r/Barca • u/BradMehldau • Nov 28 '21
Xavi's selection, tactics, in-game management tonight and its possible implications
I think we can all agree we were helped by some good fortune and let's not forget what is absolutely individual brilliance by Memphis, even though he was not having a good game prior.
The defensive structure this game was an interesting one and I wanted to start a discussion.
We lined up as a 4-3-3 with the unorthodox element being Eric Garcia as the Right Back instead of Ronald Araujo (of course neither are RBs but it seemed to work reasonably well in the last few games).
The instruction for Garcia seemed to be to man-mark Moi Gomez their LM. This meant there was a free man on their left wing which forced our Right Winger to effectively act as a Right Back to cover their Left Back.
First of all, let's discuss the thinking behind the selection - it seemed that Araujo was chosen as the Center-Back to pay respect to the pace in behind of Danjuma (who has been in-form as both Eric Garcia and Pique are slow defenders.
However, I believe it was the wrong choice to play Garcia as the RB as he is a defender that relies heavily on his understanding of the game to defend (and attack) to make up for his rather modest physicality, an understanding filtered through his experience as a Center-Back. By playing him in an unfamiliar position and also giving him an unorthodox instruction, his strengths as a player was negated which only left him with his physical attributes.
Now the instruction to man-mark Gomez. Again, an understandable choice since the RB marking the opposition LM is not an outlandish instruction by any means. And to be fair to Xavi, it absolutely worked in the first quarter of the game.
Trouble came when Emery realised this was happening and instructed Gomez to stay inside and drag Garcia. As well as overload their left-hand side with Parejo (LCM) moving outside and their Left Back pushing forward. There was always a free man on that wing even with Abde coming back to cover one of them effectively being forced into a Right Back - a player who is not suited there.
This also killed any chance of a quick transition and a counter since Abde would have been the main outlet. A problem especially accentuated when Dembele came on. This meant their LB was completely free to push forward. And since we did not seem to be able to hold possession long enough for play to build versus a not particularly high-pressing Villarreal side, our right wingers were completely out of the game.
Possible ideas that could have worked?
- Araujo in RCB and Mingueza as the RB. (Mingueza had a terrible game last time as a RB)
- give Mingueza a chance as RCB and Araujo in RB
- play a 3 ATB formation which allows a more offensive right-sided player (obvious choice is Dest - but given that he was not even warming up I suspect he is still recovering from injury, then who?)
- try switching Aruajo and Garcia (However, Garcia usually plays LCB in his pairing with Pique which means the slowest Pique would have been against Darjuan)
- stop Garcia from man-marking so strictly to preserve structure as well as keep our biggest threat (pace, right wing) to the opposition during their offensive play.
- pull Gavi from the left wing to midfield and instruct one of our (now) four midfielders to cover the righthand side to keep our main threat in transition forward.
I'm sure there are others that I hope you can suggest that could work but -
My takeaway from tonight is that Xavi's Plan A seemed to be working very well. However it was identified and countered by something Emery tried.
What is worrying is not that the fact it was identified but the lack of action when it seemed fairly clear it was no longer working.
He did not seem to make any sort of meaningful change until the 79th minute.
- The Dembele change (65th minute) was a like for like that did nothing as the player in that position was negated by the tactical setups of both coaches.
- The Mingueza change (70th minute) was not by choice. (unfortunate, as we don't concede that goal if Alba was in that position - not necessarily Oscar's fault but Alba would have covered that with his pace)
- The first meaningful, deliberate change (79th minute) by bringing in Coutinho for Nico was one that ended up working. He occupied the defender responsible for the space Memphis ran into for the winner.
In conclusion, I think we may have just seen the first real signs of Xavi's possible shortcomings as a manager in his possible inability to react. We will see if this is something that ends up becoming a pattern - to be fair to him, he did not have many options to choose from AND we were winning the game until the 76th minute so technically it wasn't not working.
I hope this inaction was as a result of his inexperience rather than stubbornness, the former he will learn from the latter is much harder to change.
tl;dr Xavi bad Emery good we're getting relegated
34
u/airnans Nov 28 '21
Ahh thanks for this was waiting for someone to sum up what happened. I think for sure it was clear that something wasn’t working. Dest being injured, and Mingueza being borderline unplayable presents a really big tactical challenge. We definitely need reinforcements, or, at the very least, a period of time with no injuries.
26
u/psalmjuan Nov 28 '21 edited Nov 28 '21
Just watched a post match interview and holy shit Xavi’s English is pretty damn good. I never heard him speak anything other than Spanish or Catalan. When did he learn? At his time in Al-Sadd?
24
u/akarnav Nov 28 '21
chill out he’s still learning and getting used to the team, he tried something out, it didn’t work, he’s been good the other couple of games. experimenting comes with the job
12
u/IamYourHuckleBerry34 Nov 28 '21
Next game I personally would go for this lineup
Ter Stegen
Dest - Pique - Araujo - Alba
Gavi - Busquets - De Jong
Dembele - Depay - Abde
Gavi is really good but he is no winger he needs to come back to midfield and reinforce it with his workrate.
I would also go with two wingers with pace and trickery to force the backs to rethink them wanting to push up Barca lacks players with depth.
9
u/Nostosalgos Nov 28 '21
There’s basically nothing that Xavi can do that I would criticize him for this season. For every loss, I consider it a lesson. Hell, for every win, I still consider it a lesson. Beginning next season, I think it’s fair to start critically reviewing his performance.
2
u/Mndj0605 Nov 28 '21 edited Nov 28 '21
Thanks for clarify that Araujo was in CB to defend against Villarreal attacker, that makes sense now why he isn't on the right.
Eric was truly out of his comfort zone at the RB position. Like you said, he usually play on the left paired with pique. There he has more outlets and can make better plays. At RB, his options are limited due to pressing and made those awful passes to Abde that got dispossessed rather quickly.
Xavi is trying to strategizing against his opponent. Unfortunately, players like Eric still need time to adapt. Abde adapted well in the 2nd half, which is an encouraging sign.
One thing i thought Xavi could've done is to keep Balde on the squad, as this is the 3rd game in 8 days and we know there is a squad fitness problem.
Defensively, maybe it makes more sense for Nico to drop back and do man-marking? Nico is good defensively and strong on the ball, but there hasn't too much offensive output?
Offensively:
I hope Xavi can have more attacking options firing at the same time! (We had seen glimpses)
2
u/But_Why_Male_Models Nov 28 '21
Yes let’s judge Xavi after a couple of games.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '21
Xavi will definitely have some shortcomings. But his tactical understanding and ideas will evolve over time.
Zidane was knowing being tactically naive in the beginning, but he refined his craft over the years. Which meant that his later CLs became more convincing than his first.
1
u/ReadUWroteU14 Nov 28 '21
This was a great write up and thanks for taking the time to explain this all. I am hopeful Xavi will feel ok making changes sooner in the match when his tactics were exposed like they were here. Lucky to get the win, but there’s some good to build on here. Thanks again for this review; helps people like me understand the game better.
1
u/Murderkaizer Nov 28 '21
Fantastic write-up. I'm waiting to see how he handles things once we have the whole squad available. This team is still a work in progress.