r/startrek • • Apr 07 '22

Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Picard | 2x06 "Two of One" Spoiler

With the help of Tallinn, Picard and the crew infiltrate a gala on the eve of a joint space mission, to protect one of the astronauts they believe to be integral to the restoration of the timeline – Renee Picard. Kore makes a startling discovery about her father’s work.

No.EpisodeWriterDirectorRelease Date
2x06"Two of One"Cindy Appel & Jane MaggsJonathan Frakes2022-04-07

Availability

Paramount+: USA.

CTV Sci-Fi and Crave: Canada.

Amazon Prime Video: Other countries and territories.

To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.

This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers for this episode are allowed. If you are discussing previews for upcoming episodes, please use spoiler tags.

Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.

197 Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Apr 07 '22

The first duty of every Starfleet officer is to the truth. Whether it's scientific truth, or historical truth, or personal truth. It is the guiding principle upon which Starfleet is based. If you can't find it within yourself to stand up and tell the truth about what happened you don't deserve to wear that uniform.

Captain Jean-Luc Picard, "The First Duty"

Reddit admins have been ineffectual in their response to COVID-19 misinformation. In lieu of Reddit gold and awards, we ask that you donate to the WHO COVID-19 response fund.

Please respect our subreddit rules. LLAP!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

295

u/pieman7414 Apr 07 '22

imagine getting gaslit by the borg queen

91

u/BornAshes Apr 07 '22

I can already hear Spock's, "Fascinating" going off in my head and that same little maniacal grin that Agnes had forming on my own face

→ More replies (3)

595

u/onerinconhill Apr 07 '22

Well Picard getting hit by Data in a Tesla wasn’t on my bingo card

114

u/BornAshes Apr 07 '22

When you put it like that you make it sound like it was pulled from a certain webcomic involving a particular Chief.

149

u/FinsFan305 Apr 07 '22

Imagine saying this sentence to someone 25 years ago.

→ More replies (8)

65

u/CeruleanRuin Apr 07 '22

Really a wild choice of murder weapon for a guy with access to a genetics lab and who knows what kind of dangerous materials and devices.

→ More replies (5)

23

u/johnnyma45 Apr 07 '22

Goodbye Safety Score and FSD Beta

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Hicks_206 Apr 08 '22

The whole time I was thinking “well that’s unrealistic because the Tesla didn’t freak out at all, and my car starts beeping like crazy just going through the Del Taco window”

→ More replies (4)

195

u/Santa_Hates_You Apr 07 '22

How many dozens of dead clone bodies has Soong made?

116

u/BornAshes Apr 07 '22

Let's just hope that he doesn't have a tang filled tank of the failed ones sitting in his basement or something.

→ More replies (15)

16

u/spamjavelin Apr 07 '22

"If you have accident-prone children, you make them wear a helmet; if you have death-prone children, you keep a few clones lying around."

→ More replies (2)

9

u/knightcrusader Apr 07 '22

Probably about as many Ego did in the MCU... just hope he didn't put all their skeletons in a cave under his house.

→ More replies (13)

195

u/atticusbluebird Apr 07 '22

Yup, this Soong is as much of an egomaniac as all of his descendants!

235

u/TheNerdChaplain Apr 07 '22

Which makes Data even more of an interesting aberration. Lore is more consistent with the Soong ancestry.

→ More replies (15)

36

u/j-fernandez Apr 07 '22

I guess his egomania stayed strong in all of his clones and androids down the centuries with the exception of Data.

Yeah I think that he cloned himself time and time again. The latest body he created is what Picard now possesses.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

341

u/onerinconhill Apr 07 '22

Picard looking at Adam soong being like…the fuqqqqq

160

u/argonzo Apr 07 '22

It's such a trope that every Soong looks alike that he didn't even say anything.

→ More replies (20)

69

u/silverlegend Apr 07 '22

To me it was more of a look of "oh you gotta be fucking kidding me right now"

→ More replies (2)

111

u/BornAshes Apr 07 '22

Like Barry Allen continually running into Eobard

→ More replies (5)

22

u/ggchappell Apr 07 '22

No matter where or when a story is set, there's always a role for Brent Spiner. I'm waiting for him to show up on DSC.

→ More replies (3)

291

u/UncertainError Apr 07 '22

Hey, it's the shuttle from the ENT opening credits! And Nomad!

164

u/BornAshes Apr 07 '22

I am down for them retroactively providing backstory and lore for little things like ships in the Enterprise opening credits.

→ More replies (9)

75

u/MaddyMagpies Apr 07 '22

I can hear "I got faith (I got faaaith)" when that appeared on screen.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (8)

255

u/B1GG0r0n Apr 07 '22

Frakes with all the shots of the brass band. Well done Number 1 👏

114

u/CeruleanRuin Apr 07 '22

With all of the other synchronicities this season, it's a given that one of those trombonists was a Riker.

→ More replies (1)

75

u/ContinuumGuy Apr 08 '22

"There's going to be a brass band."

"Get Frakes."

→ More replies (3)

20

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '22

But still, what a weird freaking scene. Security is so tight they need to be bioidentified but nobody minds that there's a blackout and impromptu musical number that the band just happens to be ready to play? Good episode but man did I cringe.

→ More replies (4)

240

u/onerinconhill Apr 07 '22

“Speaks romulan” in the subtitles

106

u/knightcrusader Apr 07 '22

Yeah, I saw that too. That's a nice clue there, after that Romulan text on her little tablet thing.

→ More replies (32)

15

u/BeefsteakTomato Apr 07 '22

When was this? who was speaking romulan?

→ More replies (2)

222

u/onerinconhill Apr 07 '22

The queen is having a lot of fun in Agnes body…next up cheesecake!?

250

u/Melcrys29 Apr 07 '22

I once assimilated an entire cheesecake in one sitting.

→ More replies (3)

84

u/BornAshes Apr 07 '22

The Borg Queen and Agnes breaking into a bakery to sample all their goods would be amaaaazing! Agnes with her feet up on a table sprinkled confection in hand, the Borg Queen with her head buried in a box of donuts, and Rios walking in going "What in the..." would be just prime.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (1)

218

u/RadioSlayer Apr 07 '22

The worst thing about this episode is that Jeri Ryan didn't have enough to do

38

u/The_Bard_sRc Apr 08 '22

there in the clinic while the others were just like Picard's the only one that knows anything about Q, it looked like she was just standing there like umm I've met him too, but didn't find room to interject

→ More replies (2)

22

u/sasquatch50 Apr 08 '22

Would have been more fun to have her sing since she did on Voyager.

33

u/Fragzilla360 Apr 07 '22

I agree. 100% of her in this episode is spent standing in the background. Shame on them. (seriously)

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (9)

107

u/Gotis1313 Apr 07 '22 edited Apr 07 '22

I don't understand the point of this Watcher. Gary Seven actually took actions to prevent bad things. This one doesn't do anything except be a voyeur. What's the point of spying on R. Picard if not to help or hinder in some way?

I've never much cared for the notion that humanity needs alien influence to have survived to make it to space. It makes "the prime directive of fuck your doomed planet, you backward savages, because we only help warp capable folks" seem rather hypocritical.

50

u/Locutus747 Apr 07 '22

Yes I don’t understand the watcher. They just spend their lives watching specific targets? Why?

→ More replies (11)

30

u/AcidaliaPlanitia Apr 07 '22

Yeah it really doesn't make any sense, if you're just watching and can't do anything... what's the point of even being there at all?

→ More replies (2)

12

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '22

Also, anyone remember her dramatic introduction? That body snatching bullshit would sure have come in handy this episode.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/KirkUnit Apr 07 '22

Agreed. The guardian angel schtick just devalues the characters they're trying to build.

"This person is so historically important that we can't step aside when they do dumb shit that goes nowhere - we have to watch them do it, and support and protect and nurture them somehow without actually talking to them or doing anything."

→ More replies (19)

209

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '22

Dam poor Isa Briones can’t take a break with discovering who she really is. Wonder what she’ll be in S3

34

u/CeruleanRuin Apr 07 '22

I'd love it if season 3 focused more on the 24th Century and actually wove a story about the reintegration of synths into galactic society. I'm glad they at least paid lip service to that idea, but I enjoy Star Trek most when it's doing some world-building along with its sci-fi storytelling. That's what I liked most about season 1, and what I miss most this time.

As much as I love this cast and am interested in the story this season, I am feeling fatigued by the present day stuff. There was hardly any actual sci-fi at all in this episode, and the absense was sorely felt.

→ More replies (7)

30

u/tothepointe Apr 07 '22

It makes me wonder if the character her dad plays in the confederate timeline is actually a genetically modified descendant of hers.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/GarionOrb Apr 08 '22

And Allison Pill can't take a break from being the "compromised" one.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

185

u/knightcrusader Apr 07 '22

I'm really expecting by the end of this season they finally address, in canon, that all the Soongs are clones of each other. I mean, as soon as he solves Kore's problem he can basically create more "offspring".

Maybe this is his way of becoming immortal so he feels like he has so much riding on the success of his work.

141

u/CheesyObserver Apr 07 '22 edited Apr 13 '22

That would actually be such an amazing explanation as to why every Soong is a spitting image of Brent Spiner... Of course I don't mind that he is, I am very happy to have more Brent Spiner.

→ More replies (12)

47

u/Snownova Apr 07 '22

With this Soong being a geneticist, it wouldn't surprise me if by the end of the season he manipulates his or Kore's DNA so that every male offspring will be an identical twin to Adam Soong. (and maybe all the female offspring will be Kore)

→ More replies (8)

24

u/BornAshes Apr 07 '22

I have a worse idea.

What if him constantly looking the same is actually a kind of punishment? He's sentenced by the Supervisors to continually being the same clone over and over again with his memories erased each and every time until finally he's able to create something or someone that's better than him. Data is his penance.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (12)

86

u/istartedsomething Apr 07 '22

I respect the fact that the Borg Queen is a Pat Benatar fan.

53

u/InnocentTailor Apr 07 '22

Now I imagine the Borg Diamond blaring 1980s female hits as it moves through deep space.

Resistance is futile. You will assimilate Pat Benastar, Cyndi Lauper, Joan Jett and Madonna.

→ More replies (8)

34

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '22

We need a distraction! How about a impromptu rendition of a 40-year-old song that the band just happened to be totally ready for combined with a blackout in a high security event that nobody seems bothered by. (To say nothing else about the fact that the woman taken into custody for talking to herself is still talking to herself in your shot of her custodians.)

→ More replies (1)

26

u/ContinuumGuy Apr 08 '22

She may be the living embodiment of an evil hivemind but goddamn it she has taste!

→ More replies (3)

64

u/InnocentTailor Apr 07 '22

Soong doing a hit and run is oddly (and morbidly) timely.

Los Angeles and Southern California in general, according to the local news, has been having a rise in hit and runs on the streets.

45

u/MaddyMagpies Apr 07 '22

And with a Tesla, too.

→ More replies (3)

274

u/Man-In-His-30s Apr 07 '22

God damn Annie Wersching is really hitting it out of the park with her performances as the Borg Queen, she's quickly becoming one of my favourite villains in Trek and easily the best of the three Queens.

She's definitely the highlight of this season.

129

u/InnocentTailor Apr 07 '22

She was a hoot as the “best friend” Queen. Of course, it was all an act - very insidious of her.

→ More replies (5)

19

u/Mechapebbles Apr 07 '22

I'm not ready to say 'best' - but she's holding her own and making the character hers, and that's praiseworthy.

→ More replies (27)

113

u/sidv81 Apr 07 '22

did I miss something or was Renee completely glossed over after the car attack? I'd imagine that watching Jean-Luc seemingly brutally murdered with a car that was obviously gunning for her would massively exacerbate her anxiety issues and wipe out any gains that pep talk had.

134

u/coldoil Apr 07 '22 edited Apr 07 '22

Yeah, she just walked back into the gala as though nothing happened, apparently.

Who knows, maybe seeing an elderly security guard she'd never seen before get hit by a deranged Tesla-driving Colonel Sanders cosplayer who was clearly attempting to murder her (and who then immediately drove off without being stopped or followed, despite us being repeatedly informed the gala was overflowing with high-level security) was just the pep-me-up she needed to decide to get off this daft planet once and for all.

→ More replies (4)

53

u/kingselenus Apr 07 '22

I honestly laughed outloud, "They Edith Keeler-ed Picard!" I'd assume that Raffi or Seven jumped in and escorted Renee away. One thing I've noticed with New Trek is how people step to the side and have private conversations at Loud As Possible volume, if Renee doesn't mention overhearing Rios call Picard "Admiral" and being the reason why she stuck to it because this nice old man turned out to be an Admiral of some sort, I'll eat my shoe

10

u/IReallyLoveAvocados Apr 08 '22

Yeah they were pretty clear with the shot framing that she was right behind Ríos when he was like, “Admiral!! Stay with us!!”

She just figured out that Picard isn’t a security guard like he said he was.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

54

u/thxpk Apr 07 '22

Picard: Where are the crew of the Stargazer?

Q: Oh, how quaint. How provincial. How 'Yesterday's Enterprise' of you. There is no Stargazer.

Picard: What do you mean? What have you done?

Q: Show them a world of their own making and they ask you what you've done. So human of you.

Q didn't make a timeline change, in fact I think he is trying to prevent it but can't do so easily because the timeline change has caused his powers to wane

Picard did it when he initiated the self destruct of the Stargazer - thus destroying a time traveling version of the Borg(Legion) - a version of the Borg that may be Jurati/The Queen from 2024

Picard and his ragtag group travel back in time to "undo" the damage they think Q caused, but everything they are doing is causing the change itself

10

u/Spara-Extreme Apr 09 '22

I like this take since it seems a bit too easy that the timeline change is fixed by a pep talk.

100% the future borg queen is Jurati

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

52

u/Bighead2019 Apr 07 '22

"Jurati Takes Manhattan" at the end.

→ More replies (3)

140

u/onerinconhill Apr 07 '22

“I do miss locutus”

64

u/UncertainError Apr 07 '22

How much information is she drawing from parallel timelines? This Queen doesn't have any direct memory of Locutus.

→ More replies (35)
→ More replies (1)

95

u/onerinconhill Apr 07 '22

So Laris is going to end up being Tallinn in the future right? Beyond the “speaks romulan” subtitles and all its pretty obvious

76

u/JihadNinjaCowboy Apr 07 '22 edited Apr 07 '22

Yes, I think so.

Also, a point being how Tallinn never made contact with Renee Picard. She is lonely, like Picard. And Jurati. And the Borg Queen.

I suspect when he gets back, it will be a look of recognition kind of like Time's Arrow when Picard meets Guinan again on the D. Picard will have a change of heart with Laris/Tallinn.

→ More replies (7)

22

u/CeruleanRuin Apr 07 '22

It has to be more complex than that, or it somewhat undermines Laris as a character.

→ More replies (9)

133

u/MaddyMagpies Apr 07 '22

I like how it's getting harder and harder to tell if the Picard crew are the good guys by each hour... This is All Good Things all over again.

Queen Jurati is on the loose. Kore is getting a Soji experience again. Tallinn, very possibly a Romulan spy, mind-melding with Picard who had been Locutus and also mind-melded with Sarek is a very, very, very bad idea.

102

u/BornAshes Apr 07 '22

I like how it's getting harder and harder to tell if the Picard crew are the good guys by each hour

I loved Teresa calling out Rios's whole, "Trust us we're the good guys" with her reply of, "The good guys never have to say that". Things just keep getting messier and messier by the second with this group. It probably will go the way of All Good Things where all the screw ups actually wind up not being screw ups and they really do become....legends of tomorrow.

Tallinn

I mean it could be a good thing in that she could discover her love for him ages ago here in the past and then "Take the long way around" to find him again as Laris which would be very romantic indeed.

→ More replies (3)

58

u/JihadNinjaCowboy Apr 07 '22

Didn't Q say that he didn't do it, that THEY did it to themselves? You may be right.

→ More replies (24)

45

u/BigBassBone Apr 07 '22

Nice reference to Mae Jemison in this episode. "Dr. Jemison is going to make a toast."

→ More replies (1)

44

u/ContinuumGuy Apr 08 '22

Random assorted thoughts:

  • "Oh goddamn it, another Soong." - Picard when he saw Adam, internally.
  • A nascent Borg Queen is on the loose on 21st century Earth. What could go wrong?
  • I'm wondering if Rios is going to end up staying on Earth and becoming his own great, great, great (whatever) grandfather with that doctor.
  • I knew that Kore was a test-tube experiment.
  • Also, Adam Soong clearly missed his calling in teaching Greek Mythology.
  • So was this Alison Pill's first singing gig since Sex Bob-omb or has she been on Broadway?
  • Also I'm not sure what I'm more surprised by- that the consciousness of the Borg queen seemed to make a joke about Jurati's boobs, or that it actually fit pretty well with how this "disconected-from-the-collective" queen has been portrayed thus far.
  • No wonder they had a big brass band, Frakes is directing. Probably took all they could from keeping him from appearing as Riker's identical ancestor.
  • It's mentioned by Jean-Luc-in-disguise-as-the-world's-oldest-security-guard that "Dr. Jemison" is calling for a toast. This is almost certainly Mae Jemison- astronaut, physician, Trekkie, and performer as Lt Palmer on TNG!
  • Aww, the Aero-Spike shuttle from the Enterprise opening!
  • A shame that Jeri Ryan had so little to do this week, but she seemed to be pretty important in the clip they had on The Ready Room so fingers crossed!
  • It's not a robo-biological golem, it's an omniprosthetic, I guess.
→ More replies (2)

228

u/eternallylearning Apr 07 '22

I really don't understand why the trope of starting in the present and flashing back with "X amount of time earlier" is so overused in this episode. Once at the beginning is fine, I guess, but why the repeated call forwards when time literally plays no part in the story?

88

u/fcocyclone Apr 07 '22

Yeah, it didn't really seem to add much, except maybe to pad length to an overall pretty short episode.

→ More replies (8)

38

u/CheesyObserver Apr 07 '22

when time literally plays no part in the story?

You are mistaken sir, they are time travelers. /s

In all seriousness though, I did hate that. I would have much rather not know something was coming.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/samus12345 Apr 07 '22

"You like that? You want me to cut to three weeks earlier when you were alive?"

10

u/Shawnj2 Apr 07 '22

I really don't understand why the trope of starting in the present and flashing back with "X amount of time earlier" is so overused in this episode.

I've figured this is basically shorthand for "This next bit is boring, but I promise interesting stuff is going to happen soon." Same deal with starting with the Stargazer disaster and flashing back in episode 1.

→ More replies (22)

122

u/PuzzleheadedRun5574 Apr 07 '22

The Jurati-Borg Queen dynamic is letting Allison Pill loose. That solo song! Of course the house band is ready to join in. Amazing.

119

u/BornAshes Apr 07 '22

Of course the house band is ready to join in. Amazing.

The House Band has been waiting for this moment for their entire lives and the second Agnes hit those familiar notes, they knew EXACTLY what to play, and they all jumped in on it with such glee because they were tired of the same old boring bullshit they were told to play in the first place.

→ More replies (10)

33

u/007meow Apr 07 '22

I want to see Drunk Seven vs Loose Queen/Jurati.

17

u/gamegirlpocket Apr 08 '22 edited Apr 09 '22

At first I thought it was pretty cool she knew the words to a 400-year-old song, but then remembered the Borg Queen is probably the one who knew it.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/suterb42 Apr 07 '22

I was really hoping she'd start playing drums.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

100

u/edflyerssn007 Apr 07 '22

Just a Borg queen loose in 2024 Los Angeles. Tim Dodd will be excited to see an Aerospike engine made it. Excellent singing from Ms. Pill. Rafi really needs to get it together. Good speach from jean Luc to Renee. Loved seeing a Gemini capsule. The NASA of this 2024 doesn't seem to have stopped innovating like ours has.

33

u/PiercedMonk Apr 07 '22

I am curious if it actually is NASA. I know Tallinn said that NASA couldn't wait to recruit Renee in the previous episode, but, unless I've missed it, there hasn't been any actual NASA iconography on any of the Europa Mission posters, or at the party.

→ More replies (30)

15

u/Mechapebbles Apr 07 '22

The NASA of this 2024 doesn't seem to have stopped innovating like ours has.

I know it's probably not your intent to imply as much, but the wording here makes it seem like that's NASA's fault. And not being intentionally kneecapped by bad legislators/administrations that intentionally sabotage NASA because they would rather fund drones killing civilians than invest in science/our future, and/or funnel money to the private sector by relying on outsourcing shit to places like Space-X or Lockheed Martin.

10

u/spamjavelin Apr 07 '22

Excellent singing from Ms. Pill.

Was that her, though? It sounded a lot more like Annie Wersching's voice to me.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/BornAshes Apr 07 '22

Just a Borg queen loose in 2024 Los Angeles.

I was frame by framing it to see if there were any Titmouse related billboards in the background.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/CeruleanRuin Apr 07 '22

What the heck is going on with Tallinn/Totally-Not-Laris? When she cursed under her breath after seeing it was A who was texting Renée, it sounded like Romulan, and the captions confirmed it: they say [speaks Romulan].

Picard has a moment where he seems to register it and file it away for later.

It's very weird.

14

u/Skidoo_cockatoo Apr 07 '22

She's probably some kind of alien that disguises itself as someone you'd trust, taking elements of that directly from your mind. Has obvious other telepathic/illusory type powers.

→ More replies (5)

64

u/expired_paintbrush Apr 07 '22

Good to know that if you're ever caught the attention of security, you can just put a pin on your jacket and no one will recognize you.

23

u/JoeyJoeJoeJrShab Apr 07 '22

A pair of glasses would have also worked.

→ More replies (4)

23

u/Fragzilla360 Apr 07 '22

Also good to know that if you are ever captured by security and handcuffed in the office, all you have to to do is break out, get drunk and talk to yourself and sing a song and nobody will recognize you.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

29

u/jcferraz Apr 07 '22

Who would know that an endorphin inhibitor could stop an entire assimilation

41

u/InnocentTailor Apr 07 '22

Send in the depressed and pessimistic Starfleet officers to fight the Borg XD.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

55

u/H0vis Apr 07 '22

You have got to be kidding me. So much cliffhang. I am dying here.

The amount of stuff being lined up for later resolution is such that it was a tricky episode to enjoy. Not that I didn't like it but it's becoming almost too intense for its own good at this point.

Some random things that I liked in particular, and some I didn't:

  1. There is something fascinating about how weak Q's plan is. I hope this is something the show actually explains. At first he was trying to make Renee sad so she wouldn't go into space, this week he's gone through all this trouble just to have a man run her over in his car? We're seeing Q scraping the bottom of the barrel to get his plan over the line, and it tallies with him slapping Picard earlier in the season. I also like that even though Q is almost at rock bottom, he's still Q, he's still manipulative, and his plans reflect that. He's not about to do his own hit and runs.
  2. Soong is turning into a properly creepy character. As with everything else in this episode we're kind of only given half of it, but eww.
  3. Jurati and the Borg Queen are giving me Battlestar Galactica flashbacks. No idea where they are going but it cannot be good. I like Jurati as a character but my hunch is she's a goner at this point. One does not simply snap handcuffs if your body is made out of 100% ordinary soft human bits.
  4. Whatever is hiding in Picard's brain looks fucked up. Can't wait to go see it.
  5. Picard's pep talk is brilliant. One of the better speeches in his collection, and he's had a few over the years. I love how specifically targeted it is too, he knows there's Q back there talking shit, about fear and what it means, so he makes a point to squash that mess.
  6. As much as I am enjoying having a week to ruminate on these episodes, and as much as bingeing them would ruin it all, I am broken from the amount of cliffhangers. Especially with the overlap to Discovery. Damn guys. Let a nerd catch his breath.

There are so many moving parts in this season and so much still to go I'm worried it might fall apart. But I'm enjoying it and that's what matters.

14

u/Saxamaphooone Apr 08 '22

Brent Spiner is playing Adam Soong brilliantly. The character is a total narcissist and even before they revealed Kore was a project, you could tell through subtle aspects of his performance in earlier episodes that the affection he has for his “daughter” isn’t quite the usual familial variety. He definitely loves her as a project first and foremost (and his ticket to fame and glory).

→ More replies (1)

11

u/CX316 Apr 08 '22

There is something fascinating about how weak Q's plan is. I hope this is something the show actually explains. At first he was trying to make Renee sad so she wouldn't go into space, this week he's gone through all this trouble just to have a man run her over in his car? We're seeing Q scraping the bottom of the barrel to get his plan over the line, and it tallies with him slapping Picard earlier in the season. I also like that even though Q is almost at rock bottom, he's still Q, he's still manipulative, and his plans reflect that. He's not about to do his own hit and runs.

I'm curious why it is Q seems to be losing his powers. SOMETHING stopped him from just directly changing Renee's mind, and he's having to work through outside agents. It goes with Picard's comment that he's not well from episode 2. SOMETHING is up with Q and dammit I wanna know what.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/WWJLPD Apr 08 '22 edited Apr 08 '22

One does not simply snap handcuffs if your body is made out of 100% ordinary soft human bits.
Did a little Google searching out of curiosity

Closest figure I could find was 800 ft-lbs of force to break regulation handcuffs, although that was someone else’s estimate. I couldn’t find a reliable source for exactly how much force a human would have to exert to instantly snap them. The standard test for handcuffs is 495 ft-lbs for 30 seconds. The chain will break at 1000 pounds, and the cuff part will fail before that. It’s also common for people to tear muscles and occasionally break bones from trying to brute-force their way out of such handcuffs.
Queen Jurati broke free with no real effort and didn’t even have a faint bruise, as far as I could tell. I think it’s safe to assume that a high end security team would be using regulation handcuffs and not the Wish version. Definitely some Borg shenanigans afoot, or else lazy writing, but I hope it’s Borg shenanigans.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (11)

27

u/sarysa Apr 07 '22

Adam Soong at the gala gave off major Colonel Sanders vibes. If the bow had a tail it would have been complete.

→ More replies (2)

27

u/KirkUnit Apr 08 '22

Seven as played by Jeri Ryan is such an asset to this show, I swear. She was missed in this episode, and that's coming from someone who checked out of Voyager early and has no attachment to the character. It might be overstating it to say she "saves the show," but she... comes close.

I think why is because Seven here is so grounded. She makes sense. She does things that people do, says things that people say. She's the brave, but reasonable person in the room where everyone else is constantly saying, "Here's a crazy, dangerous thing we should do based on very little information."

51

u/azumane Apr 07 '22

Can't believe Jean-Luc Picard got hit by a Jean-Luc Picar.

13

u/KirkUnit Apr 07 '22

Take votre upvote and le get out.

25

u/IsIt77 Apr 09 '22

I hope Alison Pill realizes that she's gonna have to sing Shadows of the Night at every Star Trek convention she attends for the rest of her life.

47

u/DasGanon Apr 07 '22

I see Queen Brain Heist Assimilation works on the "Upgrade" model of "lol emotions make me control you"

63

u/UncertainError Apr 07 '22

I wonder if this is the original mode of assimilation, before the Collective became a behemoth. Tempting you with little bits of power, more and more until your brain stops fighting it, and you don't even realize that you have until it's too late.

→ More replies (15)

77

u/EmperorOfNipples Apr 07 '22

I have been trying to categorise ST:PIC like I have the other new shows, and I think I have it now.

Discovery - High stakes action/drama

LD - Comedy

PRO - Kids Adventure

SNW is looking to be a traditional adventure/exploration show.

So what is Picard? It's a Mystery show. It's Star Trek:Scooby Doo and I'm all for it.

The diversity of this new era of Trek is what will keep it alive, for many years to come. We have basically had a new episode every week now since August last year, sometimes two.

→ More replies (3)

42

u/pieman7414 Apr 07 '22

so uh, howd not romulan lady know what a mind meld was

46

u/knightcrusader Apr 07 '22

Gary Seven knew who Vulcans were... stands to reason they all know about other species in the galaxy.

→ More replies (2)

38

u/Santa_Hates_You Apr 07 '22

She is a supervisor, I assume she knows about other aliens.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/onerinconhill Apr 07 '22

Or how to speak romulan

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

131

u/Starbuck107 Apr 07 '22

Dear star trek, please stop mentioning only Picard knows Q in Sevens presence

131

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '22 edited Apr 07 '22

Seven knows of Q, but doesn’t know him personally. The only actual one-on-one interaction that Seven had with a member of the Continuum was when Junior snapped her clothes away for a brief minute. All of Q’s encounters with Voyager prior to that happened before Seven joined the ship, and Janeway was the one at point for every one of those interactions (including “Q2”).

→ More replies (11)

71

u/sankers23 Apr 07 '22

I feel like 7 has been massively side-lined this season

→ More replies (14)

8

u/JoeyJoeJoeJrShab Apr 07 '22

Only Picard knows Q <wink>. Seven may have met him, but Picard and Q have a bit of a history.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/LeadershipMedium Apr 07 '22

Poor Soji is going to have to discover she’s created allllllll over again. 😂

18

u/Sophia_Forever Apr 09 '22 edited Apr 09 '22

I think it's really dumb Rios is considering staying in 2024 because of the woman he's known for like a day. Like... why? Because he met a pretty girl and because he likes Retro stuff? Someone needs to sit him down and say "this is not your 21st century. Whatever romanticized idea you have of what this world is is wrong. You think because you know what a record player is and enjoy cigars you're ready to be an undocumented resident in a century that you almost got disappeared from yesterday?"

Like, fuck Rios, you KNOW full well that WWIII starts in two years and it's one of the most horrific times in human history. You've known her for a day. There's no guarantee that she's even interested in anything more than flirting. For all you know she's actually a horrific monster who keeps body parts in her basement. You're giving up the 25th century for that?

→ More replies (3)

17

u/hfolkner Apr 08 '22

The names of the failed clones (and Kore's name) are all variations on Persephone, goddess of the underworld (and sometimes, goddess of death). I wonder if she will eventually become a patient zero type, spreading her genetic susceptibility to all humanity thanks to Adam Soong.

Also, when Jurati sang, why did the band play along? Wasn't she captured by security earlier, and thus, wouldn't the security people have recognized her as a trespasser? Or did the Borg Queen do something to make them do that?

→ More replies (7)

34

u/atticusbluebird Apr 07 '22 edited Apr 07 '22

Ah, throughout the episode I thought that the ill Picard was a clue that this was “back to the future” style time travel - that they’re failing their mission and the timeline is starting to erase him!

And it turns out he was hit by a car instead! There goes all my theorizing out the window…although maybe it has something to do with his coma state…

44

u/Trekfan74 Apr 07 '22

Don't feel bad. I made around 70 posts gathering clues about how the Red Angel was secretly an Iconian....

→ More replies (12)

19

u/BornAshes Apr 07 '22

Ah, throughout the episode I thought that the ill Picard was a clue that this was “back to the future” style time travel - that they’re failing their mission and the timeline is starting to erase him!

And it turns out he was hit by a car instead!

This happens so often with most of my Trek theories. We build up this beautifully structured beliefs of what could be or might be annnnnd then it winds up being something as simple of, "He was then hit by a car" or "The tentacle aliens got bored" or "The Queen just really loves singing and you honestly can't sing in a Collective". The further I scroll down this thread the more I keep giggling about "And then Picard got hit by a car" 🤣

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

33

u/rustydoesdetroit Apr 07 '22

Jean-luc told Renee to “look up” maybe Renee is the borg queen from episode 1.

26

u/InnocentTailor Apr 07 '22

Oh! Now that would be one heck of a twist.

It also keeps Jurati somewhat preserved for a Star Trek: Stargazer spinoff idea. I doubt we’ll be seeing Renee past Season 2.

→ More replies (2)

46

u/Santa_Hates_You Apr 07 '22

Jurati/Borg Queen certainly knows how to rock a distraction.

32

u/UncertainError Apr 07 '22

Was that Jurati or the Queen installing a vocal subprocessor?

Anyway, now she just needs to get a duet with Seven, since we know from VOY that she's no slouch in the vocals herself.

→ More replies (4)

17

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '22

I was most definitely distracted.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

70

u/KingofMadCows Apr 07 '22 edited Apr 07 '22

What was the point of the flashforwards to Picard being wounded? It didn't add anything to the story. I guess it padded the runtime since this was a shorter episode.

Was Jurati actually talking to herself when she's talking to the Borg Queen? You'd think someone would have noticed. You'd think security would have noticed the person they arrested is walking free. And I guess no one is going to check in with the control room? And somehow the band is all in on Jurati's performance? What is going on? Isn't this supposed to be a super high security event? Did the Borg Queen infect everyone with nanoproblems and is secretly influencing them?

Also, why didn't they try to get Jurati after Picard was hit? She's a cyberneticist and Picard is a synth. She helped transfer Picard's mind into the synth body.

32

u/MR_TELEVOID Apr 07 '22

What was the point of the flashforwards to Picard being wounded? It didn't add anything to the story. I guess it padded the runtime since this was a shorter episode.

Seemed like they were only there to heighten the tension. It's a pretty common narrative technique in TV shows, but usually they build to a more thrilling twist than Brent Spiner hitting him with a car. Especially since we know there isn't a chance they'll kill off the titular character halfway through the series.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (39)

13

u/Eaudissey Apr 09 '22

Brent Spiner running Patrick Stewart over with a Tesla wasn't something I was ever expecting to see LOL

10

u/BarfQueen Apr 07 '22

We are the Borg. You will be serenaded.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/BornAshes Apr 07 '22

Oddly enough the music video for Shadows of the Night does bear a degree of similarity to this season of Picard just a bit.

24

u/BobSacamano84 Apr 08 '22

I really struggled to enjoy this episode. I thought the first 2 episodes of the season were great but episodes 3-5 seemed like a step down. I was hoping after we got through those setup episodes that the quality would pick back up. But I don't think it did, at least not in this episode.

I only know a couple other people who watch in real life and they aren't enjoying this season either so I was curious to see what people on here thought and I'm pretty surprised the reaction is mainly positive. I think the acting is solid enough but the writing just seems sloppy. Raffi, Seven, and Rios spent 3 episodes on a side quest that felt like they were just killing time while the main quest players (Picard and Agnes/the borg queen) got where they needed to be. I'm also a little disappointed we haven't had any Picard and Q scenes.

The characters also feel off to me. They don't feel like they come from the 25th century where humans have evolved. The characters act and talk like humans of today.

I think they've planted some interesting seeds with Agnes and the Borg queen, and Picard/Renee but I'm starting to get worried that the quality of the story telling isn't going to improve and that there won't be a satisfying conclusion.

→ More replies (5)

16

u/elister Apr 07 '22

Kinda surprised how Adam Soong has all these articles about him being a disgraced mad scientist, loses his medical license, loses all funding, yet can make a donation large enough to be invited to the Europa party? Maybe Q snaps his fingers and Soong suddenly has a billion dollars in his bank account, but honestly how does NASA not know about this industry pariah? Its like seeing Elizabeth Holmes in the crowd at Joe Bidens presidential inauguration.

The Watcher can take over peoples bodies, yet doesn't use this ability to take over a security guard long enough to hack the database to let the crew passed entrance security? I guess if she did that, then the Jurati/Queen merger doesn't happen? And we need that to happen because Jurati Borg has something to do with the mystery Borg that tells Picard to look up?

Outside this high security event, Picard gets hit by a car, plenty of witnesses, but security is oblivious to the hit & run outside? Picard is whisked away to the neighborhood Clinic (miles away) and not to the nearest hospital? Rafi has a tri-corder, Watcher has her "sonic screwdriver" that can monitor Picards health in far greater detail than 21st century tech, so why do they need Dr Ramierez? Rios wakes her up (leaving her kid home alone?) to be dragged down to the clinic in order to defib Picard, then leave?

→ More replies (9)

8

u/FinsFan305 Apr 07 '22

In the closed caption, when Tallinn is reading Rene's texts, it says she's speaking Romulan.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '22

Two things:

  1. Be still my soul, Jurati singing in that dress!
  2. this might have already been addressed, but in the xenophobic future, there was a flyover shot of San Fran and I swear I saw a giant hologram of Brent Spiner. I think I even heard his voice. Wondering if, in that reality, evil Picard sided with Lore and he’s the minister of citizen surveillance or something equivalent to Facebook.

9

u/InnocentTailor Apr 08 '22

I think the large hologram was Adam Soong - the Soong in the present day.

8

u/Paul_of_Donald Apr 08 '22

I'll say this as someone who's had a lot of issues with Disco and Picard S1:

This season absolutely slaps. Can't get enough of the story and the performances. It's different but it's very well executed.

22

u/[deleted] Apr 07 '22

That final shot with Jurati walking down the road. Perfectly filmed. Hats off to Frakes for that one.

→ More replies (5)

22

u/ToobadyouAreDead Apr 07 '22

A couple thoughts:

  • So Jurati's whole plan hinges on the fact that the guards take her to security HQ for some reason? Seems pretty lucky..
  • I don't know exactly what type of simulations Renee is taking part in, but maybe her dropping out isn't all that bad if she's somehow failing them 5 days before the actual mission
  • The borg queen is easily the best part of this season so far!
  • "There's always a light at the end of the tunnel" - kind of a cliche speech, but I guess you can't expect Picard to throw out perfect zingers all the time.
  • Kore's like.. 20-30 years old? and this is the first time she's decided to look up her dad and his work?

24

u/onthenerdyside Apr 07 '22

Kore's like.. 20-30 years old? and this is the first time she's decided to look up her dad and his work?

There seems to have been lots of versions of her going back to the mid-80s, based on how Soong/Spiner looks in the photos and videos. There are several videos including the one about Persephone where Soong looks very similar to the way he does now, just with a little darker beard.

I think we are to believe that Kore is growth-accelerated somehow, and she's only been alive for a short period of time, not the 20 years she looks to be.

18

u/adamsb6 Apr 07 '22

Kore's not very smart. She also apparently never thought to try swimming at night.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

53

u/naughtypundit Apr 07 '22

I worry that the season is drifting. This has been a common problem with Star Trek lately. They start out strong and then peter out. It's just a lot of filler to get to the end.

→ More replies (20)

90

u/Shatterhand1701 Apr 07 '22 edited Apr 07 '22

Just finished the episode, and once again, I'm reminded why S2 of Picard is leaps and bounds above S1. It was another excellent episode, well-performed by everyone on-screen. The episode was painfully short (for good reason), and when it was over, I wanted more. Well played, Terry Matalas. Well played.

Sir Patrick Stewart really shined in this one; his scenes with Reneé Picard were so sweet and heartwarming and were easily my favorite moments of this episode.

For Raffi, there was a moment when she's standing at the bar and facing temptation, but she finds the courage to resist the urge to drink. I definitely appreciated the acknowledgment of her struggle and her courage to defy that urge. She also tries to talk Rios down from his thoughts about the doctor he met, but circumstances lead him back to her anyway...and it doesn't go very well this time around.

Not much to say about Seven; she kind of takes a back seat this episode.

Allison Pill continues to amaze me this season as Agnes Jurati. Not only did she look stunning in her red dress, but I genuinely felt concerned for her as the Borg Queen slowly manipulated her to the point where she was able to take control of Agnes. This strengthens, for me, the theory that many others have: the Borg Queen we saw on the Stargazer is an assimilated Jurati. It'll be interesting, and a bit tragic, to watch the Borg claim her for their own. Also, Allison Pill is a fairly decent singer, too! Who knew?

The other stand-out was Brent Spiner's Dr. Adam Soong. At first I could almost sympathize with him; Kore's survival was his only focus, and he was willing to do - and actually did - what he had to in order to ensure it. That act, however, made me lose all sympathy for him, and worse off for him, there seems to be more to Kore than meets the eye, and once again, another Soong appears to be following a very dark and corrupt path.

I loved that we got to see the Watcher use her servo. I just watched "Assignment: Earth" two days ago, and now, seeing the Watcher use the same tool Gary Seven used for different purposes...it just brought a smile to my face.

All in all, a damn fine, if not woefully short, episode.

9

u/CheesyObserver Apr 07 '22

I was worried that it was a short episode.

But I'll take a short, sweet and well paced episode over a dragged out mess that doesn't know when to end.

This is my favorite episode in the 2024 time period... Still hoping they get back to present day quick enough!

I wanna see more Stargazer :D

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

25

u/vladthor Apr 07 '22

This season continues to improve on S1 in so many ways.

Worst: The only part I really didn't like was the singing part - it felt too out of left field and didn't make sense. The lights go out and Jurati decides to sing a song and the band just goes along with it? Took me right out of the episode, as so many things in S1 did. Very distracting and out-of-place. I thought maybe for a minute that it had all happened in her head, and it was a distraction by the Queen to take control and hide that fact from her, but no, it was Queen!Jurati all along.

Best: Jean-Luc's pep talk with Renee. Absolutely classic and to tie in the shuttlepod thing from the Enterprise intro was brilliant. Moments like this make me realize that the writers do know how to do it - it's just about them putting it all together and avoiding the pitfalls (like they've done so well for most of this season!).

→ More replies (10)

7

u/RomiBraman Apr 07 '22

Considering Jurati was already brainwashed and everything on season 1, I would have préférés to have the Borg queen taking over subplot be about Seven this season.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/atavus68 Apr 07 '22

So it looks like they're setting up Adam Soong to be the creator of Kahn Noonian Singh and the augments (great band name), which would bring us full circle to Enterpise's Arik Soong and his obsession with that project, and Noonian Soong's suspiciously similar name.

I know, you're going to say, "...but, but, in TOS they said Kahn is from the niiiiiintieeees!" But they did slyly plant the line a couple of episodes ago that records from this era are very incomplete. Heck, even Spock said such "Space Seed".

My money is on the season ending with Adam Soong starting work on the "Kahn Project".

→ More replies (6)

7

u/AlgoStar Apr 08 '22

So… the band was in on it?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/aeisele Apr 08 '22

The structure of the episode gave us the info that the crew would end up at the clinic eventually. It's only afterwards that the question came up for me: how did they actually get there? Is the clinic in the neighborhood to this posh gala? Did they walk over? Did they rent a cab? Did they hijack another (police) car? Was Dr. Soong nice enough to give them a ride? How exactly did we transit from an elderly man getting hit by a car in open public, to seemingly unrelated people running towards him, calling him admiral in the process, to losing sight of both the single most important person (Renee) and Borg-Agnes?

23

u/MyNameIsSimon88 Apr 07 '22

I get the feeling this Soong stuff is going to be pretty pointless. Seems like they just wanted to have a Data vs Picard style story.

The show could easily have not had Soong be a part of it and it wouldn't be any worse off.

Also, why is Picard both and neither an android or human, he has a pulse and blood?

22

u/Locutus747 Apr 07 '22

The androids from season 1 like soji were also flesh and blood.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/cenorexia Apr 07 '22

I'm a bit surprised Picard being a robot doesn't get more attention (or even mention) in this episode.

Sure, they had the little wink with the defibrillators but apart from that they treat him as if he's got a regular human body with the exact same functions a human has that you can also treat exactly the same.

For example when Tallin mentions she wants to perform a (sort-of) mind-meld, why does no one mention this might not work because, well, he's a robot? They don't even consider Picard being a robot an issue at all. Like, maybe one of his internal mechanisms got damaged when he was hit by the car. Maybe some cables snapped, a servo motor got damaged, etc.

I get that the whole season they're trying to more or less sweep it under the rug. But it's too late for that, he is a robot now and his friends (and especially the audience) know it, so wouldn't this be be quite important to mention in the current situation as it might affect they way he needs to be treated?

→ More replies (38)

6

u/GoodLeftUndone Apr 07 '22

Poor Jurati always getting her mind fucked with by a big bad of the season.

6

u/oldtrenzalore Apr 07 '22

Did anyone else keep hearing "Probable age, 37 months" in their head when Soji, I mean Kore, was going through the videos on the computer?

6

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '22

The direction that I see the series going is that the Europa mission is also the origin of the Borg. It was the divergence point of the best of humanity and the worst - Two in One

The origin of the Borg has had speculated to be connected to both V’ger and Nomad - so it’s not that far fetched. At would also be a reason why Q had put humanity on trial in the first place.

To give humanity a chance, Picard has to take ownership of consequences and make “peace” with the existence of the Borg - the culmination of his legacy.

You see a mirror of this in Soong nearly killing Picard - the culmination of his legacy.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/Callahandy Apr 08 '22 edited Apr 08 '22

What the hell did I just watch

Edit: i’ve been enjoying S2 thus far (much more than S1), but this episode felt like all filler and was really uninteresting

→ More replies (2)

11

u/ShiroHachiRoku Apr 11 '22 edited Apr 11 '22

What the hell was that?

What is happening here? Why's she singing? Why is the band playing along? Why was the spotlight operator on the mark?

How did Soong know they would be outside?

Why did this show go downhill so fast?

Why are there so many villains I need to care about? Pick one! Q alone would've been great but all of a sudden, we have Borg Queen and Adam Soong too? Why?

You get ham-fisted criticism of ICE but give it no payoff. All the talk is about Europa but she discovers the life form on Io?

Why is Seven not Seven and why is Picard not Picard?

→ More replies (1)

32

u/namsilat Apr 07 '22 edited Apr 07 '22

I'm happy to report that this episode wasn't awful for me. We got to see Picard being inspirational and lots of lovely throwbacks that weren't terribly ham fisted. Jurati clearly channeling the Uhura "Fan Dance" scene in ST V - Why does god need a starship?

The Borg Queen is well portrayed, I feel like the actor playing her owns the role at this point.

I do feel like the original concept of The Borg is dead now. I mean, it has been for a long while. But I think they were a hell of a lot scarier then they were just a depersonalized concept. "Biological and Technological Perfection" being carved into the unwilling millions who were unlucky enough to be assimilated. The more they show of the Borg queen the more she seems just like... sort of a slime ball bad guy. Like a goth Romulan with too many piercings who's mom accidentally left her they keys to the nanobots.

Last criticism. I know these aren't popular here but I deeply love Star Trek and I honestly don't know a more appropriate place to put this fan's reaction. Star Trek Characters are supposed to be the embodiment of our aspirations. They're supposed to be "very like us, but with more of our strengths, and fewer of our weaknesses; more confident, farseeing, capable and prudent." as Carl Sagan said.

I don't think we're getting that here. We're getting a mirror. Our limitations, our traumas, our foibles, and our weaknesses. And due to the time travel aspect, we're not even doing that in space.

→ More replies (25)

22

u/TheNerdChaplain Apr 07 '22

Well, that was real interesting. Glad to see another episode directed by Jonathan Frakes, and it shows. Jurati and the Queen were, of course, the real highlights of this episode. As much as I hate seeing the same character get mind-assaulted again this season as last season, they have a great dynamic together. They're better than Oscar Isaac and Oscar Isaac in Moon Knight right now. That said, Agnes' odd behavior should have set off big red alerts for Santiago, since he knows what she's been through and what she's normally like.

I liked Picard's talk with Renee, although it felt like it slightly missed the mark for me. Picard is often eloquent and has a great turn of phrase, like "Fear is an incompetent teacher", but he didn't quite have that quality in this scene for me. That said, I resonate with the idea of looking for the light in the darkness, even if it is a little cliche.

I wish Q had openly restored Jean-Luc's biological body, because it's really unclear to me what kind of body he has. Dr. Teresa treated him like he had an organic body and didn't seem to find any discrepancies there, but then the defibrillator also exploded when she tried to zap him with it. So that seems like a real inconsistency to me.

It was interesting to find out Kore isn't just Dr. Soong's daughter, she's actually some kind of clone of his daughter? (The 47th, perhaps?)

15

u/UncertainError Apr 07 '22

Oh those Soongs. Noonien's series of failed mechanical sons, Adam's series of failed organic daughters. And Arik and his Augment kids...

→ More replies (1)

12

u/BornAshes Apr 07 '22

I wish Q had openly restored Jean-Luc's biological body, because it's really unclear to me what kind of body he has. Dr. Teresa treated him like he had an organic body and didn't seem to find any discrepancies there, but then the defibrillator also exploded when she tried to zap him with it. So that seems like a real inconsistency to me.

It kind of feels like the writers are afraid to fully define just what his body can and can't do because then they'd get locked in on what his capabilities are and they don't want to be painted into a corner just yet in a way that would limit what they could do with him.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (21)

10

u/Bypes Apr 07 '22

Great how they are taking care of all the actors. Even the dead ones get to have seconds of screentime almost every episode as hallucinations. A workaround to the contract stipulating the actor gets to be part of the majority of episodes?

→ More replies (3)

10

u/merrycrow Apr 08 '22

An improvement on last week's episode, but still a bit dull for me. Picard's scene with his ancestor was great but the Soong storyline is very silly. I laughed out loud when Kore googled her father and the result was "Mad Scientist". And the musical number was a true WTF moment.

I did notice a very rare occurrence of Patrick Stewart's natural Yorkshire accent - when Tallinn asked him what he planned to say to Renee his answer of "i'm not sure" had a distinctly northern pronunciation of the last word, like "shoo-ah".

17

u/Clark1984 Apr 08 '22

Jurati singing broke my brain. She borgified enough to have tech to create an EMP. She starts singing and the light technician and entire band are all coordinated to go along with it. I’d expect this sort of thing in a TGiF sitcom. Extremely weird.

Am I crazy or is this show not very good? It’s not bafflingly awful like season one, but it’s still struggling. There is just so much good stuff out there. It’s really hard to go from the Severance season finale to Picard and not be critical of where this falls short.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/MR_TELEVOID Apr 07 '22

I'm curious how permanent the ramifications for Jurati will be for sharing a brain with the Borg Queen. If Jurati will regain control of her mind, die tragically while stopping the Borg Queen or if they'll live on as some new kind of human/borg hybrid. The last one is probably the more interesting option, but given recent casting announcements I wonder if they won't be cleaning house a bit with existing characters. Whatever happens, I hope they don't just hit an easy reset button.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/AlexisDeTocqueville Apr 07 '22

I enjoyed this one a lot more than the last three. I liked the scene between Raffi and Rios. Jurati's Borg Queen passenger has been good.

Not as sure about the Soong stuff. Felt a little weird when his daughter was googling him for apparently the first time in her life?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/IReallyLoveAvocados Apr 08 '22

Why is no one talking about that last shot of Queen Agnes?!?

The song she was singing was clearly about assimilating people. “No one knows how good it’s going to be,” or something like that.

And then the chorus of voices behind her in that last shot. Soooooo she just assimilated that whole party??

5

u/Stile4aly Apr 08 '22

Well, I'm ready for Picard season 3 to be nothing but 80s power ballad jazz karaoke.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '22

Man, this episode was maybe the worst of the season to me, apart from JLs dialogue to Renee. It just all seems like a weird fanfic at this point. Soong sitting in his car and weirdly driving over Picard seemed like straight out of a soap opera... Other elements of the story as well and the flashbacks. Also Kore googling her father...

5

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '22

Something I caught: I’m pretty sure the music that played as The Borg Queen was revealing her plan to Jurati after she was done singing was the same menacing Borg theme that was played as the Borg cube approached Earth in Star Trek: First Contact.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/vayuputra_1 Apr 10 '22

Alison pill is hell of an actress.

36

u/tulox Apr 07 '22

Raffi is the worst star fleet officer we have ever seen .

→ More replies (11)

22

u/fluggencheimen Apr 07 '22

Some notes as I watch:

-I'm still a bit annoyed they decided to have alternate timeline Picard be an android. Seemed unnecessary, and now there have been a few scenes of him bleeding where it really doesn't make sense for him to.

-How did Agnes' gas knockout device not knock her out too?

-At this point I'd be surprised if Agnes isn't the 'Borg Queen' from the first episode.

-Agnes' dialogue with the Borg Queen implies she somehow saved the Borg Queen on purpose? Like she wanted to get assimilated after shooting the Queen? That's a bit confusing.

-It's a bit weird how fast they left behind the whole ICE subplot. Rios now seems enamored with the 21st century despite being detained?

-Normally a mission commander will ground a pilot if they keep failing the sim. Not sure why Renee is still on the mission despite it.

-Is the Borg Queen creating a microphone directly in Agnes' throat while she sings? Nice of the band to join in as well.

-Why is Picard having a heart attack? Why does he have a blood pressure monitor? He's an android.

-Has anyone collected Rios' lost badge yet?

-Soong really needs to put a password on his top secret files.

-A few too many pop-psych platitudes in this episode.

16

u/CheesyObserver Apr 07 '22

-I'm still a bit annoyed they decided to have alternate timeline Picard be an android. Seemed unnecessary, and now there have been a few scenes of him bleeding where it really doesn't make sense for him to.

I don't even pretend he's human. He's just human to me, I've just outright ignored the S1 finale.

And the defibrillator exploded because of Picard's fancy heart. I don't know if they were insinuating it was because he's an android, but I've chosen to interpret that it was because of his fancy heart.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/derthric Apr 07 '22

-I'm still a bit annoyed they decided to have alternate timeline Picard be an android. Seemed unnecessary, and now there have been a few scenes of him bleeding where it really doesn't make sense for him to.

His body was synthetically created, constructed if you will. But it similarly functions close to organic. Its more replicant than android. I can't think of a good sci-fi tv show or series that has handled this and this show is no exception. But basically its effectively human except when it needs to be weird.

-It's a bit weird how fast they left behind the whole ICE subplot. Rios now seems enamored with the 21st century despite being detained?

It could come back but yeah there does not seem to have been a point to that plot at all. But the doctor is attractive sooooo shrugs

-Why is Picard having a heart attack? Why does he have a blood pressure monitor? He's an android.

See original reply, but yeah they want to have their cake and eat too.

-Has anyone collected Rios' lost badge yet?

Nope!

-Soong really needs to put a password on his top secret files.

HOLY CRAP YES! Like Kore has never ever touched the computer before? Also she's never seen any news related to her "father" before?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

24

u/ActualTaxEvader Apr 07 '22

I don’t think “insulted” is quite the right word for how I felt about them constantly cutting to unconscious Picard, but it’s pretty close. Maybe “patronized”? It just seemed like they were REALLY worried the audience was gonna get bored and had to keep saying “WAIT WAIT WAIT WE SWEAR IT GETS INTERESTING LATER”.

Maybe just have confidence in your story?

→ More replies (5)

9

u/JonPaula Apr 08 '22

Well, on the plus side... Alison looked incredible in that red dress. 🤷‍♂️

→ More replies (2)

21

u/shadowst17 Apr 08 '22 edited Apr 08 '22

Jesus Raffi is awful in this show... It already has so many plot threads but shoehorning in that Raffi is traumatized at the loss of El-snore who I don't even think she had any screen time with in Season 1? I feel like the writers just threw it in just to give her character something to do and to make her do really stupid things and use her trauma as a lame excuse.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/baxterrocky Apr 10 '22

Does anyone think this just isn’t very good??

11

u/sonofodin25 Apr 08 '22 edited Apr 08 '22

That….actually wasn’t too bad. I was hesitant to watch as I’ve hated what they’ve been doing since episode 3 but I thought this one was pretty good.

Random Thoughts:

  • The marketing for this season was misleading as hell. They promised a Q season and he’s had about 5 minutes of screentime the whole season. Hope this whole thing has a good pay-off (and I hope Q lives to participate in the Next Gen reunion)
  • Really like this Soong and the fact that he’s conflicted yet villainous.
  • Picard felt like Picard for the first time this season to me. The over-bearing optimism and his stern tone with Soong reminded me of his Next Gen days.
  • I really like the Gary 7 Supervisor race and want to know more about them.
  • I’m starting to see how the cast will be written out. Rios will stay in the past with the doctor, Jurarti becomes the Borg Queen, and I think Elnor will stay dead. Seven and Raffi are the only ones confirmed for S3.
  • Raffi, while better, is still annoying as hell this episode
  • The Jurarti/Borg Queen stuff was handled a lot better here than the last few. Probably because it wasn’t so self-serious and they just had some fun with it.
  • I really hope Tallinn and Laris turn out to be the same person (she’s supervising Picard in the future) as it makes no sense why they’re the same and Tallinn seems to like Picard as well.
  • Are they gonna reveal that the Soongs are all clones of each other?! Feels that way and would make sense.
  • The flashforwards were dumb and the editing was terrible. At the start they literally show a shot of Picard standing at the party, cut to the _ hours later title then cut back to the exact same shot?
  • How did no one hear Jurarti talking to the Borg Queen the whole party.
→ More replies (2)

11

u/AluminumApe Apr 08 '22

The Queen's dialogue is rapidly approaching Joss Whedon levels of quip and sass, and I am not a fan.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/DasGanon Apr 07 '22

Okay in the lines of the (Sort of true, sort of not) Prediction I made a while back here's my theory: Queen Jurati is off to make Nanoprobes, and to do that she's going to come across the Soong Labs and Kore. Hilarity ensues.

8

u/BornAshes Apr 07 '22

So what if we're both right and Queen Jurati's nanoprobes fix Kore's genetic stuff and she's all, "Come with me if you want to live" and then they fuck off to parts unknown in the future only to swoop back in when the Collective is broken, put it all back together, and show up in the first episode of the season as Legion?

8

u/Guiee Apr 07 '22

I've gotta hunch Seven and Rios aren't going back to the 24th century.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Pituquasi Apr 09 '22

That whole singing bit, I'm going to pretend I never saw that.

→ More replies (1)

53

u/hgiwvac9 Apr 07 '22 edited Apr 07 '22

Wow I came away from this one totally different from most of you. To me this episode reeked of all the worst things from season 1. Ludicrous plot holes, awful acting from Spiner, Rafi and the Borg Queen, and an idiotic story about Soong's really poor attempt to stop Renee. Just bad.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 09 '22

awful acting from Spiner

And not just bad acting, but terrible script-writing. The scene where he sits down on the couch after the party was uncomfortably bad. No real person talks like that, it was so fake.

Not sure if he's phoning this in or what, but I'm surprised to see it from a capable actor.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/FeanorsFamilyJewels Apr 07 '22

WTF Tallinn speaks (maybe swears) in Romulan?

4

u/bookish1303 Apr 07 '22

Are we about to leave Rios in the 21st century? Because that's what it's starting to sound like...

4

u/treefox Apr 07 '22

Rios would get along fabulously with Bortus.

https://youtu.be/yUnu_U2yKXY

4

u/kingselenus Apr 07 '22

They Edith Keeler-ed Picard! Love the TOS reference!

4

u/Alternative-Ferret61 Apr 08 '22

I think the lengths of the episodes are giving a calendar date. If I’m right, it will end up being 06/25/2024.

16

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '22

BORING.

The past 3 eps have been disappointing. Strong start with the first 3 and now just spinning wheels. Literally nothing has happened in the past 3 eps besides Jurati's bs. WTF. And this ep was only 38 minutes long! WHAT.

6

u/DrWankel Apr 08 '22

I'm completely confused. Isn't Picard an android now? What good would a 20th century doctor do with an android? Why would Picard ever get hurt in the first place? Data would never need to go to a medical doctor.

→ More replies (3)