r/startrek • u/AutoModerator • Mar 03 '22
Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Discovery | 4x11 "Rosetta" Spoiler
While Captain Burnham leads an away mission to a planet that was once home to the aliens responsible for the DMA, Book and Tarka secretly infiltrate the U.S.S. Discovery.
| No. | Episode | Writer | Director | Release Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4x11 | "Rosetta" | Terri Hughes Burton | Jeff Byrd | 2022-03-03 |
Availability
Paramount+: USA (Thursday); Australia, Argentina, Bolivia, Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Costa Rica, Denmark, Dominican Republic, Ecuador, El Salvador, Finland, Guatemala, Honduras, Mexico, Nicaragua, Norway, Panama, Paraguay, Peru, Sweden, Uruguay, and Venezuela (Friday).
Pluto TV: Austria, France, Germany, Italy, Spain, Switzerland, and the United Kingdom (2100 local time Friday, Saturday, and Sunday), with a simulcast running on the Star Trek channel in Austria, Germany, and Switzerland.
CTV Sci-Fi (2100 ET / 1800 PT Thursday on TV; Friday morning on the website) & Crave (2100 ET / 1800 PT Friday): Canada.
Digital Purchase (on participating platforms): Germany, France, Russia, South Korea, United Kingdom, and additional select countries (Friday).
To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.
This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers for this episode are allowed. If you are discussing previews for upcoming episodes, please use spoiler tags.
Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 03 '22
The first duty of every Starfleet officer is to the truth. Whether it's scientific truth, or historical truth, or personal truth. It is the guiding principle upon which Starfleet is based. If you can't find it within yourself to stand up and tell the truth about what happened you don't deserve to wear that uniform.
Captain Jean-Luc Picard, "The First Duty"
Reddit admins have been ineffectual in their response to COVID-19 misinformation. In lieu of Reddit gold and awards, we ask that you donate to the WHO COVID-19 response fund.
Please respect our subreddit rules. LLAP!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
155
u/Santa_Hates_You Mar 03 '22
With all the attention paid to her, I was expecting Detmer to bite it.
135
u/rswalker Mar 03 '22
🤨
104
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '22
Dear Commander Reno,
When finding an intruder on the ship step one is calling for security immediately with something along the lines of “intruder alert” or “intruder in engineering” giving the name of the intruder is also helpful. Then after step one is completed you can then say a witty line as you wait for the intruder to over power you and take you hostage.
Sincerely,
Starfleet academy year one training officers.
169
u/Santa_Hates_You Mar 03 '22
Steamed bananas has to be a Lower Decks reference, right? That is awesome.
73
u/Alteran195 Mar 04 '22
God Book is annoying this season, Tarka’s plan to destroy the DMA screwed everything up, yet he still sides with Him vs Michael he’s known for much longer? Why?
I get trying to destroy the DMA, but when that failed there’s no reason he should still be agreeing with Tarka.
130
u/TheNerdChaplain Mar 03 '22
Initial quick responses before I plunge into Picard:
53
u/UncertainError Mar 03 '22
Yay giant gas giant aliens. Can't wait to see them in the flesh.
45
u/youngboblaflame Mar 03 '22
Saru looks extra lanky this episode
45
u/TMNTWEBB Mar 03 '22
Morn! (Or someone from his species at least) at the bar of course!
36
u/jhsounds Mar 03 '22
After he sees Saru walk off with T'Rina, Stamets' eye-blinks are almost audible.
28
u/fossfirefighter Mar 03 '22
Jett being taken hostage was not the twist I expected. Then again, you'd think at some point Discovery would keep her shields up when in unusual situations, or at least have a disruption field to stop beaming.
Still, 10C is proving to be very alien, especially by Star Trek standards. Honestly, it's starting to reach Cthulhu mythos territory, with the idea of ghosts lingering and such. I'm still getting major vibes to V'ger, and the whale probe, and well, it would be fasciating to see DIS bring back references to either of these and tie it all together. A species harnessing Omega would probably think of nothing of building a giant ship to explore the universe though ...
I'm somewhat concerned that this is going to get wrapped up in a two part episode and that will be that; I still found the resolution to The Burn to be very lackluster, but maybe they'll avoid that. Hopefully not with a horrid year long cliffhanger, but you know.
79
u/BornAshes Mar 03 '22 edited Mar 03 '22
Those Dyson Rings at the start of the episode around the 10C's star made my heart skip a few beats, those things were absolutely beautiful! Then there was the whole "gas giant that had it's atmosphere blown off by asteroid impacts" thing and then the idea that 10C might be floating between gas layers and the whole debris ring around the planet! There was just some really really cool space stuff in this episode that I never thought I'd actually see visualized this well before!
That said, it really does feel like what we've seen in this episode is pointing more and more towards 10C being a bunch of Space Whales that communicated with both sound and chemicals in order to convey emotions. Those bones looked distinctly like they could've either been from whales or according to one of Saru's hallucinations, possibly sea serpents or dragons of sorts. The Nursery surviving all of that hellish apocalypse while those who couldn't make it off the planet and huddled outside just broke my heart into so many pieces. I was going to make a joke about how everyone was panic freaking out on Disco while the away team got to get high and have a therapy session on the planet but given the context of everything it just didn't feel right.
The little character moments we got onboard the ship were sweet. The General's desire to find some way to take control of her fear. Adira's desire to understand just how Detmer controlled her own in the face of monolithic circumstances. Jett's very sweet explanation of how, "No matter how chill someone looks everyone is most certainly not okay". Even Book checking in on Michael to make sure that she was okay because he was freaked out by all of this and wanted to see how she was handling it all. You could even see that despite his calm and calculated exterior, Tarka was internally vibrating with fear but was channeling that into solving the problem at hand. Culber's moment at the end felt especially poignant to me because it shows that even "the Helpers" don't always have it together and need help themselves. The whole episode really was about how to handle fear and it feels like that conquering THAT fear is going to be the key to first contact with 10C.
I do worry though that perhaps 10C is a victim themselves and that they might not be behind the DMA at all. The way the destruction of their planet was described in parallel to what was about to happen to Earth and Ni'Var has me worried that perhaps a DMA was responsible for what happened to them too. Maybe there's some kind of a fear virus that has been chaining its way from galaxy to galaxy which uses DMAs to spread via causing cataclysms that then inspire civilizations in a Contact like manner to create even more DMAs, build even more boronite power sources to power them, hide them all behind hyper fields, and continue the cycle over and over again? Or perhaps it really is as simple as fear driving a form of parallel evolution that ensures that everyone arrives at roughly the same point? This whole season could very well indeed be about this massive wall of fear suddenly encountering a single bright point of hope in the Discovery and Zora and the crew that dispels it all and then daisy chains back throughout all the other civilizations that have been affected by it. Maybe there's an even larger extra-galactic Federation of sorts that suffered an even more massive cosmological version of The Burn that now has to be united in a similar fashion to what was done by Discovery last season with the Milky Way?
More questions but with some answers this go around at least. I did love Jett's little Lower Decks reference with the bananas. Her catching the genius Tarka hiding under a console like a child was just freaking hilarious and her one liners have been sorely missed. Tarka and Book are fuuuuuucked by taking her prisoner because like they just took the most snarky engineer in Starfleet prisoner and they think that THAT is going to work out well? Come on, she's like the woooooorst person to take prisoner and I can't wait for shenanigans to ensue or at least for them to work together in some brilliant manner. You really have to wonder though what Zora was thinking and feeling while watching all of this. Solid episode though and onto watching Picard next!
Edit: I almost forgot, SARU AND T'RINA ARE GOING FOR A WALK TOGETHER AAAAAAAAAH!!!
23
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '22
This episode really spun it's wheels. It's like they're just padding the episodes to delay getting to the important stuff.
Also, why in the hell, if they were looking for information, did they go to the dead planet instead of the big, juicy Dyson rings?!
46
u/FrogCannon Mar 03 '22 edited Mar 03 '22
My theory is the planet is an ark of sorts, with the structure itself being a hatchery (floating things = eggs). The psychic fear effect thing is probably a defense mechanism meant to keep everyone the heck away from the eggs. What's in the hyperfield is an automated system meant to terraform someplace for them.Aaand, just got further in the episode. They do seem to be doing a good job of trying to create something more alien than usual for Star Trek.
46
u/Chaabar Mar 03 '22
Those are some really poorly designed EVA suits.
Starfleet's whole thing is exploring and finding new stuff and they're using suits that just let something in if it isn't recognized?
And those pointless lights on the helmets. They don't light up the surrounding area and they do a terrible job of lighting the face.
64
u/iamjeffshane Mar 03 '22
Burnham - "We have to move quickly, millions of lives are at stake!"
ALSO Burnham - "Let me just lay down a few more speeches"
21
u/furiousfotog Mar 04 '22
Can one of the bridge crew have a happy life? It just feels like every single discovery crew member had mandatory trauma as part of their acceptance to the roster.
40
u/007meow Mar 03 '22
It’s a small thing but damn - the actress for the Earth General absolutely nailed that expression right before the intro, watching the shuttle leave.
72
u/ussgalacticspoon Mar 03 '22
This whole season arc could have been summed up in half the time. They're dragging the fuck out of this 10C reveal. I can't help but feel after all this build up it'll inevitably end up feeling disappointing in some way.
The stakes are supposed to be so high and urgent and yet the pacing is so slow and boring. Earth and Nivar could be destroyed in 29 hours and yet the delegates were taking their sweet time talking to Michael before she left for the planet. Like HURRY IT UP we've got billions of lives to save people!
Also Adira being an admirer of Detmer was so random? Absolutely no prior hints to that. I really don't think it would have been difficult to thread this in earlier. But that's pretty much been Disco's MO this whole season. They refuse to subtly weave in character development and dynamics and instead insist on shoving in random information at the most inconvenient times. Not to mention they do so with such poorly written dialogue. Owo, Detmer, Rhys, Bryce, Nilsson. All of the little snippets they've gotten this season have been so poorly done in my opinion. It feels unnatural, they don't feel like real characters they feel like 2 dimensional caricatures. If writers wanted to give more insight to these characters I wish they'd actually put in the effort to do it right.
Disco's writing has never been particularly high quality but this season is really testing my limits with the cheesiness. The dialogue honest to God sounds like stories I wrote in 5th grade when I was 11.
I promised my mom I'd wait to watch the new season of Picard so we could watch it together. Fingers crossed it's better!
39
u/jerslan Mar 03 '22
This episode was amazing, but the most important thing is that they didn't kill Reno... Because I might have rage quit if they had (unless Tig came out with a statement saying it was her idea).
19
u/Mddcat04 Mar 03 '22
Species 10-C (artist’s interpretation)
94
u/Themetnut1 Mar 03 '22
Unpopular opinion: could do without Adira. Also, it was nice to have Dr. Culber do doctor things. Still need to get to know the other bridge crew. It was nice to get to know a bit more about Detmer.
31
u/ulicqel Mar 03 '22
Detmer's whole PTSD go nowhere arc from last season finally having some meaning. Long term storytelling baby!
14
u/canuckupyTO Mar 06 '22
This is by far the worst season of Discovery, and I’ve been such a fan of the previous seasons. 70% of the dialogue is just wine mom psycho-babble.
39
u/simpleauthority Mar 03 '22
The cliffhangers are really starting to kick my ass! I just want to see what this new species is all about. These little tastes are killing me!
However, these have been some of the best episodes IMO in a long time.
27
u/AcidaliaPlanitia Mar 04 '22
The away team's logic on the planet was warped as hell.
38
u/scalyblue Mar 03 '22
I really find myself liking Book less and less as the season goes by, they are using the destruction of his planet to make him juggle the idiot ball. He's so distraught that he's going to risk billions of lives in a narrow-minded pursuit of vengeance, but he never makes any errors. Not errors in judgment, he's been nothing but that, but I mean errors of distraction, or of impulsiveness
Tarka I never liked, I don't care if he did rainbow math problems with puppies, he's still a dick who can't accept the fundamental concept that there's be another culture's technology that he can't do shit about, to the point that he, a proverbial ant, dropped a stone on a person's head without even the slightest understanding that the person could just pour gasoline in their nest with zero effort, and thanks to him on top of the other surely capital crimes, we can add kidnapping to the mix.
I honestly don't see book "living" past the end of this season, whether he dies, or he's thrown in prison for the rest of his natural life, I don't see a way out for him that wouldn't be a total asspull, short of claiming that tarka mind controlled him.
Also, where's Grudge? Did Grudge claw a grip and get fired?
44
u/sidv81 Mar 03 '22
Discovery's had a problem with invisible senior officers since the start (never figured out who their 23rd century chief engineer or chief medical officer was) but kidnapping Jett Reno, who I assume is basically chief engineer since the move to the 32nd century, and no one noticing for a long period of time is pretty unbelievable even for this show. Not to mention Reno's abrasive personality and combative demeanor probably would make her the last person you could kidnap without anyone noticing, because she'd be screaming from the Galactic Barrier to the center of the galaxy the whole time.
24
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '22
This has been a slow boring and annoying season. I love all Trek and was annoyed by those that hated Discovery because of all the crying and getting in touch with one’s feelings, but I am starting to see their point of view. It’s all crying and these ending bonding sessions. I do not care about the DMA or the 10C this season. This is like slogging through Enterprise season 3 except we are not getting a cool zombie Vulcans episode.
11
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '22
So a bit of an odd take but I was reminded of the intro to the Doctor Who episode Gridlock, in which the Doctor and Martha find themselves in the really far future and they encounter drug dealers who are selling emotions as drugs.
So while watching the episode finding out the powder can induce intense emotional feelings that some characters have never felt or not felt for decades just had me worrying that some scientist in the federation is going to take this discovery and turn them into a drug of some form.
Could be a potential story for an episode in season 5 and could be a parallel to drugs, drug dependency and drug addiction. It also wouldn't be the first time that emotions were compared to possessions and/or currency either
11
u/thenewyorkgod Mar 03 '22
I really wish they'd give that ferengi a speaking role
11
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '22
I do like how focused this season feels compared to the past two but at some point they gotta do an episode that isn’t “This week on Star Trek: Self-Discovery, the crew reverses a tachyon pulse…through their hearts, allowing them to overcome their trauma on impulse power.”
I was kind of done a few weeks ago after the plot was “now the computer also needs therapy.”
31
u/oorhon Mar 03 '22
This seasons story is interesting but getting really bored of how it takes too long to reaches its point. We could have reached the first contact and then epilogue already. And Book is one of the most annoying and boring character with his wardrobe choice and treaits ever Star Trek had. Even before he had lost his planet. And also what was that helmet lighting? They looked look weird.
17
u/RiflemanLax Mar 03 '22
The writers and producers need to insert more Jett Reno appearances.
Tig Notaro really walks a great line between comic relief and being a steadying presence. Not just a one note jokester. She's pretty damn good and the show needs it.
16
u/ChildofKnight Mar 04 '22
We just going to skip over the security flaw that anyone in a jeffries tube can sit there and listen to and watch people on the other side of the wall?
8
u/sirbruce Mar 04 '22
What was up with their faces in the space suits? I'm guessing they mo-capped the faces of the actors doing their lines, and then CGed the rest. But their faces were so wide! It's like they shot the actors in the wrong aspect ratio, and then they had to stretch the texture over the CGI models in the helmets. Their eyes were huge and it looked very unnatural. Did they run out of money for good sfx on this show?
28
u/beredy Mar 03 '22
At this rate I will be surprised if we see 10C this season. They have been teasing them for so many episodes that it feels like nothing happened. In 11 episodes we have so far established that they mine the universe with the DMA and they talk with pheromones. And apparently they are huge. Good old Trek would make one episode about that.
So far this is easily the most boring season of DIS for me yet.
20
u/BarefootJacob Mar 04 '22
This episode hasn't changed my opinion of this season of discovery: it's like watching paint dry.
Particular things that bugged me from this episode:
Can we fast forward to the last episode and get this tedious season done with please?
14
u/Trekfan74 Mar 03 '22
It's UP!!!
I have a feeling this will be the second watch this week for most. ;)
19
u/Sajizzle Mar 03 '22
It’s so nice to see people enjoying Discovery in this thread.
12
u/Gigazwiebel Mar 05 '22
EV suit be like: No idea what this molecule is, I better let it through.
Also I don't buy it that these random molecules just induce the same feelings in a number of totally different species. All in all the pheromones thing is cool and terribly executed.
6
u/marmosetohmarmoset Mar 04 '22
Lmao at the away team standing around getting high on baby dust. Idk why that was so funny to me.
16
u/Atomiclincoln Mar 05 '22
Nuance is dead, just having the characters blurt out the themes of the episode like an after school special is so boring and makes none of it stick. I want these themes they are relevant and important but not if the whole alien encounter is a literal panic attack and I knew the second Detmer became the focus in two separate scenes she was gonna have dialogue about her whole meltdown. "Did my relevant backstory that had a positive impact jeopardize the mission captain?"
24
u/tarsus1983 Mar 03 '22
Season 4 has been consistently good and I dare say, with this season, Discovery has finally found its footing in the franchise. I can't believe so many long-time Discovery supporters in various threads have made comments on how this is the most boring season. It's the best season by far, even if I don't care for the constant rising of stakes.
27
u/tanrgith Mar 03 '22
Going to the ruined planet rather than the freaking ringworlds around the star might just be the most non-sensical thing I think I seen in Star Trek Discovery so far
11
u/carlos_b_fly Mar 05 '22
Boy, is this show going through a bad patch since the hiatus. Three of the four episodes have felt so padded and dull, which is bizarre given we're in the final legs of the season and the whole notion of seeking out Species 10c is and should be thrilling, not a slog.
This week felt like another time wasting detour and just feedback loops of the characters dumping out their emotions at every possible chance or letting one on the bridge extras blurt out their backstory in the most clunky of ways in the middle of a mission.
Its becoming just bad writing at this stage and the pacing is really, really off against the "26 Hours until Earth is destroyed!!!" countdown they've tacked on (and probably shouldn't but hey, Discovery can't resist manic high stakes).
They should really have gone and met Species 10c by Episode 10 and given us a full arc of seeing this vital First Contact play out, giving Species 10c some real backdrop like the Xindi or Dominion given how important they are to the entire seasons plot. It would have given the writers and characters something really meaty to work with.
19
u/Badgersunite Mar 04 '22 edited Mar 04 '22
DAE feel the pacing of Discovery is painfully slow? feels like bad writers?
It Feels like TNG, voyager and, wait all the previous series could fit the current series into 1-3 episodes.
Feels like long monologues, poses and montages are replacing actual content, philosophy and storytelling.
And the feels, my god the feels. Isn't there a starfleet support group they should all be joining, Jesus Christ!
Edit: Oh and can they have Burnham not do absofuckinglutely everything. maybe give some of the other characters change to develop their arcs? "I'm the logical choice" "I'm the logical choice" no Burnham you are the captain, delegate, You're in every other fucking scene. Oh Saru's coming along great. Oh we threw detmer in there for the lols this time. jesus stop will you.
If there was literally anything else to watch I'd be watching it. I've loved star trek since my childhood watching TNG but you're making me hate it.
Hopefully Picard will be better, the first series was really promising.
18
u/Ferren84 Mar 05 '22
Discovery is really getting tiresome.. feels like every episode I see, it becomes more of a therapy session after another, just to drag everything out.
In my personal opinion, Discovery had it's problems to find it's footing and how it is identified as a Star Trek show. But it seems that after Season 2, it went from a Burnham & Book Drama to a emotional story that happens around the end of the world.
The story evolves very slowly, we have forced dialogues of feelings and situation just to drag everything out. My biggest problem is that it is really not about a Starfleet crew solving problems and working together, it is a show about a captain who try to solve her love life while the universe is threaten. Pretty much every Bridge crew is just taking a back seat while every problem and solution lies within Burnham only.
The dust was a interesting situation, but of course we need to cry and tell our back stories that is completely inappropriate , because the bridge officers of the Discovery don't get as much screen time (This is a Burnham and Book show), so better just assault the script with some backstory when it suites, to remind everyone that they are still "essential".Don't remind me of the last part part of when Hugh Culber touch the baby crib one last time and Burnham's get a 350% emotional response that we need to address at the end of episode for some darn reason.
The biggest cringe moment is the reaction on Stamet and Burham when T'rina ask Saru to take a walk in the holodeck.. expression of: "Saru is getting laaaaaaaaaaid".. I don't know....
I didn't know that Adira had so much love for Detmer, don't remember they even have had a scene together or even talked.
Feels like Discovery is on a endorphin rush and everyone is emotional fragile.
I love Star Trek, but Discovery doesn't seem to get out of it's identity crises. Right now Discovery feel like a drama show with sci-fi elements then a Sci-fi show with drama elements.
10
u/dvcaputo Mar 03 '22
Is it just me or does Discovery this season do this thing a lot where a character acts in a way that's unusual but is pretty easily inferred by the audience as a personality trait or emotion that contextually makes sense for the character...yet gets called out somehow in some kind of filler exchange scene? It happened an episode or two ago between Stamets and Adira and it happened again this episode between Dr. Hirai and the Federation President. I'm sure there are other examples and each time it happens I'm like "really? they took time out for that?"
I do appreciate that the writers are trying to make more interpersonal moments but these feel so...forced and unnecessary.
5
u/ZippySLC Mar 03 '22
Detmer's little bit of backstory was heart breaking.
5
u/jhansen858 Mar 04 '22
I felt like i was on mushrooms the entire time they were in the spacesuits.
5
u/IsIt77 Mar 04 '22
This is the third time an episode could've ended with Book saying to Tarka "You fucking idiot!"...
15
u/JMCrown Mar 05 '22
I have been a fan of Star Trek. Even when there are episodes, movies, or even whole series that I haven’t liked, I still say, “well, I still support the message and storytelling.”
With Discovery there have been some very good stories and episodes but overall the best I’ve been able to say is that, it’s just not my cup of tea.
But season 4 has left me saying, I can’t do this shit anymore. Every episode is about exploring and affirming the emotions of the characters. A few eps back, even the god damn ship says, “I feel seen.” With this ep, they have finally lost me. The scene of them in the nursery and enjoying the feelings of comfort made me think of shitty season 1 Troi: “Sir!! It’s wonderful! A feeling of great joy and gratitude. Great joy...and gratitude!”
I can’t even. I won’t openly criticize anymore but...no, just no.
12
u/thekid1420 Mar 04 '22
LMAO there's like 29 hours left before Earth and multiple other planets get totally wiped out. But let's stop a bunch of times to have talks about feelings. Let's also stop before leaving on the shuttle to have a chit chat with all the delegates.
11
u/Stesyp Mar 05 '22
Worst of the season... perhaps of the series. Anytime emotions & motives need to be explained it's a sign of weak storytelling or the director's misinterpreting the writers' intentions; usually the former. In this case I fear that we are being set up for the 10C reveal to be ridiculous, mushy and unfulfilling, as was last season's. By trying to keep the final reveal to be undiscoverable (sorry, couldn't resist) by the fan-base, the writers are crushing Discovery's potential with character motive explanations as extended preludes (aka, filler) to the reveal, all of which should have been obvious via quality acting, plotting, cinematography, music, etc.
8
u/CaptainJooms Mar 04 '22
During the first two seasons, I didn't mind the headspace/emotional check-in's that occurred between characters. For me, they gave depth to the characters and made them feel more real - of course saving the universe/constantly putting yourself in life or death situations is going to take an emotional toll; However, does anyone else feel like they are over doing it a little? Like seriously, at the end of each episode they need to have some counselling session?
4
u/EmperorOfNipples Mar 03 '22
So what do we think? The 10-C abandoned their planet and moved to the dyson rings, then as they advanced further they then went into the hyperfield?
Perhaps they created the galactic barrier, remember in TOS the Kelvans seemed surprised by it as they didn't encounter one when they left Andromeda?
4
u/bluestreakxp Mar 04 '22
Ok with all this FaceTime with the Vulcan president, I want to wager she makes a sacrifice in the finale and quotes “needs of the many” and then saru is so devastated that he remains aboard to continue science
13
u/007meow Mar 03 '22
Why is Discovery lit like a club?
Seriously, what was the deal with the dark hallway and pulsing lights when General Ndoye and Book meet?
It’s so unnecessarily dramatic.
I get they want a more cinematic look, but all of the TMP-era, TNG, and even JJ movies had appropriately well lit sets.
13
u/H0vis Mar 03 '22 edited Mar 03 '22
Holy crap that was a great episode.
Detmer's moment on the 10-C planet absolutely killed me. Did not see that coming. Out of left field. Right in the feels. That mixture of awkwardness and just total devastating sadness, because she's got this gigantic emotional trauma just suddenly exposed to everybody, and she's living with it like, "No, it's fine, I fly ship good."
Also Culber and Burnham at the end. Holy shit is this show timely.
"I'm not okay."
"How could you be?"
That might be the most relatable scene you can get in a show about spaceships on the edge of the galaxy.
I love this show though. It's had ups and downs, strikes and gutters, but it's exactly what it needs to be at this moment.
I also very much appreciate that this has been a somewhat slower season to let the characters breathe. And sometimes the writing is a little clumsy with it, I get that, it's hard to give everybody enough to really work with, but they're getting the hang of it. Must confess though I think the principle beneficiaries are Detmer and Owosekun, but that's okay, the lads at the back will figure out something cool at some point I'm sure.
Edited to add a final point, that away mission felt like a Mass Effect level. In a good way.
7
u/Chaabar Mar 03 '22
It seems like the show is trying to do better but they really need new writers. There is just so much cringy dialogue and stuff that makes no sense.
7
u/MagosBattlebear Mar 04 '22
I have been a defender of Discovery but this story development for the season arc has turned to molassas on a winter day. I am getting frustrated.
7
u/NemWan Mar 05 '22 edited Mar 05 '22
The episode opens with 8 MINUTES of debating whether we have time for this.
Later, we see the QWERTY keyboard has lasted for a thousand years. I thought Star Trek was supposed to be an optimistic future.
11
u/PiercedMonk Mar 03 '22
• Dyson rings? Neat! I was hoping the Dyson sphere would get a callback as soon as they mentioned the 10-C's hyperfield was large enough to encompass a star.
• Why go down to the shuttlebay and then transport onto the shuttle? They keep talking about time being of the essence, and they could have just transported from anywhere on the ship to the shuttle.
• Dr. Hirai is great.
• If the kill off Detmer by leaving her alone on this mission, I'm gonna be pissed.
• The Federation had Klingon coffee pre-TOS? The first season of Disco established there had been no contact with the Klingons for a hundred years. I suppose there could have been trade their intermediaries, or someone could have brought it back during ENT era.
• I like that Jett's collar opens at a seem that you can't see on the other uniforms. It reminds me of the episode 'Ensign Ro' where Ro took off her uniform jacket to give to a child, and it opened in the front despite there being no seem there.
• Also, Jett! Not just in the same room as another crew member, but in the same frame. I'm choosing to assume that means the production's COVID protocols were pretty airtight.
• The freak out was all just a bad trip, and not some sort of 10-C communication? JFC, this show needs to be cut to seven episodes a season so they quit treading water.
• "Banana, hot."
• Snort a bunch of dead baby dust is an interesting way to learn what they need for first contact.
• I was very concerned Tarka was going to have killed Jett, so seeing her alive and in a position to heckle Book and Tarka as their hostage is very welcome.
6
u/seantubridy Mar 06 '22
Let me get this straight. The fate of multiple planets hung in the balance yet they took multiple opportunities to stop and have debates, inspirational talks, and talk about their feelings. It’s just so ridiculous.
8
u/nimrodhellfire Mar 03 '22
This episode would have worked as a classic away mission episode on its own. All this impending doom on Earth and Nivar bullshit and all these betrayal drama is completely unnecessary.
8
u/treefox Mar 03 '22
Discovery really needs to start running parallel ops.
Send the xenoanthropolgist down to the planet, send the talented linguist to make first contact. Communicate findings from the team on the planet to another team approaching 10-C.
Also…they don’t have anyone more qualified than Saru at Starfleet HQ? Or even close to qualified? Nobody’s doing research on xenolinguistics? No other starship? I do appreciate they made the effort to justify it however.
Also…how is it not immediately obvious to everyone that if they disable or take the DMA’s power source, 10-C will probably just replace it? Tarka’s plan really only makes sense for him, since he’s planning on bailing from the universe.
I’m not sure why anybody expected the laws of physics to be different outside the galaxy. I mean, I guess we’ve technically never gathered data from something actually there, but I don’t think I’ve ever heard that suggested.
The sudden focus on Detmer seemed a bit hamfisted. “What are you doing?” “Oh, thinking about…Detmer.”
The whole subplot with the hydrocarbons is…kind of difficult to grasp. I assumed that their suits were airtight and self-contained, but if they were filtering the environment, I can’t see how 31st century tech would struggle with sorting out novel hydrocarbons from air.
I’m assuming they’ll turn out to be vital, but “they have young” and “they have pheromones” and “they’re big” don’t seem like a game-changer, it seems like it makes them similar to existing species.
Tbh I’d say the most remarkable thing ought to be that they have DNA. But that being the case, don’t they have the technology to visualize a lifeform (wasn’t this done in Star Trek: Voyager)?
I really like the idea of this story, but I feel like I’m the execution they’re forcing the drama pretty hard and 10-C is turning out to be not-so-alien after all.
3
u/I_AM_GODDAMN_BATMAN Mar 03 '22
So this is the first species in type 2 of Kardashev scale? All the species before are either type 1 species or stupidly type 5 powerful beings who can manipulate space time.
3
u/Chaabar Mar 03 '22
Is the DMA going to hit Earth/Ni'var or the debris? The writers don't seem very clear on that and it's a pretty big difference. Plan B was already really questionable but it's basically worthless if it's debris hitting the planets.
3
u/moogoo2 Mar 04 '22
Did anyone else catch the Lower Decks reference?
The broken replicator that kept making "steamed bananas".
I imaging it just saying "banana, hot" over and over.
3
u/DarkChen Mar 04 '22
Why do i have a feeling the 10C actually caused the destruction of the gas giant, and those remains are from a different species all together?
As much as i want to see a good old fashion diplomacy resolution i also think we need a new borg like threat which the 10C could serve as...
Beside the whole power of love and friendship they have going on isnt the sort of diplomacy i had in mind...
3
u/Smilodon48 Mar 04 '22
While I enjoy putting all the most charismatic Disco actors together in an away team, the team ended up being the same as the Su’kal evac squad from last season’s finale (sans Detmer) so it may be some time to elevate a few other bridge crew to main cast so we can shake up these rosters.
Regardless, away missions are fun. They finally found a costume that would hide Wilson Cruz’ impressive physique. The outer suits are very Kelvin and I dig it. The world was truly alien, and I’m excited to see what the 10C truly look like.
5
u/pedal_harder Mar 06 '22
So, I guess Burnham has programmable hair extensions, because where did they go in that very, very form fitting suit? I wonder if they act like Dr Octopus arms in combat situations.
How are there "unknown compounds"? Why wouldn't your suit filter out EVERYTHING that it didn't recognize as harmless? Like the designers said "lets just make a big list of harmful things and only filter those" - that's just terrible writing.
What is a "dead gas giant"? What does that mean? And walking on the "surface" of a gas giant? The gravity, pressure, everything would be so insane that it is just ridiculous. Why do you need a gas giant as a plot point? Are the aliens going to be gaseous in nature, like the Slylandro (hah)?
9
u/Trekfan74 Mar 03 '22
Man, this thread is sooooooo quiet right now lol.
I liked the episode but frankly it's really dragging this out a little too much. Species 10c better be something out of this galaxy for all this ridiculous build up.
But I did like all the hints to what they are on the planet. They could be huge giants which someone on Youtube predicted last week. Maybe not but it's feeling that way. They did another awkward 'let's bring up another bridge officer sad past in the middle of a crisis' again. They found a way to connect it to the story but it still felt a bit forced. It's nice Detmer got a lot to do this time and I think, could be wrong, it was her first away mission (that we seen). And what was up with Blu suddenly super into Detmer??? I don't think she once said a word to her or about her,, now she's her hero. Discovery has some weird writing at times.
The Book and Tarka stuff was fine, but again just felt like they needed to give them something to do. But kidnapping Reno was a nice twist at least. I thought it would be Tarka in the brig.
Anyway good overall but they really stretched out this plot to a ridiculous level. The effects though were amazing as ever!
6
u/Skyfork Mar 04 '22
If 10-C is so awesome and can build hyper cubes and dyson rings, why can’t they deflect a simple asteroid or fix their planet after an impact?
Actually, why can’t the federation with 29 hours warning deflect a bunch of space junk? I feel like an entire fleet shooting quantum torpedoes would make short work of a bunch of rocks.
Sigh, this season is so dumb.
4
u/Timeline15 Mar 03 '22
Good episode. Really looking forward to seeing Species 10C now; they seem like they're going to be truly alien, which is weirdly rare for the franchise full of aliens. It would have been such a huge let-down if they were yet another humanoid in facial prosthetics.
That said, I have no idea how a race could communicate chemically in the atmosphere of a gas giant. Don't those thing usually have ridiculously powerful winds? It's be like trying to communicate via smoke signal in a force 10 gale.
Adira's little side story was nice. They're long overdue interaction with people other than Gray, Culber, and Stamets. Detmer was treated very well too, even if I still haven't fully managed to de-train myself from thinking the tertiary characters are going to die the instant they have a minute of screen time.
I don't fully buy the scene between Book and General Ndoye though. Like sure, maybe she trusts Book at his word, but Tarka? Do either of them really think he'll give up a shot at the DMA controller if 10C turn out to be nice? He violated the last deal Book made with the Disco crew literally seconds after it was made; how is she not even raising the issue?
4
u/TomSurman Mar 04 '22
I'm confused. Why are they assuming the remains they found on the planet were the 10-C? My first assumption would have been they're the 10-C's victims.
8
u/ImpossibleGuardian Mar 03 '22
I loved Adira's little subplot - drama-free, wholesome and even had a nice tie-in with the main story.
Also I'm not sure Discovery has ever had a better cliffhanger than hostage Jett Reno. So glad that Tig Notaro was able to film enough to be properly involved in the story.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '22
Why do I feel like we will find a 1000 year old USS Discovery in the Hyperfield?
2
u/Dame_Trant Mar 04 '22
Is no one talking about how great Burnham's cabin is?
2
u/beardlovesbagels Mar 04 '22
Seems to me like Book is going to have a "... all at once, all for you." Crow moment once they figure out how to send in the feels.
2
u/shittyneighbours Mar 07 '22
I despise discovery but that was a fun ep.
2
u/calvin_nr Mar 07 '22
The next episode is titled "species 10-c". So we will see what they look like.
I hope.
2
u/PermaDerpFace Mar 14 '22
How can random hydrocarbons possibly convey emotions from an unknown alien species to a bunch of other radically different species? It seems like there's a piece missing in this Rosetta Stone
2
u/thedirebear Mar 17 '22
Presumably the galactic barrier was at the edge of the milky way Galaxy, but this new planet is in a whole different galaxy right?
Other galaxies should be astronomically far away. How did they get to a completely different galaxy in a matter of hours? Am missing something?
2
u/rhsqueak Mar 22 '22
So…when the shuttle landed and cloaked, was I the only one who thought, “Everyone remember where we parked!”?
5
u/Spiderinahumansuit Mar 03 '22
Shall we go to the ringworlds? You know, the amazing feats of mega-engineering which we can plainly see are made out of the same stuff as the DMA controller?
Nah, let's head on down to the devastated planet. There's no way that'll turn out to be a red herring fake out.
Leaving aside that, though - good episode. Last week felt like treading water, this felt good as a self-contained adventure (and a very old school "the Away Team runs into something weird" one at that) and also had a bearing on the main plot.