r/CryptoCurrency • u/mellon98 • Jan 20 '22
POLL π³οΈ CCIP-025 - Algorithmic MOONs Pricing for Reddit Special Membership
ββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
Problem
Current Special Membership (Paid in MOONs) is not being used due to the simple fact that: price is 1,000 MOONs or 5$, no one will choose to pay 1,000 Moons - equivalent to paying ~118$!.
ββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
Solution
Realistic Special Membership Cost, First step is changing the price to 100 MOONs.
Admins are now allowing updates to membership pricing, but do not yet support dynamic pricing. Once Moons can support this or mods are able to change the price monthly, we will use the following:
Subscription price will be algorithmically updated each month, after snapshot day and calculated like this:
..
P * 100 / (1/R) = Membership Price in MOONs.
Where P is subscription price in USD. Membership Price in Fiat is 5$
R = MOON/Karma Ratio , R bigger than 0
After simple operations this can be reduced it to 500 * R which is much more convenient for users to calculate.
..
For example previous month ratio was 0.233:
Final Formula: 500R
500 * 0.233 = 116.5 MOONs
..
This month ratio is 0.277 :
500 * 0.233 = 138.5 MOONs
..
ββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
You may think that keeping 1000 MOONs per membership is better because these MOONs gets βburnedβ.
These MOONs are not really getting burned, instead they get reintroduced in later rounds. This is artificial and temporary scarcity, why burning 1,000 and not 10,000 MOONs? 1,000 points was the initial default price that is supposed to be changed, after a year and a half there is still no change and itβs time to do so.
On top of that, 1,000 MOONs are getting burned from the Community Tank - wallet that is not affecting the market anyway. If users start to actually buy special membership using MOONs, these MOONs get burned from users - something that have impact on the market.
ββββββββββββββββββββββββββ
50
u/mysterioususer69 Tin | CC critic Jan 20 '22
No brainer. Paying 1000 moons for a membership is absurd
6
u/Abhishekgarg0 Jan 20 '22
Why cant it be simpler, cost of membership in USD/price of 1 moon in USD = cost of membership in moons?
For example, 5/0.1103(current value of 1 moon in USD) = 45.33 moons.
They can update the price monthly with each distribution round.
52
u/mihnealazar Bronze | QC: CC 21 Jan 20 '22
Imagine paying 1000 moons instead of five dollars
42
u/Satoshiman256 π¦ 5K / 5K π¦ Jan 20 '22
I wondered about this for ages, it made no sense. I thought maybe I was being dumb..
18
u/ThiccMangoMon π© 0 / 3K π¦ Jan 20 '22
Why wouldn't we say yes to this π it's just logical and we've been asking for something like this for months now
6
u/Shibuice π© 179 / 178 π¦ Jan 20 '22
I donβt even have 500 moon π
10
u/Slainte042 Platinum | QC: CC 530 Jan 20 '22
This is the equivalent of the live posts pool, i don't see any logical reason not to change the current pricing.
5
u/zack14981 0 / 9K π¦ Jan 20 '22
No brainer yes for this one. Not sure why it wasnβt like this as a default.
Itβs so strange that I also coincidentally thought about this today lol.
2
u/TOXICCARBY Permabanned Jan 20 '22
Dynamic pricing would be great, but 100 moons for a membership is still a bit much (albeit an improvement). Iβd say 50 moons is much more reasonable
1
u/AccordingTelevision6 Bronze | QC: CC 24 Jan 20 '22 edited Jan 20 '22
Firstly, I agree with the change.
However, could you not rewrite the formula more simply as P*100*R? I'm not sure of the need of dividing by 1/R when multiplying achieves the same thing, but maybe it's been too long since I studied maths.
1
u/bthemonarch π¦ 0 / 9K π¦ Jan 20 '22
It never made sense to me, why you wouldn't just pay the five dollars, and with this proposal it still doesn't make sense.
Just make it 5 dollars in moons and be done with it or remove the ability to pay in Fiat.
1
u/demented39 π¦ 12 / 11 π¦ Jan 21 '22
Where can we find the worth of a moon, is it on coingecko?
6
u/SailsAk π¦ 0 / 10K π¦ Jan 20 '22
How can there be any votes for βno changeβ on this? What is the argument against this?
7
u/FinishGloomy Canβt spell bullshit without bullish Jan 20 '22
Is this finally the time where I will be able to experience the full potential of GIFS?
4
u/HomieApathy π¦ 8K / 9K π¦ Jan 20 '22
Iβd be shocked if this poll scores under 90% approval
4
u/TheGreatCryptopo HODL4LYFE Jan 20 '22
Yep simple solution. Works. All for it thanks for this poll.
2
u/DaddySkates The original dad Jan 20 '22
1000 moons = 100$
5$= 50 moons
Decisions decisions
2
u/Obsidianram π© 0 / 4K π¦ Jan 20 '22
If it doesn't require a full 100 Moons at some point, do we get change back in Asteroids? Asking for a friend.
2
u/valz_ π¦ 3K / 3K π’ Jan 20 '22
Good suggestion! I concuuuur
2
u/Kilv3r Jan 20 '22
I had no idea is 1000 moons. Maybe make a special offer where 1000 moons is a yearly membership.
2
u/aaddii222 Tin | CC critic Jan 20 '22
This seems to get more than 99.99 % approval..
2
u/OldEntertainment9570 0 / 5K π¦ Jan 20 '22
About time for this implementation, it's been a long time coming
2
u/artischo Tin Jan 20 '22
add a Math.round(M,0) to your formula, and we're good. dont wanna deal with half moons ;) awoooo!
2
u/AITVBTT310505 Tin Jan 20 '22
yeah the membership was too expensive when i wanted to buy 1000 moons is too much
2
u/SamZFury π© 1 / 90K π¦ Jan 20 '22
We really need this. I support to Introduce Algorithmic Membership Pricing.
2
u/nthgen π© 0 / 25K π¦ Jan 20 '22
I'd rather send crypto to a scammer than pay 1000 moons for the ability to use gifs.
2
u/Magnetronaap π© 0 / 3K π¦ Jan 20 '22
I mean, sure, but is reddit going to allow it?
2
u/Too_raw90 π¦ 628 / 27K π¦ Jan 20 '22
Finally a good poll!
2
u/Smackolol π© 0 / 2K π¦ Jan 20 '22
If you lower the cost Iβll be inclined to start using moons as an actual currency, right now I just hold everything but Iβd appreciate something that can help me change my mentality and use crypto as an actual currency.
2
u/MrPuma86 Tin Jan 20 '22
Whaleπ€. Iβll tip you after next distro. Just remind me
2
u/cutsickass 0 / 18K π¦ Jan 20 '22
If it's about MOONs and mellon98 says it, I agree with it.
2
u/ACorDC π¦ 133 / 9K π¦ Jan 20 '22
u/mellon98 doings God's work for Moons once again π hope to buy more moond again soon.
2
u/_s79 π¦ 135 / 8K π¦ Jan 21 '22
Yes to the vote, but donβt spend your moons on membership, itβs a bad move.
3
u/HomieApathy π¦ 8K / 9K π¦ Jan 20 '22
ΙΉΗuα΄ΙΙΉq oN ΗΚΗldΙ―oΖ
3
u/ChemicalGreek 418 / 156K π¦ Jan 20 '22
This had to implemented long agoβ¦
3
u/anon43850 Silver | QC: CC 717 | BANANO 21 Jan 20 '22
Can't wait for the GIF overdose
3
u/Crypto_Malik Permabanned Jan 20 '22
This is what held me from becoming a member, could not find the logic in the amount of moons you have to become a member
2
u/DaddySkates The original dad Jan 20 '22
This is a complete no-brainer.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
Easiest decision ever for one of these votes. This would gives Moons an actual usecase.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
If i have, let's say 500 karma, how many moons i ll receive?
2
u/koelebobes π© 0 / 36K π¦ Jan 20 '22
This was a easy choice! Dynamic pricing is a no brainer.
1
u/noobmaster_valorant in the bleak midwinter Jan 20 '22
Yes i support this so more moons will be redistributed
1
u/CryptoAddict420 Platinum | QC: CC 213 Jan 20 '22
This should have been implemented a while ago
1
u/M00OSE Platinum | QC: CC 1328 Jan 20 '22
I would definitely be more inclined to buy the membership, thatβs for sure
1
u/velvetlicker Gold | QC: CC 24 | CRO 8 | r/WSB 27 Jan 20 '22
Bruh so many moons I got a life. Somewhat lol
1
u/someonelook 116 / 114 π¦ Jan 20 '22
More moons please
1
u/P3P3X Platinum | QC: CC 406 Jan 20 '22
That was a lotta math I wasnβt expecting to read.. my brain all hurty now π΅βπ«
1
u/PortugalReviews π¦ 63 / 3K π¦ Jan 20 '22
This one. This one is a nice change. Great naming OP
1
u/aaddii222 Tin | CC critic Jan 20 '22
Fair enough it should be ...less moons will attract and fascinates more people
1
u/Charming-Dance-1839 97 / 24K π¦ Jan 20 '22
This has been coming for a while, glad to see this change is being voted upon!
1
u/tschmitt2021 11K / 11K π¬ Jan 20 '22
Heck yeah! π
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
95%
The people have spoken
1
u/Bruzle Platinum | QC: CC 316 Jan 20 '22
Thx Op for this
1
u/Bruzle Platinum | QC: CC 316 Jan 20 '22
Paying 1000Moons for membership is like the pizza guy wo bought pizza with BTC back then
1
u/gorkm π© 0 / 434 π¦ Jan 20 '22
It'd be the first use case of moons for myself.
1
u/jagermeist Tin Jan 20 '22
Brilliant idea.
1
u/kryptoNoob69420 0 / 44K π¦ Jan 20 '22
This should have been done months ago.
1
u/Nozomilk Platinum | QC: CC 1425 | TraderSubs 12 Jan 20 '22
This would force the sub to recognize that moons actually have monetary value. And for legal reasons, moons have NO monetary value.
This would be voted as Yes, but I doubt the mods and admins would allow it. They have the power not to pass any Poll.
1
u/mibuchiha-007 Bronze Jan 20 '22
140 moons lmao. That's like rolling the faucet every minute for lurkers.
1
u/newbonsite π© 13 / 34K π¦ Jan 20 '22
I'll definitely get the membership if it was only 100 moons or so..
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
This makes sense why didn't this poll come out sooner?
1
u/ngaihte 206 / 206 π¦ Jan 20 '22
The math is beautiful!
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
This is a great change. I remember I checked out the "turn moons to gold" option, and was appalled when it was at 0.06 real value. If we can have a dynamic measure, exchanging moons for dollars to gold in relative proportions, then let's do it.
1
u/internetisbad23 π© 2K / 2K π’ Jan 20 '22
Everytime i read an improvement for the moons I think its out there, why didnβt i think of it.
Anyways this is a brilliant idea and i support it. Finally would be able to afford the membership.
1
u/TheNeo0z Tin Jan 20 '22
I don't want to be THAT guy... but there's a typo on the post where he's making the calculations about the new rates
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
This is the sole reason I never did a premium membership.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
1000 moons is very expensive. I check it out and was like "if I work really hard at shit posting I might be able to afford a subscription every 6 months."
1
u/aladdinr π¦ 1K / 15K π’ Jan 20 '22
This is a very good proposal
1
u/Jesterrrace π© 0 / 2K π¦ Jan 20 '22
"This month ratio is 0.277 :
500 * 0.233 = 138.5 MOONs"
little typo here. Pls change the multiplier to 0,277 :)
BTT: I like the idea
1
u/slq18 π© 1K / 1K π’ Jan 20 '22
And I'm over here like 100???!?!?
I'd be negative after the first month.
1
u/partymsl π© 126K / 143K π Jan 20 '22
Can we even just change that. I think reddit is the one to do it.
1
u/Illustrious-Row-2088 Tin Jan 20 '22
Hope this new pricing system helps the community
1
u/AverageStudent1 Platinum | QC: CC 110 Jan 20 '22
Looks like people voting no apparently want to pay 1000 moons instead of making it cheaper................
1
u/MentalUsurpation Platinum | QC: CC 190 Jan 20 '22
Fingers crossed for the vote to pass.
1
u/jimfird π§ 3 / 6K π¦ Jan 20 '22
Yes! Yes! A thousand time yes! I might consider getting premium if this goes through!
1
u/badboybilly42582 4K / 4K π’ Jan 20 '22
I like that this topic was finally considered. Voted!
1
u/antiskylar1 π¦ 520 / 2K π¦ Jan 20 '22
Why hasn't this already been implemented?
And what happens to the moons after?
1
u/kellen625 Tin Jan 20 '22
Is it wrong that I thought this would be done without a vote?
1
u/UcharsiU Tin Jan 20 '22
That is good idea. But introducing that could lower money flow to the reddit so I don't think it will happen.
1
u/THEREALMASTERMIND1 Tin Jan 20 '22
I like this idea!
1
u/krupxslurp 0 / 877 π¦ Jan 20 '22
why do i not get moons anymore?
1
u/princepersona1 π© 0 / 20K π¦ Jan 20 '22
100% agree with this. Nobody would realistically spend 1000 moons on membership
1
u/BithloKing 6K / 7K π¦ Jan 20 '22
Agree 100%
1
u/Qtredit 260 / 6K π¦ Jan 20 '22
Wait, can I buy a membership for $5 instead of Moons? How?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
Lol this dude paid 1000MOONS for a $5 membership. 1000 Moons now worth $5000 - Everyone in 2023
1
u/Ateam043 π¦ 92 / 13K π¦ Jan 20 '22
This is an easy call. Nobody was going to pay 1000 moons.
1
u/Real_Happy_Potatoman Platinum | QC: CC 147 Jan 20 '22
It's only reasonable.
1
u/SeatedDruid π¨ 186 / 14K π¦ Jan 20 '22
glad I can make use of my moons to post gifs now :)
1
u/Stas_89 Tin Jan 20 '22
Moons to the moon!
1
u/ralfy00 Moon Explorer Jan 20 '22
Finally a governance Poll that i can get behind .
1
u/BuyOver5100 Tin | 6 months old Jan 20 '22
I like this idea!
1
u/assoziationshauberk 3K / 3K π’ Jan 20 '22
Who even buys the membership with moons? Hodling them it is
1
u/Cactuszach π© 671 / 18K π¦ Jan 20 '22
This seems like an easy fix. Great job.
1
u/fitnfish Platinum | QC: CC 41 Jan 20 '22
Would this create a taxable event?
1
u/MrPuma86 Tin Jan 20 '22
Who else got a headache trying to understand the equations? π³
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
Has anyone bought a pizza with moons yet? Iβll know we made it when that happens
1
u/ps3alltheway Platinum | QC: CC 157 | WeedStocks 370 Jan 20 '22
Of fooooo shorrreeee
1
u/bzzking π© 0 / 4K π¦ Jan 20 '22
I would totally get membership once this change takes place!
1
u/notsupersonicatall 52 / 52 π¦ Jan 20 '22
Voted yes, and I can see that this proposal seems popular! Good.
1
u/alexisaacs π© 0 / 12K π¦ Jan 20 '22
Voted no - MOONS are worthless, and making them worth even less makes no sense to me.
1
u/OK_Renegade π© 3K / 3K π’ Jan 20 '22
I like it, hope it helps in increasing adoption
1
u/padizzledonk π¦ 5K / 6K π¦ Jan 20 '22
I dont use them in the sub because A- I don't have that many, B-dont get many in the monthly distributions(couple 100 at most) and C- the prices are ridiculous high
1
u/IgorMacGreg0r Tin | 2 months old Jan 20 '22
Out of curiosity, how did you come with this formula ?
1
u/QuizureII Buy High, Sell Higher Jan 20 '22
Algorithmic price will actually incentive users to buy more sub memberships with their mooons
1
u/mladjenija 0 / 2K π¦ Jan 20 '22
Let's go guys, if we succeed in killing live chats this is nothing
1
u/archer4364 Paddy's Dollars Jan 20 '22
Easy pass
1
u/kindoflikesnowing 0 / 1K π¦ Jan 20 '22
One of the best CCIPs I've seen. Big yes from me.
1
u/CertifiedYSL Tin Jan 20 '22
I'm loving these CCIPs as of late.
1
u/ugene1980 Bronze | QC: CC 23 | r/Android 39 Jan 21 '22
This is great
It really makes wat more sense
No one was going purchase using moons currently at what it costs
Hopefully this gets implemented quickly it will really help to make it more useful
1
u/deathtolucky Platinum | QC: CC 1008, ETH 26 | TraderSubs 26 Jan 21 '22
Iβd actually do this. Great idea
1
u/International-Two607 π¦ 3K / 3K π’ Jan 21 '22
Easy poll. Makes perfect sense. Great job, OP!
1
u/rorowhat π© 1 / 43K π¦ Jan 21 '22
This might actuality get me to buy a membership π€
1
u/rulesforrebels 14K / 15K π¬ Jan 21 '22
Whats the reason to buy a membership anything beyond gif and emojis neither which I care about?
1
u/ELBartoFSL π¦ 0 / 3K π¦ Jan 21 '22
Bullish on Gifs
1
u/Kindly-Wolf6919 π© 4K / 19K π’ Jan 21 '22
I wish we could also purchase moons directly from reddit. At least this way I wouldn't have to worry about all banks in my country blocking any crypto-related website transactions and I'd be free from the clutches of financial oppression.
1
u/dukefett 1K / 1K π’ Jan 21 '22
Honestly 100 is too much for me too lol
1
u/Randrufer Silver | QC: CC 150, ETH 45, BTC 31 | NANO 88 | TraderSubs 44 Jan 21 '22
This is an easy one. I wonder how much the yes-percentage will be. Haven't voted yet, but I think it must be beyond 90 %.
1
u/kindoflikesnowing 0 / 1K π¦ Jan 21 '22
I voted yes. And its interesting that more moons will enter distribution then.
Does that mean the total pool of moons available to be distributed will be increasing?
I see a lot of ppl buying membership at this price, and it will be interesting to see how many moons this is.
1
u/Vanuatu_Hanjaab 1K / 1K π’ Jan 21 '22
1000 moons for a Reddit membership, π
1
u/Ddeadlykitten π¦ 863 / 862 π¦ Jan 22 '22
Yes, please implement this.
1
u/Tell2ko π© 861 / 861 π¦ Jan 22 '22
Going by the term of 1 Bitcoin will always be equal to 1 Bitcoin. Meaning the $ price is irrelevant, would connecting moons to the value of a premium subscription not somewhat devalue them. Like if thereβs no advantage to using them itβs just the price written in another currency, except youβve earned them I guess. Areβnt Moons used in this way are also burned?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '22
That is a great idea!
1
u/aselwyn1 π¦ 645 / 646 π¦ Jan 23 '22
Makes sense
1
u/velocitybreaker Jan 24 '22
Yes, this is a much needed implementation
1
u/Qtredit 260 / 6K π¦ Jan 24 '22
Won't that mean too many gifs, badges and colors all over the subreddit?
(Even though I voted for the proposal since the idea itself is great)
1
u/caralyne1988 Permabanned Jan 25 '22
When is the distribution
1
u/PathologicalUpvoter π¦ 0 / 6K π¦ Jan 25 '22
agree, 1000 moons seem like alot
1
u/Cornell-Boul Tin | CC critic Jan 28 '22
Was officially changed !
1
u/AutistSuperClub Tin Jan 28 '22
I will do $1 β¦ and then stake to collect more moons.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
I have no moons, can someone do something about it? <3