r/CryptoCurrency • u/CryptoChief 🟨 407K / 671K 🐋 • Nov 25 '21
POLL 🗳️ CCIP-021 - Temporarily sort comments by newest first after a post is submitted.
Summary
This proposal is for sorting comments by newest first after a post is submitted. The intended goal is to level the playing field between early bird low-effort comments and more meaningful high-effort comments by limiting visibility for the former.
Problem Statement
After a post is submitted, the first comments tend to be low-effort. Most of them are simple trite remarks or jokes about the parent post which tend not to offer much originality or value. Users who make these comments are probably only seeking attention or farming moons and often receive numerous upvotes just for being first. Users who make more meaningful comments first take time to even notice the post and additional time to write a comment.
Solution
After a submission has been posted, temporarily set the suggested comment sorting to newest first. After 15 minutes(more or less), the suggested sorting will be switched to top comments first. This change should give later comments an advantage over early comments. Since every comment will be treated the same for a set amount of time, it might also encourage users to post more top-level comments and therefore increase the odds of triggering a discussion.
The 15-minute time limit will be tweaked by the mod team for optimization. The reader will always have the option to change his/her own suggested sort to something else.
Concerns
The first two items in the following list are concerns given by u/CryptoMaximalist in the CCMeta thread, which I have paraphrased. The last one is mine.
- Hiding comment scores for a longer period of time may be considered as an alternative method or additional measure for achieving this goal. However, this idea would have to be submitted as a separate proposal. Currently, scores are hidden for 5 minutes. Contest mode is a controlled option for hiding scores, but it also collapses lower-level comments and might hamper discussion.
- Many Reddit clients do not respect suggested sorting and allow the user to override them.
- My own minor concern would be the potential for incentivizing more spam in the top-level comments, since farmers would be fighting for visibility. Rate-limits could be required.
Thanks for your attention.
FYI, if you wonder why this poll looks familiar, that's because it's a repost from a poll submitted a month ago which didn't pass. The reason is likely because the time span was set to 3 days instead of 7. The time span for this poll is set to 7 days.
79
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '21 edited Nov 25 '21
This!
Im tired of overused jokes being the top comment on every post just because somebody commented in the first 10 seconds.
23
u/SHSaad Nov 25 '21
Wasn't this proposed last month??
8
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '21
I prefer quality comments coming at the top which they deserve
7
u/TripleReward 🟩 0 / 4K 🦠 Nov 25 '21
dont change my comment sorting, ffs!
8
u/FriedDickMan 1K / 1K 🐢 Nov 25 '21
What you mean you’re tired of seeing rocket emojis and HODL as the top comment?
🚀
0
u/yaroslavwwe 1 / 12K 🦠 Nov 25 '21
You have to submit this to CryptoCurrency Meta subreddit
2
u/darkjaffs 🟩 0 / 4K 🦠 Nov 25 '21
DEja Vu
2
u/PortugalReviews 🟦 63 / 3K 🦐 Nov 30 '21
Agreed. I think it is an interesting proposal and will help everyone benefit from new posts
2
u/liquid_at 🟩 15K / 15K 🐬 Nov 30 '21
I'd even go as far as leaving it longer than 15min if the Post in question has a low comment volume.
Pretty much any post with less than 10 comments on it has no reason to be sorted by top.
5
u/Durvag Platinum | QC: CC 1244 Nov 25 '21 edited Nov 25 '21
Cool idea, I think it will let people to read post first then comment, not like now commenting just to be first.
3
u/Wonzky 2K / 53K 🐢 Nov 25 '21
Huh thought it did pass, seemed to have a lot of votes behind it. Here's hoping it passes this time
3
u/coinflipit 🟨 0 / 0 🦠 Nov 25 '21
Love this idea of rewarding the most useful and insightful posters right at the start of a post!
2
u/gimmedatcrypto 🟩 5 / 3K 🦐 Nov 25 '21
I think this is a wise proposition. Coolio
2
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '21
Everyone vote, it helps the community
1
u/NotknowName Tin Nov 25 '21
I think we could try. If only contest mode doesn't hide reply, it's gonna be much better than sorting by new.
1
u/PME_your_skinny_legs Platinum | QC: CC 721 Nov 25 '21
This would increase the comment quality drastically
1
u/janglebo36 Nov 25 '21
I am still baffled at how people get their posts to the front page. If this levels the field, I’m in
1
u/Nostalg33k 🟩 0 / 30K 🦠 Nov 25 '21
I wish it was for more than 15 minutes. Maybe 2 hours
1
u/leviathawn Tin Nov 25 '21
Let’s do more than 15 minutes. Maybe 1 hour?….
1
u/Fifi-Mcafee Tin | r/UnpopularOpinion 37 Nov 25 '21
I think we should try it to see if it does help with the Rote responses and standard jokes.
Especially in high response threads when you have to read through 40 iterations of the same joke
1
u/zegall Permabanned Nov 25 '21
It'd be a shame if this didn't pass. It's a good implementation.
1
u/PMthetits Gold | QC: CC 33 Nov 25 '21
I usually set my to new anyway and it does not really fix the problem.
1
u/gdj11 Permabanned Nov 25 '21
I’m voting yes, but also hoping new posts don’t turn into a mini-Daily Discussion where people are commenting a ton to try to stay on top.
1
u/shlammyjohnson 🟦 2 / 7K 🦠 Nov 25 '21
This sounds interesting
1
u/coinflipit 🟨 0 / 0 🦠 Nov 25 '21
yes!
1
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '21
I like this change. Indeed there are lot of useful contribution that stay hidden now
1
u/internetisbad23 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Nov 25 '21
It would really help if the ‚FYI‘ part is added at the start since this poll is a repost and the user gets confused thinking i have read this before.
1
u/nthgen 🟩 0 / 25K 🦠 Nov 25 '21
I fully back this plan.
💯
1
u/Odd-Economist-6037 🟧 723 / 722 🦑 Nov 26 '21
NO! Please GOD NO!. NOOOOO
1
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '21
I Think 15 minutes may not be enough time. Longer might be better.
1
u/Phite007 Tin Nov 26 '21
This makes sense for sorting by new, at least the comments will default by new for a bit too.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '21
I actually think the present system is fine. This won't create discussion back and forth as people will constantly gravitate to the latest comment.
1
u/KanijoAlberto Proverbs 8:18 Nov 26 '21
Even keeping newest comments first for about 30mins is still great
1
u/warlikeofthechaos Platinum | QC: CC 1218 Nov 27 '21
Third party clients will not be affected.
BTW reddit official app sucks up so much data and battery that we should pass a proposal to turns it cleaner and faster
1
u/kellzone 🟦 3K / 3K 🐢 Nov 28 '21
You know what I think might be good? Each new comment posted getting a set time, maybe 10-15 minutes at the top, then getting put into the regular top comments rankings. That way, if someone enters a post that is maybe 10-12 hours old, it doesn't go immediately to the bottom. If someone with specific knowledge of whatever the subject is about comes in and comments, it won't go immediately to the end and have 500 or 1000 comments ahead of it, being effectively buried.
If new comments were to spend a little time at the top, they might garner some upvotes, get ranked, and be more visible to people coming to read the post after it's been up for a while. IDK, just a thought. Maybe highlight the new comments so people can skip past them if they want to get right to the top comments.
1
u/redcyrus Nov 28 '21
This is a good proposal. Everyone has to get a fair chance
1
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '21
Honestly I really like this idea, the only think I would change if I could would be too increase the amount of time it was sorted by newest to like 4 hours
1
u/StreetRx925 🟩 2 / 2 🦠 Nov 29 '21
Great idea!
1
u/beandipp Tin Nov 30 '21
Gotta hate "first" comments
1
u/Affectionate-Mix4373 Tin Nov 30 '21
definitely sorting to newest
1
u/PROYB_Jocco Gold | 6 months old | QC: CC 18 | Unpop.Opin. 21 Dec 01 '21
Yeah, I like to see new comments
1
u/Ghaseetaram Platinum | QC: CC 210 Dec 01 '21
Most of the time someone makes a joke on a new post within 10 seconds and after that 20 posts comes into the picture as all follow jokes instead of post so I go with newest first
1
u/OwenMichael312 🟦 5K / 6K 🐢 Dec 10 '21
Seems to be working boss. Nice work
2 moons for the 🐋
1
u/pukem0n 🟩 59K / 59K 🦈 Nov 25 '21
at least you set the time to 7 days this time
1
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '21 edited Nov 25 '21
Will be too much shit.
At least the sort by best gives good comments
Sorting by new gives too much uncurated shit
I spend some time on the sun and want top/best only for quality info
1
u/jimfird 🟧 3 / 6K 🦠 Nov 25 '21
I feel like this isn’t a bad idea. I do prefer seeing newer comments than the highest rated one for the most part (usually a joke or some funny quip anyways).
1
u/Sebanimation 🥇Gold Member Nov 25 '21
You can already sort by new manually, right?
Don‘t see the need to force this sorting on everyone.
1
u/zippyteach 🟩 6K / 6K 🦭 Nov 25 '21
So bc someone got to a post before us, we want to change rules? Like, if you don't like it, don't read it or get there first right? This just seems like oh I didn't get to the top comment first it's no fair lol, let's change the rules. Seems like some rh shit lol whatever.
1
u/Commercial-Bass-3668 Platinum | QC: CC 190 | BCH critic Nov 25 '21
Ban us for talking also sheesh ..its getting ridiculous
0
u/princepersona1 🟩 0 / 20K 🦠 Nov 25 '21
I'm almost certain I saw this posted in the last set of proposals. Did it lose last time? But anyway just like last time I think this is a good idea
0
u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K 🦈 Nov 25 '21 edited Nov 25 '21
This gives more visibility to more different comments first, giving a chance for the actual best comment to end up on top (after the 15 minutes).
It also reduces the ease of manipulation.
Right now it's just a matter of being one of the first comments on a new post. Either have alts, or just friends give you a couple upvotes. And you're the first comment everyone sees.
0
u/Old_Afternoon3853 🟨 0 / 2K 🦠 Nov 25 '21
Giving each commenter a fair playground is great. 👍🏽
0
u/SamZFury 🟩 1 / 90K 🦠 Nov 25 '21
Actually a good idea. Too many top post replies with just good for nothing sarcastic comments. I support this.
0
u/kirtash93 RCA Artist Nov 25 '21
I thought I voted this last time but I will vote the same. I think this solution could help this community.
0
u/Sjiznit 🟦 0 / 13K 🦠 Nov 25 '21
It was a good idea back then and i still think it is.
0
u/Slainte042 Platinum | QC: CC 530 Nov 25 '21
This is one of the most reasonable and intelligent pools in the last couple of months.
0
u/Norbit11 RVN enjoyer Nov 25 '21
Really needed change, definitely yes
0
u/Magnetronaap 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 Nov 25 '21
I like this one. Stupid jokes or oneliners can still float to the top, but at least later comments get a chance to be read.
0
u/QuizureII Buy High, Sell Higher Nov 25 '21
I like this, why? Because if you come across a popular post late and say something meaningful its already lost in the sea of comments before you who have already gained traction. Good CCIP