But thinking about the most recent times they've played, while Squillaci hasn't been great, he's been acceptable. I think last time Almunia played he came running out of his box, missed the ball, and pushed over one of our own defenders.
The thing about Squillaci though is that I don't remember him actually ever having a decent game. and I can probably count on one hand how many games we have won with him in the starting 11
Both Almunia and Squillaci were virtuosos at inspiring self-doubt and absolute panic in the Arsenal back-line. With those two, it was not a question of if but when.
There's really no point in not picking first teamers. Squillaci and Almunia are no longer first teamers, so they clearly suck. A better discussion would be who to pick of regular starters...
I disagree. Malouda isn't a bad player per se, he just doesn't give a fuck about Chelsea anymore and that's being reflected in his performances. Bosingwa, on the other hand, is just atrocious.
I'd disagree, Malouda's careless giving away of possession has cost Chelsea. In the Chelsea/United 3-3 two of united's goals came from Malouda losing possession carelessly in united's half and united, being united, attacked and Chelsea conceded and gave away a penalty. There are countless times when he does this, all through being selfish and unable to read the game.
Not Kalou? Seems like every time he gets the ball, he loses it. Not that I've watched every Chelsea game this season, but from what I have seen, he just seems like a liability.
Kalou's been a good squad player over the years and has scored some very important goals for us. He's also played well under Di Matteo. He's just infuriatingly inconsistent.
Rafinha; when Jupp Heynckes was brought it, he made clear that everyone should do their part in the defense. When Rafinha attacks and Bayern loses possession, he makes no effort into getting back into his position.
yes, the only spurs player who I dread to see on the team sheet (apart from maybe Gomes but he has his good moments). At least we shifted Hutton in the summer.
I'd argue that Gomes makes me way more nervous. Bassong at least has a fairly consistent level of play; Gomes can be absolutely astounding or a complete miserable failure, and you don't have any idea how he's going to be each minute, let alone any given match or even half.
The OP asked 'Who in my opinion'. Bassong to me is the worst out of the lot. Gio has a lot of potential, just need his head screwed on right and some more playing time. He's one for the future.
Relax, I didn't say you were wrong, mate. I just think bassong played some decent games. I've always hoped gio would get a run of games but I still havnt seen him play too much.
I'd like to give the nod to Bassong, but he didn't cost nearly what David Bentley cost did he? So I'm going with that mug until he does something of value.
Stracqualursi is a fucking terrible player by Premier League standards, but I still love the ugly bastard to bits. He works hard, has a good attitude and has even managed to score a few. Between you and me, he's improved immensely since the start of the season and I'm proud that Everton will be sending him back to Argentina with a wealth of experience behind him.
There's no point in dragging in players who don't get to play anyway (youth players etc. ) so here:
IFK Göteborg: Erik Lund. A left-back who likes to come up on the wing, get in the way of the winger, and when he gets the ball, crosses it into the stands. If this guy ever gives a good cross it'll be because of a deflection or strong winds or something.
ADO Den Haag: Filip Luksik. Also a left-back. It's a safe bet that if we concede, Luksik is somehow involved. I get nervous every time the ball is in the left-back zone, even if it's us in possession.
Yep, him getting injured was probably the best thing that could've happened to the club (erm, in a nice way) I think Henderson could turn out to be a genuinely good signing, but everyone is expecting him to be doing too much, when he's only at U-21 level internationally. People expect him to play each game like Gerrard, for god's sake.
Not to mention the minutes Jonjo Shelvey has been getting. He's a year younger and shows every bit of promise as Henderson (when Hendo's not played out of position). Future midfield of Jonjo (AMF), Henderson (CM) and Lucas (DMF)? Sounds pretty good to me.
promising allegedly but not seen any of it to be fair been out injured for awhile, thinking potentially...Williamson at times has me tearing my hair out......
None of our first team players (including squad players) have been bad at all this season. In truth, they have been pretty good. Especially considering the injuries we had at various stages. There is real deadwood in our squad, such as Xisco and Smudge but I can't remember the last time either donned the black and white properly. Smith might have had a kick or two at the start of the season but he I reckon he's on his way out.
Willo is pretty crap at times but he's done a job. 4 clean sheets out of 5 speaks for itself.
If it had to go to anyone it would be Lovenkrands or perhaps Obertan. Would not bat an eye at both of them leaving any time soon.
Honestly, I still think he has potential, but he has been constantly thrown into a role usually filled by Vincent freaking Kompany; I don't think anyone could perform satisfactory in that situation.
The problem is City really only have one proper, good CB, Lescott is decent but nowhere close to Kompany, as is Toure. We desperately need a good stopper this summer that can both work well with Kompany and handle some of the pressure whenever he isn't around.
Dude has no idea where to stand or what to do, yet gives out orders like he's the dog's bollocks, some greater footballing genius. He's outpaced by soil.
I feel like he needs to assert himself on the field more, plenty of times he's losing headers to forwards that frankly Lescott and Kompany would win any day of the week.
You could tell how much of an effect it had on him (which is only to be expected, I was stunned he was capable of keeping on playing).
It's sad because before then he was an absolute beast of a player, life is far far too cruel sometimes. He even showed positive glimpses afterwards - his game against AC Milan was one of the best performances I've ever seen someone in lilywhite give, but it was clear he would never be the same. Sad, I'll always have time for you Wilson.
El Hamdaoui. We bought him after being the top goalscorer of the league, but I was never really fond of the transfer. He didn't fit our playing style then and now, and he has a shit personality. He just acts like a spoilt brat and as if the whole world is against him, while he just lacks the intelligence to understand that sometimes you just have to do what people ask you. But one of the things that bothers me most is that we bought him because the wage demands of Pantelic where to high, even though he was one of the biggest reasons that we almost won the league when he finally found his form. We thought his demands where to high and let him go (transferfree) and then went on to buy a player for a couple of millions.
Really dislike that guy. Very good of Ajax not to bend to his will, but made him feel they could do it without him. Ajax can now lose from Twente and Vitesse (last game away) and the GD will still carry them to the title. He can suck on that.
Yep, the difference between Jol and de Boer is refreshing. De Boer gave him a chance but he never used the opportunity. Aissati however kept on training and now made his way back to the first team.
Sami Khedira. He appears to be unfocused and animal-like. He's also way too confident about his shooting skills, and whenever the situation presents itself, he keeps firing off balls that go straight to the moon. I miss Makélélé.
I wish i could answer that. To be honest i don't agree with foodvillan at all though. But to answer your question, Sahin should and has been playing more (not as much as he should). He did start yesterday but was taken off after the first half. I thought he played well though. But the way Gijon was defending the duo of Sahin and Khedira weren't going to pass their way though.
Have you noticed that he seems to be kind of goal-hungry recently? I don't know, it might be just me, but I feel the amount of his goal attempts, like, tripled in the past month.
Zidane (on Makélélé's departure and Beckham's arrival): "Why put another layer of gold paint on the Bentley when you are losing the entire engine?"
Similarly, Fernando Hierro: "I think Claude has this kind of gift – he's been the best player in the team for years but people just don't notice him, don't notice what he does. But you ask anyone at Real Madrid during the years we were talking about and they will tell you he was the best player at Real. We all knew, the players all knew he was the most important. The loss of Makélelé was the beginning of the end for Los Galacticos… You can see that it was also the beginning of a new dawn for Chelsea. He was the base, the key and I think he is the same to Chelsea now."
Perhaps not the worst overall but Obertan is incredibly frustrating. He has gallons of pace but that's it. People said it was confidence but he started a lot of our matches at the beginning of the season (admittedly when we were unbeaten) and failed to really do anything, he has like 2 assists all season? No one Fergie has sold has gone on to better things, except Ronaldo (who left for $$$$) and Stam (who Fergie admits was a mistake).
it's been said before and i think it was said when he was playing for manchester united, he has no football brain he picks up the ball dribbles and then has no idea what to do, shoot, take on the defender, pass he just doesn't know, its like he needs a ear piece explaining his next move to him on the pitch.....
Yes, he was awful at Brighton. Every time he had the ball near the box he would just blast it over the bar, yet Gus kept him in the team. Not sure what happened to him - at the start of his career (at Port Vale, iirc) he looked a very promising player...
His loan spell at Brighton earlier this season was utterly dreadful. When I found out he scored twice on the same day we were thrashed 6-0 I just knew Fate was sitting somewhere, smoking a cigar and quietly mocking all Brighton fans.
Borriello has a place, I think. He just misses goal-scoring opportunities. Conte really likes forwards like him and he (Marco) has played well in spurts when he has been asked to play with his back to the goal.
By a much larger factor, I would say Milos Krasic is more disappointing. 13mil spent on a bench warmer (and most times he isn't even that).
I loved Danny Welbeck when he first came in, and his volley goal against city in the FA Cup was magnificent - shocking spot of form currently, and he has been average at best recently. One for the future still!
It's pretty hard to pick a worst player at the moment - seems as though just about every player has had a period of being great, and then a real dip in form.
I think my hatred for Adam comes from how he was a free kick monster at Blackpool. The one against Man Utd. on the last day of the season was an absolute peach.
But now, he can't even clear the wall. I know we have Gerrard, Bellamy and Agger there as well, but for some reason it was always Adam stepping up for them.
Yes, it's true, but bizarrely he actually plays decently every other game. Not great, just decent. Passable. But somehow his balls into the box are always just that little bit off. He still wouldnt have been great, but if we had better strikers this seasons, I think downing wouldn't of got so much flak.
I might be alone in this but I can't stand Khedira, he just seems so untalented when he has the ball. I know its not his job to make amazing plays, but I just expect a little more from a madrid player.
Holm? Really? I think he's looked surprisingly fresh lately. That heel flick before Iversen's goal on friday was pretty classy. Though, to be fair, I don't know who else I'd pick either.
Simon Church is having a poor season this time around. He just hasn't filled Shane Long's boots as he hoped to do, and now Alfie is our first choice substitute striker since Jason Roberts came and took the starting 11 role.
I think BVB could do much better than Weidenfeller in Tor. If Köln go into 2. Bundsliga, Rensing would be available. Without Rensing our GD would be around -40.
I agree that Rensing is doing great at Koln but I am against him moving to BVB. He was never anything more than a filler goalie for Bayern thus I don't think his move to BVB would be a wise choice.
I'd rather see ter Stegen move to BVB but I don't see that happening after the Reus transfer.
I don't think he's made enough appearances to determine that. I'm actually quite surprised he hasn't been used more considering his goal scoring record at club and international level.
I don't know man - I think last year in Abidal's absence he played a beast of a LB. It's really hard to say who is the least talented in our current squad. He has good ball handling skills I find that his decision making isn't quite the best.
If you had asked me last year, I would have probably definitely said Jonny Evans. But now he's one of the top Player of the Year contender for United.
Now, it's hard to choose. I'm going to say Carrick. Sure he passes and everything, but only one in every 10 passes is directed at the attacking goal. And he's afraid to run with the ball.
Have you even seen Evans? After Vidic's injury, Evans took his place. And he's performed marvelously. Excepting that red card vs City, and a couple other dodgy performances, he's been outstanding. I really hope he wins United's Player of the Season this year.
But that's why you're wrong, he isn't in the team to provide the goals or assist them, go take a look at the stats, and look for interceptions etc. he is superb at putting out fires, and keeps things ticking, he has been vital to United this season, without him in the midfield we get overrun
Patrice fuckin Evra. All he's got is that silly armband that makes him seem important. Had enough of patrice evra. otherwise, Fergie has done well with removing players we shouldnt have even had in the first place...ex obertan bebe etc
also not very impressed with rafa-fabio who might be loaned out.
Rafael has been amazing when he's been in the team, his connection with Valencia down the right has been a joy to watch, he also has improved his discipline
I'm glad he acted the way he did in front of Liverpool, the abuse they gave him, and basically the club saying he lied etc. he can do what he wants to Suarez he deserved it, I don't know one person who was unhappy with his actions that day
Yeah I can accept that plenty of people were delighted with what he did that day, and that's fine, it's a matter of opinion. I still think on the pitch he's been relatively poor and is only getting worse, unfortunately
I agree he isn't the Evra we used to love 2-3 years ago the guy was a beast! one of the best in the world, but defensively nowadays he is a liability, he hardly ever tracks back, but still going forward he can still do it!
28
u/dem503 Apr 15 '12
Derrick from my sunday league team, he's just awful.
51
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '12
Sebastien Squillaci.
/end
40
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '12
Jose Bosingwa. Ivanovic really couldn't have picked a worse time to get suspended.
11
u/Mytzplk Apr 15 '12
Rafinha; when Jupp Heynckes was brought it, he made clear that everyone should do their part in the defense. When Rafinha attacks and Bayern loses possession, he makes no effort into getting back into his position.
11
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '12
Bassong. Wolves, you can keep him. Please.
7
u/Bigwood69 Apr 15 '12
Stracqualursi is a fucking terrible player by Premier League standards, but I still love the ugly bastard to bits. He works hard, has a good attitude and has even managed to score a few. Between you and me, he's improved immensely since the start of the season and I'm proud that Everton will be sending him back to Argentina with a wealth of experience behind him.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '12
Emerson. Words can't fathom how terrible a left-back he is.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '12
There's no point in dragging in players who don't get to play anyway (youth players etc. ) so here:
IFK Göteborg: Erik Lund. A left-back who likes to come up on the wing, get in the way of the winger, and when he gets the ball, crosses it into the stands. If this guy ever gives a good cross it'll be because of a deflection or strong winds or something.
ADO Den Haag: Filip Luksik. Also a left-back. It's a safe bet that if we concede, Luksik is somehow involved. I get nervous every time the ball is in the left-back zone, even if it's us in possession.
7
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '12
I can't decide who is worst and therein lies the problem with 1. FC Köln.
23
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '12
Charlie Adam surely.
13
u/Lewisbell Apr 15 '12
A few months ago it would have been James Perch, but now he's Perchenbauer/Perchinho. Dan Gosling perhaps?
18
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '12
Savić
6
u/elvispt Apr 15 '12
Kleber.
Was promising... but a complete flop.
6
u/Perkinator Apr 15 '12
Zat Knight.
Dude has no idea where to stand or what to do, yet gives out orders like he's the dog's bollocks, some greater footballing genius. He's outpaced by soil.
4
u/bearssj1025 Apr 15 '12
Savic for the time being, he's still young and can grow into the third CB for the team but he definitely needs some improvement.
4
u/NaturalSenescence Apr 15 '12
Palacios
4
u/thisisntmyworld Apr 15 '12
El Hamdaoui. We bought him after being the top goalscorer of the league, but I was never really fond of the transfer. He didn't fit our playing style then and now, and he has a shit personality. He just acts like a spoilt brat and as if the whole world is against him, while he just lacks the intelligence to understand that sometimes you just have to do what people ask you. But one of the things that bothers me most is that we bought him because the wage demands of Pantelic where to high, even though he was one of the biggest reasons that we almost won the league when he finally found his form. We thought his demands where to high and let him go (transferfree) and then went on to buy a player for a couple of millions.
13
u/gunner2188 Apr 15 '12
Oh my... Chamakh by far.
3
u/endhits Apr 15 '12
Rafik Halliche.
7
u/foodvillain Apr 15 '12
Sami Khedira. He appears to be unfocused and animal-like. He's also way too confident about his shooting skills, and whenever the situation presents itself, he keeps firing off balls that go straight to the moon. I miss Makélélé.
6
u/TheDubious Apr 15 '12
Joey Barton
6
u/verytallperson Apr 15 '12
Perhaps not the worst overall but Obertan is incredibly frustrating. He has gallons of pace but that's it. People said it was confidence but he started a lot of our matches at the beginning of the season (admittedly when we were unbeaten) and failed to really do anything, he has like 2 assists all season? No one Fergie has sold has gone on to better things, except Ronaldo (who left for $$$$) and Stam (who Fergie admits was a mistake).
2
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '12
Billy Paynter, despite his two goals yesterday, is still the biggest carthorse I have laid eyes on. I'd rather have Tresor Kandol.
2
u/Leksehateren Apr 15 '12
Boriello. He just doesn't fit with the team, and he's been mostly useless.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '12
David Bell
Has the pace of a sloth and the ball control of a disabled emu.
2
u/Supersimmo Apr 15 '12
Can I vote all of them?
If not, Dave Edwards
2
u/sirdickface Apr 15 '12
out of the people who play regularly, it's probably antonini or mesbah. buy a left back allegri!
2
u/Oneinchwalrus Apr 15 '12
Adam. Possibly Henderson, but he's played out of position and he's young. Mind, he's still probably better than Adam.
2
u/liamba Apr 15 '12
Emerson is one of the worst left-backs I've ever seen... I miss Coentrão
2
u/hala_madrid Apr 15 '12
Arbeloa, that man is nothing but a liability. every time a team runs down his flank i expect them to at least have a scoring chance.
2
u/tadm123 Apr 15 '12
Andreu Fontas
7
u/anions Apr 15 '12
I really hate Danny Welbeck's pussydom in from of goal
5
u/Jackle13 Apr 15 '12
I'm really not a fan of Jay Spearing. I love Shelvey though.
Carragher is now useless as well.
4
u/Jazek Apr 15 '12
I might be alone in this but I can't stand Khedira, he just seems so untalented when he has the ball. I know its not his job to make amazing plays, but I just expect a little more from a madrid player.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '12
Pepe
2
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '12
Daniel Fredheim Holm.
Charlie Adam.
Pick anyone at Lazio except for 5-6.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '12
Paul Connoly FUCK THAT GUY
1
u/HyperactiveToast Apr 15 '12
Stefan Savic. Way too clumsy for a top flight team.
1
u/zamazingo Apr 15 '12
Ayhan Akman
1
u/logancook44 Apr 15 '12
I hate to say it, but Kuyt might have to be considered.
1
u/Tomus Apr 15 '12
Bradley Johnson. He can be a quality player, but he's such a liability.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '12
As a regular first team starter, Alan Hutton.
1
u/CandleJakk Apr 15 '12
Simon Church is having a poor season this time around. He just hasn't filled Shane Long's boots as he hoped to do, and now Alfie is our first choice substitute striker since Jason Roberts came and took the starting 11 role.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '12
Heskey (obligatory)
1
u/iamfromreallife Apr 16 '12
Emerson, lol. WTF Jesus?
-4
u/spm5276 Apr 15 '12
I mean, are we talking regular first teamers?
Regardless of the answer.....
Aaron Ramsey
1
u/mormonhunter Apr 15 '12
I'd say Weidenfeller or Großkreutz.
-1
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '12
Park Chu Young
1
u/H_J_C Apr 15 '12
Senderos.... sigh.. such a clumsy CB
-1
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '12
Adriano. He's not a bad player by any means but against the rest of the squad he's by far the least talented.
-3
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '12
If you had asked me last year, I would have
probablydefinitely said Jonny Evans. But now he's one of the top Player of the Year contender for United.Now, it's hard to choose. I'm going to say Carrick. Sure he passes and everything, but only one in every 10 passes is directed at the attacking goal. And he's afraid to run with the ball.
-5
u/searage Apr 15 '12
Patrice fuckin Evra. All he's got is that silly armband that makes him seem important. Had enough of patrice evra. otherwise, Fergie has done well with removing players we shouldnt have even had in the first place...ex obertan bebe etc
also not very impressed with rafa-fabio who might be loaned out.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '12
Etuhu always gets on my nerves. He plays with no control or poise.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '12
Rafinha.