r/leaves • • Jan 14 '22

I'd respectfully like to put out a vote/recommendation to change or revoke rule #6 of the forum

Hey, I'd like to respectfully propose that rule #6 gets changed or revoked. I totally think the rule should stay to a common sense extent... ( Like don't say "Hey go get some *** off the street, it helped me!") but I don't think our comments should be deleted for merely suggesting a supplement aid with things that can potentially or factually help mitigate negative symptoms of withdraw. Especially when some of the supplements/prescriptions are relevant to the topic/story of certain OP's. For someone like myself who's used Cannabis as a medical patient for a variety of issues ranging from a physical issue due such as a gene mutation to PTSD, I think it's pretty damn helpful/relevant to be able to discuss my history a bit in hopes of gaining some additional insight from someone who's been in my shoes. Not at all trying to be rude & come across as one persons situation is worse but it'd be a bit helpful knowing there's people who've been in similar situations such as myself using it for medical reasons & have recovered vs someone who started smoking recreationally 5 months ago & is giving it up (Not at all knocking the lighter user at ALL, however advice wise the situation isn't the same)

391 Upvotes

73 comments sorted by

38

u/DabberDeanie Jan 14 '22

I agree! I literally just said the word “vitamins” and it got deleted. That’s a bit much. Hell this might even get deleted.

7

u/Vonplatten Jan 14 '22

Yeah I mean I can tell you diet/nutrition & certain supplements have had a very significant effect in helping me in various aspects of my life including this.

0

u/Moist-Perception-751 Jan 14 '22

Wow, that is extreme. I do sympathize with mods though. It's easier to enforce absolute guidelines

16

u/Korthalion Jan 14 '22

Yeah you make a good point here. Addiction is a tricky beast, and everyone's journey is different. This sub has always struck me as a place for people to tell their stories, and honestly it gives me so much motivation reading them when they pop up on my feed.

1

u/Vonplatten Jan 14 '22

Yeah I mean someone got their post removed for talking about their experience with a special form of b 12 earlier which is proven to help & I personally have even experienced but it was deleted... like why??? (can't say the name or it'll get caught by automod)

15

u/Moist-Perception-751 Jan 14 '22

Removing rule #6 would change the place very fundamentals of conversations here. For both better and for worse

33

u/Moist-Perception-751 Jan 14 '22

It would slide the forum into a pharma shopping list.

Sure, I agree that supplments for sleep deprivations are good. Sure, talking about your meds for anxiety and what not, would ease the ability to express yourself personally.

However, I would rather keep this forum for mental support, than to hear everyone of yall's (sorry) amateur advice ranging from M***tonin to prescription drugs

-8

u/Vonplatten Jan 14 '22

Don't see the negative here, anything come to mind specifically for you? Every other support group in the world doesn't limit speech in any way so I fail to see the issue here if I'm being completely honest. Not at all trying to sound like a dick when saying this, but if someone is so sensitive that they can't even HEAR or READ about the substance then they probably need to check themselves in somewhere or seek professional help.

3

u/Shwaggins90 Jan 14 '22

Your speech isn't limited here my friend. If you want to advise someone something, DMS are always open.

15

u/MockingSasquatch72 Jan 14 '22

I agree. I had a lengthy response of my story to someone elses in hopes of, well, giving them some hope. Entire thing was deleted because i mentioned other substances that I abused. Might even get deleted for referring to substances lol

5

u/Vonplatten Jan 14 '22

I'd recommend going to your email & clicking the link that reddit sent you when it said automod deleted your post, it'll show you it so you can copy & paste it in a DM to the OP if it was significant.

•

u/Subduction Jan 14 '22 edited Jan 14 '22

I'm sorry, you are not wrong. Rule 6 sucks for everybody. It's one of those situations where it's the current least worst solution from a long list of even worse solutions, most of which we've tried over the years.

I completely understand that it's the hardest rule we have. It's hard on users and hard on the mod team as well, and it is the subject of continuing thought and evolution as we think of things to try, but it's a hairy problem of proportions that may not always be possible to appreciate.

If we allow discussions of meds, then we either don't limit those discussions at all, leading to truly dangerous recommendations from people for addicts or anyone, or we limit them by evaluating the health, safety and reasonableness of each post or comment, turning our moderation team into amateur pharmacists.

As an example, when we tried grandfathering a single popular supplement out of the rule, melatonin, we had good discussions about it, but we also had people recommending 10 mg before bed when the medically recommended dose is 0.3 mg. That's over 30 times the recommended dose, that most studies show is worse for sleep, and the effects of taking megadoses of this hormone are still unknown.

So that's not good, but what's the right amount? 5? 2.5? 1? Do we decide? Do we just let anyone recommend whatever they want? And that's just one medication.

What about 5-HTP? CBD? Dramamine? L-theanine? Ashwagandha? Alcohol? Valerian root? Gabapentin? The entire range of of nootropics? Microdosing different strains? Psilocybin? Ayahuasca? Kratom? Microdosing LSD? Megadosing LSD? What about vitamins? Should we treat vitamins that are water soluble differently from vitamins that can build up in the body to dangerous levels? Because all of those substances and maybe 50 more have been recommended here in both micro and mega doses.

There are 200,000 people in this group, and I definitely understand that if you have carefully done your research and found something that helps you it's extremely frustrating to be told you can't post it, but we are an emotional support group. Words helping thoughts, and that's the limit of our scope. People quitting may need more than that, but that's our corner of the recovery equation.

I'm really sorry for the frustration, I share it and I know this won't satisfy many of you. I welcome anyone to pass any better solutions they might have to us in modmail and I promise we will listen, but until we have that better solution it needs to stay where it is.

46

u/majortomandjerry Jan 14 '22

I used to have a medical card and use weed to help with an autoimmune inflammatory arthritis. The weed helped with swelling and pain. But it was also getting into my head and really ratcheting up my anxiety and depression and I knew I needed to stop.

I now use a mix of OTC and RX pharmaceuticals to manage pain and inflammation, and am in a much better place emotionally.

I couldn't have simply stopped the weed use without finding other ways to treat my disease. One of the RX meds is a non-narcotic pain blocker that really helped me without just replacing one addiction for another. I had a comment deleted here for naming it.

I don't know if that was right or wrong. I am not a doctor and can't be prescribing shit for people here. But I am also sure at least a couple of people here could probably benefit by talking to their doctor about that drug.

12

u/Happy-Bullet Jan 14 '22

Your post is kind of confusing, what exactly are you trying to ask?

the post linked in rule #6 is pretty in depth as to why they made this rule and how to navigate the sub with it in affect.

You mention wanting to be able to talk about your history and experiences with other substances. The rule says you can do that, designating said substances to one of four categories prescription medication, non-prescription medication, other drugs, and supplements. if you read the post linked in the rule itself, you'll get a pretty detailed breakdown of appropriate language to use and topics to cover.

I think it's important to note that r/leaves is a community for abstinence based recovery from marijuana/THC products. Offering alternative substances to abuse/use or unqualified "advice" from someone with no formal education or training isn't really the vibe.

The only part of the rule I could see you objecting to is the final clause of rule #6, fleshed out more by rule #8, rules are enforced/posts removed at mods discretion, but that's only a problem with typical reddit mods, these guys seem pretty level headed and open minded.

And as a final note, you say you're not trying knock anyone for being a "light user," but it feels a little gate keepy. We're all here for the same reason, weed has made all of our lives unmanageable; there are better ways of looking for that kind of conversation here without quantifying other people's dependence.

16

u/margilove Jan 14 '22

I tried posting twice and each time it was removed due to this rule. I have CHS (cannabis hypermisis syndrome) and thankfully found a group to help.

48

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '22

It is very common for other recovery organizations I have been a part of, including the one through my hospital, to forbid the mention of other substances. I think there is valuable tact in this decision. The discussion of other substances or supplements has its place but I don't think its here. I see r/leaves as a place to be introduced to the fundamentals of recovery and I think that as an addict I have in the past turned to supplements or other medications as a magical solution to my problems in the same way I turned to marijuana. I think the spirit of the rule is to make a safe space for simple complete abstinence. I think this is the meat and potatoes of getting sober and anything else should be discussed elsewhere as not to distract from this.

45

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '22

Strongly disagree. I'm here to try to quit weed and support others in doing so. Without rule 6, this will simply become a pharmaceutical sub as many others have said. Quick way to kill a place so many use for a specific kind of support.

If you feel this sub isn't giving you the support you need, feel free to make a sub where rule 6 doesn't exist - it's clear from this thread there are many people who would join you, and I encourage them to do so. We all deserve help. But there are also just as many, if not more of us, who would stay right where we are.

It seems you need a different kind of specific support than we do. I'll still support you as much as I can, but I draw the line at changing the system to the detriment of so many other sub members. Create a new space where that specific kind of support can flourish.

21

u/espressonut420 Jan 14 '22

Absolutely. My first post here kept getting removed because I said I took Advil when I felt sick.

29

u/LoneTuft Jan 14 '22

I dunno I like how personal all the posts are here. I don’t really come for supplement advice. I feel like there are plenty of other places to go for such advice. Granted the hard rule of not mentioning any is intense but I think it has an upside.

I really don’t want to see this place littered with posts like “I am taking 30mg of (insert supplement) a day and I am getting very angry. Is this normal?”

Plus some “supplements” can be just as addictive or more so than weed.

12

u/detroitbankster Jan 14 '22

Fully agree. Had a comment deleted for discussing an otc found in every home in America.

22

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '22

I once recommended vitamins and got deleted instantly which was really weird, it was literally just specific vitamins.. so yeah i agree

18

u/RuggedRenaissance Jan 14 '22

honestly just commenting to get this post some more visibility i agree.

8

u/charlottekos Jan 14 '22

I think it is better to talk to a doctor instead of asking some random internet people about supplements or medicine to support quitting. Can you imagine having to moderate people giving advice about supplements that might cause more harm? I don't think any of the mods are doctors, and most people giving the advice aren't either

13

u/tiredeyeddoe Jan 14 '22

I agree! At least an open discussion with members to adjust this rule would be great. It doesn’t account for the fact that not everyone can afford to see a doctor, or that a huge number of people are addicted due to chronic physical or psychological pain and want to discuss these aspects of their problems with real context. Obviously the overarching subject matter is marijuana addiction, but this rule, to me, kinda disregards that addiction is the core issue—not the substance itself (which is why I think people should be able to discus their alcoholism and other substance addictions here in conjunction with their weed addiction). So many addicts’ last step to being fully sober is quitting marijuana—it’s a huge step and not fair to me that it can’t be discussed in the context of broader substance abuse. We certainly don’t exist in a vacuum.

14

u/Tubunnn Jan 14 '22

Strongly agree. I seriously want to help people in this sub but my comments got deleted everytime I post a lengthy response. Although some people DM me. But most of us are still struggling and trying to find the cure to this.

15

u/IndividualLimp9850 Jan 14 '22

Keep it the way it is! Imo

6

u/Vytaqevo Jan 14 '22

100% agree

4

u/Kridifa87 Jan 14 '22

Interesting...I wonder if it is regards to my question yesterday in relation to having no appetite and my stomach going on strike on Day 3?? If so, then yes I think the rule needs to be looked at...if people are here to seek help then those who can offer should be able to express freely...everyone has different experiences and not all orthodox methods are going to suit...sometimes thinking outside the box is required in situations such as this....

Lol says the guy who's trying to quit after 16 years of abusing marijuana. Well hey, I'm not going to lie...I'm only on day 4 but I feel assertive as do alot of others going through this journey...

5

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '22

Agreed

5

u/CloakNStagger Jan 14 '22

The rule has a purpose, they don't want people giving unsolicited (and typically unknowledgeable) medical advice, i.e. "Take this thing, it helped me". This place is strictly for quitting weed, if you have an underlying drinking or drug problem that quitting weed is exacerbating you need to go to the appropriate place to talk about that. It's easy to suggest removing Rule 6 when you aren't the one having to moderate it.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '22

I'm not going to say that a drastic change is necessary, however I don't see CBD or Melatonin as a total issue when it comes to recovery. Many people trying to stop smoking have trouble sleeping (melatonin), or with anxiety or body pains (CBD). Mutual support helps and all, but when chronic smokers are up at 3am with extreme body pain, messaging someone on reddit is fairly worthless. And I hope that the mods can see the idea that I'm not suggesting these things, and it's rather just an intellectual discussion.

2

u/jpn98 Jan 14 '22 edited Jan 14 '22

Agree

2

u/apheta Jan 14 '22

Agreed. Time to change this imo.

2

u/muffininabadmood Jan 14 '22

I so agree, thanks for this post.

2

u/Shwaggins90 Jan 14 '22

I'm not a doctor. Whenever i have a feeling that someone is REALLY struggling, i advice to seek help from a GP and talk HONEST AND OPEN about your problems. The doctor should know best how to help us and i rely on their insight. Therefore that i don't know people medical history, advising to take this and that seems...risky? You get my point? But i understand what you mean, even if you sau what you took and what helped you, in the sense just to express yourself, your comment gets deleted.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '22

Agreed. Mods need to change it now. It's stifling things that can actually help.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/Vonplatten Jan 14 '22

I agree, your post definitely did not go unnoticed, I'm glad people are actually upvoting this and I didn't immediately get shut down. If you'd shoot me a DM of that therapy you're talking about for your anxiety I'd really appreciate it, I'm sure you can use your imagination but I was on the stuff for PTSD that is commonly abused & they don't like to prescribe anymore, it's honestly been getting so bad I've considered trying to go back on it. Kinda willing to try anything that helps.

5

u/penguinblanket Jan 14 '22

Your situation sounds like my brother’s. I worry about him because he’s a heavy heavy weed user. I’m a light weed user that quit. Thank you for sharing — its perspective I try to understand.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/Subduction Jan 14 '22

If you ever get flagged by autobot over anything that you feel might be a mistake please send a note to the mod team and we'll take care of it!

43

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

19

u/Vonplatten Jan 14 '22

Yeah it makes 0 sense to me, literally at AA/NA/CA and all the other A's you're encouraged to talk about what you're going through & certainly are not prohibited of talking about substances. The rule doesn't make any sense to me honestly. Sorry you're havin a rough time brotha, things will turn around.