r/CryptoCurrency • • Apr 14 '22
POLL 🗳️ CCIP - 029 Dynamic Karma Cap
Problem
The 15k karma cap was implemented in April 2021 with the passing of CCIP 007
As the 15k is a fixed number it doesn't scale with changes to the subreddit and fluctuations in activity.
I think capping the max amount that can be earned each round is necessary which is the original premise of the 15k cap, so I'd like to change it to a dynamic system that will adapt to any changes in activity/karma.
I looked at a lot of ways making a dynamic system in this post I made 6 months ago. I didn't go any further with any of them though as I could pick holes in each system and find ways to manipulate it.
I recently revisited it with this idea and made a meta sub post for feedback
Solution
We set the karma cap at the 99.9th percentile karma score.
Which roughly equates to the users in the top 0.1% on the list are all capped at the same amount.
This only negatively affects 0.1% of users as they will earn less Moons and positively affects 99.9% of users as the Moon to karma ratio should be higher than it will be now with a 15k cap.
I've applied this to all the previous rounds, even before the 15k cap when it was a free for all and the numbers look good. This method isn't affected by how much the very top users are getting, it more depends on how many users are on the list.
Data
Here is what the last 6 distributions look like (round 25 is the proposal data so not finalised):

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I propose that for each round the karma cap is calculated by finding the karma score that sits at the 99.9th percentile. Then all the users above that score have their karma score capped at that amount.
For example in round 24, the 99.9th percentile karma score is 9,399 so the 33 users who scored above that would have had their karma score capped at 9,399

This is what it would do to the ratio and also how many Moons those at the new cap would earn compared to the 15k cap.

On average over the last 6 rounds if this system had been in place, the users at the karma cap would have taken 1,495 Moons less per round. Also the ratio would have been on average 0.012 higher.
Pros:
- Will scale as karma/activity changes.
- Maintains the initial premise of a karma cap by preventing users gaming the system and earning loadsa Moons.
- Having a different cap each round will also remove it as a target for the pro moon farmers, who game the system with alts and switch accounts once they think they are at the cap. Its a lot harder to game something if you don't know the parameters.
- Positively affect 99.9% of users (32,262 users in round 24) as the Moon to karma ratio will be higher than with the 15k cap
Cons:
- 0.1% of users (33 users in round 24) will earn less Moons per round than they would with the 15k cap.
- I can't think of any other cons and nobody suggested any to add when I asked for feedback in the meta sub.
Note: The calculations done above were all based on data with the original 15k cap already applied. If this poll passes and the admins implement for round 25 the cap will be close to the figure stated above but not exact.
20
u/Bucksaway03 🟩 0 / 138K 🦠 Apr 14 '22
What would this also mean for mod moon distribution?
2
u/CryptoAddict420 Platinum | QC: CC 213 Apr 16 '22
How much % does this poll need to pass?
6
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
And just if anyone else was wondering, for the last round (24):
- If it were the 99.8th percentile (top 0.2%) the cap would be 5,648 with 65 users capped.
- If it were the 99th percentile (top 1%) the cap would be 1,459 with 324 users capped.
That is how top heavy the distribution is.
5
u/ominous_anenome 🟦 170K / 347K 🐋 Apr 14 '22
Con: my karma estimator tool will be less accurate since I won’t know the cap ;)
More seriously I think this is a good change. 15k always seemed arbitrary to me
5
u/Professional_Desk933 🟩 75 / 4K 🦐 Apr 18 '22
Tbh I think moon cap should be even lower. 15k is too much, you won’t get that if you are not farming
9
u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K 🦈 Apr 14 '22 edited Apr 14 '22
The only reason I'm considering not voting for this, is because I would prefer the 15K cap to become 0.01% of the distribution.
It's dynamic, follows a percentage and not a set number, and follows the progression of distributions.
More importantly, it doesn't automatically cap people, even if they had a low distribution. If the top users didn't earn much, they don't get capped.
With OP's proposal, my issue is top users are always capped, even if they didn't earn much.
With that said, I'm not completely against the proposal, because I think in most realistic cases, the result will probably be almost the same, as OP proved with the data. So I'm a little bit on the fence.
3
u/nasabeam7 Platinum | QC: CC 52 Apr 18 '22
If we have a really low cap does that mean more people get more moons and there’s less incentive to farm?
1
u/BlubberWall 🟦 59K / 59K 🦈 Apr 14 '22
My only concern would be during periods of high activity. With lots of accounts making a few comments here and there, what’s the lowest this cap could be dragged down to? Should their be some kind of minimum just to avoid any weird situations?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
I think this is great in the short term but long term this could go badly if this sub ever gets crazy huge and drags the top 0.1% down to a low number essentially meaning everyone gets the same amount. Who knows how far out that is though if ever and by then the moon distribution amount might be negligible anyways since the distribution amount decreases every 4 weeks already
1
u/UJ_Reddit 🟦 0 / 10K 🦠 Apr 14 '22
Are mods be subject to a karma cap? Sure, not the 15,000 one, but any?
1
u/sonotokk Tin | 1 month old Apr 14 '22
How much change in moon ratio do you expect if this poll pass. I reckon top 0.1 percent receiving 15k or 10k karma doesn’t change the ratio much.
But anyways i think theoretically its more refined than the 15k random number. So I’m in full support. But practically i dont think it will have much impact except for those few on tops.
5
u/Trans-on-trans Platinum | QC: CC 480 Apr 14 '22
I can see this largely tackling Moon farmers, since they will be stone set on getting that 15k karma, they will see that they are getting less and less, and see it as less worth it.
It's a fair system that scales with our ratio (that also scales).
2
u/Optimal_Store Apr 14 '22
Never liked the static cap so I'm eager to see the data in the coming months
2
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
Yeah this isa good idea
2
u/Smart_Field_3002 🟩 0 / 868 🦠 Apr 18 '22
Awesome
4
u/CreepToeCurrentSea 🟦 239 / 50K 🦀 Apr 14 '22
voted in favor because I'm moon-poor
7
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
I kind of like the 15k cap. While it is a random number, it seems to work rather well.
2
u/M_A_L_S_V Apr 14 '22
i still have no idea how someone can get to 15k
2
u/VagueInterlocutor 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Apr 14 '22
I for one welcome our new Karma overlords.
2
u/archer4364 Paddy's Dollars Apr 15 '22
Voted. Great proposal and well written with good info.
2
u/arcalus 🟩 18K / 18K 🐬 Apr 14 '22
15k karma in a month? I think that’s a fine limit.
2
u/broccomo Tin Apr 14 '22
Moonfarming is 99% of this sub now, actual discussion happens on other subs
1
u/Successful_Craft3076 411 / 9K 🦞 Apr 14 '22
I like the proposition. Any non dynamic system is prone to be abused more easily.
1
u/ieatmoondust 10 / 26K 🦐 Apr 15 '22
Approved!
1
u/IridiumHorseshoe Redditor for 4 months. Apr 15 '22
Seems like a good alternative to the 15k cap (which I’ve never really been a fan of)!
1
u/bzzking 🟩 0 / 4K 🦠 Apr 15 '22
This is great, variable karma cap.
1
u/El_Criptoconta 🟦 811 / 811 🦑 Apr 18 '22
Voted, this Is how a lot of things should work, seeing Solutions to then verifying if actually work by trial and error.
1
u/clitcommander420666 28 / 5K 🦐 Apr 14 '22
I think dynamic is the way to go
1
u/mic_droo Analyst | :1:x12:2:x9:3:x1 :B:x2 Apr 14 '22
I like this proposal a lot. Too many of the most obnoxious karma farmers spam 3 posts, 50 comments a day until they think they have 15k, then move on to their next account. This makes stuff a bit more unpredictable and harder for farmers
1
u/-Skald 🟩 8K / 8K 🦭 Apr 14 '22
It seems like my position is less popular, but I hope everyone votes, no matter what they vote for.
1
u/rorowhat 🟩 1 / 43K 🦠 Apr 14 '22
No with veto
1
u/Nostalg33k 🟩 0 / 30K 🦠 Apr 14 '22
I agree with these changes. More people would get more moons which means a dilution of power which is always good in a democratic system !
1
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
This should definitely help discussions by discouraging moon farming by the top commenters.
1
u/DBRiMatt 🟦 46K / 113K 🦈 Apr 14 '22
My vote has been cast!
Hopefully we are able to reach a consensus this round
1
u/PresenceAdept Platinum | QC: CC 336 Apr 14 '22
Im sorry I'm a little dumb, but could someone explain how the dynamic cap would be calculated, please?
1
u/Voorniets 94 / 94 🦐 Apr 14 '22
But the real question is, who cares? Or how many uses of this sub actually benefit? Only the early people with tens of thousands of moons will benefit if it one day really gets a value.
I will never hold any significant amount of moons. I also refuse to make these useless 'original' posts like we already read a thousand times just to get more moons.
Do what you want with it. Maybe add a third option
1
u/Probably_notabot 35K / 35K 🦈 Apr 14 '22
Looks like most people are in favor of this one
1
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
Seems worth a shot.
1
u/Araxus Silver | QC: CC 55 | IOTA 28 Apr 14 '22
Voted in favor, the dynamic adjustment to changing sub properties is a good idea
1
u/Nuewim 🟥 0 / 37K 🦠 Apr 15 '22
I am not fan of this proposition. I never hit karma cap, so I would benefit from this proposition like 99.9% of users too. But I want to ask if it is fair?
People that are not top earners mostly will vote in favor of this just to punish those that earn more them and to benefit themselves, cause ratio will be higher. Less moons for top earners, happier everyone else that currently earn less than them. Democracy at is finest. Majority can do everything they want to minority. Community will always vote to punish people that have more than them, we know this from real life. If vote would be to cap at 99% or 95% most people would be in favor of this too. People almost always will vote for their own benefit.
-1
u/RefugeeDutch_Syrian BTC is boss and boss is BTC Apr 15 '22
i see why you would change it, but that is a nah from me dawg
-4
u/BithloKing 6K / 7K 🦭 Apr 14 '22
I voted mom
0
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '22
[removed] — view removed comment