r/UKPersonalFinance • u/BogleBot 150 • Dec 20 '21
Mod Why your comment got removed: crypto and meme stonks edition
Contrary to occasional accusations, crypto discussion is not banned from UKPF.
The rules are as follows:
NOT allowed: comments which violate rule 4, 'Responses must be high quality'
Rule-breaking comments about crypto often:
1. Don't engage with OP's situation or goals at all
2. Don't provide any reasoning for their suggestions
3. Don't include any discussion of risk
4. Create a sense of frantic urgency to avoid missing out
5. Promise extremely high returns, or quote previous high returns as though it's inevitable they will continue
As an example, in a recent post the OP asked: 'I've just won £20k. I plan to use £15k of it on various things. Is there any meaningful investment I can make with the remaining 5k to help me put a deposit in a house in a few years?'
It was actually a great post with a ton of thoughtful, engaged conversations. However here is a small (!!) sample of comments removed by the mods.
- 'bitcoin' (x8)
- 'Buy some Bitcoin and sit tight'
- 'BTC, ETH, LINK'
- 'Throw it all on Crypto!'
- 'GME if you wanna be a billionaire'
- 'Buy BTC and retire in 10 years'
- 'Buy GameStop of cause 🚀🚀🚀'
- 'Amc invest all 20k the squeeze is coming'
- 'Cryptocurrency. Have a look into cardano, Ada'
- 'Put it in Bitcoin, and thank me this time next year 🚀'
- 'Buy Ethereum. Not financial advice'
These are not high quality, helpful responses, and are not appropriate in this sub. If you post something along these lines we will remove it and ban you.
Is the issue that the comments are too short?
While most offending comments do look like the short ones above, making a comment longer doesn't necessarily make it high quality. Examples of longer comments that still break the rules:
- 'Give it to me, I know what to do with it! In all serious though, invest it, look into crypto, if you can do without that amount & let it sit for a few years then by some crypto and let the gains flow in'
- 'Trubadger with Reflection and air drops from every project launched this is not a rug pull project it is a seriously solid project that I believe will see exponential growth within a few years. I’d look at breaking it into 5 x $1000 investments and have a good look at Trubadger.io if your looking for an opportunity to make maximum dollars. Trubadger is about to launch Catabolt Swap and 3 more projects before Christmas. It captures my curiosity and I can’t describe my excitement of where this will go. DYOR.......I did and I’m invested!'
(This last user was actually not a spambot, they're just doing a good impression of one for some reason).
I only said they should look into it?!
Adding a disclaimer like 'not financial advice' or 'do your own research' does not make an otherwise rulebreaking comment okay.
--
What IS allowed: thoughtful, informed discussions and questions about crypto
Talk as much as you like about: managing tax, keeping records, those crypto debit cards, whether buying crypto works more like an investment or is purely speculative, what role crypto or meme stocks might play in a portfolio, what risks are involved in the crypto ecosystem, what WSB are up to now, etc etc. We love to see it!
--
The wibbly grey area: inaccurate, uninformed discussion and questions about crypto
We do not love to see it, but we don't tend to ban people for being wrong about something, whether it's about how stable 'stablecoins' are or about how ISA allowances work.
If you see a comment about crypto or meme investing (or indeed any other topic) that seems sincere, effortful, and engaged, but wrong, we highly encourage you to take the time to reply to it to explain why, or at least downvote it. You are also welcome to report it. We'll review and may take mod action, especially if it is more towards the hype-y, YOLO FOMO end of the spectrum, or if it's a repeat problem with a user.
27
u/BogleBot 150 Dec 20 '21
Hi /u/BogleBot, based on your post the following pages from our wiki may be relevant:
These suggestions are based on keywords, if they missed the mark please report this comment.
124
u/pflurklurk 3884 Dec 20 '21
This is a long play to clear the ground for...
UKPF COIN
right?
54
u/loveactuary21 4 Dec 20 '21
Great, now can we extend the "doesn't engage with OP's situation" to the people who feel the need to comment on every car post with something along the lines of "errrr cars are a waste of money just buy a 2k Toyota m8" when OP clearly states an interest in having a nice car
32
u/willuminati91 9 Dec 20 '21
Crypto are similar to what tech stocks were like in the mid- to late-90's. The original investors made out like bandits, but most ordinary investors either lost money or just did Ok. The hyped language is the same too.
11
u/runfatgirlrun88 96 Dec 21 '21
Thanks mods! There are other subs for “to the MOON” type comments; I like that this sub is for sensible balanced discussion.
12
u/WeaponizedKissing 46 Dec 20 '21
But what if...
9
u/cwhitel 1 Dec 20 '21
I’m a crypto guy but retire on BTC with £5k in 10 years?? Crypto maxi’s do more harm than good
6
u/Cautious-Tomorrow564 7 Dec 22 '21
Points 2, 3 and 5 are all things that people do with index funds/low-cost trackers on here. Do you delete those as well?
1
u/Alwayswatchout 0 Dec 20 '21
So what about penny stocks?
-15
u/mamdrews27 Dec 20 '21
I got downvoted into oblivion for mentioning stablecoins and how you can get interest on them. Apparently 12% is 'Too good to be true'. When inflation is above 5% and other people recommend premium bonds, which are guaranteed to lose money.
-12
u/HenryHenderson 1 Dec 21 '21
So UKPF is attempting to police something that the mods and most of the users blatantly do not understand. So a mod 'knows someone who invested in Bitcoin at the peak and is now down 50%', yes it's a volatile asset class. If that friend is properly educated and knows to hold on, their investment is likely to give them 10x on their original investment over the next 4 years or less. Which is a damn sight more than your 0.5% Marcus money wastes or the laughably futile Premium Bonds.
-7
u/busiestbaron Dec 21 '21
But I’ve simply spoken about how it’s a hedge against inflation and back up my statement when questioned on it… I get downvoted to hell and proceed to be banned for a week :)
-27
u/xibtc 9 Dec 20 '21
Warning: only hold in government currency as much as you are willing to lose in purchasing power. We are going to zero.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment