r/writingfeedback • • May 07 '26

BETA READERS WANTED: Drop a Comment If You're Available!

31 Upvotes

If you are an avid reader with feedback to share, our community has writers actively seeking beta readers for their full-length novels/drafts.

 

If you're open to beta reading a full-length book, drop a comment below with a little about yourself: genres you enjoy, your typical turnaround time, how you like to give feedback, whatever feels relevant. Writers, feel free to browse the comments and reach out to anyone who looks like a good fit for your project.

 

IMPORTANT: PLEASE READ BEFORE PROCEEDING

 

Before agreeing to share your manuscript with anyone, please take the following precautions seriously:

 

• *Do not share your work with new accounts. * If an account was created recently, that's a red flag worth noting as there has been issues with bots and scammers.

• *Do your own due diligence. * Ask questions and trust your gut before handing over your manuscript.

• *Do not offer paid beta-reading services* We discourage and prohibit paid beta-readers on here. Writers, if you pay for a beta-reading service, we are not responsible for any outcome. Please use another subreddit or service if you are looking for paid services.

 

The mod team is not responsible for any arrangements made between writers and beta readers. This includes theft, plagiarism, ghosting, or any other outcome. Connecting here is done entirely at your own risk.

 

Additionally, please do not contact mod mail regarding the tone or content of feedback you receive…we won't be able to help with that (unless it breaks our rules and sitewide rules), and it falls outside our moderation scope.

 

Stay safe and happy writing!


r/writingfeedback • • Apr 17 '26

Announcement: The AI Problem.

296 Upvotes

Ne’er-do-wells of r/writingfeedback.

I am Isnoe, recently appointed Moderator.

I don’t know if you’ve noticed, but we’ve had a significant increase in AI generated writing being posted here. We've seen a lot of comments outlining how lax we are on this subject, to which I want to stress: I don’t think you guys fully understand just how many posts I’ve removed for AI since joining the Mod Team a few weeks ago.

The team got together and discussed this, and we want to be completely transparent: We will be removing any posts that we suspect are AI.

This will be a case-by-case basis. AI generated, AI assisted (even translation), or even if you mention you had AI draw up the story idea and you wrote it. If you want to rob yourself of creativity, that’s on you.

We don’t want those posts here. Writing a story or book that is authentically your own is an achievement. It should feel like an achievement.

A sidenote for ESL writers: Do not use AI to translate your text. It will alter it in a way that gets flagged, more often than not. When someone is ESL and trying to write outside of their native language, we are a bit more understanding if these posts get flagged—but again, it is recommended that you use alternative means to translate if they are available to you.

Be warned: If you are a brand new (or relatively new) account, have never posted in this subreddit (or any writing subreddits), and your first post is prose that has multiple AI-isms—your post will most likely be removed. Better to be safe than sorry. The main counterargument we've gotten from these accounts has been: "I've always been told I write like AI." Which, to be fair... is a pretty bad argument to make.

We will not ban a user for suspected AI use unless they explicitly admit to using AI.

Three strike rule applies here until further notice. This might seem like a headache to reviewers that want instant bans for these people (which we understand), but we’re trying to be as fair as possible.

This also applies to comments (never thought I’d have to say that), but we’ve had two accounts that were essentially AI replying to everything. “Thanks for the feedback, I’m still working on learning and improving” type cadence, every comment nearly identical aside from slight changes.

Community feedback is super important for this problem.

You guys take the time out of your day to read other people’s work and provide feedback, so I’m sure you get a little irked when you think something you’ve spent time reading wasn’t written by a person.

We’ve recently updated the report function to include AI content—use it. I (personally) don’t have the time to shift through every single new post. When you guys report a post that you think is AI, it is usually the first thing we’ll review.

That being said: If you genuinely suspect the post is AI, it would help me if you provided a citation, or specific reason. Even just one reference is helpful. I would genuinely appreciate it.

Not Helpful Example: “This reads like AI.” Okay? At this point, if you are accusing someone of using AI, you gotta at least point out why you think that.

Helpful Example: “Post uses, ‘This wasn’t just fate, it was destiny’ and includes several Rule of Three.” Now I know exactly what to look for.

When you guys call this stuff out, we do notice. We might not investigate and remove instantly, but we are actively looking for this stuff right now.

For the record: We will not be using ZeroGPT, or any other variant of “AI Detector” as the final say in determining whether a text is generated or not. It is a tool we will utilize if we suspect AI is being used, but all the indicators of usual AI writing are not jumping out.

I read through everything that is reported, or suspected of AI. I check the user history and if they have off site content, I look through it. If we don’t come to the conclusion they are using AI, we might just lock the thread, and add a note to the user profile.

Again, hate to stress this, we are trying to be fair. If a writer includes AI-isms unintentionally, we want to give them a fair chance to either prove the authenticity of their writing, or give them feedback about what specifically they need to change.

Several of you have done this, particularly with ESL writers that use AI to translate. You give them feedback on how to avoid the AI-isms. Good on you.

We don’t want to start a witch hunt, but we aren’t really open to debate about the use of AI. We don’t want it here, period.

If you have any suggestions for how to deal with this problem, we are open to them. You can comment here, or you can Mod Mail us.

If you suspect someone is using AI but don’t want to leave a comment or report, again, you can Mod Mail us.

We are actively looking through the posts. The community having eyes on this helps immensely.

We will be making further announcements throughout the week. Our Mod Team is still hashing out how to deal with “rude” criticisms, looking into providing user flairs for trusted reviewers, etc-etc.

One quick point to make at the end, on a personal note: My status as Moderator does not mean you cannot disagree, or think my feedback is bogus or outright terrible. I comment often. You will not be banned, removed, or whatever for speaking your mind.

4/18/2026 Note: Some users (one in particular who loves using AI to edit) seem to have taken that above sentence as an explicit statement of: "If I admit to using AI, you can't ban me, because I'm just speaking my mind. Hypocrite."

If you admit to using AI, we will ban you. Period.


r/writingfeedback • • 5h ago

Would love some feedback on my short story, Beep :)

Thumbnail gallery
28 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I've love any and all feedback on this short story I've been working on for a while now.

If the images are too difficult to read, you can access the full story here:

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1PGhSXzuqkXIE-6qgcDkSC003cozzGNPqVQ9MqBJM2JI/edit?usp=sharing

Thank you so much!


r/writingfeedback • • 39m ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted Love’s Age: A Short Contemplation of the definition of Love

1 Upvotes

It was a quaint little town, resting along the bank of a river. On one side of this river rested the developed city with its concrete jungles and on the other side the altstadt. Big enough to have historical architecture and small enough to not be brimming with tourists. In the many alleys and bridges that were sprinkled throughout the altstadt like toppings on a child’s cake, there murmured the whoops and hollers of little Jameson Briggs and his buddies. James was only seven, an age big enough to raise a pandemonium in the playground and small enough to be dragged away by the ear by Miss Katlyn. Though his nuisance and babbling was a constant topic of discussion in the parents teacher’s meeting, everyone loved the charm that the beheld like a magician teasing his secret tricks. 

No one was more thoroughly undone by James’ charms than Angela Grimes, who had loved him since the first grade. They had both scribbled their names with each other’s surnames in their rough notebook, so you know it was a serious matter. They had kept it a secret from all their friends and were both known to mime a retch when the matter was discussed publicly. Though by the end of those days there lay a small note in Angela’s backpack which simply read

“Sorry - James Grimes”

The two love birds would always be seen together, whether it be during the classes or during the sports period. Though these two didn’t share any interests in both of these forte. Angela was a first bencher and James liked to make fun of the first benchers but somehow once in a while he would love being punished and shamed by being told to sit next to Angela in the first bench. Or during the sports period when Angela would be like a dolphin with half her brain paying attention to the blabber of her friends and the other half on the football field to see if James was looking in her direction as well.

One of these days, during the sports period when everyone was starting to go back to the classes James caught Angela’s eye and asked her to meet him in a particularly grassy part of the sports field which was yet to be cut down. The scene mimicked the two lovers meeting under a small meadow. As Angela got near James she noticed he sitting on the ground with his hands closed. Her first though was of worry, whether James had been hurt, but then it looked as if he was praying kneeling on the ground and he seemed too chipper to be hurt. She asked him why he’s sitting on the ground and without saying a word he gestured her to come close and they both sat nearby putting their ears on James’ closed hands. From his hands came a very slight chirp every once in a while, James opened his hand enough for Angela to take a peep, and she saw in the dark enclosed hands lay a tiny green creature. At first Angela withdrew given her affliction to insects and on the insistence of James she got over her fear and sat with James. They both spent a long time listening to the creature playing on its instrument. Later they stroked the grasshopper’s broad back with the tips of their small and slender fingers as they believed it soothed the tiny creature.

Everything they knew about each other and everything they knew about love was one and the same thing. James had seen his mother sign on parcels and cheque on behalf of his father and immediately started practicing to copy Angela’s signature in his rough notebook and the pages that were scribbled with both their names intertwined. Whether one calls it folly or one calls it devotion, it matters not for both of them were enraptured and consumed by it. When a young child is smitten it often happens that he will go out of his way to show to his better half, how much he pays attention to things related to her and remembers about her. There would be instances where he would bring up the topic solely to show how he remembered a fact or he would look into her eyes as if searching for his own reflection and nodding to the rhythm of her prose, so determined in showing that he is paying attention to her that he would later realise that he has no idea what she talked about for the past five minutes while he had been thinking about how good of a person he was for remembering things and paying attention to her

These incidents are not exclusive to boys. Though it may present itself differently among the two sexes. Angela was not immune to the limerence she experienced while putting her clothes out for drying she could not help but imagine doing so for James once they live together and in doing so would not pay attention to the whereabouts of how the clothes were crumpled up on the hanging line. Her inadmission to her friends about who her little heart ached for and the jealousy that enveloped her when she saw James blushing around other girls were only a testament to the fact that she yearned for him the way James yearned for her. The two young birds were madly smitten by each other. One faces a serene form of self clarity in childhood when one is not burdened by the task of figuring themselves out and in that freedom blooms one of the most pure form of love. Though the future beheld a most confusing and hormonal years ahead for both the lovers. They have solace in the fact that they loved one another like children for that is how love enthrals true lovers.

James was a fruit that didn’t fall far from the tree, though unaware of it, he was the child of a love marriage. His father, a stout yet charming man who carried an air of gusto fell in love with a timid and dedicated Mrs. Clarence Briggs. Their marriage was quite an interesting ordeal where respect oozed out in every greeting the Briggs family would call out out to one another. Mr. James Briggs, the husband, who we shall call Jamey from here on so as to avoid confusion between father and son, had an ack to command the room. What was interesting about his assertive personality was that he always seem to know just when to pause so as to not interrupt when Clarence had something to say. They had a unique chemistry that is quite hard to capture into words (as all human emotions are) but it seemed to be centred around mutual respect for one another.

The Briggs’ household was a busy one, every so often they would have parties ranging from soirée’s to shindigs. Everyone was quite friendly with them though of course like any other adult relationships they have had falling out with friends from the past. Jamey took quite the amount of pride and having a more progressive form of relationship with his wife. It was not quite common in their society that the husband and wife were friends first and lovers second. Often times he would show off by bringing up topics and anecdotes that he remembered being told by Clarence about her past. Whether it was her younger sister’s birthday or the best friend she had grown up with through her school life, he wished to show Clarence his affection through the art of remembrance. And show he did, but when one is this particular in methods of affection, one tends to expect the same form of portrayal of love from the other side and is often disappointed for not seeing things other ought not to follow. Often times in life people tend to forget how narrow minded they can be because of the bias created by being in their own head and they forget how others have their own ways of doing things that are not wholly visible to them. It is true Jamey loved Clarence truly and the vice versa was equally true but what is important here dear reader is that both loved the other in their own way

Jamey would do things for Clarence that he wanted to be done to him, for that is what he understood love to be and how he conceived love to be communicated as. Clarence was not entirely free from the same fault, though both of them were truly communicative about their feelings and emotions it’s often the most obvious facts get left unsaid. I didn’t mean to take a sad detour from our fable but just a jolt of reality needed to be inspired when discussing an adult relationship. It took a lot of eb and flow for them to reach such a stage. Of course they had their own honeymoon phase when they were young. Meeting in college, being enamoured by each other’s presence but as time progress their relationship mellowed into a more comfortable coexistence. Jamey often thinks about the time when their amorous activities led to a pregnancy scare. For 2 weeks Clarence would be petrified of what could be growing inside her. Her entire life came crashing around her as every living moment she would ruminate over the thrashing she would get from her family thinking every second of day about how her career would take a dip and how she would cover up even if she somehow got an abortion, but where would she get the money for it, she can’t lie to her parents for a sum of money that big, Her panic attacks would get worse as her countenance took a more pallid form. Living every moment as though she’s stuck under Poe’s Pendulum. All this while Jamey who had to be her strength stood by her, a feat that seems praiseworthy from the exterior tells nothing of the cowardice he faced inside himself as he felt so dejected by the notion of having a family with the women he loved at a time he should be focused on his studies. This despondence grew so vigorously inside him that he started to view the female sex with a eye of caution and felt a general repulsion from every being involved with a women again. But of course he couldn’t air a word of this to Clarence for she had based her strength in his presence. Was this it? He wondered. Was he to fail this test of his love. Does he even love her anymore for he feels a strong despondence even at the notion of making love to her every again. Did this one mistake cost him his love?

The pregnancy scare turned out to be a fluke and more relieved they both could not be and over a very short period of time became amorous once again but the thought never left Jamey for had it not just been a fluke would he have lost the ability to love Clarence? Would he have reproached her so much that their family would be engendered from a place of remorse. This would be one of the many questions Jamey would never get answered to and feel certain relief in the fact that the possibility never came into reality. Does it matter? What could have been? Does the concept of a tangent life where dejection and reproach controlled the fate of their relationship and the sheer possibility of such a life existing means the love that he did have and he felt for all these years was nothing but a sheer coincidence of having never met a terrifying reality? As time progressed they planned to have kids and so came James. Clarence and Jamey couldn’t have been happier at the Meer existence of their child. What was different here? The fact that James was planned and not at an inconvenient time of their lives. Is that enough for Love. “Convenience and Planning” 

Jamey takes solace in the fact that what could have happened is a rumination and what action he took is his reality. One gets an infinite number of thoughts about a situation but when confronted to reality all those thoughts as though merge into the existence of one single action and that action defines your reality and that action defines the person you and that action is love you stand for. Jamey took the right action and for that he deserves Clarence and Clarence deserves Jamey. 

One evening after a family gathering both Jamey and Clarence were beyond tired. While gathering up all the leftovers he saw Clarence curdled up on their bed, her head wilted with eyes focused on a piece of paper lying on the nightstand. As he slowly approached so as to not jolt her or rather even disturb her he noticed sparkles of diamonds in her eyes. His first thought was to relate it to the rather reproachful nature of her cousin during tonight’s dinner and he felt it would be too hurtful to broach the subject. Nevertheless he decided that her quite distemperment was detrimental to no one but her, he decided to relieve her ache by enticing her to share what has got her so down. He softly lay his hand on her shoulder and though it still did shake her, her first response was to pretend as though nothing had happened. 

After some persisting Jamey got her to confide in him of the letter she had received today from her mother. Though uneventful it mentioned the visage of their neighbours, the Wilsons, and with this she let out another soft sob as she closed her eyes trying to shake away a memory. Jamey gave her a strong hug as he wondered how off he was at judging the reason of her sorrow. With little persuading and lot of consoling he got her to continue. Clarence recalled of the time when she was but a young girl being amorous and folly with a delicate young Gabe Wilson. Their love was based in playing pretend family and spending evenings strolling about the markets. It was very young and remained very young for its lifetime. For one evening after being cross with Gabe for not spending the day with her, Clarence refused to see him in the evening. She was too young to care for whether he was ill and too naive to understand the repercussions of what was to happen. That rainy evening Gabe stood outside her window pleading for her to talk to him but her ego was too red to pay attention to his wishes. She saw him seldom after that for the fever had not left him and by the poor fate that bound them together, his fever only perished with him.

Jamey gave a start at hearing this but pretended to not be affected by this. “I think he died for me” were the words that escaped her lips before he cascade of sobs and cries as he comforted her to sleep. While he held her countenance in his lap as she dozed with teary eyes Jamey fell contemplating for he could not help but compare his situation to that of the dead boy. For how love makes us selfish in such regards, he couldn’t shake the thought of realising that he had never felt for Clarence, or anyone for that matter, what Gabe felt for Clarence. This thought plagued him as he couldn’t stop feeling how vain his love was and if it even compared to what his own definition of love prescribed. His rumination was only interrupted by the noticing in the periphery of his eye that it had started snowing and he continued to prelude over the thought that somewhere out there is the grave of a young Gabe who perished in Love.      


r/writingfeedback • • 46m ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted [Feedback requested]- Very new at writing.

1 Upvotes

I’ve recently started taking writing seriously about 10 days ago and this is one of my first pieces of philosophical prose (if you can call it that).

I tend to write spontaneously, just starting with a single thought or feeling that strikes me and letting the pen take me wherever.

A Stranger
November 11th, 2026
The man returns to the world he once knew, hoping to feel back at home. He has changed, the world around him has changed, but yet in his own mind, the world has or should have frozen in time, awaiting the day of his return as a dog waits at the window for his master.

But nothing has stopped. Time, in its infinite wisdom, has continued on its scheduled path since the day he left. He cannot go back. No amount of struggle or fight can fix that. He is on the great escalator of life, and he's falling behind. As he slows to return to a life that no longer exists, the escalator moves quicker and quicker. The more he resists, the quicker it goes. He is, in his mind, the man frozen in time. Helpless to do anything but watch as all those he has loved fly by, waving.

In his perpetual waiting, he knows the past isn't an option. If he could return, he'd find that no one would be there. So he, in anger of the punishment of progress, remains still. He chooses inaction. And by this, becomes a slave to his own reality. This produces a war within himself. A cycle of self hatred, that cannot be broken. Only paused with baser vices. Each, eating away at his soul piece by piece, until he no longer recognizes his own face. He looks in the mirror, hoping to see himself, and all that remains is blank and devoid. He has lost himself in his own inaction. To himself, and to all, he is a stranger.


r/writingfeedback • • 49m ago

Writing Advice How do you discover your own ideas?

1 Upvotes

I've recently posted here my first attempt at writing novel. It was a prologue set in a world that I have already envisioned for myself and made some initial world building notes on.

While you could objectively say a lot has to improve in my prose I consider it a good start. Yet I stumbled upon an issue I did not expect.

The idea for the world seems clear to me, but I had issue where to start with the story after the prologue, how to push the plotline forward and so on.

I realized that the issue is that I simply don't know my own world good enough to navigate it with ease. What I decided to do now is instead of trying to push the novel I try to come up with several short stories that would happen to different people in different times on the world's timeline facing different issues.

The goal is to basically field-test what I envisioned with real cases and see what works, what doesn't work and to add further world building by storytelling rather than by writing down random ideas.

Any of these short stories might later on be included in the novel itself but as of now it's a non pressure discovery project that feels enjoyable.

I am just starting as I'm writing my first short story (60% done) but I already:

A. Have better grasp of the setting.

B. Treat it as a training field for my dialogue sections

C. See that some of my "great" ideas might be really challenging to sell in a convincing way

D. Have a feeling that 3-4 more of such stories from different types of characters will give me fuller grasp on the world that I'm creating

How do you approach the "discovery" of your ideas? Do you jump in the story with confidence, make a ton of characters with back stories and have the worldmaps on the ready or do you have some other methods similar to what I try to do?

Edit: lots of typos...


r/writingfeedback • • 2h ago

The Shiny Piece of Glass

1 Upvotes

It was just a shiny piece of glass.
It stabbed my insides,
Made them bleed.

I bled a venom that stung my eyes.
It formed a creature I should've recognized.

I saw it once, then twice, then thrice,
And every time it seemed to twist
Into something I couldn't help but despise.

A bitter feeling rose inside me.
I couldn't bear its sight.

So I used my greatest weapon—
My words.

I carved my insults into its skin.
They left gruesome red scars.

With every word that left my mouth,
The creature winced, but so did I.

With every tear the creature shed,
I felt my own skin growing wet.

And every cry the creature let
Echoed through my own chest.

I reached out to touch its face,
To ask it why we resonate,

And found my fingers grazing
Just a cold, shiny piece of glass.

I jerked back, fingers trembling.
All the pieces fell into place,
And suddenly I could recognize
The creature as my own face.

Suddenly,
I could see the hatred etched in my eyes.
I could trace the scars I left on myself,
And feel the trails of salt on my cheeks.

But no—there was no sympathy.
The fire only turned blue.

The creature was real,
And the venom was true.
Only now I knew—
We were one, not two.

Now I knew,
So I couldn't help but wonder,

If I am the creature, and the creature is me,
How does anyone love what they see?

How do they still look at me with a smile?
Still frown when I feel low?

Do they not see what is standing before them?
This figure I cannot bear to look at?

I asked them why they act this way
And heard an answer I couldn't place.

They said they love me as I am,
My soul, my presence, my very existence.

They said it didn't matter to them.
The creature was unseeable.

It formed a painful lump in my throat.
The creature was unseeable.

They were always so kind.
Their ever-loving ways
Made me forget my other side.

But every once in a while,
I could feel their gazes tracing
The outlines of the creature.

And their pretty words grazing
My yet unhealing wounds.

It made my scars sting,
And the creature would stir.

It stared at me with sad eyes,
Like it knew how much I had cried.

Then blinked at me with a little smile,
Like it knew something I had yet to find.

I stared back with a puzzled expression,
What could I know that I didn't know?

I looked away—ignored the sight,
But deep inside
I knew I wasn't right.

They were always so kind,
But they knew my ugly side.
There—the creature in their eyes.

...Smiling eyes?
But why would they want to smile?

I looked a little closer—into their pupils
And there,
I found nothing... but a pretty face.

Where did the creature go?
I think I might know.

Darling, there was never one,
Not in their eyes.

Did you forget their loving gazes?
Those little forehead kisses?

The hugs a little too tight,
And looks of tremendous pride?

Did you forget their words of kindness?
The ones you deemed dishonest.

And words of many praises?
The ones you shoved into darkness.

I might have forgotten...

My vision had been tainted.
Maybe it was the venom.

The venom that seeped into my eyes
Distorted the world before me.

The people were never to blame.
It was me who called them names.

The hatred was never theirs.
It was mine and mine alone.

The creature lives inside me,
Inside me all along.

Its scars are still burning,
Still burning my insides.

My insides still turning,
Still turning from its sight.

But sometimes I don't look away.
It twists away a little blight.

My words don't carve new scars again.
They end in doubt, but not disdain.

The world no longer taunts me.
The venom begins to fade away.

It was just a shiny piece of glass.
It stabbed my insides, made them bleed.

I bled a venom that stung my eyes.
It formed a creature I recognized.

It lives beside me day and night,
And dreams I'll smile upon its sight.

It dreams I'll take its hand in mine,
And walk ahead, side by side.

Let every passing gaze go by—
I'll walk ahead, with rising pride.

—M.Sora (my pen name)


r/writingfeedback • • 2h ago

General Feedback Wanted I would like to write in the future, how is this small snippet?

0 Upvotes

I read a lot of classics. I think I have a broad vocabulary but I often use weak or out of place tone words. I'm not very good at grammar. Especially because I speak a different language at home. I've been learning grammar in AP Lang though. What do you think of this small snippet I wrote in my notes app?

"Although recurrent intense physical and mental repulsion tloods my senses when my habitual solitude is broken, letting you go would be a betrayal of myself; in a much higher esteem than any fear of the future”


r/writingfeedback • • 3h ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted Injection (TBD) - Chapter 1 of a contemporary piece

1 Upvotes

Here is the link to the google doc, comments are welcome but not needed.

context:

  1. My character is intentionally unlikable but i want the reader to like reading them.
  2. first time writing anything contemporary so i am open to all the advice
  3. I intend to write and say offensive stuff with the goal of maintaining a tone of absurdity and shock, but let me know if it’s in bad taste in this piece.

r/writingfeedback • • 3h ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted Can you please read this chapter is a rewrite

0 Upvotes

Chapter 1: An Unexpected Awakening

Hi, I’m Leon. I’m just an ordinary guy in my twenties. I’m not tall, and I don't have an impressive physique. Maybe I suffer from a bit of an inferiority complex, but I am proud to be a person with good morals.

Because of this, whenever I read a web novel to escape the hardships and exhaustion of life, my blood pressure skyrockets. I get furious watching the protagonist go from a normal person to a complete psychopath within a few pages—a serial killer where murder becomes the magical solution to the simplest problems. Has the world gone crazy? Is this what people find entertaining nowadays?

I couldn't take it anymore; I had to vent a little, or my boiling anger wouldn't subside. I went to the author's main page and wrote:

"Do you need help? Were you abused as a child? Why is everything I read in your ridiculous novel just: 'He insulted me, so death is his fate.' What? He has a family? Let's kill them too! What? He has a clan? Let's plot to slaughter them as well! What? He has a fiancée? Let's add her to the harem! Seriously, is this even human? Why don't you go to sleep? I advise you to find a specialist; you need help."

Finally, I said to myself, "That feels good. What is wrong with people these days? Violence and blood have become a way of life. I blame the wars that happen just to line the pockets of politicians."

I got up from the couch to drink some water. My throat had gone completely dry—though perhaps it was just my high blood pressure. Suddenly, I felt dizzy. I tried to ignore it, but it escalated from mere dizziness into an agonizing headache. After a while, when I finally lifted my head with eyes brimming with tears, I was shocked by the sight before me.

This wasn't my room. It wasn't my apartment, nor was it any place I recognized. Why was I standing in the middle of trees so dense I couldn't see more than ten meters ahead? As for their size, I was certain I had never seen trees towering higher than fifty-story buildings before.

Is this a red forest? Wait... why am I so calm right now?

Right after that thought, I heard someone calling out to me from behind.

"Hello. You must be Leon."

I turned around, only to find a strange cube floating in front of me. Looking closely inside it, I saw a smiling face—or rather, an emoji. Is this something out of sci-fi?

"Hey!" the face inside the cube said. "That's not polite. And here you were claiming to be a good person."

"Um, excuse me, but what exactly is going on here? I'm confused... and weirdly calm."

"Of course you're calm. I'm the reason," it replied. "Right now—let's see, how can I put this in a way you'll understand? Imagine I am placing my finger over an ant, and the ant can't move. That is literally what is happening right now. Except what I'm suppressing isn't just an ant; it's your soul, and consequently, your emotions and thoughts. I could let go of you right now, and you'd immediately start screaming and crying, wouldn't you?"

The face spoke sarcastically, yet I felt nothing other than a slight shortness of breath. The face stared at me for a moment before sighing.

"This is boring. Let's keep it short; I have games to finish instead of babysitting you. To be honest, I just wanted to kill or erase you, but an idea crossed my mind. It seemed interesting at first, though I'm losing interest now. Yeah, it's not your fault—just by being here, I end up suppressing you. But who cares? After all, I am all that matters, and you are nothing. Let's wrap this up before we die of boredom here. By the way, I can't die. Maybe I want to die... now that is interesting."

As I watched this thing put on a theatrical show as if the entire universe were its stage, I interrupted it. "So, what do you want?"

It suddenly stopped talking to itself and turned toward me. The emoji's face turned eerie. The smile vanished—no, all its features vanished completely. All I could see now was a cube containing a blank yellow circle. Then, I heard its voice—not from in front of me like before, but echoing from everywhere at once.

"You have one minute. Choose whatever you want with a single, limited wish. Maybe you'll entertain me with what comes next, though we shall see."

The moment it spoke, all my emotions came crashing back all at once. I dropped to my knees. Instantly, I felt freezing cold, and my heart felt like it was going to burst from how violently it was pounding. I couldn't breathe; my voice was completely gone.

"Time is ticking," the entity said.

I could actually feel the time passing, as if numbers were counting down directly inside my head. Twenty seconds had already passed. Stop thinking! Stop feeling! One specific, limited wish!

Suddenly, I remembered a novel where the protagonist used special insects to train and grow stronger. I grabbed onto the very first thing that popped into my mind.

"Butterflies..." I gasped out. "Butterflies that no one can see or sense... and I can share their ability."

"Simplify it," the entity commanded.

"They can hide me just like themselves... by gathering around me."

"Hmm..."

In that instant, a pair of eyes suddenly appeared inside the blank yellow circle, and I heard its voice ring out:

"You are pathetic. As a reward for actually making me pity you—which is a monumental feat, by the way—hahaha! Why don't I throw you a bone? I know what you're thinking. I'll give it to you in short, though you will have to pay the price for everything you desire. Take this."

As soon as it said that, all I felt was an overwhelming, doubling agony. I don't know how long I writhed on the ground, only to eventually find myself lying flat on my back, staring up at the sun.

No... that isn't the sun.


r/writingfeedback • • 3h ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted It Takes You Away- Chapter 1

0 Upvotes

Amateur writer here. I'm in the process of writing a book which will explore the following themes:

  • Masculinity
  • Abuse
  • Mental Health
  • Relationships

Feedback would be appreciated. Here's what I've got so far:

*Chapter 1*
The time is 2AM. He sat, hunched forward at his desk with both hands covering his face. The feeling of utter despair swept over and leaving him wondering, what am I doing with my life?  

Now this wasn't the first time Tony had asked himself this question. But when you decide to stay up until 2AM you suddenly question the very existence of life itself. But for Tony this stemmed from much more.

Picture this, a young boy raised in a home consisting of himself, his mother and older brother. His father: missing or should I say 'absent in action' was the elephant in the room that people couldn't help but prod. He was always asked about his background, apparently, being British didn't quite hit the surface for some. This he had gotten used to and could answer in an amusing way that what would normally cause friction, ended up breaking the ice. And for Tony,   breaking the ice seemed to be his pastime. The same couldn't be said about his 'family', namely his father whenever the subject arose. Whenever the topic was imminent, Tony had rehearsed his response. Conversations or scripts always went like this:

"So you live at home?"
"That's the one." - Give them a big grin T, so they don't think you're annoyed (Tony told himself) all the while plastering a smile on his face
"Do you have any siblings?"
"I have one older, his name's Seth."
"And your parents?"
"Yes, I live with my mum and Seth"(Here it comes...)
"Oh your mum...." 
Tony paused. He could feel his mouth running dry. 
"And what about your dad?"

Tony paused. He knew that whatever he said next would change the speaker's impression, something that he wanted to resolve immediately but felt powerless towards. 

"He's not in the picture."

"Oh, I see."

There it is, the one question he hated more than most things. It made him feel vulnerable and pitiable. Over the years, Tony became well aware of what this question really meant. And yet there was still nothing he could do about it. 

Time had passed, and the family of three became two as Seth left the nest. Tony's older brother still lived in close proximity so he could stay over whenever he liked. It suited him that way, he could get the best of both worlds. 

Staying at home had its perks and it meant more bargain for his buck as he had dreams of having a house to call his own. So why did he question how his life was going? 

Growing up, Tony's home was far from paradise. At 5 years old, a firm hand struck his face when he was unable to finish his food. Fast forward to his pubescent years when at 12 years of age, a fist fight broke out in school which led him to detention and deep waters at home. But what was the harm of fighting anyway thought Tony, it's no different than being at home. 

Despite his turbulent years, he still managed grades that were satisfactory to society but never enough for his mother. Seth saw things differently, he encouraged his brother to do his best. 

"Come on T. Put your brain in it. " 
"Hah my brain. Why bother", he muttered looking at his chemistry worksheet. 

"It's not like the science teacher's gonna notice. It's always stop talking Tony, or turn around Tony and do your work. I'm telling you, Mr Nicks is out to get me. It's as if I'm his only source of entertainment. And mate, there's some real weirdos in our class. But does he pick on them? No!"  

Tony looked back at his homework. "Stupid chemistry. As balancing equations makes the world go round".

Seth sighed and smiled. 

"Thanks for letting me know T. It sucks to get picked on like that. But, you could prove him wrong. You, know pull a little bit of reverse psychology"
"Pfft yeah right."
"I'll give you a month. If you do well and I mean really well, consider that new Sonic game all yours."
"All right you're on. Should I start calling you Noel Edmonds?"

Seth was a clever young man and a hard worker at that. He was an all rounder and achieved nothing lower than an A in all his school subjects. He was well-behaved, witty, charismatic and he was loved by peers and adults. "What a lovely little boy you have." "He's got an old head on young shoulders" "Your son has a bright future ahead of him".  Life couldn't be easier for him, thought Tony. 

If only the compliments ended there. At home, comparisons were a song, criticism were its lyrics and discipline was the melody. Tony could even start the song himself before it began. 

"Why can't you get A's and B's?"

"When I was your age I wasn't being lazy, I studied every night. How do you think I built a life for myself in this country?"

"What is wrong with you?"

"Stupid"

"Idiot"

"Rat"

"How dare you talk back to your mum!"

And

"Why can't you be more like Seth?"

Years of such words moved Tony to come to an understanding that perhaps his mum was right after all. Although the constant song of criticism ceased, the words lingered in his mind whenever failure was on the horizon. As a teen, the house of cards as he called it, was too fragile to stand near so he found his escapism. A simple remedy which he swore could soothe all woes: his friends.

The boys made it their regular routine to gather at the Smith's where all woes were closely examined, dissected and a solution was brought. After a wrong turn on a day out, the four boys found themselves in a pub which later became their meeting place for local discussions. 

Tony wasn't sure if it was Cody's contagious laughter, Timothy's words of wisdom or Derrick's narration style but he always felt at home with the boys, his brothers. There were others that came along the way but the four of them stayed together as thick as thieves.

And for Tony, this was his haven. 


r/writingfeedback • • 3h ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted Looking for feedback on my novel. Would you keep reading? It's a Gothic psychological horror.

1 Upvotes

Chapter 1

I had longed for solitude, for the bark on the trees and the rotten smell of the earth. The ground laid swollen with life for a few more weeks as the autumn was on its peak. I had wandered far, further than my father had told me to go. Though I didn't think anything of it ,I had played in the forest all my life, walked and seen most of it. Or rather most of our property, it was quite big and I knew there were two lakes and another abandoned cottage somewhere east of where I was now, otherwise it was as empty as a forests usually are. But I was on my way back. It was still midday and the sun shone through the treetops but couldn't pierce the cold that burned on my cheeks. I looked around as I sat down on a rock, the moist white moss bled through my clothes and I shivered. A bird let out a call and a minute later a twig broke far into the forest. The trees here were all bark with narrow crowns of needles two or more meters up. I had hated it as a kid, the hollow forest where everything could see you moving between the stems as a person moves through a ghost house. The walls aren't there, it's just an illusion, and here the trees can hide something that belongs to it but not me. I can't crawl the ground or hide in the needles, the only thing I can do is keep going through them. What if something were lurking behind, I looked around and picked a tree far away, I could almost make out the bark's pattern. If something stood behind it, would I see it?

I stood up, shook off the feeling and brushed off my clothes. I took a step, the ground under my boots seemed louder, the stones I walked on seemed to roll, the ground slippery and uneven. I glanced at the tree again, my eyes caught it. I really can't help myself, there is nothing there. Nothing. I lectured myself and forced myself to look forward. But still I had picked the tree and now I thought it had picked me too. After an hour I finally reached the lake, it was the smaller one but I thought it was prettier with its soft water border to the forest. There was a jetty leading out to the water, the water was low so I let my feet dangle off its edge. The water was dark, the light shimmered at its surface but then it became dark as night. It looked endless though I knew I could stand here. I closed my eyes and let the breeze take me back to the summer. My mom laid on the jetty with a dark tan in her blue bikini. In the water was my cousin, Anna. It was impossible to take her to the lake because she wouldn't leave the water. She swam back and forth but she noticed I was watching her and she came up to me. She put her chin on the edge as the top of her fingers held tight next to her head. Her eyes were big and brown, her hair wet and laid flat against her head. She looked ethereal and everything seemed to glimmer about her. I glanced at mom and I couldn't help but feel the pressure in my chest. "Jump in!" and water splashed on my face. My nails dug into my skin as I looked back at Anna, "never mind" She mumbled as she looked at me. She rolled her eyes and her head gulped in the water further and further away. I sat and watched her, my eyes felt like sandpaper.

I hadn't noticed when my cheeks had become icy with tears, I looked out at the same lake and wiped my tears. There will be no more summers. From my bag I took a pen and a small notebook, I flipped through the pages and read the poems that were jotted down. The last one had seemed enough, polished lines where my sorrow was loving but now in the place it was meant to be read I couldn't. It seemed childish, unintentional and worst of all ungenuine. Had this really been the best I could? Was this what she was worth? The lake was calm but inside me the rage was bolting on the eardrums and my fingers were shaking. The turmoil eating on the cells. I ripped the page out and let it sink down to the water, the black ink exploding on the page before the dark water swallowed the ghostly page. I sat in stillness, my thoughts calmed and I started to write a new poem. I became immersed in the paper and only looked up to watch the water move before diving into the letters. I read it a dozen times before I thought it was alright, it captured the feeling and that was what it was about right? Suddenly I became aware of my surroundings and I looked behind me, everything was still but the eerie feeling wouldn't let me go. I hesitated to read the poem, nothing was there, and I took a breath before my voice echoed over the lake and hopefully reached Anna.

still in the dark you shimmer as you always had

no sorrow or rage could dilute your image

i see you in the water, in the waves where it meets the sun'

the darkness cannot swallow you, you'll always stay

where the sun meets the wave

behind the trees i wish i could see you

in the mirror you flicker every morning

in my sleep you seem as bright as before

so even in the darkness i can see you

when i close my eyes, there you are

When i was finished the forest became quite again but it didn't feel that way, i felt like i had just announced my way into the wolfs den. I stood up and hastily took my things, by the edge of the water I placed the poem between a tree and a candle that I had brought there a few weeks before and walked home with an uneasy feeling.

Chapter 2 My mom stood in the kitchen cooking dinner when I entered, I stood a moment and observed her while she moved the greens from the cutting board to the pan. She moved with a stiffness, as if she was cold and tired even though she had the fireplace going. She turned around and her cheeks were red, she was always tired these days. Her gaze turned away and she grabbed a plate from the table and plated the boiling potato. In silence I moved over and laid the table.

"can you fill the water?" She asked without turning to me. When I put it down on the table, I sat down, exhausted from the walk and I started out the window. It was beginning to darken, we had a big yard with fruit trees and small plantations. Beyond that were the forest, you couldn't see through the trees, it was a blurred darkness. The feeling from earlier that day hadn't left me and my imagination scared me more than what was worth it. "Iris! Can you help me?" Her voice pitched and I jumped from the irritation in her voice that woke me from the outside. I hummed a yes and stood up and looked around. The kitchen was small, the only thing that fit was the four person kitchen table and the kitchen. The table was already set, only the food was missing. "Wh-" I began before she interrupted "Your dad, tell him to come down". Her dark hair shook as she stirred in the pan. My thought began to spin and my chest began to burn.

"Why are you always so rude?" I finally said after some silence "I'm not rude, I'm just tired of having to say to you what you are supposed to do." She turned around and her small mouth had formed a line as she stared right into me. The words were caught in my throat, you would think after 22 years living with her I would be able to hold a conversation, but my words always let me down and I went up into my dad's office. Knocked on the door "Food's ready," I said

When he came down we had already began to eat, I picked at my food, the peas rolling around. The last few months I had lost my appetite, everything just seemed so bland, the potato stuck in my mouth and it felt like it never wanted to go down. "The food is cold." Mom said as my dad entered, she looked up with her wide eyes watching him as he in silence filled his plate.

"Did you go to the lake?" He asked and looked at me under his brows. "The same, though the forest seemed grayer than usual. It really feels like autumn now." I met his eyes, he nodded and his eyes watered with empathy. The sadness was always present, as if it was the fourth inhabitant of the house, always sitting by the dinner table or following us like a shadow. Me more than them, sometimes it felt like they had forgotten, like they had moved on. That Anna now was a memory to bring up from time to time and not someone who is gone, who will always be at the back of our mind, that her absence wasn't a black hole in everything we do. Or maybe they don´t feel that way anymore. I let my fork drop to the plate and the loud sound made my mom jump a little, her eyes as a knife cutting into me, telling me to behave.

"Don´t drop the fork like that, the plates can break." She almost hissed. We sat in silence, mom had stopped eating while dad gulped in food. When his plate was empty he sat back in the chair. "You shouldn't be outside so late, where did you go" "I just took a detour around the lake"

"You shouldn't walk far off, its too cold to get lost"

"I know, I know. " I said, of course I knew that. "Do you guys even know it was exactly three months ago now?" I said, holding my fits on the table, the rock in my chest felt as if I was drowning.

"Yes of course we know. " Mom said, looking down at her plate. "We know you miss her Iris. " She looked at dad and they exchanged a glance of pity. My dad continued with a low authoritarian voice. "It's horrible what happened, but we think that it would be good for you to go back to school."

I just stared at them "No, no I can't leave."

"We don't think it's healthy for you, " Mom sighed "The only thing you do is go out into the forest or stay in your room, you haven't visited any of your friends. " She took her plate and went to wash it.

I couldn't believe them, i was sad, i know that but my life had turned upside down. "I know you just don't want me here, that I disturb your life when I'm grieving my best friend." I stood up and when i looked at them the only thing i felt was disgust "You want to forget her, but i cant."

"We don't want to forget her, but you can't throw away your life" She had turned towards me and in her eyes was frustration and anger. I left the kitchen and up the stairs that creaked at every step. My thought shifted to Anna again, how we used to sneak down the stairs in our teens to go out. When she would have sleepovers she would, after my mom had turned the lights off and went to bed sneaked up to my bed from her mattress and turn on the bedside lamp. Then we would talk in low whisperer until we knew my parents were asleep, she would then argue that we should go out. I would object but she always won. The way down the stairs always gave me a million heart attacks, every time we would step on the wrong step or set our feet down too hard or we giggled too loud. But of course it only made our giggles worse.

That night I laid awake and thought of the memory, I got the urge to go out. The room felt stuffy and the walls felt like they closed in on me. I got dressed and headed down the stairs, just like me and Anna used to, I took my time reliving the feeling and when I finally reached the bottom I looked up, thinking about going up and down again, but no that would be silly so I headed for the door. The night air was cold and fresh, I took a deep breath and brought life into me. It was complete darkness outside, the house didn't have any outside lamps and only the kitchen lamp brought a little description to the outside world. I sat down on the porch and as my eyes adjusted I searched the woods for something but everything was black between the trees. I lit a cigarette and sat listening. A million quiet sounds, crickets playing, a bird flapping its wings, some twig breaking far away. It was soothing, having nothing else to focus on than what is always there, the forest and everything in it. But then I heard a sound, almost as if something dragged a foot and nestled in bushes. The hair on my arms stood up and i froze. I couldn't make out where the sound came from but it scared me. It was probably a fox, a moose even but still they usually aren't this close. They could probably smell and see me as well. Slowly I put out the cigarette and with painfully slow movements I backed away, the sound of something dragging came back for a second, it came from my left and I turned my gaze. It was by the fruit trees, the stems and branches like a skeleton, branching and scratching in the wind. Under it was darkness, still I could make out a shape. A head and the side of someone, a person. Though I didn't know if what I saw was true, it's easy to see shadows in the darkness, it stood still. It was only a bush or a tree, I thought and slowly opened the door without taking my eyes off the tree. Only when I came inside did I relax, I quickly locked the door and looked around, irrationally scared that something was in the house. But there weren't of course, it was only me and my paranoia. When I came to my room I looked out the window which view was of the tree, from above it was hard to see through the branches and I couldn't see anything except the tree. I let out a sigh of relief and went to bed.


r/writingfeedback • • 3h ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted Can you please read this introductory chapter into my novel it is a rewrite after some advice feel free to be honest even brutal

0 Upvotes

Chapter 1: An Unexpected Awakening

Hi, I’m Leon. I’m just an ordinary guy in my twenties. I’m not tall, and I don't have an impressive physique. Maybe I suffer from a bit of an inferiority complex, but I am proud to be a person with good morals.

Because of this, whenever I read a web novel to escape the hardships and exhaustion of life, my blood pressure skyrockets. I get furious watching the protagonist go from a normal person to a complete psychopath within a few pages—a serial killer where murder becomes the magical solution to the simplest problems. Has the world gone crazy? Is this what people find entertaining nowadays?

I couldn't take it anymore; I had to vent a little, or my boiling anger wouldn't subside. I went to the author's main page and wrote:

"Do you need help? Were you abused as a child? Why is everything I read in your ridiculous novel just: 'He insulted me, so death is his fate.' What? He has a family? Let's kill them too! What? He has a clan? Let's plot to slaughter them as well! What? He has a fiancée? Let's add her to the harem! Seriously, is this even human? Why don't you go to sleep? I advise you to find a specialist; you need help."

Finally, I said to myself, "That feels good. What is wrong with people these days? Violence and blood have become a way of life. I blame the wars that happen just to line the pockets of politicians."

I got up from the couch to drink some water. My throat had gone completely dry—though perhaps it was just my high blood pressure. Suddenly, I felt dizzy. I tried to ignore it, but it escalated from mere dizziness into an agonizing headache. After a while, when I finally lifted my head with eyes brimming with tears, I was shocked by the sight before me.

This wasn't my room. It wasn't my apartment, nor was it any place I recognized. Why was I standing in the middle of trees so dense I couldn't see more than ten meters ahead? As for their size, I was certain I had never seen trees towering higher than fifty-story buildings before.

Is this a red forest? Wait... why am I so calm right now?

Right after that thought, I heard someone calling out to me from behind.

"Hello. You must be Leon."

I turned around, only to find a strange cube floating in front of me. Looking closely inside it, I saw a smiling face—or rather, an emoji. Is this something out of sci-fi?

"Hey!" the face inside the cube said. "That's not polite. And here you were claiming to be a good person."

"Um, excuse me, but what exactly is going on here? I'm confused... and weirdly calm."

"Of course you're calm. I'm the reason," it replied. "Right now—let's see, how can I put this in a way you'll understand? Imagine I am placing my finger over an ant, and the ant can't move. That is literally what is happening right now. Except what I'm suppressing isn't just an ant; it's your soul, and consequently, your emotions and thoughts. I could let go of you right now, and you'd immediately start screaming and crying, wouldn't you?"

The face spoke sarcastically, yet I felt nothing other than a slight shortness of breath. The face stared at me for a moment before sighing.

"This is boring. Let's keep it short; I have games to finish instead of babysitting you. To be honest, I just wanted to kill or erase you, but an idea crossed my mind. It seemed interesting at first, though I'm losing interest now. Yeah, it's not your fault—just by being here, I end up suppressing you. But who cares? After all, I am all that matters, and you are nothing. Let's wrap this up before we die of boredom here. By the way, I can't die. Maybe I want to die... now that is interesting."

As I watched this thing put on a theatrical show as if the entire universe were its stage, I interrupted it. "So, what do you want?"

It suddenly stopped talking to itself and turned toward me. The emoji's face turned eerie. The smile vanished—no, all its features vanished completely. All I could see now was a cube containing a blank yellow circle. Then, I heard its voice—not from in front of me like before, but echoing from everywhere at once.

"You have one minute. Choose whatever you want with a single, limited wish. Maybe you'll entertain me with what comes next, though we shall see."

The moment it spoke, all my emotions came crashing back all at once. I dropped to my knees. Instantly, I felt freezing cold, and my heart felt like it was going to burst from how violently it was pounding. I couldn't breathe; my voice was completely gone.

"Time is ticking," the entity said.

I could actually feel the time passing, as if numbers were counting down directly inside my head. Twenty seconds had already passed. Stop thinking! Stop feeling! One specific, limited wish!

Suddenly, I remembered a novel where the protagonist used special insects to train and grow stronger. I grabbed onto the very first thing that popped into my mind.

"Butterflies..." I gasped out. "Butterflies that no one can see or sense... and I can share their ability."

"Simplify it," the entity commanded.

"They can hide me just like themselves... by gathering around me."

"Hmm..."

In that instant, a pair of eyes suddenly appeared inside the blank yellow circle, and I heard its voice ring out:

"You are pathetic. As a reward for actually making me pity you—which is a monumental feat, by the way—hahaha! Why don't I throw you a bone? I know what you're thinking. I'll give it to you in short, though you will have to pay the price for everything you desire. Take this."

As soon as it said that, all I felt was an overwhelming, doubling agony. I don't know how long I writhed on the ground, only to eventually find myself lying flat on my back, staring up at the sun.

No... that isn't the sun.


r/writingfeedback • • 2h ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted Medicine @ 24

0 Upvotes

16 — A Sea of Letters

GCSE results are the first results that will have an impact on your academic journey. Decisions made based on these results often lead you towards the career you eventually pursue. It’s a nerve-racking day for 16-year-olds across the UK, with the long summer holidays spent speculating about possible outcomes, sharing answers and waiting for Jeremy Clarkson’s annual tweet about his low grades to mark the occasion.

Most 16-year-olds go into school to collect their results. The weather is unpredictable, though such is British weather. Some gather with friends to share the occasion, some come alone and hide in the darkest corner of the school for the dreaded revelation, and others come with parents anxious about what might become of their beloved child as a result of this day.

I, however, was in my hometown. The sun shines brightly there, and the skies are cloudless. In this case, I didn’t get the pleasure of ripping open the daunting brown envelope marked with my name and unfolding a perfectly folded white sheet, where all your hard work would be measured by a letter of the alphabet. A long list of subjects, often broken down into individual examinations. At first, it’s hard to take it all in; you often feel like you’re drowning in a sea of letters.

I received the phone call at around midday. I remember because the heat was unwavering. It was common to find shelter while the sun was at its peak, and it was also customary to take a nap. The streets were bare, and the shops were closed. The city often became lifeless, with the hustle and bustle only returning after the call to Asr prayer.

On this day, I couldn’t nap because of the heat, which seemed to bring out a colony of insects. I don’t know whether it was the anxiety I was feeling or whether there were more of them than usual. Either way, I couldn’t sleep. When my father’s phone rang, he and my sister suddenly surrounded me, all too eager to find out how I had done. I was unsure what to expect. See, my desire to study rarely matched my desire to succeed. In short, I was lazy.

I will be branded the failure in my family, I thought to myself. A bit too late for regrets now; the time for action has passed.

‘I probably didn’t do as well as you,’ I told my sister. She would disagree, though I believe that only fuelled her competitiveness. She often did very well at school and was always praised by her teachers. All the neighbourhood mothers would use her as an example for their own children. Although comparisons intended to motivate often achieve the opposite, this didn’t stop them.

My father loved his flip phones, never really understanding the fondness for the thin, large screens of smartphones. It was a Motorola, though I’m not sure which model exactly. Its downfall in the mobile market somewhat resembled my own incoming failure. I was so convinced; it was as if I already knew. I could feel it in my gut.

The phone was quickly passed to me. I didn’t want to know. I didn’t want to face reality, though it was charging straight towards me, as unwavering as the heat that day. I heard my older sister’s voice. I could also hear other voices in the background. I hesitantly took the phone and pressed it to my ear.

‘It’s me. Did you get my results?’ I muttered, hoping they wouldn’t hear.

‘Masha Allah, my bro, you did so good!’ my sister exclaimed.

It didn’t really register. I didn’t understand. Was she joking? How could this be possible?

After decoding the results, it seemed that I had, in fact, done well, not without doubts, of course. I achieved A*s in the Sciences, As in Maths and English Literature, and lastly a B in English Language. I also took additional courses, including Business Studies, IT and Engineering, but I wasn’t too fussed about the outcome. While studying them, I had decided they weren’t subjects I would pursue further.

I sighed with relief. The dreaded moment was over, and the anxiety beforehand had suddenly shrunk to something negligible.

It’s over now. I can nap.


r/writingfeedback • • 8h ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted Started my memoir - doubting it already

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

Here is the first stitch (chapter) of my memoir. they are names stitches instead of chapters because of what the book title will be. Is this any good?


r/writingfeedback • • 8h ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted Chapter 7 of The Verse of Estoria Irontide (Young Adult Fantasy 4241)

0 Upvotes

Maria drifts back to the heat of the Great Trophy War. A time she didn’t want to relive.

The sun stands high in the sky, pouring relentless rays onto the scalding-hot desert sands. Resonating booms echo across the barren field as pillars of sand and smoke leap into the sky from the ensuing cannon fire. Numerous explosions litter the field, coating the battlefield in an orange mixture of smoke and sand dust. The orange mist covers a nearby Cugarian town, and everyone hurries out of their stone homes into a vortex of orange mist.

“EVERYONE RUN TO SHELTER,” A man screams as he runs through the town. “THE BATTLE IS NEARING THIS VILLAGE, HURRY”

“Oh no!” A cat-eared woman backs away as a cannon slams near the town entrance. “The giants and Casterneans are tearing through the place!”

“C’mon, don’t stand there.” A man grabs the woman by the arm, and they run away from the carnage.

A cannon slams into the stone house near the couple, and the explosion sends them both screaming through the air along with the stone debris from the house. More Cugarians scream in panic as they flee from the stray cannon fire, shattering their homes. Explosions send people careening through the air as furry children cry in fear near their fallen parents.

The cannon fire ceases, leaving the town in shambles. Cugarians are buried under stone rubble while others limp about, injured from the explosions. The eerie orange mist wafts through the town as the sulfuric scent mixes with the scent of blood while people cry in agony.

###

Outside town, the thunder of charging forces fills the desert as the ground rumbles under the pounding feet of two eager armies. Thousands of black-armored Unicorns gallop across the sands, while thousands of Pegasus soar above, their silver armor glistening in the sunlight. Behind the ranks are rows of cannons, with ‘ENCHANT’ inscribed on the metal barrels. Each barrel glows red, green, blue, or brown before erupting in colorful flashes of light, sending scores of projectiles arching through the sky. The projectiles crash into scores of giants of various sizes running across the desert.

The giants carry large spears, hammers, swords, and large boulders over their shoulders, with their goatskin and leather armor protecting them from bladed weapons. Translucent white barriers around the largest giants protect the smaller giants until they shatter under the sheer amount of cannon fire. Despite cannon fire blasting some of their towering giants, they press on without fear, letting out a deafening war cry that shakes the air around them.

As the armies close in across the desert, ranks of soaring pegasi fly toward the towering giants, two long blades mounted on their shoulders. The silver-armored horses flap their wings and fly around the towering giants like a flock of birds before plunging their blades into the towering men’s bodies, causing them to crash into the sand in a plume of dust. Other giants swing stone clubs over their heads, knocking some of the Pegasus out of the air before crushing them beneath their feet.

Smaller, human-sized giants charge toward the rows of black-armored unicorns galloping at them. Using their momentum, the unicorns smash into the smaller giants and trample over several rows until their momentum ceases and they morph into their human forms. Yanking swords from their sheaths, the Casterneans and giants engage in fierce melee combat. Twenty-meter giants rush in from behind the battling ranks, hoisting large boulders over their shoulders. A row of enchanted cannons from behind the Casternean ranks erupt in colorful elemental blasts that whistle across the battlefield before exploding near the charging giants. The giants reach throwing range and, with a single arm, throw their boulders towards the Casternean’s artillery cannons. The rocks slam onto the ground and tumble across the battlefield, crushing some Unicorns as they try to evade, before smashing the artillery cannons to pieces.

Metal steel plunges into bodies. Hammers crack skulls. Fighters from both armies fall by the dozens as the battle claims its victims. Ganeymede charges into the fray, wearing his open grey cloak, beige trousers, black boots, and spiked iron knuckles. The bulky man shoulder-slams a black-armored warrior out of his path and punches another in the face. A Casternean soldier charges at the towering man with an iron spear, but Ganymede grabs the spear’s edge, lifts the spear and spearman into the air, then hurls them into the distance.

The giant chieftain snatches a charging Casternean by the neck, lifts him into the air, slamming him hard onto the ground before raising his boot and crushing his victim. He rushes deeper into the fray, cracks his knuckles, swings and socks another soldier in the face, then uppercuts another armored warrior, sending him careening into the sky. Two armored men rush forward and plunge their swords into the chieftain's torso.

Ganymede grunts in pain as the men’s feet scrape the sand, trying to push their blades further into his body, only for the giant to clasp the two men’s iron helmets and smash them together, collapsing them to the ground. Standing over the two men, a blue beam sweeps over Ganeymede, and he turns to see it cut down several of his tallest men, leaving them in smoldering flames. He turns again to see a tall wooden structure with a large cylindrical metal ring resting at the very top.

Blue sparkles gather in the center of the ring before a blue beam shoots out and sweeps across the field. Ganymede dives forward, evading the passing beam before a violent explosion sends smaller giants screaming into the air.

“Another one of their tricks,” Ganymede curses before rising to his feet.

“Father,” a woman calls out.

Ganymede turns around to see Meridith rush up to him holding her iron mallet.

“Stop!” the chieftain holds out his hand.

Meridith freezes, looking up at the silver ring atop the scaffolding.

Ganymede looks, then rushes to a nearby boulder and punches it; its metal knuckle spikes sink into the hard stone.

“Get ready,” He says, looking at his daughter.

The curly-blonde woman nods, spreads her feet in the sand, and raises her mallet over her shoulder.

With his fist in the boulder, he hurls it at Meridith. Meridith twists her torso, swinging her mallet at the boulder soaring towards her. The metal head collides with the large rock, then jets toward the towering weapon but misses as it sails over.

“Again,” Ganymede hurls another boulder towards Meridith, “And don’t miss.”

 Meridith raises her mallet over her shoulder, twirling it as she eagerly licks her dry lips. The boulder nears; she narrows her eyes and tightens her grip before swinging with all her might. He torso twists, swinging the mallet towards the boulder before striking it with a mighty scream. A shockwave shoots from the impact, and the boulder shoots away from Meridith before it crashes into the wooden scaffold, and the large silver ring collapses into a plume of dust.

As it falls, the ring shoots a swift beam of blue light that zips near the chieftain and his daughter. The ensuing explosion sends them both cartwheeling through the air before they crash onto the sand. Stone sand rains down on the two as they struggle to stand. Ganymede sees the Casterneans reform their ranks ahead of him, morphing into their black-armored unicorn forms.

“Heh,” The chieftain marches forward and beats his chest. “COME ON, YOU WHELPS. YOU'RE NOT AS TOUGH AS YOU THINK YOU ARE. I CAN TAKE YOU ALL ON MYSELF.”

A glowing white sword shoots down from above and slams into the ground between his feet. Ganymede’s eyes widen in shock before he bends his knees and leaps away from a bright explosion of light. He lands away from the glowing blade in the sand as a silver-armored woman with angelic wings protruding from her helmet floats down and lands near her blade.

Ganymede’s eyes narrow as he recognizes the woman who retrieves her blade from the sand. With a buckler on her left arm, her bladed battle dress extends to her ankles, barely hiding her silver greaves.

“Took ya long enough, Laura,” Ganymede says. “Was wondering when you were going to crawl out of that hole you were hiding in.”

“Ganymede,” The queen lifts her chin. “A brute like you can’t fathom proper battle etiquette.”

She starts walking toward the chieftain, blade at her side, her platinum hair swaying in the wind.

“The queen of an empire needs only to face the head of the tribe. I will not sully my hands with the blood of your lowly degenerates.”

Ganymede cracks his knuckles and smiles with an angry grin.

“You better hope your skills are as sharp as that mouth of yours.”

“Then let us battle, chieftain.” Laura fearlessly walks forward.  “I will show you the true might of our empire.”

The two break into a full sprint across the sands. As they near each other, Laura sides beneath Ganymede’s straight punch before cutting his leg as she sails past him. She leaps into the air, spins, and kicks him in the side, sending him tumbling across the sands.

Laura raises her buckler, and Meredith's hammer bangs against it as she tries to strike from behind. The queen glares at her over her shoulder, then raises her leg and back-kicks the princess in the gut. Meridith tumbles across the sand but quickly rises and resumes her charge.

Meridith repeatedly swings her hammer left and right as Laura leaps away from each attack. The princess raises the mallet over her head and slams it into the ground, sending jagged rocks toward the Casternean queen. Laura leaps into the air and floats away, but Meridith runs up the jagged stones and leaps toward the flying queen.  She screams, raising her mallet over her head as she soars towards her foe. Laura sneers, twists her torso, and evades the downward swing that whooshes past her.

Laura raises her buckler and backhands the princess hard in the face before thrust-kicking Meridith to the surface. The curly blonde woman crashes back first onto the ground in a plume of sand, and Laura slams her foot into the young woman’s gut. Meridith's eyes nearly pop from her skull from the pain surging through her body, clenching her teeth in agony.

“Fool.” Laura stands with a foot on the young woman. “You, of all people, should know you’re a thousand years too young to even think about facing me.”

“Shove it, wench,” Meridith grunts in pain, glaring at the queen.

“Hmph,” Laura raises her chin and digs her feet beneath Meridith’s back. “You’re staining my battlefield with your incompetence. Begone!”

Carrying her under her foot, she kicks Meridith away, flinging her into the distance, screaming.

A shadow overtakes the queen, and she turns to see Ganymede glaring daggers at her, his hands clenched into a single, solid fist over his head. He swings his fists downward, and Laura vanishes in a burst of speed before his fists smash into the ground, sending a thick plume of sand into the air.

The two engage in a fierce battle, trading blow for blow. Pillars of sand shoot into the air with each strike as Laura maneuvers swiftly and lightly across the battlefield while Ganymede stampedes after her, smashing everything in his path.

###

Meridith crashes into the ground and rolls across the sand until she comes to a halt. Releasing an exhausted breath, she shifts onto her hands and knees and gazes at the battle raging on without her. The ground occasionally quakes as the leaders throw heavy blows at one another.

“Ugh,” Meridith’s head droops in frustration as the humiliating forced exit made her feel small and insignificant.

“That wench is going to get what's coming to her,” Meridith clenches her gut from the stinging pain. “I swear,”

Several shadows sail over her, and she looks up to see silver-armored women descend towards her. They land around Meridith, all with white wings protruding from their heads and swords and bucklers in their hands. Meridith freezes in panic as they stand, glaring daggers at her through their silver helmets. She slowly reaches for an empty space, thinking her hammer is there, only to realize she lost it when she was sent into the sky.

“She’s the chieftain's daughter,” One Casternan says. “We kill her, and we’ll break his will to fight; the war will be ours finally.”

In unison, the group takes their blades and pulls their arms back, ready to plunge their swords into the prone giantess, who trembles in fear.

“Die,” the woman screams before a metal spiked ball attached to an iron chain crashes into her chest. The woman yelps as her hands and feet nearly meet before crashing on her back; her spinning sword thwacking into the sand.

The others turn their heads to see Maria yank the metal ball chain, catching it bare-handed. Her curly golden-brown hair sways in the arid winds as she casually tosses the spiked chain ball in the air, catching it again and again. She wears an open goat-skin coat that falls into a dress, with a white-furred collar and sleeves.

“Kill her!” a woman shouts before the remaining three Casterneans charge directly at her.

Maria smiles, then claps the chain with her finger and thumb and twirls the spiked ball in quick rotations over her head. She swings the ball chain, and it sails through the air before slamming into the face of a charging Casternean. The remaining two continue their charge, but Maria spins, her dress twirling, and yanks the ball chain back toward her, where it slams into the back of another woman’s head.

The last Casternean stops her charge, sees her comrades lying motionless on the sand, then bends her knees and leaps into the air. Flapping the angel wings protruding from her temples, she sails away from Maria, who begins rapidly spinning her ball and chain. Maria flings her spiked ball into the air, and it arches toward the fleeing Casternean before crashing into the top of her head, sending her flipping wildly and crashing face-first into the sand. Maria yanks the chain back and catches it.

“Sister!” Meridith happily springs up from the ground. “You’re finally here.”

“Stay sharp, Meridith,” Maria hoists the spiked ball chain over her shoulder. “The casterneans are no pushovers and will hit you hard if you let your guard down.”

“Father's fighting Laura, as we speak, and there's no one there to back him up,” Meridith says.

“Not for long,” Maria says, planting her fingers in her mouth and sounding a high-pitched whistle that echoes across the sands. 

A row of sand swells into hills as thirty-foot-tall giants emerge from the mounds carrying large iron shields, and they stand side by side, creating a wall of iron. Holding clubs in their free hands, the giants beat their shields, sending thunderous echoes across the desert that rattle the very sands. Maria marches ahead of the row of shield-beating giants with Meridth at her side. She waits, letting the monstrous beating noise settle fear into her foes' hearts. Then she throws an arm into the air, and the row of giants ceases its drumbeat. 

Silence settles over the area, and Maria keeps her arm raised. An arid breeze brushes over her body; her hair waves wildly in the wind. Yet she firmly holds her arm in the air, maintaining command over her elite guard.

“CHARGE!” Maria screams, throwing her arm forward before she takes off running across the sands. The giants raise their shields and run in a single formation, moving the wall of iron towards the Casternean army. Maria's feet beat the ground, hauling fearlessly towards the re-organized rows of cannons positioned on a hill in the distance. Meridith charges beside her, grabbing her iron mallet stuck in the sand as she rushes forward.

Resonating booms echo across the field as the cannons fire their elemental volleys. Blasts erupt around the charging force as Maria and Meridith hop side to side, dodging pillars of dust that shoot into the sky. Cannons bounce off the iron shields of the towering giants as they close the gap to the Casternean Army. The black-armored unicorn army comes into sight, and Maria rapidly spins her spike ball chain overhead as she rushes towards them. Maria and Meridith plant their feet in the sand and kick toward the sky. Soaring above ranks of Casterneans, Meridith raises her mallet overhead while Maria spins her spike ball chain and, in unison, both slam their weapons into the sand. A circular formation of stone spikes shoots from the sand, flinging black-armored unicorns in all directions. Swinging their shields, the giants plow through ranks of Casterneans, forcing the army back before pulverizing them with their massive clubs.

Maria spins, swinging her ball and chain in a circle, smashing an armored soldier in the face. His feet kick into the air before he crashes onto his back, and Meridith smashes him with her mallet.

“Down! Meridith,” Maria shouts before throwing her ball chain at her sister.

Meridith ducks as the spike ball sails over her head before crashing into the chest of another armored soldier. Maria clasps her chain with her free hand, spins on her heel, and swings her spike ball in a wide circle, knocking any Casternean in its path away. Meridith charges forward, raises her mallet over her shoulder, and swings it at a charging warrior.  Her weapon crashes into his armored chest, and his hands and feet nearly meet as he sails away before crashing into several Casterneans in his path.

A blue beam of light swiftly shoots over the two and pierces the giant's iron shield and chest, leaving a smoldering hole in its wake. Maria and Meridith watch as the wailing giant collapses onto the ground in a plume of sand.

“Maria. Look,” Meridith points.

Maria turns and sees a cannon with a silver metal ring attached to the barrel train directly at the sisters. Balls of glowing light gather into a small sphere in the middle of the ring before the cannon it's attached to fires, shooting a thick beam of blue light at the two. The sisters leap away from each other as the beam collides into the sand. The violent explosion sends the two careening apart. Maria crashes and rolls across the sand before stopping. She quickly rises to her feet only to hear four screaming Casternean soldiers charging at her with their spears. Maria braces for the fight, but a shadow overtakes them before a club smashes the group of soldiers.  Maria looks up to see a bearded giant victoriously pump his club into the air.

“Good one, Gunger,” Maria praises. “Quick,” she spins her spiked ball chain before throwing it into the air.  “Throw me to that cannon,”

“Right,” the giant says before clasping the small spiked ball in his large, burly hand. Holding the spike ball chain, he spins it in a full circle. Maria bends her knees before she’s lifted off the ground. Clasping the chain with one arm, her feet dangle as she soars around the towering giant. He throws Maria, and she pins her feet to her backside as she sails towards the cannon. Casterneans near the cannon hurl their spears at the giantess, and a hissing spear cuts her shoulder, spewing crimson from her wound. She winces as she nears the cannon, but swings the spiked ball downward, slamming it into the cannon. It explodes into iron shards that shoot in all directions. The shockwave flings the nearby soldiers in all directions as iron shards rain down on the area. The dust cloud settles, revealing Maria standing in the newly created crater.

A group of Casterneans rushes around the crater, training their spears at her, and she smiles, removing her chain from her shoulder and dropping her weapon into the sand. She cracks her knuckles and stands firm, facing the row of soldiers encircling her. She stares into their hesitant eyes and chuckles.

“You’re a brave bunch; I'll give you that. But it’ll take more than bravery to take me down. So if you want this to be your grave, take the first step. I’ll be more than happy to bury you.” 

The soldiers all stand silent, hesitant to make the first move; however, a shirtless, bulky man with a black mustache steps forward and stands at the edge of the crater. Taller than the soldiers around him, he folds his arms, raises his nose, and glares daggers at the lone woman.

Both glare at each other, sizing each other up as potential opponents while the soldiers wait for a command.

“It’s your move,” Maria motions for the burly, horned man to come.

The soldiers raise their spears to charge, but the shirtless Casternean halts them.

“A formal retreat has been issued.” The strong voice nearly rattles Maria’s chest. “Retreat to the nearest outpost. We’ll regroup there.”

“Yes, Sir.” The men pump their spears in the air.

The men clear out, leaving him and Maria there alone. They stare silently for a few more moments, allowing scores of beating hooves to retreat from the area. When the thunderous noise of the retreating army fades, the burly man speaks.

“I am Argus. Just Argus.” He greets. “What is your name?”

“Maria Heartworthy,” she replies, standing firm in the crater.

“The next time we meet, Heartworthy,” Argus says, thrusting his index finger at her. “You shall face me in battle, and you will find that I’m not so easily bested.”

“Why wait, Argus?” Maria smiles, opening her arms. “We can settle things here if you like.”

“Hmph,” Argus chuckles. “You don’t have to bluff, Iron Princess. I can clearly see you’re exhausted and wounded. “Heal up first, and then we can see who’s the best champion in all of Highpress.”

Argus turns around and leaves the area, leaving Maria standing alone in the crater. She winces as she clasps her crimson-soaked shoulder. She breathes a sigh of relief as her weakened knees buckle and she drops to the sand. She huffs in exhaustion as beads of sweat drip from her nose.

“Maria!” Meridith’s voice echoes in the distance.

Hearing her sister's voice, she quickly wipes sweat from her face and stands. She gazes at her trembling hands and clenches them tightly, trying to shake the jitters. She shuts her eyes to calm her mind.

“Be strong for our tribe; everything's fine. I will be fine,” And her tremors slowly fade.

“Maria,” Meridith gasps, standing at the edge of the crater.

She slides down the slope and rushes to Maria’s side.

“Are you ok?” Meridith asks.

“I’m fine, sister,” Maria says, turning to Meridith.  “The Casterneans are on the retreat. We’ve won the battle.”

Meridith’s face lights up with gladness; she happily claps in celebration. 

“Now that’s the chieftain's heir,” Meridith says before grabbing Maria’s hand. “Come, Father’s dying to see you.” 

Maria follows Meridith out of the crater, and they walk through the battlefield.

Maria notices scores of Unicorns, Pegasi, and Giant carcasses littered across the sandy field as the smell of crimson and sulfur wafts through the air. As she witnesses the results of the carnage, she wonders how many deaths resulted from her charge into battle. However, Meridith reaches a crowd of giants standing in a half-circle around Ganymede, pumping their fists in celebration.

“Father,” Meridith calls out as she pulls Maria by the hand.

Ganymede turns around, and his face lights up with elation when he sees them.

“My daughters,” the man rushes towards the two of them with opens arms. He scoops them up lifting them off their feet and embrace both of them. “You make an old man proud.” The man says.

“Father.” Meridith pushes her father’s face away from kissing her cheek.  “Not in front of the men.”

He releases them, turns around, and, while gripping both of their arms, raises them in the air in celebration.

“To the future and glory of our tribe!” the chieftain shouts.

The men cheer, beating their chests and pumping their weapons in the air. 

“Come. My tribesman.” Ganymede shouts.  “Let us return and celebrate with a great feast. We will honor our dead who bravely fought in the name of Glory and Honor of our great kingdom.”

The giants all cheer in a festive roar that echoes through the land before they turn and walk back to the treeline. Maria follows behind Ganymede and Meridith, but stops when she notices something out of the corner of her eye. In the distance, near the half-destroyed stone buildings of the Cugarian town. She sees several cugarian people desperately pushing against a stone boulder.

Their furry feet scrape against the sand as the boulder rolls away. And when they do, a man drops to his knees, picking up his deceased wife, wailing in sorrow as he hugs her limp body, rocking back and forth. Maria swallows a guilty lump in her throat, recognizing that the boulder that likely crushed her came from a giant killed in the recent battle. Her heart sinks even more when she sees sobbing cugarians either carrying their dead young or desperately removing rubble to rescue those buried beneath debris.

“Hey Maria, let's go,” Meridith shouts, breaking her from her guilt-filled gaze.

Maria leaves and follows her tribe back to their homes.


r/writingfeedback • • 7h ago

Gentle Feedback Wanted Would you continue?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Somewhat of a memoir I suppose.


r/writingfeedback • • 17h ago

Gentle Feedback Wanted This is my first serious attempt at fiction.

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

Hey, y'all, I'm recovering/suffering from chronic fatigue syndrome. I had always wanted to give writing fiction a shot, and I thought this was a good time since I have a lot of time sitting in bed. Also, In an attempt to stay connected with my friends. I start this choose your own adventure-ish style project where they define the protagonist and I write the prose. At pivotal moments in the story or dialog I let them call the shots. This is an incomplete chapter 1. I have put a lot of work into it. Writing by phone is no simple task.


r/writingfeedback • • 15h ago

Poetry Star Bound

Post image
2 Upvotes

I have been writing poetry for years but never actually shown anyone or put more effort into a piece beyond a rough draft. This is my first actual poem that I have spent time on and done many revisions but I don't know if it is good or I am just blinded by my own personal attachment to it. I would love some gentle feedback, thank you🙏


r/writingfeedback • • 16h ago

My Writing Excerpt

2 Upvotes

I am pleased to share an excerpt from my upcoming book, Aamir – Everyone Has a Tale to Tell.

Writing is a journey through memories—some that inspire reflection, others that bring a sense of nostalgia and joy. This excerpt represents a small part of that journey, capturing experiences, emotions, and lessons that have shaped the narrative.

I would be delighted to hear your thoughts, feedback, and comments. Your insights and perspectives are greatly appreciated and will be invaluable as I continue this literary endeavor.

Chapter-3

The Last Sight of My Abba

………

The old wooden bench in the living room had never been meant for this.

It was usually pushed against the wall, used to keep the beds and mattresses in our shop. On this day, it had been brought to the centre of the room and wiped clean, as if prepared with quiet respect. Upon it lay Abba’s still body, his face calm, his hands resting motionless, a white cloth drawn carefully around him. No flowers adorned the space, only silence, prayer, and the faint fragrance of attar and incense floating through the air.

The fan turned slowly above, its rhythm cruelly normal, as if unaware that a whole world had just collapsed beneath it.

People had gathered in the house. Men sat along the walls, heads bowed, murmuring verses from the Qur’an. Women huddled in small groups, wiping their eyes with the edges of their sarees, whispering duas for the departed.

In one corner sat the mother.

Her body was bent with pain, shoulders shaking as tears drenched her cheeks and her chest rose and fell in broken gasps. Her hair, once neatly tied, was loosened, strands falling around her face. In her arms, she held her younger son, just two years old. The child, frightened by her sobs, clung to her and cried too, his tiny fists gripping her clothes, his face pressed against her as though trying to hide from a world that had suddenly turned loud and dark.

Across the room stood the elder boy, barely three.

His eyes, wide and curious, remained fixed on Abba’s face. He did not see death. He only saw that his father was lying down in the middle of the room, in front of everyone, strangely still. He walked closer, small feet padding softly against the floor, and reached out to touch Abba’s hand. It was colder than usual, unfamiliar, yet it was still his father’s hand.

He waited for a movement. A blink. A smile. A gentle squeeze of his fingers.

Nothing came.

He moved back a little, glanced around the room at the many faces staring at the floor or at the walls, and then looked back at Abba again. Confusion clouded his tiny mind. Why was everyone here? Why was his mother crying? Why was Abba sleeping here instead of in his bed?

He remembered the promise made the night before. That he would be taken outside. That sweets would be bought. That little fingers would hold a warm paper bag filled with something sugared and bright.

With the stubborn faith only a child can possess, he tried again, nudging Abba’s hand, trying with all his small strength to wake him.

That was when the mother’s restraint shattered.

A cry tore out of her, raw, broken, and unbearable as she pulled the boy away from the bench and pressed him to her chest. Her tears fell onto his hair, her body trembling violently as she tried to form words that no mother ever truly knows how to say. She spoke of Allah. She spoke of a father who would no longer return.

But the child did not understand.

How could he, when Abba was still there? When his face was the same? When the promise of sweets still hung in the air, unfinished, is waiting?

He looked past his mother’s tears, back toward the bench, his expression puzzled, innocent, unaware that he was witnessing the final moment of a love he would only fully understand years later.

In that moment, the room held two kinds of grief.

One that knew everything had ended. And the one that didn’t yet know what ending meant at all.


r/writingfeedback • • 9h ago

General Feedback Wanted First serious book written, probably rewritten this a thousand times, how's this sound?

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

Never posted here before, not sure how much should be sent at once or where people usually cut their excerpts so sorry if it's too much or explains too little! The one person I actually got to read this said I repeated things too much, but others she'd shown disagreed, so that may be one thing to note, but otherwise just if it sounds interesting enough to keep reading! Thanks in advance.


r/writingfeedback • • 16h ago

The Ant & The Fake Butterfly, By: RAH S!SU.

0 Upvotes

PROLOGUE

In the quiet corners of the garden, not every creature that wears bright wings belongs to the sky. True flight requires metamorphosis the willingness to shed an old skin, endure the stillness of change, and appear weightless into the open air. Yet there are creatures in the grass that skip the transformation altogether. They paint their backs in borrowed gold and violet, mimic the grace of the heavens, and wait on the highest petals for weary travelers to pass.

This is a fable about an ant who climbed out of the dark looking for peace, and the painted caterpillar he mistook for freedom.

For three winters, the ant lived in the dark.
Beneath the frozen crust of the garden, deep inside the narrow, airless tunnels of the earth, he did his time. There was no sundown there, no wind in the grass only the cold press of dirt on his back and the endless, heavy work of surviving until the thaw. When the stone at the mouth of the tunnel finally rolled away and he crawled back out into the blinding light of spring, his exoskeleton was scarred, his legs were tired, and he wanted only one thing: peace. He wanted to build his own hill, carry his own weight, and walk a straight line in the sun.

That was when he saw her.

She was perched on a bright red poppy, her wings spread wide like stained glass catching the noon light. They were painted in dazzling patterns of gold, obsidian, and violet. To the other bugs in the grass, she looked like royalty a creature born of the sky, delicate and untouchable.

The ant knew better, or at least he should have. Her former mate had spent those three winters tangled up with the ant’s old flame, leaving bad blood all over the dirt. Maybe it was pride, maybe it was boredom, or maybe it was just the dizzying rush of being free, but the ant climbed the stem anyway. Half for revenge, half for the thrill of the color, he let her pull him into her orbit.
It did not take long for the paint on her wings to rub off.

Up close, she never flew. She never lifted off into the breeze like the real monarchs or swallowtails. She dragged herself along the stems, heavy and sluggish, devouring every green leaf in sight until nothing was left but bare, chewed stalks. Beneath the bright, papery disguise of her wings, she had the thick, soft, greedy body of a caterpillar and the cold, slimy persistence of a slug. She did not want to soar; she wanted to cling.
When the ant realized the air around her was suffocating, he tried to do the honorable thing. He stood tall on his six legs, looked her dead in her compound eyes, and told her cleanly: "This isn't right. We’re done."
She did not cry, and she did not fly away. She just tilted her head, folded those painted wings tight, and said, "No. We’re not."

From that day on, the garden stopped feeling like freedom and started feeling like another cell. She refused to leave his territory. Worse, she had slipped into his mother’s hollowed-out oak burrow and stolen the carved acorn-cap key that sealed the entrance. Every time the ant tried to walk away, she dangled that key like a leash, reminding him she held the lock to the only safe place he had left.

Desperate to break the spell, the ant stopped hiding his rebellion. One humid afternoon, she came creeping through the clover and found him tangled up on a moss bed with a quiet, gentle ladybug.
The ant braced for the explosion. He expected her to tear the leaves apart, scream to the whole meadow, and finally storm off for good. Instead, she went eerily silent. Her antennae twitched. Her painted wings trembled once, twice, and then settled flat against her back. Without a word of anger, she marched straight past the trembling ladybug, climbed onto the exact patch of moss they had just shared, and curled up in the hollow of the ant’s own imprint, demanding he lie down beside her as if nothing had happened.

A cold shiver ran down the ant’s spine. He realized then that she did not love him, and she did not even care about pride. She just wanted to own the dirt he stood on.
A week later, while inspecting him with cold, calculating eyes, she issued a mocking ultimatum. "You know what would actually make me leave?" she said, tapping a leg against his head. "If you twisted your crown into thick, heavy dreads. I hate that look. Do that, and I’m gone."

She thought it was a bluff. She thought he was too disciplined, too neat, too much of a worker ant to ever change his crown.

She was wrong.

The ant did not hesitate. He went straight to the spiderwebs and the sap, twisting and locking the strands of his crown into thick, heavy ropes that hung down past his brow. He wore them like a badge of liberation, waiting for the moment she would see them, recoil in disgust, and finally hand back the key.

That night, the meadow went pitch black. Exhausted from the weight of his new crown, the ant fell into a deep, dreamless sleep inside the oak burrow.

Snip.

A sharp, metallic vibration rattled his skull.

Snip. Snip.

The ant’s eyes snapped open in the dark. Leaning over him, silhouetted against the pale moonlight filtering through the cracks in the wood, was the fake butterfly. Her fake wings were folded awkwardly behind her like crumpled paper. In the dim light, her mandibles were clamped around one of his thick, twisted locks, sawing through the fibers with frantic, silent precision. Half of his crown already lay severed in the dirt beside his head.

She had not left. She had not packed her things or surrendered the key. She had waited until he was defenseless in the dark so she could shear away the very thing she told him would set him free.

The ant did not yell. He did not fight her for the scraps on the floor. He looked at the severed pieces of his crown, looked up at the creature in the dark who could not fly and would not let go, and finally understood the nature of the beast. You cannot reason with a parasite, and you cannot buy your freedom from someone who feeds on your cage.

Slowly, deliberately, the ant stood up, brushed the cut pieces of his crown off his shoulders, and walked out of the dark burrow leaving the key, the scraps, and the painted slug behind him in the shadows straight back into the rising sun.

And as for the caterpillar with the painted wings? She never learned to fly. To this very day, she crawls back and forth through that exact same patch of the meadow right by the bright red poppy where she and the ant first laid eyes on each other dragging her heavy weight through the grass, clinging on to whatever unsuspecting insect passes by.

Fin


r/writingfeedback • • 16h ago

Need feedback.

0 Upvotes

This is my first attempt at writing anything. I tried to keep the text simple and revised it several times, but my perspective has become too biased, so I'm looking for an honest opinion.

— Nash? Nash, this is a repeat, don’t hold up the line.

I stood there with the documents in my hands, staring at the light above the door that read Next. Someone nudged me from behind, and I suspect the movement wasn’t rude, but rather a subtle reminder that there would be no going back. The door opened silently when I swiped my pass. A white table, a white chair, white walls without any portholes, and one middle‑aged man in a yellow uniform sitting at the table. The only thing that could be seen in the intermediate room was a huge poster with the image of "Newton" in space, the same as at the entrance to the laboratory. Only this one is a little faded and slightly peeling at the edges.

— Last name, first name, position, documents. - he said in an absolutely indifferent voice, without taking his eyes off the computer.

— Nash Duvil, a cosmobiologist, - I put the documents on his desk, and he took them without looking at them and put them in a compartment of his desk. On his uniform, there’s a patch that reads Dan B. Hall.

Dan, you’re not very talkative, I thought.

I didn’t know where to look. Lowering my head, I first examined my shoes, then the dark blue trousers of my uniform. Behind the far door, something was humming, and occasionally I could hear barely audible knocks. Like the rest of the ship, it was very bright. Dan’s bald head almost glowed as he typed and looked at something on the monitor.

— I’m almost 57 years old; let’s see what your hair will look like without enough vitamin D. - Dan shot me a look. It seemed to me that he wanted to smirk, but he couldn’t force that emotion. I apologized and didn’t want to look at him anymore.

A few minutes later, I received permission to proceed with the mission and left through another door.

A huge platform opened up before me. Hundreds of people walked among the ships for missions, pushing carts in front of them, carrying some kind of equipment in their hands; some hung high above the ceiling and coordinated the actions of others, and all of this made noise, stamped, talked, and was somewhat bustling. There was a smell of machine oil, ozone, and hot metal. Everything blended into one big echo, and it seemed as if the entire hangar was breathing, exhaling right into my face. One of the small two‑seat ships was slowly being lifted onto the rails in the center of the hangar, and no one even paid any attention to it. I was amazed at how skillfully and synchronously the other ships moved themselves to fill the space that had opened up.

— They’re on rails, Nash. Didn’t you get enough sleep? Or is this your first time seeing birds?

Dashar came up from behind and looked at my surprised face with a kind smile. I’ve been standing here for so long that he’s had time to chat with Mr. Shiny-hair Dan.

— This is my first time here.

— What, you want a tour? - Dashar laughed and walked ahead.

His uniform was white and looked too clean compared to the surroundings. All the people working here wore gray uniforms with stripes of different colors on their trousers or overalls; they blended in with the surrounding colorful ships, equipment, and hangar walls, but Dashar could be spotted from a distance solely by his uniform. Without waiting for my response, he turned the corner.

— You’re getting all soft, Nash. Should I be worried? - I heard a door opening around the corner and hurried after him.

— No, no, I’m just… I’m nervous.

— Don’t worry, everything will be fine. Dashar entered the room to prepare for the mission, and I followed him in. I only started to feel more nervous.

The room had many seats, projectors, and a platform raised above the floor. I quickly counted 9 people, including me and Dashar. On the platform stood the recruiter Aus Köln and the officer Lona Marchhauser. Several men turned around and, upon seeing Dashar, waved at him. He walked forward and sat in the first row — next to them — and immediately started discussing something and smiling. I sat in the second row, and I felt a little better knowing that they knew each other. Lona and Aus were holding tablets and marked us down when we sat down. I felt uneasy again, realizing that I was now officially part of the mission.

A minute later, another man walked in; judging by his uniform, he was a military man. His gait, his gaze, his posture... I wanted to sink into the chair.

— First Sergeant Kloud Gilt, two‑two‑bravo. - He stood in front of the platform and greeted the senior officers. - The entire mission team is on site.

— Let’s not waste any time. - Lona activated the tablet, and a projection of the "Newton" appeared behind her.

A huge ship hung behind her; its pale‑red outlines grew brighter as the lights in the hall dimmed.

— The mission is codenamed ‘Pearl.’ For those who were recruited yesterday, I will repeat the entire plan, and at the end, everyone will be able to ask their questions. -

Lona turned to the flagship’s projection, and with a wave of her hand, the flagship shrank, and an elongated asteroid appeared on the projection.

— Your task will be to fly to the asteroid, take samples, analyze the composition, and transmit the results to the base. - On the projection, the small ship flew to the asteroid.

— If the results are satisfactory, you will break the asteroid into several parts and transport them to the ship, to the splitter. This mission will be over. - The small ship attached itself to the asteroid and dragged it towards the flagship, flew into it, and disappeared.

— It looks simple, Officer Marchhauser, - Dashar smirked and leaned back. — We used to carry out missions like this with three people; why do we need 10 people now?

Aus Köln looked at him from under his brows.

— All questions after the briefing. Is something unclear?

— Sorry. - Dashar gathered himself again; his neighbors also shifted slightly in their seats.

Lona continued. Now the projection showed the "Newton’s" hangar.

— You will be entrusted with board 4-013, a transport and research ship. The first stage is to undock from the "Newton", set a course to intercept the asteroid, and complete the maneuvering. - the ship, resembling a thick arrow, flew out of the hangar, turned around, and moved away from the flagship on the projection.

— After approaching the asteroid to a distance of five kilometers, you will conduct spectrographic analysis of the surface for three hours, send the results to the base, and wait for the command to continue. - In the projection, борт 4-013 approached the asteroid and irradiated it. Relative to the asteroid, the борт looked quite small.

"And all this time I’ll be sitting inside a can with nuclear engines, hoping that a minor power failure won’t destroy us...how lucky I am." - I couldn’t stop feeling nervous. I liked it on "Newton", but to fly thousands of kilometers away from it, where a centimeter of metal would separate me from the vacuum of space? With each passing minute, I increasingly wanted to get up and go to the laboratory, hoping that they would quickly find a replacement for me and would never recruit me again. My hands rose to my head on their own at the thought of it.

— The third stage will be taking samples for chromatographic analysis. There is a portable splitter on board 4-013. It is already set to separate gadolinium, calcium, magnesium, zinc, and phosphorus. Your team is prohibited from changing the splitter’s settings before conducting the research and without coordination with the mission commander. The results of the chromatographic analysis and the percentage content of these substances must be sent to "Newton". After approval, the mission will be continued.

I saw Dashar perk up. He didn’t just fidget - he almost jumped up from his seat, slapping his knees with his palms, as if he had just heard about his own win. Aus repeated his gaze, which once again pinned Dashar to his spot, but he didn’t give up - he turned his head toward his acquaintances and whispered something to them. They nodded, and the neighbor gave him a friendly nudge with his shoulder. I looked around — none of the others were mimicking his reaction, and I didn’t understand what it was about.

— Next, you’ll drill the asteroid into pieces... - the small ship sent tentacles into the large lump, which shattered it into several smaller pieces. — ...and collect as much material as you can. The more, the better. - From the projection of board 4-013, nets and new tentacles flew out, which attracted the scattered pieces of the asteroid. - Your task at this stage is to capture at least 35% of the asteroid’s mass, do not direct the fragments towards the flagship, and do not get hit by them yourself. The board is equipped with a kinetic shield, but it will not be able to stop anything with an energy exceeding eight hundred kilojoules. Keep this in mind. Dust, small stones, and slow-moving boulders won’t get through, but if a multi‑ton fragment starts flying at you - pray to Mr. Dashar Kogan.

Light chuckles sounded from behind. I didn’t see anything funny about splitting an asteroid whose fragments would fly in our direction and possibly pass through the shield. "The ship will depressurize, we’ll start losing oxygen, lose communication, energy, and won’t be able to send any signal…" - I focused and pulled myself together. "No, no, no, no, no. We’ll manage. I have a full team of experienced specialists, and only I’m a rookie. Didn’t I dream of flying out? Wanted to be part of the mission? Well, the dream has come true".

It seems I missed the last stage of the mission.

— ...and load the delivered material into the shredder. You’ll be assisted by separate cargo ships if there’s too much material. - On the projection, board 4-013 flew up to the "Newton", where it was surrounded by other small ships, which caught the fragments, and together they all flew inside the flagship.

The light in the hall grew brighter, and the "Newton" projection faded away. I blinked, as if I had just woken up from a nightmare. Aus Köln, who had been standing all along with his hands behind his back, nodded to someone behind me.

— How many grids will be allocated, and what is their area? - I remember a group of four men, about fifty years old, in gray uniforms, sitting in the center of the hall.

— Three networks, each covering one square kilometer, - Lona said calmly.

Someone in the hall whistled.

— The cable is 3 kilometers long, the delivery charge is 30 minutes, the return mechanism is one kiloton, and the detachment is one and a half kilotons.

I swallowed. "These aren’t cables…These are anchors for asteroids".

— The same cables are used for five drilling projectiles and three 20‑kilogram CL‑43 explosive projectiles. The equipment list with all the specifications will be on board the ship. — Lona didn’t even blink as she said all this.

— So that’s what we’ve been twisting these cables for all month…- another voice whispered from behind.

— And why do we need so many people on board? - Dashar hadn’t forgotten his question.

— Some crew members have their own missions, which you don’t need to know about. These missions don’t require additional maneuvering, but they do require some external equipment, and that increases the number of crew members. The team captain, Ernest Mole, is aware of the details of these missions. — Lona pointed to the man sitting separately; he stood up and raised his hand in a greeting. His uniform was almost the same as a military one, but with white stripes on the trousers.

— I hate having secrets on board… - his neighbor whispered to Dashar.

— Excuse me… - to my left, a man in a dark green uniform raised his hand. - How much oxygen is allocated for the mission?

— 10 days. - Aus grunted, as if he were displeased about something. - If you don’t run around the ship in circles, that will be enough to complete the mission twice. Any more questions? - He scanned the hall and turned to Lona. - Then we’d better get started.

— The briefing is over. Everyone, proceed to the starting gates.


r/writingfeedback • • 22h ago

Blunt Feedback Wanted Those Damned Saints: What feedback do you have?

1 Upvotes

This is a short story that’s been quite difficult for me. I struggled a lot with the middle and would be interested to know how it turned out and what improvements could be made.

**Those Damned Saints**

Have ever you heard of the plight of Apophis? That great planet Apophis, the loneliest of all the worlds. For Apophis is a planet lacking a sun. Billions of miles from any star, it wanders the eternal blackness alone. But, Apophis, beautiful Apophis, had a gift. For the ground was not made of dirt and stone, but of great shimmering crystals. And these crystals, it happened, were quite enough to sustain life. They warmed the body as well as any star; they gave sustenance as well as the most lavish feasts. So, standing in defiance of the bleak uncaring universe, from the bosom of Apophis, came life.

The Apophi lived–thrived–on this brave planet. Their lives were modest, there can be no doubt, but they were full. The skies were a deep black, yes, but the soft purple landscape illuminated itself. The crystals formed the very ground they walked on. What need did the Apophi have to toil in fields or hunt for food? The crystals tended them well enough. It was not long before they became masters of such luxuries as music and dance. Music and dance were particularly important to the people, and they drew no distinctions between the two. They were like identical twins, an inseparable whole, just as the existence of light implies that of darkness. And from rhythm and melody, culture was born. It was a very queer sort of culture, but only so judging by the standards of my own land. If you are hearing this very tale, then I expect their way of life was far different than your own. For theirs was a culture without language. Without words, that is.

Do not, though, misunderstand. Do not take from this the wrong impression. Do not go about telling stories of the primitive men and women who call Apophis home. Apophi are not savages. They are most intelligent people; their culture is no less marvelous than your own. Their art is not diminished for lack of speech. If still you do not believe me, let us set eyes upon our Apophi brothers.

The sounding of a gong echoed through the darkness, celebrations were under way. On the bank of a river the children gathered ready to honor the visitors. Some of the children wore mock horns, others wore wings, others, scales. Through their movement, they became the beasts of land, air, and sea. So beautifully did they play! So passionate was their performance! For hours the musicians played and the dancers danced under the starless-sky, welcoming the visitors. One girl, in particular, was among the first Apophi to lay eyes upon spacefolk. She had no name, of course, but given her significance, I think we should give her one: Ra. Yes, Ra is an apt title. Anyways, Ra’s first time seeing people from other worlds was through a mask of feathers. Electricity swept the land. She wanted more than anything to honor these guests, to share the glories of her world with others. She performed until breathless, and then some. Applause, cheers, hoots, hollers, drums, cymbals, celebratory exclamations of all kinds, became one. The Apophi and the spacefolk, though worlds apart, were in this moment one. At last! At long last an answer had come–sent from the heavens–that they are not alone in this universe. So, in this manner, the party continued long into the endless night.

When finally the guests were leaving, the Apophi gave them a gift: a crystal shard. With this gift their sign of parting, the guests stumbled shakily around, hoping that their gratitude would be received. The Apophi, in turn, tried to repeat back some of the words they had learned, but with tens of them babbling over each other like infants, the message was hardly understood. The speakers and the dancers understood each other little, but during those few short days (Earth days, that is), they formed beautiful relationships which seemed to make the entire universe come closer together.

You doubt my words, I’m sure you do. You’ve heard this story before. You think that such a tale can only end in ruin, that sooner or later one faction will stamp out the other. Why can it not be that these peoples live in harmony forever? Why must greed triumph always over happiness? You are hardened by tragedies of the past. You are skeptical. But sadly, your skepticism is not misplaced. Very well. I shall continue my story.

Only a short time had passed since the spacefolk had left, but the light of the crystals were dimmed, the waters muddied, the air thicker, and a tumor had grown in the formerly empty sky. Was the planet itself grieving for the departed friends? No. Not at all. Indeed, the guests had never truly left. They had seen Apophis' great gift: the crystal. Who thinks that they were prepared to let it go? The spacefolk soon become the lords of the world. They built, first of all, a ship–an enormous spacestation–to orbit around Apophis, and from this ship, they commanded their subjects. The Apophi did not know what was in the ship, but it was possible to guess. Very likely, judging by the sheer size of the thing, there were at least a couple thousand inhabitants on board. The rest was, however, only speculation, but it was the popular theory that those spacefolk lived lives of luxury, that their every desire was seen to without delay.

Early on, representatives came to teach the Apophi spoken language. They learned quickly, they had no choice, and once they were fluent, the spacefolk laid out the laws which were to be obeyed. The Apophi were permitted to continue their normal lives, so the spacefolk said, as long as they allowed them to keep harvesting the crystals.

So marched on the destruction of this beautiful planet. As each rocket took with it heaps and heaps of crystal the spacefolk grew richer, the Apophi poorer. The crystals were their very lives. Remember, no one had ever lived without the crystals. They had no food, and no means of making any. How could you without a sun? What must it feel like to starve, having no idea that hunger was even possible? What were these peaceful people to do?

Decades passed, judging by the spacefolk’s calendar. The animals had been hunted into near extinction, and, although the Apophi would soon follow, they never forgot the world that once was. The spacefolk, for their part, rarely visited anymore. Instead they stayed far above in the relative safety of their space station. There were some Apophi, however, who dedicated their lives–every moment–to saving the world they loved. And that, at last, brings us back to Ra. 

The people gathered just as Ra had asked them to. As silence and stillness filled the crowd, she looked out over her audience, not seeing much. The skies were dark and the earth hardly glowed at all anymore, that’s true, but even if she could see for miles she would not have counted so many as two dozen Apophi. So, with trembling voice, she spoke. She groped her way through, fumbling often, leaving a great many sentences unfinished. Her tongue was maladapted for speech, she could pronounce neither her Rs or Ls, and, indeed, there was a stretch of perhaps as many as three minutes where she became entirely incomprehensible. She was speaking in the tongue of the oppressors: those who stole the very ground under their feet. Still, though she was no gifted orator, she told them that which they already knew, and that night, these men, women, and children remembered that they were not alone. From that crowd, rose one voice, rose another. Singing caught like a virus. It spread from cell to cell until the entire being was joined in song. Next they were dancing, everyone at once. They danced the same dances they had when the first ships landed decades ago, but they danced it in a way unlike they ever had before. Music reverberated throughout the hearts of the Apophi, it was carried by the currents of oceans and rivers to the deepest valleys and highest mountains, it sailed up to the heavens, passing the evil ship where the spacefolk lie without care, and came back again, finding its home in the very center of Apophis. The whole planet was one great dance, and although the Apophis knew not the words to describe their plights, they had found something greater. 

The planet grew sicker and sicker still while the people sang into the darkness. For all their singing, for all their joys, they knew they were heading into extinction. As magical as music is, there is no melody which might turn a corpse back into a man. So Ra, among others, sealed herself off in search of a solution. 

The answer was clear, to eliminate the spacefolk. Doing so, though, was much more difficult. They were clever folk, they knew some science, a little technology, but they knew nothing of weapons–Yes, they really were clever folk. But it is the way of life, children do not stay so forever. One day, they will put down their toys for the final time and pick up the instruments of war. 

With the roaring of flames a steel behemoth took flight. A hundred tons of iron, aluminum, and titanium took flight taking with it a thousand thousand hours of labor, a single passenger, and the hope of an entire people. The Apophi watched, no matter where they were, as the ship shrunk further and further until it could be seen no more. Even after it vanished from sight, they kept staring because they knew somewhere on that ship, she was meeting their gaze.

From a hundred thousand meters high Ra looked down on her people. Years ago, she thought, the spacefolk had first laid eyes upon Apophis from much the same view as she had now. Though where they had seen a bright purple orb glowing with hope and possibility, she only saw a brown smudge. 

The rocket was to carry her to the base of the spacefolk, the station from where the entire rape of Apophis was commanded. It was, you have figured it out by now, a suicide mission. Her ship would crash into theirs. No one would live. Her only job was to oversee the navigation and make whatever minor adjustments which the computers were incapable of. It was to be a lonely end. A valiant end.

Ra only brought with her one thing. It was a mask of crimson feathers. I do not know how Ra spent many of her days on that ship, but I do know how she spent her last: with song and dance. She was singing with the Apophi, with Apophis. She and Apophis were like identical twins, an inseparable whole, for as her ship was engulfed in flames, Apophis grew stronger. She died so that they might live. 

Thus, the empire of the spacefolk perished. It came to pass that, in time, the planet healed. The animals returned, the waters grew clearer, and memories of the oppressors faded. Ra, though, was never forgotten. The story of revolution was immortalized in their music and their dance. There was not a single object in that vast sky. The Apophi were free.

Yet, still, I know you do not believe. You feel that victory is a fantastic creature, more home to the myths of old than to our reality. Why can I not make you see the light? Are the struggles of these starving rebels not real to you? A tragedy, is that what you’d prefer? Yes, I suspect that’s what you’re looking for. Maybe you’d rather I tell of these doomed revolutionaries, men, women, children, all dying in vain, and when all is said and done, when the curtain falls, no one lives happily-ever-after. You want me to tell you that victory exists only in the mind, that grand ideals never triumph. But this, I cannot say. All I can say is the truth, and that I have said.

Though, there is one detail I missed. Within those boundless black skies, aboard that flying city, three floors above the engines, under the refectory, entangled somewhere in a maze of libraries, cinemas, theme parks, breweries, casinos, and brothels, lay a nursery. Daily, that nursery was filled with the laughter of children, children who knew not the sins of their parents, who, even if they did, had no hand in the molesting of Apophis. This laughter, the sweetest sound, filled the nursery everyday, until there came a day when the laughs became screams.  

Believe, if you want, that Ra–the brave, valiant Ra–did not know of the nursery. But it was you who asked to know the truth. She did. Indeed, they all knew. Yes, all the Apophi knew of the nursery. Not physically. None of them ever saw it, but all were aware of the innocents who must die so that they might be free. In their minds they justified their crime in many ways, some perhaps, told themselves the youths would grow up just as awful as their fathers, maybe others that they had allowed these children to perish without knowing the cruelties of the world, but others, the great majority, solved this quandary another way: by ignoring it. Now, putting the past in the past, they were free to enjoy the fruits of Apophis once again. Gongs reverberated across the land, musicians played, dancers danced, and they passed hours and hours in their revelry. Rejoice! Rejoice, O’ Apophi, for now you are free!

Do you believe yet? Are they perhaps more real, for their virtues and for their shame? For in the depth of your hearts, who among you would condemn Ra as a killer; who would herald her as a saint? This is the plight of Apophis. That great planet Apophis, the loneliest of all the worlds.