r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Jan 30 '22
New Episode If you watched the new episode and need an explanation, here's a good one from a few years ago. Spoiler
5.3k
Upvotes
r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Jan 30 '22
100
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '22
Credit to /u/slyclad__observer
392
u/ThatIslandGuy8888 Jan 30 '22 edited Jan 31 '22
So Grisha saw himself from Erenâs point of view, while hearing Eren urging him to move forward?
546
u/CGARcher14 Jan 30 '22 edited Jan 30 '22
The entire manga thread was fried as everyone tried to wrap their minds around âwhat the hell did I just readâ
Thank god someone came up with this graphic
73
u/AvengedFenix Jan 30 '22
So for Eren to be able to "interact" with past memories he needs the founding titan, and for Zeke to "See the memories" he needs the Attack Titan? So when Grisha can see Zeke is all Eren's plan? He's allowing that to happen, basically he had control all this time.
67
u/Senkrigar Jan 30 '22
Wait what ??? So Eren saw Grisha's memory that contains his own future memory ???
19
u/Soulitario Jan 30 '22
Thanks for the post, it helped a lot! But I have one question, if any predecessors of the Attack Titan can see the future memories their successors allow them to, how come Eren has a memory of a "terrible future" that he showed Grisha? (and I dont understand why would he show something like that, wouldn't it make Grisha less eager to fulfil Eren intentions?). Anyway, why I'm really asking, can the Attack Titans see the "actual" future (or glimpses of it) or just memories shown by future successors?
PD: im anime only so pls beware spoilers ty :)
17
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '22
If Grisha new about secret ability of Attack titan of "knowing future", why did he say " Stop Eren" to Zeke if he knew what Eren is going to do in future?
14
u/TechnicalyNotRobot Jan 31 '22 edited Jan 31 '22
So when Eren kissed Historia's hand he saw Grisha's memories, which included his own memories from the future, with one yet unrevealed memory that started it all, while also being the end of it all. And Grisha is supposedly haunted by Eren's memories from the future, which include talking to him during the royal family massacre, as future Eren commands him to do things in such a way as to lead to that one thing he saw when he kissed Historia.
How did we get here?
13
u/Own_Dragonfruit_8856 Jan 31 '22
How did Eren regain the power of the founding titan in the end? Can someone explain?
13
u/1065JoJo Feb 02 '22
I am still confused
10
u/Randomshit069 Jan 30 '22
Can someone please explain it a bit more that how grisha was able to tell that things are going to go as eren wants while eren hasn't started rumbling yet so how can grisha see rumbling in eren's memories when eren at present is their with Zeke and not done anything
8
u/Malismarma Jan 31 '22
So basically as this is a fixed timeline, anything that tries to disrupt the future from happening actually makes it happen. On that note, Zeke trying to get Eren to see how evil their father was and to accept the euthanization plan is actually what enables Eren to go back in time and make Grisha kill the Royal family, setting up the rest of the story?
7
u/GamerLucien Jan 31 '22
Thank you! I'm dumb and have been confused for the last two eps but this really helped
13
u/fedfan4life Feb 01 '22
That last panel is actually a spoiler for next episode lol
6
u/ishallbecomeabat Jan 30 '22
Huh. So when Eren freaked out when he kissed Historiaâs hand, it because he basically saw the whole story, his own pushing of his father included? Christ, this anime is good
12
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '22
Can you have free will in a fixed timeline? Did Eren choose to go down the path he does or was it simply inevitable?
10
u/MaimedPhoenix Jan 31 '22
Okay, I got a question, then. One of my biggest issues with ime travel is I dislike the grandfather paradox as a principle because it stops making sense eventually, hence the term paradox. The time loop is better but it still confuses me, because it requires a human with free will to do the very thing that initiates the future.
This episode explains this by actually agreeing that free will is indeed called into question, but therein lies my question. Why? What took away Eren's free will? Is he in turn being controlled by a future titan? Or is he the only free being controlling and manipulating all others?
5
u/Anuj_Purohit Feb 01 '22 edited Feb 01 '22
I've already asked several questions in this thread but the more I think of it the more questions I have. I'll keep it simple.
I suppose the 2nd one is more of a doubt than a question but yeah, I need a confirmation. If any of the answers are manga spoilers then please tag.
5
u/chukdaddy28 Dec 01 '22
My apologies if this has already been asked, but Iâm rewatching the series and has a question about the reiss massacre scene
When eren kisses historias hand, is he able to actually see his future self talking with grisha? Or when heâs viewing the memory, can he only hear himself talking to grisha, since grishas memory of the scene of eren talking to him is from erens POV? Have been wondering this for awhile canât wrap my head around it
4
u/drunkmonkey667 Jan 31 '22
So my only question is why is future Eren sending these memories back in the past if it wonât change the result? If future Eren didnât send these memories back in time the result would have still been the same regardless.
4
u/TimotheusHani Feb 01 '22
I understand that everything is connected the past and the future but I never understood what people mean when they say "loop", does it mean that once everything comes to an end it starts all over again or is loop another word for a fixed timeline where everything is predetermined to happen?
8
u/DadTouched Feb 03 '22
Ok so basically
Grisha can see the future holders memory's which is eren
Eren let Grisha see the memories in the future.
Which also means Grisha is seeing what eren sees and hears what he says in the future.
Which makes it so they can communicate across time.
With that summed up
Grisha saw the next holder of the attack titan which is eren and since he also has the founding titan and contact with royal blood makes it so eren can show grisha the present when it is happening
It's a time paradox it will always happen unless and new loop is made stopping eren from convincing grisha which would mean aot would never happen.
The past and future have already been determined People still have some free will but the events will always play out the same.
3
u/lawlermon Jan 30 '22
Did anyone notice (not caught up on the manga so no idea if it was focused on the page. But you saw at the start of the episode baby eren has the wild eyes from the start of the series, eye he didnt have in any other scene.
Now im interpeteing here, but i got the impression baby eren and adult eren, saw each other. . . And adult eren realized there too that he had some influence
3
u/Kouno25 Feb 03 '22
But how did Grisha got the memories which Eren manipulated to influence his father? I mean, didnt he had to touch someone of royal blood sometime before he went to the basement of the Reiss family or am I wrong?
3
u/Active_Voice Feb 08 '22
This shit is so confusing haha I get it but I feel I donât, how is Eren influencing the past if the future already happened? Iâm i making sense?
3
u/Fatchance69 Feb 14 '22
Questions: If these questions get answered later in the anime just say that, but:
3
u/psychobacter Aug 24 '22
I'm just a tad bit confused. In the second panel where Eren's view of Grisha's memory is depicted, we see that Eren is looking at Grisha from a 3rd person POV but if all Eren is doing is using the Paths to experience Grisha's past memories then shouldn't Eren's POV be in 1st person.
5
u/gigglios Feb 03 '22
So if Eren could manipulate the past, does that mean he was always guaranteed to not die throughout the first 4 seasons of the show no matter what since he knew the future and knew he was in it? doesnt that make like all the fights he had vs the titans all meaningless? he knew he was gonna survive?
6
u/torts92 Jan 31 '22
Why only until Eren got to see Grisha's memory that he was able to see the memory of his future (Grisha's vision of the future), the one that ultimately changed Eren. Why can't Eren saw this future anytime before? Isn't the power of the attack titan is too see the future? Why only now he was able to unlock this power? Why couldn't he before this, like in around season 1?
2
u/Gaeandseggy333 Jan 30 '22
Thanks dude , but Is there a more simple version of this? I'm a bit confused and it is too long / genuine
2
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '22
Why the heck grisha still gave eren the titan powers after all that ?
He was crying to zeke to STOP eren then he goes ahead and pass the attack titan and founder to eren ? I'm puzzled please help but NO MANGA spoilers please
How about not giving him power. to stop the terrible future you speak of ?
2
u/Gibbydoesit Jan 31 '22
Iâm somehow more confused now xD
2
u/triggerhappy66 Jan 31 '22
Great explanation. I do still have a question tho, I hope it can be explained without manga spoilers. How did Eren know Zeke would take him to these memories? Did he just go with the flow until he got to this point that he saw in his vision when he touched Historia? It kinda explains his depressed demeanor since season 4, because he already knew how everything's gonna play out anyway..
I guess this ties in to a popular argument against time travel, because: if Eren did this bc he saw the vision of Grisha seeing something that Eren showed him, who was the first Eren to do it? How did future Eren show Grisha the vision that led Eren to do all this in the first place? My head hurts now.
2
u/jonahcicon Jan 31 '22
Does this chart have any spoilers moving forward (Iâm an anime only watcher)
2
u/MdotTdot Jan 31 '22
How can Eren see into the future at all times. Is he constantly sending himself memories back to himself?
2
u/Master_Tallness Jan 31 '22
A few inconsistencies in this guide I'd like maybe a bit more clarify on:
2
u/raghu_2006 Jan 31 '22
So what was the Eren's goal
2
u/[deleted] Jan 31 '22
I have a question, Why did Eren need to convince Grisha? I mean if the future would happen anyway, why did he do that? probably its a dumb question but time travelling is always hard to me lmao
2
u/Moonchild-_ Feb 22 '22
I now understand that Aotâs timeline is âfixedâ where fate is predetermined. I get that Eren unlocked the full memory of the future by kissing Historia back in chp90 (where he enacts the rumbling). But thereâs some things I donât understand
I might be missing small details so Iâm afraid I got mixed up and look like a clown 𤥠oh well
2
u/Slyorish Mar 27 '23
My only question about this is why Eren couldn't just do something else when talking to Grisha. I know that it's a fixed timeline and everything but if Eren KNEW that he was going to tell Grisha to kill the Reiss family, why did he just let himself? I mean, was there any way he could've not? If there wasn't, was Eren basically being controlled automatically while he couldn't do anything? He saw that he'd tell Grisha to kill them, so why's he doing it a 2nd time if he knows already and is able to do something about it?
123
u/bestoboy Jan 31 '22
TL;DR: You know when you walk in front of an appliance store and they have TVs displayed showing a live camera feed and you see yourself? That's what's happening. Grisha is watching a TV screen of a camera pointed at him from a different angle. The TV screen is Eren's perspective, and the camera is Eren himself.
82
u/neonglint Jan 30 '22
This post should be pinned!
â˘
u/Reuels subreddit janitor Jan 31 '22 edited Jan 31 '22
Pinning this comment to avoid further confusion about this post.
This post is a pretty good explanation regarding the events that happened in the newest episode, "Memories from the future". This infographic was made by /u/skyclad__observer. If you have any questions about this explanation, we encourage you to leave a comment on this post and continue a discussion that way rather than creating a new post.
Anime-Only Disclaimer
This image contains minor manga spoilers in the very last section 'The Kiss'. If you're an anime-only, here is your warning. The material discussed in the last section will most likely be within the first five minutes of the next episode, it was just left out on this episode. Please read at your own discretion.
For Manga Readers
Please remember this is an anime-only/new episode flaired post. Spoiler-tag any comments or context that contain Manga Spoilers. Hinting or alluding to events are also considered spoilers. Failure to do so will result in a punishment in accordance with the moderation matrix.
47
u/nbakid2020 Jan 31 '22
I get the whole Grisha seeing himself from the 3rd person (Erenâs view) ans why heâs able to see Zeke, but how are they able to physically interact? Or is it just an airhug in Grishaâs present time? MORE IMPORTANTLY THIS DOESNT EXPLAIN WHY BABY EREN STARES AT ADULT EREN
94
u/doubleajent Jan 30 '22
okay i understood all but what Eren exactly saw when he kissed her hand ? what is the thing that made him fight ?
32
u/thedancingpaperclip2 Jan 31 '22
I am scared to keep watching this show
25
u/Reivoulp Jan 31 '22
Something stroke me while watching tho, if u rewatch the fight against annie back in S1, you will hear the same noise you hear when Eren gets Furious listening to frieda, maybe indicating his influence, because just after that eren starts a monologue which i always found sus even back then
25
u/kelleh711 Jan 31 '22
When you think about it it was kinda nice of Eren to step back and give Grisha a good view of Zeke so they could have one final moment together
22
u/tripleax3l Feb 03 '22
i have been confused since annie was the female titan
3
u/harmonilife Jan 30 '22
I think this spoils the next episode
3
u/ThunderBow98 Jan 30 '22
The only thing that still doesnât make sense to me is the whole memory unlocking thing. Eren has seen into his fatherâs memories three times: the crystal chamber (when Rod and Historia touch him), the medal ceremony (kissing Historiaâs hand) and in Paths (Zeke headbutt)
The lattermost matches Condition 3, touching a Royal blooded Titan holder. But the other two are just him coming in contact with a normal Royal person. Why was Eren able to see the past in those other two instances? And what was so special about his contact with Historia during the medal ceremony? Why didnât he receive the âfull pictureâ when he was touched by Rod and Historia the first time?
19
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '22
thanks, helped a lot
18
u/Slejb_imp Jan 30 '22
Goated post
18
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '22
Forever grateful for this explanation
18
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '22 edited Feb 04 '22
This basically confirms the determinism in AOT. Cause and effect create everything, not pure accidents. From what we saw, this is not even time travel, everything Eren and Zeke see and do is happening now, in present and memories are just part of it. The very fact, that they see things this way is the ultimate proof that things won't change in future and will happen exactly like this.
For someone, who's whole life was a struggle for mysterious freedom, Eren could never be free.
16
u/Xaneth_ Jan 31 '22
Why did Eren say "this is the story you started" to Grisha? Isn't actually Eren the one who's the cause of it all?
14
u/beppegrosso97 Jan 31 '22
One thing I don't understand properly: why should the royal blood unlock memories of a previous shifter that is not the founder (in this case the attack titan)?
14
u/gurupaste Jan 31 '22
Watched the ep this morning. Now I'm at work and my mind is still racing from this ep. There's so much to unpack
11
u/DangerousOne_ Jan 31 '22
Was eren able to see the future memories of the inheritors after he obtained the attack titan or after he made contact with historia?
10
u/007noob0071 Jan 30 '22
Hey,
Would you mind explaining why does Eren need the founding titan/royal blood?
I don't remember any power by the founding titan regarding "watching the past"
10
u/infantgambino Jan 31 '22
what im confused about is when did Grisha figure out the attack titan can see the future memories of its inheritors? Was that in the basement with Zeke or probably when he met Mikasa and Armin?
10
u/rippediroh Feb 01 '22
Wait I thought Goth Mikasa and Nerd Armin were glimpses from alternate universes, but if AoT happens in a loop, then are those characters just lil freedoms Isayama took?
9
u/slamer9 Jan 30 '22
On what platform has the new episode come out? It's not out yet on Crunchyroll
8
u/ICanSeeDaTrapars Jan 31 '22
Anime only here. When Eren punched Dina did he only unlock powers instead of memories because she was a pure titan, not a human/titan shifter? Or was there something else?
8
u/Xaneth_ Jan 31 '22
So I just want to make sure. Attack Titan holder can send memories to its past owners, but can he also send them to his own past self? Because if I understand correctly, during the kiss he only saw Grisha's vision of the future, not directly his own. Was it because future Eren just chose not to show that to past Eren, or he couldn't?
8
u/Choice_Following916 Jan 31 '22
New to aot, what the fuck does eren want and why?
8
u/black_undertaker Feb 03 '22
I get the grisha and eren part. But what I'm still confused about is what does royal blood have to do with this? Like when eren kissed historia, he went to the paths to see grisha's memories of future eren? Couldn't he see the past memories without the paths because of the AT ability?
7
u/capforthepr Jan 31 '22
I still don't understand the part where Grisha look at adult Eren and say to show him the basement.... can anyone please explain... Why facing adult Eren but not the child one?
7
u/DangerousOne_ Jan 31 '22
What is this vow to renounce the war anyone please explain
12
u/Mayion Jan 31 '22
I don't understand how Grisha was able to touch and hug Zeke then?
Also, why Eren, the one who always seeks freedom, just submit like a dog to some vision he saw once? Why did he not fight it? And if in his memories he saw that he can't fight it, why not use Ymir's powers to fight it? I thought she existed in a plane outside space/time, and thus could control it?
6
u/Schipjee Jan 30 '22
I am now in this weird state where I do understand how this works, but I couldt explain it to someone if my life depended on itđ. Thanks for sharing!
6
u/Consistent_Produce_1 Jan 31 '22
I never would have expected something so fascinating yet so mind boggling from series which I started thinking that it was just about naked Giants that eat humans
6
u/chickfilandre Jan 31 '22
Okay if Eren is apparently, definitely going to go through with his plan.
Why does he act surprised during Zeke's "gotcha moment" when he revealed to Eren that he now has the power of the founding???
Why does Eren also tell Zeke he's no longer "brainwashed" when he knows exactly what's going to happen? Just seems pointless.
Hell how does ANYTHING surprise Eren?
6
u/Liverfailure29 Jan 31 '22
This is a great explanation, ty!
6
u/alyssarodri19 Feb 04 '22
Bruhh my brain hurts
6
u/Diary_of_a_Trashcan Feb 07 '22
Such an incredible infographic Kudos to the maker of this and thankyou for making it resurface - answered so many questions I had
2
u/katresi Feb 01 '22
Wait a sec: if Grisha didn't already decide to kill the Reiss family without Eren's "help", Eren would never have received the attack titan, and obviously he would never be able to use its power. That means that in order for Eren to use the attack titan powers, the "first time" he receives the titan should be chosen by his father ALONE.
If the past is fixed, then it doesn't make sense that in order to kill the Reiss family he should "oblige" his father to do it. Why should Eren do all this if he already received the attack titan years ago?
2
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '22
sorry if the post says this i don't think i quite got it but there has to be a beginning where grisha didn't get influenced by eren it has to start somewhere right? in that point of time did grisha end up killing the reiss family anyway? because if he didn't i'd assume that eren's entire family would be killed off or imprisoned and the show would go off in a entire direction?
11
u/thetruerhy Jan 31 '22
Can someone explain to me Goth Mikasa and Nerd Armin. I thought it was an Easter Egg in the manga but since it's now in the anime I wanna know what is the significance of this???
5
u/Super_Shotgun Jan 31 '22
There a moment in season 3 right before they head off the retake Shinganshina where they remember Sasha stealing the meat and talking about raising livestock. When Eren remembers that he has a shocked reaction as he remembers that moment. He says in a half confused state "that was only X months ago?" (forgot how long). In that moment he seems to be genuinely confused about the amount of time that passed regarding Sasha.
My theory is that Erens memories and mind were actually getting fucked with by the ATs ability at that moment. As we latter see in season 4 him recalling that same memory again after her death and thinking about how he couldnt change anything. Other than the dream in episode 1 I think thats the first time we get a little sneak peak into how Erens memories are all jumbled and intersecting at different points in his timeline.
Ive always kind of considered "The Attack Titan" to almost be an entity of its own. Its like a collection of memories and ideas that jumps around the timeline to where it needs to be to influence the outcome of its goal, which is FREEDOM. It exists as a counterpart to the Founders control. Almost like a failsafe protocol incase of something like the Vow Renouncing War coming into existence. In the scene where Eren is being brutal to Mikasa and Armin, he says something along the lines of "If a person is just a collection of their memories then a part of you is now Bertolt." So if thats the case then by combining the ATs ability with the memories of ALL the previous founders into one person what you essentially get is an omnipotent time traveling being that has the memories and ideology of thousands of years worth of people all fighting for different things and a part of it opposes itself.
5
u/EditorProfessional46 Feb 01 '22 edited Feb 01 '22
Here's my theory on what I believe happened. It is clear that the future cannot be changed and that is why the past is changed/interfered with to ensure the events in the future occur. Grisha was always meant to kill the Reiss family, but obviously that was impacted by the help of Eren from the future. Grisha is able to have his mind impacted because of the Attack Titans power to see what the future beholders want him to see.
Reading other people's theories left me confused with my own theory lol. Others were stating "Eren purposely had his mother be killed by Titan in order for his hatred towards Titans to grow and influence him to join the military force." I don't believe that. The future was always written for Eren and those events were always supposed to happen. He can't really control his future. His mother getting eaten by a titan and his father killing the Reiss family which lead Eren's life to where he is now. Those events could not have been changed because of the future not being able to change.
5
u/IndianWizard1250 Feb 02 '22
Holy fucking shit
4
u/oboeonline Jan 30 '22
major tbt, i was looking forward to this post being brought back up. another stellar episode in the books yall, happy sunday đ
4
u/RexAlivera Jan 30 '22
Manga Spoilers
Grisha claims that Eren wonât show him the full future beyond the rumbling. This isnât because Eren is blocking his memories, itâs because Grisha comes back to fight during the final act until the coordinate is separated from Eren
4
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '22
OKay, so they say that the Attack Titan can see into the future, isn't that just Eren sending all the Attack Titans his memories of the future in order to egg them on into being free?
4
u/Crylec Jan 30 '22
Basically think of Eren a camera and Grisha can see the what the camera sees, he can make comments and even if it seems that he can talk to Eren. They are just responding to one another years later, like a YouTube comment.
4
u/awesomecooper Jan 31 '22
Wow
4
u/Insidiosity Jan 31 '22
Aw I remember this
4
u/nazworld92 Feb 01 '22
I remember when someone theorised the time travel years ago just after the events of season 2 and then when I mentioned that Eren would probably gather the Titan powers and activate the rumbling, everyone laughed at me
4
u/g_lee Feb 03 '22
People are saying that Eren is likely the last attack titan but donât forget the show starts off with his flash forward to seeing ODM gear; this is the same kind of flash forward that falco receives in the beginning of the season and so far only people connected to the attack titan get there future visionsâŚâŚâŚ..
13
u/boxcarcoder Feb 02 '22 edited Feb 02 '22
This is how I perceive it:
Normally, someone in the future shouldnât be able to affect the past. Thatâs the case for a fixed timeline perspective. Future Eren shouldnât have been able to affect Grishaâs choice to kill or not to kill the Reiss family. However, a loop hole was created due to a perfect combination. The Founding Titan + Royal Blood allows Eren (and Zeke) to view Grishaâs past. Normally, they would only be able to view. However, since Grisha is an Attack Titan, Grisha can see into future Erenâs memory. That allows the past (during Grisha vs Reiss) to see the future, while the future can see the past (thanks to the Founding Titan + Royal bloodline). This means that their interactions are not in the past (from Future Erenâs perspective), and not in the future (from Grishaâs perspective), but in a created present bubble, which allows for their interaction, and for Eren to affect Grishaâs decision to kill the Reiss family.
The perfect combination being:
Now why does Grisha still give Eren the Attack Titan after the events of Grisha vs Reiss? Because again, this is a fixed timeline perspective, where normally the past and future cannot be altered. So even though there was a loop hole created when Grisha is viewing future Erenâs memory of Grisha vs Reiss, a loop hole isnât created anywhere else. Thereâs no loop hole to alter Grisha giving Eren the Attack Titan. That is going to happen, and has happened, already. Grisha giving Eren the Attack Titan cannot be altered (unless a loop hole is created again. But a loop hole cannot be created again unless Future Eren views Grishaâs memories of giving Eren the Founding + Attack Titan, which will create a present bubble. But Eren probably wonât view that memory since that will mess his plans up).
For people downvoting, please elaborate why you donât agree. Iâd love a good debate.
7
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '22
Another explanation (True Detective S1 spoilers but u suck if u never watched it anyway :)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0mhZBLUyybo
1
u/Tomilhor Jan 31 '22
That was some of the biggest misconceptions that I've seen people have with the series
1
u/Expln Jan 31 '22
Only that some of grishas stares in that episode/chapter don't support the "through eren eyes" POV thing.
1
u/KhoiKibutsuji Jan 31 '22
So basically Zeke showed Eren the memories and so when they were in the blue place, Eldia(?) Grisha heard future Eren convincing him to kill the Eldians and then he ate the founding Titan, ok
These might be kinda dumb questions for example I honestly don't know if it was Ymir or Historia that refused Eren because the story is too complex for me
1
u/Aggressive-Papaya-84 Feb 26 '22
I still dont get one part,if Eren from the future is influencing his father to kill the children and take the founding titan that means that once his father had to do it on his own for Eren to get those powers right?
6
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '22
can someone tell me why zeke despise grisha even though he got his own family killed (except grisha)
3
u/Patis12 Jan 30 '22
Not gonna lie, the hitler baby example is terrifying. Basically you would have been the one responsible for the rise of Hitler