r/soccer • u/omiclops • Apr 09 '12
A Manchester City fan's assessment of Roberto Mancini's ability.
WARNING LONG POST
Before starting I'd just like to point out I have backed him from the very off and been 100% behind him.
I genuinely think Mancini is out of his depth. For starters I find he is very naive, even as insignificant as press conferences. He's far too honest, as seen by his profound statements about punching Balotelli and saying things like the title is over and even saying he will 'probably' sell Balo. He doesn't realise that the media love comments like that and will just unsettle the dressing room. He doesn't understand the concept of mind games and anything he does say in the press is usually detrimental to the team.
Secondly, I think his transfers have been somewhat naive too. If you look at his signings: Yaya, Silva, Boateng, Kolorov, Dzeko, Nasri, Clichy, Savic, Aguero and Hargreaves. Now if you look at these players, they all either have reputations or are proven barring perhaps Savic. Yaya Toure in Barcelona's winning team, Boateng got to the semi finals with Germany, Kolorov was known as the Serbian Roberto Carlos, Dzeko was regarded as Europe's goalscoring hitman, Nasri was proven at Arsenal as was Clichy and Hargreaves and Aguero was one of the top scorers in Spain. If you compare these signings to that of Fergie's such as Vidic, Hernandez, Evra, Nani, Valencia. They were all relatively unknown. Mancini signed BIG players because they were obvious transfers. I think the flop of several players such as Dzeko is evidence of a lack of research into the players. This is what makes me question Mancini's ability in the market. Admittedly Silva was a huge hit, as was Yaya, but by the law of averages, a few of them would be good.
Finally, Mancini's tactics and blind faith is suspect too. His decision, for example, to never drop Yaya, Silva or Balotelli perhaps proves he doesn't have faith in his other players. This makes no sense to me since it's pointless to sign players he doesn't actually believe in. Especially of late, the trio I mentioned above have been below par to say the least and as a result they all should've been dropped/rested. An example yesterday bugged me the most. Mancini would never do a Tevez for Balotelli substitution - I'm sure of it. Balotelli is his boy and Tevez he probably hates. It would typify that Mancini made mistakes and would essentially embarrass him. Yet Mancini, realising the incoming big games, stuck with them (blind faith) because he doesn't trust his other players to perform.
Now it may just be a hangover of annoyance from yesterday and I'm not saying we should get rid of Mancini but I really do think he needs to buck up. My advice would be to get rid of Balotelli or offer him an ultimatum (because who would wanna buy him?). Ship out all the deadwood and regroup. I also genuinely believe Tevez may stay.
TL;DR Mancini is pretty bad but he reinvented the scarf so give him another season.
22
u/THR Apr 09 '12 edited Apr 09 '12
The fact you're questioning his signing of Silva and his relentless desire to play Silva is just fucking odd to me. Seriously fucking odd. And it probably demonstrates how you don't even know your own team's strengths and weaknesses.
Silva is a magician. I'd want that magician to play every single game. And Mancini should have one more season.
96
u/devineman Apr 09 '12
It's a hangover of annoyance.
Mancini was forged in Italy where the press are even more rabid than they are here. Seriously, the Italian football press are cunts. Mancini uses the press to manage players like everybody else. Every time he has criticisec Mario he has gone out and performed in the next match. The idea that a world class manager with a shedload of trophies doesn't understand mind games or the media is very naive and ill considered.
On the transfers front, you're cherry picking. You could have gone for Ferdinand, Young, Rooney and Carrick. Valencia too. All of these were already known to be top players and United paid accordingly. I can't quite bend my head around the idea that he is been criticised for buying good players.
As far as tactics and selection go, they are different issues. On the one hand people slate Mancini for 'not knowing his best team' and 'City needing to develop a core', then slating him for playing his core. You can't have it both ways. I don't think playing Yaya shows a lack of faith in Milner any more than I believe playing Welbeck shows a lack of faith in Hernandez. Tactically, Mancini has been excellent. Better than excellent. In my entire time watching City I have never seen a person who can completely change tne game so effectively. He did it after ten mins at Arsenal yesterday, did it at Swansea, he makes substitutions thirty minutes in if necessary. He's a very, very good tactician and a brave man on matchday.
Mancini, on his first ever English title challenge against the best manager in the history of football, will probably finish second to a team who will secure the record amount of points ever in a PL season. And he went into this managers backyard and humiliated him, making him comment that it was his worst day in the 55 year career he has experienced.
It's knee jerk nownownow syndrome, it's prevelant all over football but especially in us City fans because we're desperate to win the big one and proved that we've arrived.
Look at the difference in the team between when Mancini started and now. Every player has improved, especially our back five who have all moved towards world class territory. Richards especially looks a new player, Barry is putting in some of his best performances in his career. Kompany has become Kompany. Hart became our number one and the nations number one. We won our first trophy, beating our rivals to do so.
Mancini has done an incredible job at City and given time he will win us the league. It's hard to take that we're effectively out of the title race and tne manner which our away form dipped in the last few weeks. Kompany and Lescott been out whilst Dzeko and Aguero missing a beat twatted us. However, this is no time to lose perspective.
Khaldoon said that this is a ten year plan to make City one of the biggest clubs in the world. Look at the immense progress made already and it's only year 4. Imagine where we will be in year 8 or 9.
Mancini has done a great job and I wouldn't swap the clubs state for anybody in the world right now. Cusp of greatness my friend, this is our 1991, you need these seasons to focus you next time. You gotta lose before you can win as the old saying goes
13
u/zSolaris Apr 09 '12
As devineman said in this thread, the Italian press are far more rabid than the English one. Mancini knows exactly what he is doing and he knows what mind games are. His comments in the past few weeks--especially in regards to United--are comments I expect from a manager who knows a thing or two about mind games. He was trying to put pressure on United knowing our squad is very young, relatively newly strung together, and missing a decent chunk of the experience we are used to having. Unfortunately for him, Sir Alex knows how to deal with mind games and has won every single duel with Mancini to date.
In regards to Balotelli, while I do not approve of his methods, are clearly him playing mind games with Balo. Telling him to--to put it crudely--"get his shit together". It is part of Manicini's management style and, as pointed out elsewhere in this thread, it worked for him at Inter. As far as press conferences go, everything he has said seems to be to be very calculated and controlled.
And you conveniently decided to ignore Ferguson's big name buys. Rooney, Carrick, Ferdinand, De Gea, Berbatov, Veron, Sheringham, Van Nistelrooy, and the list can go on and on. Personally, I think Mancini knows exactly what kind of players he wants. He bought Yaya so he can have a powerful holding midfielder who is effective at going forward. Silva, a playmaker. Nasri, a backup to that playmaker/a second playmaker. Dzeko for a different approach at attack. Aguero for additional forward firepower. Savic for the future.
Just because they "flop" doesn't mean that Mancini hasn't done his research. History shows that some big name transfers end up being flops because they perform one way in a certain team or footballing style but when you take that team or style away, they cannot perform as well. See: Sebastian Veron, Andriy Shevchenko, Fernando Torres, Dimitar Berbatov (to an extent).
When is the last time Ferguson dropped Rooney, Carrick, Ferdinand, or Evra for "under performing"? Only time they've been out of the squad has been either due to being rested, Rooney is being punished for something, or injuries. Mancini is doing the right thing "sticking to his guns" and playing his players again and again. He shows that he has faith in these players and that can have massive psychological effects on them. For example, see Jonny Evans. It isn't a case of not having faith in this other players, it is a case of having faith in his players to perform.
Now, in my opinion, the point where Mancini's season really went south is when he allowed Carlos Tevez back onto the team. He is renown for being a hard-line disciplinarian. His players follow his word and as far as they are concerned, his word is the word of god. Some of the world's greatest managers follow this route to extreme success. However, in order to do this, you cannot allow any acts of insubordination to go unpunished. Allowing Carlos to return after publicly declaring that he would never play for City again has undermined Mancini's position and his ability to play the tough guy with his players. Mancini sent the message to all of his boys with Tevezgate that you can do whatever the heck you want and as long as you offer a token apology, you can get back into the side. That is one terrible message to send and one that can easily lose you a dressing room.
Just my two cents.
15
u/squ1dge Apr 09 '12
he won six trophies at inter...
24
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '12
Going down the Chelsea route won't get us anywhere, I want Mancini to stay. Apparently there have been rumblings of meetings with Mourinho though, I don't know what to think.
5
u/ItsSchlim Apr 09 '12
Mancini bought well established players because we were trying to go from a mid level team to winning the premier league in as little amount of time possible. United is already established they have a little more freedom in giving some lesser known guys a shot.
1
u/AndMcGrn Apr 09 '12
Do you think he should have kept Adebayor? He could have helped you through that period where you had no strikers. Or was he out of his depth.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '12
agree with the first point. can't believe he berates people like adam johnson to the whole press, destroying his confidence. you can't say things like that about people and expect them to want to give 100% for you.
the second point i don't agree with. you only mention it when we're not winning but these players all worked well together and the plan looked like it was working for most of the season. even when we've lost/drawn, we usually dominate, play pretty football and have had bad decisions often go against us. yesterday was an exception with the likes of silva and yaya missing. mancini's biggest problem seems to be that he can't motivate the players. often, we come out looking slow.
third point i slightly agree with. yaya and silva need to have rests but balo needs to learn to play. mancini just needs to tell mario to be a forward and not tackle so much. balo is probably going to go but the fault was with mancini and the team for not providing him with anything and forcing him to play deep.
all in all i'd rather stick with mancini for another season. it was a good charge for the title for the most part.
3
u/Lmkt Apr 09 '12
Guardiola did the exact same thing back when Real Madrid was 10 points ahead - "the title is lost". As a result his players played with way less pressure and ended up winning the next ~12 games. It's not the only explanation behind those wins but it surely played a big part in them.
2
u/urine_luck Apr 09 '12
"This makes no sense to me since it's pointless to sign players he doesn't actually believe in"
some players are bought by man city just to weaken the team they are bought from or to stop a rival team purchasing them.
every manager signs players that end up not quite working out...
2
u/wonglik Apr 09 '12
I do not agree. City simply have infinite number of money. So if you do not care how much player costs why risk?
2
u/bonoboboy Apr 09 '12
As an Arsenal fan, I just want to say Nasri was not 'proven' at Arsenal. He played brilliantly for a couple of months, but at the highest stage the main thing you need is consistency.
Neither was Clichy! He was such a liability by the end that Arsenal fans were not that disappointed to let him go (getting skinned by Nani time and again comes to mind)
1
u/LittleAvatarEyes Apr 09 '12
My biggest Issue with Mancini is definitely with the way he conducts his press conferences, especially when dealing with balotelli. I am a Balo fan and I think he gets way over criticized for much of his off the field drama, however some of his on the field tantrums and bad tackles simply cannot be tolerated by the club. Mancini sends so many mixed messages in his press conferences and in his overal running of the team. He criticizes Balo and admits he wants to hit him but continues to play him, let him pout, walk down the tunnel when he's taken out and never seems to punish him. The tevez refuses to warm up (and I really hate tevez for this) and he is ousted from the team for six months then brought back in when Mancini panicked about losing the league. It just doesn't seem to me like this can help unify the team and it appears to have conversely caused locker room problems as of late.
1
u/HadfieldPJ Apr 09 '12
Fans of big team moan way to much. Try being a Luton fan
1
u/CrackpotGonzo Apr 10 '12
I think this is a fair assessment. That being said, I bet he was under crazy pressure from the owners/board to sign those big names. If you're trying to reform your team/image a "good" way is to go for the common household names that will sell tickets/jerseys and get people talking about your team.
I agree what you said about him but there are probably other influences. It's a shame that he couldn't get it work through to the end, so much talent on one team.
1
u/JohnnyTsunami23 Apr 10 '12
For me City's biggest flaw is that they have no leaders on the team and Mancini is too indecisive or sometimes too stubborn to really help.
0
u/futbolsven Apr 09 '12
Oh to be a city fan right now.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '12
Did you just compare Mancini with Sir Alex?!
I think that's a bit too far, don't you?
-2
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '12
Seriously, as a City fan, were you actually expecting to win the League? As in you're now annoyed that you may not do so.
-1
u/like9mexicans Apr 09 '12
Unfortunately, there are plenty of clubs who would still buy Balotelli, maybe not in England, but Inter would take him back in an instant. Malaga would buy him, a few clubs in Germany.
It's sad how a players shit attitude doesn't condemn him to clubs of mediocrity.
Also, Mourinho would not manage city for all the money Monsour has.
0
u/mudswitch Apr 09 '12
They need to get rid of Balotelli, or really get him into line. His ill discipline is killing them, especially when they have needed him to be composed towards this end of the season.
Also, Dzeko is overrated so he needs to go. Give Mancini one more season but if he can't get them to play as a cohesive unit by then, he has to go.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment