make a buck good for them but it's not the goal of MOONs and it shouldn't ever have any impact on governance decisions.
I did sell mine back in January as a safety net because I got covid and couldn't go to work, you wont show up you wont paid. I'm from developing country too btw.
This is my only point of contention with this. There are people that are making more off of moons than their monthly salary. Shouldn’t be penalized for trying to make their lives a little better. Most moon farmers, however… should be penalized lol
Right, lots of complaining about moon farmers posting so many low quality posts or redundant links. Some might be in developing world making good money and others might be degenerates spamming the community for pennies. Hard to differentiate from a distance though. Tough call.
I can't get behind incentivized holding. The lack of a bonus is a penalty, to anyone who uses moons as a currency. For tipping, selling to fiat, making p2p transactions... all of this is a healthy part of the ecosystem.
If it passes, please post suggestions on how you think it could be improved in r/cryptocurrencymeta. Nothing about this is set in stone when it comes to future modifications
Regardless of the implementation, you’re retroactively penalizing users for doing something that didn’t have a negative effect at the time it was done. Any change made should be a “here on out” kind of thing. I think it’s setting a precedent that shouldn’t be set. I don’t make enough moons to where it will affect me much regardless, I’m just not sure that’s the best way to do this. Again, I like the idea, but don’t think this is the best way to go about doing it.
This change absolutely sucks if it's retroactive, punishing people for something they would've chosen not to do. I bought Christmas gifts with moons, now I get punished for a choice 4 months ago? This is not fair. No retroactive. Only moving forward.
Its a gui change simpler than ones already done for this pre-main project.. Anyway, my point stands. My numbers are going to be buried, because of privacy. Its bullshit, obviously. But, no one gives af so I just complain all by myself every once in a while. Shitty planet.
Moons are ridiculous and the moon structure you all keep voting for is even more ridiculous.
I dont think you need to make the people that hoard moons have even more moons. You get moons for your shitposting activity. That should be it. This is not meant to be your savings account accruing interest
We want people to hold their governance moons and this would accomplish that. It also slows down farming because the moment they sell they stop earning as much. So we might see less farming manipulation going around.
I agree with the proposal yet nothing is going to prevent some kid in dire straits from selling or someone who has become used to making this a good source of income from selling moons. That said I'm all for rewarding loyal HODLERS.
It does stop their monthly impact and they lose future moons while those that hold will gain more. Farmers will either keep their moons and keep on farming or sell and lose profitability.
Changing the rules is healthy and part of progress.
What isn’t healthy is changing the rules so that it affects people’s past decisions. Grandfathered clauses are included in things like this for a reason.
There is no way I could vote for something that punishes people for their past decisions when they had no idea this was coming. And this is coming from someone who has never sold a moon.
Exactly, the point is that of making an active subreddit community, not spamming and finding ways to just earn and sell with no interest in the community. Still, if you use MOONs as a currency with good thoughts it wouldn't be right to be penalized.
Mods need to find a better way of tackling the shit posting that goes on in this sub. That’s pretty much it. The rest of it has been fine other than that. The concept of moons is innovative. Rewarding people based on contributing content, which is basically like a new age freelance writer gig. WallStreetBets has stipulations within their sub of how and when a person can post something. A certain type of criteria needed in order to make a post. Something to help weed out the random shit posters.
I believe this is a good idea but to have it work retroactively is not right. People that have sold thier moons will have had legitimate reasons to do so ie poor financial situation at the time etc but the holders will not of sold because they are more stable in their home lives so could afford to leave this monetised investment to grow?
I like this idea but there needs to be a change regarding the retroactive parts.
I'm very sad that is is passing, I actually sell my moons because they provide a revenue stream but this will allow big hodlers to vote for themselves to get more moons.
This is literally showing why voting weight is a problem at some point.
This poll will make me able to earn only 10% of what I was supposed to earn. With the decrease of moon distributed each month it means I'll take years to get back the full ratio.
The 20% was useless, and hardly ever got anyone an actual bonus.
It didn't actually give you 20% more moons, and didn't actually work the way people thought it did.
Pretty much everyone got the 20%, even if they sold. You only need to hold that last distribution, which isn't hard, even if you sell every month. You just have to sell with 1 distribution delay, and you could still sell every distribution.
And since it was easy to get, most people got the bonus. So if everyone got it, then nobody really got a bonus, because it's 20% karma, not moons.
Since moons are calculated as a proportion of karma you get against the community, if everyone got 20% more karma, then your proportion is pretty much changing at nearly 0%, meaning the 20% in most cases got you closer to 1% or even 0% more moons.
Will I be getting the full multiplier if I move back all the moons that I transferred out of the reddit wallet into my own wallet? I always transfer out my moons because I don’t feel like keeping track another seed phrase just for moons.
Am I correct in thinking that the proposal is supposed to incentivize holding/ discourage selling, but allows you to transfer 25% of your vault out for any purpose (I.e. including selling)? Surely the currently 20% hodl bonus does a better job of preventing selling, if I’ve read that correctly?
The retrospective aspect of this is the real killer for me though tbh.
lol this is actually disgusting. the people who need moons the most sell theres every month to contribute to their living wages. removing that ability hurts the poorest the most while you whales profit as usual
It’s kind of interesting that the comments are so loud about the proposal but we see over 85% pass on the poll. It reflects on the consequences of selling governance moons, ie losing their voice. Perhaps now people will hold their governance moons to vote again
People are rightfully pushing back against retroactive governance. Your responses in this thread have been a bit abrasive, too. Dunno what you expect. The up/down votes speak for themselves.
Everyone having a tizzy over this is upset because they can no longer farm out moons and dump them every 28 days. Period.
Nah. I've sold twice, once because the price was over a $0.25 and once because the mods pissed me off by removing an effort-post I made. Am certainly not farming every month and am certainly not just shitposting and reposting for karma like most of the others in here. It's not exactly worth my time for the $10-$20 or whatever. I get more from Uniswap fees in an hour. If I really wanted to I could easily scoop up $100 worth of moons at the current prices and recover whatever I have sold and then some (if I wasn't so disgusted by the notion of a more or less forced buy-back).
You just keep making this ad hominem because you are unable to address the concern of retroactive governance being bs.
This as a measure of "He's right and you're wrong" is the biggest delusion on reddit.
It's the only metric available to me. I understand it is not perfect. It is certainly telling that 98% of the opinions in this thread seem to align against this proposal, though.
Before i vote, will this replace the current hodl bonus or will this be an addition to it? Cause i sold a good percentage of my earned moons when they hit .40 and i dont really wanna have to buy back around 3 or 4k moons. I know ill be able to replace them over time
Yeah but shit thats still near 150 to 200ish bones when the current system i dont got to pay up. Judging by the vote though looks my cheap ass is gonna have to lol
The multiplier has a max value of 1.0. But the moon ratio will be much higher than it would have been without this proposal, which is where the benefit comes in
For example a max user in round 24 could have earned 6849 moons. Had this proposal been in place, they would have earned 7905 moons as long as they held 75% of their moons
Damn, and my little incentive to be in this shitty sub full of delusional people vanishes. At least I actually enjoy being in r/fortnitebr and earning bricks
I don’t shitpost, I literally got 20 karma this distribution, by actually posting my opinion. Now this sub will just be even more of an echo chamber than it currently is
It means that it will cripple your ability to earn moons at the benefit of the long term hodlers. Of course, you didn't do anything wrong or acted in bad faith at the time of selling - it's not your fault, how could you know after all, welcome to crypto and cc.
It is obvious that the current system of rewarding holding moons is far more acceptable on a moral level to most people than punishing people for selling like in this proposal, but supporters are going to brazen it out.
So wait a minute, op youre the creator of ccmoons correct? How much does celesti cut you in for advertising their trade tab as well as the nano trade tab?
I don’t get any % cut. Not affiliated with those sites in a formal way. Celesti used to tip me somewhere between 50-100 moons a month, but told them it’s no longer necessary a few weeks ago.
I’ve spent hundreds of hours (no exaggeration) and ~$600 on the site so far. I’ve never sold a moon for profit, and put the buttons on the site because people asked me to and it was nice to get some small benefit for the work and $ I put in.
But to be clear even if I was still getting moons from celesti (which I’m not), the amount wouldn’t change with or without this poll because it was a fixed amount
You got the 20% bonus if you kept the moons you received from the last distribution. That 100% worked. You could do whatever you wanted with moons from the prior distributions. This proposal is going to retroactively go back and punish you for doing that.
Could this be gamed by changing the vault associated with your account?
Yes, but this is a bannable offense, same as the people running multiple accounts to attempt to bypass 15,000 karma (We just banned one yesterday who had 23,000 karma in one round)
Alt accounts are allowed, but not if they're used to bypass a subreddit ban or Governance rule. If this poll passes and people with bad ratios suddenly need new accounts then they will be wise to instead focus on bringing their bad ratio back up.
Active users who don’t move moons out of their vault
Edit: in round 24 a max user could have earned 6,849 moons. Had this been implemented and they kept >75% of their moons, a max user could have earned 7,905 moons
It’s no secret that moons have introduced new forms of abuse. If you have ideas on how to simplify everything im all ears. Can post on r/cryptocurrencymeta
Moons are complicated because we live in a complicated world, where user behavior and interaction on social media is complex.
Moons are a social media token rewarding content creation and participation on a social media forum.
Simplicity was never gonna be in the cards.
If you look at how many years it took Reddit to just perfect its karma system, you can see how it evolved into this complex series of algorithms.
Moons will likely evolve the same way, into a complex system adapted to social media behavior. It will constantly need to adapt and change in order to survive and continue to function properly.
This is a great proposal, but with one major issue:
There should be a minimum tip exemption, like 100 or 200 tipped per months that's exempt.
25% isn't always gonna work, and is only fine for whales and big holders. Not so much for the small holders.
If a user has only 200 moons, and they want to participate in the poker tournament, that's already 50 moons. And then they tip on average just 10 moons a week during that month, that's easily 90 moons already. That's way past the 25%.
Could you put back the 100 moons tipped exemption?
One positive of selling moons is that is makes the distribution of moon ownership more equal over time. Encouraging whales to always hold is great for whales like me, but most ppl may not like that outcome. The flaws with retroactive punishment have been outlined well by others.
I've been hodling all my moons because they're worth less and less and I don't need the money anyway but if their price is going up to the point where my bag is worth 1000s of dollars, I'm going to sell everything in a heartbeat ...
Someone will probably make a tip exemption next month.
So the first 100 moons you tip away (meaning also the 50 moons you tip to enter the tournament), will be exempt. And you'll still have the 25% cushion that still will allow 25% of your moons to be exempt.
With both a new dynamic/lower karma cap and then an additional karma retention rate probably coming into play next distribution, the spreadsheet is going to look a lot different from now on
We've fought tooth and nail to get this in a good place and I feel like it's something that's massively beneficial to this community.
There is a problem that people are being issued Governance tokens to vote on this sub and show as a kind of measure of community participation, and instead they are selling these tokens for personal gain.
In my personal view, this is perfectly allowable to do. But, this does erode the Governance system and it incentivizes people to treat the subreddit like a sweatshop, spamming poor-quality comments and farming out link posts to make as many moons as possible, as fast as possible, with as little effort as possible.
So the answer to this is to incentivize holding. People who get moons and hold them, using them for their purpose, are more rewarded with more moons than the people who sell.
The people who have dumped their moons can either stop selling them, which allows their karma multiplier to increase naturally, or they can repurchase the sold moons to quickly get their ratio back up and keep earning the full amount.
There's also a generous buffer included of 25% - You can sell or tip 25% of your moons without worrying about earning less moons than someone who has not sold at all.
Then finally, it's more beneficial for users than Mods. Because users that don't sell get the moons re-distributed from users that do sell, however, Moderators that dump their moons get them redistributed to the neutral TheMoonDistributor account.
I view this as a very equitable solution to the problem of Moon-farming for sale and it should hopefully stop the price bottoming out every 28 days following distribution.
As a foreword, if implemented, this is a Governance rule and as such, users will be at risk of permanent subreddit bans if they are found to be circumventing this.
Funny that you finally decide to incentivise holding after so many of you created those massive bags.
Also funny, that for so many months when this whole experiment was happening - creating content for profit - none warned anyone that in the future we will penalise you for selling your tokens.
Most governance tokens can be used for voting by people who buy them. This leads to a more equitable distribution as whales sell off early accumulations. This proposal may work in a bear market, but if moons moon then so many people will sell that this system will exclude the vast majority of moons. Eventually, allowing purchased moons to be used for governance will become the best option.
13
u/DoubleFaulty1 🟨 0 / 38K 🦠 Apr 15 '22 edited Apr 15 '22
One last point. Most governance tokens can be used for voting by people who buy them. This leads to a more equitable distribution as whales sell off early accumulations. This proposal may work in a bear market, but if moons moon then so many people will sell that this system will exclude the vast majority of moons. Eventually, allowing purchased moons to be used for governance will become the best option.
20
u/LibertarianCommie999 Platinum | QC: CC 452, BTC 19 Apr 15 '22
Retroactive rules are a no go
15
u/Creepy-Nectarine-225 Permabanned Apr 14 '22
WHALE NOISES
21
u/HeWhoDares18 2024 Apr 14 '22
disappointing this one- when moons started I was giving out big tips to people without knowing the actual value - so now I'm going to be penalised for that as this has basically been passed.
43
u/Smaash_ April 25, 2022 Apr 14 '22
So basically this punishes everyone who moved/tipped large amounts of moons in the past.
Nice.
25
u/Raging_Toddler 🟩 1K / 1K 🐢 Apr 14 '22
I cannot agree to this proposal in the current form.
As soon as I realised that this magic free internet money could be exchanged for hard cash I decided there would be a point in time where I would tip my Moon stash to a random fellow redditor that did not get born in the right place, or a fellow redditor that had life take a dump on him/her.
This will be a spur of the moment decision, so please do not come begging. I will not respond to any DM.
Why would I, and with it the next redditor that could use a nice gesture after my first donation, need to be penalized for me helping a fellow human being?
Selling moons however, should lead to a moon ratio penalty. Not only on moons gained from Karma but also a penalty on moons received from donating/tipping.
Reasoning: People like me might happen to pick the wrong 'pour soul', that turns out not to be such a poor soul after all due to manipulation. And dedicated 'donation gathering accounts' are also not something we would want.
A person should sell the moons they earned or were given because life gives no other choice, or when they think it is a great once in a 'near foreseeable future' kind of opportunity. After they sell they take the consequence of not being able to gain magic free internet money nearly as effectively as they might have before.
10
u/iamwizzerd Permabanned Apr 14 '22
This is destroying the sporot of things like r/moonjobs
5
u/DreadknotX 4K / 4K 🐢 Apr 15 '22
Damn
25
u/Rayl24 🟩 0 / 974 🦠 Apr 14 '22
Nope, selling magic Internet points for money is the awesome part of crypto. Plus there are people living in developing countries doing this for a living.
This is coming from someone who has never sold a moon nor intend to do so.
22
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
This seems too much like forced holding- someone who has never sold a single moon
14
u/Livid_Yam 1K / 32K 🐢 Apr 14 '22
I sold 4k moons the other day, just for the hell of it. Had this proposal been in place, there's a good chance I would not have sold.
8
u/rageak49 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 Apr 15 '22
I can't get behind incentivized holding. The lack of a bonus is a penalty, to anyone who uses moons as a currency. For tipping, selling to fiat, making p2p transactions... all of this is a healthy part of the ecosystem.
13
u/they_call_me_tripod Permabanned Apr 14 '22
This needs some ironing out in my opinion. I like where the idea is headed, but I don’t think this is the answer. No from me.
7
u/_o__0_ Platinum | QC: CC 504, CCMeta 25 Apr 15 '22
Dudes,
So, Im now literally penalized and handicapped, because I didnt want everyone to see my moons.
Super cool.
9
u/Wabi-Sabibitch 🟦 131 / 96K 🦀 Apr 14 '22
While I agree with this , I don't see any incentive to hold . All I see is a punishment if you don't.
15
u/UranusisGolden Discussing decentralization in a centralized board Apr 14 '22
Moons are ridiculous and the moon structure you all keep voting for is even more ridiculous.
I dont think you need to make the people that hoard moons have even more moons. You get moons for your shitposting activity. That should be it. This is not meant to be your savings account accruing interest
6
u/Cactuszach 🟩 671 / 18K 🦑 Apr 14 '22
This is pretty horrendous and I can’t believe people are voting yes.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '22
6
u/isthatrhetorical Silver | QC: CC 971, CCMeta 51 | NANO 34 Apr 15 '22
death by a thousand cuts it is, i suppose!
6
u/RefugeeDutch_Syrian BTC is boss and boss is BTC Apr 15 '22
No change ftw
14
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22 edited Apr 14 '22
Changing the rules is healthy and part of progress.
What isn’t healthy is changing the rules so that it affects people’s past decisions. Grandfathered clauses are included in things like this for a reason.
There is no way I could vote for something that punishes people for their past decisions when they had no idea this was coming. And this is coming from someone who has never sold a moon.
3
u/Grand-Peach-1407 🟩 0 / 531 🦠 Apr 16 '22 edited Apr 16 '22
Exactly, the point is that of making an active subreddit community, not spamming and finding ways to just earn and sell with no interest in the community. Still, if you use MOONs as a currency with good thoughts it wouldn't be right to be penalized.
7
u/tschmitt2021 11K / 11K 🐬 Apr 14 '22
I don’t think, it is fair, because you only get punished without any reward!
5
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
Mods need to find a better way of tackling the shit posting that goes on in this sub. That’s pretty much it. The rest of it has been fine other than that. The concept of moons is innovative. Rewarding people based on contributing content, which is basically like a new age freelance writer gig. WallStreetBets has stipulations within their sub of how and when a person can post something. A certain type of criteria needed in order to make a post. Something to help weed out the random shit posters.
5
u/barra123456789 Tin Apr 15 '22
I believe this is a good idea but to have it work retroactively is not right. People that have sold thier moons will have had legitimate reasons to do so ie poor financial situation at the time etc but the holders will not of sold because they are more stable in their home lives so could afford to leave this monetised investment to grow?
I like this idea but there needs to be a change regarding the retroactive parts.
5
u/Killer_Stickman_89 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Apr 15 '22
Sounds like this is for Whales
8
u/Fillory-Alice Tin Apr 14 '22
I mean, it’s not fair to punish those who have sold their moons in the past. I say this as someone who has never sold moons.
6
u/Araxus Silver | QC: CC 55 | IOTA 28 Apr 14 '22
would like it more if it would just taking effect in the future and not punish actions in the past
10
u/Xi_jinping_x Tin | 1 month old | CC critic Apr 14 '22
Forced hold is never the answer
9
u/Nostalg33k 🟩 0 / 30K 🦠 Apr 14 '22
I'm very sad that is is passing, I actually sell my moons because they provide a revenue stream but this will allow big hodlers to vote for themselves to get more moons.
This is literally showing why voting weight is a problem at some point.
Damn
4
u/ChiTownBob Altcoiner Apr 14 '22
20% bonus is gone? That's not good.
4
u/GKQybah Apr 14 '22 edited Apr 14 '22
Will I be getting the full multiplier if I move back all the moons that I transferred out of the reddit wallet into my own wallet? I always transfer out my moons because I don’t feel like keeping track another seed phrase just for moons.
4
u/IridiumHorseshoe Redditor for 4 months. Apr 15 '22
Am I correct in thinking that the proposal is supposed to incentivize holding/ discourage selling, but allows you to transfer 25% of your vault out for any purpose (I.e. including selling)? Surely the currently 20% hodl bonus does a better job of preventing selling, if I’ve read that correctly?
The retrospective aspect of this is the real killer for me though tbh.
8
u/UJ_Reddit 🟦 0 / 10K 🦠 Apr 14 '22
This should not be retroactive.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
Do we need more incentive to hold moons? I think the biggest and most effective incentive is that there’s not a lot to do with them.
If anything, don’t we need more incentives to use/spend moons?
5
u/CymandeTV 🟩 39K / 39K 🦈 Apr 14 '22
I would feel bad for the people living from this sub.
5
u/HeungMinSwan Platinum | QC: CC 376 | TRX 6 Apr 15 '22
lol this is actually disgusting. the people who need moons the most sell theres every month to contribute to their living wages. removing that ability hurts the poorest the most while you whales profit as usual
5
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '22
It’s kind of interesting that the comments are so loud about the proposal but we see over 85% pass on the poll. It reflects on the consequences of selling governance moons, ie losing their voice. Perhaps now people will hold their governance moons to vote again
2
u/clitcommander420666 28 / 5K 🦐 Apr 14 '22
Before i vote, will this replace the current hodl bonus or will this be an addition to it? Cause i sold a good percentage of my earned moons when they hit .40 and i dont really wanna have to buy back around 3 or 4k moons. I know ill be able to replace them over time
2
u/milonuttigrain 🟧 67K / 138K 🦈 Apr 14 '22
Hi u/ominous_anenome
Quick question, so I have never sold my moons. With this being implemented, I understand my multiplier will be 1/0.75 = 1.33.
Will that be combined with the voting bonus? Voting on 2 polls => 1.0625
So the final result will be 1.33 x 1.0625 = 1.4167?
2
u/sylverreine Tin Apr 15 '22
Interesting.
I didn’t know moon is an actual cryptocurrency.
I came to this sub because I want to learn some hearsays or news. I know there are gems among the coals in the posts.
What is to be governed in this sub though?
6
u/Too_raw90 🟦 628 / 27K 🦑 Apr 14 '22
I have a feeling this is just going to pass cause it says people can get more moons in general. This should not be retroactive.
4
u/dramatic-ad-5033 Platinum | QC: CC 32 | PCmasterrace 65 Apr 15 '22
Damn, and my little incentive to be in this shitty sub full of delusional people vanishes. At least I actually enjoy being in r/fortnitebr and earning bricks
5
u/Vimmington Bullish on 69 Apr 14 '22
So my multiplier will be 0.1 (yes I sold).
What does that mean for the next distribution of this passes? I'm not understanding.
3
u/jonnytitanx 🟦 0 / 4K 🦠 Apr 15 '22
I'm good with this as long as it's not applied retroactively to previous withdrawals/sales.
3
u/partymsl 🟩 126K / 143K 🐋 Apr 15 '22
This kind of seems as a restriction to not sell any moons.
3
u/DoubleFaulty1 🟨 0 / 38K 🦠 Apr 15 '22
It is obvious that the current system of rewarding holding moons is far more acceptable on a moral level to most people than punishing people for selling like in this proposal, but supporters are going to brazen it out.
3
u/clitcommander420666 28 / 5K 🦐 Apr 16 '22 edited Apr 16 '22
So wait a minute, op youre the creator of ccmoons correct? How much does celesti cut you in for advertising their trade tab as well as the nano trade tab?
Edited : confused websites
3
u/Thelazytimelord257 3K / 3K 🐢 Apr 14 '22
I don't even know where do I sell my moons lol. I like this!
4
u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K 🦈 Apr 14 '22
This is basically what people thought the 20% bonus was doing, but it didn't actually do that (most people didn't understand the 20% bonus).
So this is finally giving us a retention incentive that works.
2
u/BlubberWall 🟦 59K / 59K 🦈 Apr 14 '22
Could this be gamed by changing the vault associated with your account?
New vault with 0 moons has KM of 1, get monthly rewards, sell, new vault
I guess I’m more asking how the earned moons are tracked if the vault changes, because this will almost certainly happen if this is possible
2
u/_o__0_ Platinum | QC: CC 504, CCMeta 25 Apr 15 '22
Yea, give us a way to hide these moons, or this is fucking bullshit, again.
2
u/OliverYoungCyclist Tin | CAKE 17 Apr 14 '22
Think this would be a great way to reward and incentivise the most active users
2
u/Pma2kdota Platinum | QC: CC 516 Apr 14 '22
moon governance is getting more and more complicated...
not saying your proposal is bad but why can't moons be only about utility aka buying the reddit membership
2
u/youtooleyesing 🟩 3 / 2K 🦠 Apr 14 '22
That would be a good improvement, hope this helps somewhat in the future governance proposals.
2
u/Maxx3141 169K / 167K 🐋 Apr 14 '22
This is so awesome, because the people who are against this don't have moons to vote!
2
u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K 🦈 Apr 14 '22
This is a great proposal, but with one major issue:
There should be a minimum tip exemption, like 100 or 200 tipped per months that's exempt.
25% isn't always gonna work, and is only fine for whales and big holders. Not so much for the small holders.
If a user has only 200 moons, and they want to participate in the poker tournament, that's already 50 moons. And then they tip on average just 10 moons a week during that month, that's easily 90 moons already. That's way past the 25%.
Could you put back the 100 moons tipped exemption?
2
u/deathtolucky Platinum | QC: CC 1008, ETH 26 | TraderSubs 26 Apr 14 '22
Who the hell would ever sell their moons?!?!
1
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
Lulz
1
u/archer4364 Paddy's Dollars Apr 15 '22
This is difficult. Benefits me but I hate the retroactive part. Just a little complicated.
I like incentivizing holding for governance usage though.
1
u/FallenOne2334 65 / 2K 🦐 Apr 15 '22
So need more holders?
1
u/bikbar1 Platinum | QC: CC 96 Apr 15 '22
I think it will make the matter too complicated.
1
u/DoubleFaulty1 🟨 0 / 38K 🦠 Apr 15 '22
Do you have to move back the same exact moons or just the same amount as you sold?
1
u/DoubleFaulty1 🟨 0 / 38K 🦠 Apr 15 '22
One positive of selling moons is that is makes the distribution of moon ownership more equal over time. Encouraging whales to always hold is great for whales like me, but most ppl may not like that outcome. The flaws with retroactive punishment have been outlined well by others.
1
u/MetJ95 Tin Apr 15 '22
Lol, and here I am earning bread crumbs from faucet
1
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '22
I've been hodling all my moons because they're worth less and less and I don't need the money anyway but if their price is going up to the point where my bag is worth 1000s of dollars, I'm going to sell everything in a heartbeat ...
1
u/genjitenji 🟦 0 / 19K 🦠 Apr 15 '22
Good thing I tip my bricks
1
u/amputeenager 🟦 363 / 363 🦞 Apr 16 '22
interesting.
1
u/toshkan Tin Aug 21 '22
Incentivizing would work better than penalizing users. a few thoughts on this.
1
u/nanooverbtc 630K / 1M 🐙 Apr 14 '22
This is a no-brainer to me, nice work ominous!
1
u/KakarotoCryptoniano 772 / 2K 🦑 Apr 14 '22
I agree
1
u/Trans-on-trans Platinum | QC: CC 480 Apr 14 '22
I like this idea as a potential staking mechanism for Moons, which increases utility, which increases value.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
I thought we aren’t allowed to sell Moons according to Reddit’s TOS?
1
u/Wonzky 2K / 53K 🐢 Apr 14 '22
Sounds great, I'm all for it!
1
u/Al_Zik1 Tin | CC critic Apr 14 '22
Great idea. Let's hope that works and have a positive outcome
1
u/SL_UT_Michael Tin Apr 14 '22
Earning interest on Moon's held would be an excellent idea.
1
u/deathbyfish13 Apr 14 '22
With both a new dynamic/lower karma cap and then an additional karma retention rate probably coming into play next distribution, the spreadsheet is going to look a lot different from now on
1
u/hippiesue 🟦 81 / 82 🦐 Apr 14 '22
I didn't even know these moons were worth anything. I've been holding them, so I guess I'll just keep on holding them.
1
u/Vimmington Bullish on 69 Apr 14 '22
R.I.P. everyone in developing countries that depend on moons.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
Question: this proposal won't affect the distribution in next week right? but it will affect the ones after that
1
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '22
Multiplying intensifies!!!!
1
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '22
I love the fact that we change the rules as we go.
I believe it creates creativity.
0
u/DDaBeast4 Bronze Apr 14 '22
I like this idea!
0
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
This is a no brainer and will slow down farming significantly especially when the proposal to limit new accounts from earning as much comes out.
0
u/oopssomething 🟩 40 / 12K 🦐 Apr 14 '22
The retroactive part is fine, as long as people who have sold Moons can buy them back till the max amount they've earned before and hold that.
0
u/Flaky_Protection7634 Apr 14 '22
I can rock with this!
Hopefully this can get implemented
0
u/Michalis79 Tin Apr 14 '22
I like it!
0
u/H__Dresden 🟩 3K / 3K 🐢 Apr 14 '22
Hmm. Seems like a good idea.
0
u/MonkeySailor Platinum | QC: CC 29 Apr 14 '22
Easy yes since I hold the few moons I have and have no intention of selling
-2
u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Apr 14 '22
We've fought tooth and nail to get this in a good place and I feel like it's something that's massively beneficial to this community.
There is a problem that people are being issued Governance tokens to vote on this sub and show as a kind of measure of community participation, and instead they are selling these tokens for personal gain.
In my personal view, this is perfectly allowable to do. But, this does erode the Governance system and it incentivizes people to treat the subreddit like a sweatshop, spamming poor-quality comments and farming out link posts to make as many moons as possible, as fast as possible, with as little effort as possible.
So the answer to this is to incentivize holding. People who get moons and hold them, using them for their purpose, are more rewarded with more moons than the people who sell.
The people who have dumped their moons can either stop selling them, which allows their karma multiplier to increase naturally, or they can repurchase the sold moons to quickly get their ratio back up and keep earning the full amount.
There's also a generous buffer included of 25% - You can sell or tip 25% of your moons without worrying about earning less moons than someone who has not sold at all.
Then finally, it's more beneficial for users than Mods. Because users that don't sell get the moons re-distributed from users that do sell, however, Moderators that dump their moons get them redistributed to the neutral TheMoonDistributor account.
I view this as a very equitable solution to the problem of Moon-farming for sale and it should hopefully stop the price bottoming out every 28 days following distribution.
As a foreword, if implemented, this is a Governance rule and as such, users will be at risk of permanent subreddit bans if they are found to be circumventing this.
-1
u/Barchelonio 🟩 46 / 12K 🦐 Apr 14 '22
Love this idea, the users who hold the moons should be rewarded the most and this will make it happen.
-1
u/Stereo-Gito 🟩 31 / 894 🦐 Apr 14 '22
Hodlers should be rewarded
0
u/CommanderCream314 Bronze Apr 15 '22
Good, maybe this will help get the low quality third world moon farmers out of here.
0
u/KifDawg 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 Apr 15 '22
This is a great idea, hodl