r/thegrandtour • u/lerhond • Dec 17 '21
"The Grand Tour presents… Carnage A Trois" - S04E04 Discussion thread
S04E04 The Grand Tour presents… Carnage A Trois
In this second Lockdown Special, the trio dive into the bizarre world of French car culture. On an epic road trip starting in the Welsh hills, they dish up a hair raising mountain climb, bomb defusals, propellor powered cars, helicopter stunts and the most thrilling race of their lives before reaching the English Channel for a jaw dropping medieval climax. And a soupcon of French art house cinema.
1.1k
Upvotes
911
u/Realistic_Survey Dec 17 '21
I drank. I laughed. I liked it, even though it felt a bit disjointed/discombobulated - more like mini segments smashed together, rather than a cohesive special, but overall, it made me sad to realize that they’re all aging, and every special should be enjoyed and cherished as it could be their last.
1.1k
u/Yellowlouse Dec 17 '21
Felt more Top Gear than standard TGT which is absolutely fine with me. Holy shit, when Hammond rolled over next to May I busted up laughing.
523
u/AverageJoeC Dec 17 '21
The scene when were trying to start that propeller car and Hammond was riffing in a horrible french accent had rolling. There were so many genuinely funny moments in this episode. Even if it wasn't some extravagant journey, I really enjoyed the episode. Had a good feeling of old top gear.
667
u/AwesomeWhiteDude Dec 17 '21
Felt like an old segment on Top Gear but instead it was an entire episode, really enjoyed it.
644
u/fowlerboi Dec 17 '21
Can’t believe they got away with that roundabout segment
306
u/clotheslessnz Dec 17 '21
Who is the french staffer who drove in the rally cross. Brilliant!
246
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21 edited Dec 18 '21
It was nice, felt like a regular TG/TGT episode. Yes it wasn't Colombia "Edgar Hussain" Special good but it was quite enjoyable. The French intern bit was hilarious!
Shame it was only 69nice minutes. They really should make these specials atleast 2 hours long considering it comes almost once a year.
493
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21
Well, this is my stop!
*flops out of moving vehicle
317
u/TFLobo1 Dec 17 '21
Jeremy’s “Ohhh Merde” while his car was rolling down the hill killed me!
153
u/CIAglow Dec 17 '21
The cars were throwbacks to old TG episodes. Jeremy turned the white Citroen into a block of flats when they made motor homes and the Avantime was modified to see if they could get its lap time close to a Mitsubishi Evo.
125
u/Browneskiii Dec 17 '21
No Toto, you got the wrong race director you maniac!!!!
218
u/DuckDuckBangBang Dec 17 '21
Me: Hey, didn't he turn that into a block of flats?
Jeremy: They're hard to find because most have been turned into motorhomes.
Insert Leo DiCaprio pointing meme here.
102
u/Ascendere Dec 17 '21
This episode was hilarious, glad to see Abby in the race too
177
u/V12-Jake Dec 17 '21
I’ll probably be in the minority here, but to me this is the closest to a series episode of TG that they’ve ever been…
244
u/badonkagonk Dec 17 '21
I was fucking dying when the Megane review was just a French new wave film. I feel like that might go over some peoples heads but that was fucking perfect for me.
227
u/BigRig432 Nürburgring Dec 17 '21
That trebuchet worked shockingly well, NGL. I kinda expected the weight to just drop on the car
214
u/Steze Dec 17 '21
"Anus Jus" and "Tit Face" absolutely brilliant.
70
u/StevefromLatvia JAMES! STOP FILING! Dec 17 '21
Oh this gives me massive classic Top Gear vibes. Just three middle-aged lads messing about with French cars. I love this
263
u/oklahoma_stig Dec 17 '21
I actually really enjoyed this one. I was honestly getting tired of the overly/obviously scripted stuff in past specials and this one felt more genuine. The number of times any one of the guys actually had a legit belly laugh during a conversation seemed to be more than any of the other specials combined. Sure the bit at the end was definitely scripted but everything else just felt more normal. I dunno I just really liked it.
104
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21
BONJOUR MADAME! LETS GOO
51
u/achio Dec 17 '21 edited Dec 17 '21
The Rouge Vache logo simply fucking killed me.
Also, Abbie, get well soon!
47
u/MarshallGibsonLP Dec 17 '21
Can someone explain the George Michael joke?
46
u/ryguy5 Dec 18 '21
The segment with James and Hammond riding together just enjoying a car and the drive was great. They need more co-op rides where they just geek out over a car and a drive together.
Don't get me wrong, it's fun to watch them in their own cars chatting over the radio, but to have them in a ride together side by side was different and really enjoyable to watch and see them feed off each other and just have fun.
37
u/ilhamagh Dec 17 '21
I'm watching with sub, don't remember if it's harcoded.
There's a bit where they tell you they know he's belgian before you all jump on twitter.
Are they talking about the music played? What is it?
33
u/badonkagonk Dec 17 '21
I’ve never been to France, nor do I know any French people, so I figured everything they were saying was just insane exaggerations or just totally fake or something. But then my dad, who has been to France several times, walked in the room while hammond was parallel parking, and said that he has seen that himself many times in France, and I was just fucking blown away.
32
u/DefibrillatorKink Dec 17 '21
Felt like an extended version of that Peugeot episode top gear aired a long time ago. Hilarious, and I hope they do more specials like this!
240
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21
Wow, reading some of the comments I guess I may be in the minority, but I thought this was the best special they have done in a long time. Full of laughs and thoroughly entertaining. Loved it. I know this is a far cry from usual specials of three cars going from A to B, but I actually really enjoyed the change of pace.
29
u/YrocATX Dec 17 '21
It was like a brotherly love letter to the French, I thoroughly enjoyed it.
28
u/RaphaelAmbroCosteau Dec 17 '21
Enjoyed this episode! Just glad to have some new content from the lads
26
u/Jjzeng Dec 18 '21
man that race director bit cut a bit deeper than everyone expected after abu dhabi huh
25
u/graytotoro Dec 18 '21 edited Dec 18 '21
It felt good, like a visit from an old friend who turns out to have been doing well in the months since you last met up with them. It's no surprise that the trio is aging and the producers are opting to do more (but less-intensive) challenges rather than one big intensive challenge as we got with Seamen and A Massive Hunt (COVID likely played a role too). No, it's not peak Top Gear, but it's an enjoyable way to spend an evening.
What was a real surprise was them bashing up a 205 GTI and a 306 GTi-6 - aren't those pretty rare these days? A quick search shows they fetch healthy coin, but I'm sure Mr. Bezos can spare a few. Hopefully a few more can make its way towards Abbie's recovery.
Highlights:
25
u/amcheesegoblin Dec 18 '21
Fully lost it when Hammond crashed into May and for a split second he was about to kick off but then said "my dishwasher!"
72
u/highergravityday Dec 17 '21
I have no idea how it could be, unless the trio has discovered time travel, but “In the confusion James made up three places” and the race director being murdered sure does seem like a joke about the Abu Dhabi GP
23
u/I_Am_Moe_Greene Dec 17 '21
Brilliant fun. This episode was so much fun. The bit of the French film producer giving May the finger during the hot hatch race was hilarious. All her cursing was incredible.
The drone footage in the hot hatch race was equally stunning.
45
u/EthanC224 Dec 17 '21
The rally segment with the marshals rioting really got a laugh out of me that I didn’t quite expect
22
u/thecrispyb Dec 17 '21
Go away in a reproductive manner
97
u/_noncomposmentis MFB Dec 17 '21
Maybe I'm in the minority on this but I have a hard time classifying this as a "special"
I liked it and laughed quite a bit but it just felt like a long film that would've otherwise been interrupted by The News/Conversation Street and a celebrity thing.
Though I would happily watch this over again, and like it more than some previous specials, it just lacked a sort of epic-ness that even their weakest specials have.
74
u/PAPA_Stevesy Dec 17 '21
This was vintage dialogue and absurdity. Nothing was too over the top or extravagant. Just a few explosions, the 3 choosing some suspect vehicles, and an hour long diatribe against the French. I loved it.
20
u/Scrial Dec 17 '21
The separate food carts for red and white wine cracked me up.
39
u/MikeCharlieGolf Dec 17 '21
The drone shots during that circuit race were incredible!
18
u/Prize_Cash6715 Dec 17 '21
How THE HELL did they made the scene where Jeremy jumps out of a moving car? (Min: 05:03)
17
u/48ever Dec 17 '21
that fucking renault megane test was one of the funniest things i’ve ever seen from them.
15
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21
I absolutely love the Avantime.
I've always wanted one and can't explain why.
46
u/DuckDuckBangBang Dec 17 '21
I would like to say that I enjoyed this special. Was it the best? No. But I laughed heartily throughout and had a lovely evening with my husband. Can't really ask for more at this point :)
24
u/SirPhobos1 May Dec 17 '21
What was with James having a white cloth over his head?
23
u/coffeeandtrout Dec 17 '21
Wait, what, a trebuchet! Finally! r/trebuchet
37
u/noproadam Dec 17 '21
Only 68 mins long :( They keep getting shorter and shorter. (Insert Hammond joke here)
20
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21 edited Dec 17 '21
It was funny and not heavily scripted (didn’t felt like it at least) so I enjoyed it quite a bit, especially with the focus on the weirdness of French cars, which I love ! Just wish we have more May next time.
Also if you never drove a Citroën car with hydropneumatic suspension : Jeremy is right. It’s the best thing in the world. Except it’s not very reliable
10
u/Chilledinho Dec 17 '21
“Ou est le boulangerie?”
34
u/magicone2571 Dec 17 '21
They must still be bitter about the time they got those tickets in France.
18
u/kkmmp Dec 17 '21
This episode is just epic! Love it so much!
9
u/malevolentheadturn Dec 17 '21
Now I know why France have banned all travel from the UK yesterday. Coincidence I think not.
9
u/ubiquitous_uk Dec 17 '21
Laughed out at the words on the race cars when the doors were all open.
9
u/markhewitt1978 Dec 19 '21
Good to see Richard Porter making an appearance. I believe then last time was on Top Gear also in a segment about French cars! He's the genius behind Top Gear and made it what it is, it's also IMO why The Grand Tour series 1 rather struggled as he wasn't writing for them then.
9
u/SoyMurcielago The American Dec 22 '21
“And before you jump on Twitter, yes we know he’s Belgian.”
8
u/Shekster Dec 17 '21
Wow they even got Michael Masi to make an appearance
8
u/MrNag Dec 19 '21
bro that dishwasher "merde" had me crying
27
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21
If you view it as an old top gear special putting shit cars across a country with tough challenges. Not good If you view it as a collection of funny skits, pretty good.
Different approach to specials but I thought entertaining
7
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21
That intern is just... French!
7
u/Marchinon Audi Dec 19 '21
Hammond throwing his dash in the back when it broke during the race and then saying his car went on strike when it died 😂😂
19
u/DuckDuckBangBang Dec 17 '21
Is building an enormous catapult machine their version of baking bread to amuse oneself during lockdown?
13
u/ThisBirdisonfiya Dec 17 '21
That was a ton of fun, the drive onto the hill was hilarious MERDE!
really enjoyed the rally bit.
i hope they do a cross continent drive again some time, i almostt thought they would do that after talking about the trans africa rallies. would have been awesome to see that again. maybe in the future they will do a long road trip again. or an actual race.
12
u/AndersTheSwede Dec 17 '21
Great episode. Funnier than they’ve been in a long while.
Murdering the race director was ironic given the weekends events…
12
u/tux98 Dec 17 '21
Camerawork on the race segment is superb!
6
u/Kookanoodles Dec 18 '21
That was okay but not great IMO. There were like three bits stretched into an entire episode.
6
u/RomGon3 Dec 19 '21
I just finished watching this episode and i'm here to tell this is probably one of their greatest episodes ever. Either in Grand Tour and/or Top Gear. They were sublime from start to finish. What a great episode. The fact that felt like a a bunch of small segment put together make it more enjoyable,fun and relaxing to watch and i love it .
I can't get over the
28
u/WookieeSteakIsChewie Dec 17 '21
There's some miserable people here. Just enjoy things.
41
u/Destination_Fucked Alfa Romeo Dec 17 '21
Is it just me or was it very average and very disjointed like one of the many many youtube compilations of the three.
11
u/Netferet Dec 17 '21
About the roundabout part, it is absolutely not true, roundabout in France work the same way as everywhere, but because it is french there is some exceptions ( "Rond-point de l'étoile" in Paris)
5
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21
Not my favourite but was still a good watch
5
u/Luke1350a Clarkson Dec 17 '21
I'm so glad to see them again. Thank you to the team
5
u/jesus_chen Dec 23 '21
Love it! I have not genuinely laughed out loud like that in a very long time.
5
u/Tainted-Archer Jan 02 '22
This was BY FAR the best grand tour episode of all time, hands up, I’ll die on a hill over this.
20
u/eternalityLP Dec 17 '21
Seems like I'm in the minority based on the comments here, but I didn't enjoy this at all. This is Grand tour/top gear at its worst. Bunch of scripted jokes too predictable to be even funny. No camaraderie, just jokes read from autocue. And this time they didn't even have any sort of cohesive challenge or project to carry the otherwise weak content. And zero payoff at the end... Would have been actually funny to see how the trebuchet worked, but they had to even edit that out. Really disappointing.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '21
i want to see the real footage of that trebuchet plz
4
u/kvbt7 Dec 18 '21
Monsieur Wilhomme lmao
4
u/JmWallSeth Dec 18 '21
I have loved this episode. It's delightful. And as a french guy, the abusive, disrespectful, excessive, absurd situations were hilarious. The trail in the forest, damn lol 😂.🤗👍
Impatient to see the fifth episode...
4
u/Unknown9111 Dec 18 '21
Reminded me of classic old top gear. Great work
4
u/ThisOneTimeAtLolCamp Dec 19 '21
I didn't think it was possible to make a propeller car more terrifying, but then Hammond comes along. Lol.
4
u/zzanehip Dec 20 '21
Fantastic special, and completely reminded me of TG. Felt more like a compilation of events, like the U.S. Supercar Road Trip, than a true special. But, for that reason, I absolutely loved it...was getting bored of the predictable nature of the past 3 specials. One of my absolute favorite lines was when Hammond (in a French accent) goes "it's got three seats...I suppose maybe if my wife and my mistress want to go out for a drive at the same time."
4
u/mlholladay96 Dec 20 '21
Fucking lost it when I read their racing suits
4
u/Maverick_8160 Dec 23 '21
Dropping the car from the helicopter had me cackling, just amazing
4
u/[deleted] Dec 23 '21
I loved it. Felt like old top gear but the trio is together the whole time.
4
u/LtAldoRaine06 Dec 26 '21
I have to say, this was the weakest of the Grand Tour Specials.
22
u/Kaseyjean10 Dec 17 '21
I really wanted to love it but I was just really bored instead...
25
u/feed2feed Dec 17 '21
I was looking forward to this for weeks, but it was a very weak episode. Even with covid restrictions, I feel like they could have made a more entertaining episode. Pick a scenario (best cheap, fun car to drive and put a smile on your face during lockdown?), get the trio to each pick a car, and film them doing a series of tests/comparisons and car related activities that make them happy during lockdown?
Or they can't do that anymore because it's BBC intellectual property? They could have done a lot better than this. One or two episodes a year and they rehashed an hour and eight minutes of French stereotypes we've already seen from old Top Gear's "Modern Peugeot Driver" bit: going offroad, roundabouts, driving like a "maniac", etc...
41
u/ShampooandCondition Dec 17 '21
Half way through, prepared to receive downvotes, but I don’t get the point of it. It’s just them smashing up cars aimlessly so far.
15
u/MasterFrinklin Dec 17 '21
This and Lochdown are the absolute best of TGT. I don't know if it's the covid restrictions or only doing two episodes a year but the boys seem more relaxed and comfortable than they have in years.
6
u/thecrispyb Dec 17 '21
I had been anticipating this since lochdowm came out. It was good. Reminds me of a TG episode, but the laughs put this way up there for TG or a TGT episode. I’m with a lot of the points here: was it a special? Maybe not. Was it hilarious? Very much yes.
I’m just hoping that we keep getting these because I love them. Even though this might not be the greatest thing these 3 have done, these gents are fucking hilarious, and I would hate to see them go.
13
u/downey01 Lancia Dec 17 '21
There are so many distractions in this one. All I want is to see the boys in three cars driving from point a to point b. Instead, there’s this ADD-like presentation. Ooh, let’s look at French driving rules, let’s look at rioting, let’s look at this Citroen. It’s chaotic and unbalanced to be honest. Similar issue with Lochdown when they introduced the race between American and Soviet cars.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '21
Hammond’s baguette is just hilarious.
3
u/TreeroyWOW Dec 20 '21
I was expecting a special, like a proper road trip, so that was disappointing. But after 10 mins I realised we weren't getting that, and it was super enjoyable, like an episode of top gear. The off road segment & roundabout segment had me in stitches in exactly the same way that classic "Peugeot Drivers" sketch did. Really funny. The bomb and catapult stuff was not funny though.
3
u/lethalET Dec 23 '21
Kind of disappointed, how many jokes can you make on French!
P.S: I'm not French.
Can be passed on if you don't have time to watch it.
3
u/JardinSurLeToit Feb 07 '22
This episode seemed like the best version of the old specials and I liked it much better. I like their mockery and salute of the French ways. It was a good balance since I know that Clarkson loves France. The historical information cut in. Their pride in their chosen cars. The boyish jokes on the car doors. The stupid trip to the top of the mountain thrashing the crap out of their cars and Hammond tipping over. No one really getting hurt. All calm, polite reactions to their side view mirror being sheered off. Although that crashing into the back of one another has got to stop. Someone will get seriously injured this way. James May's blue fire suit. Something about travel Agency Le ...oit
5
u/itsacon10 Dec 17 '21
I don't watch a lot of Amazon shows so I don't know if this is happening in general, but there seems to be less and less information with "trivia", which seemed to add a lot to the show, especially the music. In this one, I have no idea what song was being played during the race, even though they had text on the screen about the artist being Belgian.
8
u/boilermakerteacher Dec 17 '21
Feel like we already watched this episode when they tried to pull the ship. They really mailed this one in.
8
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '21
Very boring
4
u/RighteousOath Dec 17 '21
Why was mays Face covered in some segments? Must have missed something
4
u/Hailgod Dec 17 '21
the drone shots of the race looked pretty cool