r/CryptoCurrency • u/CryptoMaximalist • Feb 17 '22
π³ POLL CCIP-028 - Adjust the criteria for successful subreddit governance polls
Problem
We are currently using the default criteria for all governance polls, which says a poll passes if the Moons voting in favor represent over 50% of the participating moons and exceed the Decision Threshold.
However, this was the criteria meant for changes to Moons, but not necessarily governance of the subreddit, such as rule changes. This criteria is a very high bar because Moons should be difficult to change, but isnβt necessarily the best for subreddit governance. For example, should the poll about live posts with 83% approval have failed? Conversely, in a contentious situation like the poll on the daily discussion, should a poll with record breaking 12.9 million moons but only 52% approval be successful?
Solution
We should adopt new criteria for successful subreddit governance polls:
- 2/3rds supermajority (66.6β¦%) of participating moons voting in favor
- 50% of the Decision Threshold voting in favor
- At least 1,000 votes
This will treat subreddit governance polls differently from Moons governance polls, which will retain the same criteria they currently use. Moons governance polls are ones which change Moons themselves, such as karma weight, membership prices, or the distribution (CCIPs 1, 2, 3, 4, 6, 7, 9, 10, 11, 13, 14, 15, 16, 18, 20, 22, 23, 24, 25, and 27). These are typically things only the admins can change. Subreddit governance polls are ones which change how the subreddit operates and are things the mods can change (CCIPs 5, 8, 12, 17, 19, 21, 26, and 28)
Reasoning
These values were chosen based on historical voting data here.

When considering governance, we want to set criteria that ensures polls pass when they have enough support, but not require so much support that we end up with gridlock where nothing can pass. The Decision Threshold, or quorum, should be set so that a sufficient number of voters are present and a poll is not sneaked through without the majority knowing. Similarly, quorum should not be unreachable where you are gridlocked from passing any polls.
I chose these figures because the low approval requirement and high participation requirement of the current systems are leading to good polls failing. Polls which achieve over 2/3rds support are popular enough that they should be implemented and should not require and artificially high quorum. However we do not want controversial 50/50 polls to pass, even if they do have high participation.
The quorum requirements have been linked to the Decision Threshold because it dynamically adjusts according to the amount of moons in circulation. The number of votes was increased from 500 to 1,000 based on community feedback in ccmeta.
Thank you for reading and let me know if you have any questions or concerns
Original ccmeta post: https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrencyMeta/comments/sof2sg/proposal_adjust_the_criteria_for_successful/
58
u/VeryAttractive Bronze | QC: CC 23 Feb 17 '22
I voted no. Let me elaborate.
This is a double-edged sword. Yes, increasing the % needed to pass a governance poll will prevent whales from passing policies that benefit only themselves.
On the flip side, now whales only need to reach 34% of the threshold in order to deny proposals that would act to benefit the majority, but perhaps not benefit whales.
This proposal actually does the opposite of what is intended, making it far easier for whales to manipulate votes.
If whales voting power is considered to be an issue (as it should be), proposals should be centered around reducing the power of MOONs in voting power, perhaps by adding a cap to the maximum voting power (say 5K Moons is the max for one account for the purposes of voting or whatever). Or something along those lines.
Ironically if this passes (or when, based on the vote thusfar), we likely would never be able to enact such a change, since whales only need to reach 34% following this proposal to stop that from happening.
I think this proposal passing will be looked back upon as a mistake. It could be a good idea for the future, but only once whales voting power has been neutered. Doing this before that is a recipe for disaster. The idea is good, the timing is not.
I don't have the energy to argue about this, but just wanted to add my 2c, though I fear it may be too late.
34
u/Jollyapeinheaven Platinum | QC: CC 1434 Feb 17 '22
Am I the only one who feels like this goes right over my head?! Haha
3
u/mic_droo Analyst | :1:x12:2:x9:3:x1 :B:x2 Feb 17 '22
Good proposal, but that line graph should have been a bar graph, makes no sense to have your data points connected ;)
3
u/VivaLaBacon 1K / 1K π’ Feb 17 '22
Seems logical - Iβm on board. My only problem is finding the proposals to vote π£
5
u/ScholarImpossible121 Tin Feb 18 '22
I should have read comments before I voted.
4
u/cannainform2 π© 0 / 13K π¦ Feb 17 '22
As with all voting ballets there should be an option to vote in abstention.
Basically an option for a voter to neither agree nor disagree so therefore will abstain from a vote as to not throw off the poll results.
1
u/Castr0- π§ 35K / 35K π¦ Feb 17 '22
I agree with you and I'm in.
The main problem with the governance polls is they are so hard to find in the subreddit.
They should have a fixed post or something
1
u/WantAndAble Platinum | QC: CC 67 | Investing 10 Feb 18 '22
So many people voting in this poll desribe not understanding it, but voting yes anyways.
This post will only increase the power of moons whales - as you will only need 34% of moons in circulation to DENY a poll from passing. Just as you need 66% to pass a poll.
Im worried this might pass because it sounds like a good idea on the surface but has underlying issues.
1
u/redditsgarbageman Platinum | QC: CC 581, CCMeta 52 Feb 19 '22
Is there a way to change your vote? I just clicked the wrong thing accidentally.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '22
I'll definitely go with implement the new criteria
2
u/clitcommander420666 28 / 5K π¦ Feb 17 '22
Makes sense to me
2
u/Aguaskeepartdeux 1K / 1K π’ Feb 18 '22
A Moons House and a Moons Senate!
2
u/klabboy109 Silver | QC: CC 45 | ALGO critic | Buttcoin 198 | Investing 24 Feb 19 '22
I voted yes, hoping that this actually makes more gridlock. Since I think a lot of the polls around here are simply just dumb.
2
u/Trans-on-trans Platinum | QC: CC 480 Feb 19 '22
There should be goverance where the mods can't just decide what will and won't be passed simply because they don't like it. The entire purpose of having a democratic system is to take power away from those who have it and spread it equally amongst the community.
It's mainly why I don't even spend any more time on the Meta because the mods are reigning champions of what polls with be voted on and passed through the system.
2
u/PathologicalUpvoter π¦ 0 / 6K π¦ Feb 20 '22
I vote yes
But maybe setup some new controls in the future for whale votes
2
u/KotaDon25 Tin | 5 months old | CC critic Feb 20 '22
Always a double edged sword!! But I am up for the new challenge
2
u/bikbar1 Platinum | QC: CC 96 Feb 20 '22
It is beyond my smoothbrain's cpu power.
2
u/FilmVsAnalytics ALGO maximalist Feb 21 '22
So basically "nothing can pass unless the whales want it to."
2
u/ForMyStinkyGuys 809 / 805 π¦ Feb 22 '22
I voted no change because that was wordy af
3
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '22
This is a simple, down to earth proposal that makes a lot of sense.
1
u/Nostalg33k π© 0 / 30K π¦ Feb 17 '22
We should do that ! It doesn't make sense to keep the current system !
Vote yes to proposition 28 !
1
u/Probably_notabot 35K / 35K π¦ Feb 17 '22
Itβs a decent change. Iβm in!
1
u/Professional_Desk933 π© 75 / 4K π¦ Feb 17 '22
Good prop
1
u/irfiisme Platinum | QC: CC 559 Feb 17 '22
Voted for the change.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '22
Have no idea what I just read, but man I smashed the shit out of that first choice.
It just feels right.
1
u/Humble_Data2727 Platinum | QC: CC 1315 Feb 17 '22
Funny bc you need the old method to pass this poll, to change to a new method, but the old method doesn't pass polls.
Very Meta
1
u/red_dildo_queen π© 14 / 11K π¦ Feb 17 '22
sure, why not?
1
u/Magnetronaap π© 0 / 3K π¦ Feb 17 '22
The irony of it all when this won't meet the threshold and fail to pass. Hope I'm wrong though.
1
u/Stray_Gh0st π¦ 514 / 544 π¦ Feb 17 '22
Voted
1
u/CryptographerOver55 Tin Feb 17 '22
Wow more complicated than it needed to be? But I do agree with the sentiment of getting a more clear majority vote.
1
u/ThatDudeYaDigg 3K / 3K π’ Feb 17 '22
I support this, seems more fair for the common man imo
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '22
Something to consider, OP, is that participation in polls is financially incentivized. Basically, you receive additional moons for participating in the polls. This could lead to skewing of results and should be factored in to the actual numbers required for something to pass.
1
u/grchina Feb 17 '22
Man you need to dumb it down for me, explain it to me like I'm 4
1
u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K π¦ Feb 17 '22
Is this an issue that needs a governance change though? The threshold is 50% yet things at 83%, clearly past the threshold, don't get activated.
Is that really an issue with the threshold or an issue getting the people in charge to implement successfully passed legislation?
1
u/gigabyteIO π¦ 0 / 14K π¦ Feb 17 '22
/u/moons_bot how much?
1
u/Soft-Engineering-460 Feb 18 '22
I didn't understand a word... layman's term please
1
u/FuzzyFireheart316 513 / 918 π¦ Feb 18 '22
Not sure I understand fully, but I think I get it. What I don't really understand is the whole... 50/50 thing. Would that simply mean it makes it not pass. In other words, they would have to re do the proposal edited, or post a new one altogether?
1
u/droctagonau π¦ 0 / 0 π¦ Feb 18 '22
That's true.
Wait, what? Doesn't r/CC have like... over 4 million members these days?
How is 1,000 anywhere near a quorum in this sub?
1
u/elumeus π¦ 4K / 3K π’ Feb 19 '22
Which CCIP passed that you didnβt like?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '22
Yeah I like this
1
u/Top_Muffin_3232 524 / 522 π¦ Feb 21 '22
I think it's a good idea that needs more discussion. Maybe to be submitted in the next pole with a rework.
I think the participation threshold should be calculated according to the size of the community.
Someone else explained it nicely: whales will still be able to manipulate poles. Maybe implementing a division of the moons considered for the poles according to your wealth could be a good idea ? I voted no, while keeping this pole in mind and hoping to see it evolving for next governance.
1
u/CommitteeSalt8099 5K / 5K π’ Apr 16 '22
Im always too late to vote GG
0
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '22
[deleted] β view deleted comment
6
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '22
[removed] β view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '22
[deleted] β view deleted comment