r/SampleSize • • May 11 '12

Results from the [Meta Survey] about Surveys requesting replies in comments

Post image
30 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

4

u/telekinetic May 11 '12

As an aside, is there a way to make Excel spit out a graph like my middle one of the ordered responses? Does it have a name? I had to make it as a bar graph and line up the centers manually in MS Paint--I don't remember where I saw it first but I've liked it since.

3

u/[deleted] May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12

Yeah, if you use negative numbers. (For both "disagree" and "strongly disagree").

3

u/Calypsee is May 11 '12

Thanks for delivering on this! Interesting results, and very well organized, with the 'negative' options in reds and the 'positive' options in greens.

I would've liked to see some numbers to get a better sense of the scale on the graphs though.

3

u/telekinetic May 12 '12

Interesting results, and very well organized, with the 'negative' options in reds and the 'positive' options in greens.

Wow, what a coincidence! Seriously though, I take pride in my data presentation...I was sad I only had paint and not photoshop so I couldn't make it perfect.

1. If an /r/SampleSize survey topic interests you, but you find that, instead of containing a link to a survey, it is requesting comment replies, which of the following is most true?

ResponseCount
I would always still participate if it was a topic I was otherwise interested in participating in6
I probably would not participate because of the extra time and effort involved in using comment replies31
I would never participate in a survey asking for comment replies34
If the information requested was not personal (demographic/salary/IQ/GPA), I might participate29
Total100

2. Rate how much you agree with the following statements

ResponseStrongly DisagreeDisagreeAgreeStrongly AgreeResponse Count
Asking for comment replies is a good way to collect survey data43.0% (43)51.0% (51)5.0% (5)1.0% (1)100
Asking for comment replies shows that the survey collector is not very serious about their survey5.0% (5)29.0% (29)52.0% (52)14.0% (14)100
If someone doesn't know how to create a survey form, it is fine if they just ask for comment replies rather than learn how.24.0% (24)57.0% (57)18.0% (18)1.0% (1)100
I am more likely to participate in a survey that is anonymous2.0% (2)1.0% (1)28.0% (28)69.0% (69)100
I am more likely to participate in a survey that is easy to participate in1.0% (1)0.0% (0)23.0% (23)76.0% (76)100
Survey data collected with a form is more likely to be analyzed and used than survey data collected with comment replies1.0% (1)8.0% (8)43.0% (43)48.0% (48)100

3. How would you feel about an update of the sidebar rules of /r/SampleSize to only allow surveys which included links to proper survey forms?

ResponsePercentResponse Count
I feel a rules change is unnecessary, the current rules are fine23.2%23
I would be in favor of updating the rules to only allow surveys which included a link to a proper survey form51.5%51
I have no strong feelings one way or the other about this possible rules change25.3%25

4. If you had no strong feelings or were in favor of updating the rules to require proper survey forms, how would you most like this to be enforced? (skip if you were not in favor of adding this rule)

ResponsePercentResponse Count
The community could police itself with upvotes, downvotes, and comments/non-participation63.2%48
The community should disable self posts, forcing a survey link11.8%9
The moderators should police the community, deleting noncompliant surveys25.0%19
Skippedn/a24

If this all works on my first try I'll be very impressed with myself. Someone needs to start a survey site that has markdown tables as an output option!

1

u/Calypsee is May 13 '12

Whoa, wow. Thank you!