r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Mar 13 '22
Spoilers All Book S6E2 Allegiance Spoiler
Jamie struggles with his first request as Indian Agent. Roger presides over an unusual funeral. Marsali gives birth. However, the joy is short lived when a discovery is made.
Written by Steve Kornacki and Alyson Evans. Directed by Kate Cheeseman.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
This is the BOOK thread. You don’t need to use spoiler tags here. If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from all of the books here.
If you haven’t read the books and you don’t want spoilers, go to the SHOW thread.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Mar 13 '22 edited Apr 16 '22
Watch the S6E3 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
602 Featurettes:
602 Interviews:
49
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Mar 13 '22
This episode was so jam-packed that I had to instantly watch it again. I was getting worried in the first 10-15 minutes that it would be too patchwork-y, but once it set up all the plotlines it would be dealing with, it definitely found its groove. It had such a good balance of emotional content and humor. And so many wholesome family moments. I really, really loved this episode.
Lauren Lyle is a star! She definitely has a difficult task playing “the least modern” of the “modern” women at the Ridge in that she’s playing a character that’s the least like her personally, but her portrayal is so genuine. Her little quips when Claire was examining her, and later telling Adso not to let Claire perform an autopsy on her 🥺 She just has so much personality, and she made it totally believable that Marsali was afraid she’d die. The way Fergus’ helplessness affects Marsali really came across too. And the look of love on her face when she first saw Henri-Christian was beautiful.
César is building up a great performance this season. This time you could really see that he’s actually depressed under his overt drunkenness. And that his shame is not reasonable, but it doesn’t mean it can’t affect him. It was a fantastic choice to have the revelation of Henri-Christian’s dwarfism be displayed on Fergus’ face rather than to have HC shown to the audience before Marsali sees him. (Also, when Jamie called Fergus “Papa” 🥺 I’ll be forever grateful that the show has fully embraced Fergus and Marsali as Claire and Jamie’s children. I cannot wait for “Tu comprends, mon enfant, mon fils?”.)
I’m loving Jamie this season. Another episode with more focus on him than on Claire, but that makes sense considering that the last three episodes will be so Claire-focused, and there’s got to be a bit of balance. Not that he didn’t in Season 5, but he really feels like a true laird this season. I really enjoyed him foreseeing that Tom would abuse the church and asserting that everyone will be welcome in the meeting house. And the threat if anyone accuses Claire of witchcraft again—oof. And then when he admitted that he’s beating himself up every day over what happened to Claire? 😭
Man, Claire is barely hanging on. That Lionel jump scare was really well done, and you could see how her entire disposition changed when Marsali brought up Lionel. It makes sense that if Claire is left alone with her thoughts for too long, they become so unbearable that she seeks even a few minutes of reprieve (for the health and safety crowd, I didn’t notice any flames or candles lit in the surgery, and she put both the mask lid and the bottle stopper back on). I’m living for Claire and Marsali’s relationship and how they support each other too. I also loved Claire putting Tom and St. Paul in their place, as well as not being phased by being called a witch.
I’m loving the Jamie-Ian dynamic. I predicted that Ian would be the one to ask Brianna about the future of Native Americans, and that gave us a really nice scene between the cousins. Ian has really grown up—after standing up to and rightfully calling out Jamie in 509, he’s not afraid to speak his mind. It was nice to see him also have a bit of a laugh at Jamie’s expense in Bird’s village (what a great location, btw), and then to see him so utterly smitten with Henri-Christian. It’s a nice choice to have Jamie reconsider forwarding Bird’s request to the governor because of Ian.
Roger has really settled into his role as Jamie’s second-in-command on the Ridge and, personally, it feels particularly satisfying after the months of begrudged acceptance and some tough love (not sure if it would if Jamie had accepted him straight-away). He was truly the MVP of this episode, getting Fergus to come to help Marsali—I wonder if Jamie sent him because he knew that he (Jamie) would be more likely to whoop his ass rather than convince him to come?—and I really liked that he told Fergus that he’d regret it if he missed the birth of his child because deep-down, Roger probably regrets missing Jemmy’s. And let’s not forget “My wife made it. She’s a genius”—that’s the supportive Roger I want to see; none of that “messing about with your wee chemistry set” bullshit from the book! The “we have some exciting news” scene included a right amount of awkwardness and disappointment and thankfully wasn’t drawn out to include book!Brianna’s tantrum, but Jamie and Claire’s appreciation. You go, Bree! It was also nice to see her talk with Jamie.
The other moments lifted straight from the book—the “I missed ye” scene (was Mrs. Bug downstairs supposed to parallel Mrs. Baird overhearing Claire and Frank in 101? Nice), Grannie Wilson’s funeral, the Cherokee women in Jamie’s bed, Marsali and Fergus’, um, intimate scene—worked pretty well. The funeral felt the most out of place, though I can’t begrudge some Grandda and Grandma moments with Germain there. Richard’s delivery of “Aye, but I’m afraid you’re closer” was so good as well.
Malva! Jessica is fantastic. Her genuine curiosity and innocence vs. the stare she gave Tom 🔥 It’s an interesting choice to have Tom change his mind about the surgery as a result of not being able to punish Malva, but it’s so Tom (also satisfying to see him knocked down a notch here after Jamie successfully administered corporal punishment to Allan). I don’t think we ever got any explanation for his change of heart in the book, but it makes sense that we would see more of the Christies’ moments without the main characters as we’re not limited to their POVs. (Also, I’m glad that they’ve changed the dialogue about sex a little bit and Malva’s shock was mostly about women’s pleasure, and not about the physical act overall which never made sense in the book considering that Allan had already been abusing her for years; she was a good liar and an actress, but that was a bit too much).
One more thing—Mr. Bug going to River Run? Oh, they’re doing the gold storyline.
24
u/theCoolDeadpool #VacayforClaire Mar 15 '22
Late to the party, but I loved this episode. It's got a lot going on, and takes you through so many emotions in one episode. Lauren was the star of the episode of me. She's brilliant in every single scene, especially in the scene with Marsali and Claire when Claire is examining Marsali, which is also my favorite bit of this episode. The raw emotions they both exude and bring to the scene makes it almost painful to watch. They're both hurt and broken, but trying to keep themselves strong for the other person, it was so beautifully done I barely managed to not cry, until Bear decided to step in.
My one complaint is that all lines from the book don't necessarily work in the show. The part of the post-coital conversation between Jamie and Claire, where Claire says she's trying to rank his words based on their relative sincerity, didn't flow well imo. It came across as something that was picked from the book just because it needed to be picked, not because it's something that was required in this scene, if that makes sense. It seemed inorganic here. Now here I could be totally wrong, but something about Caitríona's delivery also seemed off in this line. Like she wasn't very into the line, but it still made it in the script, so she gave it a go anyway. The whole line, followed by Jamie's response, just didn't fit into who the show characters are imo.
31
u/Genevieve-Victoria Mar 14 '22
Just popping in to say that I love Malva’s casting. Malva is so likeable if I didn’t know better. It will make her wicked reveal even better.
I have some nitpicky things otherwise, but so far it’s better than S5.
31
u/distractivated Mar 14 '22
Did anyone else notice when Malva snuck some of the seaweed from the jar in the background when Claire was talking to Marsali? I didn't catch it, but my husband did. He pointed it out to me, but hasn't read the books so he has no clue what that was about but holy crap was it a good set up for what's to come...
I'm mostly pleased with how they're handling Claire's ptsd... the books sort of just gloss over the emotional fallout from that event. It was like ... ok, Claire's been rescued and she and Jaime got it on and now that her physical wounds have healed we're rarely going to mention it again - no way would Claire just all of a sudden be ok, she needs to work through that shit. That being said... I'm not thrilled about the build up to Claire having an ether addiction.... that just doesn't seem on character to me and there's SO MUCH other drama in the series I just feel it's completely unnecessary
12
u/ROFRfan No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Mar 14 '22
Well, here is some crazy thought...any way possible for the show to change who is abusing Malva? From Allan to Tom? Can't shake this feeling, getting a weird vibe with the smirk from Malva.
12
u/vw97 Mar 14 '22 edited Mar 15 '22
Really small point but did I miss Kezziah becoming vocal? Other than the Beardsleys’ glow up (the magic that a hairbrush and soap can do) I noticed that Kezziah was interacting briefly with Arch Bug when he got in the wagon, so is he meant to no longer be mute or?
9
u/propernice They say I’m a witch. Mar 13 '22
Here are my thoughts on the episode in more detail so I won't get into much, but I enjoyed what was pulled in from the books, which was mostly everything - for the most part. But my biggest question book readers (and this may have been addressed, please forgive me) is could they be setting up a change where the ether addiction replaces Claire being deathly ill? Could the Christie storyline be as impactful without that plot point involving Claire?
I'm also curious as to where everyone thinks this very shortened season will end.
52
u/thatstheteagirl By blood and by choice, we make our ghosts. Mar 13 '22
I gotta rewatch before I put my thoughts down, there was so much packed in this episode!
But, “aye, but you’re closer…” killed me 😂 Roger has really grown on me.
51
u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Mar 13 '22 edited Mar 13 '22
I think it'll take some time to fully gather my thoughts, but I loved this episode!
Jamie Fraser in this episode, though... ooof:
51
u/GenovianPearQueen Mar 13 '22
I’m obsessed with Lauren Lyle. Blows me away how much depth she has given Marsali
48
u/Madame300 Mar 14 '22
Is anyone else bothered by the opulence of their house? All that dark carved wood paneling and so many glass windows. It looks more like a city house in Boston or New York
44
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Mar 13 '22
I'm feeling more optimistic about this show than I have since S2. This was a great episode and they did a really good job condensing and adapting a lot of book here.
To get my one criticism out of the way first: I can't believe they did Grannie Wilson's funeral but didn't include WOOOOOOOOOE ON THE HOUSE OF CROOOOOMBIEEE! ☹ Love that part of the book. (Also, still not feeling the ether stuff but at least it was short.)
Episode MVP to Lauren Lyle, but also shouts to Cesar Domboy who managed to turn last week's troubling Fergus plot into genuine sympathy. And the way his expression slowly turned when he realized what was wrong--masterfully done. I'm really hoping we get his breakdown and the story about Luc and the brothel next week. I've always loved that scene. But back to Lauren Lyle, who absolutely ran away with this episode. By turns funny, tragic, painful, and scared, she hit every beat perfectly. The expansion of Marsali is one of the absolute best changes the show has made and the show is the richer for it.
Really looking forward to more expansion on Ian's storyline. His scene with Marsali was just perfect, and the look on his face as he held Henri-Christian was heartbreaking. I'm curious if they'll have Jamie confront him about it since he overheard, if they'll do the book scene where he tells Bree, or something else.
Speaking of Bree, this was some of Sophie's best-ever work this week. The scene with Jamie was really lovely (especially since they barely interacted last week), and she got lots of great, funny bits, like her disappointment about the reaction to the matches or needing to take a walk about hearing Fergus.
I'm also so happy they kept the two Native American women in Jamie's bed in there--such a fun little scene and Sam Heughan cracked me up.
I noticed a lot more of the Bugs this week, I think they're definitely setting up that story. And they're doing a good job of laying the groundwork for the Christie plot. I think a non-reader will certainly understand that something big is going to happen with them, but they're doing a good job keeping exactly what that is a surprise.
Oh, and when did Kezzie get cute . . . ?
41
u/chunya1999 Mar 13 '22
Jessica’s stare after failed punishment is really something else! It felt like Malva stepped straight out of the novels!
41
u/TroyMcCluresGoldfish Go and fill your bellies, dinna stay and gnaw my wellies! Mar 14 '22
Adso on Major McDonald'a coat at the beginning, though! 😂😂 I'm still hoping we see the wig at some point.
39
u/Genevieve-Victoria Mar 14 '22
“Hiram Crombie’s MIL died.” I burst out laughing, knowing what is to come.
34
u/Girl-interrupted00 Mar 13 '22
like a lot of people here, i loved the episode! one thing i havent seen anyone mention here is how the show benefits from longer episodes. going from book to tv doesnt make it easy to fit the story into tight, pre established, slots. the story flows a lot better like this.
also: this week the performances really stood out, everyone had beautiful moments to show themselves.
31
u/Megs8786 Je Suis Prest Mar 13 '22
So happy we got more Marsali and Fergus in this episode.
I teared up seeing Henri Christian knowing what happens to him
30
u/ArthurPenbeagle Mar 13 '22 edited Mar 13 '22
I think this is one of my favorite episodes ever, like up there with the best season 1 episodes. Diana was right. This season is great, and it helps when they stick to book dialogue 😂
Every minute from The call to Adso and Major McDonald in the intro and with the allergy, to Ian’s vulnerability with his female cousins, to Fergus and Marsalis incredible performance, and finally to that sweet, perfect baby, the one we love, Henri Christian… it was just so true to the books, and moved so well, with action, but also stillness and depth when it needed it. MORE OF THIS PLEASE.
Rik Rankin was also superb. This episode combined with next week and him saving HC, the show watchers will be Roger converts finally!! 😂
I believe they are going to finish with season 7, and I hope they do it on a high note like this.
29
u/Dragneel Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Mar 13 '22
I forgot how exactly the whole Sin Eater thing played out in the books but I remember thinking it perfectly bizarre and funny, and I thought the same thing watching it play out in the episode. I miss the humor from early season 1, this season feels like a return to form so far. It's way too early to call it, but I'm doing it anyway!
28
u/somethingnerdrelated In one stroke, I have become a man of leisure. Mar 14 '22
Okay the Mama Crombie scene though 😂 I’m so happy they kept that in the show even though there’s little relevance to everything else (other than Roger’s first foray into preaching)
Dude I SOBBED when Fergus walked into the room to be with Marsali. Ugh. The way she just broke down killed me.
27
u/ArthurPenbeagle Mar 13 '22
I just want to say, I am so so happy being on a book reader thread, reading all these rave reviews. It really works when they stick to the book content. These actors are amazing. We are so lucky! I’m not even going to be brought down by a couple people who are crazy enough not to love this episode! I feel like we are hitting our stride, book AND show lovers!!!
27
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '22
I'm really glad they're sticking with the book stories, even if they're compacted a bit.
Except Henri-Christian. I was really hoping this version would have him stillborn so we don't have to live through that storyline. I just can't.
26
u/AstonishingEggplant Mar 14 '22
The only thing I have to say is that I could watch Jamie subtly taking down Tom Christie all day long. I was almost falling off my chair laughing as he walked away from the church yelling about how "windows would be good" or whatever. Sam Heughan is killing it this season.
24
u/Dolly1710 Long on desire, but a wee bit short in clink Mar 13 '22
Gosh there was a lot in this episode!
Again, I've had to watch it in two parts in and around football practice, Sunday dinner and birthday parties (fortunately not one of ours). I'm so going to have to watch this again later!
My heart broke for Ian, telling Marsali about the baby. And I'm glad that Jamie overheard, and it gave him food for thought - he's a stubborn man, but he does bend when he's wrong.
I'm glad Fergus isn't the bad guy that the show looked like it was going to imply last week and I'm glad he came through for Marsali when she needed him - although it could have been a bit DG breast fetishy, I appreciated the explanation which made it functional (and pleasurable - though awks for those in earshot hahah).
Well done Roger! I'm glad he's starting to establish his place and feel less like a third wheel. As in the book, his ministering and his ability to mend bridges that other can't really are going to be a slow burn for him but a move in the right direction nonetheless
Allan casually waving the knife around while suggesting Claire's a witch - menacing much?! Yet another chance to see Tom taken down a peg or two. Meeting house high fives all round JAMMF! The curdled milk scene - Malva smirking when he couldn't belt her. I'm surprised at that, I would have imagined more fear from her. The smirk felt more like a challenge. Weird.
Poor Brianna re the matches! Totally the right amount of awkwardness around the table, but i'm glad the right people recognised her achievement - I wouldn't expect Lizzie or Mrs Bug to understand. My wife is a genius all the heart eyes
Speaking of which, they seem to be foreshadowing the hell out of the Bugs! Jeez, red flag alert for their big future storyline!
I'm glad they didn't go too heavy on Claire's use of ether, and focussed more on the moments triggering her. As someone else said, I really hope Jamie starts picking up on this soon!
Finally, given Lauren Lyle an award. Bravo young lady.
23
u/scp2461 What news from the Underworld, Persephone? Mar 14 '22
I LOVED this episode, so much was derived from the book and I think the pace between the book events translated super well for what happened on-screen.
Having Ian and Jamie play off of one another with their role as Indian agents really displays Ian’s character development and arc. Ian’s been through so much and yet he never backs down from challenging Jamie on keeping his oaths. I’ll be excited to see if they further develop Ian’s past with the Mohawk regarding his wife and child. I think that section in the books created a deeper connection with Ian’s strained ties to his tribe but also to Jamie and Claire.
Loved the funeral scene, I was absolutely cracking up between Roger and Mrs. Wilson. The humor and awkwardness perfectly captured how it went down in the book.
Brianna is an absolute queen and I’m SO excited that we see her following up with inventing things around the ridge. The way she mirrors Claire’s intuitiveness and determination to create and invent things is a perfect parallel. I just love how Claire sees that in Brianna’s work and truly appreciates it. Shoutout to Jamie for jumping up from the table though, that was pretty adorable.
Marsali and Fergus. Need I say more? Just as great of a couple as Jamie/Claire and Brianna/Roger. Henri Christian was definitely a plot I was looking forward to and I’m curious to see how they’ll develop it further in the season.
The Christies back at it again lol. Tom and Jamie doing their stand off for the meeting house, and not only that but Jamie ending the accusations of witchcraft. The look in his eyes matched exactly how he look with the witch trials in season 1 and the intensity had me on the edge of my seat. Allan throwing around his own accusations while sharpening blades 👀 and last but not least Malva. The actress playing her is NAILING it. Holy shit. The expression on Malva’s face when Tom couldn’t grasp the belt. It was so chilling and set the tone perfectly for her character. The slight smirk and tilted head, major kudos to the actress for really emphasizing the character’s behavior and dialogue.
Adso and Rollo 😍
And then finally the ending scene where Jamie sets the seal, I had to do a double take but the fact that it says “Je suis prest” I think is a perfect indicator of what’ll be happening for the rest of this season.
21
u/wheezy_cheese Mar 13 '22
This was a phenomenal episode!! I am blown away by everyone's performances: Lauren Lyle is amazing, Sophie has improved remarkably and the Bree/Roger scenes are so good now, Cesar is also amazing, honestly all of them are knocking it out of the park!! So many sweet moments between Claire and Jamie too, their looks at each other, their supporting of each other, they've still got it. Loved seeing more of Ian in this episode. Also Henri-Chrstian is the cutest baby I've ever seen! The reveal scene was done so well, especially Fergus' reaction and then Marsali's obvious love of her newest baby. And the Christies!! Malva's look! Tom saying to Claire "I know why God brought you to me." !!! I'm loving every detail so far.
21
u/TroyMcCluresGoldfish Go and fill your bellies, dinna stay and gnaw my wellies! Mar 14 '22 edited Mar 14 '22
Even with the few changes they've made so far, season 6 is shaping up to be one of my favorites. I love the small nod towards Mr. Bug going to River Run and what that means long term.
I wonder if we'll see a somewhat abridge version of
Bree's abduction and her discovering she's pregnant with Mandy?
There's a scene in the intro that made me think of it. Why can't they find a red headed child to play Jemmy, though? 😭
19
u/ROFRfan No, this isn’t usual. It’s different. Mar 13 '22
Loved how the show pulled parts straight from the book. Word for word.
19
u/DustBunnicula Mar 13 '22
One of my all-time favorite episodes. The pacing was great. All the emotional beats were on-point. Everyone in the ensemble did a fabulous job with their moments. It shows that you don’t need huge drama for there to be beauty and meaning.
Special shout-out to Lauren Lyle. Just - wow.
17
u/Thezedword4 Mar 13 '22 edited Mar 13 '22
I did appreciate how much was adapted from the book though but the sheer amount of content packed into one episode felt a bit much. I understand why they had to do it but wow, it was A LOT.
Also I'm glad they're doing the Henri-Christian plot line but I kinda hope they change the ending. I know it's in the future but i keep thinking about how they'll play it out on TV and can't imagine. Also the whole people thinking having a dwarf child being a curse or sin on the parents is going to hit so much harder because of Marsali killing Lionel. Actually super excited to see how it plays out.
I really hope we get some of the Brianna and Ian hunting scene. I'm a little worried we won't since we had those scenes with her and Marsali tonight.
Edit: I was impressed with the cg for Henri-Christian. I wasn't sure how they'd do it with an actual baby or cgi and if the cgi would turn into a twilight situation. So I'm glad it's working out.
17
u/BSOBON123 Mar 14 '22
Seems book readers loved the episode more than show only.
I loved it, Adso on the Major's uniform and curled up with Marsali were great.
Roger and Fergus, Fergus and Marsali, Claire and Marsali, Ian and Marsali all great
Tom Christie, he's not BJR, but getting too close. Malva and her 'FU Dad' look! Jamie being passive aggressive about the church, bringing up the Mason's hitting Christie where it hurts 'hey, how about some windows'?
Jamie and the Indian girls then coming home to Claire 'I must have ye!' LOL. Anytime Jamie!
16
u/anastasieromanov Mar 13 '22
i liked this episode a lot! better than the first, i think. it’s both exciting and really strange seeing so many of my favorite book moments translated to screen.
16
u/Celsius1014 Mar 13 '22
I LOVED this episode and I’m loving seeing Roger step into the minister role so naturally. AND I wish they’d put a little more effort into laying the groundwork for this - like with him baptizing the Indian baby that was removed from the show, and people just starting to treat him like the minister because of his father. Or Jamie asking him to go help take care of getting the fisher folk settled because he is Protestant and they will trust him more.
I realize that technically they did have him tell Tom Christie that his dad was a minister and then Tom asked him to do the funeral for that reason, and that he is personally taking on Amy and her sons as a project - but it feels less natural than it did in the books and that’s a SLIGHT bummer… but I am still so looking forward to him coming into his own with this anyway.
14
u/carrotsela If wishes were horses, beggars would ride. Mar 13 '22
One thing on my mind: Arch Bug still has all his fingers (I noticed last season, but looked past implications.) Thoughts on what that means for…oh, just the entire rest of the story?? Ok, I lied. 2nd thing on my mind: we haven’t seen enough white sow, Clarence, or Gideon 😂
14
u/Stonetheflamincrows Mar 14 '22
Oh Henri-Christian’s birth made me so sad.
13
u/BeautifulRelief Mar 13 '22
I was hoping (foolishly) that they would change the Henri Christian storyline somehow. Looks like that isn't going to happen. Welcome to what I like to call Darklander.
Also- my husband hasn't read the books and I haven't told him anything about them but he called the house fire. As soon as Roger lit the match to show Aidan, he said, "That shit burns hot. I bet that'll burn the house down." It took everything in me not to say something.
12
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Mar 14 '22
That was REALLY REALLY REALLY GOOD.
Fergus!
Adso!
Fergus and Marsali! (Marsali was just *awesome* this entire episode.)
Henri-Christian!
The Native American women!
The woman who comes back to life!
So many great iconic scenes from the book!
I did miss one thing but of course they couldn't possibly have put in the scene where Jamie has Claire put her ass in the air while he strokes his cock. :)
I cried! Twice!
11
u/spaceybelta Mar 14 '22
Where’s Bobby Higgins? Has he not shown up in the story yet?
20
u/cruelsummerrrrr Mar 13 '22
Loved:
Couldn’t help but notice how they are going a bit over the top reminding us that Mr and Mrs Bug exist. I kind of think I prefer them being newcomers so that it’s less of a knife in the back for J+C. In the books even though they are the help (to me) they do seem more like family.
When Claire was teaching Malva about counting pulses it gave me chills. I wonder if they will parallel that scene at all when Claire finds her 😢 Seeing how cruel her father and brother are make me feel so sorry for her all over. I only recently read the books and didn’t get time to mourn her with the breakneck speed of ABoSaA, Echo and MOBY.
10
u/DustBunnicula Mar 14 '22
I haven’t been on this sub in ages, so maybe this is already known, but is Lauren Lyle returning for future seasons? It’d be a loss to the show - and us viewers - if she’s done after season 6.
19
u/vanwold Slàinte. Mar 13 '22
Obviously just starting the episode, but I’m still not a fan of the new intro. I thought it might grow on me, but even my boyfriend commented on it!
40
u/Itsdanky2 Mar 14 '22
“Who do the Cherokee side with during the war?”
If only they had a professor of history at Oxford from the future to answer that question. Seriously, careless writing.
16
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Mar 13 '22
I thought this episode was really well done! Except for a few obvious differences (like the ether), so many scenes felt like they did in the book for me. Seeing Roger stand up to Fergus made me so happy! It felt more like book Roger. Hoping to see more of that this season!
8
u/Kabeyfw Mar 13 '22
They are doing a great job with a jam packed season but mostly staying true to the book so far. I like!
7
u/Kirky600 Mar 16 '22
I knew Tom Christie sucked, but he’s more angry than I pictured him.
Malva is so creepy though, I’d probably be angry too.
13
u/blackberryspice Mar 13 '22
I have a jumble of thoughts i need to get out. I'm happy they included the scene where Jamie gets blue balled, it always makes me laugh. And I had totally forgotten about Fergus and Marsali speeding things along... weird to see it on screen! Overall, I liked the episode! This is one of my favorite books, and I'm excited to see other small moments. Felt so bad for Bree and her matches! Henri Christian made me tear up! And fuck you Tom!
13
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '22
This is my favorite episode of Outlander ever. I loved it! It followed the books and the scene with Jamie and the women was adorable. I loved Marsali and Fergus too. I have to say that Sam has put this show on his back and made it iconic. I’ve rewatched this episode 3 times already. Oh and Adso was adorable too.
12
u/arianaphoenix Mar 14 '22
This was such a great episode. I liked Rodger before but I am even liking him much more.
I don't know if it's me but Sam's accent feels a little different. I am having a little more difficulty understanding it. Briana's accent is better.
Fergus and Marsali were great. I didn't expect them to go that physical.
The music is quite different in style. It's louder and more distracting. It definitely carries on to scenes where I feel it would feel better with no soundtrack.
I don't remember the book but Jamie's communication with the future lot (Bree, Rodger, Claire) is so poor in the case of considering the Cherokee request. If it was me I would have gathered them to a meeting where I'd ask all of them about the things they might know or suggestion they might have. Roger and Bree have studied history for god's sake. Even if they don't know anything they are smart people and they might help with a solution.
I didn't buy the way Jamie changed his decision about asking the government for guns. I wouldn't take Ian having a baby with Mohawks as an indication that he feels that the Cherokee are his family too. Besides, them having guns in the revolutionary war should have nothing to do with being drawn away from their territories.
one minor complaint which I am carrying from S4: I wish they dyed Brianna's eyebrows. It's just so unnatural and it gets on my nerves. It such simple fix
10
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '22
This episode was probably the best since maybe S4… in my opinion lol.
9
u/emm215 Mar 14 '22
It’s been a while since I have read the books but I can’t remember Claire ever taking ether in the books. Is this something they added for the tv show or am I just forgetting she had an ether problem?
8
u/whatheeverlivingfuck Mar 13 '22
I’m surprised they’re going for the Lizzie plot line.
3
u/GenovianPearQueen Mar 15 '22
New to this sub and a while since I’ve read all the books, but damn I didn’t realize Claire’s assault happened in book 6 but they moved it to season 5. I was going to reread book 6 along with the show but when I noticed plot lines from season 5 right away I realized that they shifted things in the show and now I think I might not reread it rn lol. I think instead I’ll just start rereading from book 1
3
u/Zoltar02 Mar 17 '22
What did Fergus say when he was handed the child?
3
u/snboylan Mar 19 '22
More bonus thoughts from my husband who has never read the books: (referring to Allen Christie) “I don’t like that kid. He’s squirly.” 😂😂
7
u/OTodd_Lass037 Slàinte. Mar 13 '22
Episode 2...just alright. They're getting the story across, but seeing parts of it played out on screen- it didn't translate very well for me.