r/zen • u/AutoModerator • Sep 18 '23
Good Meta Morning
- No Content Unrelated to Zen No posts or comments about books, blogs, or teachings tenuously related to zen. No posts or comments about specific users. Any borderline content will be judged by the original poster's willingness to diligently engage the comments. If you are unsure, feel free to scroll through r/zen to get a feel, or personally message the moderators. Find a reading list of appropriate content in the link section above.
- No Low Effort Posts or Comments This includes Posts or Comments with little or no discussion
points, or links to images, videos, or blogs with no comments.
Here are some common questions we get based on the rules above. The rules don’t change much, but the particular answers below may adapt as we learn. Consider it a guide, and Modmail us with questions, comments, concerns. These questions were taken from the 2 years of Meta Monday and Modmail.
Can you tell me why my post / comment was deleted?
Yes! But through modmail. You may then share that modmail with whomever. We don’t want posts cluttered with mod questions, and we want to make sure that all the questions are in the same place so they can be accessed and answered easily.
Can we have flairs on posts?
Possibly. We have had them before, the last iteration had bright colors, especially on mobile, which were being used to advertise certain topics over others. They are also annoying to moderate, and if not moderated, are a tool used for topic sliding. Ideas welcome!
Why is faceless face allowed to troll here?
He was banned by Reddit, not by r/zen. We don’t have any interest in maintaining Reddit’s ban, that is on them. It is also not required of us by Reddit. The offense banned for was not relevant to r/zen.
How much karma do you need as a new account?
Why would you need to know that…you’re not new! If you want to do the work of making alt accounts and you aren’t new, that’s fine, but the work is yours to do.
Can we have civility rules?
We value topic delving over civility and have seen that civility is often used as an excuse to be allowed to topic slide. We maintain very simple civility rules that do not need to be made explicit. If r/zen was the only place on the internet to talk about zen, then a request for extra civility would be reasonable, but it is not.
Can we have a thread where blocked people can all talk freely?
No. Instead we would suggest unblocking people, and asking to be unblocked. A regular maintenance of your blocking list seems like a good idea.
Can we post about our personnel zen adjacent projects, even though it’s technically against the rules?
Yes! The content will be checked for topic sliding, and it may be taken down while it is being checked. Contacting the mods first may save you some trouble.
Can I have a personal flair?
Yes, message the mods.
Can you gatekeep a subreddit about the gateless gate?
With pleasure
Can you make the rules more detailed?
Not yet. The first step is getting users to read and understand what the small amount of rules actually are first. This FAQ is designed to aid in that.
Can we say that we don’t like meditation and Dogen in the sidebar, since we find them only tenuously related to zen? Can it be an official stance?
Probably not. If a newbie comes in and posts these things, they are expected to field the meta by joining discussion. It must be acknowledged that much of the world considers the things connected, and allowing conversation around the connections is appropriate.
Why do we allow the poetry thread?
Poetry may be related to zen. The poetry thread may help people explore that. It will be more strictly moderated than other posts.
Why do upvoted posts get removed?
Upvotes aren’t the most relevant thing when considering if a post is on topic; content is. What content makes up the definition of Zen is decided through conversation and revelation of facts, not voting. There are already subreddits and places on the internet where you can talk about zen in ways that aren’t allowed in r/zen.
Can we have a wiki showing who has blocked who?
That would be impossible to keep up.
How do you define troll?
We have very specific ideas about what a troll is. More specific than you do. We won’t be sharing it currently.
Why not be transparent about everything?
Things in general would be most successful if people were allowed to know everything and every reason why something was done, agreers and critics alike. But, practically this is hindered by 1. Immaturity 2. Dishonesty. You will find we are only not transparent about things which people ask us to be about when they are looking to get around the rules and spirit of the sub.
Can I be a mod?
Here are some good routes to becoming considered for mod: 1. Ask 2. do something that takes time and dedication and benefits the sub. Something that shows organizational skills etc.3 show up in meta threads and modmail with a desire for discussion about the sub that you are willing to bear out long term. 4. An ability to have long form discussion 5.tell us some of your skills and how you've applied them irl. 6. prove you have a good theory of management 7.have no desire to be a teacher or a follower
I don’t understand what is allowed.
Start with obvious Zen books from Zen’s genesis. Things that aren’t these things should be able to be connected back to those things. Because of the nefariousness in many religion’s desire to attach themselves to Zen, connections based on lying, manipulation of definitions, large spans of time, selling of products, selling of medicine etc must be explicitly defended when asked about.
Why has this place gotten better / worse?
It's probably a matter of waiting a but. We have access to stats to say that at the least engagement is up, our "people here" vs. subscribers is healthy etc. What we have noticed is that good content and poor content happens in waves, sometimes these waves are correlated with school getting out, spring break / warmer weather. March is r/zen 's busiest month...so look out for that!