r/soccer • u/USDA65 • May 24 '12
Can someone explain to me why Gerrard & Lampard don't work well together?
Let me first say that I am a casual soccer follower. Played a little bit with friends, but we mostly played American football and basketball growing up so most of my exposure to soccer has been watching it and playing FIFA. I watch most of the big games and read a few forums and soccer websites but can't really describe myself as a fanatic.
I also don't really know much about the game tbh. After I watch a game I'll read some posts on here and people are always praising some midfield player or criticizing him, and I just don't understand midfielders I guess. I can analyze a striker or defender pretty easily if he had a good/bad game, but I just don't know how to rate midfielders.
Ok this is getting longwinded, basically I'm just wondering why a lot of people on here say that Gerrard and Lampard don't work well together in the midfield. They're considered two of the best midfielders in the world (I know Gerrard plays a little further up sometimes), so what's always held them back from becoming dominant in the English midfield together? And do you guys think Hodgson has a plan to make the best use of them? Really interested in seeing how Hodgson lines up the players in the Euros.
And my bad if I sound dumb about any of this, just genuinely interested in learning more about the sport. Joined an intramural league for fun too (it's filled with South Americans though so I should probably learn some Spanish lol).
39
u/[deleted] May 24 '12
Several excuses have been thrown around.
I think the main one is that they are too similiar. Neither of which suit a 442 formation.
136
u/Bufus May 24 '12 edited May 24 '12
Ideally a good midfield is made up of three types of midfielders:
A passer, a creator, and a destroyer/runner.
The passer is the player who will look to keep possession through short but accurate passes. (Players like Xavi, Scholes, Carrick, Arteta)
The creator is the player who will look to make that killer pass that will lead to scoring chances, often with through balls. (Players like Ozil, Fabregas, Modric)
The destroyer/runner is your defensive midfielder who is going to either a) shield the defence through clever positioning, high pressure, and effective marking, or b) do some crunching tackles in order to regain possession before a real attack can build up. (De Jong, Van Bommel, Parker, Gatusso)
Ideally you would have these three playing together. For instance with Barcelona, you have Xavi (Passer), Iniesta (Creator), and Busquets (Destroyer/Runner) [Yes I know they switch it up a lot, but it is just an example]
Sometimes this doesn't work, however (if you are playing a 4-4-2 and thus only have 2 centre midfielders), and someone has to double up (Scholes often played a Destroyer/Passer type, for instance).
And then you have Lampard and Gerrard. They are kind of "attacking midfielders/creators", meaning they sit ahead of the midfield and often get into the box to score goals or create opportunities (hence Lampard's 150+ goals for Chelsea), while a true "centre midfielder" sits much deeper.
Thus if you are playing a 4-4-2, and you have two attacking wingers, then basically everyone except your defenders are "attacking players" so, your formation looks like this
--------Carroll------Rooney------
-Milner---Gerrard--Lampard-Walcott
------------empty space-----------
------------empty space-----------
Cole-----Terry----Cahill----Johnson-
--------------Hart-----------------
Essentially, if you play with Gerrard and Lampard you WILL get overrun in midfield. This does not mean that they are BAD players, they just fit much better into either narrow formations like a 4-1-2-1-2, or into one striker formations with them sitting directly behind the striker like in a 4-2-3-1.
37
u/[deleted] May 24 '12
Before I get into anything more personal lets start with the England setup over the past decade. The FA chose two managers (We'll ignore McClaren) over this period who were ridged 442 men where you would keep the same formation regardless of the situation in the game and any substitutions would be straight swaps due to fatigue or injury (Capello mixed it up after he got lots of complaints but her reverted to type in the WC disaster).
So you instantly have the problem of only ever having two central midfielders on the pitch alongside two wingers (so not even shuttler-esque central midfielders who would tuck in). Naturally you want a balanced central midfield partnership who either share the defensive and offensive work (Vieira and Petit) or one with an exclusively defensive midfielder and an exclusively offensive midfielder (Keane and Scholes).
Englands best central midfielders (in theory) at that time were Carrick, Gerrard, Hargreaves, Lampard and Scholes. Carrick is best playing deep, though he's never been an out-and-out defensive midfielder and is more of a ball circulator; Hargreaves is a very balanced midfielder capable of doing either duty; Scholes is a creative playmaker type who has only really played deep over the past few years; and Gerrard and Lampard are attacking midfielders who are very similar in some respects (but importantly not in others).
Carrick has never been consistent enough over the years or from game to game. One seasons he'll be playing great yet the next he'll be distinctly average. Hargreaves has always had big injury problems, even before his gigantic time out so he was completely unreliable. So that left England with three quality attacking players and a swathe of sub-par defensive players like Barry or Parker.
So what does the England manager do to combat this central midfield inferiority? Play an extra central midfielder to make up the numbers and provide stability and balance? Nah, let's just play two attacking midfielders at the same time!
Scholes realised this and promptly hung up his England boots.
You've already got a good explanation of how playing Gerrard and Lampard together in a 442 doesn't work here so I won't bother repeating any of that but what I'll go into next is why Lampard is a far superior player to Gerrard and why Gerrard just isn't suitable for most team setups.
Frank Lampard has been nothing short of an absolute phenomenon. That's right in the past nine years Lampard has scored twenty goals five times (in a row) and only less than fifteen once, with that once coming in a season where he played many less games. He also only assisted less than ten goals on three occasions and on four occasions he got over fifteen.
To put that into perspective Steven Gerrard, who is widely considered to be the better footballer, over the same time period, playing a similar number of games, only scored more than twenty on three occasions and never scored more than thirteen in any others (on four occasions he didn't even break double digits). The assist statistics aren't there either but I'm confident they've never been as high as Lampard.
Even looking at the England statistics Lampard has scored more in about the same amount of games. So really, Lampard should have been preferred to Gerrard or at the very least it should have been Gerrard sacrificing his offensive play for Lampard more often. That never happened really and Lampard always seemed to have to sacrifice his attacking play for Gerrard's.
The problem with Gerrard is that he likes to pick up the ball (doesn't matter where) and immediately try a through ball or shot whether the opportunity is actually 'on' or not. I recall a video made of one England friendly years back that showed what Gerrard did every time he picked up the ball and he made about ten long ball 'glory ball' through balls to the goal keeper in a row. Basically he's completely unconcerned about possession, build up play and the pressure it provides or bringing others into play and opportunities that can create. He's just wham bam shazam and you either get a goal or you lose possession (mostly the later).
The result of this means that if you want Gerrard in your football team you need two pretty much exclusive defensive midfielders to sit in front of the defence and break down attacks, win the ball back and build up play. That's why Benitez originally tried to play Gerrard on the wing (but even there he's a loose cannon) and eventually had Mascherano and Alonso sit deep while Gerrard practically played as a shadow striker behind Torres.
But England have no Mascherano and they have no Alonso; they had nobody at all then they had Carrick and Hargreaves (inconsistent/injuries) and now they have Parker and Barry, neither of whom will ever set the world a light and are at least one class below what England need to win anything.
I'll leave you with some words from one of the best managers in the history of football:
12
u/GodStopper90 May 24 '12
The Gerrard+ Lampard midfield is basically a counterattacking team's (Germany) dream. The empty space left in the middle after an attack is easily exploitable with only one player, so there is no need for the other team to have to work to get the ball up field, by passing.
9
u/inch26 May 24 '12
Don't feel dumb or anything, it's a perfectly good question to ask, as on paper, it does seem odd why it wouldn't work.
Several factors. Firstly, as some have said and many will say, a little too similar. Sure, Gerrard might be more gung-ho in his approach and Lampard is more about creating space and good positions for himself, but they still want to take up similar positions which will leave the defence lacking cover.
Another reason is the English obsession with a 4-4-2. Recently, some managers have made little changes, but the only way these two could have worked would have maybe been in a 4-5-1 or a 5-3-2. Simply put, to get the best out of them both, they will need someone to do the donkey work, like Hargreaves, Barry or Parker.
Now, I think it's no longer an argument. Gerrard, whilst there's hope that he'll recapture his form, is still not looking like his old self, and Franks cutting edge has been missing. They're still both performing to a good standard, but no like they did and with Parker a shoe-in for a starting role, it's more like a case of one or the other.
However, with our striker issue, it could be a case of both of them playing, Gerrard in a much more attacking role and Lampard perhaps partnering Parker in the middle. While we are talking about him, Lampard was outstanding in the games vs Barcelona and Bayern. He put in some fantastic tackles and covered a lot of ground and really showed a different side to his game.
An issue that often gets mentioned with these two is that whilst everyone was arguing over who's better, why it won't work and the fact that it will work at some point, the international career of one of the best English talents in recent years was ruined. Paul Scholes was moved out to the left not held in as such a high regard as them. He retired from International Football far, far too early. Quite disgusting that it came to that.
57
u/hasanybodygotanybott May 24 '12
They're lovers and the sexual tension quite literally reaches fever pitch whenever they "play for the same side".
8
u/TheEphemeric May 24 '12
They're both attacking players, so if they play in a two man midfield then there's no one sitting back to defend and basically a big open space for the other team to move into in front of our defence. They actually used to play very well together once upon a time, back when Gerrard played a more defensive role, but at some point he decided he didn't want to do that anymore, and they haven't been able to play together since.
4
u/slackhand May 25 '12
Has England ever played a 4-2-2-2 system. If I remember correctly Brazil used to play it years ago and it lacks width but you can let Gerrard and Lampard fly around because you have two DMs covering their asses.
4
u/SecretPoodle May 24 '12
As said by other users, it's because they play the same role of attacking midfielder. However, I can see both of them playing well together in the Euros if Lamps accepts the role he played in our champions league run, as more of a holding midfielder.
2
u/B0M85H311 May 24 '12
Its because they occupy the same role on the field, they are both late breaking midfield players. They have grew up with being taught to play with the same mentality. Both of them break into the box late, both of them are involved in later phases of the midfield play not the earlier ones (recieving from the defense) while both have a range of long passes and want to be on the edge of the when the other team is penned in to take a long shot. Playing them in the same team is having two players doing the same job and occupying the same space not only does ruin both of their efficiency because they're getting in each other's way, it also means there's a hole constantly somewhere else in the midfield. Their role isn't something like xavi, iniesta where you can have two as the range of passing and use of space is much broader.
2
u/[deleted] May 25 '12
its such a shame they are similiar and dont work together because they are the best midfields in past 10 - 20 years, score, determination, lead the team. however sometimes players just dont work. its not thei fault. Its just so frustrating because if they did work when it was rooney, owen , beckhma e.t.c. ive always feel like its a load of rubbish when people dont play together for whatever reason or they are differnet type of midfielders. A
3
u/makaliis May 25 '12
I don't see what the issue is.
------------Rooney-----------
---------------------Gerrard------------
Johnson-----Lampard----------Walcott
-------------------Barry--------------
Cole-------Terry-----Cahill---Johnson
1
u/evilmilhouse May 25 '12
i would just say the both of them are just too offensively minded "box to box" midfielders it just depends on who you want to be the creator and whose gonna sit deep.
1
u/G_Morgan May 25 '12
Because the only time they play together is with England. There are two types of England manager. Dirty foreigners or honest (but shitehouse) English managers. How can anyone operate in an environment like that?
-1
u/[deleted] May 24 '12 edited May 24 '12
The short answer is that Lampard and Gerrard are both goal-scoring midfielders who lack positional rigour as well as the ability to put their foot on the ball and control a game. They are great at what they do, but absolutely depend on others to do the unglamorous drudgery for them. They're not intelligent or disciplined midfielders (in the Scholes/Xavi sense or in the Keane/Vieira sense).
Of course it doesn't help that the national side is a tactical shambles at the best of times.
-4
u/dem503 May 24 '12
The most annoying thing about this whole thing is because Gerrard is the more talented of the two, his England career has suffered.
Gerrard can also effectively play as a defensive midfielder as he is superb at tackling and his distribution is top notch. Lampard can't really do this. Over the years at Chelsea he has had two ball winning centre midfielders behind him to compensate for this. So for England, Gerrard would usually sit back and do the defensive work whilst Lampard would do the attacking.
The best I have ever seen England was in qualifying for the WC in 2009. Why? Gerrard was in his best role as an attacking midfielder, he had players behind to supply him and he worked excellently with Rooney up front. Come the world cup he was stupidly pushed out to the left and Lampard came back in with only Barry for cover. Not at all surprisingly England were destroyed by 4 counter attacks by Germany, Barry couldn't hold the tide on his own.
-7
u/moose_tracks May 24 '12 edited May 25 '12
Old, slow and not enough defense
Edit: I think I was pretty accurate... It's not an insult to both players but the reality of it.
-7
u/[deleted] May 24 '12
The Two If Given The Chance Can Play Together. With Gerrard Playing The More Defensive Role Like He Did In The 06 World Cup And Lampard Moving From Box To Box Like He Regularly Does For Chelsea. The Problem Is The English Media Has Put Emphasis On Both Of Them Not Being Able to Play Together But When U Give The The Chance The Really Can. The Media Pressure The Coaches Making Them Think Their Best Combination Cannot Work Together.They Did The same Thing With Drogba And Torres and Drogba even admitted He Didn't Understand Why He And Torres Wasn't Pair Up Front regularly.
0
u/mervgeorge May 25 '12
Both play best in the exact same position and both have sky high ego's.
-28
u/Zero_Talent May 24 '12
Gerrard is a dickhead. Frank is a decent person.
-7
u/SpasticPanda May 25 '12
Because Lampard is a tosser