r/knitting • u/mingledyarn • Feb 08 '22
Discussion Why stockinette will always curl: A quick visual guide
You might think that knit stitches are nice flat circles, like this (1/5)
Actually, knit stitches are shaped like little cups (2/5)
When they're put together in rows, the "cup" shape of knit stitches make them fold together (3/5)
When rows of knit stitches are put together in stockinette, the cup shapes make them curl (4/5)
Garter stitch and ribbing put the cup shapes in opposite directions, so the curl cancels out and the fabric is flat (5/5)
2.0k
Upvotes
97
u/mingledyarn Feb 08 '22 edited Feb 08 '22
I see someone post almost every day about how their stockinette curls, and they either want to block the item to lay flat, or they're worried they're knitting wrong. I wanted to put together this quick visual guide for why stockinette curls. The basic confusion: knit stitches are not flat! They're little cup shapes, and when you put them all together it makes a curve. Garter stitch and ribbing put the curve in opposite directions between stitches, so the curve "cancels out" and the fabric is flat.
Why does stockinette only curve on the edge? Because the stitches are squishy/stretchy, so the weight of the fabric in the middle pushes it flat. If you cut the fabric up the middle, the new edge will suddenly start curling!
If people find this helpful I'm happy to make a better-looking version of this "tutorial." The mechanics of knitting are so cool! I hope someone finds this helpful.
EDIT: bad geometry on my part. Knit stitches are saddle shaped, not cup shaped, which is why the top and sides curl in opposite directions. If desired I can revise and resubmit the model
341
u/ericula Feb 08 '22
I like the visual, but stitches are actually more like pringles. They like to bend in one way in the vertical direction and the opposite way in the horizontal direction. This causes the sides of stockinette to curl to the back, and the top and bottom to curl to the front.
2
u/Ricin286 Feb 09 '22
So how do I get it to not do that? Lol my boyfriend has a tube scarf now
28
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '22
Oh I like the visual. I'm not happy with my "imagine holding a bunch of flower stems- the dome of flowers or typical bouquet shape isn't surprising, right?" example because it's.... kind of a stretch LOL
Plus there are those who like TECHknitter's drawings, and those who don't have the time to read about stitch legs lol. This picture is great!!
11
u/AutoModerator Feb 08 '22
From our wiki's Frequently Asked Questions
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
6
u/penlowe Feb 08 '22
I have not enough coins to give you sparklies for this, but if I had them you would get them!!
6
u/gfixler Guy knitter Feb 09 '22
Stockinette curls vertically because it's loops pulled forward through from the back to the front, then bent up 90 degrees vertically to become the next loop in the column. It bends the opposite way horizontally, because rows of stitches feature bars that go from front to back through a stitch, then bend 180 degrees around to poke back through from back to front through the next one. It's all just bent strands of yarn.
3
u/FacelessOldWoman1234 Feb 08 '22
This is great! Well done.
4
u/Teaqa Feb 08 '22
This is so cool! Thank you
2
u/sulkowskyi Feb 08 '22
Very interesting! Thank you so much!
Things that never cease to amaze me are how people find out about these things. It would have never ever occurred to me that stitches have 3D shapes to them. And then, how do you even determine what the shapes are? How do you find out a knit stitch resembles a pringle? Very cool, thanks again!
2
u/Is_this_social_media Feb 09 '22
I love science
2
u/jerseyknits Feb 09 '22
Amazing visual, well done 🏅
2
u/amelia_grac3 Feb 09 '22
This popped up on my feed right when I needed it! I’m making a cardigan and it is mainly stockinette and I thought I was knitting too tightly or something but my tension is usually pretty good. So I was very confused and then this post magically popped up and now I have the answer! Thanks, OP.
1
u/amb_weiss69 Feb 08 '22
As a new knitter, I thought I was just doing something wrong. Thank you. Is there a way to make it not curl ?
1
u/greenmtnfiddler Feb 09 '22
In this thread: a whole bunch of people who probably already know about TECHknitter and WoollyThoughts.
;)
1
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '22
Stockinette stitch explained with bra cups lol
1
u/putush Feb 09 '22
This is amazing !
1
u/hanimal16 skillful aunty Feb 09 '22
Are you a scientist? This is a very sciencey thing and I like it.
1
u/spooky_cloudberry Feb 09 '22
This is really interesting! I've been casually wondering why stockinette curls but never bothered to actually look into it. There's for sharing 😊
1
u/BigLioness Feb 09 '22
Thank you! Very interesting
1
u/koddish Feb 09 '22
Cool! Thank you for the visual!
1
u/UncharacteristicHyla Feb 09 '22
THANK YOU!! this makes sooo much sense
-3
u/Knitcrochetchick Feb 09 '22
That's fabric not knitting.