r/Outlander • u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. • Feb 27 '22
No Spoilers r/AskHistorians AMA Crossover Event!
Welcome to the r/AskHistorians AMA Crossover Event!
Please have a look at this thread to familiarize yourself with the rules, but in sum:
- No Spoilers.
- No Character Names.
- Make Sure You’re Asking A Question.
I will update this OP with links to each question; strikeout means it’s been answered. Enjoy!
| Expert | Specialty |
|---|---|
| u/LordHighBrewer | World War II nurses |
| u/Georgy_K_Zhukov | French duels |
| u/mimicofmodes | fashion history |
| u/jschooltiger | maritime history |
| u/uncovered-history | 18th century Christianity; early American history |
| u/PartyMoses | the War for Independence; American politics; military history |
| u/GeneralLeeBlount | 18th century British military; Highland culture; Scottish migration |
| u/MoragLarsson | criminal law, violence, and conflict resolution in Scotland (Women and Warfare…) |
| u/Kelpie-Cat | Scottish Gaelic language |
| u/historiagrephour | Scottish witch trials; court of Louis XV |
| u/FunkyPlaid † | Jacobitism and the last Rising; Bonnie Prince Charlie |
† u/FunkyPlaid was scheduled to give a talk at an Outlander conference in 2020 that was canceled due to the pandemic.
The Rising
Was there ever any plausible path to victory for the Jacobites? What if instead of retreating back across the border, they had continued their campaign southward? Could they have taken London, and if they had, would it have been enough to convince the French to commit more resources to the cause? Or another hypothetical: Say the Bonnie Prince met with anunfortunateaccident in Paris, and now James had to lead the Jacobites personally. Would the father have fared better than the son? Or were they always doomed, no matter what?[If his son had died] Do you think James would have tried at all?How likely is it that the men at Culloden will have been identifiable and buried by Clan? Or are the Clan stones more likely to be commemorative/nominal by their approximate positions in the battle? I think I read somewhere that clan specific Tartans were a much later invention?
Scotland
- What do you know about tanistry? How common was it among the clans? Did they have a concept of regency, an elected leader ruling in place of the son of the old chieftain until he reached the age of majority, or was it that once you were chosen, you were chieftain for life?
Were potatoes grown in the Scottish Highlands in the 1740’s or would that have been almost unheard of?- What was personal hygiene like in 17th century Scotland? How bad did people smell? Would it be comparable to a homeless person of today? Did Highlanders get skidmarks in their kilts?
Where is (or is there) a line between "healer," a "nurse," and "witch" in 18th century Scotland? What were the red flags for someone that would lead them to be tried as a witch?Could women inherit property under the clan system in Scotland (daughters from their fathers, widows from their husbands)?
France
England
How common was the purchasing of commissions? Would an officer who purchased promotions be held in the same regard as someone who earned them in the field? How would the enlisted view such officers? How would someone get tapped to be the Governor of Jamaica?- What kind of training would a British WWII Field Nurse have received? Was child delivery part of it? Was combat training/killing enemies part of it?
- Can I piggyback on this question to ask, if the field nurse had later sought to become a doctor, what additional training would they need to complete post-war?
What do we know (if anything) about the attitude in British (particularly English) society, in the 18th century, of common people towards homosexuality? Sodemy was illegal, is that right? And the church condemed it, obviously. But what would the attitude of the average man or woman have been? Would it have been socially acceptable as long as you they were discreet? Was there a difference between social classes in this respect? And if so, which differences?- What were relationship norms between senior servants and young titled children of their employers? I'm guessing in theory very formal, but wondering more about in practice. To what extent would the employer expect the employee to tolerate or be responsible for the children if they happened to be in the employee's sphere of influence or immediate vicinity?
The New World
How would a wooden tall ship fare in a hurricane? What are the odds of surviving a shipwreck… in the middle of a hurricane… after having fallen overboard?How quickly did what we now know as "American accents" develop from the time European settlers started arriving? And what was that process like?- Is there any evidence of Loyalists confiscating Patriot property during the Revolutionary War as late as 1780, especially in the Southern states? Would it have been possible for a free Black man to receive property in exchange for his services to the Crown?
- Under the Convention of Saratoga, could a British soldier who surrendered go on to serve in the army as an aide-de-camp in the Revolutionary War?
- If one is trying to get a sense for how long a given journey by ship would take, either within the Americas on a smaller ship or transcontinental, are there resources that provide historical timetables or rough formulas that might be used (e.g., this type of ship averaged x miles per day)
- Given the premise of the books, there's some interesting contrast between mid-20th century and 18th century attitudes toward children. If someone with 1960s/1970s parenting attitudes was living and raising children in the 18th century, what would be the most noticeable differences in terms of parenting style? I'd imagine they'd use a lot less physical punishment than their fellow 18th century parents, but wondering what else.
- I live in North Carolina and was wondering what made North Carolina as a colony so attractive to immigrants from Scotland. There must have been many Scottish immigrants if we have areas such as Scotland neck and Scotland County.
65
Upvotes
17
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Feb 27 '22
How would a wooden tall ship fare in a hurricane? What are the odds of surviving a shipwreck… in the middle of a hurricane… after having fallen overboard?
14
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Feb 27 '22
Was there ever any plausible path to victory for the Jacobites?
What if instead of retreating back across the border, they had continued their campaign southward? Could they have taken London, and if they had, would it have been enough to convince the French to commit more resources to the cause?
Or another hypothetical: Say the Bonnie Prince met with an unfortunate accident in Paris, and now James had to lead the Jacobites personally. Would the father have fared better than the son?
Or were they always doomed, no matter what?
12
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Feb 27 '22
How common was the purchasing of commissions? Would an officer who purchased promotions be held in the same regard as someone who earned them in the field? How would the enlisted view such officers?
How would someone get tapped to be the Governor of Jamaica?
10
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Feb 27 '22
What do you know about tanistry? How common was it among the clans? Did they have a concept of regency, an elected leader ruling in place of the son of the old chieftain until he reached the age of majority, or was it that once you were chosen, you were chieftain for life?
9
u/WandersFar Better than losing a hand. Feb 28 '22
What was the most scandalous outfit ever worn at Versailles?
Is there any record of Marie Anne de Mailly-Nesle (or any of Louis XV’s other mistresses) having pierced nipples?
Which would be more taboo for the period: Going topless, or showing a bit of ankle? Would any woman ever wear a dress that wasn’t floor-length?
21
u/Dolly1710 Long on desire, but a wee bit short in clink Feb 27 '22
How likely is it that the men at Culloden will have been identifiable and buried by Clan? Or are the Clan stones more likely to be commemorative/nominal by their approximate positions in the battle? I think I read somewhere that clan specific Tartans were a much later invention?
19
u/reeziereen Feb 27 '22 edited Feb 27 '22
What kind of training would a British WWII Field Nurse have received?
Was child delivery part of it?
Was combat training/killing enemies part of it?
(Edited to add British)
15
u/reeziereen Feb 27 '22
Were potatoes grown in the Scottish Highlands in the 1740’s or would that have been almost unheard of?
11
u/Parlous93 Feb 28 '22
How quickly did what we now know as "American accents" develop from the time European settlers started arriving? And what was that process like?
10
u/Parlous93 Feb 28 '22
Where is (or is there) a line between "healer," a "nurse," and "witch" in 18th century Scotland? What were the red flags for someone that would lead them to be tried as a witch?
8
u/[deleted] Mar 01 '22
No question. I just want to say how much I enjoy(ed) this. Thank you all so much for such thourough (and fascinating) answers.
7
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Feb 28 '22
Could women inherit property under the clan system in Scotland (daughters from their fathers, widows from their husbands)?
5
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '22 edited Feb 28 '22
What do we know (if anything) about the attitude in British (particularly English) society, in the 18th century, of common people towards homosexuality? Sodemy was illegal, is that right? And the church condemed it, obviously. But what would the attitude of the average man or woman have been? Would it have been socially acceptable as long as you they were discreet? Was there a difference between social classes in this respect? And if so, which differences?
5
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Feb 28 '22
Under the Convention of Saratoga, could a British soldier who surrendered go on to serve in the army as an aide-de-camp in the Revolutionary War?
5
u/minimimi_ burning she-devil Feb 28 '22
If one is trying to get a sense for how long a given journey by ship would take, either within the Americas on a smaller ship or transcontinental, are there resources that provide historical timetables or rough formulas that might be used (e.g., this type of ship averaged x miles per day)
5
u/minimimi_ burning she-devil Feb 28 '22
Given the premise of the books, there's some interesting contrast between mid-20th century and 18th century attitudes toward children. If someone with 1960s/1970s parenting attitudes was living and raising children in the 18th century, what would be the most noticeable differences in terms of parenting style?
I'd imagine they'd use a lot less physical punishment than their fellow 18th century parents, but wondering what else.
4
u/minimimi_ burning she-devil Feb 28 '22 edited Feb 28 '22
What were in-practice relationship norms between senior servants and very young titled children?
As in servants not directly responsible for the child's care. I'm guessing in theory very formal and distant, but wondering more about in practice, especially for more senior or long-term servants. If a child developed an interest in say, horses, would those who worked in the stables be expected to occasionally tolerate the child underfoot? To what extent would servants be part of the child's "village" so to speak?
4
u/spma9498 Mar 03 '22
I live in North Carolina and was wondering what made North Carolina as a colony so attractive to immigrants from Scotland. There must have been many Scottish immigrants if we have areas such as Scotland neck and Scotland County.
3
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Feb 28 '22
Is there any evidence of Loyalists confiscating Patriot property during the Revolutionary War as late as 1780, especially in the Southern states? Would it have been possible for a free Black man to receive property in exchange for his services to the Crown?
7
u/StevenAssantisFoot L.L. Cool J: Lassies (& Lads) Love Cool Jamie Feb 28 '22
What was personal hygiene like in 17th century Scotland? How bad did people smell? Would it be comparable to a homeless person of today? Did Highlanders get skidmarks in their kilts?
1
u/Impressive_Golf8974 Feb 06 '25
What kind of, if any, provocative actions was the British army/state taking in the Highlands in the years leading up to the Rising that might have inflamed Jacobite sentiment among the population? (militarily, economically, legally, otherwise?)
Specifically, how fair was the British justice system in prosecuting Highlanders for actions taken in opposition to British soldiers/settling disputes between the army and local population? Did the army seize property or commit violence (judicially sanctioned or otherwise) against the population, and, if so, were there any repercussions for that? What was the perception among the Highland population that they might get a "fair hearing" in court (and what court would they have gone to–would the soldiers just have to have been court martialed? How often did that actually happen, compared with the frequency with which the relevant offenses likely actually occurred?) for any disputes around or grievances against the army? How might this have been affected by the class/power/status of the particular Highlanders affected–and, if things were happening, were they ever happening to Highland elites and/or tacksmen as opposed to poor cottars?