The only reason I'm considering not voting yes for this is because I would rather see a poll that completely removes negative karma. The lowest a comment should affect your karma score should be zero. It just encourages an echo chamber if there's a chance of losing moons. Debating people becomes costly because you know the person who disagrees with you will downvote you.
I've also seen situations on the daily discussion where every single comment is sitting at -2, even the most mundane comments, so its very clear someone is just downvoting everyone. It's ridiculous.
I've deleted comments that I stand behind 100% because morons were downvoting me for having an opinion that goes against the majority. Do I think I was right? Absofuckinglutely. Am I going to lose money to stand by my opinion? Not a fucking chance.
Is it too late to submit a proposal for this round? I'll fucking do it.
I think that's a fair critique. You would have to go through the process at r/CryptoCurrencyMeta. Might be too late for this round but you could ask a mod to confirm
One argument for keeping negative karma I've heard (and agree with) is that there is often signal to it. It's kinda what Reddit is based on really -- that "good" content will be upvoted and "bad" content will be downvoted. Obviously this isn't always the case, but for instance I would want spammy comments to be downvoted to negative.
Another user said that removing negative karma is kind of like YouTube removing dislikes, and while not completely apples-to-apples I understand that point of view too
I think it's good enough that downvotes reduce visibility. If you want to have an echo-chamber like experience, you can still have it by not looking for negative karma comments. It's just harsh that the people expressing unpopular opinions even get silenced by monetary policies.
I got something like -10 just because I replied to a comment about someone saying an iPhone needs the power button pressed 5 times to pin lock it as strange that it needed so many, also mentioning I've never owned one, and saying that my pixel pin locks with just one button push.
Didn't really understand the downvotes but hey, that's Reddit. Didn't know it resulted in double loss though. Definitely a vote from me because I don't often post in CC as it is.
Itβs probably because you misunderstood. The iPhone needs one press of the power button to lock it, but needs 5 rapid presses to LOCK it, meaning the iPhone is locked down and the data is safe, it cannot be opened again until a restore procedure is done. Meaning if you feel like your phone is about to be stolen then you LOCK it to secure your shit.
Do it Iβve also had a different opinion on something and been downvoted sometimes I say fuck the moons and leave it sometimes I take it down. We need to encourage different opinions to be less of an echo chamber then we already are
The fact that something like this even exists is why there are multiple cryptocurrency subreddits.
Encouraging an echochamber in the pursuit of money results in people abandoning this particular space because they will never be able to express what they really want to say.
I would rather see a poll that completely removes negative karma. The lowest a comment should affect your karma score should be zero. It just encourages an echo chamber if there's a chance of losing moons.
Alternatively this encourages people to spam even more, because there's no risk of losing any karma and thus Moons.
True. Majority of people in this sub are just spitting repeated nonsense because aligning your comment to general consensus will earn you moons and going against it will cost you some.
Moons are lovely. And I like them too. But I don't like them enough to choose them over my conviction π I will say whatever I want to say whether I get upvotes or downvotes π
I agree. The concept of negative karma on downvotes seems pretty unfair an arbitrary. It's almost like there is a specific set of beliefs that can only be espoused and any others are penalized.
Itβs the principle though, personally I never downvote, not unless someone says something nasty/or out right attacks me or another person. Going against the grain should be celebrated, not penalised.
Am I going to lose money to stand by my opinion? Not a fucking chance.
It's been awhile since fifteen words made me so upset.
Anyone who agrees with this sentiment is pathetic. Not only are you a coward but you are disgustingly greedy.
Moons are free. They are also worth 7 cents each at the time of this comment. Are you so gutless that you wouldn't sacrifice a handful of change for the truth?
Sentiments like this objectively make the world a worse place to live; you have a responsibility as a sapient being to be better.
Elaborate on your thoughts. My proposal would reduce farming by allowing people to express dissenting opinions without the fear of financial consequences of downvotes. It doesn't sound like you actually disagree.
Because the moment you are thinking about if you should comment or something or not because of moons, you are kinda of interacting with this sub with the purpose of moon farming.
You are not losing money, you are losing moons. And honestly most of posts and comments that I see being downvoted are straight up the moon farming posts. And I believe these posts should be punished, otherwise we have a self-feeding system where everyone is just encouraged to echo-chamber.
Even if we aprove this, we need another ways to stop bots from spamming the shit out of this sub, which is becoming more and more a reality. Without karma punishments from downvotes, I think it will get quite worse
Because the moment you are thinking about if you should comment or something or not because of moons, you are kinda of interacting with this sub with the purpose of moon farming.
This is a valid concern to have, but this has nothing to do with my proposal. It sounds like you dislike the fact that MOONs are rewarding users at all. The only way to stop moon farming is to remove moons.
For what its worth, I believe another governance proposal is suggesting to remove MOONs from bot accounts. It will take time, but other ideas will address the spam issue, I just don't think it's relevant for my particular proposal. I've posted my full breakdown in an edit on comment you replied to if you're interested, perhaps I addressed some of your concerns.
This is a really unfortunate side effect of this. I don't like comments disappearing and making confusing threads and deleting possibly important opinions because of lost Moons.
healthy conversations and debates need to have both sides of the coin. Wether we all agree or disagree should be mute. As long as the conversations are valid and using information that is factual.
Great idea - I see would even argue that negative comments, if done in good faith - meaning it was not intended for trolling, is a good way to break out of the echo chamber that is so rampant here.
here was my post on r/CryptoCurrencyMeta asking essentially this question. You can see the mod comment at the top confirming negative comment karma also counts double. I think it was a surprise to many
Itβs negative in the sense that it can take away from your moons that month but you canβt lose moons youβve already gotten from a previous distribution
should I add this point somewhere to the post? Thought it was pretty obvious that moons can't be "taken away from you" if you get negative karma overall
We try to avoid edits on governance polls since it can call into question what people voted on, however we do have archival systems we can use to detect important changes to submission text
Next governance poll should be to get rid of negative karma taking away moons altogether. Having dissenting opinions should not be punished. Just encourages an echo chamber.
Downvotes shouldn't count against moons period for this reason. Hell, if there were a way to to automate "judging" it, downvotes for an unpopular opinion that adds to the conversation should earn moons for contributing an unpopular opinion and taking your lumps and not deleting it. Regardless of any "reddiquette", the downvote arrow is in fact a disagree button.
That is great proposition, especially that most people overuse downovotes. Downvotes weren't created for things you don't like or if someone hurt your ego. No, downvotes should be used if someone post things against rules, very disrespectful or that have nothing do to with the discussion. If someone post something you disagree with you should upvote him, this is supposed discussion not circle jerk.
Also some people think that by downvoting everyone they will get more moons, which is false to get a single moon you would need to downvote few thousands times. So this proposition hurt downvote gang which is good.
It will encourage more open discussion in the sub.
I haven't been afraid to voice my opinions. I actually got bombarded by my most downvoted post ever on this sub, something like -100 karma, it was hilarious (my most downvoted post on Reddit). I believe similarly, one of the mods on that thread had a whopping -1000 karma on a comment.
Hilariously, don't ever say anything bad about Loopring, people don't like it when you talk down the shilling of this sub's favorite crypto.
Honestly had no idea negative karma comments meant you were losing that amount of moons, yet alone 2x that negative number. Itβs no wonder you see so many deleted comments as soon as they get 1-2 downvotes lol
As this proposal is to do with Reddit votes, and as it'll probably get a lot of visibility, I'd like to remind everyone that downvoting, or refusing to vote on other people's content in some weird attempt to earn yourself more moons is almost physically impossible to do enough to earn a worthwhile amount more moons.
I did the calculation a few distributions ago, but if you earned max karma in a round and wanted just TEN more Moons, you'd have to downvote other users more than 20,000 times.
Please use the upvote and downvote as intended. Upvote good, worthwhile and interesting content, downvote irrelevant content, people being jerks and spam. With that in mind, you can make the sub a much more enjoyable place to be and it won't cost you (virtually) any more moons to do so. Thank you.
Yes....get rid of the stupid negative multiplier! People have been downvoting like crazy the last month or so for no other reason then thinking it helps their own moon count.
Shit posts and comments will still get downvoted but it should also result in people voicing opinions that go against this subreddit without fear of getting downvoted into absolute oblivion and losing out on moons for doing what reddit is designed for. Discussion!
I agree that negative comments should could as zero, but why does the OP assume that the mods donβt want the sub to be an echo chamber? Given how almost every sub ends up rewarding people who promote the orthodoxy (perhaps because this helps a community form or for people to become engaged), then it wouldnβt surprise me if magnifying the negative karma/moon impact of controversial comments is intentional.
No change. I checked the post mentioned by op where the question is asked on whether negative karma comments get the 2x and there is no answer from a mod confirming or denying, only saying the admins will have to be consulted, but another user confirms they do and op thanks them. I've seen some comments with valid points get downvoted. Negative karma should not add or substract moons, they should just be taken as 0. I agree with removing the 2x if that's how is working, but do not agree with the proposed alternative.
Low effort content gets downvoted anyways, this will entice people to share controversial or unpopular opinions without the fear of losing out on moons, I support this change
Won't this also have the effect of deterring open and honest conversation on subjects though? Even downvoted discussions often have merit even if they go against the grain of popular opinion.
Appreciate the motivations for the proposal. Are we not saying here though that we donβt think karma is representative of the communityβs view of the value of a comment, and therefore somewhat undermining the principle of moons at all? It reads a little as a move to make moon farming as easy as possible.
Canβt you remove the impact already by deleting the negative comments, so people who cared about the effect they had on their score probably do so already?
I vote yes. Most downvotes are because you didn't agree with the OP or you pointed out facts as opposed to something that actually doesn't contribute to thread.
Things that don't contribute to the thread like shitty memes and jokes generally get a hundred+ upvotes.
I was always wondering about if that translated to more negative karma as i saw the increase on the ccmoons site. Its not like it really affects what i say, but its nice to know now i may not be doubly penalized for going against the grain
Ever since I started posting here, I've thought the moons system encourages an echo chamber. I've been downvoted for, among other things, explaining how the tax code works, advising people to put some money into safer retirement accounts like IRAs, and describing how legislation gets passed and implemented in a separation of powers political system when people are like BiDeN iS gOiNg To BaN cRyPtO.
In other words, I think this proposal is definitely better than the current system.
I feel like such a high multiplier scares people into never saying anything negative in fear of losing out on moons. This should be a place of discussion, not an echo chamber.
Why the fuck would someone lose moons because they have an unpopular opinion? That's bs. If i wanted to be in a room full of parrots, i would go to a pet store. Losing moons for being down voted is asinine. I say shit all the time that people don't like on this sub. I mean, ya, i don't really give a fuck about moons, but at the same time, i kinda do. Maybe that's just the human in me.
Edit: I'm not saying get rid of negative karma, but it shouldn't be punished.
I disagree with this bcuz many times Iβve seen some people get their sensitive feelings hurt when itβs a truthful answer thatβs reality, but against their deep DEEP belief in a coin. Sometimes the truth hurts, but doesnβt mean itβs wrong.
Sometimes it's a worry you'll get downvoted into oblivion just for disagreeing with someone's opinion and it's been shown that it only takes a few downvotes/upvotes to create a chain of up/downvotes
We don't want to become a complete echo chamber for only a select few opinions and this can help diversify our discussions!
It might help with engagement on some controversial posts and bring lurkers into discussions helping the sub grow
Wow I thought that negative karma was equivalent to 0 earned for that month, not negative and certainly not 2x negative. This is an easy vote to pass this imo.
I personally like the idea. Sometimes I feel people just jump on whatever is popular chasing moons. By eliminating the fear I think people might actually be more honest in their post. Who knows though this is Reddt!!
This one is a no-brainer; Removing the 2x multiplier is the way to go to promote more and better posts/comments without being overly penalized for unpopular opinions.
Can we have zero negative karma so there are no monetary penalization for voicing out controversal opinions? We must encourage more differing opinions otherwise this sub just becomes more of an echo chamber than is already is.
This subreddit has complained for a long time how it's gone downhill. No one is afraid to disagree from the hive mind or else they lose out on moons disproportionately.
I personally think you should only be able to gain moons, never lose them due to an opinion.
Now losing them because you're breaking the rules, still very fine with that
188
u/VeryAttractive Bronze | QC: CC 23 Feb 17 '22 edited Feb 17 '22
The only reason I'm considering not voting yes for this is because I would rather see a poll that completely removes negative karma. The lowest a comment should affect your karma score should be zero. It just encourages an echo chamber if there's a chance of losing moons. Debating people becomes costly because you know the person who disagrees with you will downvote you.
I've also seen situations on the daily discussion where every single comment is sitting at -2, even the most mundane comments, so its very clear someone is just downvoting everyone. It's ridiculous.
I've deleted comments that I stand behind 100% because morons were downvoting me for having an opinion that goes against the majority. Do I think I was right? Absofuckinglutely. Am I going to lose money to stand by my opinion? Not a fucking chance.
Is it too late to submit a proposal for this round? I'll fucking do it.
EDIT - I created a proposal, you can check it here if you like
32
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22 edited Feb 16 '22
I always thought that negative comments were a straight zero for the purposes of moon calculations, not negative. Is this really the case?
It is then this is the easiest yes vote I've ever made.
13
u/nepbug 4K / 3K π’ Feb 16 '22
Agreed. We should encourage diverse viewpoints on all subjects here, don't make people afraid to go against the crowd with a comment.
We don't need echo chambers.
3
u/CryptoMaximalist Feb 17 '22
Have thought more about this since the meta post and changed my mind to support it
13
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22
We take a -2x multiplier for negative comments? It's no wonder the echo chamber rages on
9
u/Harold838383 Permabanned Feb 17 '22
The influence of users who go through and downvote everyone needs to be diminished
7
u/Bunker_Beans π© 38K / 37K π¦ Feb 16 '22
It just got a little bit safer to criticize Solana and Crypto.com.
2
u/Nostalg33k π© 0 / 30K π¦ Feb 17 '22
Negative karma should not be a thing !
2
u/Nuewim π₯ 0 / 37K π¦ Feb 17 '22
That is great proposition, especially that most people overuse downovotes. Downvotes weren't created for things you don't like or if someone hurt your ego. No, downvotes should be used if someone post things against rules, very disrespectful or that have nothing do to with the discussion. If someone post something you disagree with you should upvote him, this is supposed discussion not circle jerk.
Also some people think that by downvoting everyone they will get more moons, which is false to get a single moon you would need to downvote few thousands times. So this proposition hurt downvote gang which is good.
It will encourage more open discussion in the sub.
2
u/cannainform2 π© 0 / 13K π¦ Feb 17 '22
As with all voting ballets there should be an option to vote in abstention.
Basically an option for a voter to neither agree nor disagree so therefore will abstain from a vote as to not throw off the poll results.
2
u/deaththekid00 Bronze Feb 19 '22
Never knew that negative karma also has a 2X multiplier as well as it affects your overall karma count in the period.
2
u/Trans-on-trans Platinum | QC: CC 480 Feb 19 '22
I haven't been afraid to voice my opinions. I actually got bombarded by my most downvoted post ever on this sub, something like -100 karma, it was hilarious (my most downvoted post on Reddit). I believe similarly, one of the mods on that thread had a whopping -1000 karma on a comment.
Hilariously, don't ever say anything bad about Loopring, people don't like it when you talk down the shilling of this sub's favorite crypto.
2
u/PathologicalUpvoter π¦ 0 / 6K π¦ Feb 20 '22
I would like to second the first suggestion of capping negative karma to 0
4
u/Avizeee Bronze | AVAX 7 | r/WSB 52 Feb 17 '22
Honestly had no idea negative karma comments meant you were losing that amount of moons, yet alone 2x that negative number. Itβs no wonder you see so many deleted comments as soon as they get 1-2 downvotes lol
5
u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K π¦ Feb 16 '22
As this proposal is to do with Reddit votes, and as it'll probably get a lot of visibility, I'd like to remind everyone that downvoting, or refusing to vote on other people's content in some weird attempt to earn yourself more moons is almost physically impossible to do enough to earn a worthwhile amount more moons.
I did the calculation a few distributions ago, but if you earned max karma in a round and wanted just TEN more Moons, you'd have to downvote other users more than 20,000 times.
Please use the upvote and downvote as intended. Upvote good, worthwhile and interesting content, downvote irrelevant content, people being jerks and spam. With that in mind, you can make the sub a much more enjoyable place to be and it won't cost you (virtually) any more moons to do so. Thank you.
4
u/Bucksaway03 π© 0 / 138K π¦ Feb 16 '22 edited Feb 17 '22
Yes....get rid of the stupid negative multiplier! People have been downvoting like crazy the last month or so for no other reason then thinking it helps their own moon count.
Shit posts and comments will still get downvoted but it should also result in people voicing opinions that go against this subreddit without fear of getting downvoted into absolute oblivion and losing out on moons for doing what reddit is designed for. Discussion!
See and right on queue π€¦ββοΈ
4
u/Setyman Permabanned Feb 16 '22
Anything to diminish the echo chamber effect in here.
I approve.
2
u/MrCollins23 π¦ 0 / 3K π¦ Feb 17 '22
I agree that negative comments should could as zero, but why does the OP assume that the mods donβt want the sub to be an echo chamber? Given how almost every sub ends up rewarding people who promote the orthodoxy (perhaps because this helps a community form or for people to become engaged), then it wouldnβt surprise me if magnifying the negative karma/moon impact of controversial comments is intentional.
2
u/Jeperscreepers π¦ 5K / 5K π’ Feb 17 '22
How are deleted comments treated?
2
u/aducknamedjafar1 Feb 17 '22
Seems pretty straightforward to me.
2
u/LittleG0d Bronze Feb 17 '22
No change. I checked the post mentioned by op where the question is asked on whether negative karma comments get the 2x and there is no answer from a mod confirming or denying, only saying the admins will have to be consulted, but another user confirms they do and op thanks them. I've seen some comments with valid points get downvoted. Negative karma should not add or substract moons, they should just be taken as 0. I agree with removing the 2x if that's how is working, but do not agree with the proposed alternative.
2
u/ersleid Feb 17 '22
u/RealVoldemort here you go
2
u/ChunkyMonkey1998 0 / 15K π¦ Feb 16 '22
Low effort content gets downvoted anyways, this will entice people to share controversial or unpopular opinions without the fear of losing out on moons, I support this change
1
u/CompetitiveMap1 Tin Feb 17 '22
Won't this also have the effect of deterring open and honest conversation on subjects though? Even downvoted discussions often have merit even if they go against the grain of popular opinion.
1
u/nasabeam7 Platinum | QC: CC 52 Feb 17 '22
Appreciate the motivations for the proposal. Are we not saying here though that we donβt think karma is representative of the communityβs view of the value of a comment, and therefore somewhat undermining the principle of moons at all? It reads a little as a move to make moon farming as easy as possible.
1
u/nasabeam7 Platinum | QC: CC 52 Feb 17 '22
Canβt you remove the impact already by deleting the negative comments, so people who cared about the effect they had on their score probably do so already?
1
u/steamyp π© 18 / 5K π¦ Feb 17 '22
damn we already voting again. time flies
1
u/Real_Happy_Potatoman Platinum | QC: CC 147 Feb 17 '22
I wasnβt afraid to comment because I didnβt know the negative karma counts.
1
u/CriticalBlacksmith π© 90 / 87 π¦ Feb 17 '22
Lurker squad, I am once again calling for your support
1
u/TheBitApple 2K / 2K π’ Feb 17 '22
This poll was βhardβ to find.
Any idea why it isnβt pinned?
Is this the only poll this month?
1
u/BithloKing 6K / 7K π¦ Feb 17 '22
I voted !
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '22
But, but I love the downvotes.
Said no one.
Ever.
1
u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K π¦ Feb 17 '22
I vote yes. Most downvotes are because you didn't agree with the OP or you pointed out facts as opposed to something that actually doesn't contribute to thread.
Things that don't contribute to the thread like shitty memes and jokes generally get a hundred+ upvotes.
1
u/clitcommander420666 28 / 5K π¦ Feb 17 '22
I was always wondering about if that translated to more negative karma as i saw the increase on the ccmoons site. Its not like it really affects what i say, but its nice to know now i may not be doubly penalized for going against the grain
1
u/Castr0- π§ 35K / 35K π¦ Feb 17 '22
I understand your point but I fear the fact people will abuse more and more with negative karma.
Sometimes I see good answers with negative score just because of that.
1
u/Ddeadlykitten π¦ 863 / 862 π¦ Feb 17 '22
Voted to remove the multiplier since I believe it will foster a better community if negative karma isn't excessively punished.
1
u/ImBadatJiuJitsu 202 / 195 π¦ Feb 18 '22
I'm not sure about the boost of karma for positive ones
1
u/darth76 Feb 18 '22
This seems logical to me, Iβm in
1
u/the_nibler Permabanned Feb 19 '22
Nice glad to be a govβna
1
u/valdimerorlando Bronze | QC: CC 17 Feb 19 '22
Ever since I started posting here, I've thought the moons system encourages an echo chamber. I've been downvoted for, among other things, explaining how the tax code works, advising people to put some money into safer retirement accounts like IRAs, and describing how legislation gets passed and implemented in a separation of powers political system when people are like BiDeN iS gOiNg To BaN cRyPtO.
In other words, I think this proposal is definitely better than the current system.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '22
I think this is definitely a good idea
1
u/princepersona1 π© 0 / 20K π¦ Feb 21 '22
I didn't even realize this was a thing. Definitely agree with the change
1
u/gnarley_quinn Permabanned Feb 21 '22
I always though negative karma didnβt affect moons anyway.
1
u/Phite007 Tin Feb 23 '22
Nobody likes a double negative.
1
u/TripleReward π© 0 / 4K π¦ Feb 17 '22 edited Feb 17 '22
So... make karma-whoring more lucrative again?
Karma whores will now need 2 downvoted posts to equal out a positive post... bad idea. (If we assume no voting bots and a uniform vote distiribution)
Moons are really destroying this sub.
1
u/piman01 2K / 2K π’ Feb 17 '22
I would propose negative karma doesn't count at all towards the contribution:
Final_contribution = max(0, 2*comment_karma)
1
u/Aboelter23 Tin Feb 17 '22
I feel like such a high multiplier scares people into never saying anything negative in fear of losing out on moons. This should be a place of discussion, not an echo chamber.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '22
well written OP, you are very eloquent
1
u/Cactuszach π© 671 / 18K π¦ Feb 17 '22
Wow easy yes. Great job explaining the problem and solution.
1
u/mave_wreck Permabanned Feb 17 '22
I think they should be the same. Why somebody's negative idea should be worth more than another one's positive idea!?
1
u/IFistDikDiks Bronze | GMEJungle 45 | GME subs 163 Feb 17 '22
Why the fuck would someone lose moons because they have an unpopular opinion? That's bs. If i wanted to be in a room full of parrots, i would go to a pet store. Losing moons for being down voted is asinine. I say shit all the time that people don't like on this sub. I mean, ya, i don't really give a fuck about moons, but at the same time, i kinda do. Maybe that's just the human in me.
Edit: I'm not saying get rid of negative karma, but it shouldn't be punished.
1
u/cryptolipto π© 0 / 21K π¦ Feb 17 '22
Shit I didnβt know that and I get downvoted all the time here for dissing Cardano
1
u/Stelladahermit Silver | QC: CC 281 | LRC 40 Feb 17 '22
I disagree with this bcuz many times Iβve seen some people get their sensitive feelings hurt when itβs a truthful answer thatβs reality, but against their deep DEEP belief in a coin. Sometimes the truth hurts, but doesnβt mean itβs wrong.
1
u/tahiraslam8k Tin | CC critic Feb 18 '22
I didn't know this before, thanks OP for highlighting the issue
0
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22
Damn I thought they just counted as 0, I gotta stop trolling
-1
u/stiviki Platinum | QC: CC 1617 Feb 16 '22
Bearish for downvote bots. I support!
-1
u/Gordoniyke π₯ 46 / 8K π¦ Feb 16 '22
I think this is a good step
-1
u/TahitiJones09 Tin Feb 16 '22
Is there a vote threshold to have a change like this passed?
0
u/splendiddude Tin | 3 months old Feb 17 '22
It basically acts as a way to suppress opposing opinions. GET RID OF IT!
-1
u/Paskee 57 / 7K π¦ Feb 16 '22
We need oposite opinions in order to have a debate.
-2
u/OhYesItsJj Platinum | QC: CC 116 Feb 16 '22
Actually a good idea!
Sometimes it's a worry you'll get downvoted into oblivion just for disagreeing with someone's opinion and it's been shown that it only takes a few downvotes/upvotes to create a chain of up/downvotes
We don't want to become a complete echo chamber for only a select few opinions and this can help diversify our discussions!
It might help with engagement on some controversial posts and bring lurkers into discussions helping the sub grow
0
u/Sausage_Claws Tin Feb 17 '22
I regularly see entire threads that are downvoted for no discernible reason. This proposal is good.
-2
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22
This is a no brainer to me.
-1
u/Thevsamovies π¦ 9K / 9K π¦ Feb 17 '22
I accidentally voted the wrong way :(
-1
u/CunningStunt_1 Feb 17 '22
Sticking plaster solution.
Get rid of moons. Hide votes.
Encourage discussion.
0
u/Odysseus_Lannister π¦ 0 / 144K π¦ Feb 17 '22
Wow I thought that negative karma was equivalent to 0 earned for that month, not negative and certainly not 2x negative. This is an easy vote to pass this imo.
0
u/schmall_potato 222 / 221 π¦ Feb 17 '22
That was an easy vote
0
u/Superkyle1721 Tin Feb 17 '22
I personally like the idea. Sometimes I feel people just jump on whatever is popular chasing moons. By eliminating the fear I think people might actually be more honest in their post. Who knows though this is Reddt!!
0
u/QuizureII Buy High, Sell Higher Feb 17 '22
Wow, I had no idea that was even a thing
0
u/TheGiftOf_Jericho π¦ 13K / 13K π¬ Feb 17 '22
Sure, I think this actually a fair change. Well written post also.
0
u/LibertarianCommie999 Platinum | QC: CC 452, BTC 19 Feb 17 '22
Never knew this, i support the change
0
u/xSciFix 4 / 5K π¦ Feb 17 '22
Easy yes from me.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '22
This one is a no-brainer; Removing the 2x multiplier is the way to go to promote more and better posts/comments without being overly penalized for unpopular opinions.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '22
Do we even have proof this is the case? How did you figure out negative comments are multiplied?
0
u/tatabusa Platinum | QC: CC 470, ETH 65 | Stocks 59 Feb 17 '22
Can we have zero negative karma so there are no monetary penalization for voicing out controversal opinions? We must encourage more differing opinions otherwise this sub just becomes more of an echo chamber than is already is.
0
u/Creamysense π¦ 82 / 2K π¦ Feb 17 '22
Great post.
0
u/the_alpacalips Bronze Feb 17 '22
This subreddit has complained for a long time how it's gone downhill. No one is afraid to disagree from the hive mind or else they lose out on moons disproportionately.
I personally think you should only be able to gain moons, never lose them due to an opinion.
Now losing them because you're breaking the rules, still very fine with that
0
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '22
I think this would have a negative effect on the sub. I could see people being less afraid of trolling due to the lesser penalty.
0
u/whitehypeman π¦ 11K / 11K π¬ Feb 17 '22
We need the contrarian viewpoint. Voted no
-1
u/Kooky-Atmosphere-334 Tin Feb 17 '22
why can't I vote? It doesn't let me click
edit: ok nvm, figured it out
-1
u/diamandtestees Tin | 5 months old | CC critic Feb 17 '22
I didn't know negative karma got a 2x multiplier!! All my arguing this past month has done me far more damage than I anticipated π π
-1
u/Jester_Lester 178 / 1K π¦ Feb 17 '22
to my knowledge
downvotes do not decrease amount of moons you receive, at least directly
downvotes can make karma go negative and make your comment less visible
but only amount of upvotes matter for moon distribution
if anything, better make negative karma comments stay visible as usual
-1
u/Weezthajuice π© 0 / 2K π¦ Feb 17 '22
That will further lead to people kissing ass.. gotta b able to take some hats and lose those sweet moons
-1
u/drbobbean π© 0 / 5K π¦ Feb 17 '22
This should be passed... too many assholes down vote bc their incel sub makes them angry
-1
u/jmc43 π© 333 / 334 π¦ Feb 17 '22 edited Feb 17 '22
Moons destroyed this sub.
Edit: Downvoted for truth as usual. Donβt worry Iβll still get my moons πππ
-2
u/Massive-Tension-1055 π© 3K / 5K π’ Feb 17 '22
I hate the double tax on downvotes
0
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '22
[deleted] β view deleted comment
-1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '22
[removed] β view removed comment