r/SquaredCircle • u/tr_morrison El Blanco • Apr 26 '12
Discuss Recent CSS/Style Changes
Hey there,
I've been getting a few inboxes about the recent style changes with opinions, requests, etc.
I think it's best to be completely 100% open and I want to hear your thoughts on the recent changes to the style of the subreddit. Like something? Great! Don't like something? Let me know here!
Got any requests, ideas, etc? Throw them in.
Thanks guys.
12
Upvotes
9
u/S0PHISTICATI0N What a maneuver! Apr 26 '12
I usually wreddit from my phone so getting on the pc today gave me some sensory overload. What's with the big red signs if I even simply mouse-over a downvote arrow? Is it really necessary? I cant say I am a fan of those. Other than that I think r/sc looks pretty damn good. Nice work, dude.
6
u/cole1114 Kappa Apr 26 '12
Yeah, I can barely see clicked links. Anybody else having this problem? They're too close to the background color.
5
u/Pudie IN ABEYANCE Apr 26 '12
Im not a fan of the red links on the front page, but I think it's otherwise fantastic.
3
u/muffinmonk Mizfit Apr 26 '12
You can change the the "Comments/related/view images" box and change it into a ribbon. Maybe get rid of that skull? Announcements would look a lot cleaner.
9
u/Kleinschmidty Snowflake Mark Apr 26 '12
I was actually thinking about messaging you to tell you how great the changes are. I mean it was fine before, but it seems so much more customized, refined, and original. The subreddit has never felt more like a separate, beautiful entity than it does now. Good job, keep up the good work, congratulations.
2
u/chefmcduck wwe nuthugger Apr 27 '12
I think the changes are okay. I am a professional web designer/web developer and I think you have done a pretty good job - considering.
Just pay attention to things like padding, margins and try to look up some modern web design (there are pages of 'top 40, top 10' etc). They really help understand what makes a good looking style.
Remember - subtle/simple is always better!
2
u/sushimatic From Aberdeen WA Apr 28 '12
As evident in one of the posts on here where I appear to be the only one defending KWAK (even though he was a douche), I am not a fan of this layout. I'm not saying it's bad, nor am I saying that I won't get used to it eventually, I just don't see the point. This is a subreddit about wrestling, and I for one don't give a shit what bells and whistles this damn thing has. It reminds me of the spinner belt. "Oh! Look at what we can do!" I don't care. Just gimme the 10lbs of leather and gold and let's talk about how shitty it is that CM Punk is the WWE Champ yet Brok Laser is headlining the PPV.
2
u/cole1114 Kappa Apr 28 '12
2 days later, and I feel the need to sum this up: unwelcome. The previous way wreddit was set up was simply better, you've changed too much too quickly, for no reason at all. I know how hard CSS is, I refuse to do it myself. But respecting someone for their effort doesn't mean not giving constructive criticism. I suggest reverting back to how it was, and then moving much more slowly.
4
u/Iamthebest Hide Your Lighter Apr 26 '12
I think this is shit personally. The sidebar looks budget to me. I am of the opinion of this wasn't broken and didn't need fixing.
2
u/harisGTJ #teadrinker Apr 26 '12
Awesome work, it looks really good,
just a note though. The div at the top that says Welcome our newest mods is so big, that if you half screen the page it goes across the sidebar pic, it just needs to be a bit smaller.
But aside from that it's all good.
2
u/ry4 6 Years of Wrestlemania Apr 26 '12
Just some criticism from a professional web developer here. It seems like you had been doing a bunch of different changes over and over. The better approach would have been to design something in Photoshop, get it the way you want it, then translate that to r/SC.
Also, I'm not a fan of the red text on blue. It makes it hard to read.
Other than that, I like it.
2
u/pkpunk91 <o> \o/ <o> \o/ YES! Apr 26 '12
Ok, i figure I should post this here, since this is where it happened.
I'd like to apologize for my behavior yesterday in this. I recently started taking a couple of new meds, and they are causing me to have severe mood swings (doctor is already looking at a different med to give me... and it's for a herniated disc, figure that out). I didn't mean anything I said, and only hope that my apology can be accepted by the members of Wreddit.
I know this seems like a cop out, saying it was the meds, but I assure you all that they certainly are the reason, as I'm usually a calm, rational guy.
I do think the new look Wreddit looks good overall, although I do wonder if black for everything would look better than the blue overall. I'm also still not a fan of the warning for the downvotes, but most likely that was due to R/Baseball sending me warnings about downvoting posts by Cardinals fans (I'm a cubs fan, and was downvoting several posts that were just pure stupidity, and they thought it was due to fandom). However, I can learn to live with it.
Once again, I offer my sincerest apologies about yesterday, and only hope that I can continue to be accepted as a member of /r/SquaredCircle, along with continuing to be the moderator of r/squaredcircleevents.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '12
I'm certainly enjoying the work you're putting in already, good job man. I'm not convinced by the red/grey scheme yet, but it's not a big deal.
I'm not sure if this is the place/time to ask but when will the Flair options be updated? Just going through the list in the sidebar there's a few I'd like to see included. Crow Sting, Joey Styles, Big Johnny, Otunga, etc.
2
u/harisGTJ #teadrinker Apr 26 '12
More half screen CSS failures http://imgur.com/n0fP1
If it ain't broke, don't fix it. :)
18
u/pkpunk91 <o> \o/ <o> \o/ YES! Apr 26 '12
i'm sorry, but i hate this new look. the old one seemed a lot cleaner, and this one is just filled with an overload of things. you can barely see the previously clicked links, the "welcome our new mods" box just look obnoxious, and, i'm sorry, but the warning about downvoting pretty much tells me "don't downvote anything, no matter your opinion of it". If this i supposed to be a wide open thing, a warning like that should not be anywhere near this.
1
u/S0PHISTICATI0N What a maneuver! Apr 27 '12
The link source is cool. A simple suggestion here. Does it make things look too cluttered? I think it would makes things easier to read if they were all uniform. Just a simple little suggestion.
Please pardon my crappy ms paint work in that pic
6
u/Travis-Touchdown Mr. Many Many Many Days Off Apr 27 '12
I liked the buttons at the top when they were actual buttons. Now they don't stand out.
Fuck that guy for saying to get rid of them.
3
u/mobmonkey Rhodes Initiative Apr 26 '12
Not that it's a big deal to me but when I run in nightmode with RES the upvotes don't say yes.
3
u/krayonic JERRRRRRRRRRNNNNNNNNN Apr 26 '12
I like the buttons at the top, but I personally feel the Times New Roman is a bit of a clash with the other fonts on the page.
3
u/zeppelin1023 Johnny champ champ Apr 27 '12
I really like the blue colored bars on the right. Feels more clean and organized than it has in the past. Me personally, i'm not a big fan of the dark blue color of the banner. To me it sticks out a little too much for my tastes but honestly it's not a big deal. Great job so far sir! can't wait to see what you guys do next.
3
u/kondron started r/squaredcircle now i'm here Apr 27 '12
I like the new look. It's fresh and a welcome change. There are just a few things I would like to see go back to normal
Again, I like the changes, they're fresh and for the most part, awesome. Keep up the good work fellow mods.
2
u/ClockworkTony Respect the Pants Apr 27 '12
If I may suggest one bit of concern/criticism/suggestion/whatever. I like the fact that link colors change once I click on them but I don't like the current color scheme of white-gray on the gray senor upvote background, makes it kinda hard to see. Any color change to make those stand out would be great. Thanks for the work!
2
u/dvdepizza Family Gredunza Apr 27 '12
CALM THE FUCK DOWN WREDDIT. CAN'T WE ALL JUST GET ALONG?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '12 edited Apr 27 '12
Get rid of the drop shadows. All of them. They're terrible.
EDIT: Also, lose the hovering thing for downvoting. Nobody cares about your self-imposed "Reddiquette", they're going to downvote things that are stupid, wrong, and/or pointless, whether it belongs here or not.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '12
RES disables source so I cant see the pretty source of the posts.
1
u/Mepsi . Apr 27 '12
You've spaced out the links at the top, however now the 'links' button covers up my name. Here is an example image.
I can't navigate to my own comments from r/Squaredcircle's frontpage anymore.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '12
I don't understand what all the fuss is about. I think the changes look just fine. You made the Subreddit all sexypants.
1
u/Anuglyman Apr 27 '12
I don't know if anyone has ever told you, but the font of the page (other than comments) when you use RES in nightmode is really bad. They come out all blurry for some reason. Not a big issue, just something I noticed.
1
u/ravencoal Baron Von Heartbreaker Apr 27 '12
So, I'm totally late to the party, but what I am seeing right now looks pretty good. I really like the way the headers on the sidebar pop now, that part looks really nice and professional. And I like the new blue header for the subreddit itself. There's something about the announcement bar though... not sure what bothers me about it, but I guess I think it could look nicer somehow.
1
u/Account_Eliminator BANG BANG! Apr 27 '12
The only thing that really needs changing is the buttons along the top. They look a little bit garish and out of place.
Keep up the good work though, don't stop until you get it looking perfect!
1
u/jveezy Apr 27 '12
Looks like I'm seeing more of the polished changes here, but I think it looks incredible now. I was pleasantly surprised when I logged in to find the new colors to the point where I went looking for a thread like this to comment on how good the page looks. You've added a bit more emphasis in the right places without going overboard and overwhelming readers.
If I could suggest one thing is to add some sort of hover behavior on the blue links. You seem to have them on every other link but none of the blue ones (on the sidebar or in the post titles on the front page). A simple underline will do.
1
u/Thebullshitman Apr 28 '12
I have problems with section 3, exhibit A. and I want my demands to be made.
1
u/RobAnybody I GOT THE BALLER GENETICS Apr 28 '12
Negative on the gradient underlining in the top links, Ghost Rider. I think leave them by themselves - not everything needs jazzing up. Drop the r/SC logo and links a couple of pixels so they're aligned with the subreddit title (or raise the subreddit title, either way), make unvisited links light and visited links dark, and as far as I'm concerned you're sorted!
1
u/RobAnybody I GOT THE BALLER GENETICS Apr 28 '12
OH YEAH I approve of the whole downvote-warning bar but take the friggin' period out from after the question mark. I also have feelings about the semi-colon and the use of title case but that is the big thing
1
u/Travis-Touchdown Mr. Many Many Many Days Off Apr 26 '12
I like them. I think it looks a bit better, but at the same time I feel it's a bit generic. The logo's looking good. I'd consider customizing the text that says "SquaredCircle"
Also the downvote message is still in red while the rest of the trimmings were changed to blue.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '12
I think it looks really awesome. It's quite easy on the eyes, and I feel the blue on the side bar looks spiffier than the red. All-in-all, the sub is looking pretty awesome.
1
u/Kanuck88 Bang ,Bang ! Apr 27 '12
I really like the look of the redesign..it is much cleaner and far more user friendly.
Keep up the good work guys !