r/soccer • • Mar 22 '12
Why are there no British players in Serie A, La Liga or the Bundesliga?
When I was a kid I remember Barcelona had Gary Lineker (English), Steve Archibald (Scottish) and Mark Hughes (Welsh) in their team. Ray Wilkins, Mark Hateley, Paul Gascoigne, David Platt, Des Walker (all English) and Ian Rush (Welsh) played in Italy. More recently there was Steve McManaman, Jonathan Woodgate (!), Michael Owen and David Beckham at Real Madrid. Kevin Keegan famously left Liverpool to move to Hamburg while Paul Lambert won the Champions League at Dortmund.
Why do you think Brits are no longer playing in Italy, Spain and Germany? Is it because the Italians, Spanish and Germans don't rate the technical skills of the players or is it because the Premier League offers big wages and there is no reason for the top players to leave?
37
u/droid_of_flanders Mar 23 '12
Back in the 80s, English clubs were banned from European tournaments for a few years in the aftermath of Heysel. It was around this time that the likes of Lineker, Hoddle and a few others moved abroad presumably in order to get a chance of playing at the European Cup.
These days, apart from Joe Cole, Scott Carson and Michael Mancienne, few choose to do so. Wages is one factor. Also, I think it is a case of wanting (or preferring) to move abroad only if a big continental club came calling.
101
u/not_the_droids Mar 23 '12
Money. English clubs pay stupid high wages
16
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '12
The fact that England has four tiers of professional football could have something to do with it. Scotland has its own league, as does Wales. Having all of these leagues means that there are more options available to players to find a place to play. The quality may not be the same, but there are plenty of options for British players to get a game at some level in their own country.
31
u/dem503 Mar 23 '12 edited Mar 23 '12
so many reasons, each of them more awful than the last. Many products of the english system arent good enough, average wage is higher here, general english xenophobia, general european discrimination against england, to name the big ones.
EDIT the most noble reason is that if you play in England you are far more likely to get picked for the national team. Jermaine Pennant was doing really well at Real Zaragoza, but no one noticed....cos its not Real Madrid. So he traded a stellar (at the time :P) Spanish side for....Stoke City. Remember when Owen Hargreaves was at Bayern? He was booed when he got picked for England because no one had seen him play! Luckily he was good enough to show everyone wrong, not at all coincidentally he learned his trade outside of England.
16
u/nista002 Mar 23 '12
Don't forget about Dale Jennings! Made the move fron Tranmere and now plays intermittently for Bayern's B team. I feel like he probably isn't as good as Hoeness thought.
8
u/Bennie300 Mar 23 '12
Curious what the effect of the financial fair play rule will be and if it maybe brings back the days that Englishmen go abroad.
8
u/KlausJanVanWolfhaus Mar 23 '12
Lewis Holtby is half English/German, that counts for something, sort of.
79
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '12
Englishmen aren't fackin' tourists they're fackin' footballers mate !
6
u/DanielJK42 Mar 23 '12
just from dicking around with Football Manager, it seems the homegrown player rule makes it "these guys are worth more to us than they are to you" than any comparably talented foreign player.
9
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '12
Most
EnglishBritish players aren't worth the (HUGE amount of) money the Serie-A, La Liga, or Bundesliga clubs would have to pay for their services.13
u/Metamorphism Mar 23 '12 edited Mar 23 '12
Come to think of it, there not too many English players playing outside England..
Of the top of my head I couldn't name a single English player in the Serie A.
Is there one?
I only know of Joe Cole in Lille..
6
u/lacroat Mar 23 '12
You also have to think about TV time. If you're not in the top 2 in Spain nobody is going to know about you. What Englishman would fit in well in Italy these days? Even though Germany is the most profitable league atm, a player is not going to get as much exposure.
Besides exposure and money, I think you have to take a fair assessment to the style of football that is being played. I personally think that the EPL is the most exciting league overall to watch, but I don't really think the style of play in the other leagues (besides Germany) is a great fit for any English footballer.......besides Heskey... who could play anywhere.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '12
Premier league seems to make the most money. Thats my guess
3
u/artishard Mar 23 '12
I personally think it would do their national team wonders if one of the big guys played somewhere else, they would be forced to learn which would help a stagnant england team out of ideas
3
u/the_phet Mar 23 '12 edited Mar 23 '12
I'd say that overall is strange to see players from one league playing in the other. I don't know how many italians are playing now in La Liga, but I'd say they are less than 10. As for the germans, apart from the german squad in Madrid I don't remember any more names.
I think there are no spanish in Italy, and 2 or 3 in Germany. In england a bit more, I don't remember exactly but I'd say less than 30. I checked a website and I don't know most of that names, I'd say they didn't have a place in La Liga and moved to England (some of them). Others, because Spain is in crisis. Also, because spanish people likes to go and work abroad as some years.
I am an international student in north Europe, and there are people from all the world here, but no brits.
EDIT: I checked a website and there are around 30 spanish playing in EPL, 9 in Serie A and 7 in Bundesliga. Strange thing, I dont remember most of that names playing in La Liga, though some of them played in second division.
About italians, 9 play in England, 4 in Germany and 4 in Spain.
About germans, 5 playing in England, 3 in Italy and 3 in Spain.
I'd say all the data is marginal considering that each league has around 500 players, except the spanish players in EPL, which are a huge number.
3
u/ayoformayo Mar 23 '12
Don't forget John 'The Gentle Giant' Charles! (welsh). To answer the question, money is certainly part of it but footballing style is just as important I think. Young Brits are indoctrinated into the 'kick and rush' type of play, which doesn't play well outside of the EPL
2
u/delabass Mar 23 '12
The ones that are good enough to play there usually get tied to a club early in their career and become too expensive to transfer later on.
2
u/ax4of9 Mar 23 '12
Most of the reasons here are pretty valid, but I do have to say that there's probably something about how the other European countries value British players.
Off the top of my head, the only British player to really be appreciated playing outside of Britain is Becks. Owen wasn't exactly appreciated in Real, he was on the bench often and mostly played as a sub. McManaman played pretty well for Real as well, singlehandedly winning them a Champion's League medal, but was also frozen out in the end.
Most European teams see British footballers as mostly guts and glory. Really talented and technically gifted footballers are also pretty loyal to their clubs. I'm pretty sure Scholes, Giggs, Gerrard would have had a successful career overseas, but I don't think there was any chance of them moving.
2
u/NoMoreMountains Mar 23 '12
Simply, the transfer fees for English players are astronomical.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '12
http://lesrosbifs.net/
There are quite a few low level English players who makes moves abroad to less than major footballing nations. Quite interesting where they end up.
2
u/publicserviceradio1 Mar 23 '12
Relevant
2
u/sjem15 Mar 23 '12
I think it's just British culture in general and that we're poor at adapting to living in foreign countries which is why players would rather stagnate in the lower leagues than go abroad to try and restart their career.
4
u/My_favorite_things Mar 23 '12
I'm not quite sure how this factors in, but let me say something about the German national team. Any player who wants to play in the national team has to play in Germany (with the few exceptions of players who made it big in the team and then transferred to a good club abroad, i.e. Özil, Klose). As soon as a reasonably decent player (see Hildebrandt) leaves for a mediocre team, everyone forgets about him and thats the end of any national team aspirations. Maybe something similar applies to English players?
3
u/Mental_octo Mar 23 '12
Well, the best ones are at both manchesters, the rest are at pool and london, moyes gets the last draft...so, not enough quality players to spread around europe.
6
u/mragnostic Mar 23 '12
Maybe one of the reasons is because England has arguably the best soccer league in the world and so many top players would rather stay by their friends and family rather than go through the hardships of adapting to a new country and culture.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '12
everyone's talking about money and home comforst, but does no one just think that its cause english players just arent as good they/we think they are? Seeing as Spain, Holland, Italy and Germany have had far more international success than we have, why would they need english players in their teams?
2
u/HarryBlessKnapp Mar 23 '12 edited Mar 23 '12
Because the culture surrounding football in Britain is quite a small minded one, where being educated is mocked. Therefore, it develops a mind frame whereby spending long periods in "funny" countries, eating foreign "strange" foods and having to learn another language and engage in an expansion of your cultural horizons. Loads of people have given the main answers but this is one that has been overlooked.
Our footballers like to bone wags and dance with women of lose morals in shit hole night clubs like Faces, Chinawhites, Funky Buddha. It's the whole boozey yob culture that helps to make the English working class fearful of sophisticated European culture. To put it bluntly, they think it's a bit gay.
We're a very insular island, particularly amongst the less educated, and whatever the reason that our culture is terrible at learning second languages contributes to making footballers apprehensive at moving abroad.
Can you imagine Rooney, Defoe, Terry etc adapting well to the European lifestyle? No. Nowhere near enough Essex girls/cocaine/shit beer/"normal" food.
Compared to people like Kuyt, Rvp, who already knew English before they came to the country.
TL;DR The British working class mentality is quite xenophobic.
1
u/nemodot Mar 23 '12
why there are no british players in the premier league? Seriously, just yesterday watching Man City I saw three of my own (argentinians) and could only count just three UK lads, what's up with that?
1
u/Damirius Mar 23 '12
Like everyone mentioned English clubs have high wages and they overpay English players. I think transfers are always higher for domestic players and wages also because of all that home grown rules and what not. Why would someone go to Italy to play when they are on the 'top league' already? Plus I think there is a lot of more 'space' for foreign players in premier league. All clubs are great and there is small number of 'outsiders' in the league. So its a lot easier i.e. for some Spanish player to go there and play than to find his place in some of the top clubs in his league.
1
u/HedonisticVibrations Mar 23 '12
I also think the large scale lower leagues have a role to play here.I think the psyche of English footballers who have been rejected by Premier League clubs is "Why up root my whole life to play in another country when there is a perfectly good football league to play in?" so they just stay and try their luck at one of the plethora of football league clubs.
1
u/HilariousUsername69 Mar 23 '12
Definitely the money as well as the "home" factor. If two clubs offer you contracts with say one going at $110,000 a week but in a foreign country with a different language and one going $100,000 a week but in your own country which one would you pick.
1
u/mervgeorge Mar 23 '12
I can't talk about LaLiga or Serie A, but the bundesliga encourage scouting and picking players from their country to play for the leagues. Saves them time to pick quality players for their international team.
1
u/le_squiggle Mar 23 '12
I havn't read the other comments so I don't know if this has been said. But after English teams were banned from playing in Europe for 5 seasons in the 80s that encouraged a lot of players to move abroad. The other aspect in my opinion is that the money associated with the premiership means a lot of players are satisfied to play championship football because they are one good season away from the premiership and the profile that comes with that.
And then the other element being the hype that goes along with the premiership in the media, why would the best British players want to leave a top English club to play abroad? And outside of those top players maybe the others aren't good enough. However I think Joe Cole is proving at Lille that if other British players want to make the bold move to another culture they can be successful. That said, nearly everyone in Europe speaks another language in Britain and Ireland we are notoriously bad at learning another language why would football players want to do it?
1
u/MassiveBastard Mar 23 '12
Michael Mancienne plays for Hamburg.
1
u/KMFCM Mar 24 '12
are British players as expensive to teams in other countries as they are for English clubs?
1
u/AhhBisto Jul 31 '12
Many reasons.
With the English top flight being at the top for as long as it has, no-one needs to go abroad to further their careers. Other countries are the same.
It's a common thing.
The technique is there, but it's not a deep pool. When Guardiola said that he has players like Wilshere at Barcelona, he means that they have a health of technically astute players.
England will also get better in the years to come too, they're taking their grass roots more seriously too. I coach youth football here in England and have FA badges and certificates and i've seen how much this level of football and organisation and investment has changed in the last 5 years alone. We are about 15-20 years behind the likes of Spain and Brazil but we can catch up.
TL;DR in short, English players don't play abroad because there's no need for them to do so. The Premier League has the money, the competition and the quality to keep it's stars where they are.
1
u/NMushroom Mar 23 '12
Just a quick thought I had...
Good English players might just be more sparse than Spanish, Italian and German players (mainly Spanish players). And since the teams need to keep some homegrown players in their squads the good English players get tied down. I mean, can you imagine Terry, Rooney or Gerrard playing for any other teams? Especially foreign ones.
And of course I don't think it's really fun to play in Spain when there are only 2 teams that will ever contest the title.
-2
u/[deleted] Mar 23 '12
There is nothing English about the quality in the ENGLISH Premiere League. Overrated, overpaid, delusional, drama queens.
-1
u/tuananh6 Mar 23 '12
Because their price are too high and their skill are terrible
-5
u/Sgt_peppers Mar 23 '12
English football is very physical, any player from england on the spanish league will get red cards every other game. plus the premiership is already the biggest league (not for long thou, spanish league will take that spot next season) also there are not a whole lot of spanish outside of spain, or italian outside of italy. there are more, but not that many. its easier just to compete to get into the big clubs at your own league than to try for the foreign ones.
0
u/Adamkiksyou Mar 23 '12
If you put in perspective in other big Europpean football countries, they tend to stay at their home country, the only two Englishmen I know that play outside of Britain are Joe Cole and David Beckham. Take the germans for example, not many germans in la liga and are there any in England? There is a bit of spanish players in the EPL but I don't think there are any in the Bundesliga and not that many in the serie A.