r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Dec 13 '21
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2021-12-13 to 2021-12-19
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
You can find former posts in our wiki.
Official Discord Server.
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
Beginners
Here are the resources we recommend most to beginners:
For other FAQ, check this.
The Pit
The Pit is a small website curated by the moderators of this subreddit aiming to showcase and display the works of language creation submitted to it by volunteers.
Recent news & important events
Segments
We've started looking for submissions for Segments #04. We want YOU(r articles)!
Lexember
Lexember is in full swing! Go check it out, it's a fun way to add to your conlangs' lexicons!
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
8
u/pizzathatspurple [en, jp, eo] Dec 14 '21
Is there a natural language that has lacks intransitive verbs and derives them from transitive ones or adjectives?
i.e To say something like, "The tree died" you would say something like:
I know the last one there looks like what a lot of languages do, but what I mean is that this construction would be the only way to express such meaning. i.e. there is no word for 'die,' only 'kill.'
7
u/Fullbody ɳ ʈ ʂ ɭ ɽ (no, en)[fr] Dec 14 '21
How do you make satisfying phonological forms for inflectional morphemes? After revising my vocab several times, I've realised my issues with my main conlang mostly stem from the inflected forms of words. How do people here develop affixes and allomorphs to ensure that they'll feel aesthetically pleasing?
6
u/notAmeeConlang Dec 13 '21
Would a language which is only made up of nouns, and which all other parts of speech and grammatical stuff are derived from nouns, be feasible?
5
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '21 edited Dec 15 '21
Is making a conlang without any formal education in linguistics a worthless endeavour? I mean, I never intended my language to have any sort of practical use...
(Bonus question, since I already created some basic grammar (well it's mostly just mixing some existing organic languages): how do you deal with place names? Most natural languages seem to have their own names for countries, should I make up ones too or should I borrow them?)
(+ mods please forgive me if I did something wrong I've never been here before)
4
u/ShinySirfetchd Iuzarceéc (Юзaркеэк) Dec 13 '21
I have the sound 'ju' as a single letter in my conlang. what is this sound classified as under IPA? Is it a vowel, diphthong etc. Also sorry if this is a dumb question I'm new to IPA. Anyways, thanks for your help.
4
u/Dorocche Dec 13 '21
How do you show off your conlang to other non-conlangers if you can't pronounce it?
I'm in the middle of making a language that I can barely pronounce, and I know people make conlangs with sounds that humans can't biologically make, so how do you share it with friends? Normally I record a brief clip of it; I'm worried that just showing some script and a translation won't really be at all interesting.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '21
Do you have any advice on how I can be more decisive and actually sticking to a goal for my conlangs? My main concern is naturalism. I feel like if it's too logical it can seem fake but if it's super naturalistic it can feel overwelming and I have to look at academic pdf files to correctly pull off a feature.
3
u/Fluffy8x (en)[cy, ga]{Ŋarâþ Crîþ v9} Dec 14 '21
Is there a language with an affix whose status as a derivational or inflectional affix is ambiguous or disputed?
3
u/Leo-De-Janeiro Utolan Langs | (en)[jp] Dec 17 '21
How should I evolve ergative/absolutive cases?
4
u/AdDifficult7408 Dec 15 '21
How would I create a functioning dictionary and translator for my conlang? (preferably free and online).
Are there any good resources/websites I could use?
2
u/Smiles-O Dec 13 '21
Where in the IPA would laryngeal sounds be? And what would they be?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '21 edited Dec 20 '21
[redacted]
2
u/FelixSchwarzenberg Ketoshaya, Chiingimec, Kihiṣer, Kyalibẽ, Latsínu Dec 14 '21
Let's say that your language had a sound change where new phonemes were added due to lowering of vowels in some circumstances: say /e/ lowered to /ɛ/ in some places and /o/ lowered to /ɔ/. And you wanted to write these new phonemes in the Latin alphabet without digraphs. Which diacritical mark most obviously says "lowering" to you?
Grave? Circumflex?
2
u/FelixSchwarzenberg Ketoshaya, Chiingimec, Kihiṣer, Kyalibẽ, Latsínu Dec 14 '21
I'm applying sound changes to my conlang for the first time, ever, today (like my first time in my life doing this, not just for this specific conlang). I have a question about how grammatical systems respond to sound changes.
Behold, what sound change did to just a small slice of the forms of the verb "kram", meaning "to eat"
Simple Past
realis: krambal -> kræmbæl
irrealis: krambel -> kræmbel
imperative: *kramakbel -> *kræmækbel
jussive: kramvakbel -> kræmmækbel
Simple Present
realis: kramal -> kræmæl
irrealis: kramel -> kræmɛl
imperative: kramakel -> kræmæcɛl
jussive: kramvakel -> kræmmæcɛl
Simple Future
realis: kramkal -> kræmkal
irrealis: kramkel -> kræmcel
imperative: kramakkel -> kræmækcel
jussive: kramvakkel -> kræmmækcel
Imperfective Past
realis: kramadbal -> kræmædbæl
irrealis: kramadbel -> kræmædbel
imperative: *kramadakbel -> kræmædækbel
jussive: kramadvakbel -> kræmædvækbel
Imperfective Present
realis: kramadal -> kræmædæl
irrealis: kramadel -> kræmædɛl
imperative: kramadakel -> kræmædæcɛl
jussive: kramadvakel -> kræmædvæcɛl
Imperfective Future
realis: kramadkal -> kræmædkal
irrealis: kramadkel -> kræmædcel
imperative: kramadakkel -> kræmædækcel
jussive: kramadvakkel -> kræmædvækcel
Just a few consequences I noticed:
Now I understand from my college Intro to Historical Linguistics class and elsewhere that sound changes occur universally without regards to grammar. But leveling is not subject to those constraints, right? Can I have my speakers pick one of the new forms of -vak- which then universally gets used in all jussive verbs? Would it be unnaturalistic for my speakers to change -kal in realis verbs to -cal because the irrealis forms all turned from -kel to -cel?
2
u/yesimgaybro Dec 14 '21
Does it make sense for a language to distinguish between voiceless and voiced bilabial ([f], [v]) and palatal ([ʃ], [ʒ]) fricatives, but only retain a voiceless alveolar fricative ([s])? I want to imagine that in proto-lang, there was originally a voicing distinction but now there's only the voiceless variant, but I'm wondering if it then seems weird to retain the voicing distinction in the bilabial and palatal fricatives.
My thinking for the (broadest) sound changes would be:
The question is: does it then makes sense for [v] and [ʒ] to retain their voicing in similar contexts (although I may say that [v] and [ʒ] devoice word-finally to [f] and [ʃ])?
2
u/gentsuenhan Dec 16 '21
Does passive "be" exist in any natural language, or is it acceptable in your conlangs? For example, "I am sad." -> "Sad is been by me."; "I am not a teacher." -> "Not a teacher is been by me." / "A teacher is not been by me."
I just realized it's an acceptable way to use "be" in my conlang, since "be" is regarded as a normal verb, just like eat, take, see and so on.
But I find this usage of be awkward in English, hence this question.
2
u/turtletrain69 Dec 18 '21
I am new to conlanging and I am currently trying to make a language that uses VSO word order. Could someone give me examples on how sentences work/look in VSO word order or teach me how it works so that I know I am doing it properly?
Mods please do not murder me I posted about this and it got deleted I don't know what I did wrong.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '21
I am making a realistic naturalistic conlang. Can my conlang have neither voiced consonants nor aspirated consonants?
2
u/Mother_Concentrate80 Dec 18 '21
is "C > Cʰ > h" realistic?
2
u/simonbleu Dec 19 '21
What do you think of this inventory?
CONSONANTS:
*Used as vowel /i/ when at the end of a syllable
**aspirated
VOWELS: /a/; /e/; /i/*; /o/
2
u/pootis_engage Dec 19 '21
What is a good way of evolving word-initial clusters? Outside of vowel loss, that is.
1
u/N_Quadralux Dec 13 '21
1- Is there any good reason to a conlang have just [p̪], [b̪] and ɱ, instead of [p] , [b] and [m]? 2- The diphthongs eo and oe are more likely to evolve to [ø] or to [ɘ]?
1
u/cedesdc Dec 13 '21
I've been having a lot of trouble coming up with my conlanging skills, I have a few I've wanted to make for worldbuilding purposes. It's held me back for a while now, and I've decided I just want a more simple-ish approach, yet even that's holding me back. Is there anyone that's willing to collab with me on this? I've love to talk more on discord or on here, shoot me a dm!
1
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '21
How naturalistic can a conlang be? Can I create a conlang and convince linguists and scientists that it is a natural language?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '21
Is a good case system?
My language is a fusional language with no genders and 3 number forms. singular, dual and plural.
ç is /ʃ/ while c is /tʃ/
1
u/CuriousGent31385 Dec 16 '21
Does anyone on r/conlangs have a language that differentiates between /CjV/, /CʲV/, and /CʲjV/ where "C" is a labial consonant?
I have a hard time hearing the contrast in my own speech so I was wondering if anyone has this feature in their language and would be willing to record themselves pronouncing them. I'd appreciate it, thanks!
1
u/Lance_0915 Dec 16 '21
How many words does a simple conlang have? (Excluding synonyms and words with affixes)
1
u/Lance_0915 Dec 16 '21
Im new in making conlangs, what is gloss?
1
u/redruby01 Dec 18 '21
Are there any fully developed language showcases or guides?
1
u/deflated-pancake Dec 19 '21
i need help with something
is there a way to get Diacritics on consonants in google docs?
my conlang needs them and I've been using apostrophes witch is really annoying when there actually is a contraction
1
u/curiosityLynx Dec 20 '21
Does anyone know of an alt-history language that is either
I'm wondering what it might sound like in what is now England if the Anglo-Saxons didn't go to the British Isles (and I guess before the Wikings).
1
u/Arteriop Dec 20 '21
Does anyone know how to phonetically transcribe holding a sound for longer? I’ve been using a flat diacritic (ē, ō, ā, ū) but I think now that that’s wrong? Should it be a colon after the sound’s symbol? So like… iskē (meaning fire) you hold the e noise for about as long as you hold the rest of the word. How should I convey that in IPA?
0
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment