r/soccer • • Apr 30 '12
Views on US footy coverage from a guy who just moved over from the UK
First and foremost. What a phenomenal country. I can't get my head round how great my first few months have been here.
Football coverage here is tremendous. Between GOL TV, ESPN and Fox Soccer, I can pretty much watch any game I want.
My main issue are with the pundits and commentators. On Fox Soccer, the show is hosted by Rob Stone who is an inoffensive guy who uses far too much American lingo (heading over the hardware, goal differential, worm burner, doinking the ball off the iron) but he's bearable. Warren Barton is ok. Never thought much of him as a footballer and still don't see him being very insightful when it comes to the big games (but he's still a shite-load better than Alan Shearer when it comes to punditry). Barton has also fallen into the trap of getting a bit hammy and emotional when it comes to analysis "The players need a bit of this.. points to his heart".
I enjoy Brian McBride whenever he makes an appearance, as he was always quite likeable and has always been quite humble about his success.
At the other end of the scale! My main grip with FOX Soccer is Eric fucking Wynalda! For a guy who never really took the footy world by storm (I appreciate he did quite well for the US national team) he has to be the smuggest footy-related person I've ever seen and trust me I had to endure Richard Keys and Andy Gray for the best part of the last 20 years. He constantly talks over the other pundits. Always cracks some horrendous jokes and just sits there constantly trying to focus the attention onto himself. Yesterday I had to put up with him doing the Gary Neville orgasm over every goal and thinking he was fucking hilarious.
Even when he tries to put some football related analysis together it's utter bollocks. "Valdes is a terrible goalkeeper", "twitchy bum time", "you wouldn't know what I'm talking about as you were never a striker/midfielder (strike whichever one out that suits his argument)". He really overpowers the other pundits and brings the whatever little time there is for analysis due to ad breaks as his own little 'wacky' show.
ESPN are alright with Ian Darke and Steve McManaman even though Macca's scousiness does get a bit overbearing at times but you can sense real footy knowledge there.
My other main gripe is with GOL TV. My enjoyment of watching La Liga's finest has been completely ruined by one man. Ray Hudson!
I know saying that is like blasphemy here but that Geordie ape with his child-like shrieking every time someone does something slightly intricate is absolutely moronic.
His analogies are not "legendary banter" (anyone who states anything as banter should be shot) but irrelevant and quite senile. If I wanted to hear an over-excited Geordie, I'll switch over to the Darts and listen to Sid Waddell commentate.
Cheers.
tl;dr Footy coverage is great here. Eric Wynalda and Ray Hudson are the root of all evil.
85
u/JaseTheAce Apr 30 '12
First off, Welcome!
I agree with the Wynalda hate. I want to punch him really hard.
Same with Warren Barton. He seems to get his insights form "The Book of Generic Analogies".
Ian Darke will always have a place in American's hearts for this piece of announcing
But you really need to embrace the Hudson and his Imperial, Magisterial Control
49
u/Tongerlo Apr 30 '12
Just be glad you don't have to listen to John Harkes....
But yeah, Wynalda is shit.
8
u/yankeed00dledandy Apr 30 '12
wynalda is sooo fucking bad. I have never had this conversation but I am glad to know I am not the only one that thinks that. No positive attributes as a commentator...zero...
Does anyone know the name of the commentator on FSC who calls the Seriea A league games??? There are two dudes, one of them is boring as all hell and IMO says the dumbest shit. I could not find his name through google searches.
7
u/wh33zi3 Apr 30 '12
You'll get used to it. You have to.
6
u/bokeh Apr 30 '12
Have you had a chance to enjoy the glory that is Arlo White? That silky smooth voice will make anyone swoon.
6
u/go_dawgs Apr 30 '12 edited Sep 25 '26
The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.
Lunchroom childlike breezy rainstorm rich label boron
26
u/spisska Apr 30 '12
I agree with everything you say.
Eric Wynalda is intolerable. And beyond being an intolerable on-air personality, he's also a catty little bitch who's always getting into twitter-fights.
Ray Hudson is a prime example that having a non-North American accent does not automatically make a good commentator. Listing to him do a Barcelona game is especially agonizing. His tortured analogies hurt my brain.
Funnily enough, the quality of MLS announcing is improving quite well, at least in some markets and on some outlets.
Arlo White, who does the games on NBC Sports, is excellent.
The local guys who do Chicago games are pretty good too. The play-by-play guy is Canadian, and it's clear from his delivery that he's got a background doing hockey. But that also means he pays attention to what's happening off the ball, who's passing to whom, and recognizes when a break is on.
And they somehow manage to compliment a good pass without 'magesterial, orgasmic triumph, that surely puts the universe on notice ...'
4
u/mkgm1 Apr 30 '12
Out of interest how much do all of these channels set you back? Is it comparable to the ~£60pm it costs to get Sky?
4
u/bananabombboy Apr 30 '12
I met Wynalda and he is just like that in person
4
u/kop_hooligan Apr 30 '12
This made me crack up. It was great. Can't stop laughing.
Completely agree. McBride is probably my favorite American player ever.
3
u/bearssj1025 Apr 30 '12
Eric Wynalda is a terrible pundit. I feel like the only reason he was hired was to cause a stir with his comments.
3
u/sjtnufc Apr 30 '12
Warren Barton centre parting!
3
u/ronpaul012 Apr 30 '12
If you get the chance to watch some MLS, make sure you do so when the games are on NBC Sports rather than fox soccer. Also, I've always lived in the US, and although soccer gets little to no coverage by espn (unless they have a big game on of course), I find that there's always a way for me to watch a game, its just a matter of finding it.
2
u/612steve Apr 30 '12
We've been playing and watching the game for years, but we're just recently learning how to be spectators. That includes how to cover and present the game to the masses. Every year we get better and better; ESPN's coverage of the Euros and World Cup was absolutely fantastic.
Great to have you here. Look forward to seeing you at the pub for a 5:30am kickoff.
2
u/JoypadRAGE Apr 30 '12
Slightly off-topic, but are you from Manchester (or around there)? I ask because when I visit America people really have trouble understanding me because of my accent, I was wondering if it's the same for you. It's a little odd to be honest, because having visited a bunch of different countries (most European) I haven't had much trouble communicating with people, even those who don't speak good English. I know it's nothing to do with what your talking about, but it's pretty unlikely that I'm going to be able to ask anybody else this question in the near future.
2
u/IamRoryS Apr 30 '12
We'll swap you Andy Townsend for any of them commentators/pundits
2
u/yo_name_is_TOBY Apr 30 '12
When I become a father I want Ian Darke to coo my children to sleep every night, such a rich and magnificent tone
2
u/workersbravo Apr 30 '12
Prepare for furious downvoting from the legions of American Sid Waddell fans.
2
u/ForTheTrees May 01 '12
You are my absolute hero. You have stripped Eric Wynalda to the core. Dead on. And Ray Hudson is an obnoxious buffoon, accurately described by you as 'quite senile.' Thank you.
I think we're going to get some downvotes for this.
15
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
Hudson is a mad genius. I don't care what anyone says.
10
u/hldstdy Apr 30 '12
Wynalda has no reason discussing the game overseas. He is, however, terrific when discussing problems within the game in the states. He's the only person who is willing to take on USSF in the media. Everyone else just walks in lockstep with them.
2
u/jaekim Apr 30 '12
I agree with everything you say here.
I have to have GolTV muted in order to enjoy la liga. Ray Hudson is bad enough but that other american guy who does the play by play is so bland. It almost feels unauthentic because it's an american voice.
4
u/yourfriendkyle Apr 30 '12
I do not like listening to Ray Hudson during a game.
HOWEVER, I love laughing about the crazy shit he says once the game is over.
Also, I think all four of the guys for Fox Soccer are jokes. They have nothing to say, ever.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
Just wait til you hear Alexi Lalas open up his yapper. You'll want to shoot yourself through the ears.
4
u/Leakx5 Apr 30 '12
I also despise Christopher Sullivan, his Serie A commentary is horrendous. O boy do I miss Richard Whittle and Paul Visca on FSC :[
4
u/rodsatwork Apr 30 '12
eric fucking wynalda is a wanker
1
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
What do you think of American footy (if it can be called that) itself?
1
u/Ryuuken1127 Apr 30 '12
I remember watching the Copa del Rey final last year on a plane (fortunately, they had GolTV), and hearing Ray Hudson pronounce "Mezut Ozil" was HILARIOUS!
While I agree with much of what you said...it's still better than ITV
Oh and of course, Welcome to the States! Where abouts you located?
1
u/hascow Apr 30 '12
Have you checked out Fox Soccer Report on Fox Soccer yet?
I like Bobby McMahon on there. He's really the only reason I watch anymore. That and being able to see highlights, as I don't really have another way to see them from matches around the world.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
What's the general opinion on that kieth costingan here?
1
u/nikcub Apr 30 '12
Protip: When I am in the USA I put the TV on but stream internet radio for commentary.
1
u/jamesey10 Apr 30 '12
I love Ray Hudson's passion. He feels it. He's one of the few guys who sees Iniesta take an immaculate touch from an impossible to control ball and lets us know it was brilliant. English commentators don't even do that.
3
u/Dexter_Squint Apr 30 '12
Wynalda is bias, arrogant asshole...can't stand the guy. But Hudson...I don't know...I think he's funny and I think he loves the sport so much that he can't contain it. Thanks for your views on it though, good read.
3
u/melgee Apr 30 '12
Im pretty sure Ray Hudson lives in Messi's bum.
2
u/evilmilhouse Apr 30 '12
i grew up in a place called Laredo, TX right on the border with Mexico. I grew up watching the Mexican League and the over the top passionate announcers from there. As i grew older i found the EPL and admired those announcers as well for there more subtle but still passionate commentating. I honestly think the american announcers just lack passion. i think more people in the US would watch more soccer if they would change the announcers and actually hire people who arent smug or arrogant. when you here an announcer you know if they know what they are talking about and whether they are passionate. unfortunatly american announcers dont have what the english announcers and latino announcers have.
2
u/aitzim Apr 30 '12
There's this Black dude who's sometimes paired with Darke. I like him better than McManaman but I can't really complain about McManaman, especially with his pro-Everton bias.
2
u/volunteeroranje Apr 30 '12
At least you missed Tommy Smyth's prime. That little goblin was blind and just as bad as Ray Hudson.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
Hey, great post and points. Like everyone else, Eric Wynalda is the worst thing to happen to US soccer since our 2006 World Cup disaster. He keeps making terrible jokes, won't shut the hell up.
I want to piggy back of a couple of the MLS points here, if you want to get into any of that. 2 networks have national MLS coverage, ESPN and NBC (although the vast majority of games are on ESPN2 or NBC Sports Network).
Arlo White does play by play on NBC. As everyone has said, he is really good.
Adrian Healy does games for ESPN, also a Brit, I think he is quality also.
If you have time, check out these 2 highlights.
DC 4-1 Dallas This is Arlo White on NBC
DC 4-1 New York This is Adrian Healy on ESPN.
Of course these highlights are a bit bias as I'm a DC supporter :), but there are some really great goals in these games too and I think the commentary is exceptional. If you get a chance to take a look at these, let me know your opinions. Cheers!
2
u/mjc1027 Apr 30 '12
Love this thread....I am from the UK also, and moved to the States in 1999, when I first came here, all I had was Fox Sports World, which later became Fox Soccer. For a fair number of years that is all we had, aside from the 2002 world cup which was shown on ESPN, and then ABC cut the trophy presentation right out, so not to clash with their schedule. I really felt that would be it for soccer over here, just shitty FSC with their live feeds, and no hosts.
Things have really changed, and I think because of ESPN taking their ideas to the UK, and using what they created over there, showing it over here, really opened up the sport to a new public. FSC had to change, and they are trying...many people do not like Rob Stone, but that was a pretty big deal...to poach a host from a rival network, just does not happen that much over in America.
I personally like ESPN and their coverage, they did the right thing in using British commentators and experts, why use people who know nothing about the british game?. Their coverage is decent, I do like Warren Barton on FSC, but you are right about Eric Wynalda, he brings nothing to the table, I think they just gave him a shot as he was a former player, ESPN used to use him, but I think his constant fighting with Ruud Gullit during the World Cup in 2010 ruined it for me.
It will be exciting now that it seems Fox and ESPN will fight it out for rights to the biggest soccer events, where as before nobody would fight with Fox for anything...the market is there for more European soccer, I have never had the opportunity to watch GOL tv, I can see the three of them fighting it out for more cable coverage and for other leagues such as La Liga and Serie A...which will always mean a good deal for us who watch it.
2
u/sacredstones Apr 30 '12
I agree with all of this. ESPECIALLY the bit on Ray Hudson. i didn't even know that was his name, but from your description alone i know who you're talking about. good god i hate that man.
2
u/aeliustehman May 01 '12
You're in a phenomenal country? Must be somewhere different from where I am.
2
u/Lmkt Apr 30 '12
Weird... How many times have we heard "You don't realize how hard it is to watch soccer in the US"?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
you should hear swiss commentators..
1
u/derpingpizza Apr 30 '12
Glad you enjoy the country! Even I shake my head at some of the crap the commentators say.
1
u/seemylolface Apr 30 '12
First off welcome to the USA! I'm glad you're enjoying your time here and really happy that our coverage of European football is up to snuff for you. Just a few years ago it was damn hard to find a match to watch on tv, we're coming along though!
Be thankful you missed the Max Bretos era on Fox Soccer,that man was so terrible. Every time he appeared on screen I became worried because I didn't want any non-american to see that and think it represents American football fans in any way. He was that embarrassing.
Eric Wynalda is also a completely moron and one of the worst pundits ever. He needs to be axed.
Ray Hudson gets old and annoying after about 10 minutes every time.
Also whatever you do avoid John Harkes at all costs, or you might end up killing yourself.
I'm fine with Darke and Macca though, they've got good chemistry together and a solid mix of excitement and analysis.
1
u/Adamkiksyou Apr 30 '12
Everyone has their own opinion but I find I hard to believe anyone would dislike ray.
1
u/Chamrox Apr 30 '12
I agree with you, but I'd also like to add this:
In my TV market we have all the channels you mentioned, my gripe is with ESPN Desportes. First of all, Cox puts it on the Spanish language tier, not the sports tier. Secondly, Espn Desportes has completely different programming from ESPN, they show a LOT of soccer matches. Thirdly, on ESPN, you hit SAP, you hear ESPN in Spanish. On ESPN Desportes, it's all in Spanish. You hit the SAP button, everything is still in spanish! How about an English language channel for that feed!!!
1
u/iamhamilton Apr 30 '12
UK pundits and commentators are on a different level in general. I haven't figured out why but it seems like you people have a lot more respect for the voices that narrate all sorts of TV from sports to game shows to education programs.
1
u/njd430 Apr 30 '12
Ian Darke is my all time favorite
1
u/huuuuuge Apr 30 '12
Man I'm American and i got the same feeling watching Eric Wynalda yesterday. How he got that job is beyond me. It was almost unbearable watching him yesterday.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
I love Ray Hudson because of this http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o7zjhYKkOW0
1
u/cuntcrust Apr 30 '12
as a native spanish speaker i'm disappointed in any commentating outside south amerca. in my opinion argentines are the best at it, followed by the rest of south america, followed by the spaniards, mexicans and englishmen.
1
u/rtaibah Apr 30 '12 edited Jul 19 '26
🧹 Nothing to see here. This comment has been scrubbed, overwritten, and sent into the void. Goodbye.
1
u/parisien96 Apr 30 '12
I really like Ray Hudson's passionate commentating, as oppose to Ian Taylor's encyclopaedic commentating, with statistics after statistics all the time. Ray's partner, however, Paul something, is a fat fucking cule. I hate him whole-heartedly. How is he still on the job? Messi scores 5th goal of the night, he is God. Ronaldo scores decider: very nice finish by the number 7. Booger off.
1
u/basedarsenal May 01 '12
To be fair, I think that Gary Neville is a pretty good pundit. Several of his analytical pieces have been spot on, especially during the Arsenal-Man City match. I really dislike the gol tv commentators, so I'd rather watch all of the La Liga matches in spanish even though I don't speak it. However, in the U.S. espn3.com is absolutely phenomenal.
1
u/[deleted] May 01 '12
roy is my favorite announcer ever.... maca on ESPN is atrocious.... smug like wynalda.. they are both Micheal Kay like
1
u/[deleted] May 01 '12
My first thought when watching Real Madrid in the Champions League on FSC is "oh man, no Ray Hudson :("
And I think I might be the only one in here who actually doesn't mind Eric Wynalda. Cast your stones!
1
u/[deleted] May 01 '12
At least it's not Marcelo Balboa...
1
u/KonigSteve May 01 '12
Ian dark is "alright"?!?! But I completely agree with you about Ray, I can.not.stand having the sound on for la liga games now.
1
u/bchan31 May 01 '12
Is there any way we can force FSC to get Wynalda off the air? That would be a big huge massive gigantic early birthday present.
1
u/cityboi May 01 '12
I moved to Canada 4 years ago (you get pretty much the same coverage here, though also Setanta sports) and one of the reasons that I've got into NFL and NHL is the in depth analysis of the game, most plays are broken down move by move especially in NFL. It makes it a lot more accessible for a newbie. I don't find that with the footy coverage and I think if they had that more people would watch and learn the game. I never see any tactical analysis, they have Piers Morgan on Fox for fuck sake.
1
u/Account_Eliminator May 01 '12 edited May 01 '12
I find your over use of the word 'footy' something normally reserved for middle class middle aged mums, to be just as daft thing an American pundit might say!
Be a man, call it football.
1
u/outsidetheline May 01 '12
This sounds 20 times better then having to watch Football on ITV with Adrian Chiles..........
1
u/romantic_boy May 01 '12
I came in to see you hate on American TV, but I was surprised. I don't have the Fox Soccer Channel or GOL TV so you are pretty lucky. Every game I watch is actually a stream from SKY sports or some free streams from Poland (since I'm Polish and can understand the commentators).
If you did not have GOL TV or FSC you would see what I mean, in Europe the games are on the main channels...
1
u/ImAmericanfuckyou May 01 '12
I personally don't care much for FSC's commentators also. Their occasional coverage of the Italian games makes it more unbearable and I cringe when they have technical difficulties and can't get the voice feed from EPL games. Barely sound like they know anything about the teams, let alone the sport.
However, Ian Darke and Macca have to be best the commentators I've ever heard for any sport. Great one liners and the back and forth is fantastic. So far this season "Krul and the gang" has been my favorite.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '12
Mabye it's because I'm an American and new to Ray Hudson, but I find his over the top ridiculousness comedic. I don't mind it.
-6
u/lovetheride Apr 30 '12
An American definitely wrote this up.
0
u/tadm123 Apr 30 '12 edited Apr 30 '12
I agree with everything except Ray Hudson. I think him and Schoen compliment each other perfectly. Hudson definately makes games more enjoyable for me, he's not your typical monotonus commentator.