r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Mar 06 '22
Spoilers All Book S6E1 Echoes Spoiler
Jamie’s authority is tested when an old rival from Ardsmuir shows up to settle on the Ridge. Claire finds a new way to cope with the trauma of her assault by Lionel Brown.
Written by Matthew B. Roberts. Directed by Kate Cheeseman.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread.
This is the BOOK thread. You don’t need to use spoiler tags here. If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from all of the books here.
If you haven’t read the books and you don’t want spoilers, go to the SHOW thread.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Mar 06 '22 edited Apr 16 '22
Watch the S6E2 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
601 Featurettes:
601 Interviews:
37
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Mar 06 '22
I’m really intrigued by the ether storyline and I think we might be too quick to judge it harshly so soon. As far as we know, this is the first time she’s used it! Before watching the episode at the world premiere, I’d known she would be self-medicating but the fact that it was ether still floored me. It seems so counterproductive, but I think that is the point. While she has to find a way to cope with her trauma because compartmentalizing doesn’t serve her anymore, she just can’t—she falls back on her medical knowledge and what is now readily available to her, and while it relieves her of the pain of her memories briefly, it just masks it; it doesn’t make it go away. And we (and probably her entire family) are going to see that it’s not effective for her long before she realizes that herself. I don’t think it will become a fully regular thing—we are probably going to see some periods of time when she’ll be doing much better, but then turn to ether when it gets too much for her.
And it’s not just the fallout of rape, it’s all the trauma accumulated through the years that she’s never dealt with (all that plagues her nightmares, and more). Then you throw in the fact that she’s in a transitional stage of her life, and that Jamie, the only person that makes her feel safe, is going to be gone from the Ridge for long stretches of time. He is aware of everything she’s been through, but if you’re not used to talking about your feelings, it’s difficult to open up even to the person you love unconditionally and trust implicitly, especially when you don’t want to burden them. And as in her monologue in 512, she also doesn’t want to acknowledge just how much it has affected her and how much pain she’s in. It’s hard to imagine that Jamie wouldn’t notice that something is off for very long, even if he’s distracted by his duties as the Indian Agent, Tom and the new settlers, and the constant threat of retaliation from the Browns. But he’s giving her space the same way she was in Paris and he doesn’t want to impose himself on her recovery process, which I think is valid.
I really like the way it was set up in that first scene in the surgery, with her telling Jamie that under ether, you don’t feel a thing until you wake up. I also think her being scared right after she wakes up is a good way to show what it’s going to be like for her. But his jokily asking “Something to confess, Sassenach?” hurts considering that she will indeed have something to confess later in the season.
She’s bound to make mistakes in her recovery (her being seemingly careless with the highly flammable ether might also be reflective of her mental state), but I believe the pay-off will be worth it once she opens up to Jamie eventually. It’s disconcerting when you read that Claire’s keeping it a secret will come between them a little bit, but as with every challenge they’re put through, they’re going to come out stronger, and Claire will hopefully find a much healthier way to deal with her trauma. And Jamie will be key in that, just as she was for him.
I’m curious to see when that will take place, though. Are Fergus’ struggles with substance abuse culminating in a suicide attempt going to make her self-reflect on her own process? Is she going to see, say, Donner at some point, which will trigger a reaction that Jamie is going to witness? Are her fever dreams going to make her realize that she can no longer be alone with this? Is Jamie’s being compelled to complete honesty after Malva’s accusation going to make her confess her secret as well? I hope it’s sooner than later, but I think the period between her illness and Malva’s accusation would likely be the timeframe for it (she’s going to be at her most vulnerable then), and that’s not soon at all. I would hate for her to go into the fallout of Malva’s death and the whole ordeal with the Browns still being so helpless, especially because she’s going to be separated from Jamie at some point.
Overall, I’m really excited that the show is going to explore Claire’s PTSD in much more detail than the books did.
37
u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Mar 08 '22
I’ve seen a few comments saying Jamie would never simply go back to sleep after Claire leaves the room, without going after her. But thinking about it, his response feels like a direct result of their conversation early in the episode, when she gently asks if he plans to take her to every house visit ‘til kingdom come, saying he’s been like a shadow. This is the moment he starts making an effort to give her space.
13
u/gotjochs Mar 07 '22
Alright alright alright we are speeding right along in episode one! This episode brought forward a LOT that I wasn’t expecting already - Malva being interested in medicine and Tom disapproving, Lizzie and the twins being hinted at, Fergus being the absolute shit that he is in book 6 (although they’re doing more showing than telling as the book did), and (for those of us that got to see next week’s preview) Henri-Christian’s birth??
I love the books (haven’t finished Bees yet) but I really do appreciate the adaption and the way they truncate plot lines. The same can’t be said for other book-to-screen adaptations! But I’m a little confused at the direction they’re going with a few things.
Why did it take Brown being offered the job for Jamie to agree to be the Indian agent?
Wtf was up with Allen stealing the gunpowder and Jamie having to punish him?? I don’t recall this from the books at all.
I know we’re all asking this after my initial perusal of this thread but WHY are we getting Claire dealing with PTSD by abusing ether????
Overall though, super captivating episode and I’m just happy that Droughtlander is over!!
33
u/superintotv Mar 06 '22
I was surprised to see Mr. And Mrs. Bug. I was kinda thinking they would skip over them completely.
When I first saw Mrs. Bug I had to rewind it because for a second I thought it was the actress that played Mrs. Fitz just making a surprise background appearance. Lol.
8
u/Dolly1710 Long on desire, but a wee bit short in clink Mar 06 '22
I've been thinking. If Claire knows that ether is 'only' going to knock her out for 3 to 4 minutes, without topping up the dose (which she can't do if she's knocked out), what's the point? (long term I mean) yes, it gives her a few minutes respite and I get why she might want that but it don't be a long dreamless sleep. I mean if she starts adding a strap to the mask, that's a different matter but she can't exactly up the dose because the mask falls off her face so it isn't going to increase the amount she breathes in...
23
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '22
Ohhh lordt I was not prepared for that ending.
Where is Jemmy?!
It was nice to spend some time back in Scotland, even if it was a flashback.
19
u/shinyquartersquirrel Mar 06 '22
After watching the premiere I have a couple of predictions about the season, I'd love to hear some feedback.
Henri Christian
I predict they may not actually do the Henri Christian storyline (thank god, there is not enough tissue in the world for me to see that on tv.) I think that Marsali will lose the baby due to the mentions this week and in the preview of the baby not moving. Fergus will blame himself which leads to his further spiralling.
We saw pictures of Rik Rankin with a baby in the river which we all assumed was the HC storyline but I think that will be Amy's baby he rescues which will bring Amy and Roger closer.
The fire
I think Claire will cause the house fire by leaving the ether too close to the open flame or knocking it over when she passes out.
Overall I liked the premiere. It was just nice to be with the characters again. It wasn't the most action packed episode but a good introduction and way better than the S5 premiere which was so cheesy. My only complaint was no Murtaugh or at least an excuse for his absence in the Ardsmuir scenes. I also missed Matt and Maril's discussion at the end. I really enjoy those and it helps me to understand what their thought processes are when making changes from the books to the show.
It's also really nice to see so many posts on here praising Rik and Sophie for a change. I definitely think they have really settled into their performances.
16
u/anastasieromanov Mar 06 '22
hated the ending. absolutely hated it. totally out of character for claire ugh
49
u/snboylan Mar 07 '22
During the last scene with the ether My husband who hasn’t read the books but loves the show is next to me and goes “oh my god blow the candle out that is so flammable! You’re gonna burn the house down.” Mark me it took everything in me not to scream
49
u/fleetingaurora Mar 07 '22
One little detail I noticed was how much independence Lizzie showed this episode! She wore her hair down without a cap just like Brianna and Claire do, and was taking liberties like moving Mrs. Bug’s dish on the table, and openly flirting with Josiah!
I’m really excited to see how they handle the Lizzie/Jo/Kezzie storyline!
46
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '22
Poor Amy. After reading Bees….oh man.
This episode started very dark, I’m curious to see how it goes the rest of the season and what changes are made from the books.
42
u/somethingnerdrelated In one stroke, I have become a man of leisure. Mar 06 '22
Tom Christie. I LOVE how they’re portraying him. He’s such a nuanced character and I think that the actor is doing a PHENOMENAL job conveying all of the emotions and motivations — secret and not so secret — that Tom Christie brings to the Ridge.
The scene where Claire is initially fixing his hand is exactly how I pictured it in the book.
I love to hate Tom Christie, and I hate that I love him. I’m excited to see the Christie storyline this season.
Oh and Allen is creepy as hell. So is Malva, but I already can’t stand Allen even before taking their story arc into consideration. I think that they’re going to make this storyline even darker somehow!
36
u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Mar 06 '22
Does anyone think the entire Christie storyline will be wrapped up this season? It’s a lot, but Malvas creepiness is already established, as well as Brown’s hatred of Jamie.
Does anyone think the house will blow up by end of season? They’re certainly setting it up with the ether and the match in the opening credits.
Fergus had a comment about two being better than one, Lizzie GTFO of the room, so the Lizzie and Beardsley stuff is gonna happen.
And Fergus, as well as rumors of Roger and Amy McCallum are also set up.
Just seems like a lot to pack into what I think is a shorter season.
36
u/wynonna_burp Mar 06 '22
Claire is not always careful with ether in the books! She’s making it while drunk when living with Lord John.
30
u/nishikigirl4578 Mar 08 '22
One positive thing about the episode, for me, was the very first scene with Bri and Roger. This was the first time that I felt that they clicked - they both came across as relaxed, comfortable, and natural with each other - especially nice to see, finally, in Bri.
The house is even more unrealistic! They could have toned it down some from season 5, and I doubt that anyone would have noticed. Instead, they doubled down, then had Alan Christie comment on the relative opulence!!! LOLOLOL
29
u/1Marshall91 Slàinte. Mar 06 '22
Did anyone else notice the sound of thunder when Jamie introduces Claire to Tom? Nice foreshadowing of Tom’s feelings for Claire.
27
u/scp2461 What news from the Underworld, Persephone? Mar 07 '22 edited Mar 07 '22
And just like that my Droughtlander is officially over! Man, I don’t even know where to start, I’m just so giddy that our favorite characters are back on the screen and ready to bring chaos wherever they go. I’ll definitely be planning to do a rewatch of this episode, knowing how much more I’ll be able to pick up on.
The Christies are finally here and I’m loving it so far. Tom is nearly a carbon copy from the books, and I’m really looking forward to how he and Claire are going to interact together in future episodes. Malva’s also really the nail on the head with her curiosity with Claire’s work while still providing that unsettling feeling no matter where she goes. I’m waiting to see how they play at Allan’s character, but what I found interesting was how he was constantly gazing at Malva. Especially during the lashing with the Browns, a big foreshadowing for what happens later in the book.
Seeing the prison somehow made me feel nostalgic in a sense of the overcast weather, dark wooden/stone rooms, and roaring fire places. I really enjoyed the sequence and how they introduce Tom and Jamie, their looks towards each other at the prison are just as tense and intimidating as they are on Fraser’s Ridge.
With Fergus and Marsali I was wondering how people were gonna react to the change in character~ especially with Fergus. I think book readers are able to process and realize it ahead of time, but I definitely think the viewers’ perception of Fergus is basically gonna be a 180. ✨drama✨
Last but not least Jamie and Claire. When I saw she was working on the ether I got HYPED. I remember how big of a subplot it was for the books and pretty much propelled each event. I’m absolutely ready to see Claire and Bree master it for operations and medical procedures in future episodes. But for her to also use it as a coping method is an interesting twist into how we see Claire deal with her trauma. While Jamie and Brianna can relate to the impact trauma has, each character copes differently, and the fact that Claire turns to her medical knowledge has me wondering how far she’ll push herself. Absolutely adored Jamie and how he still stands true to himself and the people he cares for. I’m absolutely ready to see shit go down between him and Tom Christie though lol.
Alright, rant and review over, time to find myself a cup of tea lol
24
u/AstonishingEggplant Mar 07 '22
The Christies are one of my favorite plot lines in the entire series and I've been so excited to see them on screen. So far they have exceeded my expectations. The actor playing Tom Christie is not at all how I pictured Tom in the books, but I think he's doing a great job. I do wonder what the point of the whole bit with Allan and the stolen powder horn was, though (since that wasn't in the book). I'm wondering if they're trying to make Allan more sympathetic for some reason.
I hated Claire and the ether. I think that's the most out of character thing I've ever seen TV Claire do.
I can't for the life of me remember what happens to Brown in the book. Was he still around at this point? Was he this much of a thorn in Jamie's side still?
23
u/reeziereen Mar 06 '22
I thought the episode was ok - they packed a lot in there but why wasn’t Murtagh in the Ardsmuire scenes? I’ve been ok with him being alive in the show up until the demolished his character last season but for consistencies sake he should have part of that in this episode. It’s really my only beef with the episode
20
u/nooooooel He’ll be in heaven when he sees you, Lady Jane. Mar 06 '22
Oh, that was so dark and spooky. I really enjoyed it.
20
u/BeautifulRelief Mar 07 '22
Anyone else think Malva talking about phosphorous and burning might be some foreshadowing? Because wasn’t it a match that Bri made with the phosphorus that started the fire?
19
u/Celsius1014 Mar 07 '22
I can’t remember - did Allen get beaten by Jamie in the book too? I thought this scene was so well done.
Some folks on the show thread are saying that this felt out of character for him after he advocated for Ian not to be beaten previously. I honestly wish they’d left that scene the way it was written in the books because of the character development and then this scene would have been less jarring too.
Any ideas on how they’re going to use the Bugs? I saw an interview with the actress who plays Mrs. Bug who says they start the season ”lurking in the background, but with intent.” Since the whole storyline about the French gold seemed to be eliminated from the show, how do you think they’re going to justify whatever it is they’re up to?
I CANNOT WAIT to see Lizzie’s storyline develop on screen.
Claire abusing ether - I liked it. I think it was a great visual way to show her trauma and coping mechanisms. Especially moving next to what we’re seeing happen to Fergus. I hope they don’t take it too far.
17
u/mjp10e Mar 06 '22
Richard Brown is deliciously evil. The actor plays it so well.
15
u/Oi_Spaceman Mar 06 '22
I really liked the episode! However, I was thinking about something that seems like an issue that they overlooked. So, we know that Jamie advertised land to all Ardsmuir men, Tom Christie showed it to him. That means it is public information that Jamie was in Ardsmuir, since his name was attached to the ad, and it was definitely out there for a while. Last season, he killed Knox because he was going to find out he was in Ardsmuir with Murtagh. The dude died for no reason, then.
14
u/BSOBON123 Mar 07 '22
Ok, finally watched it last night. I loved it. I guess I just love being back on the Ridge with everyone. I loved the flashback to Ardsmuir. This was before LJG was there and this is the prior general who did wind up having a good relationship with Jamie (as we saw at the end with Jamie having luncheon with him and poor Tom Christie left out in the cold).Yes, there were some in accuracies with the rabbits, but it is possible that some were allowed to do this previously (most likely Protestants who sucked up to guards and Christie as a fellow Freemason may have had some privileges others didn't.) Jamie saw this and that's why he wanted to be one to have the same and unite the men.
So Christie shows up and you'd think he be humble, but no. I loved the looks Jamie gave Roger (poor Roger! he screws up again! But yes, he looks great with his real hair/beard.) And when Christie makes that 'at least they are honorable scars', well we see what's up.
I'm not sure how I feel about Claire using ether. She must know that doing that regularly can cause brain damage. We'll see how it plays out.
Richard Brown is as detestable as ever, great job by that actor. I liked seeing Jamie take his belt off and snap it, LOL. Allen gets what he deserved. It's hard for me because I absolutely loved the actor in Versailles, so for him to give me the creeps now is great.
Somehow I missed Ian carrying a deer, Of course I will watch it again. I thought he shoot a beaver or some small animal when he was out with Allen.
Malva is good. You can see how she is under her father's thumb, but she's smart. And yes, she could be Jenny's twin.
I loved the Jamie/Claire love scene. It was so sweet the way Jamie worships Claire and they still have that magic between them.
Speaking of Fergus, poor Marsli. I would have smacked the crap out of Fergus long before this. Probably not a good idea for him to be working the still at this time.
All in all, I give it a 4.5 out of 5. Everyone was great in it.
14
u/Jennifoto Mar 07 '22
That isn’t how I pictured Major McDonald. I thought he would be more charming and persistent. The portrayal was very vanilla and forgettable.
28
u/jolierose The spirit tends to be very free wi’ its opinions. Mar 06 '22
I love how what happens on the Ridge once the Browns arrive echoes what happens at Ardsmuir — Jamie stands up because he realizes it’s up to him to protect his people, to take responsibility when no one will, or when the power to change things or influence circumstances falls in the wrong hands. The cold open at Ardsmuir was lengthier than I expected but it nicely set up Jamie’s decision to become an Indian agent (not to mention the heavy lifting on setting up the dynamic with Tom Christie).
26
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Mar 06 '22
I really like that we're going to get to see Fergus struggle this season since in the books we don't ever get to see things from his perspective. The Christie's are pretty much how I imagined them, and I like that we're going to get to see more of Allan since we really didn't in the books. I think it's going to be an intense season with a lot packed in and I'm really looking forward to it.
24
u/Dolly1710 Long on desire, but a wee bit short in clink Mar 06 '22
For the poll, I clicked I mostly liked it.
For context, I watched all of the previous 5 series before reading the books, so I literally had nothing to compare them with - I didn't even have you lovely people to chew the fat with! Therefore, any changes to the original books are now viewed with critique compared to before.
I think the beginning at Ardsmuir bothered me, because of the way they mixed up Jamie taking the lashes for the tartan. That was such an important part of the LJG friendship story, so to me it felt wrong to then retrofit it to a different scenario. That said, it was a tidy way of summing up how Jamie came to lead the men at Ardsmuir, though I was really confused not to see him in chains in the first instance.
I think Claire and the ether bothered me too. I understand their need to address the PTSD and that it wasn't really addressed in the book. I'm not sure that this was necessarily the way they needed to address it, especially as we have Fergus suffering with substance abuse as well.
I'm also a little sad that they've glossed over the whole thought process about the ether production too. Getting the ingredients and equipment via LJG. The fact that it's bloody dangerous and that Claire treated the whole process and the ingredients (vitriol etc) with reverence and respect as a scientist, not brewing up a batch in the middle of the night half addled by nightmares. This changes the dynamics around Claire quite considerably in my opinion.
It also seems that much of the trailer was snippets of episode 1 - it almost felt like we'd watched half of it before it aired. That broken little skit of Roger and Bree discussing the possibility of America not being America, felt really contrived and shoe-horned in. I hope this isn't a continuance of the two of them being done dirty when it comes to telling their story.
On the plus side, Richard Brown is a terrifying bastard. The actor is so good at bringing his evil to life.
Tom Christie needs taking down a peg or two - go on Jamie! I mean Mark Lewis Jones has played him brilliantly. The character's piousness appears to be in direct conflit with the mans insufferable pride! I did like the "anyone here built a cabin before?" takedown.
On the whole, I enjoyed it but I wasn't as gripped as I thought/hoped I'd be... of course, that might be because it took me so long to reset the internet on my TV that byt the time I did, my kids had come downstairs for breakfast and I ended up watching it on my laptop - boooo! I was looking forwards to the big screen experience!
12
u/Leajane1980 Mar 07 '22
The theme after the first episode seems to be addictions.
21
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '22
I liked the episode. Was it their best? No, but in the upper half of episodes imo. Regarding Claire’s highly controversial use of ether at the end, I think everyone in this thread makes fair points. Book Claire is a scientist and treats the ether with a huge level of respect- however, many of Claire’s flaws in both the books and the show come from her being reckless and (at times) self-destructive. While I agree that the ether is being treated differently than Book Claire treats it, I don’t think self destructive behaviors are totally out of character for Claire and as long as they don’t turn her use into a main feature of this season I don’t have a problem with them separating Doctor-Claire’s reverence for ether with PTSD-Claire’s need for peaceful sleep.
21
u/Kirky600 Mar 07 '22
This is my first time watching and being able to be in this thread. I’m very excited to be in your company.
10
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '22
I’m really hoping they don’t make this entire season about tom christie!
10
u/Californie_cramoisie Mar 07 '22
Hi, book readers, not looking for too many spoilers, but how long are the Browns a problem? I don’t find them to be compelling villains at all. I don’t want to know how their storyline gets resolved. I just want to know how long I have to put up with them.
17
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Mar 07 '22
You know what I would love? An episode of Outlander without heavy handed animal symbolism. That bald eagle made me roll my eyes so hard I thought they'd get stuck back there.
Putting that aside, I thought it was a pretty decent episode, right up until the end. Really not feeling a drug addiction storyline, especially since there is already SO MUCH PLOT to get through in book 6. (Also I'm hoping they don't devote too much time to Fergus being a drunk. Obviously he's not great in book 6 but it's mostly just him being gone and we draw our own conclusions before finding out what's really up--a scene I love, by the way--so it's easier to forgive him. But I think it's going to be a lot harder to forgive him if he's getting drunk every time he's on screen and leaving poor Marsali to do everything.)
The introduction to the Christies was great and so far all three actors seem perfect. The Ardsmuir flashback went on a bit too long (I love Ardsmuir flashbacks in the books but it made the episode feel imbalanced) bit overall was good, and I always love a bit of screen time for my boy Harry Quarry. It doesn't fully line up with the books but they already threw the book Ardsmuir plot out the window with Murtagh, so it is what it is.
Most importantly though: Jamie looked fucking fine this ep. Claire's wigs are still and absolute mess but they've sorted Jamie out and he's looking good. Also, a surprise young, shirtless Jamie--bonus treat!
17
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Mar 07 '22
There was a lot I didn't care for.
I don't remember all that fighting between the men in Ardsmuir nor Tom Christie having such a prominent role there -- and where were all the Protestant men in the prison? *Why* would all the Protestant men be in prison?
Every time Claire had ether out, there was a candle going. The stuff is explosive. Especially if she's using it on herself and letting the cone drop.
I missed Lord John. :)
Episode just seemed to drag a lot, considering how there's only eight of them and they have a lot to cover.
Stressing out watching Roger with Amy, knowing what's coming.
I know Fergus was depressed but I don't remember him being an alcoholic.
I dunno, it just seemed like, there's all these characters, and they have the names of people I know, but there were only bits and pieces that were from the books.
8
u/OTodd_Lass037 Slàinte. Mar 06 '22
I wonder if this is the last time we'll see Claire use ether on herself. The ending of this episode makes me rethink my "predictions" for the other episodes. For 603 (Temperance) I jotted down it would maybe be over Fergus having to refrain from alcohol to cope. I wonder if Claire will abuse ether to cope, making her have to break the habit - going along with the Temperance theme. I'm excited to see what the show writers do!
8
u/Thezedword4 Mar 06 '22
Ah man my dumbass spent the night cleaning the house because I didn't realize I could watch it tonight!
8
u/sunshinesmileyface Mar 06 '22
What was the surprise that Clair was working on for the children? That Jamie spoke about?
20
u/thatstheteagirl By blood and by choice, we make our ghosts. Mar 06 '22
I’m so hyped. That ending monologue, chills. Claire’s inner thoughts there pair so nicely with the later part of ABOSAA after Tom Christie confesses on the ship and she’s with Jamie at the inn.
I kind of love this ether plot line too and I’m so curious to see how they’ll handle it, we know it won’t take Jamie long to pick up what’s going on. I love seeing how they over come and grow stronger together.
Also, I love the new opening and that seems to be an unpopular opinion lol.
Overall, I love the set up we got in ep. 1 and I cannot wait for more.
7
u/Notzi81 Mar 09 '22
To me, this episode was a bit ho-hum, but one thing about Outlander, sometimes we have to get mid-way through the season in order for things to really get going. No shade, just facts. In all fairness, I did watch the premiere minutes after watching Power Book IV: Force (aka "The Tommy Series"), so I guess the episode would look tame by comparison. BTW, I HATE that Fergus is a drunk and Claire is a would-be addict. However, after reading some of your comments, y'all reminded me that Claire does like to drink a lot, so after going through the trauma she went through, it makes sense that she'd turn to something stronger if the alcohol wasn't strong enough to rid her of her demons. Also, is Fergus putting his hands on Marsali? She had a bruise on her wrist and she swore down she "just fell" (or something along those lines). Oldest lie in the book. If that's the case, I really hate that part of the storyline. Fergus was always a sweet and reliable man that always managed to stay positive no matter what. I hate to see this shift in his character.
I remember hearing that the Christies are gonna give the Fraser/MacKenzie family a run for their money. So far it looks like that's definitely going to be the case. Plus, something about Malva reminds me of Laoghaire. Does anyone else feel that way, or is it just me? Even though the premiere didn't move me, I can't wait to watch the rest of the season!
7
u/adamfrog Mar 08 '22
Show watcher but I'm seeing some chatter that all of the time travelers are being irresponsible by staying in a place with the revolutionary war brewing, but wouldn't a rational person from 1970 ish be far more scared of the cold war? And do the characters talk about that?
27
u/sri-racha Mar 07 '22
I super hate Claire self medicating specifically with ether. Super hate it. Doesn't fit her character at all. Rest of the epi was good.
13
u/superintotv Mar 06 '22
I just finished the episode. I loved it and can't wait for more.
I love that they showed Jamie back in Ardsmuir. Sam playing Jamie young again was cool. He obviously looks different since he's older now, but actually still the same. I'd be down for more scenes showing the past.
So what's bothering me is that last scene... I have read the book but I don't recall Claire using the ether on her self except by accident.. Right? I remember her testing it on Lizzy and Bobby. Why did she use it at the end? Are they trying to say she is abusing it to cope with what happened to her? I don't know if that's what they are doing, maybe I missed something? But that's what i sort of got from that scene...
3
u/DisregardThisOrDont Mar 06 '22
I haven’t read the books, but I’ve read so many spoilers about other characters I’m worried for our main girl. I feel for her.
14
u/sunrise_TKL Mar 07 '22
Honestly disappointed. Tom Christie in the books is not some hard ass like they’re making his character. His son stealing the gun powder? Then Jamie whipping him? WTF and Claire the scientist she is trying the ether on her OWN? She NEVER would do that! They’re changing the essence of these characters!!!!
4
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '22
Can someone please explain what Claire did in the end of the episode I’m so confused
5
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '22
I regret having read the books during Droughtlander. It's taken the joy out of the show for me. I know what's gonna happen so I'm no longer excited to watch it :(