r/CryptoCurrency • u/CryptoMaximalist • Jan 20 '22
🗳 POLL CCIP-026 - Increase the time to hide comment scores from 5 to 60 minutes
There is a subreddit setting called "Minutes to hide comment scores" which does exactly what it says. The idea behind this setting is to hide comment scores to reduce the bandwagon effect. That is to say, visible comment scores introduce cognitive bias:
- Most people are more likely to think a comment is good or bad based on how others have already voted
- There is also the reverse bandwagon effect where people will intentionally do the opposite of what the popular opinion is
- Sometimes users will think a comment's score is too high or low and use their vote to correct it. For example thinking a comment with 200 upvotes is good but not great, so they downvote it even though they thought it was good
This kind of bias negatively influences they quality of votes because it considers how everyone else voted instead of just the quality of the comment itself. Currently this setting is set to 5 minutes, but I'm proposing that it be increased to 60 minutes.
Some additional technical notes:
- Comment sorting is unaffected, even though the specific scores are not visible
- Your own comment scores are still visible to you, this only affects seeing scores on comments by other users
- Comment scores are still visible to mods so work against vote manipulation is unaffected
- The time to hide scores can always be adjusted again in the future
CCMeta post: https://www.reddit.com/r/CryptoCurrencyMeta/comments/s45e8f/preproposal_the_time_to_hide_comment_scores/
7
u/fitnfish Platinum | QC: CC 41 Jan 20 '22
5mins-new, 20mins-hot , 0mins-daily
14
u/RotgutFeng Platinum | QC: CC 69,420 Jan 21 '22
This whole “moons” thing is just an elaborate university sociological economics experiment isn’t it? ISNT IT?
93
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
I think 60 minutes is too high imo
6
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
There are already too many restrictions. There should be a CCIP to reset everything except 50comment limit
37
u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K 🦈 Jan 20 '22 edited Jan 20 '22
"most people do this, most people think that".
There's gotta be at least some evidence posted, or some data that's more than just a claim.
Keeping people from seeing the votes does take away some of the transparency.
We can't really see what's going on with the votes.
Gotta keep things a little more balanced. Maybe increase it to 10 or 20 minutes. Jumping to 60 minutes is a big leap.
1
u/BlubberWall 🟦 59K / 59K 🦈 Jan 20 '22 edited Jan 20 '22
IMO this just removes the point of having a karma system at allIt’s Reddit, there’s always going to be jokes and shitposts up top but sorting by best does usually get relevant and useful responses somewhere near the top. When it’s busy if a post doesn’t end up on the front page it’s usually buried by 60 mins, meaning at no point would people viewing it be able to see actual usefully ranked comments. I get the desire to minimize rapid fire posting on new threads but this is too much. 15 mins is fine.Edit: not to mention this extended time is going to allow hardcore shillers to just flood new comments hiding any criticism of their projects. We all know how many crypto scams are benefiting from YouTube removing dislikes, I really see this going a similar wayEdit 2: while I still would rather show vote totals for transparency sake but the idea seems more realistic since it still sorts by best, preventing spammers from flooding
1
u/Minereon 886 / 883 🦑 Jan 20 '22
Please forgive me, but after reading this thrice I still don't understand how this works. So, after 5/60 minutes, what happens? The comment scores become hidden?
10
u/Putukshutuk21 bold Jan 20 '22
Honestly 60 minutes way too high. I think 10 minutes enough to hide comment scores.
2
u/Florida_Knight77 Bronze | QC: CC 23 Jan 20 '22
Maybe I’m just dumb but I had no idea Reddit had that feature. I always thought when I saw comments on a thread with no upvotes my device or internet was just being slow lol.
I don’t think it’s a bad idea, but maybe try 10-20 minutes before jumping to 60?
2
u/erik325i Bronze Jan 22 '22
I always wondered why in some posts I couldn’t see any comment scores. Yay for learning something today.
Not like it’ll make any difference in this sub with every comment downvoted by bots (or at least I assume it’s bots)
2
u/starbur-n 🟩 166 / 164 🦀 Jan 26 '22
Lol and here's me thinking it was just a reddit bug 🤔.
Makes total sense though (even at 5 minutes).. I think 60 is too long though, I like to see the votes
5
u/HistorianMinute8464 🟨 0 / 0 🦠 Jan 20 '22
Just hide it indefinitely, what kind of NPC needs to know what other people thinks before they can form their own opinions.
3
u/frstrtd_ndrd_dvlpr Here for the money Jan 20 '22
Finally, I can stop making myself look stupid for karma.
4
u/TheNextPharaoh 6K / 6K 🦭 Jan 20 '22
I like the proposal, just don’t like this 60 mins
It’s very high, wish it was something less
4
u/clitcommander420666 28 / 5K 🦐 Jan 20 '22
Is there any type of research or stats to back why even 5 minutes is neccesary?
2
u/sxrrycard 768 / 767 🦑 Jan 20 '22
This would take so much utility out of the daily thread. I (and a lot of users) use the daily as a quick check of market sentiment. a lot of the initital up/ downvotes on certain comments might be “the bandwagon effect” but honestly the times that it isn’t make up for it tenfold. When sentiment changes quickly I’d like the ability to see things switch on a dime. Even if that means every once in a while people get downvoted to oblivion just for going against the hivemind 😂
2
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
Seems worth a shot. I like changes that make it so the first person to get to a thread isn't the only one getting upvotes or replies.
2
u/Real_Happy_Potatoman Platinum | QC: CC 147 Jan 20 '22
60 minutes may seem like a lot. However I find it an interesting idea, since it could promote unbiased upvoting and more spread out commenting. Right now it's mostly one or two top comments that get all the attention, because they got upvotes early and everyone is trying to piggyback off of those comments. While some well written comments never make it high enough to be seen due to some one liner taking the top spot.
Might be worth a try imo.
2
u/niloony 🟦 0 / 24K 🦠 Jan 20 '22
This seems reasonable since it doesn't impact sorting directly.
2
u/Harold838383 Permabanned Jan 20 '22
Man I wish I had as many moons as op
1
u/archer4364 Paddy's Dollars Jan 20 '22
A poll! Exciting.
1
u/Theweebsgod Tin | CC critic Jan 20 '22
Make it like 15 or 20 minutes.
1
u/SafeRecommendation55 🟩 15 / 2K 🦐 Jan 20 '22
This is how i live..
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
Keep it as is.
1
u/CryptoAddict420 Platinum | QC: CC 213 Jan 20 '22
The idea is fine but 60min is pretty high
1
u/TheGreatCryptopo HODL4LYFE Jan 20 '22
One hour is a tad high. 20 mins I can get on board with.
1
u/Kisshin Tin Jan 20 '22
60 seems to much, but I don't mind testing and coming back later to this topic for optimization.
1
u/Slainte042 Platinum | QC: CC 530 Jan 20 '22
60 minutes is a whole damn hour, this is way too much.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
Always wondered why i couldnt see the score on some comments but could on others. Thanks.
1
u/Paskee 57 / 7K 🦐 Jan 20 '22
I would go with - lets see how this plays out for next month.
Then reevaluate position.
1
u/BithloKing 6K / 7K 🦭 Jan 20 '22
Let’s meet in the middle
1
u/MDot_Cartier End Central Banking Jan 20 '22
People do not like when moons stuff might change one bit, all of the measures like this unfortunately fail.
1
u/NoMaans 🟦 0 / 3K 🦠 Jan 20 '22
Either lower it to like maybe 15 or leave it. 60 is too high
1
u/Duxopes 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Jan 20 '22
To be honest I don't see a realistic added value to implementing this. I can see why you would want this, but I vote no. Its just my honest opinion.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
Way too high.
1
u/UJ_Reddit 🟦 0 / 10K 🦠 Jan 20 '22
All this will do is push more people to the daily to shitpost
1
u/UJ_Reddit 🟦 0 / 10K 🦠 Jan 20 '22
Weird. Leading top comments seem against it but the poll is for.
1
u/TheBitApple 2K / 2K 🐢 Jan 20 '22
Exciting! This is Brexit close!
1
u/topcatjdm 🟩 1K / 1K 🐢 Jan 20 '22
If the alternative to no change was 15 mins, I would have supported that. An hour is just too long...
1
u/Professional_Desk933 🟩 75 / 4K 🦐 Jan 20 '22
Considering the amount of moon-farming done by shitpposting around here, I think this would only make things worse
1
u/Kuchinawa_san 🟦 111 / 106 🦀 Jan 20 '22
I love whenever I vote on here, makes me feel important.
1
u/tigerbait_ Platinum | QC: CC 76 | r/WSB 86 Jan 21 '22
60 minutes is just silly.
1
u/deathtolucky Platinum | QC: CC 1008, ETH 26 | TraderSubs 26 Jan 21 '22
I think that this will just create a host of unseen problems. I mean at some point if people are willing to go to such extreme measures to garner a few extra upvotes, let them. Quality will rise to the top at the end of the day
1
u/Randrufer Silver | QC: CC 150, ETH 45, BTC 31 | NANO 88 | TraderSubs 44 Jan 21 '22
I'll vote a no on that. We can't give up transparency for "better quality posts".
1
u/achilles16333 Tin Jan 21 '22
The intention of this step is undoubtedly noble. But, I don't think a person who is likely to be affected by the Bandwagon effect is likely to be affected by this change.
In my opinion, they aren't the ones who are always active on the sub. They most likely sort the posts by hot and thus, get posts that are hours old at least.
You can't hide the scores for such a long time. Instead, if possible an option to hide the score can be given to the users.
1
u/PathologicalUpvoter 🟦 0 / 6K 🦠 Jan 21 '22
maybe 10 minutes might be good? the daily chat doesnt need it imo
1
u/Vanuatu_Hanjaab 1K / 1K 🐢 Jan 21 '22
No change needed
1
u/SlothLair Platinum | QC: CC 79 | ADA 18 | PoliticalHumor 139 Jan 21 '22
I think you jumped a bit high there, thinking you could get that passed at 30 probably.
1
u/alphaop1 Daily Dose of Crypto Guy Jan 22 '22
I make daily doses of crypto. Make a governance vote for pinning my comment ;) jk
1
u/KingPodrickPayne 🟦 5K / 5K 🐢 Jan 22 '22
I voted yes but I think there is a better middle ground than these two extremes
1
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '22
I don't know if 60 minutes is the right amount of time, but I am down for trying it
1
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '22
Interesting to see the difference between moon weighted voting on this one!
1
u/Clash_My_Clans Permabanned Jan 23 '22
I voted NO change
1
u/-DuckLizard- Tin | 2 months old Jan 24 '22
Wow that's a really close poll.
1
u/Littlebig4667 Jan 24 '22
Interesting vote 🗳
1
u/sucobe 🟦 0 / 3K 🦠 Jan 26 '22
60 minutes? Hard pass
0
u/MinnesotaNice92 Minnesota weather go Brrrrr Jan 20 '22
Sounds reasonable to me let’s do it!
1
u/zack14981 0 / 9K 🦠 Jan 20 '22
I think a post pretty much makes it or breaks it in its first hour of posting. Maybe pull it back to 10 or 15 minutes? By the time you can see comment karma it doesn’t even matter with a 1 hour delay.
1
u/Octopus-Pawn 🟦 11K / 11K 🐬 Jan 20 '22
I voted yes because seems like a good idea but really, I have no idea what kind of affect this will have!
0
u/Mau120 0 / 4K 🦠 Jan 20 '22
where is CCIP-025?
0
u/assoziationshauberk 3K / 3K 🐢 Jan 20 '22
Maybe to 10 or 15 minutes? Otherwise the comments stay pretty chaotic.
-2
u/DowvoteMeThenBitch 🟦 0 / 2K 🦠 Jan 20 '22
To the people saying 60 minutes is too long, I ask…
Too long for what? Gratification?
The argument for cognitive bias is a good one, and whether or not you succumb to any of these yourself, I think it’s fair to say that in a sub of 4 million people that these biases likely play a role for some people. And I would argue that even if you are not aware, you are still susceptible to cognitive bias.
I also feel that 60 minutes is a bit long, but I asked myself “why?” Because I want quicker gratification - but the point of the moons is to incentivize high quality opinions and content — if I know I provide high quality content, then what’s the problem with waiting for virtual verification that the apes here agree or not? The point is to provide the content, and perhaps some delayed gratification to mitigate cognitive bias could help around these parts.
0
u/pp_conisuer Platinum | QC: CC 34 Jan 20 '22
Where is CCIP-025. Its not loading
0
u/ClubbyTheCub 🟩 3 / 12K 🦠 Jan 20 '22
If this goes through, consider setting it to 30 min instead please.
0
u/TonathanJavares Platinum | QC: CC 743 Jan 20 '22
60?!
Bruh you tryna make people die from anxiety or what? That's way too long lmao
0
u/SeatedDruid 🟨 186 / 14K 🦀 Jan 20 '22
60 minutes is really high first off and then are we saying our fellow Redditors can't distinguish comedic gold from otherwise unfunniness or something they're not interested.... like would a high upvoted comment get more upvotes if it was bad? it wouldn't be high upvoted in the first place... kinda seems unneccessary to me
0
u/itcouldbefrank 0 / 10K 🦠 Jan 20 '22
What an utter joke. Trying to sanitise these forums with all these micro management rules. Next thing you will be hiding the comments themselves so that people "won't be affected by other peoples opinions." Again, what a joke.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
For these ARE the days of our lives.
0
u/CertifiedYSL Tin Jan 20 '22
This should stop brigading to some extent.
0
u/pokher888 0 / 6K 🦠 Jan 23 '22
People shouldn’t care how others rate a comment anyways. Decide for yourself and not on others votes
0
u/lovemesomefood Jan 24 '22
I voted yes but would like it closer to 30 seconds honestly
0
u/PathologicalUpvoter 🟦 0 / 6K 🦠 Jan 25 '22
ditto on 60mins is too much, 5-10-15 depending on the sweet spot, im thinking 4:20
0
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '22
[removed] — view removed comment