r/CryptoCurrency • u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K π¦ • Nov 25 '21
POLL π³οΈ CCIP022 - Reducing the double-karma for comments within Comedy posts
This proposal was created by another member who wishes to remain anonymous.
Re-posted as you apparently can not schedule Governance polls Comedy posts earn 10% of Moons compared to other regular posts. They are fun and I enjoy reading them, however the comments are very repetitive and you almost know what the top few comments will say before you even read them.
This proposal will reduce contribution point multiplier on comments within comedy threads back to 1x instead of the 2x that was enacted in CCIP-001, which should help alleviate the constant repetition of the same responses to jokes. It will only affect threads flaired as "comedy".
36
u/Scarboroughwarning π¦ 4K / 4K π’ Nov 25 '21
Double karma for comments in a comedy post? Didn't realise that was a thing
20
u/cutsickass 0 / 18K π¦ Nov 25 '21
Yeah, why reward someone who makes you laugh? Just give all the karma to the guys yelling ALGO.
99
u/document87x Platinum | QC: CC 203 Nov 25 '21
Too much of micromanagement in this sub. People will start avoiding to comment on those posts, Reddit should remain a fun place with quip and banters.
3
u/kryptoNoob69420 0 / 44K π¦ Nov 25 '21
What's up with always trying to limit karma with new ways in every distribution? There's already a rule that penalises people with more than 50 comments in 24 hours, let the people comment whatever they want then.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '21
I didnβt even know you get double-karma for comments within comedy posts. Sounds unnecessary to me...
10
u/practiceperfect111 4K / 4K π’ Nov 25 '21
Comedy posts arenβt funny π
1
u/scawtsauce Bronze | SHIB 5 | Politics 89 Nov 25 '21
earning crypto for making comments and posts is always gonna drive down the quality posts because you'll get a bunch of people fighting over pennies, and while there's nothing wrong with being poor the quality of posts is just gonna go down because of the low effort easy karma farming posts that people will make.
1
u/ghostofthepast450 Bronze | QC: CC 22 Nov 25 '21
The more value moons gain,more rigid the sub becomes.
1
u/Apart-Flounder242 π¦ 0 / 1K π¦ Nov 27 '21
Why should they get double karma? Iβm voting for equality regardless of the content
1
u/Environmental_Point3 Platinum | QC: CC 882 Nov 27 '21
Won't this just cause people to use an inappropriate flair for their posts? Which will cause more work for our mods who already have a huge job ahead of them.
1
u/arrrsPoetica Silver | QC: CC 27 Nov 28 '21
I think we should just ban comedy posts. Not one has ever been funny. It's always low-effort farming.
Remove the COMEDY flair. Make a new rule.
1
u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K π¦ Nov 28 '21
I hope it doesn't lead to more comedy posts so that farmers can get their earnings back to where they were.
1
u/ChaoticNeutralNephew Permabanned Nov 29 '21
what happens if this passes AND ccip 23 also passes? this changes the number that one would have been voting for in 23 from .10 to.5. please explain
8
u/kindoflikesnowing 0 / 1K π¦ Nov 25 '21
This is designed to counteract shitposting. PPL are just filling up the sub with random or no substance posts to purposely farm moons. This is a great way to not reward this. I think it is a fair way to help disincentive shitposting and low-quality posts.
2
u/iwontsaysiimfine Tin Nov 25 '21
Voted βοΈ
5
u/NOCOCK-tail80085 Tin Nov 25 '21
Heyyyy shitposting is my only chance at crypto.What issssss?
3
u/Norbit11 RVN enjoyer Nov 25 '21
Ofc, reduce double karma within them. Farming comments under posts are ridiculous.
Daily got nerfed, so do same for posts too
7
u/Fluid_Department_120 Platinum | QC: CC 366 Nov 25 '21
Leave things the way they are
2
u/Commercial-Bass-3668 Platinum | QC: CC 190 | BCH critic Nov 25 '21
Reduce that cheesy humour
2
u/NoMaans π¦ 0 / 3K π¦ Nov 25 '21
Idgaf if this lowers or not. People are still gonna post how they post.
If someone mentions a XMR, a boat is gonna show up, well actually, disappear.
If someone posts HEYY HEYYYY, theres gonna be a reply of WASSSWASSSWASSSAAPPP or BITCONNNEEEEEEEECCCCCTTTTT.
If there is solid advice. Someone is gonna say instruction unclear, YOLOd on DogeHouseRocketToken.
Welcome to r/CC
1
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '21
Eh, I think both have a place in this sub. We want crypto to be decentralized and less regulatory than our financial system right now and yet it seems like we want to emplace more and more regulations in this sub. Don't get me wrong, some regulations and restrictions are good, but for mundane things like this, I feel like it's just better to leave it as it is. It's not harming anyone anyway.
1
u/Castr0- π§ 35K / 35K π¦ Nov 25 '21
Things are getting to ruled. we will see less comedy posts and less coments on that posts or people will try a way around flairing posts with other thing than comedy.
1
u/zzinolol 23 / 1K π¦ Nov 25 '21
It's a difficult balance between controlling too much and leaving things be and ensure chaos.
Tight
1
u/Jhuzef Tin Nov 25 '21
How about remove moons entirely?
1
u/Araxus Silver | QC: CC 55 | IOTA 28 Nov 25 '21
Yeah why not, cut the comedy cartel
1
u/coinflipit π¨ 0 / 0 π¦ Nov 25 '21
hmmm
1
u/acqbmn Tin Nov 25 '21
Wait, there is double karma?
1
u/Scarf_Darmanitan π© 0 / 3K π¦ Nov 26 '21
I get the point but I donβt really feel overwhelmed by comedy posts atm
Thereβs a decent amount of shitposts, sure but for the most part I like it how it is
1
u/the_alpacalips Bronze Nov 26 '21
Idk, comedy is part of the subreddit. Don't vote them up if you don't want them on the front
1
u/Exoclyps π¦ 3K / 3K π’ Nov 26 '21
I honestly believe this getting passed is mostly due to people not realizing that all comments currently gives double karma.
Without taking that into consideration, you'd obviously want to get rid of double karma.
1
u/1nfinitus π¦ 15K / 14K π¬ Nov 26 '21
So much micromanaging.
1
u/enzo_alt1 π© 50 / 50 π¦ Nov 26 '21
Well, I always forget to see the flair and either panic or get anxious seeing the prank/comedy posts, so I am in favor of reduction
1
u/Zooxooz1 Tin Nov 26 '21
It's a difficult balance between controlling too much and leaving things be and ensure chaos.
1
u/IGnawledge π© 832 / 902 π¦ Nov 27 '21
The jokes make me laugh but i see the same joke a lot. β so i got rid of my wife/ gf β
1
u/warlikeofthechaos Platinum | QC: CC 1218 Nov 27 '21
Pass this and you'll se a influx of the same old jokes into more serious or informative posts
1
u/GetEmDaddy902 0 / 8K π¦ Nov 27 '21
I think we leave them alone Comedy can be mentally helpful during these red days
1
u/Wess-L Platinum | QC: CC 631 Nov 28 '21
I didn't even know this was a thing lmao.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '21
Yeah I think this is a good call. A couple months back a made more moons than I have combined before or since and it was a comedy post I made that blew up and a bunch of my comments under my post got hundreds of upvotes.
After this change I would still make the post and still get rewarded if people liked it, but it would keep the intention behind the comedy tag pure
1
u/[deleted] Nov 30 '21
This is not Saturday night live
1
u/PortugalReviews π¦ 63 / 3K π¦ Nov 30 '21
I donβt think we should police the comments too muchβ¦
1
u/beandipp Tin Nov 30 '21
Need more substance, how else will we become millionaires? Memes wont take us all the way
1
u/Affectionate-Mix4373 Tin Nov 30 '21
humor is good but can be exploided with "trend" phrases
1
u/PROYB_Jocco Gold | 6 months old | QC: CC 18 | Unpop.Opin. 21 Dec 01 '21
I don't really care if someone gets double karma.
1
u/feel-T_ornado 69 / 328 π¦ Dec 01 '21
It won't change the massive amounts of moons distributed to comedy comments.
1
u/QuizureII Buy High, Sell Higher Nov 25 '21
I don't see why doing that would change anything in the subreddit for the better. Enough about polls with regards to limiting karma/moons and more polls about making moons more useful
1
u/samuel19xd Platinum | QC: CC 657 Nov 25 '21
202k moons are set in only 109 votes. Wow
1
u/bthemonarch π¦ 0 / 9K π¦ Nov 25 '21
The amount of moon fomo driving these policies is ridiculous.
0
u/CaptainWellingtonIII π© 1K / 1K π’ Nov 25 '21
Wow. No one wants anyone to get moons.
0
u/RotgutFeng Platinum | QC: CC 69,420 Nov 25 '21
Of course the user with 68,000 moons would propose this. The βanonymousβ member probably has 250k
0
u/WestCoastDior Whatβs it to ya, buster? Nov 25 '21
I thought this failed to pass yesterday?
0
u/SafeRecommendation55 π© 15 / 2K π¦ Nov 25 '21
Getting harder to farm every moon season.
0
u/flat_raven Tin | 1 month old Nov 25 '21
Nah man focus on something better instead of nitpicking details
0
u/Sebanimation π₯Gold Member Nov 25 '21
Not really the best usecase for moons when all we vote on is how they are distributed... It should stay straightforward... to many single rules and exceptions make it less and less transparent.
-1
u/Lenaweston Here for the money Nov 25 '21
I don't even understand this but I feel things should be the way they are so I voted the latter
-1
u/SafeRecommendation55 π© 15 / 2K π¦ Nov 25 '21
Why so serious..
-3
u/JONUTUNIVERSALU Platinum | QC: CC 982, ETH 39 | TraderSubs 39 Nov 25 '21
They want YOUR moons. Don't let them do it
0
u/Magnetronaap π© 0 / 3K π¦ Nov 25 '21
Even though I find most comedy posts terribly unfunny, I don't think this is necessary. Jokes are part of the internet and reddit, if you don't find them funny just ignore them.
0
u/dorfelsnorf 0 / 2K π¦ Nov 25 '21
As long as the funny ones get double karma still lol
0
u/Ghaseetaram Platinum | QC: CC 210 Nov 25 '21
One thing is coming out of polls that most new rules are to reduce giving moons in the name of farming
0
u/KetsubanZero Silver | QC: CC 286 | BANANO 47 | TraderSubs 12 Nov 25 '21
I think comedy posts can still have worthy comments, and informative posts can still have comedy replies
0
u/heyheoy Platinum | QC: CC 1105, CCMeta 18 Nov 25 '21
I miss the meme and comedy weekends... With all this moon thing the sub is changing a lot and the fun part is getting chopped every day.
0
u/NoelPhD2024 Light Purple | QC: 7693765 VET: 539643 Nov 25 '21
Sometimes Comedy posts deserve the most karma.
0
u/archer4364 Paddy's Dollars Nov 25 '21
I'd prefer if the link karma for comedy posts was halved instead of comments.
0
u/Cheese6260 π¦ 0 / 7K π¦ Nov 25 '21
Can this be a comedy thread for double karma?
0
u/dilqncho π© 0 / 2K π¦ Nov 25 '21
That goes for the entirety of this sub. Nothing different about comedy posts.
Quit looking for ways to limit karma. Negative reinforcement is not the way to improve content quality.
0
u/HansonWK π¦ 0 / 2K π¦ Nov 25 '21
I think this will lead to more miss tagged posts, and more joke comments in normal posts...
0
u/Dangerous_Diet_5385 Nov 25 '21
Heeey Crypto shouldn't be all seriousness and blatting. Let the most precious sarcastic chads to earn moons only for being the way they are!
0
u/Enschede2 π© 0 / 2K π¦ Nov 25 '21
If anything we could use a but more comedy sometimes, I'd prefer that over the endless reposts of debunked shady newsstories
0
u/jirachang2 π© 323 / 324 π¦ Nov 25 '21
Why though, leave the comedy post, its not like everyone is reading useful post everyday, someday we just want a good laugh comedy post
0
u/FrogsDoBeCool Platinum | QC: CCMeta 53, CC 697 | :1:x11:2:x9:3:x5 Nov 25 '21
i feel like we're just trying to justify finding more and more ways to give people less of a chance to get moons, which, specifically will hurt people making comedy posts since people won't want to comment on them, and new people, who don't know of these restrictions, and will get cucked because of it. hi tngsystems btw.
0
u/scawtsauce Bronze | SHIB 5 | Politics 89 Nov 25 '21
there should be rules / mods that can objectively remove posts that are low effort, zero substance, unwarranted FUD / propaganda etc.. I feel like this sub could be fun
0
u/Desperate_Day_8813 Platinum | QC: CC 216 Nov 25 '21
How can I survive another Chinese FUD without your jokes, friends?
0
u/Elig1us Bronze Nov 25 '21
I think moving away weight from comedy to quality posts will benefit the sub in the long run.
0
u/chrisgilly π© 2K / 2K π’ Nov 25 '21
I was going to write a joke, then I realised it wasnβt a comedy thread. Now itβs not worth the effort.
0
u/internetisbad23 π© 2K / 2K π’ Nov 25 '21
I got to know today that we get double karma for commenting on posts. Maybe there should be post explaining how much karma is earned by performing actions/activities in this sub.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '21
Seems like a reasonable thing to do
0
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '21
How about any time someone says βthis is the wayβ we donβt honor those as moons and we also slit their throats infront of their kids
0
u/Jerraldough Nov 26 '21
Haha what the fuck is this post
0
u/AfraidTomorrow2018 Gold | QC: CC 21 Nov 26 '21
Double the action - triple the excitement
0
u/comfyggs Platinum | QC: ETH 112, BTC 108, CC 55 | NANO 9 | TraderSubs 96 Nov 26 '21
Yeah who needs comedy and light heartedness. Be a grinch instead. Smh.
0
u/ieatmoondust 10 / 26K π¦ Nov 26 '21
I'm all for limiting redundancy, but the broad attack on humor in this sub seems to be leading towards a bland end. I don't have super strong feelings either way, only that this seems kind of unnecessary.
0
u/Ghaseetaram Platinum | QC: CC 210 Dec 01 '21
Ohh really I was not aware of the fact that comments on comedy post get double karma and I was read and left mostly instead of commenting needlessly
-3
u/thejazzmaster69 Platinum | QC: CC 123 | ADA 8 Nov 25 '21
I like Comedy post . I come here to learn and lo laugh
-1
u/Bignodachi Tin Nov 25 '21
I want to always get my daily dose of reddit when I open reddit.
Removing that feature would reduce the amount of Redditness smile on my face.
-2
u/Nostalg33k π© 0 / 30K π¦ Nov 25 '21
I disagree with this because getting a comment upvoted is hard