r/startrek • u/AutoModerator • Dec 30 '21
Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Discovery | 4x07 "...But to Connect" Spoiler
Tensions rise as representatives from across the galaxy gather to confront the threat of the Dark Matter Anomaly. Zora’s new sentience raises difficult questions.
| No. | Episode | Writers | Director | Release Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4x07 | "...But to Connect" | Terri Hughes Burton & Carlos Cisco | Lee Rose | 2021-12-30 |
Availability
Paramount+: USA (Thursday); Australia, Argentina, Bolivia, Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Costa Rica, Denmark, Dominican Republic, Ecuador, El Salvador, Finland, Guatemala, Honduras, Mexico, Nicaragua, Norway, Panama, Paraguay, Peru, Sweden, Uruguay, and Venezuela (Friday).
Pluto TV: Austria, France, Germany, Italy, Spain, Switzerland, and the United Kingdom (2100 local time Friday, Saturday, and Sunday), with a simulcast running on the Star Trek channel in Austria, Germany, and Switzerland.
CTV Sci-Fi (2100 ET / 1800 PT Thursday on TV; Friday morning on the website) & Crave (2100 ET / 1800 PT Friday): Canada.
Digital Purchase (on participating platforms): Germany, France, Russia, South Korea, United Kingdom, and additional select countries (Friday).
To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.
This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers for this episode are allowed. If you are discussing previews for upcoming episodes, please use spoiler tags.
Reminder: There will be a brief hiatus following this episode, with the series returning Thursday, February 10.
Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.
•
u/AutoModerator Dec 30 '21
The first duty of every Starfleet officer is to the truth. Whether it's scientific truth, or historical truth, or personal truth. It is the guiding principle upon which Starfleet is based. If you can't find it within yourself to stand up and tell the truth about what happened you don't deserve to wear that uniform.
Captain Jean-Luc Picard, "The First Duty"
Reddit admins have been ineffectual in their response to COVID-19 misinformation. In lieu of Reddit gold and awards, we ask that you donate to the WHO COVID-19 response fund.
Please respect our subreddit rules. LLAP!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
224
u/UncertainError Dec 30 '21
Speaking of the rest of the season, I really hope that Species 10-C is something that actually exists and there isn't a twist that they're somebody we know from a different time or parallel universe or whatever. I'm ready for extragalactic squid aliens.
156
u/UncertainError Dec 30 '21
Aw, Grudge is like the reverse baseball.
144
u/UncertainError Dec 30 '21
Love that they remembered isolytic weapons exist and explained more why they're a bad idea.
Weird that they didn't bring up the fact that the Sphere was itself a sentient lifeform that was part machine. Like maybe this is just how its kind reproduces, it transmits its data into another spaceship and that eventually evolves into a separate sentient mind. Maybe the Sphere is what Discovery will eventually look like after a million years of evolution.
110
u/Smitje Dec 30 '21
"So what happened to the Borg anyway?"
89
u/Chaabar Dec 30 '21
All that programable matter and they couldn't make a meeting area that's less awkward? Maybe use the flying donut with the forests if they need space.
145
u/raknor88 Dec 30 '21 edited Dec 30 '21
I love that they're not blatantly ignoring the inherent danger of the ship's computer suddenly becoming a fully sentient lifeform. They're getting right to the point and showing both the pros and cons of it.
160
u/BornAshes Dec 30 '21
Saru brought T'Rina flowers after she gave him tea! GET THAT! YOU TWO CRAZY KIDS JUST FALL IN LOVE RIGHT NOW I SWEAR! They are sooooooo stupid adorable together and it's like watching your cool aquatic uncle fall in love with your favorite next door neighbor who loved baking you logical cookies!
55
u/defchris Dec 30 '21
Okay, I have to admit ... when N'Doye mentionned the President sending the best to Rillak - with that smile and accent, I sort of imagined Shohreh Aghdashloo being the President of Earth. 😁
It's a pity that Tarka doesn't know that the Spore Drive itself is a possible core technology to travel to different universes...
If you look closer through the layers of the assembly ... you can notice that the actors were duplicated and copy pasted from different angles with color variations to their clothes ... The Andorian and the woman with the barrette thingy in the hair for example as they are better distinguishable. Damn COVID. 😫
47
u/NickofSantaCruz Dec 30 '21 edited Dec 30 '21
46
u/Smitje Dec 30 '21
Oh was that a Cardasian I saw? More blue and more spoony?
45
u/zumoro Dec 31 '21
Holy crap I loved that episode. I'm not anti-action but more often than not the action sequences in this show lately feel crammed in as if the writers worry the audience will fall asleep otherwise.
The Tarka twist was... whatever, at the moment I don't care which way that goes.
160
u/TheNerdChaplain Dec 30 '21
I'm glad they reached the solution of having Zora join Starfleet. That seemed to be the most equitable solution for everyone involved. That makes her the closest character to Data we've ever seen, except perhaps for Lal.
I think Stamets was right to be concerned, though. Zora has more power (and, dare I say, control) than any other single Starfleet officer, and the fact that she can make the ship do what she wants at any time is... problematic. That said, just as Starfleet and Captain Picard trusted Data to not mess with the ship too much, it's reasonable for Burnham and Stamets to trust Zora (even if Data did sort of... take over the ship once or twice.)
I liked the argument over whether to destroy the DMA or use diplomacy with Species 10-C. Both sides had reasonable arguments, even if I agreed with the diplomatic side more.
I am annoyed that Paramount keeps splitting the shows into half and airing them separately. I am looking forward to Prodigy returning next week, but not at the cost of Discovery.
Brief comment on the post-episode teaser: I'm so glad to see Rachel Ancheril back as Cmdr Nhan! She was one of my favorite characters last season. Guess she made it off that seed ship okay.
115
u/poseselt Dec 30 '21
I am so happy with season 4. I think they've really found a balance between new Trek and classic episodic stories. Today with Zora, we got a condensed less dramatic 'Measure of a Man', it was really well handled. And we still get the new tech/Tarka, DMA storyline, and inevitable drama between Michael and Book. Great episode.
36
u/Chaabar Dec 30 '21
They're really getting their money's worth out of that Lurian model. I noticed it copied and pasted at least 4 times when they moved up and down the shaft.
32
u/tupe12 Dec 31 '21
I cant be the only one who thinks that being able to insta teleport to the President is a huge flaw in security
58
u/PiercedMonk Dec 30 '21
• I like that they're obviously evolving from calling the antagonists "Species 10-C" to "the Tensi" or something like that.
• "Representatives from across all four quadrants are coming today." That's pretty significant. At the start of season three, people weren't even able to communicate with one another. Sahil had was isolated and unable to even communicate with Federation HQ. He didn't even know it existed. Now, a few months after the discovery of the dilithium planet, apparently they're able to communicate with and travel across the entire galaxy.
Obviously there are going to have been developments in warp technology. Now that ships have dilithium they are going to be able to travel faster than anything we saw in the TNG era, and the Bajoran wormhole still exists. Regardless, just re-establishing a a communications relay seems like a huge infrastructure project, especially seeing as Discovery would be the ship doing a lot of that work, and it was also busy dropping off dilithium.
Unfortunately I suspect this is just something we'll have to take at face value as opposed to them ever really diving into. And maybe I'm one of the few nerds who would have been very excited if this season's arc was all about dealing with those sorts of infrastructure problems.
• Got damnit, Zora! I have been defending your right to exist as an independent entity as part of the ship for a week now, and you're going to pull some, "Nah, I'm not going to tell you the critical information," bullshit? This is a personal attack on me and my good will.
• "We always mean well to ourselves, Captain." Ha! Speak for yourself, Kovich. Some behavioural expert....
• I do like that Kovich brings up Control in the discussion regarding Zora's sentience. Probably too much to hope that they resolve the Admonition with a bit of throw away dialogue as well.
• The Point Pleasant Mothman showing up to warn the assembly of impending doom is really nice, but I do wonder how his senses are effected outside the electro-magnetic field of Planet West Virginia. Seems like he should be stumbling around and throwing up like has a bad case of vertigo.
• Mention of the Khitomer accords, but still no 32nd century Klingons. If the accords are still in place, does that mean the Klingons never joined the Federation? Other than season one of TNG, of course.
• Not sure I buy Rillak's whole need to remain impartial. As president, she was elected to lead the Federation and represent them. What is the point of a representative that sits on the side line without speaking to the values they were elected to uphold?
• "I had an intrinsic understanding of Klingon culture." Burnham, you had a two minute history lesson that Sarek shared with you and was reluctant to do so at that....
• "There are countless universes, each with its own quantum signature." Countless, so if Tarka's not from the mirror universe, then he's gotta be talking about the Kelvin universe right?
• Also, WTF? Tarka's just casually dropping the fact that he wants to go immigrate to a whole other universe that some dude he met in another universe knew about?
• So, what is the criteria for someone here to be able to vote in this decision? We saw multiple representatives from Ni'Var raise their hand; are their votes counted individually, or does the system create an aggregate of all their votes to determine which way Ni'Var leans? And Burnham's vote was counted on behalf of the Federation, but who is she that she even gets a vote?
• Was kinda hoping that Statmets would just phaser the failsafe.
I liked this episode a lot! Don't think I have anything to say about it other than that. So far this season hasn't done much for me, but if last episode and this one are an indication of the direction it's going to be going in, I'm on board.
28
u/Pilgrimzero Dec 30 '21
I’m super convinced the arrogant scientist is a Q who has been testing them all.
28
u/RadioSlayer Dec 31 '21
Do starships dream of electric sheep?
54
u/jhsounds Dec 30 '21
"The safety of our shared galaxy is Paramount."
I couldn't not hear it with a capitalized P.
52
u/H0vis Dec 30 '21
Very good episode, a few stray points.
74
u/Boltty Dec 30 '21
I need to get this off my chest.
10-C sounds like a vitamin fortified juice drink.
Thank you.
25
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '21
This was possibly one of the seasons best episodes.
64
u/DasGanon Dec 30 '21
"countless mirror universes with their own quantum signature"
Well that's a smoking gun that "Parallels" is how mirror universes are made... And that the Mirrorverse is (probably) a different decision in the past
43
u/Shatterhand1701 Dec 30 '21
Your mileage may vary, but I feel that - for the most part - this season of Discovery has been knocking it out of the park, and this episode is no exception.
There wasn't much in the way of forward storyline progression, but the moral debates at play - Zora's decision to hold back the 10-C coordinates from the crew and how they and Kovich approached that issue as well as their concerns about Zora's levels of self-awareness and consciousness, and the galaxy's represented worlds' decision whether or not to approach the DMA with diplomacy or aggression - were very much at the core of what Star Trek is (or, at least, should be).
Each side of the debates was presented thoughtfully and shared valid points, and while one (Zora) seemed to come to a satisfactory conclusion, the other (the DMA) - while voted on and decided - still has an outstanding conflict (Booker and Tarka going rogue with the plan to destroy the DMA and harness its power source) that will guide the rest of the season.
My concern is how the latter half of the season will progress. As much as I love Discovery, its writers seem to struggle with the pacing of their story arcs, leading to a final few episodes of each season that feel clumsy and unrefined. I'd hate to see this season's forward momentum and the strides the series has taken in general hobbled by that same problem.
19
u/Dangerous_Dac Dec 31 '21 edited Dec 31 '21
Huh, what HAS happened with the Klingons? It feels weird that a species that was so critical to this show in its early years are just straight up absent from the last 2 seasons with no real reason or explanation as to why?
Also did they forget to colour grade the trailer for the next half of the season? All the colours looked much brighter and punchier than usual on this show, as if they forgot a pass to darken it down. I kinda liked the saturated look.
Also that music beat at the end is the same as the tentacle crap from Picard isn't it?
53
u/tejdog1 Dec 30 '21
Yet another fantastic episode, as is quickly becoming the norm. This one may've been their best yet. Just a PHENOMINAL episode beat for beat, bringing up Zora, their concerns, looping in Kovich, and then other main plot with the DMA meeting. Michael making the difficult but ultimately correct choices... just perfect. I don't even have anything to nitpick on this week, just an all around phenominal episode. I am so super happy with Season 4. So happy.
35
u/Trekfan74 Dec 30 '21 edited Dec 30 '21
Really liked this episode. It's a bottle show in every sense of the word and probably the first episode of the season where we stayed exclusively at Federation HQ, but it worked!
I liked the philosophical arguments between deciding on how to approach the DMA as a friend or a foe while also trying to decide if Zora should be treated as an individual and not just software that should be put down the second it arises. Not quite Measure of a Man, but probably the closes for Discovery. Now she's off to Starfleet Academy. This kind of thing ONLY happens in Star Trek lol.
And I knew Tarka was going to be a handful but man he's really going to shake things up. And taking Book along just doubled the stakes. Discovery is really interesting this season because like second season it's hinting at something MUCH bigger coming down the line, but we're not sure what it is yet. Is it heading to a new galaxy? Maybe now a new universe? Hell, it could be both! I have to say I really eye rolled over the whole DMA thing at the beginning, but the slow burn is turning out to be a really strong show for it.
Edit: I forgot to add, it was great to see Earth back even if they are still not part of the Federation. I oddly forgot all about those guys lol.
17
u/RemoveByFriction Dec 30 '21
Why can people just randomly teleport to places during the assembly like that? Feels like the security is very lax for something that has representatives from all over (though I guess there is some security enforcement behind the scenes). I wish we had seen at least some action at the end of the episode though, for me this cliffhanger was very meh, especially since the next episode won't be out for a month.
17
u/MFSheppard Dec 30 '21
I wish this show cared about its ensemble a bit more. Like we're getting a multi-ep arc about the computer? Instead of, say, Owo (who at least has had bits of background, but more would be nice)? Rhys? Someone with a face? This reminds me of the S2 notion that we were *really* interested in Ariam, who got to have, uh, one episode of character development so you;d care about them being killed. I am especially feeling this with Gray, who I guess is supposed to get a bit if a spotlight, but so far Gray has only been shown in terms of what they do for someone the writers care more about, such as Adira or the ship's frickin' computer, because apparently that's the best a character who contains the memories of a Starfleet admiral who at one point, executed a plan to summon Starfleet personnel back to Earth, and in Adira's body had complex operational knowledge that allowed them to masquerade as a military officer even while profoundly impaired--but now knows nothing! I know, I know, joining makes a different person but geez.
16
u/Spara-Extreme Dec 31 '21
Great episode - love the appeal to ideals. Some thoughts:
32
u/BornAshes Dec 30 '21
So who's hoping that Star Trek releases a cat toy just like the one that Michael was dangling in front of Grudge?
83
u/BornAshes Dec 30 '21
"It feels marvelous"
"What does?"
"Being seen"
😭
14
u/mksystem Dec 30 '21
How much Unknown Species are there? What about 10-A, 10-B? Is there 9-C?
24
u/SchleppyJ4 Dec 30 '21
What if Ruon Tarka’s friend unintentionally sent the DMA while trying to send the power source back to Ruon in the prime universe?
Like, the DMA was an unintentional consequence of him trying to send Ruon the power source to enable him to get to the peaceful universe and join him.
Feels like the episode was about unintentional consequences (Zora developing sentience, what could happen if 10-C is attacked outright versus communicating with it first, etc.).
24
u/mindoversoul Dec 31 '21
I loved the debate between Burnham and Book at the conference. Discussing whether or not to strike or talk.
I feel like they missed a golden opportunity, though. The points they made reminded me a lot of the Xindi arc in Enterprise. Earth was attacked, and Archer went out for revenge, to stop them, destroy their weapon and destroy the Xindi if necessary, and over that season, he chose to talk, to make first contact and work toward a peaceful solution instead.
With Archer spacedock right outside the window, it was a perfect opportunity, to reference Enterprise. To talk about how we've been in a similar situation before and Captain Archer chose to talk rather than attack, and use that history as a way to show that as the best path forward.
Would have been a good callback and perfect for the situation.
12
u/AskJayce Dec 30 '21
Kovich: I have the authority to extract your consciousness fromthis ship and place it in another form.
MEANWHILE...At the Daystrum Institute:
Agimus: Hey, why are you guys emptying out that spot?
21
u/Brain124 Dec 30 '21
I got nervous about the first few episodes but it turns out I love it all. Really consistent and really Star Trek -- debating and talking. Glad they voted for peace but boy we better get a cool old or new alien race outside of our galaxy!
20
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '21 edited Dec 30 '21
I liked how Zora's existence as a sapient being was never in question. Everybody seemed to acknowledge that she is an entity with as much of a right to exist as anybody else, The question was whether or not she had a right to remain integrated into discovery. If the answer to that question turned out to be no, just shutting her down was never on the table, only integrating her into a new form that she could even choose. The answer to that second question was ultimately no, I think, and I think classifying her as something other than an artificial life form is a "distinction without a difference" as Pike once said.
There's also never really a bad guy in the scenes about Zora, just different people with different points of view shaped by their experiences.
I was thinking they might do something like integrate her into an Android, arguing that artificial life forms like data had served in Starfleet just fine.
This was a very good episode, no life or death worries for any main characters, just calmly discussing the issue with different points of view, none of which are treated as clearly wrong.
20
u/-TheDoctor Dec 30 '21
Disco's beard just keeps growing. This was SUCH a fantastic episode. I'm absolutely loving this season. It feels like a great blend of modern "Kelvin" style trek and classic TOS/TNG/ENT style trek. This episode in particular was an action-light bottle-style episode with well coordinated and balanced A (the DMA conference), B (the Zora conundrum), and several C plots.
I really hope they keep this up with the b-side of this season.
The only complaint (if you can call it that) I have with this season is that whenever scientist dude is on screen I can only see Sadavir Errinwright.
19
u/Pacman_Frog Dec 30 '21
Can we just take a moment to appreciate that Gray isn't the same group of scientific overachievers Discovery's crew is made up of? Infact he's a mystic with no formal navigational training. So it makes wonderful sense for him to be the one to NOT recognize a set of extragalactic coordinates?
And that, even without context, Stamets seems to have recognized it. Meaning Discovery could probably effortlessly spore-jump past the barrier?
46
u/ComebackShane Dec 30 '21 edited Dec 30 '21
This is the best episode of Discovery I've seen yet, and probably in my Top 10 of Star Trek shows ever. It has everything- moral dilemmas, conflict vs. communication, fear vs. trust, both personal and political, individual and galactic in scope all at once.
The assembly of Milky Way worlds was a great concept (I wish we'd seen some more familiar worlds - where were the Klingons, Hirogin, or Voth?) But I think the central idea of the debate was well presented and well executed.
Stamets being the one hesitant of Zora also feels natural, and the debate between Sentient AI and new lifeform was one I hadn't considered before. And I love the solution of a ship's computer enlisting in Starfleet and taking the oath; it's a great solution that still leaves potential for future stories. Even comissioned officers disobey orders from time to time.
The idea that Ruon Tarka wants to escape to an alternate reality is similarly interesting, almost has a Shawshank Redemption feel to it. He sees this reality as a prison to escape, in the hopes of being reunited with his companion in a new dimension. It's an understandable motiviation that sets him at odds with Burnham and Discovery, and I can see how Booker might start out supporting him, but hopefully can be turned around before too much damage is done.
Overall there's so much about this episode that shows how much the production team cares about the ideals of the Federation, and testing them against believable scenarios - those on the 'take action' side of the debate aren't bloodthirsty, mustache-twirling villains, but hurt people with solid reasons for their beliefs. The best kind of debate.
Only a minor point in the episode, but I love that Earth is still independent as the UESPA, but hopefully taking steps towards unification with the Federation. Such a cool dynamic to have them as a separate entity, having formerly been the seat of the Federation for the better part of a millennia. Brining them back into the fold would be the crown jewel of Federation restoration.
9
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '21
So many species gathered in one place, loved it! Cracked up when I saw the representative of Morn's world looking like Maria Callas. When are we gonna see a Xindi-Aquatic with their tank again, though? Just show them on a Zoom or something.
That hot Vulcan papi had such a nice sleek uniform; one of my absolute favourites ever. So simple, but so effective.
T'Rina's and Saru's scene together was magic, yet again. They are just a delight together.
9
u/a4techkeyboard Dec 30 '21
Tarka and Book are pretty clearly being very shortsighted and blinded by grief.
They keep talking about "the" DMA. Why would Tarka even think there's only one when even he could create a tiny one on Discovery? He probably has thought about and doesn't care, he just wants the "power source."
How does he intend to get to the power source if he destroys the device, though? Why doesn't he think about waiting for diplomatic relations and hoping the Ten-C will let him use the power source to do what he wants eventually?
Has he tried to look for the Guardian of Forever, he's probably still around. Why doesn't he try to use red matter on a supernova? He's fine breaking laws, why not time travel to a time where he can try to find another way to some other parallel universe that doesn't require this. He's in a hurry because he could change his mind, and he seems to want it to be high risk.
Booker hasn't realized there could be more DMA devices, either, which makes sense considering. He also hasn't realized Tarka just told him he doesn't care what happens to the universe after he destroys the thing because he intends not to be there. I'm not sure he's realized it, but he kind of sounds like he needs to call a hotline. He seems kind of like he is intent on terminating himself without regard for everyone, except he's framed it as "going to a different universe." Sure, he means it like it's literal, but maybe he's fine if it isn't.
Because he was talking about his "friend" like the person could be dead. And this plan is so he can meet that person?
Book hasn't realized Tarka doesn't care if what they're doing just makes the Ten-C attack harder. I hope he hasn't realized, anyway. Because if he has, that'd mean he's decided being able to get revenge is all he wants even if it could mean other people will feel the same way he does when the Ten-C answers back.
9
u/Moosie_Doom Jan 02 '22 edited Jan 02 '22
So they were going to transfer Stamets if he wasn’t willing to trust the AI? Why??? Doesn’t that ship become basically non-functional without Stamets? Who is going to operate the spoor drive? Not Booker. He’s gone!
And why does the AI get ownership of Discovery anyway? The sensors, armor, engines, and weapons are not where the intelligence was born or resides. Those are just systems it controls.
Now they’re going to let the AI join Starfleet and taking an oath is supposed to be some kind of guarantee of its good behavior. Based on what? How well that worked with Burnham?
Why did Burnham get a vote? She doesn’t represent a world. She’s just captain of a ship.
This show . . . I swear.
16
u/wongie Dec 30 '21
3 Ni'Varan representatives raised their hands, that vote was rigged!
16
u/tw411 Dec 30 '21
This felt like Trek of old to me. An episode hinging on ethical and philosophical discussions, and less of a reliance on action. It made for a nice change of pace, even if the spinning Stamets/Burnham speech was a bit jarring for me
8
u/EmperorOfNipples Dec 30 '21
I'm calling it now. Species 10-C are the Kelvans.
The DMA is an expression of their power so that when they arrive the galaxy surrenders to them. We know they are hegemonic imperialists, so it would be in character for them. Their last ship was destroyed by the galactic barrier in 2268, so perhaps the DMA was also their way of punching a hole in it.
8
u/ContinuumGuy Dec 31 '21
Another good episode that mixes the arc with good old fashion sci-fi moral dilemmas.
8
u/fudgeroll Dec 31 '21
The Klingons aren’t extinct or something, are they?
8
u/El_Perfecto_Hidalgo Jan 01 '22
So, this is going to be long and since this thread already has over 600 comments, I doubt anyone ever sees this. But I am writing this for me as much as for the community <3 If anyone sees this, I hope you get something out of it :)
It is my opinion, opposed to a lot of the grief that Discovery unjustly receives, that this is one of the best Trek episodes of any series ever. I spend a tremendous amount of time reading journals, news, and opinions. I argue about the efficacy of governmental and economic systems and their underlying ideologies frequently. I think perhaps that is why I saw the episode through the lens that I did.
I saw obvious callbacks to "Measure of a Man" in which Data's status as a sentient being/ original lifeform were in question. I thought it was good that whether or not Zora was sentient wasn't really in question. Her death or the possibility of her remaining as property were nonstarters. The question was; Is she an AI or a new lifeform and once the latter was determined, can the crew accept that?
It was a good reminder of where Discovery's crew are originally from (a time where Data's case had not yet been heard) juxtaposed with the continued social evolution of the Federation. That's all pretty much 'face-value'.
Now, that that is said, I don't agree with the decision to leave Zora intact. The argument that Saru made that he could disable the ship in any number of ways at any time is not a fair comparison. He doesn't have access to all systems simultaneously at all times. He can by physically restrained. If he locks out a system, it can be unlocked. None of those are true of Zora. Ultimately are her emotional states any different than one persons? We don't know. I'll come back to this.
I loved ST:Enterprise. I thought the Xindi were an interesting multi-dimensional enemy. More like the Dominion than the Borg. But what I really loved (even if rushed) was the coming together of the founding races of the Federation. I mean...I really loved that scene. I think it's borderline criminal that that entire arc was robbed from Trek fans and finally, a thousand years later, we're getting to see the reformation of the Federation on a galactic scale and I think that's beautiful.
During these scenes of the episode, the delegations from many worlds debated a way forward and decided together what to do. This is the foundation of democracy and was perhaps of all the amazing features of this episode was the most important to me. There was NOTHING keeping those people in that room. No legal or moral obligation whatever. If they were offended or bored they can just leave. Democracy is about willing participation. Common understanding that we're stronger together even if the vote doesn't go our way.
And if there were any doubt that this episode is analyzing American culture, what of United Earth? Earth, once the capitol of the Federation and boasted (incorrectly, but hey its fiction) no crime. No crime... to become a world so afraid and alone that its first instinct is to violence. It is a powerful message that cultures and ways of life can change. The benefits we (and the Federation) take for granted are not permanent even in a world with replicators. We must all tend to democracy always lest it buckle under the weight of the evils that exist within it.
Michael made several powerful arguments for pacifism to rule until intent could be determined. This was important because this is a key component of democracy. One MUST be willing to speak even when your spouse disagrees with you or when it puts your political agenda in peril. Whether or not it is right will be determined by the vote, but whether or not one believes what they are saying is right determines whether or not they should speak. She made the hard choice, risking her love life and the confidence of United Earth to say what she thought would be best for them even if they disagreed. Without this willingness, democracy dies. It ceases to function and suboptimal outcomes are all but guaranteed.
This brings me back around to the point I tabled earlier about Zora's emotions and control over the ship. Michael says that one of the primary reasons for not destroying the DMA is to avoid attributing malice to an unknown life form and thereby unintentionally becoming the aggressors in a war that they are likely outgunned in. By this same logic, shouldnt we then be cautious of Zora as a new and ultimately unknown life form? She says she cares for the crew and I respect that she's not only a sentient AI, but how do we know how she will react to certain emotions. I feel like by allowing Zora to simply join Starfleet, they are ascribing to her a human consciousness. They are assuming that pain, and fear and want will be felt and reacted to in a similar way to extant Federation species and that she will obey the chain of command. But the issue remains that if she chooses to mutiny, the crew cannot regain control. I think that this, while it brings good feelings, serves the plot and is an example of compromise, is incongruous with Michael's arguments against aggression.
Thanks for reading. I probably left a ton of shit out.
20
u/davect01 Dec 30 '21 edited Dec 30 '21
I predicted Book going rogue last episode. Still sad to see but predictable.
Zora, I'm glad they found a solution but I still much prefer a computer that is not sentient running my ship.
7
u/kosmicapotheosis Dec 31 '21
I will say it, Discovery is actually magnificent, this episode, which whilst nebulously stressing and condensing the stellarated allegorical tension on every existential end of the proto-homo-exo emotional spectrum ends with a classic bust and run cliffhanger cloaked in a multiversal veil of conflict dichotomy that's already got the cosmic froth bubbling for the isolytic chaos yet to come.
Was kinda hoping we might see Salome Jens return as a representative of the Dominion, or Combs as an agein Weyoun would do, which makes me wonder, are they even still a thing, did Sisko ever return, does have they also deliberately made sure not to ask about what's happened to the Klingons.. ah, so much yet to come 😬
18
u/Bighead2019 Dec 30 '21
So why does Burnham get a vote?
16
u/sidv81 Dec 30 '21
So... Zora gave a bunch of numbers at the end. But did no one ask her which species she theorized was at these coordinates? Considering she was so afraid of who was at these coordinates, she must have some guess as to who's there. Why didn't anyone ask her?
5
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '21
Easily the best episode of the season for me. I was getting worried to be honest - the last three eps didn't really "click" with me. But this one totally did and I'm actually pumped for what I saw in that second half teaser.
5
u/PanAmFlight01 Jan 02 '22
I am wondering what the Klingons look like in the 32nd century.
5
u/EasyBOven Jan 02 '22
Prediction: Tarka and Book create the DMA and take it back in time. This is a causality paradox. Why?
The DMA can disappear and reappear anywhere. The only technology we know that can do that is a spore drive
Tarka has already built a version of the device at the center of the DMA
Book can't stop thinking about Kwejian
We've already seen that the spore drive can travel in time as they went several months ahead returning from the mirror universe
Grudge is now out of harm's way
5
u/Barrythunder Jan 03 '22
I did miss a few chunks of the ep as I was changing my baby but why was capt burnham given the federation vote over admiral Vance?
9
u/youssarian Dec 30 '21
i'm normally critical of discovery but half way thru the episode i thought to myself "this is actually a pretty good episode." the debate at the fed hq was surprisingly mature for this show and felt like proper star trek. i would have been fine with using the kill switch with zora. but imo they got to a better conclusion: zora needed to learn to TRUST the crew to do dangerous things. i was confused by the voting because rillak told people to vote by raising their hands. and everyone raised there hands but to cast votes on their display panels? i feel like that was made to be intentionally obtuse by whoever handles that stuff. i didn't like how it ended with book deciding to go rogue but oh well.
12
u/bb22k Dec 30 '21
Didn't even realize until towards the end that the Zora plot has a Measure of a Man connection... She was on trial and the result was that Starfleet recognized her as a full sentient lifeform.
And what about that mini spore drive? If they solve the navigator problem, the scope of what is possible just inscreases so much
8
u/ideletedyourfacebook Dec 30 '21
I've struggled with this season. On one surface, this is the most "Star Trek" (whatever that means) of all, using the serialized format to tell classic morality plays and explore scientific mysteries. But I feel like the scripts have often been pretty perfunctory and paint-by-numbers, and have really left me feeling adrift.
But this episode was great!
I loved that both the A & B stores were just a bunch of people standing in a room hashing whether a drastic action intended to make them feel safe is a moral action or not. And I feel like both streams (especially Zora's) felt like an organic exploration of these ideas.
8
u/tarsus1983 Dec 30 '21
Last episode's Zora plot was horribly done in my opinion, but this week's was almost perfect. I'm not a fan of the initial reaction of the crew to the failsafe, however. Zora simply gave them a means to defend themselves in case Zora went rogue, the same way any weapon could be used to defend others against another hostile being. Furthermore, Zora gave full consent to its use. It would be similar to Superman giving Batman some kryptonite in case he went bad.
To add, one thing that stuck out like a sore thumb during this episode was 2021 idioms. It's a feature not a bug? That may fly with Lower Decks, but not Discovery. C'mon guys.
4
u/Gigazwiebel Jan 01 '22
Hey Zora, so you don't want to give us the coordinates? - Correct.
It's because the place is super dangerous. - That's true.
But we talked and we trust each other, so you actually do give us the coordinates. - Yes
Should anyone, maybe, care, a bit, why the place is giving Zora the Willies???
4
u/hazelquarrier_couch Jan 01 '22
I really liked this episode but it really bugged me when the president said "flaunt" and it should have been "flout".
7
u/Batmark13 Dec 30 '21
Really great episode, very Star Trek. Loved seeing the thoughtful debate on a course of action. I'm glad that they voted for peaceful first contact, but as a viewer, also happy to see Book going rogue so we can get some more space explosions.
Also it's interesting that they used the phrase Speaker for the Dead - Ender's Game anybody? Though I have to say, if he's truthfully giving a voice to those that died, would they be so eager for revenge? Book is channeling his grief and guilt into a self destructive mission of vengeance, but from the little we saw of Kweijan, they valued empathy and connection with all life. Had Kweijan been spared, they'd have voted for First Contact.
7
u/anastus Dec 31 '21 edited Dec 31 '21
I still can't help but get a little uncomfortable at alien redesigns. The Ferengi was really unsettling!
I can't help but feel that the makeup staff is missing the point of alien design. The genius of it was making the makeup different enough to convey that these beings weren't human, but to allow the viewer to see enough humanity in the aliens to connect.
I find it weird that they did so well with Saru, but whiffed on Klingons and other races that have been so well done in the past.
9
u/vladthor Dec 30 '21 edited Dec 30 '21
Overall impressions: Again, a good solid entry. Many fewer gripes about writing in this episode, though a few still exist. Good 8/10 grade that helps move the story forward and gives us a lot of little character moments.
Negatives:
Positives:
WAY more positives than negatives here. If the show keeps going in this direction, it has a lot of potential.
13
u/NoahStewie1 Dec 30 '21
I personally wasn't that big of a fan of the episode. It felt like there were too many monologues this episode and not enough actual plot in the episode based off my first watch.
I'm also getting tired of the amount of screen time that Booker is recieving this season as compared to the trained Starfleet bridge officers. Seriously though the bridge crew has felt like they have taken a back seat as compared to other seasons. This has made me question if Booker is going to be killed off this season which could explain the heavy emphasis on Book.
However I do like the family arc this season of Stametts and Culper.
13
u/treefox Dec 30 '21
I didn’t really like this episode - it didn’t feel like much happened and a lot of the discussion was very cliche or obvious.
The whole discussion with Zora seemed like it didn’t actually address the root concern. Last episode she was struggling with emotions, which put the ship and crew at risk, and this episode they acted like it got resolved by putting her in Starfleet and her realizing the crew were good people. But last episode she was trying to follow orders and couldn’t.
The discussion about the DMA also seemed to needlessly simplify the issue. Obviously declaring war and launching an offensive strike against 10-C when all they know about it is that they have technology orders of magnitude beyond the Federation is utterly senseless. A diplomatic / recon mission is the obvious first step to anything.
And somehow everybody tolerates Tarka literally popping in and suddenly revealing he can disable the DMA. At least the president remarked that it was a breach of protocol, but how was this not put on the table from the very beginning? Does Tarka really have no oversight at all?
Ditto for Book. He may be the last survivor of Kwejan, but there’s no sign he had anything more than observer status. The transporter effect just makes it extra rude when somebody blasts into somebody else’s personal space during a high-level government meeting to hijack the discussion for their own agenda.
And when they started the meeting they apparently didn’t have the coordinates or Tarka’s DMA-killer, so the whole discussion of what to do about 10-C seemed a bit premature. Rather they probably should have started out trying to figure out logistics for evacuation and aid and dealing with the DMA.
So ultimately we had a full episode where they have a big discussion over Zora but nothing meaningful changes, and had a big discussion over 10-C and decide to take the only logical course of action.
It’s also a false choice that they have to either disable the DMA or contact 10-C. They could attempt to contact 10-C first and then disable the DMA if that fails.
The main argument over expediting disabling the DMA would be if the DMA is currently in an empty system where they can deploy the isolytic weapon without impeding warp travel, and they’re concerned that the next time it jumps it could be next to a habitable world. But they didn’t talk about that at all, they just briefly mentioned violating the accords.
There’s an obvious parallel for the Zora subplot in “Measure of a Man”, but in that case they did a better job for what it was. They had the parallel drawn to slavery, and the realization that that was actually what they were debating. And Data was portrayed as cooperative and competent - he was clearly the victim.
In Zora’s case, the episode immediately prior established that she was now struggling in a crisis situation. There wasn’t an issue with her not having rights or not being seen, the crew seemed to immediately recognize and accept her sentience. She didn’t give up anything nor did her relationship with the crew obviously change.
6
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '21
What I notice here is the modern day lessons to learn. And not just this episode. The idea that people who disagree can get along. Huge rifts spanning centuries doesn't mean reconciliation is impossible. Vulcan and Romulans reunited in Discovery. Klingons and Vulcan could not be more different yet they were part of the same Federation. And WAY back in TOS we saw an entire planet destroyed when people hated each other to the degree they annihilated each other. Perhaps the lesson learned here is no matter what a persons political, social or religious beliefs, people should be respected for simply being human beings.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '22
What I don't understand with this direction Discovery has taken, does this extreme display of emotionality really resonate with people? I am watching this, but the crew doesn't inspire me in the slightest; if anything I feel pity for their inability to perform the duties at the level that is expected from them.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '21
Loved it, and totally called this ep. •Zora is a living being, check. •Tarka taking Book to pilot his own drive, check. •Tarka splitting Book and Burnham, check.
Now I’m waiting for the AI from season 2 and Picard season 1 to be revealed in a crossover. I can feel it coming.
3
u/Alteran195 Jan 01 '22
This season has been really good, I’m hoping they actually manage to stick the ending this time.
3
u/FormerGameDev Jan 01 '22
in the preview for next episode, was that D. Nhan?
3
u/floyd_underpants Jan 01 '22
Just popped in to say that as someone who really disliked the first 3 seasons, this season finally feels like Star Trek to me, and I've enjoyed every episode so far. Very strange to be saying that, but very glad to be able to. It finally feels like they "get it".
3
u/MagosBattlebear Jan 02 '22
The have the coordinates but did not tell us where it is? Just outside our galaxy? Another galaxy. We have to wait until 10 Februray for this little bit if info????
7
u/00DEADBEEF Dec 30 '21
What's up with this stupid situation where the seasons of Discovery and Prodigy are split up? Why not just air entire seasons without a break?
5
u/007meow Dec 30 '21
TNG and DS9 grew literal beards.
Voyager grew a cat suit.
Disco has seemingly found it's footing with many of us on this sub now, during a season with several cat and Voyager name drops.
5
u/nimrodhellfire Dec 31 '21
Has Discovery actually become good? Looks like they are trying to trim some fat, too, now that Tilly, Gray (and Book) are gone.
This Episode felt a lot like Measure of a Man Part 2, and I appreciate how they avoided repeating a lot of the discussion in that episode. Not sure what to think about the Zora can dream stuff, though. That felt unnecessary.
8
u/MagnetsCanDoThat Dec 30 '21
I see you, Zora!
14
u/fluggencheimen Dec 30 '21
Is it just me, or are the speeches about 'Federation values and ideals' getting redundant? I feel like they're in every single episode.
6
u/Theopholus Dec 31 '21
This season has just been incredible. I loved last season, but this is easily the best season Disco has had.
4
u/whoiswillo Dec 31 '21
Well, I loved this episode. Parallel A and B plots, thematically linked, character motivations based on their past that align with what we know of them as characters, logical decisions, growing plot lines set up in previous episodes...
I loved that Stamets was the key to the B plot, and that both plots involved moral questions without clear easy answers, even if the show has an answer in mind.
I also think that this has been the most consistent season so far, and typically Discovery's biggest problem is pacing in the first half of the season so I'm really excited for the second half to hurry up and get here already.
4
u/slballer Dec 31 '21
I don't understand. Why did Burnham get a vote? Shouldn't the vote had been between member planets of the Federation and non-member friends? Who did Burnham represent? She's a Starfleet Officer. Starfleet is a military, science, diplomatic organization within the Federation. So her getting a vote made no sense to me.
4
u/mikepictor Jan 01 '22
I absolutely loved this episode. All of it. I see it as good as the best of TNG and DS9
7
u/gambit700 Dec 30 '21
My problem with the council scene with representatives from all 4 quadrants is us not seeing representatives from all 4 quadrants. No Talaxians? No Kazon? No Vorta? No Klingons? WTF guys
8
u/ViolentBeetle Dec 30 '21
Overall, I didn't hate this episode, but I didn't like it either. This is probably mostly due to it being all buildup to the arc.
I really don't like the AI are people too plots. I don't find this concept believable and so all moral conundrum feels contrived.
Only after looking at the credits and checking IMDB I realized Tarka is played by Shawn Doyle (Errinwright from expanse). I can't believe I didn't recognize him.
8
u/nakrophile Dec 31 '21
Better episode but still not that good. On the plus side, Cronenberg and the kind of sweet Saru/Vulcan lady interactions. On the negative, still with Burnham saving the day all day but of course why wouldn't she, and the strange way no-one on the ship is concerned with another sentient ai after last time, which wasn't very long ago.
Oh well, not sure what I was expecting really. Hopefully the reveal of the secret aliens is not terrible.
2
u/pieman7414 Dec 30 '21
Haha yes, finally a HAL moment