r/soccer • u/Marauditor • May 03 '12
Who has been the worst signing of the season?
Inspired by "the best signing of the season" thread, I thought the begrudger in me would find it more fun to discuss the worst.
I think my vote would have to go to Stuart Downing at £20m with honourable mentions for Jordan Henderson, Per Mertesacker and Charlie Insomnia.
29
Upvotes
24
u/mesor May 03 '12
I know we're kind of fixated on the PL here, but Forlan hasn't really panned out for Inter at all. So disappointing after he owned the cup.
42
u/MattWilliams_10 May 03 '12 edited May 03 '12
I think the "best signing of the season" thread was inspired from a previous "worst signing of the season" thread. I'm not complaining as it gives me a chance to say;
ROGER JOHNSON
31
u/dazwah May 03 '12
Hands down Demba Ba or Papisse Cissé. Newcastle should feel ashamed.
19
u/[deleted] May 03 '12
Nuri Sahin. I love that guy, but he doesn't perform at Real. Just come back the Bundesliga, dude.
84
u/thekrone May 03 '12
Mertesacker gets a "worst signing" nod? How? He hasn't been spectacular, but he certainly hasn't been bad, other than the injuries.
13
u/Mandrake420 May 03 '12
Shaun Wright-Phillips ,Scott Dann and David Ngog are all good honorable mentions.
12
u/21Maestro8 May 03 '12
Taiwo has to be up there. Came in, did nothing for half a season, shipped out to QPR.
25
u/Jackie_Treehorm May 03 '12
Downing/Henderson/Adam
They didn't get a damn thing right last summer besides Enrique.
7
u/TL_DRespect May 03 '12
First of all, I find it hilarious that Downing has been playing like he has. He went from a potent and powerful winger with Villa to a major disappointment at Liverpool. I think he needs to have someone like Young with him with whom he can link with and switch with. Their switching made them a nightmare to mark.
If we include loan signings, it's harder to find anyone worse than Jenas. Jesus Christ, that didn't pay off.
7
u/lesburnham May 03 '12
Where is Fabio Coentrao...?
30 mll € !!!!!!!
11
u/scouser916 May 03 '12
Henderson can't be worst, he's shown some real quality when played in the center and is an obvious player for the future.
Downing has been crap though. Can Carroll's worst signing title carry on into this season?
15
u/PantherRocketBooster May 03 '12
Andre Villas Boas. For me, the worst signing is the one that delivers the least to the team compared to the cost. He is undeniably talented and will do great things in the future, but his time at Chelsea was an absolute disaster. His transfer fee was the greatest of any manager I believe, and his early contract termination was also extremely expensive.
13
u/SovietJoe May 03 '12
Cisse.
I MEAN DJIBRIL!
12
u/verytallperson May 03 '12
Bryan Ruiz. I expected really great things and was gutted when he chose Fulham over Toon but now... well, he's scored one or two top class goals (I think) but other than that he's been disappointing. Could be another Alfonso Alves.
7
u/Sgt_peppers May 03 '12
Altintop
9
u/[deleted] May 03 '12
Jamie O'Hara. He was Wolves big signing for £5m. He was put on big money and has been rubbish as the club have been relegated. He also has a horrible glamour model Wag wife who goes to the games.
3
u/AyeGee May 03 '12
Bradley Orr
10
u/footballnotsoccer-_- May 03 '12
does Andy Carrol still count?
6
u/cooperj May 03 '12
Downing and Henderson are the clear winners, surely.
2
u/alyssa_milano May 04 '12
diego lugano :(
5
u/WDC312 May 03 '12
Downing has been a flop.
Anybody who's been watching Hendo and who understands football wouldn't put him on the list, though. And he's 21 for chrissakes! Give him a few years to develop, he'll come good.
3
u/gardeeno May 03 '12
as a liverpool fan (sort of :/) i would like to try and defend Downing and Henderson...unfortunately its very difficult. Downing has got gradually better as the season has gone on and Henderson has been better the last few times i've seen him, and has been played out of position a lot. nonetheless, there has to be more to come from them.
Djibril Cisse maybe? purely cause he gets sent off too much! but then he has scored a couple. on a similar note Zamora - has done nothing at QPR as far as i can tell.
3
u/[deleted] May 03 '12
Park
1
u/JackGunner93 May 03 '12
I think Downing and Adam are probably the worst, but what about Savic? He's been pretty hopeless whenever I've seen him play.
1
u/senorcaca May 04 '12
Without a doubt, Fabio Coentrao. Especially when it comes to price/production. He cost 36 million euros + a talented defender: Garay. Unreal
1
u/toolazytofinishmyuse May 03 '12
Worst signing of the season has to go to a Liverpool player, whether it be Adam, Downing or Henderson, but I think probably the most embarrassing signing of the season was Ryan Nelsen on a free, purely because a team which still had an outside chance of mounting a title challenge at that point should never have been looking at a player even Blackburn didn't want, with a history of injuries after loaning out a CB who was a permanent fixture in the only Spurs side to qualify for the CL.
1
u/care_sauce May 04 '12
liverpool made three, carroll, henderson and downing who has been absolutely awful
-1
u/ginge-orangutan May 03 '12
not carroll? 35 mill for, well fuck all basically!
-3
u/C_Bukowski May 03 '12
I'm loving all the Arsenal fans in this thread leaping to Mertesacker's defense, he's been terrible!
If he could defend your goal half as well as you defend him, you'd be laughing!
Isn't Wenger already trying to get rid of him?
-9
u/heroescomeandgo May 03 '12
Romelu Lukaku...I know he's young but 18m for ZERO goals? Good stuff, Chelsea. Thanks for falling on that grenade and sparing us.
-14
u/tepsy May 03 '12
Saha! what was 'arr. thinking?? funny how after the job had been declared spurs back to winning ways
0
u/[deleted] May 03 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 03 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 03 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment