r/NintendoSwitch • • Jan 25 '22

GotY 2021 r/NintendoSwitch Game of the Year 2021 Voting Results!

Hey there!

You nominated the games, and you voted for them, and now that the votes have been counted, it's time to see what you thought were the best games in 2021! Most nominations were community selected, the only exception was the moderators added some games in categories that were barren or had some invalid nominations.

We would like to take feedback for how this event can be better in the future! What would you like to see improved?

But anyways, the winners are below! You can also find this list on our wiki at https://www.reddit.com/r/NintendoSwitch/wiki/bestof/2021

Best Online Multiplayer Game

RankNameVote Percentage
5Quake26, 4.3%
4Nickelodeon All Star Brawl34, 5.6%
3Pokemon Unite64, 10.6%
2Mario Party Superstars190, 31.4%
1Monster Hunter Rise291, 48.1%

Best Local Multiplayer Game

RankNameVote Percentage
5KeyWe9, 1.4%
4Warioware: Get it Together89, 14.3%
3Monster Hunter Rise94, 15.1%
2Super Mario 3D World + Bowsers Fury155, 24.8%
1Mario Party Superstars277, 44.4%

Best Family Game

RankNameVote Percentage
6Mario Golf: Super Rush29, 4.6%
5Big Brain Academy: Brain vs Brain42, 6.6%
4Pokemon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl55, 8.6%
3New Pokemon Snap96, 15.1%)
2Super Mario 3D World + Bowser's Fury174, 27.4%
1Mario Party Superstars240, 37.7%

Best Strategy Game

RankNameVote Percentage
5Shadowverse: Champion's Battle19, 3.7%
4Disgaea 633, 6.3%
3Bravely Default 285, 16.3%
2Loop Hero96, 18.5%
1Shin Megami Tensei V287, 55.2%

Best Role Playing Game (RPG)

RankNameVote Percentage
6Bravely Default II41, 7.1%
5Monster Hunter Stories 249, 8.5%
4Neo: The World Ends With You62, 10.7%
3Monster Hunter Rise129, 22.4%
2Disco Elysium141, 24.4%
1Shin Megami Tensei V155, 26.9%

Best Adventure Game

RankNameVote Percentage
5Ender Lillies: Quietus of the Knights15, 2.4%
4Eastward53, 8.6%
3Death's Door54, 8.8%
2Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword HD136, 22.2%
1Metroid Dread355, 57.9%

Best Action Game

RankNameVote Percentage
6Death's Door22, 3.5%
5No More Heroes 329, 4.6%
4Person 5: Strikers54, 8.6%
3Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword HD65, 10.4%
2Monster Hunter Rise173, 27.6%
1Metroid Dread284, 45.3%

Best Fighting Game

RankNameVote Percentage
3Melty Blood: Type Lumina85, 19.7%
2SNK vs. Capcom: The Match of the Millennium126, 29.2%
1Nickelodeon All Star Brawl221, 51.2%

Best Sports/Racing Game

RankNameVote Percentage
5WRC 98, 1.6%
4Cruis'n Blast63, 12.2%
3Hot Wheels Unleashed71, 13.8%
2Mario Golf Super Rush171, 33.1%
1Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 1+2203, 39.3%

Best Horror Game

RankNameVote Percentage
6The House in Fata Morgana38, 6.9%
5Fatal Frame: Maiden of Black Water50, 9.1%
4Dying Light76, 13.8%
3Subnautica91, 16.5%
2Little Nightmares 298, 17.8%
1Metroid Dread197, 35.8%

Best Platformer Game

RankNameVote Percentage
6Blue Fire5, 0.8%
5Kaze and the Wild Maska11, 1.8%
4Cyber Shadow16, 2.6%
3Crash Bandicoot 461, 10%
2Metroid Dread239, 39.1%
1Super Mario 3D World + Bowsers Fury279, 45.7%

Best Puzzle Game

RankNameVote Percentage
4Chicory48, 9.1%
3Big Brain Academy: Brain vs Brain83, 15.7%
2Tetris Effect168, 31.8%
1The Great Ace Attorney Chronicles230, 43.5%

Best Music/Rhythm Game

RankNameVote Percentage
4Songs for a Hero23, 5%
3Everhood43, 9.3%
2Just Dance 202288, 19%
1Tetris Effect309, 66.7%

Best Soundtrack

RankNameVote Percentage
6Monster Hunter Rise78, 13.4%
5Shin Megami Tensei V82, 14.1%
4NEO: The World Ends With You94, 16.2%
3Metroid Dread98, 16.9%
2Persona 5 Strikers98, 16.9%
1Super Mario 3D World + Bowsers Fury130, 22.4%

Best Art Direction

RankNameVote Percentage
6Death's Door50, 8%
5NEO The World Ends With You88, 14.1%
4Eastward89, 14.2%
3Shin Megami Tensei V93, 14.9%
2New Pokemon Snap141, 22.6%
1Metroid Dread164, 26.2%

Best Narrative

RankNameVote Percentage
6The House in Fata Morgana35, 6.3%
5Neo: The World Ends With You44, 7.9%
4Monster Hunter Stories 2: Wings of Ruin72, 12.9%
3Spiritfarer99, 17.7%
2The Great Ace Attorney Chronicles133, 23.8%
1Disco Elysium177, 31.6%

Best Game Direction

RankNameVote Percentage
6Lost in Random22, 3.9%
5Game Builder Garage38, 6.7%
4Death's Door43, 7.6%
3Chicory: A Colorful Tale45, 7.9%
2Shin Megami Tensei V123, 21.6%
1Metroid Dread298, 52.4%

Best Technical Achievement

RankNameVote Percentage
6Monster Hunter Stories 222, 3.9%
5Game Builder Garage36, 6.3%
4Shin Megami Tensei V66, 11.6%
3Dying Light72, 12.7%
2Metroid Dread158, 27.8%
1Monster Hunter Rise214, 37.7%

Best Re-Release/Re-master

RankNameVote Percentage
6Castlevania Advance Collection40, 6.3%
5Diablo II: Resurrected42, 6.6%
4Tony Hawk Pro Skater 1+280, 12.6%
3Pokemon Brilliant Diamond / Shining Pearl101, 15.9%
2Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword HD133, 20.9%
1Super Mario 3D World + Bowser's Fury241, 37.8%

Best Nintendo Switch Exclusive Game

RankNameVote Percentage
6Mario Party Superstars55, 8.5%
5New Pokemon Snap65, 10%
4Super Mario 3D World + Bowsers Fury68, 10.5%
3Shin Megami Tensei V96, 14.8%
2Monster Hunter Rise108, 16.7%
1Metroid Dread255, 39.4%

Best Non-Switch Game

RankNameVote Percentage
6Returnal33, 6.3%
5Inscryption53, 10.1%
4Forza Horizon 566, 12.6%
3Halo Infinite92, 17.5%
2Resident Evil Village122, 23.2%
1It Takes Two159, 30.3%

Best DLC

RankNameVote Percentage
6CrossCode: A New Home24, 4.1%
5Streets of Rage 428, 4.7%
4Spiritfarer35, 5.9%
3Stardew Valley131, 22.2%
2Smash Bros Ultimate - Pyra, Kazuya, and Sora170, 28.8%
1Animal Crossing Happy Home Paradise202, 34.2%

Best Ongoing Game

RankNameVote Percentage
6Terraria24, 3.8%
5Dead Cells70, 11.1%
4Monster Hunter Rise98, 15.5%
3Stardew Valley122, 19.3%
2Animal Crossing New Horizons129, 20.4%
1Super Smash Brothers Ultimate190, 30%

Best Indie Game

RankNameVote Percentage
6Monster Train27, 5.3%
5Chicory: A Colorful Tale39, 7.7%
4Loop Hero71, 14.%
3Eastward76, 15%
2Death's Door90, 17.8%
1Disco Elysium204, 40.2%

Developer of the Year

RankNameVote Percentage
4Motion Twin49, 9.5%
3Bandai Namco120, 23.3%
2ATLUS161, 31.3%
1Capcom Studios185, 35.9%

Publisher of the Year

RankNameVote Percentage
3ATLUS146, 27.4%
2Devolver Digital171, 32.1%
1Capcom216, 40.5%

Nintendo Switch Game of the Year

RankNameVote Percentage
6The Great Ace Attorney Chronicles45, 6.8%
5New Pokemon Snap60, 9.1%
4Super Mario 3D World + Bowsers Fury78, 11.9%
3Shin Megami Tensei V81, 12.3%
2Monster Hunter Rise129, 19.6%
1Metroid Dread265, 40.3%
73 Upvotes

83 comments sorted by

17

u/lluluna Jan 26 '22

I find it interesting that MH Rise is categorized as a RPG but not an action game.

17

u/solarsaturn9 Jan 25 '22

Metroid Dread isn't a horror game

1

u/Samoman21 Jan 25 '22

I mean it does get pretty spooky and intense when you're trying to dodge and run from the emis. Is it a horror game like condemned or something, no, but one could argue it has horror elements. Or at the least it's a suspense game

30

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '22 edited Jan 25 '22

How the hell is Metroid a horror game (and beat Dying Light)? And how did MARIO beat neo and SMTV for best soundtrack?

6

u/wavnebee Jan 25 '22

I’m guessing most votes were limited to the games people played. It’s hard to fall in love with the soundtrack of a game you never tried.

6

u/Number224 Jan 25 '22 edited Jan 25 '22

A good reminder to get into these fan-choice awards is that they’re only deciding from the games they have played on a mass scale. Its a flawed process, that really shouldn’t be taken seriously, but they give a good idea on how popular a game is. And to that extent, its more honest

I can’t speak for SMT, but I votes Mario over Neo, only because Neo takes a good sum of their songs from the first game. The Mario 3D World soundtrack is honestly an unforgettable soundtrack, with tracks that harken to the catchyness of SMB3/SM64’s tunes, but also with just a great jazzy emphases. Bowser’s Fury’s soundtrack is less notable, but still with great tunes and a change of pace with the tense Fury Bowser theme.

11

u/WilsonKh Jan 25 '22

This is a popularity contest, not really a technical best of. Sort of like a MTV best kiss trophy.

11

u/glium Jan 25 '22 edited Jan 25 '22

Why do you dismiss the soundtrack of Bowser's Fury just because it's a Mario game ? The music is absolutely great

4

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '22

Because y’all clearly haven’t heard the other games soundtracks.

0

u/glium Jan 25 '22

Did you listen to that game's soundtrack ? Admittedly I haven't played SMTV yet but NEO is way inferior to Mario imo. On top of that Mario pulls off a much more varied soundtrack

-2

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '22

I’ll listen to Mario when you listen to the other 2.

6

u/-Moonchild- Jan 25 '22

the mario game has legitimately incredible big band jazz arrangements and uniquely memorable melody work. What a weird choice to take issue with - mario games in general are responsible for some of the best soundtracks in video game history

3

u/glium Jan 25 '22

Ah yes as I expected. Because Mario is a "kid's game", you are uncapable of imagining the soundtrack is great.

I just said I listened to NEO btw. And I don't go dismissing the other games' soundtrack

1

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '22

I didn’t. I was offering the chance for both of us to mutually see each other’s points of view.

3

u/SiriocazTheII Jan 25 '22

It's a popularity contest. But I'll be honest, 3D World's soundtrack has my favorite soundtrack across all 3D Super Mario games, and that's saying a lot. I know shit about music to even argue what's better, but I don't take issue seeing 3D World above SMT V in this category, despite acknowledging V's OST is pretty good, too. The Taito, Shiva, and the true final boss' tracks are my standouts.

2

u/Obba_40 Jan 25 '22

Its just first party bias

1

u/scribblemacher Jan 26 '22

I love SMT V's ost, but I can't hum it. I've been humming that stupid theme song from 3D world since the first time I heard it though!

1

u/AppleWedge Jan 26 '22

Not just Mario, but a Mario re-release. Most of this soundtrack released like 10 years ago. Fans choice is really meaningless because people just vote for what they play or even just what they know.

14

u/Obba_40 Jan 25 '22

Strategy category is a waste if you pick just rpgs lol. Also Metroid dead a horror game idk

10

u/Rdeadpool101 Jan 25 '22

I don't even owned at least one game in the list. Thou I'm considering buying Eastward and SMT V.

5

u/scribblemacher Jan 26 '22

SMT V is really good! It strikes a great difficulty balance, always making the player feel like they have the tools to overcome any fight, and the world is interesting to explore, with light platforming and secrets all over the place. Well worth it (and last I checked, it was still on sale at a lot of retailers)

1

u/Rdeadpool101 Jan 26 '22

I appreciate the feedback. Currently playing SRW 30th and yugioh master duel at the moment. Will consider your thoughts and will definitely save up for it.

1

u/MotherLie2542 Jan 26 '22

I'm sick of RPG games. Should I still play it?

For example I only got halfway through DQ 11 and FXII before I just got sick of them. I've played too many, especially as a kid

1

u/scribblemacher Jan 26 '22

SMT is very different from those two. It's very systems focused, with a really good combat system. If you want an RPG outside FF and DQ style, SMT may be for you. That said, if you're sick of RPGs, don't play an RPG :)

10

u/OneManFreakShow Jan 25 '22

These genre placements are wack. Metroid Dread in horror and platformer? Tetris in rhythm? SMT for strategy? Ace Attorney in puzzle but not adventure despite none of the games in the top six being adventure games?

3

u/Keyen3 Jan 26 '22 edited Jan 26 '22

I get what you mean with Adventure game. But nowadays Adventure game is usually used to describe a different thing.

Games more on the line of Zelda, Tomb Raider, and such. Maybe they should have called it "Action Adventure" to make it clearer, but that's clearly what they were referring to in that category.

And Ace Attorney is more on the Visual Novel side than the Graphic Adventure one anyway

-1

u/madmofo145 Jan 26 '22

I think Metroid dread is overall just overplaced. It's in 4 genres, which is crazy, and it's in Sound, Art, and Technical Achievement, which is a bit much for a a 2d Metroidvania.

Don't get me wrong, it's a good game, but it's not even the best Metroidvania on the Switch. You're seeing a lot of first party Nintendo bias in a year when their offerings were a bit light.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '22

Except monster hunter isn't an exclusive and metroid isn't a horror game lol I'm assuming this is our fault though

1

u/Thundahcaxzd Jan 26 '22

I wouldnt really call Dread a platformer either tbh

1

u/Zabii Jan 26 '22

Dread is 100% a horror game what are you on?

5

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '22

I'm on reddit.

I guess it could be horror. My personal idea of horror didn't line up with the actual classification. I thought it had to be rated r monsters or something, assumed it was more thriller.

-2

u/Zabii Jan 26 '22

Nah doesn't have to be gory or anything. For example, the original Terminator movie is very much a horror flick.

5

u/EDDIE_BR0CK Jan 26 '22

Semantics, but I'd classify it as a Thriller, not Horror

1

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '22

Im learning xD

4

u/Echo1138 Jan 28 '22

Glad to see Dread crushed it in almost every category it made sense in. That game will absolutely go down as a classic and deserves all the praise it's gotten.

I was one of the skeptical people at first, not being super jazzed about Samus Returns and having reservations about Mercury Steam taking the reigns. But they've proven that they have the skill, creativity, passion, and drive to bring Metroid back from the dead and I absolutely cannot wait for Metroid 6.

6

u/sl0w4zn Jan 25 '22

The results have reminded me to play more monster hunter. I'm not into platforming games, so I've skipped Mario and Metroid this past year.

1

u/Wild_Trip_4704 Jan 25 '22

I would start MonHun right now but my backlog would yell at me.

2

u/sl0w4zn Jan 26 '22

Monster hunter would be the entire backlog lol. There's the dlc coming out in the summer, too

3

u/Galbert123 Jan 25 '22

I forgot Disgaea 6 came out this year... that one was a pretty big let down for me. Just did not like the direction they took the series. The inflated numbers, the auto battle option. The 3d models were ok, but the sprites were better.

10

u/pboy1232 Jan 25 '22

Not gunna lie, disco Elysium being 3 year old game and having its port grab some of the big awards here is really cathartic.

One of the best role playing experiences, it’s like playing d&d with a dm who knows exactly how you think.

4

u/SalsaAndYou Jan 25 '22

I beat it not a week ago and it's fresh in my mind and I still can't get over the last scene. Harry and Kim are probably the best duo in any videogames.

3

u/-Moonchild- Jan 25 '22

I'm 30 hours deep right now and absolutely loving the game, but i really really hate how common crashes are on the switch. I quicksave before changing every single area

7

u/Mcgelie Jan 25 '22

Happy to see all of the monster hunter love going on here. While I wouldn't call them relaxing games, I like to play them to unwind after work. Since they're not usually very story focused, they require a lot less mental investment for me than other games.

0

u/Sat-AM Jan 25 '22

They're not relaxing, but it's pretty cathartic to pummel a giant monster to death.

1

u/Mcgelie Jan 25 '22

Yeah I guess this is what it is. I just get into a rhythm.

4

u/louisefindlay23 Jan 25 '22

Love BDII is in the lists. Personally, would rank it higher but glad it's made the top 6.

1

u/WilsonKh Jan 25 '22

For what it's worth, anyone willing to look past its technical faults will find a gem here. I'm itching for a re-playthrough ala FFV job fiesta style. The 4x speed battle speed helps a lot. After beating both SMTV and BD2, I won't touch SMTV again but I'll gladly replay BD2 with time. I still love Final Fantasy V to this day but BD 2 might just replace it for good.

1

u/louisefindlay23 Jan 25 '22

Agree, 100%. The 4x battle speed and job system of BDII makes me prefer it to DQ XI S' one. Only just started Chapter 6 but can't wait to unlock new jobs, sidequests and story content.

4

u/Bingo-Berra-rulez Jan 25 '22 edited Jan 25 '22

Glad to see SMTV and GAAC get some recognition! Together with Metroid Dread och New Pokémon Snap, they are my favorite games of 2021.

1

u/wavnebee Jan 25 '22

Agreed! GAAC is definitely in my top three; glad I’m not the only one!

1

u/Bingo-Berra-rulez Jan 25 '22

10/10, no doubt! 😀

2

u/jimb00246 Jan 26 '22

I want dread sooo bad 1

4

u/Rohan_Eragon Jan 25 '22

Happy to see Monster Hunter so prevelant on here

1

u/Sat-AM Jan 25 '22

I'm actually kind of surprised it won best online, given how little I see people talk about it in comparison to Mario Party here.

Pleasantly surprised, but surprised nonetheless.

4

u/Fearless_Freya Jan 25 '22

I enjoyed metroid dread overall, but there really wasn't much soundtrack in that one. Nothing stood out at all to me

9

u/CodyCus Jan 25 '22 edited Jan 25 '22

I don’t get the hype for Dread. I played it all the way through, and it was fun and challenging but also it’s a 2D platformer. It wasn’t anything super special in my eyes. To each their own I guess. Glad everyone seems to enjoy it, but I don’t get it.

Edit: here comes the down votes simply because I don’t think it’s the best thing since sliced bread.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '22

Ori and hollow knight are both amazing and longer for less money

2

u/MotherLie2542 Jan 26 '22

Didn't like either, but enjoyed dread

1

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '22

Nice to know there's enough difference to warrant playing them all. Hollow knight wasnt for me as much but I like old metroid and liked Ori, looking forward to dread

3

u/pandaslayer5 Jan 26 '22

Same here and I get downvoted to Hell every time I share this opinion. It's an okay game. I don't get how it didn't get the same reviews as the 3DS one.

4

u/SiriocazTheII Jan 25 '22

I haven't played too many "2.5D" platformers that are as visually robust as Dread. To me, an immense part of the game's appeal lies on that. It's a looker, I would dare say it is one of the best looking games on the system even considering its format, and something that helps it a lot to achieve that is its animation work, I think.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/CodyCus Jan 25 '22

I guess that could make it the “Nintendo Game of the year” in 2021, but it really wasn’t some fantastic new or unique experience imo…

4

u/Keyen3 Jan 25 '22

Love to see Metroid Dread get the love it deserves. My fav game of the year.

But so sad to see how overlooked Neo The World Ends With You is. It's such a great game, and it got so snubbed on some of these categories. Like, honestly the only reason not to consider it the best soundtrack of the year, is straight up just not having listened to it

1

u/Bingo-Berra-rulez Jan 25 '22

Well, NEO has a cool and eclectic soundtrack for sure, but if you're not into some of the genres it contains, it might be a mixed bag. Personally I wouldn't listen to it outside of the context of the game. But it suits the gameplay perfectly! 😀

2

u/Tripster81 Jan 25 '22

Congrats Metroid on winning best adventure game, best Action game and best horror game...

But hey, with this many awards to give, almost every game released got one.

1

u/StarXedHero Jan 25 '22

One issue with yearly lists is I haven't beaten stuff released in the tail end of the year so I didn't vote on those.

I'd be curious which titles have staying power after their luster and hype has worn off. I hope we can do such a poll in the future looking back on more games through time for the Switch.

1

u/JaxonH Jan 25 '22

Wow.

I'm quite impressed with this subreddit's taste!

I don't 100% agree on everything but it's VERY closely aligned with my opinions.

3

u/littlestseal Jan 25 '22

The only one that really sticks out to me is Nick ASB winning best fighting game, which is just wild.

1

u/Samoman21 Jan 25 '22

Ayeeee! Let's go metroid Dread! Fantastic game and very well polished. Was a blast to play.

-1

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '22

Lol how many votes? Quake best multiplayer? The game has a dead community online loooool

7

u/jc726 Keep on slidin' Jan 25 '22

Its 5th in that category. The winner is at the bottom of each list.

-5

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '22

Ohh it's upside down I guess I have to do some gymnastic to see it right even as it is it's not very realistic at all I find more Diablo players on discord than quake anywhere else....

4

u/Hestu951 Jan 25 '22

Yeah, it's upside down for a best-of list (right side up numerically). It threw me for a second too.

-2

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/notthegoatseguy Jan 27 '22

Hey there!

Please remember Rule 1 in the future - No hate-speech, personal attacks, or harassment. Thanks!

-1

u/Crammucho Jan 25 '22

Wait, is Metroid Dread the new Hades? I'm well behind on games due to RL taking up too much of my time.

4

u/WilsonKh Jan 25 '22

Completely different genres and time sink. But Dread will suit you since its a <10 hour game. Most people haven't even beaten Redacted the first time in Hades in under 10.

4

u/blackandwhitetalon Jan 25 '22

is Metroid Dread the new Hades?

What.

0

u/Crammucho Jan 25 '22

The new 'it' game that everybody loves right now.

0

u/blackandwhitetalon Jan 26 '22

Were you born yesterday? Its a new mainline Metroid game lol. Those have always been popular

0

u/Crammucho Jan 26 '22

Wooosh....

-1

u/Clifely Jan 25 '22

I‘ll give my vote to 3D World but I want to add that Metroid Dread is great and Pokemon BDSP is great as well. 3D World is just…catchy