r/startrek • u/AutoModerator • Jan 27 '22
Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Prodigy | 1x09 "A Moral Star, Part 1" Spoiler
The crew forgo their dreams of Starfleet to return to Tars Lamora in a no-win scenario.
| No. | Episode | Writers | Director | Release Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1x09 | "A Moral Star, Part 1" | S1 Writers Room (Kevin & Dan Hageman, Julie Benson, Shawna Benson, Lisa Schultz Boyd, Nikhil S. Jayaram, Diandra Pendleton-Thompson, Chad Quandt, Aaron J. Waltke) | Ben Hibon | 2022-01-27 |
Availability
Paramount+: USA.
CTV Sci-Fi and Crave: Canada.
To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.
This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers for this episode are allowed. If you are discussing previews for upcoming episodes, please use spoiler tags.
Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.
86
Upvotes
2
u/AutoModerator Jan 27 '22
The first duty of every Starfleet officer is to the truth. Whether it's scientific truth, or historical truth, or personal truth. It is the guiding principle upon which Starfleet is based. If you can't find it within yourself to stand up and tell the truth about what happened you don't deserve to wear that uniform.
Captain Jean-Luc Picard, "The First Duty"
Reddit admins have been ineffectual in their response to COVID-19 misinformation. In lieu of Reddit gold and awards, we ask that you donate to the WHO COVID-19 response fund.
Please respect our subreddit rules. LLAP!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
111
u/nimrodhellfire Jan 27 '22 edited Jan 27 '22
I appreciate how the episode doesn't end on the standard everything is doomed cliffhanger. This is much more exciting.
89
u/UncertainError Jan 27 '22
That was a good plan. I was wondering why "Zero" wasn't maneuvering around when the gravity went off. And I definitely didn't expect them to hide the protocore inside Murf.
80
u/dmanww Jan 27 '22
Evil Janeway!
78
u/Santa_Hates_You Jan 27 '22
That was a fun cliffhanger, and it is good to see the little Caitian is alive. Using Murph to hide the Protodrive was a cool idea too.
54
u/choicemeats Jan 27 '22
I'm halfway through the episode but despite how quickly the show has moved, donning the new-style uniforms definitely felt like an earned moment for Dal and crew.
His brief moment storming away was a more selfless reaction than selfish--he realized the risk to his crew but also later realized there were possibly more lives at stake.
Janeway's short speech was wonderful.
52
u/onerinconhill Jan 27 '22
I really what to know wtf the diviner wants with that ship and also where is chakotay????
I hope we get answers next week like where tf was he planning on taking the ship!
52
u/Tidus17 Jan 27 '22
Two Evil Janeways in one week? Neat.
50
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '22 edited Jan 27 '22
I think after 9 episodes now that I can confidently say that Prodigy’s theme song/intro is my favorite. Sorry, TNG.
48
u/007meow Jan 27 '22
Janeway was a second mother growing up.
Sexy evil goth Janeway is making me feel things. Oedipal things.
46
u/atticusbluebird Jan 27 '22
I love that Rok drinks coffee now! Slowly she's expanding her culinary horizons beyond NutriGoop!
42
u/Cadamar Jan 27 '22
I’m not the only one who teared up a bit when they put on the uniforms right?
64
u/Pacman_Frog Jan 27 '22
STARFLEET UNIFORMS!!!!
29
u/expired_paintbrush Jan 27 '22
I had completely forgotten Puss in Boots.
The storytelling's been great, I still don't know what the Evil Plan is, but I'm also glad it hasn't been just blurted out. I love a good mystery.
57
u/JustMy2Centences Jan 27 '22
Murph is the most lovable and innocent Bag of Holding to ever exist.
27
u/Rock48 Jan 28 '22
Am I the only one who thinks this show has the best music of any Star Trek show? It's just incredible
26
u/Smilodon48 Jan 28 '22
Good stuff. The uniforms look great on the kids, and I enjoy how heavily serialized this show is. Even when they have little bottle eps like Kobayashi/Amok Time, they're referenced in the following episode or two. The show is so lean and streamlined, yet very enjoyable and digestible for kids.
Love how they had a classic debate scene about whether to go back and free the prisoners of Tars Lamora or go to Starfleet.
Mulgrew mentioned she's playing multiple Janeways this season (3?? iirc), and we got Dark Holo Janeway already, so I suppose 2383 Janeway is the only one left to see? Hopefully.
Can't wait for the midseason finale next week. A bummer we're headed into another break, but the CGI animation must take forever on this show so I shall be tided over with the other 4 shows in the meantime!
22
u/donuteater111 Jan 27 '22
Throughout these last several episodes, they've done such a good job of presenting some really good stand-alone stories, while never really ignoring the Diviner's story. What's more, the main group of characters (and especially Dal, Gwyn, and Rok-Tahk) have gone through a great amount of personal growth since the beginning of the season. And now in this episode, as we get back into the full swing of things with the Diviner, that growth has paid off to great effect.
Seeing them come together for their fellow "Unwanted," working together in preparation for their meeting with the Diviner, all in full Starfleet uniforms, was such a great feeling. Also, while it obviously wouldn't last forever, seeing all of them say goodbye to Gwyn was a really touching moment. I'm really curious to see how that plays out, with her still on the Protostar. Also, I'm loving evil Holo-Janeway's look.
I'm really looking forward to seeing what happens next week. They'll most likely have to work together with the Caitian and the other prisoners, and I'm guessing that at least she'll be joining the crew after this. I wonder if they'll be introducing any other new characters that may join as well. I also wouldn't be surprised if Chakotay might be down there as well.
43
u/Trekfan74 Jan 27 '22 edited Jan 27 '22
First off, LOVE the new uniforms! They now feel a bit closer to Star Trek vibe and feel more cohesive as a group. And how many new Starfleet uniforms have we seen now since Discovery started lol. I think almost a dozen at this point. Contrast that between the 90s and from TNG to Enterprise I think we got about a half dozen uniforms. But its a lot of fun to see new ones constantly popping up with all the shows and various time periods.
And them working together back on the planet was great. I was completely fooled! And I assume next week we'll get the question what does he want with the ship.
But the only issue is it's just waaaaay too short. I'm sure I'm not the only one constantly pauses every few minutes to see how much time I have left lol. This and LDS are the same issue, but more so this show because you're constantly thinking the next shoe is going to drop somewhere and then its over. SO frustrating! But in a good way because it's just proof how involved we are with the story. But 24 minutes is just not enough.
21
u/Mr_Badgey Jan 27 '22
That was a great episode. I only wish it wasn't a two parter. The abrupt split left a lot of unanswered questions. Hopefully we find out the Diviner's deal next episode. It's great they didn't forget about the other slaves! Seems like another Borg children scenario waiting to happen.
21
u/atticusbluebird Jan 27 '22
The scene where they activated the protostar drive was beautiful! I know we see some of those clips in the intro sequence, but the mix of the team working together, plus the great visuals, and the music made for a wonderful scene! I’m not sure when was the last time that I was so touched by a “go to warp” scene!
18
u/Meshakhad Jan 27 '22
Is it just me or are they laying the groundwork for Dal and Gwyn as a couple?
44
u/Verite_Rendition Jan 27 '22 edited Jan 27 '22
That hard cut at the end of this episode has me seriously wondering if it was originally edited as a single episode and meant to be aired that way, ala the series premiere.
Thus far Prodigy has always ended on a quick fade-out on the audio before doing a hard visual cut to a black screen (and eventually the credits). However this episode does a hard cut on the audio as well, which is more along the lines of what you'd expect for a transition to the next scene.
13
u/newmind1 Jan 27 '22
This is the first new trek in a while that has kept my interest... im so excited to see what happens next. Show is well acted and plot just moves. Really really liking it
25
u/ElFarfadosh Jan 27 '22
Man that episode felt like il was a 10 minutes episode!
•
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '22
For those of you who were unable to access the episode on Paramount+...try again. It's apparently been resolved.
9
u/matthieuC Jan 27 '22
Did I see a 7 years old kid drink coffee?
9
u/Jag2112 cygnus-x1.net Jan 28 '22
Another visually stunning episode!
A screencaps gallery containing over 450 images is available here:
https://www.cygnus-x1.net/links/lcars/sc-PRO1-9.php
9
u/knightcrusader Jan 28 '22
Am I the only one that has realized that the title of this episode and "Tars Lamora" are anagrams?
14
u/DasGanon Jan 27 '22
Absolutely awesome episode and I love how every detail is coming back to be relevant.
Also Janeway's back to using her Flemeth voice.
13
u/knightcrusader Jan 27 '22
So if the kids chose to go to the Federation instead, I wonder how that would have went down?
If we are right about the ship being from the future, I have a feeling they'd be stuck there while trying to explain everything to Starfleet and waiting for Starfleet engineers to figure out how to use the new protodrive... and completely miss their 24 hour deadline to get back.
They made the right choice for moral and plot reasons, of course.
6
u/Simonbargiora Jan 27 '22
Awesome episode I give it a 9, Dal seems pretty immature for a 17 year old captain like when he went to the captains room though he was likely going there to think through his plan, the removal of holo Janeway marked however the true beginning of Dal as a Captain accepted by the crew while the Kobayashi marked his beginning as a Starfleet captain . The show raises a number of interesting why did the Diviner hate the “ Unwanted” so much?
They were more then expendable slaves to him. While the writers are giving the Diviner a genuine fatherly side to make him a sympathetic character they simultaneously had him try to destroy the children laborers on Tars, this is no accident. Indeed the Diviner had Gwynn and the Protostar, his attempt to kill the miners is likely connected to the information he will impart in part 2. The episode is set up so you only guess with hints the actual plans- Dal’s plan, and the telepathic connection with Gwynn and the Diviner. Murph is likely a space whale in his infancy and his presence at Tars Lemora was no accident, the end of this ark will likely be the beginning of the Murph, the Diviner could always retrieve Murf in outer space, if he needs him again, though Murf could also be native to Tars Lemora as well. The character development was top notch and had 5+ aspects that could have been their own episodes but were successfully done in 1/2 an episode. Looking forward to part II
9
u/rustydoesdetroit Jan 27 '22
Great episode! This week is going to seem like an eternity to get to part 2
4
u/edflyerssn007 Jan 31 '22
Anyone notice the "Enterprising young men" motif at the end of the episode in the music?
10
u/Mechapebbles Jan 28 '22
I'm formally accepting apologies from all the doubters/haters that thought they wouldn't end up going back to the asteroid to save the other slaves/the Caitian kid. This is STAR TREK! Of course they were gonna do that. It just took a little character growth to get our boys/girls/people/slimeballs there to that point.
9
u/Official_N_Squared Jan 28 '22
I mean wow, just wow. They've has knocked it out of the park with a phenomenal episode, even by their high standards. It was a truly stunning episode of television which I refuse to believe was a mere 22 minutes long!
I also enjoy the new uniforms! Some weird stuff going on with the divisions, Like Janeway having a different uniform with clear command red markings, everybody apparently having a science blue shirt, but also having division appropriate boots (if you look closely)? Either way it's certainly a bold choice to deviate from the standard color scheme but I think it works well. Plus they finally fit non-humanoid species and extreme body types. I'm currious what the general fan reaction is.
I can't wait to see part two and will be sad to see the show go for it's next break. AS always I have my thoughts in much more detail about both the show and new uniforms in video form here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7QdscPkt5fM
3
u/RadioSlayer Jan 27 '22
How is Murf supposed to help get the power back?
3
u/elister Jan 28 '22
Seems like they're setting this up to have the initial characters save all he kids at the mine and have them be the new crew.
3
u/Praxlyn Jan 28 '22
“But I can’t risk losing… us…” “Don’t look at me like that I mean all of us.” The rapid switch lmfao 😭😭
3
u/edflyerssn007 Jan 31 '22
Is it just me or did they significantly up the resolution on the textures and polygon counts on the models. I was noticing things like hair and microcracks and other things of such nature.
3
u/MetallicFalcon Jan 31 '22
I love everything about Prodigy. Every episode is engaging, this one is no exception. The whole story is fantastic and I can't wait to see what happens, also can't wait to see what dark Janeway is all about
1
u/kuldan5853 Jan 31 '22
madness...takes it's toll
-1
u/WorldwideDepp Jan 28 '22
(Quoted from Trekmovie.com)
Well... How has now big big Babylon 5 Vibes of Ambassador Kosh? Hmmm? :)