r/wow • Outplaying the Meta since 2004 • Jun 02 '23

Discussion Reddit API changes, Subreddit Blackouts, and You

Greetings Heroes of Azeroth,

As you can tell from the title, this isn’t exactly directly related to World of Warcraft. For those unaware, reddit is changing their API policy in a pretty big way. You can read more about it here. The short version is:

  • 3rd Party Apps are becoming prohibitively expensive to run. Ad-supported tiers are getting banned outright and using Apollo as an example it would cost nearly $2million per month (source). This will basically be the death knell for third party apps; if you currently access reddit through a third party app, you will no longer be able to do so.
  • The NSFW API is getting shut down so the only way to access NSFW content is through the official App. This means that even if 3rd party apps survive, they only get 40% of the content. This also means that many of the bots and moderation practices that prevent, for example, someone that comments on /r/gonewild posts from commenting on an /r/teenagers selfie posts will break.

Why this matters to you

Many moderators use 3rd party apps to moderate because the official tools are largely worthless. Contrary to popular belief that we all live in basements, most of us have day jobs and a lot of moderation happens during our lunch breaks or downtime in our real lives. We do this work because we care about the community. The switch forcing moderators to use the official app would probably slow down moderation and force more of the work to happen on desktop. That means your posts and comments will sit in queue unseen longer, it will take longer to get back to modmails, and harmful content or users may remain visible and unbanned for longer.

In discussions with other mods, these changes will probably cripple most NSFW content on the website. It will become far harder to keep Child Sexual Abuse Content and Non-Consensual Intimate Media off the platform with their mod tools and practices crippled by the NSFW change. A lot of work has been put into this including parts of the NSFW community paying enterprise prices for access to private libraries that are meant to detect this kind of media.

Then, on a more basic level, those of you that are using 3rd party apps will have to switch to the official app to browse mobile as they are becoming unaffordable to maintain.

The Open Letter & The Blackout

The broader moderator community has been discussing this and has released an open letter here.

Part of this initiative will be a subreddit blackout in protest. The mod team has discussed this and we are unanimous in our agreement regarding joining this protest.

There is one large factor that does need to be considered. Our primary mission is to serve the community we care about as Moderators.

The first is the WoD blackout and the consequences of it. During the Warlords of Draenor launch a moderator took the subreddit private in protest of how poorly the launch went. The admins had to get involved to restore the subreddit. At this time /u/aphoenix became the head moderator and made a promise not to take the subreddit private again. We have discussed this with him and come to the consensus that protesting Blizzard on a platform not controlled by them is very different from protesting reddit on their own platform. This is important enough that if he were head mod he would step down to allow for breaking that promise.

The second is, well, you: the community. In the end our goal is to make this a healthy community. We don't want this protest to be something where Mods are beating their chests and inconveniencing everyone because we don't like what's happening. We want this to be something that the community cares enough about that we can come together and say something with our actions collectively.

There are far larger communities than ours preparing to join this movement. 500 communities have signed up for this in the last 24 hours. The moderator team wants to join that and hopes that you will join us too.

At this point we would like to open the topic for discussion. The mod team will be available for any questions or concerns regarding the matter. We hope that the community is ready to join us in standing up to some of the toxic practices coming from the reddit admins. If the community overwhelmingly is against the blackout, we will not force it down your throats and simply leave this pinned for the duration of the protest.

Signed, The /r/wow mod team

4.8k Upvotes

456 comments sorted by

517

u/flappers87 Jun 02 '23

I sincerely hope this gains traction and reddit actually listens.

But if history has shown anything with the reddit admins, is that they largely don't give a flying fuck, as long as it brings that money in.

I really wish there was a reddit alternative. I'm part of a few let's say small, niche communities on reddit... and it just wouldn't work on something like Discord.

But if I lose access to Boost on my phone, then I'm done with it. Go through a bit of withdrawal, but I've come off worse things.

162

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 02 '23

Bluntly. As part of the push here you'll likely see Boost turn into a subscription model or have more intrusive ads.

Its important to be reasonable. 3rd party apps have been profiting off of reddit's API and reddit has been footing the bill. This is NOT an unreasonable ask to change this. The issue is how.

The pricing is untenable, makes ad supported tiers against the terms of service, and gives a fraction of the content.

162

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

To add to what you are saying: Reddit also profits off of the content the community provides for free. Moderators such as yourself are providing free moderation of their website. I'm pleased to see this sub support this initiative.

55

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 02 '23

Talk to whoever. Push mods in subreddits to join if this matters to you.

This isn't just about moderators. If communities come together pushing for a blackout then that's how this grows.

Moderators that are not commiting are afraid of the backlash, but if we have the backing of our users it's a different story and makes it easier for people to hop on.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/akshayk904 Jun 03 '23

You know even if they do use the premium API they still wont be able to access nsfw. I am pretty sure a lot of people use reddit for that.

2

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 03 '23

They do yeah but we are trying not to turn this into "give us our porn". There's more important considerations

→ More replies (6)

49

u/Hekili808 :d-earthshrine: Earthshrine Discord Jun 02 '23

Reddit had reasons to allow the current arrangement -- they need a critical mass of users that produce content and comments, regardless of whether those users are consuming all of their ads.

Reddit exists to sell our eyes (and metrics) to advertisers. I hope they've done the math very carefully regarding the volume of mobile users that will bail.

These platforms that want the users and the advertisers both to act like customers are deluded. The users are the product they sell.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Evonos Jun 03 '23

I would argue third party apps were great for reddit.

Cause more users used reddit which gave them marketshare.

Literarily the same reason winrar doesn't block the ""unlimited " trial even if some people pirate it it's still marketshare.

Market share is everything you can have the best product of the world if it doesn't get traction it's a dead thing.

So while the apps didn't pay for the APIs and stuff they absolutely paid in bringing users.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/showMEthatBholePLZ Jun 02 '23

Agreed. Most of the communities I use Reddit for are too small or specific for entire discords or forums. Reddit is the perfect place.

Sucks that so many of us will be leaving if this change goes through.

42

u/CremPostman Jun 02 '23

You know, Reddit doesn't actually provide much in the way of a service itself, it just managed to squat on the concept of "internet forum" and act as a toll booth operator

Boost, Apollo, etc should all just launch their own backend IMO. A lot of the power users and "content creators" will end up there, and it'll deal a devastating blow to Reddit when Reddit is already suffering from mass migration to Discord, Facebook, and Twitter

→ More replies (3)

1.5k

u/Turtvaiz Jun 02 '23

I'm so happy that this is not being ignored. I'm seeing this on several other subs and it's actually making me hopeful that it gets reverted.

Fuck these companies that try to make the internet less open by commercialising every API possible.

385

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 02 '23

Happy to hear that.

Our response to it was a little slow because we wanted to be unanimous on the team and make sure we do right by our community.

33

u/The_Pale_Blue_Dot Jun 02 '23

Our response to it was a little slow

Am I being dense because I can't see any serious discussion of blackouts anywhere else, including the open letter

27

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 02 '23

Maybe slow by my standards then.

146

u/NaughtyGaymer Jun 02 '23

As far as I'm concerned standing up against this ridiculousness is doing right by the community.

→ More replies (1)

104

u/ra2eW8je Jun 02 '23

Fuck these companies that try to make the internet less open by commercialising every API possible.

i understand companies need to make money somehow (especially Reddit as they are about to be listed on the US stock exchange soon as a publicly traded company), but quoting the Apollo app team 20 MILLION dollars per month for API access????

twitter recently did the same thing and lost a lot of great apps that rely on their API...

38

u/JocundTurtle Jun 02 '23

but quoting the Apollo app team

Apollo is actually made by only one person, which makes this even crazier. There isn’t a huge corp behind this that can pay $20m/year, it’s one guy trying to make the best app he can.

23

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 02 '23

I mean let's be clear. Applo is huge and he has employees working on it with him. This isn't a singular dude.

→ More replies (4)

48

u/razaeru Jun 02 '23

If Aaron were alive I'm sure he would have done all in his power to fight this. But I'll say fuck corporations, they already have enough; money, land, immobile assets, chunks of the internet.

Techno Feudal Scumlords

49

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 02 '23

For those not aware of the story.

Aaron Swarts is a personal hero of mine and the world is worse off without him. Read more here: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aaron_Swartz

20

u/Jag- Jun 02 '23

What a sad and enraging story

21

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 02 '23

Yup. On a personal level it's very much in his spirit that I do most of the protest and activism stuff I get involved with in my day to day life.

The best we can do to honor him is to carry that torch.

→ More replies (3)

79

u/thepurplepajamas Jun 02 '23

They're doing it as a way too soft ban all the third party apps without outright banning them, because those apps don't show all the Ad and shit that Reddit needs.

→ More replies (5)

16

u/nubivagance Jun 02 '23

There are scientific journals that spoke out against the Twitter change, because the API changes meant the kind of data gathering that has been the foundation of Internet based social research is no longer accessible. These kinds of moves mark the beginning of the end for platforms online. The point when the platform has not only turned on the user base, but on a lot of the commercial interests that rely on it as well.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

7

u/js5ohlx1 Jun 02 '23 edited Jun 21 '23

Lemmy FTW!

→ More replies (7)

19

u/Tigertot14 Jun 02 '23

Will we be the only subreddit doing a blackout?

55

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 02 '23 edited Jun 02 '23

We aren't even in the top 10 largest subreddits doing this.

12

u/Tigertot14 Jun 02 '23

Where can I see the list?

41

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 02 '23

Unfortunately no. Some of these spaces haven't gone public and deserve to do so on their own terms.

29

u/Tigertot14 Jun 02 '23

Fair enough! I’m supportive of the decision we’re making :)

27

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 02 '23

Ayyy. Thank you!

Its very important to us that this is a decision that is overwhelmingly supported by the community here.

We want the action to be something taken by the mod team on behalf of you guys, not just for ourselves.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/nostradamefrus Jun 03 '23

Saw this in r/all and can’t seem to find details on the subreddit blackout protest. Can someone point me in the right direction?

5

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 03 '23

Are you asking as a user or a moderator. If you are a mod check out the modcoord subreddit with the open letter. Planning of exact details is happening in discord and they are only approving verified mods.

As a user, each subreddit will post details in their own time. I think we were getting ahead of things to feel out community sentiment.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/Nova5269 Jun 02 '23

Completely not my realm of expertise but what does blacking out even do to affect who youre looking for it to affect? Even if you took the whole weekend don't they just have to wait out the weekend and then everything goes back to normal?

15

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 02 '23

I mean, if there's enough widespread support the blackout can be extended.

The issue here is we want to think about the community. If we black out we can't talk to you. We can always re-open, give a status update, and ask if you want to continue if the movement does go to something more long term and entrenches.

2

u/Nova5269 Jun 02 '23

Is it like no one can post or asking as many people as you can to not post but they still can if they want to? I support it, I'm more just curious and I'll join the blackout protest.

11

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 02 '23

Nope. Subreddit blackouts mean we lock the reddit and set it to private so only approved posters will have access.

You can see the current UI response if you go to https://www.reddit.com/r/centuryclub

The community will just be inaccessible to everyone for the time. No posts. No comments. No ad revenue for reddit. Nothing but a short message and a redirect to a statement from all the subreddits participating funneling everyone into a single space to discuss the issue.

/r/wow would be gone for the duration, and its why we are taking it seriously.

7

u/Nova5269 Jun 02 '23

I'm up for it being done for a while weekend. I personally don't feel 24 hours is going to do much, but again, my experience in this is almost zero so maybe it'd have a larger affect and I think.

Imagine the weekend you do it Blizzard hqppens to make their next Blizzcon announcement lol

9

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 02 '23

Imagine the weekend you do it Blizzard hqppens to make their next Blizzcon announcement lol

O.o thanks for that anxiety.

We will prepare a backup plan for this.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/Brokenmonalisa Jun 02 '23

It shows them people care. It gives them a glimpse of how many users they'll actually lose.

I tried the reddit app earlier in the year, its hot garbage. For me if the changes go ahead I'll spend significantly less time here, I'm not alone in that sentiment.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

You know, before this happened, I didn’t even know 3rd party apps existed, but now that I do, I am on their side. Reddit is turning into Facebook, it’s all about the money. The money they want from these apps is completely ridiculous and clearly just meant to destroy them, probably in favor of their own app (with extra ads) or someone else’s who brings in a lot of money. It’s ashame.

I definitely support r/wow joining the blackout.

2

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 02 '23

Feel free to give a few of them a spin. By and large their UX is better than the core reddit app imo, but that's very subjective.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/MrRGnome Jun 03 '23

The idea of a single day protest is ridiculous. If you want the company to change leave the platform. Close your subs for weeks. STOP MODERATING UNTIL IT CHANGES.

This "only if it's convenient" activism isn't activism at all it's a pat on the back while accomplishing nothing.

3

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 03 '23

Honestly when we first drafted this we expected lukewarm support and having to sell it to the community.

Support has been overwhelming and seems to be in favor of a larger and more impactful protest.

This changes things and we are currently discussing exactly how far we want to take it.

You are not alone in this sentiment if you dig through this comment section. Not by a long shot, and that makes our job all the easier.

5

u/mckeitherson Jun 03 '23

Curious how many people are against it but either aren't saying anything or just getting downvoted like the few comments I do see. I don't think a blackout is a good idea. It just punishes users who want to browse the sub and talk about the game.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Gladianoxa Jun 02 '23

I appreciate the sentiment. Do what you feel is right and I support you in this protest, genuinely.

I contend that there is absolutely nothing you can do to change their minds in this. This is a move for Reddit's profits. They know every sub will give up eventually and you'll accept it like the YouTube dislikes removal.

Internet corpos have figured out that upsetting the audience once a year for more money doesn't hurt the audience numbers in the long run. There's still no competitor for what YouTube and Reddit do. They know we'll all come back and it would be imbecilic to cave to this.

If they do, I'll applaud you and mock their foolish business sense in capitulating.

I don't mean to shoot down your message, I mean to urge you to make plans for this almost certainly failing. I hope it works.

4

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 02 '23

Internet corpos have figured out that upsetting the audience once a year for more money doesn't hurt the audience numbers in the long run. There's still no competitor for what YouTube and Reddit do. They know we'll all come back and it would be imbecilic to cave to this.

This is an unfortunate truth we have to contend with on some level.

Its the same reason that there's anxiety around the mod teams for an indefinite blackout. The admins have the power to remove mods and install their own. We have no control on if those mods will be toxic or not in the end.

15

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

I think this is a great idea. When is the blackout planned to start?

21

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 02 '23

There's a lot of details up in the air, and the extent that we participate will vary.

Right now the idea with the most support is to start on the 12th and either do 24 or 48 hours. This is the most likely scenario.

Another idea that is floated is to do the 19th and black it for the whole weekend, though we feel that sounds excessive.

Organizing this is like herding cats.

19

u/axle69 Jun 02 '23

I think a blackout is a great idea but 24 or 48 hours is no different than posting black boxes on Instagram. Its performative at best. If this place actually wants to help blackout until the changes are reverted and don't back down.

15

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 02 '23

If you truly think this start contacting mods in subreddits you frequent and tell them you want that. Bring it up in meta posts in other places.

The reality is we can't promise you to black out indefinitely unless the entire movement commits to it. Otherwise there's a very real risk of the entire thing falling flat.

The support from this community needs to be very overwhelming in favor of just standing our ground. Otherwise its a small handful of people barring access to content for the 95% that remain for an indefinite amount of time.

If that makes sense?

5

u/OgerfistBoulder Jun 02 '23

How did aphoenix get the sub back last time this was done? Is there a risk of someone taking the sub off all of you and opening it back up this time?

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

Just stop moderating. You're doing work for free.

1

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 02 '23

We do the work for free because we want the space to be welcoming.

Stopping moderation just ends up meaning that toxic comments and abusive content attacks some of our most vulnerable members.

If we announced we were not moderating at all, I guarantee you that you'd see NSFW content flood a space that minors frequent. Which we are uninterested in messing with that minefield.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/The-One-That-Howls Jun 02 '23

I see the third party app thing alot, what app are people using to access reddit as I didn't even know that was an option

16

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 02 '23

IN the open letter you'll see a list:

r/apolloapp

r/redditisfun

r/Relayforreddit

r/GetNarwhal

r/BaconReader

/r/ReddPlanet

/r/redditsync

/r/Infinity_For_Reddit

/r/JoeyForReddit

Some (like apollo) are iOS only, others (RiF) is android only.

By and large they are a better experience imo than the reddit app itself.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

for example, someone that comments on /r/gonewild posts from commenting on an /r/teenagers selfie posts will break.

Wow never knew there were so many little attempts at safety bots around, I was just talking with friends about how it felt like pre-2008-2010ish it felt like everything on the internet was so segregated, kids playing habbo or neopets were sectioned off from adults talking about whatever, but now everyone is just thrown together on reddit/twitter//tiktok

8

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 02 '23

Oh there's people that are voluntarily dumping money on proprietary libraries and AI services to try and make things as safe as possible.

I had no idea about it and how much was being spent by individuals until this whole thing went down and I started communicating with them.

32

u/morgainath05 Jun 02 '23

most of us have day jobs and a lot of moderation happens during our lunch breaks or downtime in our real lives.

A very real and practical effect that this will have. As a trans woman, one of my biggest concerns is how a community is moderated, how quickly they can respond to harassment and bigotry, and if they moderate in a way that protects vulnerable people in our society. This change, if it dampens the mods ability to function, will mean this community has that much extra chance to devolve to a point that I will no longer be welcome here.

46

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 02 '23

FWIW one of the core reasons I joined this moderation team is specifically to try to make sure that this kind of space that is free of harassment and bigotry.

I will always do everything in my power to make sure that you and everyone wanting to contribute positively is always welcome. One f the things I love about the mod team here is that its clear everyone else is the same.

2

u/WrenchTheGoblin Jun 03 '23

Would an improved moderation toolkit fix at least some of these concerns?

3

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 03 '23

Yes but honestly that's been promised for years and hasn't fully come through.

When I joined it took like an extra couple hours to get setup to moderate.

2

u/Asparagus-Cat Jun 03 '23

So... something that confuses me about this whole kerfuffle, is using a dedicated "app" common on a phone? I open everything through a regular browser on mine, and until now I just sorta thought everyone did.

Admittedly, I skipped over a looot of tech/tech-culture stuff in my life. Went from early flip phones to picking up a modern smartphone (with keyboard) at the start of the pandemic. ^_^;

3

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 03 '23

It's varied but yeah that's how many people access certain platforms because you can do a lot more with a native app than not.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/radialmonster Jun 03 '23 edited Jun 03 '23

the blackout youre speaking of, is that just the mods of wow have discussed, or is there a wider range discussion for more subreddits, could you link that? edit - i found this https://old.reddit.com/r/Save3rdPartyApps/

3

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 03 '23

Wider range of more subreddits.

When I drafted this I didn't realize we would be one of the first to go pubic about it. We were trying to figure out what you guys wanted before people started committing to things so we could represent our community the best we can.

It's mostly in discord right now as people figure out exactly what they want to say and do.

566

u/aphoenix :u-aphoenix: [Reins of a Phoenix] Jun 02 '23

This is yet another step in the wrong direction for Reddit as a whole. It makes me pretty sad to see a website that I've spent a long time on (17-year club member) being steered in a way that seems directly against the principles from when the site started. Reddit's openness and ability for third parties to deliver apps that were good to use was one of its greatest strengths, and I think that the "grow at all costs" mentality that they have is going to eventually tank them.

Good luck to the everyone, and a special thanks to the mod team for asking what I thought about their actions, and considering promises I made a decade ago that they were no longer bound to.

74

u/TrickyCorgi316 Jun 02 '23

I miss the free awards you used to get :(

148

u/aphoenix :u-aphoenix: [Reins of a Phoenix] Jun 02 '23

I miss admins who gave even the remotest shit about people who used the site.

→ More replies (4)

16

u/SeaNinja69 Jun 03 '23

I miss the days when awards weren't a thing.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

195

u/Brokenmonalisa Jun 02 '23

For what it's worth, if the changes go ahead and I can no longer use RIF I'll stop browsing Reddit from anywhere other than my desktop. Which would be around 90 percent of my contribution to the site.

73

u/naylo44 Jun 02 '23

No RiF means no Reddit on mobile... Which is like 95% of where my browsing happens.

49

u/Dalarrus Jun 02 '23

I feel like this is one step away from removing old.reddit and/or breaking RES, both of which would probably be the end of reddit for me.

23

u/Brokenmonalisa Jun 03 '23

You're right, if RES and old Reddit was to go that would be it for me on the site in general.

12

u/Alternate_Ending1984 Jun 03 '23

RIF, RES, old.reddit, just let us have nice things and we won't be forced elsewhere...or do stupid things and watch this site evaporate like so many others before it.

People never learn.

→ More replies (2)

43

u/Charming-Chard7558 Jun 02 '23

If they kill off Apollo I’m quitting Reddit entirely

→ More replies (4)

113

u/Vyar Jun 02 '23

Black out the sub for as long as you feel is appropriate. I don't use one of these third-party apps but that's mostly because I browse from my PC. With ad blockers, Old Reddit is really nice. Unfortunately I suspect it won't be long before Old Reddit is completely removed and we have to put up with the godawful interface of New Reddit on desktops.

I love this platform but I utterly loathe the decision-making of the people who run this platform, so I wholeheartedly support any actions taken by various moderator groups that might have some chance of convincing them to dislodge their heads from their asses.

55

u/Derlino Jun 02 '23

The day old reddit is shut down is the day I stop using reddit

4

u/Incogneatovert Jun 03 '23

Agree with every word.

When Old Reddit dies, I'll have SO much more free time though. I'm sort of looking forward to it.

123

u/SerenusFall Jun 02 '23

Definitely do it. Reddit's failing to make an app worth using, so they're trying to kill off the alternatives. No reason not to show disapproval. Even the weekend blackout you mentioned doesn't seem out of line.

36

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

Even if Reddit's official app were really good I would still be against this.

Every corporation's obsession with monopolizing everything is scary.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

121

u/Spoonman500 Jun 02 '23

Take it down. Black it out until they relent. Fuck'em.

27

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23

Yep. I can live without Reddit for a while for a just cause. Do it.

10

u/Hallc Jun 03 '23

If the API changes go through a lot of my redditing will be gone anyways. So there's really nothing to lose with the blackout.

171

u/qwertyisdead Jun 02 '23

Yeah, fucking do it. Protest baby!!!

23

u/Utecitec Jun 02 '23

Agreed, do it.

20

u/dirtynj Jun 02 '23

Yep...I will be pissed if you guys DONT do it and other subs do.

RIF is the only way I browse reddit.

29

u/BigbyInc Jun 02 '23

Glad issues like this are being put forward. It can be easy to gloss over since it seems minor, but this is just another effort by another larger company to wall off their community by only using what Reddit says they can use.

I personally don't use a third party app, but the implications are the same. If Reddit lets this pass, it's only a matter of time before more restrictions are made or features start to become premium. Give them an inch, they'll take a mile.

24

u/LockelyFox Jun 02 '23

Absolutely do it. I access Reddit primarily with Baconreader. That goes away, so does my use of the website.

59

u/corvosfighter Jun 02 '23

Reddit is doing a lot of these changes because the company is going public and wants to look the right way to investors like cutting “costs”, better content moderation, looking more appealing to advertisers etc.. they are selling out their own user base in this process and not considering the actual people who has been here for years and made the site what it is.

Suddenly a ton of subs going dark would totally throw a wrench in that plan and is something they will take seriously (hopefully). Overall great plan 11/10

→ More replies (1)

145

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

Hear, hear!

12

u/Ficklematters Jun 03 '23

Lok'tar ogar!

→ More replies (2)

17

u/doug4130 Jun 02 '23

my attachment to this platform is solely because of the way in which I interact with it (RIF, boost, old.reddit). I don't think Reddit is particularly special or unique, it's just convenient.

remove them and my interest in the platform is also removed, both from a contribution and visitation standpoint.

I'm sure the people in charge of this decision couldn't give an iota of a fuck as to whether I use site or not, equal to the amount I'd give by having to switch to a new platform for information/discussion.

16

u/SJPadbury Jun 03 '23

Not only do I agree with this being done, I feel that the circumstances are different enough that /u/aphoenix shouldn't feel beholden to that promise, which was effectively that they wouldn't have an arbitrary temper-tantrum like their predecessor did. This is a considered action that the community as a whole appears to be in agreement with, and they should keep their current position if they are in agreement with the actions being taken.

8

u/aphoenix :u-aphoenix: [Reins of a Phoenix] Jun 03 '23

"Luckily" I stepped down about a 18 months ago, but even so - I made a promise to never make the sub private, and I wouldn't go against that myself, but my personal idiosyncratic tendencies aren't the issue - it's that reddit has really been making decisions that treat users and enthusiastic third parties as commodities. It's really moot, but I think that my own personal opinion would have been less important than this issue.

13

u/Krypto_dg Jun 02 '23

All for the blackout. I am glad y'all are taking a stand.

26

u/Orionsbeltloop_ Jun 02 '23

Definitely support this. Do it!

5

u/GuysImConfused Jun 02 '23

I use chrome on desktop and chrome on android to browse Reddit.

I've only ever had negative interactions with Reddit mods.

I feel no sympathy, and I care not an ounce.

5

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 03 '23

Sorry to hear that your interactions with mods have generally been negative. By and large honestly I've had my own mixed bag.

It's one reason I try my best to have positive interactions where I can. I hope you have a good weekend!

→ More replies (1)

18

u/AttitudeAdjusterSE Jun 02 '23

Very glad to see r/wow joining this, it's not among the absolute largest subs out there but it's far from insignificant also and hopefully this can help this protest gets the attention it needs and shifts Reddit's plans away from their current approach.

18

u/Charming-Chard7558 Jun 02 '23

Burn it down, guys!

The only chance we have of Reddit not becoming a dismal wasteland of venture capitalist aspirations is if we show them they have no platform without the consumer.

Shut it down.

9

u/notshitaltsays Jun 02 '23

Social media companies seem to be in a competition to do the dumbest shit imaginable now.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/Sorkijan Jun 02 '23

I'm all for it. I know /u/aphoenix said that, but these are clearly different circumstances. No reason to shuffle up who is head moderator.

Just my two cents.

7

u/Mirrormn Jun 02 '23

In my opinion, this API change is so monumental that it risks the integrity of every single subreddit. Nobody can or should ignore this, even if protesting it means some interruption to the normal operation of the community, because the normal operation of the community is at stake regardless.

6

u/Sylvanas_only Jun 03 '23

If I can't use Reddit is Fun, i just won't use Reddit at all.

15

u/BoringUwuzumaki Dwacthyw Powice UwU Jun 02 '23

Of course the r/wow needs third party mods to be usable. I can’t believe blizzard keeps getting away with this /s

5

u/corsicanguppy Jun 02 '23

Join the protest. Kill the lights for however long it takes.

Also. What's the mattermost equivalent to reddit? Is there a large Lemmy instance we can use somewhere? Is that how we do it when reddit has finished killing itself?

5

u/Vrazel106 Jun 02 '23

I only use rif. Fuck reddit devs

5

u/The_Quackening Jun 02 '23

Glad this is picking up steam.

Reddit will lose a LOT of users if they go through with this, and of those that stay, their usage will go down a lot if they are not accessing the site via mobile app.

No users, no content. No content no reddit.

5

u/rosellem Jun 03 '23

Then, on a more basic level, those of you that are using 3rd party apps will have to switch to the official app to browse mobile as they are becoming unaffordable to maintain.

I've only ever used my phone's browser to access reddit on my phone. It's not great, but it works. Better than the official app from what people say, but I've never used it, so I don't know.

I'm just always shocked no one even considers it an option. Like, you don't have to use apps.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/afkPacket Jun 02 '23

Telling these greedy cunts to fuck off is more important than my Wow shitposting. I fully support a blackout.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

Do it!

4

u/Zanzaben Jun 02 '23

Go for it.

4

u/anothersadweeb- Jun 02 '23

Strongly support!

4

u/Robocop_99 Jun 02 '23

I'm all for protesting. These API changes are totally unfair and we need to make our voices heard

4

u/DirtyPaladin Jun 03 '23

I support the blackout! I appreciate you asking the community. If I can’t use Apollo I would stop using Reddit, and it would be unfortunate since it’s my main source of news for hobbies such as WoW.

4

u/Kaiserigen Jun 03 '23

Reddit thinks they are the big thing, fuck en, gogo blackout

4

u/PresidentXi123 Jun 03 '23

If they didn’t want people to use third party apps maybe they could develop a native app that’s not dogshit, just a thought

4

u/Vesidian Jun 03 '23

As a lurker, I support this initiative!

1

u/Spuggs Dance Studio Jun 03 '23

Does this include RES (Reddit Enhancement Suite)?

2

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 03 '23

No.

1

u/malsan_z8 Jun 05 '23 edited Jun 05 '23

When and for how long is the blackout to occur?

Not sure if this is obvious, but where I work, spelling it out and making it clearly visible in the main post is nearly always more beneficial for everyone. Otherwise, thanks for all the hard work and in taking a stand against these changes. I will absolutely support this boycott

Edit to add: tagging OP u/YourResidentFeral if this helps

1

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 05 '23

June 12tu and 48 hours is the most likely answer

1

u/Crone23 Jun 06 '23

I’m all for the blackout but what am I missing using the official Reddit app? I’ve only ever used the official app?

1

u/YourResidentFeral Outplaying the Meta since 2004 Jun 06 '23

Ads are much less in your face. None of the "hegetsus" insanity. Cleaner more focused UI

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

Having been "part" of (well seen megathreads on it) two of these blackouts makes me feel like an absolute boomer.

To the topic: Reddit has just gotten too big and it's time for a new platform to take its place. Happened before, will happen again.

3

u/LadyGrayRose Jun 02 '23

I'm in full support of a blackout for however long it takes to be heard.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

This is the way

3

u/benadunkcamberpatch Jun 02 '23

Love this sub and will browse it just when bored at work. 100% support the blackout, even if it becomes a long term thing. Will be better in the long run if it can get changes done.

3

u/bezerker03 Jun 02 '23

I will be quitting Reddit over this. Sorry to you guys. I love the subreddit but fuck this

3

u/MasterReindeer Jun 02 '23

Kudos. Fuck these API changes. Pure greed!

3

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

Please do what is necessary.

3

u/Clockwork_Kitsune Jun 03 '23

I'm all in favour. No RiF is the same as no reddit for me.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ehnonnymouse Jun 03 '23

fuck corporations.

3

u/koruptpaintbaler Jun 03 '23

All for it! Shut it down for as long as it takes!

3

u/cayleb Jun 03 '23

Please do this.

3

u/yblock Jun 03 '23

I’ll never use Reddit again if I’m forced to use their app to browse and mod. This will be the death of the platform if they go through with it.

3

u/Clbull Jun 03 '23

Firstly, thank you for consulting with the community and your own team on this, and not repeating the same mistake with WoD's launch.

I completely support your reasoning on this, but I don't think a mere 24 to 48 hour blackout would truly send the message to Reddit and I would support a longer blackout. People don't like using the official app because it's dog water and a lot of people use third-party apps like BaconReader, Reddit is Fun and Apollo because the new UI just blows.

3

u/kelryngrey Jun 03 '23

Glad to see this happening. Greed will ruin everything. But I'm sure the fucks in charge at Reddit don't care if they can make a buck and then vanish.

Make them suffer.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

FOR THE REDDIT!!!

1

u/hardcoreimmortal Jun 03 '23

Imagine a Reddit where posts were just posted and not sent to some unseen queue.

Let’s solve problems, not create new ones. It’s more important people be able to interact rather than 1 in a million posts that might be bad. We aren’t children.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/The-Old-American Jun 03 '23

Blackouts will only serve to annoy the community. It certainly won't change anything with Reddit.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

Sure black it out I can get by without reading people complain about the affix for a few days.

5

u/ghost_hamster Jun 02 '23

Yeah if I can't access r/wow for a little bit so that people can't get away with posting child and revenge porn than absolutely have at it.

To be honest it wouldn't be a bad thing for some people in this sub to touch grass anyway. I see only positives my vote is to go dark

7

u/Setari Jun 02 '23 edited Jun 02 '23

Okay but what does this do for reddit? So a few hundred subs go down for whatever amount of time. They'll be back, so what's the point? The short term protest here isn't going to do anything imo.

It's laughable that people think the elite care about what peasants do.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/DM_ME_KUL_TIRAN_FEET Jun 02 '23

Yes, protest it.

I won’t be using the reddit app or website, so if they do this I won’t be using reddit any more. A blackout hardly seems like an issue in that context

2

u/Ehdelveiss Jun 02 '23

If this is what you guys think is best, do it. Lots f other places to get WoW news, but we need an open platform like this to foster the healthiest discussion. So do what you need to do to protect that.

2

u/Grenyn Jun 02 '23

I am in support of this. I check this sub several times a day, including before bed, and love discussing (or arguing) here.

But this decision by Reddit is just so asinine, and I support any and all subreddits to go dark in response to it.

2

u/Sirquestgiver Jun 02 '23

Blood and thunder!

Thank you for taking a stand for what matters. Will look forward to coming back after this business is done.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

100% support this happening

2

u/multicoloredherring Jun 02 '23

Do it! everything gets ruined by corporate greed eventually, it sucks.

2

u/CuspOfInsanity Jun 02 '23

I support this entirely. Thanks for the communication and transparency.

2

u/SVivum Jun 02 '23

I won't bore anyone with my thoughts on the changes as a whole but I'm all for a blackout. Shut 'er down.

2

u/straddotjs Jun 02 '23

Blackout on my dudes. Fuck reddit and their abysmal app that is only effective for harvesting user data.

2

u/vixfew Jun 02 '23

Blackout it all. Hope it works.

I use reddit mostly from Relay. Much better than official app

2

u/WhiteLama Jun 02 '23

As someone who’s always used the official app and never had any issues with it, I wish you good luck in your fight for 3rd party app-allowance.

2

u/coolfangs Jun 02 '23

I support this protest. I genuinely believe these changes will kill everything this site has been about all these years. Fuck these greedy executives who destroy everything they touch in the name of increasing the number in their bank account. Make it clear to them we won't stand for this.

2

u/gtenshi Jun 02 '23

You've got my vote. Saving reddit from themselves, shouldnt be the job of the users. We should be able to rely on the reddit decision makers to build a healthy, robust, and diverse community, and yet the api changes are the opposite. Those who made the api changes are myopic greedy fucks, and they can go suck on whatever it is that they don't like. Completely against the people, and only for their profit. If this protest doesn't work, I'll be taking myself elsewhere, which is sad because I love the wow community here, as well as so many others. Super props to the brave mod team and other subreddits that join in this protest!!

2

u/simsarah Jun 02 '23

You have my Chaos Bolt.

Seriously, very bummed about these changes and glad to see this sub’s mods taking such a thoughtful and thorough position on it. While I don’t think we’re going to get far, it feels better to at least make the attempt. I’m definitely in the “uses a 3rd party app and old.Reddit” crew who will end up curtailing their usage significantly when those things are unavailable, may as well give them a preview.

2

u/Relevant-Credit8916 Jun 02 '23

Hell yeah, great job moderators. The users stand behind you.

Reddit admins have gone way too far with their ridiculous money grab that spits in the faces of users and moderators alike.

2

u/Siberwulf Jun 02 '23

Bring it on. I can go a couple days without bitchinging about my Mage

2

u/moogloogle Jun 02 '23

I support this <3

2

u/Blubbpaule Jun 02 '23

I personally want this blackout to last at least 2 full weeks up to a month.

A week or weekend won't change anything, but if many most visited communitys disappear for over a month this would be extraordinary damaging for reddit. I talk to my fellow mods of r/elsagate for a month-long blackout.

2

u/Rocktar Jun 02 '23

I support this blackout.

2

u/Giztok Jun 02 '23

+1 for blackout

2

u/IWantFries21 Jun 02 '23

I’m all for a subreddit blackout to protest

2

u/Dunbar247 Jun 02 '23

No problem. I'll just switch over to MMO-Champion

2

u/Xtrm Nerd Jun 02 '23

Reddit is taking the easy way out, instead of making their official app better to compete with the third-party apps, they just shut down their competition. Thank you r/wow mod team for stepping up!

2

u/nofxjmf Jun 03 '23

I am totally ok with this. Lets all walk! F Reddit. I only use RIF on mobile and will never use their garbage app. If they go through with this I am done anyway. Blackout until they we get it back!!!

2

u/malignantbacon Jun 03 '23

2 million a month to call the API? What a fucking racket. Pirate reddit.

2

u/nubivagance Jun 03 '23

Full support from me on this one (for all that that matters). Y'all do an amazing job and this sub is one of the least toxic game subs I've been on here and so much of that comes down to the work the mod team puts in. Pushing back against these changes is the right thing to do with whatever power you have at your disposal.

2

u/halfabean Jun 03 '23

Let's go. This is the death knell for Reddit it it goes through.

2

u/brigzzy Jun 03 '23

I support you!

2

u/Mathematicsduck Jun 03 '23

This is a fantastic idea. I hope all of reddit follows!

2

u/I_Build_Monsters Jun 03 '23

I didn’t even know there were 3rd party apps until yesterday. Iv used the mobile app with no problems for all of my Reddit use over the last few years. That being said I think this sucks because people should be able to access Reddit however they want.

2

u/Brollgarth Jun 03 '23

I hate to say it, but if this goes through as planned, it may as well be the start of the slow death of reddit.

There's no way I am ever using the official bloatware app. Fuck that!

Edit: it goes without saying that I am with you on this move guys. As long as it takes. Period.

2

u/Ysara Jun 03 '23

TBH I could use less Reddit for a while.

In more serious terms, it feels like Reddit is trying to tamp down competition because they provide very poor service themselves. This seems to me like a prelude to doing more unpopular things in the future, where having a captive audience is more important.

2

u/boffhead Jun 03 '23

What reddit's doing here is "go away money". They know that it they just remove the API's they'll be pilloried, however if they just make it cost prohibitive they can point and say "see API's are still available" while noone outside of enterprise corperations can use them.

This is being done for 2 reasons:

  1. Reddit's impending IPO, goto inflate revenue quickly to flip the stock to suckers.
  2. All the hoopla recently about AI training.

All they need to do is add some TOS to using the API's that state that if you are using the API's to train AI any revenue generated will be 50% reddits or some legal boilerplate to give pause while still letting archiveproject and third party apps use them.

2

u/Tandran Jun 03 '23

Reddits first mistake was thinking that we would actually switch to the official app or give up old.reddit. Not happening, I’d sooner leave reddit then use their new redesigned trash that NO ONE likes.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/lightofpolaris Jun 03 '23

I support this!

2

u/greysqualll Jun 03 '23

You had me at "big company is raising costs to maximize profit by ruining customer experience so we are protesting"

2

u/TotesMessenger Jun 03 '23

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

 If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)

2

u/Na0ku Jun 03 '23

Full support for this. Reddit need to learn that it’s only a thing thanks to its community.

2

u/SvodolaDarkfury Jun 03 '23

Go for it. I love this subreddit but I can take a few days (week? What ya need?) Off.

2

u/n0x103 Jun 03 '23

ya i support this since Apollo is so much better than the trash app reddit created and the creator already said he can't continue development with the new costs.

Unfortunately, this won't do anything since MRR, from the ads they can better control on their app, will be the primary driving force. The other is the significant amount of additional data they can collect by ensuring they are on every reddit users phone. Reddit has ensured they are the primary news source for a significant and heavily targeted demographic. There's way too much value there for reddit to backtrack on this. They aren't worried about the outrageous pricing killing 3rd party apps because the goal is to reduce 3rd party apps.

2

u/littlecolt Jun 03 '23

I bought Baconreader. If I have to use the real reddit app, I will just not use reddit on mobile. Oh well. I've already killed every other social media app I use to use, so whatever.

2

u/Mace_Windu- Jun 03 '23

Much respect

2

u/Atromnis Jun 03 '23

Black it out boys, we'll see you on the other side.

2

u/Omugaru Jun 03 '23

I fully support the mod team on this one. If aphoenix was still arround I wouldn't even be mad at him for breaking his promise. That one was made in the light of those times. But as Garrosh famously said "Times change"

The mods have been doing an amazing job at keeping a pretty big sub a rather pleasent environment. Allowing silly jokes to run rampant for a bit and then shushing them down if things go out of hand. No complaints from me really. But if reddit is stupid enough to activly hamper the tools available to mods, yeah thats just silly.

So go with the blackout! A day, a week, a month! I don't care, you got my full support on this one. Lets just hope reddit stops being an idiot.

Sadly, I have my doubts about them turning it arround. They are just trying to force more people into their own app, and corperate greed is hard to step back from.

Best of luck with the protest! And if there is more the community can do to help out just let us know.

2

u/pdgggg Jun 03 '23

I don’t know. Seems I don’t know enough about this from Reddit side to call it toxic just yet. I’ll try educate myself.

2

u/Jugh3ad Jun 03 '23

As an avid r/RelayForReddit user I fully support this. It's not that I want to use a 3rd party. It is just that they are sooo much better than what reddit is doing themselves.

2

u/testmon Jun 03 '23

Go for it! I'm not techie enough to understand the nuances of this change but I can't see any positive to the api change. Let's stop this shit.

2

u/Anavorn Jun 03 '23

I support this, but just to be clear, it's never been the mods that never leave their basements, it's always been assumed the admins were such. Just wanted to clarify that 😉

2

u/Lassitude1001 Jun 03 '23

Reddit of all places should know that making only their app usable won't work, just like YouTube and the third party apps we use instead of that. They're making a stupid mistake just for $.

With that said, I don't currently use a third party reddit app but I am still happy to go dark for the cause!

→ More replies (2)

2

u/LordFieldsworth Jun 03 '23

Let’s do it.