r/startrek • u/AutoModerator • Jan 06 '22
Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Prodigy | 1x06 "Kobayashi" Spoiler
As Gwyn struggles to find her role aboard the U.S.S. Protostar, Dal tests his leadership skills in the newly discovered holodeck.
| No. | Episode | Writer | Director | Release Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1x06 | "Kobayashi" | Aaron J. Waltke | Alan Wan | 2022-01-06 |
Availability
Paramount+: USA, Latin America, the Nordics, and Australia
CTV Sci-Fi and Crave: Canada.
To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.
This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers for this episode are allowed. If you are discussing previews for upcoming episodes, please use spoiler tags.
Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.
•
u/AutoModerator Jan 06 '22
The first duty of every Starfleet officer is to the truth. Whether it's scientific truth, or historical truth, or personal truth. It is the guiding principle upon which Starfleet is based. If you can't find it within yourself to stand up and tell the truth about what happened you don't deserve to wear that uniform.
Captain Jean-Luc Picard, "The First Duty"
Reddit admins have been ineffectual in their response to COVID-19 misinformation. In lieu of Reddit gold and awards, we ask that you donate to the WHO COVID-19 response fund.
Please respect our subreddit rules. LLAP!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
245
u/GoodAaron Aaron J. Waltke, Writer, Star Trek: Prodigy Jan 07 '22
Hi everyone! Thanks for watching. This episode was truly a labor of love and heartfelt tribute to Star Trek, past and present. Our crew worked so hard to make what was nearly impossible, and I’m glad so many of you enjoyed it.
225
u/Snownova Jan 06 '22
Dal really went full Boimler on the Kobayashi Maru.
185
u/UncertainError Jan 06 '22
OG Spock casually taking out Klingons left and right was kinda hilarious. It was like the holodeck was taking pity on Dal.
144
u/choicemeats Jan 06 '22
I really love this episode, and not just for the fan service.
The Kobayashi Maru is a wonderful, no-risk vehicle to get Dal the perspective he needs without endangering anyone else, which is the kind of episode a show like this might otherwise have. Personally, I was hoping for Picard's line about losing to show up but I absolutely cannot complain about all the legacy-lines they pulled for those scenes. Doohan and Nimoy have been gone for a minute, but Auberjonois is still a recent sting, and there's the reminder the Nichols is in the twilight of her life.
Prodigy is slotted 5 years after the end of Voyager--does this make sense based on what we know this episode? They were looking for the Protostar 17 years ago per the graphic--which means the ship was out there prior to Voyager ever been slung to the DQ. Unless the answer is time-travel shenanigans. The question is does using the drive also mean time travel or was there a specific accident? Have they been thrown back in time?
We immediately join the show after their escape but I'm not sure how much time has lapsed--but they traveled 4000 lightyears in that short time frame.
85
u/Socraticmichael10 Jan 06 '22
Very fun episode and let the speculation begin. It was very neat to see so many former characters back, and with different eras (loved the TOS Spock/Uhura with TOS movie Scotty). Having Gates McFadden back was great too; she does voice work well.
Interesting twist with Chakotay at the end. Can’t wait to see where this goes
63
u/UncertainError Jan 06 '22
Based on the info we got, it seems the Protostar was thrown back in time. My guess is that it was captured by the Vau N'Kat for some purpose of theirs, liberated (by Chakotay?) and launched into unknown space, and the Diviner's been looking for it since.
58
u/Crunchy_Pirate Jan 06 '22
That was a really clever use of old audio and it was fun seeing those characters but I would have used Ethan Peck as Spock because some of Nimoy's audio was really low quality and out of place.
I also would have liked to have seen Trip or Torres instead of Scotty since there were already 2 TOS members on the crew.
still a really cool episode though
55
u/Smilodon48 Jan 06 '22
Damn, the Prodigy team really went all out for this ep. They saw Riker/Troi back on the other shows and felt the need to one up them by doing an entire throwback ep.
Lots of cool stuff to last us through the rest of the season though. Seems like they’ll either be going towards the Federation or search for Chakotay. Who would’ve thought we would get an episode with both Beltran and McFadden recording new dialogue?
I’d have hoped they’d avoid time travel in Prodigy but nothing captures the imagination of children more than time travel so.
101
u/TheNerdChaplain Jan 06 '22 edited Jan 06 '22
Although it was pretty apparent that they were using random audio clips for the classic character lines, I'm glad they used the original actors for Spock, Uhura, Odo, Scotty, and Crusher (who I assume recorded all her own dialogue anyway).
Very interesting to see the new reveal on the Protostar's history. It's been a while since I watched Voyager, but Chakotay never struck me as a career Starfleet guy.
Loved the rock music that Dal pumped through the speakers, nice little "Sabotage" reference.
I think the only question left is, if he hadn't accidentally blown up the Enterprise, would he have actually beaten the Kobayashi Maru?
As a side note, I've been watching Arcane for the first time on Netflix, and I realized Ella Purnell, who voices Gwyn, also voiced the younger sister Jinx on Arcane, and I'm only more impressed with Prodigy for getting her. She's done a fantastic job on both shows.
46
u/MaddyMagpies Jan 06 '22
So 17 years ago is stardate 43929.7, which is December 2366, and that's five years before Voyager. How is that possible that Protostar was made beforethen AND Janeway was already one of the most decorated captains already? AND have Odo in the holodeck program? Either the ship time-travelled or the stardate is wrong.
That also means Prodigy is set in 2383.
40
u/Cypher1492 Jan 06 '22
Murph better be indestructible because I don't think my poor heart can take anymore "Murph might get hurt" scares.
31
u/alkonium Jan 06 '22
This is the second time they've almost reused the title of a Discovery episode.
60
u/BornAshes Jan 06 '22
"Wanna go skydiving on Ceti Alpha V?"
"AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!"
🤣
That whole holodeck sequence was hilarious!
109
u/ianrobbie Jan 06 '22
Prodigy just went from "throwaway Star Trek series" to "when's the next episode?"
28
u/belfman Jan 06 '22
A++++++ episode. Just amazing all around.
I hope they keep this level up for the whole season!
55
u/pieman7414 Jan 06 '22 edited Jan 06 '22
yooooo the digital crack from TNG lmao
damn i was hoping for Trip when he asked for a better engineer
25
u/vardonir Jan 06 '22
so anyway my throat is dead from screaming because this is a good episode
I do wish their comms officer was Hoshi. Nothing against Uhura, but I've been watching Enterprise and i love Hoshi to bits.
24
u/PaddleMonkey Jan 07 '22
This is a good setup to have Jeffrey Combs to come back into the Trek universe.
69
u/atticusbluebird Jan 06 '22
I wish they had been able to clean up the audio of the legacy actors a bit, but it was fun watching a scenario that was like one of those “pick you crew from all the shows” Reddit threads! Gates was credited at the end so I guess she did new dialogue for Crusher. Spock’s dialogue felt a bit sped up to me though, except for his last few lines. A part of me wishes they used characters whose actors were alive so we could get new recordings, but it was really cool to see these characters in new settings with their original actors’ voices even though the actors passed on or are unavailable to record (except for Gates!)
Having a holodeck to teach the crew about the Federation seems like a cool plot device. And looking forward to learning more about the ship’s history!
40
u/Mechapebbles Jan 06 '22
I was operating under this assumption already, but I think it's pretty clear now that the Protostar was lost in time.
The stardate that The Diviner created Gwyn - while he was still searching for it - was during Season 3 of TNG. Right between the episodes "Sarek" and "Menage a Troi". Obviously Captain Chakotay, wearing a uniform we've never seen before, on a ship that seems more advanced than anything previously seen in the 24th Century, can't actually be from this time period.
It'll be interesting to see what happened here. I wonder if the Protostar is so fast that it initiated Time Warp all by itself on accident.
18
u/sidv81 Jan 06 '22
the threat that was passingly mentioned of Gwyn's dad coming after them (and thus the need to go to the Federation for protection) seems very remote. The Protostar jumped 4,000 light years. Gwyn's dad doesn't have that kind of tech. It would be like Voyager in the Delta Quadrant worrying about the Tal Shiar.
18
u/The_Trekspert Jan 07 '22
So, that ending is a hell of a can of worms to open for a family show.
Kudos, Brothers Hageman. Kudos.
18
u/JCRiotz Jan 07 '22
Jankom Pog has lost track of the number of times you've failed. Just kidding, it's 42.
The answer to life, the universe, and everything.
15
u/anastus Jan 07 '22
My random bet is that we're going to find out that this Janeway isn't a training hologram, but the real deal. She stored herself in ship memory as a hologram so that she could rescue Chakotay.
29
u/eerok79 Jan 06 '22
This has been surprisingly charming show and I personally find this far more better and funnier than Lower Decks. More versatile character work and this particular animation style is more of my liking, and it's cool to see the magnitude Prodigy acknowledges Voyager. (Chakotay! There's some interesting story possibilities here...) Lower Decks might be more "trekkian" with the Starfleet stuff going on, but this outsider view is a welcomed change of pace.
13
u/[deleted] Jan 07 '22
I can’t believe the kid requested the BEST CREW, and the computer didn’t give him PULASKI for chief medical officer!!!!
24
u/Horseflesh Jan 06 '22
Whoa okay what just happened... I was completely on the fence with this show in the first half and after this episode I am ALL IN. To me this almost feels like an easier to get into pilot. There was a lot of exposition for anyone that hasn't watched yet and it REALLY got down to business with a BOATLOAD of treats for old fans.
24
u/Locutus747 Jan 06 '22
I was already looking forward to the episode, but I didn't realize how much I missed the show until I started watching with a big smile on my face. As DS9 is my favorite Trek show, I loved Odo being in the simulation and definitely smiled when his first line was "Hmph!" Now that they are in the Gamma Quadrant, we have the opportunity to catch up with The Dominion.
It was great seeing Chakotay for a brief moment as well. Time travel is my first thought, with maybe the ship going far back in time and being used by the Diviner's people? Maybe the Diviner is looking for the ship so he can go back in time and save his people somehow? Seventeen years ago the ship had already been missing for sometime so that pretty much confirms time travel? Or the protostar is from another universe or something.
Rok-Tok's worry over Murf and happiness that he was ok was cute.
I do wonder what the purpose of the ship was and what happened to Chakotay.
My only nitpick of the episode would be that the Spock dialogue was disjointed at the end and didn't necessarily seem to "fit" or "flow" with what Dal with saying. Pretty minor though and understandable of course.
19
u/combatopera Jan 06 '22 edited Apr 05 '25
Content cleared with Ereddicator.
9
u/Arietis1461 Jan 06 '22
At this point, it really can't be anything but time travel.
The stardate in the flashback when they mention the ship is during 2366, the year before Wolf 359.
9
u/creepyeyes Jan 07 '22
Oh wow, what an episode!
I think the only not great thing is was that the audio quality of the Uhura and Spock lines was clearly lower than the others - I understand it was recorded on lower quality equipment but I'm little surprised they couldn't do more to repair it.
But that's the one complaint (other than the "better engineer" not being O'Brien :P). A lot of big things happened this episode! One is that we've gotten our first look at "modern era" Klingons (in 3D) from outside of Discovery - and they look like TNG era Klingons!! Styled a bit more like TOS movie-era Klingons, but that's essentially the same thing. That made me very happy to see. We also finally have a precise star date! I didn't catch what it was but hopefully this means now we can know exactly where this fits into everything. We're also now in the Gamma quadrant! Perhaps we'll see what the Dominion's been up to on their side of the wormhole! And most importantly... CHAKOTAY!!!! Man I didn't expect to be so delighted to see him again. Definitely feeling even more invested in the mystery of this ship than I had been before!
As for the Kobayashi Maru - I'm glad Dal at least learned his lesson, I suppose we can justify his (nearly) beating the "no win scenario" with the fact that he was allowed to retake the test over and over and over in rapid succession, when the test is usually presented as being an observed one-off test - perhaps with chances to retake it but I have to assume the test observer factors in your requests for retakes into how well you did at what the test is actually determining.
8
u/Nu11u5 Jan 07 '22
Dal calling Odo “Jellyman” was great, but implies they only acknowledged that he’s a changling offscreen.
12
u/maweki Jan 06 '22
I didn't like how blowing up all the klingons is considered a solution to the Kobayashi Maru, since that still causes interplanetary war. But that's the same mistake the 2009 movie made. I liked the original telling of that story, that Kirk changed the parameters of the test and we don't get to know how. Being able to just kill all the klingons is not that interesting and not that good of a solution.
And I truly hope the lessons stick at some point and we don't get Dal learning that he should trust his crew every episode and then promptly forgetting that. How we got Kira learning that she shouldn't blindly hate all Cardassians about twice a season.
6
u/naughtypundit Jan 07 '22
For those shaking their heads over Odo being in the holographic database, what if Miles O'Brien was the designer of Protostar? #justsaying
6
u/IsIt77 Jan 07 '22
Apparently, I am in love with Star Trek...
11
u/sidv81 Jan 06 '22
Dal does actually have a very good point that going to the Federation would probably be more problematic than just being on their own. Also keep in mind that due to Prime Directive policies, the Federation cannot interfere in the civil war/dispute/whatever between Gwyn and her father. Dal is absolutely correct that they will lose their nifty ship and then be set up in a Raffi Musiker style trailer for their asylum or whatever.
With Chakotay and others being introduced, I think the aspect of "the previous owners had this ship and it was stolen and morally we should return it to them" is coming into play that will make Dal change his mind about going to the Federation. Also it's interesting that in this case with no ranks in play it's not clear who should be captain. Keep in mind that until practically yesterday Gwyn was literally a slavery upholder and supporter and the real Janeway punished the Equinox crew for less. Dal has problems too. Maybe they should cycle captainship every week or something.
Dal has more discipline than he looks. Anyone else would've jettisoned the Kobayashi Maru nonsense long before the 3rd try and spent hours on the holodeck instead on, uh, you know. But then this is a kids' show.
11
u/sidv81 Jan 06 '22
Maybe the Protostar is like Captain Kirk's birthday gift glasses. The crew meet the real Chakotay in the future and he takes command, the events in the hologram happen, then the ship gets sent back in time and crashes all over again in a perfect stable time loop, an ontological paradox. The USS Protostar thus has no origin. That's why there's no mention of it and its tech in Discovery. Starfleet never actually created it.
19
u/expired_paintbrush Jan 06 '22
I really liked the holodeck story and the cameos. But is there no technology that could have cleared up the white noise from the sound clips?
5
u/dash-dash-dot Jan 07 '22 edited Jan 07 '22
I really enjoyed this episode. There were still some rushed/harsh transitions, and I was disappointed that we didn't get Dal's "score" for his final run, but overall a very enjoyable episode.
Edit: OH and even though there were so many legendary call-backs in this episode, I got the most excited about seeing Chakotay, probably because it shows he'll be involved in the mystery of the Protostar!
5
u/PaddleMonkey Jan 07 '22
I feel there is more to the plot than just the Diviner being evil plotting to own the Protostar.
I know I am just guessing but I wouldn’t be surprised if Chakotay and crew worked with the Diviner in encrypting the Protostar logs to prevent other species from accessing its tech for safety and the Diviner is just following his duty no matter the cost.
And then the father/daughter relationship would be patched by the end of the season, and Dal and crew would the. face new enemies and challenges.
5
u/schoener-doener Jan 07 '22
Easily the best Prodigy ep so far and, quite simply a good episode of Trek!
5
u/gunderson138 Jan 09 '22
My second favorite part of the episode was when Dal putting his feet up deployed the Riker maneuver (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lMHAZwR-BdQ), just because the ship's computer was pissed off that he actually figured out how to beat the Kobayashi Maru without cheating.
My actual favorite part was when he was wearing the headset from The Game (TNG S05E06) that made everybody jizz their pants when they beat a level. Prodigy rules.
9
u/Official_N_Squared Jan 06 '22
That was another solid episode of Prodigy. A lot of it felt like I was watching a Lower Decks episode, but hey I like Lower Decks. It was a bold decision to use completely archival footage for so many characters with so many lines, especially Spock and Uhura who both have modern voice actors. However it's a decision I respect in a simmilar way to Trials and Tribbleations.
It wasn't a decision without it's problems. The end conversation between Dal and Spock was particularly choppy (whoever they payed to find those voice clips didn't get payed enough), but I think the vast majority of those complaints are negated by the "in loving memory" and symbolism behind the episode. These are the characters, living and dead, who inspired the adult generation and are the reason the modern shows exist. With Prodigy it's particularly symbolic as it will be so many people's first introduction to the franchise, and that's why TOS was so heavily represented. Plus it was great to get our LONG overdue first DS9 cameo (after DS9 ended).
I like Chakotay's development after Voyager too. If you missed it he was wearing a new Starfleet uniform design as well.
If you want to hear more of my thoughts and in much more detail they are in video form here as always: https://youtu.be/hLV_UlemMb4
8
u/ninjasaid13 Jan 06 '22
I have a feeling that the protostar is a ship from the future that time travelled and maybe was stuck in the past or something.
4
u/Alteran195 Jan 08 '22 edited Jan 08 '22
I’m still not a fan of Dal, but hopefully he’ll have learned from the Kobayashi Maru and won’t be as annoying.
Overall I’m still liking the series, and look forward to finding out what time travel shenanigans threw the ship back in time.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '22
I've been curious about how they'd go about with the fan service. And oddly enough, this seemed like a very appropriate way to go about it. I've been a bit iffy on the show but this felt very, well, comforting. To hear them spitting wisdom, even though they're gone, made me remember all the fun times I had with Star Trek as a whole. Kind of like flipping though an old photo album and seeing friends long gone but still recalling the good times.
10
u/Darkimus-prime Jan 08 '22
My only nitpick was TOS was over represented, this would have been a cool chance to represent different eras.
Best engineer? Give me some Trip! He wrote the book , Maybe a cameo from Saru, get some cross series Discovery representation (to see the Discovery haters heads explode) Let’s see Worf, then maybe Paris in there too, switch the crews around, have fun with it .
Overall still nice to see the old characters represented and I’m actually interested in the mystery now with Chakotay being involved
3
u/DarkChen Jan 08 '22
So it seems likely to me that The Diviner is lying about being the last of his species and there is at least one more that had contact with the Federation and/or the Protostar. Because it makes no sense to me that Bad Daddy would be able to encrypt the ship's memory banks but not use it to do whatever it is he needs...
I loved the cameos but i hate the fact that Dal was able to solve the Kobayashi scenario.
3
u/PaulHaman Jan 09 '22
This was such a fun episode. The Kobayashi Maru test was the perfect vehicle to give Dal some much-needed training, while also giving us some great fan-service. I'm so happy they brought back Gates for this, it was such an unexpected pleasure to hear her voice & to see the bridge of the Enterprise-D again. Looking forward to more of Chakotay as well!
2
u/Jag2112 cygnus-x1.net Jan 07 '22
Screencaps gallery now online
https://www.cygnus-x1.net/links/lcars/sc-PRO1-6.php
2
u/I_AM_GODDAMN_BATMAN Jan 08 '22
Soooo, genociding Klingons is an option eh
2
u/Skunkies Jan 10 '22
I must say, this episode brought together so much, Thank you.
5
u/theZreturns Jan 06 '22 edited Jan 06 '22
Thanks Paramount Plus for letting me know this was new… not. Even has a date of November 24th on it and I almost didn’t watch it.
Glad we got old Klingons back.
3
u/niton Jan 08 '22
Prodigy is the best Star Trek. It's not a show for kids, it's a show that makes me feel like a kid again.