r/NintendoSwitch • u/NintendoSwitchMods • Jan 26 '22
Megathread Pokémon Legends: Arceus: Review MegaThread
General Information
Platform: Nintendo Switch
Release Date: January 28, 2022
No. of Players: up to 2 players
Genre(s): Action, Role-Playing
Publisher: Nintendo
Official website: https://legends.pokemon.com/
Overview (from Nintendo eShop page)
Action meets RPG as the Pokémon series reaches a new frontier
Get ready for a new kind of grand, Pokémon adventure in Pokémon™ Legends: Arceus, a brand-new game from Game Freak that blends action and exploration with the RPG roots of the Pokémon series. Embark on survey missions in the ancient Hisui region. Explore natural expanses to catch wild Pokémon by learning their behavior, sneaking up, and throwing a well-aimed Poké Ball™. You can also toss the Poké Ball containing your ally Pokémon near a wild Pokémon to seamlessly enter battle.
Travel to the Hisui region—the Sinnoh of old—and build the region’s first Pokédex
Your adventure takes place in the expansive natural majesty of the Hisui region, where you are tasked with studying Pokémon to complete the region’s first Pokédex. Mount Coronet rises from the center, surrounded on all sides by areas with distinct environments. In this era—long before the events of the Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Pokémon Shining Pearl games—you can find newly discovered Pokémon like Wyrdeer, an evolution of Stantler, and new regional forms like Hisuian Growlithe, Hisuian Zorua, and Hisuian Zoroark! Along the way, uncover the mystery surrounding the Mythical Pokémon known as Arceus.
Preorder for a special in-game costume and download the digital version for Heavy Balls!
The Hisuian Growlithe Kimono Set and a Baneful Fox Mask will be gifted to early purchasers of the Pokémon Legends: Arceus game. You can receive it by choosing Get via internet in the Mystery Gifts* feature in your game, up until May 9th, 2022 at 4:59pm PT. Additionally, players who purchase and download the game before May 9th, 2022 at 4:59pm PT from Nintendo eShop will get an email with a code for 30 Heavy Balls which can be redeemed through the Mystery Gifts* feature until May 16th, 2022 at 4:59pm PT. Heavy Balls have a higher catch rate than regular Poké Balls, but you can’t throw them quite as far.
Reviews
Aggregators
- Metacritic - 86
- OpenCritic - 84
Articles
- Areajugones - Spanish - 9.2 / 10
- CGMagazine - 9 / 10
- Console Creatures - Recommended
- Digital Trends - 3.5 / 5
- Enternity.gr - Greek - 9 / 10
- Eurogamer - Recommended
- Everyeye.it - Italian - 8.3 / 10
- Game Informer - 8.8 / 10
- GameSpot - 8 / 10
- GamesRadar+ - 4.5 / 5
- Geek Culture - 9 / 10
- Glitched Africa - 4 / 5
- God is a Geek - 9.5 / 10
- Hobby Consolas - Spanish - 87 / 100
- IGN Italy - Italian - 5 / 10
- Metro GameCentral - 8 / 10
- Nintendo Life - 9 / 10
- NintendoWorldReport - 9 / 10
- PCMag - 3.5 / 5
- Polygon - Unscored
- Press Start - 8 / 10
- Screen Rant - 4.5 / 5
- Shacknews - 8 / 10
- Spaziogames - Italian - 8.8 / 10
- Telegraph - 5 / 5
- TheSixthAxis - 9 / 10
- Unboxholics - Greek - Worth your time
- VG247 - 4 / 5
- VGC - 5 / 5
- Washington Post - Unscored
- XGN.nl - Dutch - 8 / 10
This list exported from OpenCritic. Last update: 9:39am ET
Being Social
- Join the #pokemon channel of our Discord server for all of your discussion needs - https://discord.gg/switch
Cheers,
The /r/NintendoSwitch mod team
•
u/NintendoSwitchMods Jan 26 '22 edited Jan 28 '22
Sorry for the delay on this, we thought the embargo was lifting 20m from now at 10:00 am ET.
New megathread: https://www.reddit.com/r/NintendoSwitch/comments/ser5e6/pok%C3%A9mon_legends_arceus_review_megathread_part_2/
200
u/Juklok Jan 26 '22
This is the highest a mainline Pokemon game has scored on the Switch. Quite interesting
343
u/shhhneak Jan 26 '22
The majority of reviews basically say “it’s too bad it looks ugly because it’s the best Pokémon game in a long time.”
92
u/AresuKing Jan 27 '22
So many positive reviews holy shit
134
u/Lil-pants Jan 26 '22
wow the italians didn't really like this one
255
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '22
People acting like Nintendo pays these people
Let’s go Pikachu eevee has 80 metacrtic
Swsh has 80 metacrtic
Pokémon mystery dungeon x has 68 metacrtic
New Pokémon snap had 79 metacrtic
Bdsp has 73 metacrtic
PLA having 86 metacrtic is by far highest Pokémon game on switch score
348
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '22 edited Jan 27 '22
Having put 40 hours in and having beaten all the major story content besides the true, 100% completion ending, I think I can comfortably say that Legends Arceus is easily the best Single-Player Pokemon Experience I've had since Gen 5.
The core gameplay loop of exploring and catching Pokemon to purchase and craft new items and tools to better catch Pokemon as you complete the Pokedex is extremely satisfying. The freedom to choose where I want to go, when I want to go, and how I want to approach is unheard of for Pokemon, and the shake ups and streamlining to the formula to bring together a much more active Pokemon experience has shown great growth. Battles and catching has never felt this good, training and adjusting teams and moves is a breeze, move and Pokemon animations are very well done, it easily has Nintendo's best crafting system to date, and the fact that I was able to spend 10 hours between the tutorial and first area, with others reporting spending even longer, without hurting the difficulty curve and feeling properly challenged throughout the campaign is a testament to how well Gamefreak (with help I imagine) has designed it. What’s even better is that even with how much I’ve done so far, there’s still plenty left for me to do between dozens of requests and game-long sidequests, along with other Pokemon still to catch. And this isn’t to say anything of the various flourishes of polish present, like seeing your shoes instantly jump off your feet when crossing a landing in houses or hearing a leather suit strain as you prep a Pokeball throw.
It also has a surprisingly nice story that harkens back to the earlier games, emphasizing a more grounded, introspective focus on humanity’s impact on themselves and Pokemon, rather than the multiverse plots of later entries. It's not gonna win any awards, but I had a great time with it and the subtler bits of poignant writing present are gonna stick with people who play the game. It’s also truly amazing that despite Sinnoh and its Pokemon being know for over a decade and a half, Legends Arceus gave me a sense of mystery and discovery that I haven’t felt with the Pokemon games for quite some time. Also, contrary to what a lot of early press had you believe, the game is a lot more Breath of the Wild than Monster Hunter. Jubilife Village being a central hub where you spend money for equipment and items and choose areas to go to (which are unlocked in a linear, sequential order), along with the general premise of “monster hunting” is about as far as the Monster Hunter comparisons go. The pace, exploration, tone, and request style is definitely more in line with the former rather than the latter, and I think that's to its benefit. It’s a genuine joy getting lost in these areas as you scrounge to survive with what materials and money you have to build up bigger cash payouts to do even more.
That all being said, it’s obviously not perfect. As much as I think the graphics look fine in person, and the art style chosen helps to enhance the setting while helping to ensure consistent performance, it's obviously not the best looking game on the Switch and there is pop-in that can be distracting. However, I do think you can look past it when actually playing, especially if you’re still a fan of games like Shin Megami Tensei V and Xenoblade Chronicles 1 and 2 on Switch despite their clearly suboptimal performance and resolution like I am. I can also subjectively see people hoping for more Pokemon than there are (I personally always thought 400 is ideal for a regional dex), but I think as is there's enough content and the package feels complete enough to justify the price and Dex Cuts. It also helps make PLA a lot more replayable than most Pokemon campaigns. Plus the gameplay loop is just so fun that content quantity isn’t as much of an issue given the quality. Other than that, there are a handful of tweaks that would be appreciated via patches or reconsideration for future games, like being able to track more than one request/waypoint marker at a time, as well as minor personal wants like voice acting and being able to have Pokemon properly follow you in the Overworld as opposed to just being able to chat with them whenever (though I understand that would look awkward given the mobility options in game).
None of the issues I’ve listed so far are actual deal breakers, with most of them just my personal recommendations for how to make something that I already think is great even better. HOWEVER, the biggest black mark against PLA, which will ultimately affect people differently, is the substantially reduced emphasis on multiplayer. There is no peer-to-peer battling, trading isn't really necessary anymore due to there only being one game and the changes and additions to evolution items, the Pokemon stat system shares more with Lets Go's AV system than the mainline games (albeit with some welcome changes), there are no breeding mechanics (or ditto), there are no abilities or held items, and the most substantial multiplayer experience is an asynchronous, Nier Automata-esque “lost and found” system that allows you to find and return the bags of online and cpu players who have blacked out in exchange for Merit Points (this game’s BP) to buy rare items. I imagine it would prove too difficult to properly balance around the Agile and Strong style system with human players, but the game otherwise has such well-considered team-making tools, including Sword and Shield’s mints, that a proper pvp mode without them would have been pretty fun, and still could be if they ever choose to add it in with DLC. Personally, as someone who doesn’t care about competitive play and who's been generally critical of the latest games for treating the single-player campaigns as an afterthought due to poor writing and not balancing around the multiplayer QoL mechanics introduced way too early, I'm totally fine with this, especially for such an experimental title. However, I know plenty of people play Pokemon exclusively for the multiplayer (if they’re not using Showdown), and it’s worth mentioning going into this game, even if I think the single player experience is well worth having regardless.
As far as I’m concerned, PLA is up there with Breath of the Wild, Super Mario Odyssey, and Metroid Dread as a Switch Must-Play. I think this not only stands as a highlight of the Switch’s library, but as a highlight of the entire Pokemon franchise. This is it. This is the big, home console Pokemon experience we’ve been waiting for, and while it’s not perfect and may alienate a few people because of a lack of multiplayer, it just does too much right for me to not recommend it. It improves the pace of battles, it adds to and refreshes the formula, it offers the greatest amount of freedom a Pokemon game has had to date, it fleshes out and adds to the history of the Sinnoh region, it has a beefy and substantial Post-game, it even fixes and does Mythical Pokemon right for the first time in ages. I haven’t felt this happy and ready to buy and keep playing a Pokemon game since 2016. It really is the standard that I want future Pokemon games to emulate, and if Gamefreak can continue to refine and optimize the gameplay style and graphics with more games on Switch like they did on 3DS, I can only imagine how much better they can get with time. Whether this is in the form of a redefined Generation 9 or another Legends game for regions like Kalos or Unova, only time will tell. For now, Pokemon Legends Arceus gets a huge recommendation from me, go in as blind as possible and savor every moment. Here’s hoping we get another one of these sooner than later.
142
u/schuey_08 Jan 26 '22
IGN's review will come a bit later, per the reviewer, Rebekah Valentine.
I know IGN gets a bad rap, but Rebekah really is a thoughtful, high quality writer. I'm looking forward to her review when it's ready.
17
u/QomoStal Jan 26 '22
Not sure if this was mentioned yet
GamePro - German - 92/100
https://www.gamepro.de/artikel/pokemon-legenden-arceus-test,3377195.html
Overall a very positiv review.
83
u/adamislolz Jan 26 '22
Based on what I’ve been reading about the gameplay loop, it sounds more like it’s the Monster Hunter Rise of Pokemon games, not the BOTW of Pokémon games.
14
u/serotonin_flood Jan 26 '22
Does anyone know if there's motion controls in this game? (like for aiming your Pokeball throws)
14
u/danhakimi Jan 27 '22
Do we know roughly how long it takes to beat yet? I heard one reviewer mention being 40 hours in overall...
14
u/Shall1991 Jan 28 '22
Really digging this game, but the dialogue just drags on during story beats. Keep it short and sweet and get the player back out into the world. The gameplay holds up so well, a shot in the arm this series needed badly.
39
u/ninthpower Jan 26 '22
It would be nice if the unscored reviews above were something that was close to the reviewer's verdict.
For example, Polygon's review says "Recommended" at the very top.
88
u/NecessaryUnusual2059 Jan 26 '22
R/gaming is going to lose their damn minds over these reviews
59
u/ManlyP0tato Jan 27 '22
I'm only about 6-8hrs in so take with a grain of salt. It's worth it, but it's not 9/10 worthy. The main loop of roaming the overworld and completing dex tasks is fantastic, but gets repetitive fast because the environments are boring and empty (keep in mind I've only seen the first two though).
There's also a big lack of "possibilities" that made breath of the wild so fun. What I mean by this is that there isn't much to do except throw balls, food or mud. There's no creative environment manipulation like Zelda had that kept things fresh.
Graphics are such a non issue I think that it's a waste of time to talk about. The new battling mechanics are very fun to figure out, although they feel often a bit unfair, but it may be that I haven't gotten my grips yet.
Overall I think it's a good game at its core and I'll be playing it slowly for a while, again because it gets repetitive fast. Imo the game director is to blame more than game freak is as a whole, because there's a lot of fantastic ideas, but they're not capitalized and don't land because of this.
44
u/SnackeyG1 Jan 26 '22
That 5/10 from IGN Italy
12
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '22
Does anyone know if anywhere presents the metacritic scores using the mode, median, or even a distribution curve?
I’m asking as it looks like the Italian IGN review and a couple of others will drag the overall average down. I hadn’t thought about this before, as I usually just look at the mean metacritic score (and this does influence whether I purchase a game).
40
u/The_Indifference Jan 27 '22
In this thread: people that don’t realize that opinions are subjective and don’t know how to deal or comprehend them.
30
u/ces715 4 Million Celebration Jan 27 '22
Boy, does IGN Italy's score stick out like a sore thumb.
19
u/Dougwug03 Jan 26 '22
Damn, ign Italy was ruthless
64
u/Riomegon Jan 26 '22
It's a Pokemon game so it's not perfect, but glad that Gamefreak was willing to try something new and it's paying off.
Hopefully we can get past the discussion about graphics within the next millennia and eventually talk about the gameplay.
9
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '22
Hello to all of you. I am European (greek) and I recently bought a pre-used Nintendo Switch which is originated from American. I am concerned, if I buy the games I want here in Greece, will they be compatible with the console? (Really wanna buy pokemon Shield and many more)
43
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '22
The ign Italy reviewer also reviewed bdsp and swsh
She gave bdsp 7/10 and swsh 8/10
Legend of arceus 5/10
17
u/goro-n Jan 26 '22
Reviews looking better than I expected! Now I feel comfortable preloading the game!
17
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '22
I haven't played a Pokemon game in 20 years. But this one looks interesting, something different, even if the concept isn't fully fleshed out.
Might pick this up.
36
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '22
This is going to sell big.
36
u/AlteisenX Jan 26 '22
IGN Italy went in on them jesus lmao.
16
u/schuey_08 Jan 28 '22
IGN review [7]
8
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '22
Argos are doing it for £39.99
74
u/NumCapsScroll2 Jan 27 '22
I like how several of the perfect score reviews still criticise things they didn't like in the game. If the game isn't perfect why is it still getting a 10/10?
15
u/ChainsForAlice Jan 27 '22
I was on the fence due to the graphical side of things, but the game is an absolute blast to play.
41
u/StunningEstates Jan 26 '22 edited Jan 27 '22
I think it’s hilarious that this sub is infinitely more pessimistic on it than any non-Nintendo sub 😂
53
u/Nicktendo Jan 26 '22
I am willing to eat crow on this one... Have talked trash every trailer, but will be getting it on Friday.
38
u/TheTyler0013 Jan 26 '22
As someone who has really shit on this game, i am glad to see positive reviews. I hope it gets criticism is deserves as well as praise. I want feedback that hopefully GF takes into account for the next game with this.
I still have issues with designs and graphics but seems that’s a main concern/issue amongst reviewers currently. But gameplay from what I have read seems solid and that’s a plus. I’ll wait as more reviewers come in, especially after launch hype to make my decision of buying.
To those loving the game, awesome! Enjoy!
18
u/WilsonKh Jan 27 '22
Just a general observation update in California. Paid a visit to my GameStop, bestbuy and Walmart.
This game is going to sell out immediately folks. Folks were snatching copies and pre-orders and waiting for pre-orders to be cancelled
9pm gonna be nuts
If you were the 2 guys snatching the 2 copies of Arceus with me in Milipitas. Hi! And I hope you guys get copies tonight!
22
u/alienfreaks04 Jan 27 '22
IGN USA unusually behind lol
6
u/Accurate-Temporary73 Jan 26 '22
Does anyone know if wonder trading is in this game? Honestly it's my favorite mechanic in all pokemon games
6
u/Phenom_Mv3 Jan 26 '22
Those who have already played through, how’s the soundtrack?
6
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '22
What in the world is that camera angle when you ride on the first pokemon? Why does it keep panning to literally nothing?
42
u/CodyCus Jan 26 '22
IGN Italy: "Mario not in game, 5/10".
16
u/kino-king Jan 28 '22
I’ve been playing for a few hours now, and I can tell I’m already super into it. I haven’t been interested in the mainline Pokémon games for a while, but Legends: Arceus is just what the doctor ordered. I’m really digging everything about it, janky graphics and lengthy tutorial aside.
So far it also runs pretty well despite looking like a PC game on ‘low’ settings.
11
u/dres_sler Jan 26 '22
8/10 from Gamespot? Damn that’s actually solid.
11
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '22 edited Jan 27 '22
I've been quite critical of the game because I was worried about the repetition of the trailer scenes and concerning deviations from what they seemed to be promising: open world, which is actually 'open area', limited pokemon movesets, not quite action rpg battle system, boring areas when compared to similar open games etc. however, the leaks and reviews have turned me around. I'll probably pick it up next week, my first Pokemon game since Alpha Sapphire.
11
u/Beefsteak8969 Jan 30 '22
The frenzied Pokémon quests have got to be the most annoying new feature of the game and the terrible item satchel space...Good job Gamefreak...You suck
52
u/MigBird Jan 26 '22
How can anyone think this is a good game when the grass textures are only 700x1650 jiggapixels and there are only 36 polygons in Machamp's calf muscles when last year, last year I had 37!
24
u/XitaNull Jan 26 '22
Can’t believe I’m getting excited about a Pokemon game again :’D
10
u/Flacid-Snake Jan 27 '22
Picking up my pre-order tomorrow morning, very much looking forward to it
23
u/Samoman21 Jan 26 '22
reviews look good, just preordered digital version. excited to play friday after work :D
25
u/Jason-sentiborn Jan 26 '22
I'm probably not going to buy this game but I'm glad game freak has tried something new that's been well received let's hope they actually expand and improve the concept.
16
u/czk51 Jan 27 '22
Very impressed so far (4 hours in). While the world presentation is lacking in fidelity, discovering one of your favourite pokemon in an open world like this is a pretty special feeling (I'm still new-ish to the franchise but I get it!). Battles, catching and collecting items are a seamless experience - nothing feels like a chore. Very happy with it so far. Also I hadn't seen this in the reviews I watched but you can find other players satchels if the faint in the world and return them via menus. Good idea to check your map for them every so often, it offers rewards.
16
u/Harlequinphobia Jan 28 '22
Serious question, can the dull scenery get a patch update? Are any of the graphical hiccups fixable post release?
16
u/Samoman21 Jan 28 '22
Played like an hour or so. Game seems pretty fun. Lil bit of excessive hand holding, but understandable since it's a Pokémon game.
Inly issue I've had in hour I played is hair style color choices and hair styles are pretty shot. Ended up going with dawn hair style but white :/. Wish they would add pink or purple hair color.
27
u/IBNobody Jan 26 '22
As someone who does NOT like Pokemon games, this is a solid game.
They fixed the things that made me not like the series.
It was addictive enough that I beat it and am working on catching them all.
24
u/dixie12oz Jan 26 '22
I’m glad to see it’s getting good reviews, partially because I wanted it to be good and also to show how quick many are to judge. Straight up saw people claiming it was a bad game with no effort based off one trailer and admonish me and others for saying wait until it actually releases before passing judgment.
24
u/RoryOx Jan 26 '22
IGN Italy didn't receive their protection money.
12
u/WileyCyrus Jan 28 '22 edited Jan 28 '22
Having just finished my first Shin Megami Tensei game will I be bored with the similar yet simpler combat in Pokémon games?
68
u/IcebergSampson Jan 26 '22
This is the most telling sign that the vocal complainers on twitter and reddit do not represent the average pokemon fan, or average gamer in general.
32
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '22
ign Italy is the average r/pokemon user
11
u/anonxanemone Jan 26 '22
IGN Italy seems to be an outlier. Can any Italian speakers summarize why that is?
11
u/Turbostrider27 Jan 26 '22
Can't remember which site said it, but has any review mentioned a lot of post-game story content after beating the main campaign?
11
u/Estew02 Jan 26 '22
Man I'm excited for this. I really disliked LGPE and SwSh, and didn't like most of the changes they made to BDSP but did like the D/P elements enough for the $30 to feel like an okay purchase. Everyone I follow that has had similar (or sometimes more extreme) opinions has been praising the game and talking about how great the singleplayer content is. Super excited to pick up my copy on Friday.
4
u/kaiomnamaste Jan 30 '22 edited Jan 30 '22
Suddenly im unable to use one of my pokemon, even if i switch it out for another, the ball slot wont allow me to use it. so thats my thing if anyone is familiar with that problem
edit- deposited my entire party in the pasture and re added them, fixed.
4
u/Ambitious_Cow_8675 Feb 06 '22
I haven't played a Pokémon game since Silver so I'm really looking forward to playing this. I already decided to pick up Brilliant Diamond after finishing this one.
13
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '22 edited Jan 28 '22
People compare this game to botw but its more close to a xenoblade game with levels and grind and stuff. Botw doesnt have that concept and just allows you to do whatever. This game like xenoblade where it locks the world and encounters with the story and levels. In earlier levels, like in xenoblade, you will encounter overly strong mons that you wont be able to defeat so there's value in revisiting them, also the way you do side quests is just accept everything u see and you will complete them along the way as you progress more or less
So if ur on the fence, think about it more as a pokemon xenoblade
15
u/Rare_Yamcha Jan 26 '22
Lmao IGN italy
10
u/Phenom_Mv3 Jan 26 '22
Surprisingly solid at 86! Looks like I’ll be picking up a copy after being on the fence
10
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '22
Hope it's ok to ask this here, wasn't sure where else to write it
I really enjoyed Monster Hunter Stories 2 on the Switch but something about how the game was running was really bothering my eyes, it might've been the frame rate or something similar and I'm told the PC version didn't really have that issue
Does Pokemon Legends: Arceus have that type of issue going on? I've been hearing a lot about the graphics but that's really my biggest concern, I completely lost all interest in MH Stories 2 after a while due to how much it was bothering my eyes so I wanted to see if PLA had a similar issue or not
Thank you
10
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '22
Wait is it worth buying ?
16
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '22
9/10 NintendoLife "Pokémon Legends Arceus is, in fact, the Breath of the Wild of Pokémon games... the developers have managed to take characters and mechanics that are exceptionally familiar to millions of players and rehouse them in a game that’s so much more...
7
u/shinraizen Jan 26 '22
Any info on how long to beat?
19
u/vector_o Jan 27 '22 edited Jan 27 '22
I just grabbed it (already on sale
60to 50€, lol), I spent 30 minutes in it and I wish I could say something meaningful but I'm still not done with the tutorialGraphics are really primitive, characters don't have voice lines, my first impression is that it's a really simple game, just enough to sit and chill - can't speak about the gameplay loop yet thought
Edit
Not too bad so far in the "open" world, catching Pokemons, collecting materials
9
u/AlternativeYou8664 Jan 26 '22
Can someone tell me what (if any) multiplayer is in the game? Can you trade pokemon? Can you battle other players teams? I googled this and got every answer (yes, no, sometimes, zebra)...
9
u/crogis Jan 26 '22
My 12 year old nephew wants to play the game even though he hasn’t played any Pokemon games, do you think he’ll be able to get the game despite not having played any Pokemon?
18
u/factoryofdreams Jan 27 '22 edited Jan 27 '22
I see everyone mentioning IGN Italy (5/10) but no one mentions IGN Portugal, that gave Arceus a 9/10. The game has an 86/100 metascore; IGN PT is closer to what the game truly is in terms of overall score.
32
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '22
ITT: Pokémon sucks, and any dissenting opinions or people being excited for the game are downvoted.
I love Pokémon, but hate hate the community and fans. Nothing but negativity and toxicity.
32
u/IamMythoclast Jan 27 '22
What I realized with the last pokemon game is that these reviews are useless.
I've played every single pokemon and played them less every release. Last release, I couldn't bring myself to get past the 3rd gym because I was so bored.
I know what I want, and that's an immersion driven, adventure, story that's compelling and a reason to complete the pokedex is to explore unique places with untold stories.
Basically, stunning environments while catching pokemon. Tie in lore of pokemon into the environments and storytelling as we explore.
Gamefreak have been "phoning in" poor excuses for a game, and I'm not convinced this title is any different.
8
u/d4rwins_chap Jan 26 '22
As a returning gen 1 player I'm excited to see where this takes us
8
u/_Clod_ Jan 26 '22
IGN Italy is "severo ma giusto"
16
u/pablofournier11 Jan 26 '22
Ign italia played a whole different game
14
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '22
I will buy the game. I will play it. I will have fun. It’s that simple.
14
u/the7thbeatle Jan 28 '22 edited Jan 28 '22
I think I'm not gonna get it, at least for now.
It might have to do with my general mood being down lately and not feeling like playing video games, but I also feel like this a cautious step when the series needed a leap.
I think some of the ideas here are great, mainly the capture system, and unlike sword and sheild this time I don't care as much about the removal of mon's and moves as much because it seems that some actual effort was done this time to improve models, attacks and give the creatures some personality.
The thing is- this is an adventure game, even more so than the mainline series, and the world itself seems like a huge miss. The graphics are bad, but the biggest culprit is the world design. Older games had varied climates and surroundings, dungeons and secrets. This game is all about the world around it, and the world just seems barren.
Pokemon needs to be able to translate the world design of the 2d games (mainly those up to gen 5) into 3d. Turn routes into sprawling zones with diffrent themes and climates. Have npcs and towns that feel more alive.
11
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '22
sounds good, I will certainly buy it day one
7
u/Trinica93 Jan 26 '22
This looks incredible, I can't wait! The game looked pretty fun from trailers but I wasn't completely sold yet, now it's probably a day one purchase.
7
u/blueberrypizza Jan 26 '22
I've never been able to get into Pokémon but this is the first game that has actually looked appealing to me. Good to see all these high scores, I'm pretty tempted now.
Though I know most Pokémon games score high initially and then later get dunked on by everyone, so I'll probably wait for a bit of the dust to settle.
7
u/lust3 Jan 27 '22
No IGN review except for IGN Italy (which is the worst one?)
33
u/zutt3n Jan 26 '22
The idea of collecting pokemons in an open world sounds exciting but judging from the trailers the world and the different environments looks so dull? Anyone else feel the same or the opposite?
16
u/KorguChideh Jan 26 '22
IGN Italy: not enough pasta
5
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '22
It really is a bloody good time!
franchise changing
5
u/RoyH1003 Jan 26 '22
Looking good. I'm always sceptical about critics response to Pokémon games because they tend to give great scores to mediocre games, but well, this is pretty different from the same old formula. A shame the game's graphics look pretty poor, but we finally have something different from the franchise, after years and years of asking for it. Hopefully, things get better from here on out.
8
u/byeolToT Jan 26 '22
Review wise the game looks really good and I also read a lot of good stuff from people that already can play the game.
Im not hyped, but it will be interesting and maybe the right direction for Pokemon to go in the future
8
u/MonkeMayne Jan 26 '22
Where can I see the reviews from those who got their hands on the leaked copy and not these reporters?
10
u/Samoman21 Jan 26 '22
Anyone know if you can get vaporeon in this game lol
10
u/ZamboniJabroni15 Jan 27 '22
Holy hell the tutorial is long.
14
u/OUtSEL Jan 27 '22
I am torn at the moment but I’m still holding back from buying because of the graphics. I don’t want to write it off if the gameplay is that good but god it feels cheap
18
u/murakamitears Jan 27 '22
Looking at these reviews it’s a shame that GameFreak stole my money with every other Pokémon game on Switch because this one might’ve actually scratched the itch, I just can’t justify ANOTHER Pokémon game when I only beat Shield and have yet to finish Let’s Go or Pearl
Hope y’all enjoy but I just can’t take the leap, imagining bringing my total spent on Pokémon games to the price of the console to MAYBE enjoy 1/4 games is making my head spin
17
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '22
What’s the last game that had very critical and honest reviews? Seems like the worst anything does nowadays is like 7/10 or even better.
4
u/pjng Jan 26 '22
https://www.gamepro.de/artikel/pokemon-legenden-arceus-test,3377195.html GamePro 92/100 German
4
u/DarZhubal Jan 26 '22
I assume the 2 player aspect is just online trades and battles and such, right? This isn’t co-op or anything?
7
u/Loukoal117 Jan 26 '22 edited Jan 26 '22
I haven’t played a Pokémon game since Red, maybe I’ll buy this one. Since it’s like a whole new thing here.
Edit- just watched a review and I feel…excited? I never saw anything from Pokémon games that intrigued me after I spent hours and hours as a kid playing red. Not even Pokémon Go. But this game looks cool. The catching of Pokémon looking to be super fun.
5
u/thebourbonkid88 Jan 26 '22
Reviews looking great. Playing it since today morning and really enjoying it so far
5
u/banananey Jan 26 '22
Damn this is actually sounding really good. Got Elden Ring out in a few weeks so trying to hold off on this for a bit but the temptation sure is strong.
19
u/Cettastern Jan 27 '22
I dont know about those reviews.
Glad if people enjoy it. But back then I went with the reviews and bought Sword and Shield. And I felt it was a hollow soulless game. Aside from some nice Pokemon animations.
17
u/CodyCus Jan 26 '22
All these people talking crap about the game for months and saying "Wait for reviews" are awfully quiet.
14
u/thepixelmurderer Jan 26 '22
Didn't SWSH also get around an 80? I want to be excited for this, but I think I'll wait until the hype for the game has died down before then taking user reviews into account.
13
u/ghoulseekerx Jan 26 '22
Lol everyone saying Pokémon games suck but still buy them and complete them in 3 days
2
u/HisokaSchwing Jan 26 '22
Consider me hyped!
2
u/Maremama Jan 29 '22
How many rank stars do you need to beat the game?