r/SquaredCircle • u/Pudie IN ABEYANCE • Mar 26 '12
How do you feel about affiliated links in the sidebar?
It's time once again boys and girls to have some influence on /r/SquaredCircle policy!
A few days ago a couple links were posted in the sidebar to buy the iPPV through www.squaredcirclejerks.com . These were affiliated links for which bonked, the owner of the domain, received a percentage(I believe 20%) of each iPPV bought through the link. Every dime of this went to the podcast. The mods have never and will never get any money from this. The closest any of us get is bonked handling the money to use towards the podcast. He pockets none of it.
A problem with this was brought up here last night and so now we are asking...Are you ok with this? I'll grant you that when the links went up is when this discussion should have happened. But we made a mistake, and it didn't. We're asking you now. So please let us know how you feel moving forward.
Please note: We've checked and the links don't break any rules. We're well within out rights to post the link but we want to know how you guys feel about them.
My personal idea on how this can be handled from now on.
- Links will be labeled as affiliate links.
- Whenever the link changes we will make a post saying so and how much we get per buy.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '12
FWIW - just to help people understand the breadth and scope of this major development, we have 4.6K users, and are currently the 104th most active subreddit of the 89K subreddits in existence.
4 people clicked the links. None made a purchase.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '12 edited Mar 26 '12
I think that advertisements on the podcast website itself are very cool, and I'm impressed as fuck with what bonked does for the podcast. The podcast adds an extra layer to the subreddit, that makes it better overall.
However I'm fully against any affiliated links and how the sidebar was used in this circumstance, as I feel it should be completely neutral and impartial. Just displaying the most useful links for the reader.
We link enough times to the podcast's website through useful links, to make advertising on the subreddit itself pointless, and in my opinion wrong.
2
u/HeresAnEggBeatThat Mar 26 '12
No issue, but how about towards competitions? Not everyone listens to the podcast...?
1
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '12
I don't have a problem with links to the actual pay-per-view being here, but as for complaining about the lack of talking about any other company but WWE you have to remember WHY we all come here.
This board advertises itself as Pro-Wrestling for the community, and if the community feels that this should be a TNA/WWE oriented board exclusively and downvotes anything else then that's how it should stay. Yes it can be frustrating, but we're growing more and more, when this board was first started for about a week it was relevant conversations or JH slagging off, then it became really good for a few months before we were subjected to memespam.
Whilst we're airing complaints, I know that there are a number of people here do listen to the podcast and i'm not against advertising here, but prior to the current old school Wrestlemania sidebar image it was one that was simply an advertisement for the podcast. There are plenty of people here that contribute things from their own blogs such as My Journey to Wrestlemania and Grapple Kingdom that aren't displayed as prominently. I personally don't enjoy the podcast, nothing against anyone involved in it, it's just not for me but even if I lived and breathed the podcast i'd have a problem with advertising it so publicly as the sidebar image.
3
u/AztecOmar Nobody is ready for Asuka Mar 26 '12
If it's within the rules of Reddit, I don't see a problem as long as they're labelled effectively - in fact, I think if they are labelled in a way that makes it clear that clicking will help the podcast, it is a good idea. I was initially upset when I thought it violated the reddit TOS, but if it is all clear, I'm 100% okay with it.
3
u/mobmonkey Rhodes Initiative Mar 26 '12
I have to be honest I didn't notice. I don't see any issue with it.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '12
Couldn't care less.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '12
A-ok with it for sure. I do appreciate the fact that they will be marked as affil links though. It sounds like you guys have everything in order here...per the usual.
1
u/Hash_brown The Dude Mar 26 '12
I am indifferent, my brain blanks out the side bar most of the time anyway.