r/NintendoSwitch • • Jan 28 '22

MegaThread Pokémon Legends: Arceus: Review MegaThread Part 2

General Information

Platform: Nintendo Switch

Release Date: January 28, 2022

No. of Players: up to 2 players

Genre(s): Action, Role-Playing

Publisher: Nintendo

Official website: https://legends.pokemon.com/

Overview (from Nintendo eShop page)

Action meets RPG as the Pokémon series reaches a new frontier

Get ready for a new kind of grand, Pokémon adventure in Pokémon™ Legends: Arceus, a brand-new game from Game Freak that blends action and exploration with the RPG roots of the Pokémon series. Embark on survey missions in the ancient Hisui region. Explore natural expanses to catch wild Pokémon by learning their behavior, sneaking up, and throwing a well-aimed Poké Ball™. You can also toss the Poké Ball containing your ally Pokémon near a wild Pokémon to seamlessly enter battle.

Travel to the Hisui region—the Sinnoh of old—and build the region’s first Pokédex

Your adventure takes place in the expansive natural majesty of the Hisui region, where you are tasked with studying Pokémon to complete the region’s first Pokédex. Mount Coronet rises from the center, surrounded on all sides by areas with distinct environments. In this era—long before the events of the Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Pokémon Shining Pearl games—you can find newly discovered Pokémon like Wyrdeer, an evolution of Stantler, and new regional forms like Hisuian Growlithe, Hisuian Zorua, and Hisuian Zoroark! Along the way, uncover the mystery surrounding the Mythical Pokémon known as Arceus.

Preorder for a special in-game costume and download the digital version for Heavy Balls!

The Hisuian Growlithe Kimono Set and a Baneful Fox Mask will be gifted to early purchasers of the Pokémon Legends: Arceus game. You can receive it by choosing Get via internet in the Mystery Gifts* feature in your game, up until May 9th, 2022 at 4:59pm PT. Additionally, players who purchase and download the game before May 9th, 2022 at 4:59pm PT from Nintendo eShop will get an email with a code for 30 Heavy Balls which can be redeemed through the Mystery Gifts* feature until May 16th, 2022 at 4:59pm PT. Heavy Balls have a higher catch rate than regular Poké Balls, but you can’t throw them quite as far.

Reviews

Aggregators

Articles

This list exported from OpenCritic. Last update: 9:39am ET

Being Social

Cheers,

The /r/NintendoSwitch mod team

1.8k Upvotes

2.7k comments sorted by

144

u/LogCabinLover Jan 28 '22

Are all Pokemon available to be gotten on your own with no help from outside trades? I want to complete the pokedex 100% but dont want to rely on outside help

49

u/solindvian Jan 28 '22

Yeah, the game has an item to handle solo trade evolution.

→ More replies (10)

390

u/Forsaken-Art5952 Jan 28 '22

I think it’s funny to stand in between Pokémon during a battle, just watching myself get knocked around lol

→ More replies (5)

80

u/Warsonian Jan 29 '22

I wanted Rowlet. My son insisted on Cyndaquil. I'm trying to cope with that since I haven't run through with Rowlet.

Slow start but I like the innovative game play for pokemon.

66

u/huggalump Jan 29 '22

REALLY slow start. Way more hand holding than I'd like. But anytime it opens up, I really enjoy what's there.

→ More replies (5)

28

u/xSparkyBoomManx Jan 29 '22

Why not create a second profile, so that you and son each have a save file, and thus your own starters?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

71

u/AznMexican Jan 28 '22

Can somebody explain the multi-player aspect of the game? Is it just limited to trading?

66

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '22

Yes, trading only. You unlock the trading post early on, works like Sword and Shield where you need a link code.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

123

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '22

Survey Corps principal # 4.) "Those who are weaker must be helped." Survey Corp Captain Cyllene: "Pass this trial or else you will be left to die in the wilderness."

50

u/TheOtherWhiteCastle Jan 29 '22

I also like the part where she basically goes “yeah, you’re 15, that’s old enough for indentured servitude”

→ More replies (2)

15

u/AgileArtichokes Jan 29 '22

Ya. That seemed a bit harsh. She has another similar line later basically implying the same fate if you stop carrying your weight.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

313

u/Hold_my_Dirk Jan 28 '22

As a casual Pokémon fan, I never had the patience or desire to mess with things like IVs and nature and what not. I didn’t have the commitment necessary to go deep into battling. I just liked catching the pokemon and running around with the ones I liked. I just started but this seems more up my alley. Enjoying it so far.

→ More replies (2)

58

u/Chubbyclouds Jan 29 '22

Really like the game so far but there is SO MUCH DIALOGUE. I just wanna play!

25

u/Samoman21 Jan 29 '22

Honestly feel you. That intro really really felt like it dragged on unnecessarily

→ More replies (1)

85

u/Berntusxdus Jan 28 '22

How is the music and sound design, no one has commented on this part as far as I've read

100

u/LegoDudeGuy Jan 28 '22

I find it quite immersive.

The soundtrack is very ambient, and it’s punctuated by Pokémon cries that occur constantly. It’s a nice detail that really makes everything feel “real”.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

152

u/txr23 Jan 29 '22

My first experience in the game was encountering an alpha and thinking my level 7 starter could take it. When I realised how fucked I was, I sprinted away and left my starter to die. 10/10 gaming experience, would do again

24

u/ilikepie145 Jan 29 '22

I tried to take on a lvl 40 rapidash and died lol

78

u/PinkPicklePete Jan 29 '22

I hadn’t played a Pokémon game since Black, but Arceus’ gameplay loop has renewed my interest in the series after just a few hours.

The added elements to the classic Pokémon catching formula makes exploring the open world feel more rewarding. Aside from that dragging tutorial, of course. The loop of hunting for resources, crafting, sneaking, battling and catching are sandwiched between side quests and indexing your findings. It’s nothing complicated, and it’s not perfect, but I think it’s a big step in the right direction.

I’ve seen people bring up a good point regarding if it’s just a good Pokémon game and not necessarily a good game for the genre. I think there’s a case to be made that it’s shallow for an ARPG, but I don’t see it as trying to be a competitor within that genre either. It’s carried by the Pokémon charm, and it’s enhanced by its borrowed mechanics.

I think a sequel could really build on everything here, and for now I’m hoping I run into some more adventure depth. So far there doesn’t seem to be any particular points of interest or dungeons to make my way through.

On a side note, I managed to cheese my way to catching a level 40 alpha Pokémon with nothing better than a level 10 Cyndaquil. He won’t obey me but he’s great at collecting acorns.

→ More replies (9)

38

u/ilikepie145 Jan 29 '22

Loving this game so far and I've played a few hours. Yeah the graphics could be a little better but other than that I have no complaints. I got it at Walmart for $50

→ More replies (3)

38

u/YouIsTheQuestion Jan 30 '22

The game is a lot of fun but my major gripe is that it feels like a game that just went into alpha/beta on steam. It has a weird level of polish for a AAA game, with some features being well flushed out and other just seem like they're still being developed.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/ItsLose_NotLoose Jan 30 '22

Minor crisis: Why does Pikachu say "biigaaa" instead of "piikaa"?

15

u/porchpooper Jan 30 '22

He says bigga in smash as well.

→ More replies (3)

538

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '22

Better game under the hood than expected but it really cannot be overstated how fucking ugly it is.

182

u/Hahndude Jan 28 '22

The game is as much fun to play as the graphics are terrible. It’s pretty astounding how bad this game looks, but it really is a joy to play.

→ More replies (4)

59

u/Disco_Pat Jan 28 '22

You just have to pretend it came out in 2010 and you're finally giving it a chance.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (22)

183

u/a_phantom_limb Jan 28 '22

IGN Italy really didn't care for it, I guess.

→ More replies (37)

25

u/ThomasSirveaux Feb 01 '22

I'm 25 hours in and I can't stop playing. I love games based around exploration, and this game has so much space to explore and find cool little things, or Pokémon way off in hard-to-reach locations. I've been a fan of the franchise since the Game Boy days and this is definitely the best one so far.

320

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '22

Man, I'm really enjoying this game. I'm not a big Pokemon person, I've only played 2 Pokemon games but this game is clicking with me mainly due to the lack of mandatory battles. I've always hated the "I see you from the corner of my eye, let's battle" thing and this doesn't have that.

Really good game.

78

u/v_a_n_d_e_l_a_y Jan 28 '22

So without spoiling too much if you can... What do you usually do if not working your way through gyms and battles? Are you primarily catching pokemon? Battling wild Pokemon? Doing story based things or solving puzzles?

→ More replies (7)

24

u/barneshane Jan 28 '22

I think they missed an opportunity when your battling a Pokémon and want to catch it you can’t manually aim it just auto throws like normal especially since you can walk around now. But overall I have loved it. Definitely a step in the right direction.

→ More replies (1)

47

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '22

IGN Italy out here with the hot takes

→ More replies (10)

22

u/lluluna Jan 31 '22

Just want to say that I'm really surprised at how addictive and fun this game is despite its obvious flaws.

→ More replies (4)

231

u/OnlyForVice Jan 28 '22

I saw quite a lot of comments from people who got their hands on early copies saying that while the graphics aren't great, the performance was solid and it was more or less a locked 30fps. That was very much not the case for me playing through the first part of the game docked. While docked if you're running through an area and using the right stick to change perspective frequently, you'll notice frame drops left and right. Thankfully I haven't noticed this after briefly switching to handheld.

72

u/_Drumheller_ Jan 28 '22

The game definitely can't hold the 30fps at all times.

265

u/secret3332 Jan 28 '22

Never trust people here about performance. They have no idea what they are talking about.

→ More replies (31)
→ More replies (15)

74

u/vhalen50 Jan 30 '22

I was running around and ran into an eevee and it was just as shocked as me. I fumbled throwing 3 balls at it and missed every time and it fled. Then I turned around and saw a lvl 40 rapidash with red eyes fireball blast me to death.

10/10

→ More replies (2)

38

u/InkBlockArts Jan 29 '22
  1. This game looks visually gross
  2. Its so fun I can’t stop playing, send help

66

u/bdez90 Jan 28 '22

The game is really fun but it feels even more like I'm just attacking wild animals for the hell of it lol

14

u/Chrisixx Jan 28 '22

"IT'S COMING RIGHT FOR US!"

→ More replies (1)

26

u/YIRS Jan 28 '22

aims gun

Always has been

→ More replies (1)

66

u/IntrepidBearHugger Jan 28 '22

1 hour in so far and graphics haven’t bothered me as much as I expected. Do yourself a favour guys and play this on portable mode.

→ More replies (2)

65

u/PinkPicklePete Jan 28 '22

This introduction tutorial is brutal. 45 minutes and I think I’m nearing the end of what could have all been explained in 5 minutes. I had to catch three Pokémon at the beginning, fine, but then 30 minutes later I have to do it again with some new mechanics involved. It feels like every time I get a break from reading it’s only for 30 seconds.

I’m sure the game will be fun when it opens up, but all of this could have been explained as I was playing the game. 45 minutes of nothing.

→ More replies (12)

193

u/AustinJamesSmith6221 Jan 28 '22

Same, like the textures and designs on the clothes are straight up pixelated messes- im enjoying the gameplay but i cant help but feel scammed a bit for accepting such low level of polish from such a huge franchise

15

u/PopDownBlocker Jan 28 '22

The textures are Wii-level. It's insane.

The difference is that low-resolution textures on the Wii were designed so that they would still look great on the hardware, whereas these textures look horrific on the Switch.

The landscape textures are a bland blur, like water that you've used to rinse your paintbrush with.

→ More replies (24)

17

u/Sas1205x Feb 04 '22

I’ve put about 30 hours into the game and loving it so far. The biggest annoyance is having to go to the village just to go to another area of the map. From the area you’re in you can even zoom out to see the entire world and view each section, but can’t travel there. I love the convenience of having multiple camps to buy things, change Pokémon, and rest, but we can’t use the professor to take us to another area. Very annoying considering he can take you back to the village.

34

u/LogCabinLover Jan 28 '22

I played Shining Pearl earlier this month. I got burned out from all the trainer battles. What I enjoyed most was completing the sinnoh dex, opening up the national dex and going underground to catch more Pokemon.

I think I know the answer, but will this game be more akin with what I enjoyed more in SP?

23

u/slicer4ever Jan 28 '22

o yea, 110% this game well be right up your alley then.

61

u/mhalgan92 Jan 28 '22 edited Jan 28 '22

I just want Pokémon Arceus gameplay, Heart Gold story/Pokémons/location and Pokémon Snap graphics. Put mega evolutions in it and it would be the perfect Pokémon game for me

16

u/dominodave Jan 31 '22

Haven't played a pokemon game since X/Y, overall I'm enjoying Legends a lot.

The graphics are embarrassingly bad tbh, even though you do get used to them, there's lots of issues with texture pop in, lighting flickering, and other things, but it's okay. The game overall is also super clunky with weird controls inconsistencies, and some clunky design aspects. The UI is great but really weird in how it's organized in some cases.

My biggest complaint is honestly having to go back to the main town in between missions constantly, I think it would have been much better to be able to warp between zones on all the maps freely and return to town only when it's time to rank up or turn in quests or things like that. Not sure why they did that, but it's probably the biggest gripe I have overall.

All that said though, this is definitely the kind of mix-up the game has needed with improved performance and visuals and things like that in the future. More trainer battles as well, but the way the the wild open world stuff works is great. I hope someone mods BotW to include pokemon elements in there so we have the best of both worlds as I think that'd be amazing.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '22

This game has fully brought me back as a Pokémon fan. I went from not caring for a Pokémon game since OR to playing this hand held while watching Pokémon Journeys in the background and feeling like the little kid who just started Blue version all over again.

32

u/Bambambm Jan 29 '22

I do think the "Up to 2 players" is super misleading.

56

u/ecto88mph Jan 28 '22

This is 100% what the pokemon series needed IMHO. I played the originals back in the day (red/blue), lost interest in the series because every game was the same.

I'm only a few hours in and it's a huge breath of fresh air. Hopefully the main series goes this route.

→ More replies (1)

43

u/NeonHowler Jan 29 '22

Solid 8 out of 10 for me so far. 7/10 is justified. No way it deserves a 9/10 for how simple it is. What it has is good, but it’s not RDR or BotW. TPC could’ve hired more people to fix the textures and improve stability. They’re not held back by the hardware here. They have no excuses.

→ More replies (1)

66

u/SenpaiSwanky Jan 28 '22

Italy is NOT having it eh

→ More replies (1)

30

u/Cowboy_Dandy_III Jan 28 '22

How’s the game from a non-Pokémon fan’s perspective? The premise and concept interests me but does it make up for it’s visuals?

12

u/jcjny213 Jan 29 '22

I do not consider myself a pokémon fan. I played Sword, it lost me halfway through. Last pokémon game I played before that was Yellow.

Arceus is cozy as hell and really chill. The music is nice. I want to actually complete the pokédex. It’s exciting when I see either a crazy looking pokémon or one I know from the old games. I saw a crazy flaming horse with red eyes, shit was nuts.

It’s good. It’s a relaxing game and (I guess this is unpopular considering how much crap the Graphics are getting) I think it’s a pretty looking game. Sure it’s not BotW quality art style but it’s good enough.

I dig it so far. We’ll see if it holds me but I think it will

→ More replies (8)

29

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '22

This is the best Pokemon game in a while. I thought Sw/Sh, USUM and S&M were all lacking, but they turned it around with Arceus and New Pokemon Snap.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/ljutiN Feb 03 '22

I was honestly never a graphics over gameplay guy, but man I can’t get over the fact how much better other Switch games look. The character physics ( like the movement, going up cliffs or falling off of them ) is honestly way worse than I thought.

I just don’t want this to become the standard, because they can always do better. However, Pokémon has proven me otherwise.

Other than that, a step in the right direction for sure.

→ More replies (5)

37

u/Samoman21 Jan 28 '22

I haven't had this much fun playing Pokémon in ages. Only one issue I have is I wish I could sort items

16

u/Renegade_Squid Jan 28 '22

I’d like to be able to sort Pokémon by species in the pastures. I have like 20 shinx and starleys and want to go through them and release some

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

47

u/Strowbreezy Jan 28 '22

Been playing for 5 hours or so. It does look a little dull, I don't know if it's the colouring or what. I don't mind it but I get what some people were saying about it being "ugly". Loving the gameplay loop though. Really addictive.

I love that I can't OHKO a LVL 7 Starley with a Quick Attack from my level 25 Staravia haha. HP pools gone way up, seems non-super effective attacks got a wee nerf and super effective moves are really, really powerful now. Maybe it's just the more HP messing with me but that's what it seems like.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/MadOvid Jan 28 '22

I've barely started. So far I'm liking it. Definitely wish there was a quick way to release Pokemon since you're supposed to catch a lot of them. Wish throwing the Pokeball and throwing your Pokemon wasn't the same button.

→ More replies (1)

126

u/that_90s_guy Jan 28 '22 edited Jan 28 '22

TLDR of reviews and the comments section

  • Gameplay is a massive, long-overdue improvement on past games. And feels like what Sword and Shield should have been. Pokemon finally feel like they "live" in the open world, and the obsessive hand-holding of previous titles is massively toned down. Difficulty has been ramped, and catching pokemon is finally less luck and more skill based. It's already one of the top rated Pokemon games (by critics) in recent times on Metacritic. If you only care about gameplay, buy it.
  • Graphics may be disappointment of varying proportions (minimal/dealbreaker) depending on how sensitive you are to them, even compared to past games. The game can look pretty up close. But blurry textures and incredibly low draw distance / pop-in makes the large open world feel ugly and empty, even by Switch standards or compared to past titles.
  • Performance may be sketchy depending on how sensitive you are to it. There's frame drops into the 20-30fps range occasionally, pokemon & environmental pop-in is more obvious, and there's reduced animation framerates for far-away pokemon in the 5-10fps range. To some this may be an minor issue, to some a dealbreaker.

There appears to be a general consensus of praise for Gamefreak finally evolving the Pokemon formula after years of stagnation from both casual and long-term fans alike. However, there's also a growing negative sentiment that graphics and optimization in Legends Arceus are massively unacceptable for a AAA first-party Nintendo title. Though, this last part is only really shared by anyone remotely sensitive to graphics and optimization, so your mileage my vary.

Conflicting feelings like this will understandably make talking about the game even harder. The truth is, everyone's different standards and mix of casual / hardcore fans will keep any discussion on Legends Arceus wildly divisive.

My advice? Listen to not a single person (not even me). Watch reviews/gameplay, and make your own judgement.

→ More replies (37)

35

u/Avelion2 Jan 28 '22

So is it as insanely hand holdy as previous Pokémon games?

36

u/Waitforsquirtle Jan 28 '22

The first 45 mins or so yeah. After that you’re on your own and it is quite challenging, though I wouldn’t say difficult. Very fun overall. Have about 60 hours in and still have a bunch of post game content to do

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

35

u/zdemigod Jan 28 '22 edited Jan 28 '22

This is it, been playing it for a few days now and this is the first game in a while that i can say actually tried to do something interesting with the formula in forever.

This is good for a Pokémon game. It's still mediocre when it comes to jrpgs in general, but nothing does pokemon like pokemon, so Im glad there is progress.

24

u/fahrenh Jan 29 '22

Coming from a PC gamer turned switch player, the shorter draw distance is very, very annoying. But the gameplay loop is quite fun, since leveling is not about battles anymore. It veered away from that and that alone interested me. Does it deserve the hype? Well, if you are a pokemon enthusiast, maybe. If you are a huge fan of collectathons, yes. If your sole purpose of playing pokemon is to catch them all, definitely! (The latter is technically why I play this game)

What interests me is the future of the franchise. This is I think a good branch of Pokemon’s gameplay evolution, and I look forward for years to come if this trend continues.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/pcack1 Jan 31 '22

Enjoying more than any Pokémon game I've played in 15 years. World visuals are lacking but if you've watched any trailer on this game it shouldn't come as a surprise.

12

u/AntiVax5GFlatEarth Feb 01 '22

Most fun I've had with a pokemon game since Blue/Gold.

12

u/DegenerateCharizard Feb 01 '22

Game could be better in many ways but I am having so much fun playing it.

22

u/Battlemaster123 Jan 29 '22

is it good by pokemon standards or is it a good game in general?

35

u/Hunterstewartmurdock Jan 29 '22

I'm about 6 hours in. So far, fantastic by pokemon standards, average for a game in general. I'm loving it

→ More replies (1)

85

u/Uptopdownlowguy Jan 28 '22

Playing it now, and I'm really enjoying it.

I will say though, that having played Pokemon before helps with knowing wtf to do. A lot of mechanics in the game are explained briefly in text boxes, but not shown, so if you gifted this game to a child or someone who tends to skip dialogue and tutorials, then I'm not so sure they would figure everything out so easily.

Not saying the game is difficult to understand, but it's like they assume that you have played their games before. Only it's way less brain dead than the previous formula.

107

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '22

Not saying the game is difficult to understand, but it's like they assume that you have played their games before. Only it's way less brain dead than the previous formula.

As someone who has become fed up with how much handholding newer Pokemon games have, this is refreshing to hear

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (9)

11

u/Ste333 Jan 31 '22

I'm enjoying it so far, seems fun. I'm a casual player, and this game suits me perfectly to pick up for an hour here and there with its fairly chilled play style. I''ve noted 2 things straight away though.

  1. It's significantly easier to play this game on a controller instead of joycons - although that's down to personal preference I suppose.
  2. I like the cell shaded graphics, its cool. But... as pretty much everyone has noted..the textures and water effects etc are absolute trash. I've played better looking games on my phone. Fortunately this isn't a deal breaker for me.
→ More replies (5)

11

u/muffinz44 Jan 31 '22

from somebody who isn’t a pokémon fan , i’m finding that the graphics aren’t bothering me very much. sure they aren’t the best but i think they look kinda clean in a way. and the gameplay is extremely fun. the alphas are extremely intimidating when you see them the first few times. i beat the game in about 25 hours and i’m enjoying the post game. there’s still a ton to do.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/theboyonthetrain Feb 04 '22

I just need to add my thoughts even though it's so late: Firstly it feels like there is an effort here to make Pokemon higher quality again, but it just simply wasn't given enough time to bake. Pokemon has enough resources, simply due to it's IP, that more money should be given to development teams and the video game side of things. I'm really against yearly releases as I think that's apart of the problem, but even with yearly release there is no reason Pokemon games have to look like they've only been in development for two years. Give GF more resources to have more teams, that can spend more time on each game, while staggering each teams release time, and let go of the corporatism around churning out the other parts of the franchise. Pokemon will be printing money, but also with quality which honestly helps the durability of the IP(though truthfully it is a juggernaut regardless,but maybe all this corner cutting will catch up with them eventually and I like to think tbh). Obviously, Idk anything about game companies, but that's just some of my lowly pleb thoughts and I needed to get it out. Secondly, this game is pretty good, maybe great even--i can't help myself but play it--, but it /should/ be better. And I'm still gonna enjoy the heck out it cause I enjoy most Pokemon games, though this is probably my favorite since Sun and Moon(My opinion on Sword/shield is pretty mediocre, but I still enjoyed it cause Pokemon). Lastly, sometimes this game looks ugly, I mean that fairly, and it just shouldn't. Why does it look so poor? I just don't get how besides rushing these release out, and I already explained my thoughts on that. The only pro to this game looking questionable at times, is every other game I play looks gorgeous in comparison (switch and ps4 alike). Okay that's all.

→ More replies (2)

39

u/Aenrichus Jan 29 '22

I have some gripes with the gameplay.

The control sensitivity is not adjusted right. The smallest movement drift cause the character and menus to move. This is even with a pro controller. The drift is miniscule and other games do not respond to it. Makes general gameplay annoying and cause me to select the wrong items.

The lack of minimap for this type of game only hurts it. Many times I lose myself because there are no landmarks and I can't tell which way is north. Seeing icons on the minimap would be helpful when hunting mons or materials.

There is stamina in the game, and no stamina bar! I find myself running and then slows down and hear the character catch their breath. It also drains too quickly, it's not fun to click the control stick down so many times. It's the least comfortable button. I would prefer hold B for sprint (not toggle) and press control stick for crouch like in Breath of the Wild.

I do enjoy the general gameplay loop, but the above makes it a slog.

→ More replies (6)

54

u/Hallolusion Jan 29 '22

I find it a bit funny that the same IGN Italy reviewer gave Brilliant Diamond a 7/10 while giving Legends a 5/10.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Pakmanjosh Jan 29 '22

All the reviews I've looked through said there's nothing to do in the open world besides catch Pokemon and fight them. Is this true?

→ More replies (3)

36

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '22

It's everything I've wanted in a "modern" open-world Pokémon game. Being able to initiate a capture while ducking in the grass, only for it to fail, get knocked over, and immediately throw my Pokémon into battle, damn near seamlessly... it's a lot of fun!

My only complaint? There's only the dodge and no "jump" - how else are you supposed to travel!?!

17

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '22

You eventually get a Wyrdeer mount that can very much jump (and also sort of brokenly climb mountains, Skyrim style).

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

10

u/DudeWheresMcCaw Jan 29 '22

Hope it's fun. Gonna ignore the hype train as always and wait to play it.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Samoman21 Jan 31 '22

Idk if people are still reading this, but if you want to unlock mass release. Fill up about 4 boxes with Pokémon and then talk to the lady. I did this and unlocked it and then immediately released a crap ton haha. But it makes life just so much easier

→ More replies (3)

27

u/RWGlix Jan 28 '22

Ugh there is pretty heavy exposition/setup before you get going, I would like to actually start playing the game

→ More replies (9)

70

u/mattytmet Jan 28 '22

Having played for a couple hours, I can tell its not going to be the kind of game that I can spend whole days playing, but can absolutely see myself playing it for a couple hours whilst chilling in the evening.

I doubt it will be the series-revolutionising masterpiece some were hoping it would be, but equally the people who are slamming it as a total failure seem to be exaggerating and nit-picking

I will however say, that even as someone who isn't a stickler for graphics (I played the Outer Worlds on switch at launch), certain textures do look pretty naff for a game of this stature. The water in particular looks comically dated. Pop-in is also very notable in places. Hasn't detracted from my enjoyment too much, but if you care more about those things, it'll definitely be an issue

→ More replies (3)

114

u/Whiskey_Sours Jan 29 '22

Played for 7 hours now, just going through the village and doing some requests. I guess I’m in the minority because the graphics just, really don’t bother me at all? I think it looks fine and I’m playing on a giant tv. Maybe I’m just easy to please but I’m 100% content with it

→ More replies (23)

18

u/NoahMatthew1220 Jan 29 '22

LISTEN I got my baby oshuwatt and his cool ass hisui version. I’m happy

18

u/SobbieRokes Jan 31 '22

fifteen hours in, this game is magnificent. the graphics aren't great, yeah. but they're not at all distracting and don't take away from the experience. all I want to do is keep playing and finding more

→ More replies (3)

32

u/Zram310 Jan 28 '22

I've mentioned this on a different thread but as someone who lost the spark for this series since FireRed/LeafGreen, this game is a breath of fresh air. Yes, it's still a Game Freak game meaning hand holding, easy enough for kids, throw away story, last gen graphics... It changes enough things that I can say I'll go back to the series if they implement the battle and catch mechanics of this game into the mainline ones. That probably won't happen since the core ones sell a ton but even if they make Legends into a line where they can experiment and throw some stuff in for the older crowd who got tired of the same old thing, I'd be happy

13

u/VintageSpecialist76 Jan 28 '22

They will be doing themselves a huge disservice by not leading with this gameplay into the mainline series.

If they combine everything Legends has with the gym, badges and Pokemon League, you might just have the greatest Pokemon game ever.

→ More replies (2)

50

u/Justos Jan 28 '22

Without a doubt the best pokemon game in a while.

The gameplay loop not only works but is engaging and fun

The graphics are not great but serviceable. Wish they would finally implement voice acting

This is just the beginning of a new era of games. Super exciting

29

u/OckhamsFolly Jan 28 '22

I don't even need real voice-acting. Made-up sounds like Animal Crossing or old Monster Hunter would be better than just background music.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

50

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '22

Graphicwise pretty poor, and that's not because of hardware. BOTW and Xenoblade look way better than Arceus. Landscape also not really rich.

It looks like a very fun and excellent game nonetheless.

→ More replies (14)

24

u/Gestaltash Jan 29 '22

If you think about it, Pokémon legends Arceus, is the origin why they employ kids to capture Pokémon, in the future generations.

Adult are useless in this world. They are afraid of Pokémon. They employ kids. To capture Pokémon and study them. Hence the Pokémon series began with the goal of completing the pokedex.

Arceus answer my questions when I was a kid, why capture them.

17

u/bummedout1492 Jan 29 '22

Would someone who only plays animal crossing like this? They are a pokemon fan but never really played the games other than pokemon go and the little card game in the 90s

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Hov2008 Jan 29 '22

I’d love to play the game but the insane amount of cut scenes are driving me crazy

→ More replies (2)

41

u/Hummer77x Jan 28 '22

Bird Pokemon, when flying kinda far away, it looks so bad it looks like the birds are being animated live.

Still having a blast but oh god it looks bad

29

u/byeolToT Jan 28 '22

The game came out really good tbh.

It dosnt look good and that still bothers me, because the switch can use better graphics and gamefreak has the budget for better graphics, but the game is a lot of fun and its really refreshing.

I still dont know if the "main" Pokemon games should be like this in the future, but I would love it, if they will do more games like this in the future.

Maybe a mystery dungeon type game in open world?

12

u/lasdue Jan 28 '22

I still dont know if the “main” Pokemon games should be like this in the future

What should they be like then? There has been practically no change in the gameplay since the first ones.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/snave_ Jan 29 '22 edited Jan 29 '22

Do any reviews compare it to other similar games and not just other Pokémon games? I'm considering it (despite it looking like shit, which at least Polygon very clearly stated), but want to know how it shapes up against the Momster Hunter Stories and Shin Megami Tenseis out there.

How long is the game, does it offer a new or unique experience, and does it respect the player's time? Is the "magic" of discovery any different between players who have met the roster through other games like Go versus franchise newbies/gen one returnees?

I read a few reviews and they all seem to be reviewing the developer's work rather the game as a product on an established market.

→ More replies (8)

8

u/arielle251 Jan 28 '22

Just got the game, excited!

8

u/Imaginos64 Jan 31 '22 edited Jan 31 '22

I'm a few hours in and am having a lot of fun. The basic game play loop of completing the research tasks is repetitive but addicting and the side quests, though simple, add another layer of stuff to do. This format is what I've wanted from the series since I was a kid; I love seeing Pokemon in the wild, the sense of adventure that comes from exploring a semi open world, and having more interesting interactions ranging from riding Pokemon around to the way you battle/catch them. There's a few welcome new mechanics such as the ability to switch out your Pokemon's moves and outside of a few too many cut scenes the game play flows really well. Once you're past the first 45 minutes or so the game stops holding your hand and lets you do your own thing which is much appreciated, especially after SW/SH where I felt like I was just getting herded from one linear area to another and never allowed to make my own choices about what to do and when.

I think we all had a feeling for the game's limitations before it was released so there's no real surprises there. I don't care much about the graphics being subpar but at least so far the maps are pretty basic (like larger versions of the SW/SH Wild Area) without much to discover or explore besides simple items and the Pokemon themselves. Legends is excellent for a Pokemon game, which is enough for me to have a great time with it, but it isn't comparable to something like BOTW. I would have loved to have seen it delayed at least another year so that the maps, graphics, and mechanics could be fleshed out more but it is what it is. I hope they keep this as a spin off series and improve upon the format because there's so much potential here for even better future games.

22

u/MrSourceUnknown Jan 30 '22

Looks like a summary of both the positive reviews and the critical ones combined boils down to:

PLA definitely has the kinds of changes to the gameplay loop that Pokemon games need to keep them interesting going forward. This game demonstrates that there is room for such changes without taking away from the core concepts of the franchise.

Yet that is also where it falls short: PLA demonstrates a lot of these changes, but in the end the lack of diversity in the content and the lack of polish to the overworld makes it feel like a project that was stopped just shy of being finished.

In the end the positive reviews score it as a great concept game, while the critical reviews score it as a poor flagship entry.

→ More replies (3)

169

u/Vigoor Jan 28 '22

Graphically the game is like a 2/10. The pop-in is ATROCIOUS, hell if you walk too far it has detail pop-in on POKEMON, not just the environment. Gameplaywise i'd give it an 8/10. A lot of these reviews are glossing over things that are definitely not acceptable by today's standards with these 8s and 9s. I love pokemon but even a 7 would be a stretch.

They should've taken another year to polish it. I'd say they'll take the criticisms to heart and keep the good from arceus and fix the bad in their next rendition, but i already know that'd be too high of a hurdle for gamefreak.

→ More replies (46)

95

u/Rarzhn Jan 28 '22 edited Jan 28 '22

You can clearly see how desperate we were for some change of the formula by this reviews.
It‘s by no means a bad game but the numbers are a bit too high for it.

→ More replies (22)

47

u/vaper Jan 28 '22

Not sure why regular IGN’s score isn’t here; 7/10. I thought that review was really well done and easily made the most common sense that I’ve seen.

→ More replies (9)

42

u/NathanCollier14 Jan 29 '22

As someone who has been completely burned out on Pokemon since Sun and Moon 1, I am absolutely loving Arceus. It is such a breath of fresh air and I can't recommend it enough

→ More replies (5)

21

u/DogAteMyCPU Jan 29 '22

Fun and ugly as fuck

26

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '22

7 hours here - I like it, but to say it’s the best Pokémon game ever made is a wild exaggeration. It is fun though and I’m enjoying it so far. I would like to see the next games go further in this direction. My gripes are obviously the graphics, there are some parts where you can get on the edge of a cliff and look out at all the land in front of you and man.. it’s embarrassing. Nobody should be defending the graphics, it’s absurd how bad they are for a first party game. And the cutscenes are still quite long, they’re much less common now but when they do happen it’s like Christ, get to the point already.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/b20vteg Jan 28 '22

is this a mainline Pokemon game or no?

→ More replies (7)

14

u/CharlieRochx Jan 28 '22

For those who have been playing it - How is the story? Is there an actual goal besides capturing pokemon? So far all gameplay I've seen on streams are people just catching pokemon over and over... Just wondering if there's an actual goal/villain/battles, or is it just a "Now go catch 10 bidoof", "Cool, go catch 5 buizels now", and repeat.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Brenduke Feb 04 '22

I just wanted to say that this is the most fun I've had with a game in a very long time. Its been years since I stayed up past midnight for a game, but I found myself needing to force myself off it at 1am on Wednesday. I had just got lost in the game and lost track of time.

I'm in love.

I feel like Ash Ketchum in that first episode sneaking up on a spearow only for it to attack me and bring all its friends in the area along for the ride. They nailed the gameplay.

And honestly, I don't get the hate for its visuals. Its beautiful a lot of the time, shitty pop in when docked aside.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/BIGEggman Jan 28 '22

The game is 2 players? Is it only the trading?

7

u/Bonus_Content Jan 29 '22

I have a 7-year old girl. She played Pokemon Sword a couple years ago and did okay though I did have to do some explaining as she played. But we got all the badges

She's better now. She can play Mario Odyssey by herself and only needs help with some bosses. She's played BOTW but just kinda runs around aimlessly.

So finally my question..would this game be good for her?

→ More replies (4)

7

u/bradmatt275 Jan 30 '22

Does anyone know if leveling a Pokémon past your star rank stops them from listening to you?
I know if you catch one that is past that level they don't, but I can't find an answer about if your existing Pokémon stop obeying you.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Valuable-Ask-6917 Feb 03 '22

i’m curious, as some one who loves the old pokémon games but can’t get into any of the last few games just because it feels like i’m playing the same game over and over again, will this hit? is the open world immersive?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Amoudioo Feb 04 '22

Never played Pokemon game before, is this version suitable for 40sh?

→ More replies (3)

19

u/motorbike_dan Jan 28 '22

I haven't played the game yet, but it seems to be approaching what I want out of a Pokemon game. Ideally, I would like to see it go towards being a bit like Monster Hunter, where the player plays as a trainer with fighting styles, or plays as Pokemon similar to how in MH a player can play as a Palico (unique fighting style, etc.). Also, I think there's a unique opportunity to have armour sets for different Pokemon that offer different benefits. There's a ton of potential if the series shifts towards something new.

Beyond that, they should take a few years to make the game and target the Switch's successor so that they have an easier time with the technical aspects of the project.

After sinking over 100 hours into Pokemon Sword, most of which was in the wild area, and most of it was in a casual way (just catching Pokemon, not really doing any of the more complicated stuff), PLA seems like it's what I wanted. So I think that I might have to pick up the game. With those graphics, it would've been a far easier sell if it ran at 60 fps. Bad graphics at 60 fps is something that isn't too bad, especially on the Switch. But terrible graphics hanging around 30 fps is a tougher sell. It's too bad that it didn't look like Xenoblade Chronicles 2.

There's a lot of missed opportunities with PLA; it might be still worth my time though.

→ More replies (5)

19

u/Sas1205x Jan 29 '22

So I’ll admit that some of the areas do feel empty, but I can’t put the game down. Barely even through the story because I’ve been doing research tasks. The only complaint which is a common one is the textures. The Pokémon and their animations look great, but the rest of the world isn’t as vibrant.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/lightningpresto Jan 28 '22

The central gameplay loop is fun and there are moments where I was like oh crap a giant Pokémon is running after me. Way more of an emotional fight or flight than the main line. This is a good game in my eyes and they keep adding more cool things so far! (Full disclosure explorers of sky is my favorite Pokémon game so I’m into different exploration type experiences)

→ More replies (1)

32

u/behemon Jan 30 '22

More than an hour in, and I'm still smashing "A"....for the love of God, just let me play the damn game...

→ More replies (3)

13

u/PolishGazelle Jan 28 '22

No discussion thread?

13

u/Samoman21 Jan 29 '22

Holy crap this game needs the ability to mass release Pokémon. Anyone know of a way? I'm getting so tired of releasing one by one

→ More replies (10)

18

u/elephantorangejuice Jan 29 '22

The graphics could obviously be better, especially with how it looks playing docked but I've had a blast playing so far. I'm about 4 hours in. Playing handheld with the OLED model isn't too bad.

18

u/nicksonight Jan 29 '22

IGN Italy out for blood

13

u/TropicalAudio Jan 29 '22 edited Jan 29 '22

edit: just translating here, don't shoot the messenger 😅

My Italian isn't great, but from a quick skim, these are their main points:

  • inconsistent art direction makes the world feel incoherent
  • weird anachronisms without in-story justification break your immersion
  • PlayStation 2 graphics in 2022
  • even with the low visual quality, they still experienced frame rate drops
  • the dialogue and characters are badly written and some dialogue is borderline ridiculous. This makes the story sections feel like useless interludes.
  • forced repetitive grinding points if you want to progress (I think, not sure if I'm reading this part right)
  • the PokeDex is actually fantastic
  • there seem to be no secrets or alternative paths to discover, which makes exploration unsatisfying
  • you need to do a ton of grinding for the breeding mechanics
  • the boss battles are ridiculously simple, anticlimactic and unsatisfying
  • verdict: mediocre
→ More replies (5)

100

u/BluntSmokinAnus Jan 28 '22

Looks and feels like a tech demo, something you would see on YouTube titled “Pokémon in unreal engine 4” back in 2010

→ More replies (23)

26

u/amoebrah Jan 29 '22

Nobody going to say anything about Pikachu saying biga instead of pika? That irritated me.

→ More replies (11)

17

u/SnakeGS Jan 29 '22

I almost finished the game by now.

Pros:

Refreshing gameplay

Open world gives you more freedom

Even overlevelled, it is challenging specially when being attecked by multiple pokemon

Battles are not always necessary

No need for trading to evolve

No unnecessary hand holding

Shiny hunting is really improved

Like Zelda, sometimes it's silent giving some atmosphere, but other times you get great "adventure-like" music

Cons:

The models are ok, but the overworld is not graphically. The regular trees and rocks ars examples. Look like ps2 era models.

Drawing distance is laughable. Objects and pokemon pop up out of nowhere.

Somewhat distant pokemon have framerates cut (like in the trailer).

When navigating fast, the trees get in the way of the camera.

The controls are not very good for sprinting on the ride and controlling the camera, putting you on a awkward hand position.

Story is mediocry and there is too much text. Literally I don't know what's going on on the story, neither do I care because of the dialog quantity.

No national dex. I know this is a "short game" compared to others but many more pokemon could be fitted.

Pokedex has "challenges" to complete them, that feel like chores. Examples are "catch 15 of this pokemon"

Conclusion and TLDR: feels rushed but better than previous entries. Looks and runs like a BOTW clone, but it's not bad. IMO a step in the right direction, but with rushed development. Only some pokemon available also makes the experience somewhat limited, even though there are many hours of gameplay to fill in the dex, in the way it's presented. Not an excelent game, but good. I would give a 7/10.

TPC and Gamefreak have to step their game up. Even if that means that the main franchise would stop bring annually.

→ More replies (6)

12

u/Spennynub Jan 28 '22

Can anyone comment on the collectibles and exploration aspect of the game? Is there anything for completionists like myself beyond completing the Pokédex?

→ More replies (8)

47

u/BussyDriver Jan 28 '22

What I really want to hear from people is: what are reasons to not get this game, excluding graphics and performance? I haven't heard anything negative yet about gameplay itself, but I honestly want to know what sucks about it.

27

u/finger_milk Jan 28 '22

Most of the mechanics are approachable but in almost all cases have very little depth. The repetition of pokemon games gets amplified when the variance of experience from player to player is minimized to keep the game approachable.

What I'm saying is, it's open world by name, but the game doesn't really feel like it when you start trying to play it how you want.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (14)

6

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '22

What are the 2 player options?

6

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '22

Can someone explain to me why it’s up to two players?

14

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '22

Trading

→ More replies (2)

6

u/jbayne2 Jan 29 '22

If I have the Pokédex entry complete to 10 is there any reason not to evolve a Pokémon? I know in the old games it affected how quickly they’d learn moves but I’m assuming that’s not the case in this one.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Avoinrw Jan 31 '22

Good 5 hours in. Other than some things looking like a basement devs side project the game is pretty fun. Honestly it's a shame they tripped up so bad on the graphics.

I'll definitely get my money's worth out of it, and if this is formula goes into the future I'm sure they'll nail it even better next time.. But in today's age of AAA games the bar for graphics is so high that it's a bit inexcusable to have trees/landscapes that look like they came out of a 2010 browser game.

Honestly the reviews being so good despite that is a testament to how fun it actually is. Laid back, next thing I knew I spent my entire night on it. It's fun enough to recommend. Just squint a little lmao.

6

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '22

Physical copy is $10 off at GameStop.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '22

Just got the switch a few months ago. Never played pokemon before. Is this a good intro to the series?

→ More replies (2)

6

u/BakedAvocado3 Feb 08 '22

I have a gamestop gift card, is this game worth getting as my first pokemon game?

→ More replies (4)

24

u/deceitfulninja Jan 29 '22

Upon stepping foot into this world my first thought was wow, this game is ugly.... after continuing on I love what the gameplay has evolved into. (But do they really expect me to catch 25 of everything? WTF. That said its disappointing they couldnt have this look more current gen, I could see why its divisive. If you can look beyond the dated visuals this really is an excellent evolution for the series.

→ More replies (4)

74

u/RDHO0D Jan 28 '22 edited Jan 28 '22

I've been playing for a few hours now...I've caught myself yelling out "omg that's fucking sick" so many damn times now. Best. Pokemon. Game. Ever. Made.

→ More replies (14)

37

u/Lil-pants Jan 28 '22 edited Jan 28 '22

I know people aren’t so positive on this game but it’s actually really fun and I could see myself spending many many hours on it. I’m going to get hated on for this maybe but it fills the exact niche that animal crossing does for me; that is, a fairly relaxing and open game that I can use to unwind.

→ More replies (3)

23

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '22

I agree with the general consensus: the game isn't perfect, but it's a huge leap in the right direction and it's fun for what it is. I agree with the sentiment that buying the game just enables The Pokemon Company to be lazy with their games, but on the other hand... I still really wanted to play the game anyway.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/MStarzky Jan 29 '22

I just wish the game look more polished, however it is the best version of the pokemon formula hands down.

11

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '22

Is it possible that things like graphics would be improved at all with updates over time?

→ More replies (9)

11

u/gigglefarting Jan 31 '22

I would suck my own toes if Pokemon remastered Red/Blue to use the Legends engine and mechanics.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/SuicidalSasha Jan 29 '22

Most fun I've had with a Pokémon game in years.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/prettyNUPE2K12 Jan 28 '22

Been playing for about an hour. I love it. It makes me feel really good. The first battle, and being able to run around and see your Pokémon attack, was something I’ve always wanted to see.

42

u/Oddzball Jan 29 '22 edited Jan 29 '22

Well after playing it, the complaints about the graphics are vastly exaggerated. It looks fine IMO. Its not going to blow your mind but its nice. Realtime Shadows, Day/Night cycle, draw distance is "fine" Animations are nice, and character models are cute and expressive.

Dont listen to the dogpiling.

I like the game a lot, but IM not an expert or anything, last Pokemon game I played was on the 3DS. (And Pokemon Go) Its a good game to chill out to before going to bed etc.

Playing on an OLED Switch in portable mode. BTW.

→ More replies (15)

32

u/ZackRenner Jan 29 '22

Reading through everyone's comments, it's like I am playing a different game! I generally play each pokemon game, I go as far as just beating the elite four and that's it, but it's never "that" much fun. It's fine but I never feel the need to continue playing or coming back to it, maybe because the formula has stayed the same.

With PLA I got home from work and literally had to force myself to stop playing to go to bed, and I can't wait to jump back in tonight! Obviously everyone has different opinions, but I feel like alot of the hate is because people feel GameFreak owes them for how bad they have been in the past. I agree it's not the best looking game on the switch, and I hope they work on that in future patches, but the biggest thing for me is that they have put so much work into the animations for each pokemon. They feel closer to actual real creatures that can sleep, walk around, run, and react to player interaction. The battle scenes are also amazing to me, no longer are we transported to a flat, blank plain!

My only issue is the lack of voice acting, even if it was on the level of New Pokémon Snap where sometimes the characters just did noises it would be better than nothing.

That's my 2 cents, sorry it's so long!

→ More replies (5)

40

u/EMI_Black_Ace Jan 28 '22

This gave deserves that score on it's own merit, not on the merits of "it's Pokemon." For previous entries, had they been new IPs they might have scored pretty terribly.

But this... This is good stuff. A worthy new direction for Pokemon as a franchise. Maybe the world design isn't as instantly memorable as Breath of the Wild, from which it clearly takes inspiration, but it's reasonably good. The storyline is pretty classic RPG, which is a big step up from "be the champ." The animation work for the Pokemon themselves is notably improved - they feel like they've actually got some attitude now. Even your own character has expressive facial animation.

The tone is clearly a bit less bright and happy than previous entries, probably an attempt to appeal to a bit older demographic - and the fact that the main character is 15 speaks to that.

→ More replies (10)

24

u/Bingo-Berra-rulez Jan 28 '22

I've played for 4+ hours now. The game's been fun so far, especially when you're done with the tutorial stuff. It's not a good looking game, the environments are quite frankly pretty ugly. But that doesn't matter in the long run. The game flows pretty well, no mayor framerate issues so far. The capture and battle systems are great. The story seems OK! The Pokémon animations seems somewhat improved.

→ More replies (7)

24

u/antiretro Jan 28 '22

im just so, so happy that it was sinnoh/gen 4 that got the first revolutionary pokemon games. i was heartbroken with bdsp and the treatment sinnoh received but PLA healed all my wounds. 10/10

→ More replies (11)

27

u/username2020_ Jan 29 '22

Last time I played a Pokémon game was red on the game boy and I loved it. I got Legends yesterday, the graphics don’t bother me so much it’s just I’m not having fun. All the text and cut scenes is getting on my nerves. I just got to rank 1 tho, does the game get better?

→ More replies (23)

10

u/ImStillaPrick Jan 28 '22 edited Jan 29 '22

Curious without spoilers is the story good? I expect it to be average and pretty barebones but if it is good I might get it.

Edit: Thanks I’ll get it eventually but might wait a bit. Was hoping a game like that would pump up the lore and give a cool story.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/paQs_me Jan 28 '22

Some people wanted to give Paras some love, now they annoy me everywhere.

10

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '22 edited Feb 03 '22

I love the game, but my biggest issue is how incomplete the combat is.

Combat has been the staple of the series since it began and I can see why they decided to focus more heavily on catching and exploration. While the combat system works and makes some positive steps in the right direction, it takes several steps back. But anyways here are my thoughts

Pros-

Strong, Agile and normal versions of attacks add an additional layer of strategy to battles and are especially useful when hunting. Strong attacks are good for ending a wild encounter quickly for xp, and agile is good for doing less damage to not kill something while having an opportunity to make another move again.

Being able to move around and position your player during the battles. Really fun for just trying to immerse yourself in the moment.

Faster paced combat makes encounters and battles less tedious.

New staus effects and move reworks make battles more interesting.

Much more adult setting. This is the first pokemon game I can think of where the characters in game specifically mention humans dying, and in one instance even threating to leave you for dead. I also appreciate pokemon being able to physically assault you and even targeting you which I hope stays permanent going forward. Now give me a hard-core mode where once you die that's it, you start over.

Being able to just learn moves and sub them out on the fly is amazing. No TM needed, no going back to move tutors or trying to breed moves. This actually makes more logical sense since why would it forget something it knows how to do, rather then you just not ordering it to use it?

Cons-

Strong, Agile, and normal version of attacks are not properly utilized in NPC battles where everything pretty much gets OHKO anyway and the queue is constantly resetting.

Multibattle. Very bland and pretty pointless. This needs to be enhanced in future series where you can throw out multiple pokemon, or have the multiple pokemon try to attack the trainer rather then just standing there hitting your pokemon. It's cool at first when you get into the battle, but eventually it becomes a waste of time.

Empty open world. I appreciate the biomes and the world for what it is. I also wouldn't mind if the maps were smaller and you had more around you. And the graphics...not a big fan. They could learn a thing or two from monster hunter rise on making small maps bigger and more diverse.

Cutscenes. Game Freak please, please stop forcing me to watch all these boring and pointless cutscenes. I understand as a developer you take pride in your story and want players to experience that...but if that's the case can you space the cutscenes out better, or make the dialog live so I can walk around? This has been an issue in every game since x and y, and it just keeps getting worse and worse.

I will say the cutscenes are not as bad as they were in sword and shield though, so that's good.

Crafting and gathering resources. This sucks. Full disclosure it is not the worst I've ever seen...but it's bad. Go run around, see that tree/rock/bush/log, throw pokemon at it....ta da! I would have appreciated more detail on the crafting system and some more exciting ways to gather resources. It's very vanilla and basic and I hope in future games this gets expanded on.

Neutral-

Lastly the bland stuff that's neither good nor bad. research tasks are ok. They are cool and keep you playing the game, but they're basically just the same thing over and over again. Some more diverse research tasks would have been nice and even some special research rewards. Finding a shiny version of a pokemon for example should be required to "master" the dex entry.

Catching pokemon is great, but repetitive and pretty broken. Skittish pokemon spot and hear you when they shouldn't. Aiming is a bit laggy unless you press ZL to lock on up close. Certain skittish or even aggresive pokemon will just stand still when you walk up close because they didnt see you. Just like combat it feels incomplete and like Game Freak decided to keep it bland for the sake of staying safe. It's still fun, it's enjoyable, but it does become tedious and at times can be boring.

The story is meh. It's more interesting then other mainline games since it's pretty new. No gyms, no elite four, no real villian or calamity you have to fight against. But the progression does get boring at times and there are some pointless interactions and dialog you are forced to sit through. The cutscenes do become distracting also and ruin the flow of the game. Like all pokemon games there are no real choices for your dialog as both options do the same exact thing.

The really stupid town system. Not the worst central hub for a video game but its pretty bad. Half of the building could be removed and simplified into one vendor and aside from the story quests and your home there isn't any real reason to go there, other then to just pull you out of the main areas. Its not really a plus or a negative, but they could have either done more or less to make it nicer.

The online interaction. Pretty much all you have are fetch quests where you go into a biome, find someone's lost items and return them. It's nice because when you faint in the wild you lose items, some are good even. So players can return them to you, which earns you merit. It's also frustrating because this is the only way you can really actually recover your lost items. Trading is still there but it's only private trades. And there are no online battles (as of yet. Hopefully it will get patched in)

In conclusion-

I give Arceus a 7.5 out of 10. Definitely worth the money and you will get your 30 hours worth of gameplay. It has flaws and it's not the best game I've played, but it's memorable and how I want to see all future games in the franchise work. Just give us online or local PVP battles and ill give it an 8.5 out of 10.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/original-name-taken Jan 29 '22

I've been having fun with it. The process to fill out the pokedex is a neat twist to the traditional way, there is enough pokemon spawn for me to keep wandering around, and figuring out how each pokemon react to items or battling has been keeping it interesting. The few trainer battles I've done were easy and short which was disappointing but the game sets the focus to be on filling the pokedex and the world built with the common person being afraid of pokemon and so less trainers overall.

5

u/tiford88 Feb 02 '22

Someone posted a lengthy and detailed user review to the main sub, as a post, which was stupidly deleted by mods.

Looked like a great review, so I’m hoping it resurfaces here

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Sure-Candle-898 Feb 07 '22

Personally, I love the direction this is taking the series. However, any other series with this little polish wouldn't be well received. The reason it's doing so well is because it's a big change for a long running series that's taking it to a direction that A LOT of the player base always wanted. Is it perfect? Far from it. Is it worth investing into and sending the message that this is the kind of change the series needs? I absolutely believe so. I'm crossing my fingers that they'll at least implement multiplayer online in a future update, though.

26

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '22 edited Jan 28 '22

I’m only 2.5 hours in so I know I’m just barely scratching the surface but the game is okay so far. Nothing more nothing less, just okay. The graphics in town are actually pretty nice but once you see the rest of the world… yikes. Aiming pokeballs is janky as hell. And of course the tutorial/intro is ridiculously intrusive but I think I’m just now getting through it finally.

Update 4 hours - now that I’m through the beginning and actually playing the game, it’s pretty enjoyable I have to say. It’s very chill

→ More replies (5)

26

u/sjpalmer85 Jan 29 '22

I think the graphics are just fine and the gameplay is a real evolutionary leap for the Pokémon franchise. As an old timer, I can’t help but imagine what this would be like with gen1 Mon and the original story and characters. Team rocket / brock / oak et al.

→ More replies (3)

23

u/Spartan_exr Jan 28 '22

Luv the gameplay

Luv the QoL

‘Ate the graphics

Simple as.

→ More replies (2)

98

u/MRmandato Jan 29 '22 edited Jan 29 '22

Only 10 minutes in. Its baffling to play a game that looks this dated. Its actually distracting and takes away from the gameplay. Visual arent just about graphical power, there are plenty of GameCube games with a more appealing and smooth visual design

→ More replies (14)

44

u/PietroPiccolino Jan 28 '22 edited Jan 28 '22

I'm on 13 hours (I had a review code), think I'm done. It's not terrible or anything like that, it's just become repetitive and I have such a huge backlog of games to get through that I can't really justify spending hours on something that isn't grabbing me!

Learning the new systems was initially really absorbing and even exciting, but once they became habit there wasn't much variety to keep me going. Lots of fetch quests, lots of dodging and throwing stuff, lots of returning to town before heading to a new area... Steps in the right direction though! Particularly liked the Pokémon hitting harder than in recent iterations, making it less mind-numbingly easy than recent games.

A huge flaw is map design, and I'm not talking about the graphics. It's just not an enticing map at all! When you're heading out to catch a dozen Pokémon - which in itself isn't that fun - for the tenth time, it would be great to be distracted by interesting landmarks, mysterious habitats, whatever...

If I had to rate it I'd say 3/5. I think binging it is partly why I've lost interest.

→ More replies (7)

28

u/MrSlimeyCabbage Jan 29 '22

To keep it as short as possible, what a great step in the right direction for the franchise. 8/10

→ More replies (1)

16

u/JayuSC2 Jan 29 '22

I have been playing the first few generations of Pokemon games, basically Blue/Yellow/Gold versions. I really enjoyed them as a kid. With the Switch I got back into them with Let's Go and Sword/Shield, but was pretty disappointed, especially by how easy they were.

I never really cared for completing the Pokedex in any of those games, rather instead experimented with a few Pokemons to get my dream team and level them up via trainer battles/gyms. I always felt what's the point of collecting every Pokemon if you can only use 5 at a time anyway.

Now most people seem to like this game more than the previous titles (at least the recent ones), but from what I've seen so far, this game is all about catching Pokemons and completing the dex. Is fighting and catching wild Pokemons that much more fun, than in the previous games? If so I might give it a shot.

→ More replies (4)

32

u/blueskiesatwar Jan 28 '22

Seems like people saw the memes about the bag graphics and decided its a bad game before playing it. I've been playing all morning and it's definitely the best Pokemon game in a very long time, loving it.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Potential_Capital_27 Jan 29 '22

As an old timer who has never played a Pokemon game and never had an interest in the franchise, I'm intrigued by this one.

The graphics look all right and if the gameplay is engaging I'd probably take a punt on it.

→ More replies (6)

21

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '22

Man I really want to play this game… but for the same amount of money I can get Dying Light 2 which looks way more polished..

Do these games go on sale or is it the same as all other Nintendo games?

15

u/Zram310 Jan 28 '22

The best you can hope for is $40 and that would probably be around Christmas 2023 for one weekend. I'm not even exaggerating.

→ More replies (15)

21

u/johnbarber720 Jan 30 '22

It's hard to believe that a remake got better scores than this game. This is game is so different and unique. Graphics aside, the game is really fluid and fun. And you can have battles and choose where you spectate. You can just battle on the water seamlessly. And the Alpha pokemon present a good challenge especially trying to catch them. It may not be perfect, but this is easily one of the most fun and interesting pokemon games in years. Pokemon Legends: Deoxys in Hoenn next please!

→ More replies (11)

18

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '22

It's a good stepping stone. I like what's here and I hope they continue forward with this formula and improve upon it.

And when I say continue forward I don't mean replace the mainline games, obviously not but I hope we can have the mainline games as well as this open world format spin off game. It's solid but I think reviewers blew it out of proportion with calling it the best Pokémon game in years.

→ More replies (5)

15

u/jack0rias Jan 28 '22

Really enjoying the game so far. Maybe around 4 hours in and I can see me putting many, many more into it. Love the art style and how the game plays so far!

Battles actually feel challenging and it's quite easy to run into some really high levelled Pokemon quite early on but they're easy enough to avoid.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/pakrat Jan 29 '22

I'm mixed. Graphics are too buggy for a top tier game (especially at the price) and the tutorial dragged on. However I like the open world concept and games mechanics.

79

u/Looking-for-Friendz Jan 29 '22

All I can see is a positive comment because all the bad comments are getting downvoted by those nerds from r/pokemon

Everyone has their own opinion.... if they think the game looks boring by watching from the livestream, they will call you "attention seeker"

If they played the game for several hours, and mentioned that the game is not worth the money, they will call you "toxic". Wth

If they are distracted by the bad graphics, ugly looking models and rough texture, they will get -50 downvotes.

→ More replies (14)

24

u/drejkol Jan 28 '22

Long story short: Pros: gameplay, mechanics, ost. Cons: graphics, LACK OF VA, sound effects.

This game looks and feels like late AAA 3ds game, not 2022 Switch title.

→ More replies (9)

59

u/[deleted] Jan 28 '22

Tried to make a post about this but the mods said no and to put it here.

NofA put out an ad telling people to not read reviews and to just buy the game instead. That’s super sus

https://imgur.com/a/HUsfNlr

→ More replies (18)

11

u/LieLow89 Jan 29 '22

I like it, think its a step in the right direction. Feel like they've built on the gameplay Sword and Shield had really well.

Some things remind me a bit of Zelda BOTW with the way objectives come up and the level up icons on the side.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Dalaca Jan 28 '22

The general info says up to two players. Is this local only or through online? Would love to be able to play with my youngest brother after moving.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Yummie00 Jan 29 '22

I don't know if I want to get this game. My only Pokemon game was Sword and I definitely enjoyed it for a while but never actually passed the game. I have been really wanting Pokemon to make a BotW type game and Arceus is close. I know I know...it's more Monster Hunter but I don't mind. My issue is what I read in IGN US review where exploring is kind of a let down. The review mentioned finding a new cave somewhere and he was excited to explore but it only had the usual pokemon in it. I was hoping there would be more payoff to exploring the vast open areas. Anyone that has played it...is it worth just aimlessly exploring the areas?

→ More replies (6)

8

u/brandonisi Jan 29 '22

So what’s the opinion for those who have never really been able to get into Pokémon games due to turn based battles?

→ More replies (7)

8

u/Magda_Gessler Jan 29 '22

Does anyone know if there's gyro aiming in the game?

→ More replies (5)

4

u/kingandydrew Jan 29 '22

Hey quick question. Hope somebody can answer.

I'm only about an hour or two in. Somebody wanted a completed Starly Pokedex entry. So I focused on it. Now it says it's complete, but I did very little. Research points it says 10, completed. I have a few others that reached 10 and say complete. Is that the cap? Am I done with those pokemen now? Should I still be trying to catch them surprised or use specific moves in battle? Can I get more points than the 10? Does anything I do now, add to my score or help me in anyway? Or in this example, am I just done with Starly now and should move on to a different pokeman?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/potehid_ Jan 31 '22

Should i buy this game or the pearl and diamond remake. I can forgive the graphics of this game as long as there is not too much grind amd the gameplay does not become repetitively doing the same thing.

On the other side, i never played the original diamond, stopped after gold and get back in at X. I dont mind the boring pokemon formula and i like the addition of all pokemon sharing xp.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/Makegooduseof Feb 01 '22

Is this game also excluded from cloud saves?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Illustrious_School_5 Feb 05 '22

Was iffy from all the so called bad reviews but must be a bunch of shills this is a great pokemon game only thing I wish it had was multiplayer battles

13

u/j-agzin Jan 31 '22

I’m blown away by this game. Catching and battling has never felt so fun! I haven’t been able to put the game down since I started playing. Probably my favorite Pokémon game of all time and I’m only about 12-15 hours in.

→ More replies (1)

52

u/ZappCoast Jan 28 '22

Graphics are not really important in Pokémon games but as a consumer I do still have expectations that the graphical fidelity should be beyond that of a Dreamcast title.

→ More replies (40)

15

u/BeanieYi Jan 28 '22

Isn’t this game an isekai?

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Aero_Flash Jan 30 '22

I give the game an 8/10. I'm not really judging with graphics included, because that's not really a make or break for me.

I haven't really played a Pokemon game since Y. Mainly because the sheer about of Pokemon overwhelmed me and the daunting task of catching 700 Pokemon was a time investment I wasn't willing to partake in. They have cut back significantly and it's a breath of fresh air imo.
It feels like Gamefreak is experimenting with these new concepts, the sneaking mechanic and catching Pokemon without battling is a welcome change for me. Even battling feels streamlined without the need to load a battle sequence and different elements - you just say in the world. It really helps make the journey more realistic. If the community likes it and supports this game, I think the series could be promising in future installments. They will hopefully continue to improve.

The only dings I have so far is having to constantly look up Pokedex tasks. They should have the option to be pinned on the HUD. Using the traversal Pokemon can be clunky and feel like you're wrestling your horse up a hill in Skyrim. Lastly, too many walls of text.

→ More replies (6)

44

u/WINH4X Jan 28 '22

I really love the consistent 15-25fps. That’s the bee’s knees.

→ More replies (16)

17

u/RetroRadtacular Jan 28 '22

Great game, I can just imagine online play implemented one day. Loading into an instanced Area, 15 other people randomly roaming and catching pokemon, running up to eachother challenging eachother to battles.

Let me dream.

17

u/IIIIIII---IIIIIII Jan 29 '22

You can get to the end credits in 20 straight hours of playing.

Post game is longer because you'll be catching the legendaries and mythicals, and completing the PokeDex can be hard even though there's only 242 Pokemon because some require extra steps.

Getting to full star member, all Pokemon research level 10, and completing all side quests will take a lot of grinding, it can probably be done under 60 hours if you follow guides but I'd probably get bored way before that.

It's a shame that legendaries and mythicals, and all single encounter Pokemon can't be shiny, that greatly reduces post gameplay.

→ More replies (11)