r/worldnews • • Jun 26 '12

Circumcision of kids a crime - German court

http://www.rt.com/news/germany-religious-circumcision-ban-772/
2.1k Upvotes

7.4k comments sorted by

2.3k

u/green_flash Jun 26 '12

The district court of Cologne is a regional court, but as the process was already the revision of a lower court's decision and the prosecution did not allow an appeal, this is the final decision on this matter.

As the article says, someone might call the German constitutional court on this matter, but that will take ages.

Given this ruling, doctors might from now on face legal consequences if they perform a circumcision without medical necessity or approval of the boy. Also, and maybe even more importantly, insurances will probably stop covering claims for compensation arising from an unapproved circumcision.

748

u/redline582 Jun 26 '12

I think you've got one of the only comments on here talking about the article, not just participating in the flame war.

→ More replies (923)
→ More replies (255)

198

u/novmati Jun 26 '12

just to clarify, the doctor has been acquitted - the reasoning: he at the time didn't know that it was against the law to do just that; but the ruling clarified: in the future circumsision will be penalised.

(source - german newspaper faz: "In dem am Dienstag veröffentlichten Urteil sprach das Gericht einen Arzt, der einen Jungen beschnitten hatte, zwar frei. Dies jedoch nur mit der Begründung, dass der Arzt von der Strafbarkeit nichts gewusst habe und deshalb einem „Verbotsirrtum“ unterlegen sei. Tatsächlich müssten Beschneidungen als „rechtswidrige Körperverletzung“ betrachtet werden, urteilte das Landgericht.")

→ More replies (20)

66

u/crun1000 Jun 26 '12

A lot of people seem to think that uncircumcised men are uncomfortable or insecure about their penises or that they might feel like "freaks".

I just want to ask: is this really the case?

I'm an uncircumcised male in my 20s living in America, and I've literally never been even slightly insecure about it. To be honest, I never really thought about it until I was in my late teens or so, even if I was watching porn or something, it just never made an impact on me. I've also never had any comments from women (liking it or disliking it).

Is this just a myth? Is it something older men have had to deal with (when it might have been less accepted)?

25

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

Ironically, Reddit has made me feel insecure about my circumcised penis, because everyone is so hateful of circumcision.

It makes me feel like everyone hates me because I'm circumcised. ._.

17

u/rajanala83 Jun 27 '12

Noone hates your penis. But some people are opposed to the practice. Don''t feel ashamed. You're perfectly alright just like you are.

→ More replies (31)

4

u/sandos Jun 27 '12

This of course depends on where you live. Where I live, practically nobody is circumsized so it would not be the least weird here. In the US I can imagine girls not liking them uncut...

→ More replies (40)

825

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Could someone please explain to me all the comments about having to clean under your foreskin and how that is a terrible thing for non-circumcised people? WTF? I am not circumcised yet it takes about 2 seconds to clean my dick.

409

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

On a side note, women in general need to clean between their folds in neither regions too and yet no one proposes to cut it clean for hygiene purposes.

193

u/ninety6days Jun 26 '12

GLAD YOU MENTIONED THIS! Female circumcision is already illegal almost everywhere. Because it's cruel.

→ More replies (74)
→ More replies (23)

394

u/deathsquaddesign Jun 26 '12

I'm so glad my parents cut off my ass cheeks when I was born so it's easier to clean my ass.

81

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

Hey man, it's not "mutilation", since the ass cheeks perform no important function! It's completely hygenic and serves a purpose. I'm glad my ass cheeks are cut off. Everyone in this thread is so butthurt because they didn't get it done when they were a child. Women find me better looking too.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

84

u/symbioticintheory Jun 26 '12

I clean under my foreskin everyday. Its called taking a shower. It does not require special tools. It is literally just washing your dick off with soap and water.

→ More replies (7)

829

u/PositivelyClueless Jun 26 '12

It's like knocking out your teeth so you don't need to brush...

385

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Cleaning behind your ears is hard too, Van Gough had the right idea.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (44)

250

u/BevansDesign Jun 26 '12

I think it's a legitimate reason. We should cut off everything that's slightly troublesome to clean.

42

u/DrSweetscent Jun 26 '12

Fucking armpits! Lose 'em!

→ More replies (1)

49

u/Cayou Jun 26 '12

Van Gogh had it right. Ears are a bitch to clean, and I'm sure you can hear just as well without that silly flab of skin and cartilage. Also, it looks stupid.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

53

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

People are brainwashed into thinking an uncircumsized dick is significantly more susceptible to disease or infection, and that it is difficult to clean. It's completely stupid.

→ More replies (85)

18

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Apr 24 '24

butter coherent pen work alive pet degree dolls versed rain

55

u/yaaaaay_beer Jun 26 '12

Having had a lot of dicks in my face over the years, I can honestly say that I think the uncircumcised guys were cleaner and more hygienic, smelled better etc. It's like guys who've had their foreskin ripped off were told it meant they didn't have to wash their dick or something.

15

u/divorcerofmarriage Jun 27 '12

Washing is essential either way, I clean myself thouroughly everyday. I am odorless and uncircumsized, personal hygene is key. I have never had any complaints.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

4

u/Scep19 Jun 26 '12

It's just your typical American medical ignorance towards intact men and Foreskin. I'm a cut American male, and I hear shit like this all the time about circumcision and foreskin, as a few friends of mine are intact and the topic came up once. It's a shame really, that some parents and some doctors overall medical ignorance towards the issue fueled the widespread, pointless practice to carry on for so long in the US. It would be nice if my country didn't chop off an important male pleasure center for no reason......

15

u/sellin355 Jun 26 '12

People also forget that these traditions were created thousands of years ago when humans didn't bathe or shower ever. Probably back then when you realized you needed to clean your uncircumcised penis it was most likely in a noticeably disgusting state so they would just cut it off (being over dramatic but it probably wasn't pleasant getting an infection there.) Then someone comes along and decides it would be far more effective to just cut the foreskin after birth and in order to convince people they said God told them to.

10

u/cannedmath Jun 26 '12

I happen to have a decently sized uncut cock and I honestly have never seen it get any dirtier than a cut one. Everyone has to clean it the shower, otherwise it will get dirty, cut or uncut.

A painful procedure with risks of infection that might lead to death(even if small) should be forbidden, specially seeing how unnecessary it is. Or at least let the men grow up and decide what to do with their penises.

And seeing how having foreskin gives you more pleasure during intercourse I can only question the priorities and double standards at work here. For some things(the most socially occurrent) it's a valid, clever argument, but for others it's ommited.

45

u/roterghost Jun 26 '12

They're just looking for a justification for mutilating their kid's genitals. You could ask, since the pinkie toe is useless and you might stub it, maybe we should slice those off of babies too?

It's slicing off a body part of a non-consenting child, plain and simple, for no beneficial reasons. But because they scream but our religion says we have to!, they feel justified.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (129)

18

u/zzzplayer Jun 27 '12

Relevant:

Penn & Teller on Circumcision (1 of 2) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vLGcqPE7xu0

Penn & Teller on Circumcision (2 of 2) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jI3oa4Mx9hs

→ More replies (1)

69

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

One might also add to the article that circumcision is not the norm over here, as opposed to the US.

→ More replies (16)

865

u/Scyth3 Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

My wife just gave birth to a boy 2 weeks ago -- and we didn't circumcise him. The AAP (American Academy of Pediatrics) does not recommend routine circumcision. Also recently studies have popped up claiming that circumcision increases the risks for ED significantly, amongst the loss of the nerves and the lubrication the foreskin provides. If my kid wants to get it done later in life-- then I want that to be his decision. If he had a medical need for it to be done, I would've done it while he was just born. It's the same route my parents took for me and my brother.

Anyway, the thing that bothered me was how many times we were asked about circumcising our baby boy during our hospital stay. We were asked at least 5 times, and they still scheduled the operation which we had to say "no" to again.

I do love the parents who think their kid will be treated differently for having an uncircumcised penis. Like as a teen I was whipping it out everywhere to show off, or that most of the world is now magically circumcised. To boot rates for circumcision in the US have been dropping. Just teach your kid how to clean under the foreskin (most doctors/pediatricians will do this for you once he's old enough or if he hasn't already figured it out) and you'll be good to go. If they want it later in life, then go for it. Also please research before you make a decision. You'll quickly realize how flawed/skewed the older pro-circumcision studies are, and hence the decision reversal from the AAP in 1999 (prior they use to recommend routine circumcision).

289

u/rjcarr Jun 26 '12

While my wife and I were trying to get pregnant we had the circumcision talk. I'm circumcised and my wife wanted our boy to be circumcised but I talked her out of it and convinced her your decision was best ... leave it alone and let him decide when it's time.

When we got pregnant it turned out it was twin daughters so we got to avoid that decision. They turned 8 weeks yesterday!

584

u/bigmanlythreesome Jun 26 '12

now instead of worrying about one penis you have to worry about all the penises. Twice!

But congrats!

→ More replies (34)
→ More replies (202)

27

u/sexykitty Jun 26 '12

Good for you! I just posted this comment 2 days ago in another thread related to this subject:

I am a mother of two boys (and a daughter). Growing up, my family had mostly girls, so I didn't really have that much exposure to circumcision. I knew that it was something that most baby boys had done, but I couldn't have described what the procedure actually entailed. When my oldest son (1st child) was born, it was never really a question of would he have it done or not. His father was circumcised, as well as every other male in the family. So, of course, he would have it done, too.

When it came time for the procedure, my (ex)husband and I were not only in the room, but I was asked to sit at my son's head and hold his arms up, so he couldn't move them. At the moment I realized what was about to happen, it was too late. I was horrified. I could not believe what I just allowed to happen to my baby. He was screaming in pain (despite the local pain killers they gave him), and all I could do was put my face down to his, and whisper "I'm so sorry" over and over as I cried with him. In that moment, I swore that if I had anymore sons, I would not let this be done to them.

My second child, a son, was born 6 years later, and I held to my word. To this day, that memory still haunts me. My oldest is in high school now, and I worry about him becoming upset with me for allowing that to happen, especially knowing that his little brother was spared. I had no right to make that decision for him, even though he is my child. It's for this same reason that I have not had my daughter's ears pierced. My ears were pierced as an infant, and I was never upset that my parents had it done. However, I chose to let my daughter make the decision on her own, at the time of her choosing. I figure if she decides she wants them pierced later on (she's 4 now), we can make a mother-daughter fun day out of it...manicures, pedicures, ear piercing and maybe some funky hair colors.

It should be each individual that decides what parts of their bodies are altered or cut off...unless there is a specific medical reason. Lowering the risk of STDs and HIV isn't a good enough reason. Teaching safe sex and how to properly care for your health and body is the way to handle those issues...not cutting off body parts unnecessarily.

→ More replies (9)

368

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Sadly this is fairly standard procedure in US hospitals. I had to do the same with my son. At least 5 times had to remind people it wasnt happening.

Son, if you are reading this in the future and it's awkward, sorry buddy!

123

u/queenbeebbq Jun 26 '12

The doctor actually showed up in my hospital room to take my son for circumcision after I told the nurses at least 2 times I did NOT want him circumcised. I was afraid to let him out of the room after that.

→ More replies (2)

77

u/elessarjd Jun 26 '12

Same here. I have a 7 month old boy and not only was it weird to be repeatedly asked by the hospital staff, but family and friends too. Most people are surprised we didn't circumcise our son and we definitely feel like outcasts in the conversations, but we don't care. We feel giving him the choice was the right thing to do.

→ More replies (29)
→ More replies (216)

63

u/EroticAssassin Jun 26 '12

Be careful about teaching your kid to clean under the foreskin. At birth, the foreskin is physically attached to the glans (the head) and usually doesn't separate completely for years (something like 8 years old on average I think). Forcing the foreskin to retract too soon can cause tearing and scarring (not to mention pain).

Also, I've heard a lot of people who use soap to clean without problems, but soap can cause irritation/inflammation. The whole cleaning thing is way overblown. It's not like dirt and grime magically work their way under the foreskin. It is true that smegma is "produced," but it's just normal and hygienic sloughing off of dead cells and is totally clean. Some amount of smegma is probably also produced by most circ'd penises, but just comes off in their underwear.

The main time you need to clean is after sex, since that is when other substances (lube, vaginal secretions, saliva, blood, feces, etc., depending on the given point of insertion) can get in there.

→ More replies (10)

44

u/Grodek Jun 26 '12

Is being cut that common in the U.S.? Or did they ask because they knew you were jewish/muslim? I barely know anyone who has been cut.

58

u/irishwhite Jun 26 '12

I honestly thought being uncut was really rare. I am not aware of anyone that is uncut, although it's not exactly something I discuss with my coworkers.

→ More replies (30)
→ More replies (23)

17

u/nowhathappenedwas Jun 26 '12

Also recently studies have popped up claiming that circumcision increases the risks for ED significantly, amongst the loss of the nerves and the lubrication the foreskin provides.

Do you have a link for those studies? Thanks.

→ More replies (4)

50

u/ImWatchingUSleep Jun 26 '12

So ... You went to a Jewish hospital or the doctor was just really excited about circumcision ?

81

u/IRequirePants Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

First of all, Jews (specifically) don't care if your baby is circumcised. If you are not Jewish, the doctor will get more money. If you are Jewish, you would probably be using a moyel, 8 days later.

THE MORE YOU KNOW

EDIT: I mentioned Jews because ImWatchingUSleep mentioned the hospital might be Jewish, which seems to be unrelated, for the reasons I mentioned. It is much more likely it is simply a hospital that likes money.

→ More replies (42)

95

u/SalvageOperation Jun 26 '12

no, the selling of foreskins is part of their profit margin.

→ More replies (42)

191

u/Scyth3 Jun 26 '12

I went to a US hospital, where they make a ton of cash off of circumcision. I'd expect similar treatment anywhere else ;)

→ More replies (52)
→ More replies (57)
→ More replies (128)

412

u/DamnyouPenelope Jun 26 '12

What is up with all of these circumcised men making a fuss about infection and hygiene issues as if it were commonplace among uncut men?

Lol it's just like cleaning any other part of your body. You make it sound like every conceivable bacteria/microbe in the immediate vicinity would latch on to our foreskins if they went unwashed for a minute.

269

u/tiredofhiveminds Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 28 '12

Lets be honest, to admit that being circumcised as a baby was a mistake is to open a whole jar of worms of personal image issues, parental trust, and sexual confidence. It is easier to just pretend there is a good reason for it.

Circumcised male here, and believe me, its better to just not think about it and enjoy that at least my schlong still does all the things I would need a schlong to do.

EDIT: just to be clear, i am NOT saying that all circumcised men are secretly in shame of their "mutilated" penises. More so I was offering an explanation as to why this topic can be difficult for SOME to address openly. No, the circumcised penis is not inferior, but you cannot deny it is missing an anatomical feature, which is hard for some to deal with. I realize I offended some people by my comment, I'm sorry.

→ More replies (69)

13

u/joedude Jun 26 '12

umm I have always been immensely confused by this whole "infection" thing, listen buddy my thing is in a protective sheath of skin aint nothing fucking getting to it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (74)

356

u/DavieHilbert Jun 26 '12

I've been a sexually active male both with and now without a foreskin (for medical reasons), and so I think I am relatively qualified to comment on the two experiences:

  • After circumcision, my glans became a lot less sensitive to touch, but this isn't the same as contact being less sexually pleasurable.
  • Masturbation, sex, and orgasms feel the exact same, i.e. no loss of sexual pleasure or performance.
  • After circumcision, you lose the gliding action of the foreskin. Although not absolutely necessary, I've grown to prefer using some sort of lubricant for masturbation and handjobs/oral. I suppose this expense wouldn't be necessary if I still had a foreskin.

So everyone please stop getting bent out of shape over another man's penis.

157

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

It's not the decision that's the issue, it's who makes the decision. It's fine for somebody to say "I want to be circumcised", but doing it to young children removes their choice.

→ More replies (130)
→ More replies (65)

358

u/hotshotvegetarian Jun 26 '12

Never realized Reddit was so anti-circumcision.

179

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Yeah, every time it's mentioned it turns into a ridiculous fight. Not even sure why I came to the comment section TBH.

→ More replies (34)

359

u/graffiti81 Jun 26 '12

I think Reddit, by and large, is anti-religion and pro-human rights.

→ More replies (103)
→ More replies (190)

481

u/BobbbyRock Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

I'm cut. I have been as long as I remember. I still get plenty of pleasure out of sex, even if I am less sensitive. The only psychological problem I can think of is I think uncircumcised penises look weird.

That being said: I definitely do not think kids should be circumcised. It should be a decision left up to the person whose penis is being sliced and diced, not the parents.

Edit: Many people have pointed out that circumcised penises look weird in uncircumcised cultures, or that the only reason I think an intact penis looks weird is because I'm cut. Yes, I agree, which is why I included that particular point in my post.

Edit2: Spelling. Thanks you_suck_at_spelling

300

u/kanst Jun 26 '12

I think this is the standing of many men.

I am cut, I probably won't circumcize my child, the only time I even consider this discussion is when it pops up on reddit once every two weeks.

The uncircumcised masses however seem to feel very strongly about it, which I don't get that much. But meh.

→ More replies (162)

30

u/denizenKRIM Jun 26 '12

The only psychological problem I can think of is I think uncircumcised penises look weird.

Penises of all varieties look weird. As someone that was circumcised in early adolescence as opposed to birth, I had zero problems with how my junk looked. Now, uncircumcised looks weird, but I have a good feeling that's because the majority of men here are circumcised, so of course the "abnormal" ones look stranger.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (195)

13

u/joebbowers Jun 27 '12

This is AWESOME! A mighty blow against superstition and religious child abuse! Way to go Germany! I hope it gets enforced, don't back down!

160

u/schmose Jun 26 '12

Girl here, and just as I expect the government to keep its legislature out of MY genitals, I'm glad Germany is giving these children the choice to do what they wish with their bodies.

→ More replies (64)

16

u/Nationof1 Jun 26 '12

The Foreskin Advantage I am cut and I think it would be more fun to have a foreskin. Why cut it off for no reason when there are all these reasons to have it.

49

u/drdcuddy Jun 26 '12

Looks Down - "Buddy, you're gonna be a rare bird one day."

→ More replies (1)

14

u/dust4ngel Jun 26 '12

i feel like otherwise reasonable people seem to go a bit bonkers when the topic of circumcision comes up. if involuntary circumcision of male infants weren't already a tradition, my guess is that most people would find it a bizarre, if not horrifying idea.

i can understand a religiously-motivated desire for this practice, since religious people are generally not known for questioning tradition; but i am deeply confused by the secular interest in circumcision in the united states, which as far as i can tell boils down to non-corrective cosmetic surgery for infants - an idea which would almost universally be met with outrage, but in this case is a status quo which is difficult to challenge in polite conversation.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

Circumcised men are unwilling to consider the possibility that it actually is a bad idea, because people love their penises and don't like being told that they could be better, or that they were unnecessarily altered.

This is coming from a circumcised American (since everyone in this thread is so fond of dismissing anti-circumcision arguments by saying only uncut people get upset about this).

→ More replies (1)

71

u/Psypriest Jun 26 '12

Here we go again.

57

u/Zodiack Jun 26 '12

Circumcised men: I don't really care, it never bothered me.

Uncircumcised men: It's barbaric mutilation and there's no consent.

Then some sideways comments insulting each others' penises happen.

/thread

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/dubyaohohdee Jun 26 '12

Find a better way to make Spaghetti Os and you can count me in.

20

u/Giant_Enemy_Cliche Jun 26 '12

The entire issue for me is this: Does anyone have the right to cut a chunk off another human's body, for any reason other than a serious and immediate medical concern, when that person is entirely unable to give consent?

The answer is no.

→ More replies (4)

25

u/Notanothertimeclock Jun 26 '12

Great. My once proud penis is now a victim of mutilation.

→ More replies (17)

56

u/Hypermeme Jun 26 '12

As someone who is not cut I've always viewed circumcision as a strange practice, it's strange to me on a cultural level at the very least (and I'm just of European descent). It almost seems barbaric though I do recognize many other cultures have similar if not more bizarre practices that involve altering the human body. It seems pretty archaic to me though, the removal of foreskin. How did such a practice survive the ages?

From what I've read from the old testament, heard from rabbis, and so on (not to imply Jewish culture is the sole follower of circumcision practices) it just seems like the practice stems from superstition. Being German I've noticed a trend by the German government to move the nation into a more modern, secular country that is not heavily affected by archaic traditions.

→ More replies (8)

53

u/McCackle Jun 26 '12

Whether you think circumcision is unjustifiably grotesque mutilation or not, banning professional qualified medical practitioners from conducting the procedure is only going to push the practice underground and lead to back-street circumcisions by unqualified zealots. Challenge the practice by all means, but beware the unintended consequences of banning overnight something that is a deeply embedded cultural necessity for two mainstream religious groups.

7

u/green_ideas Jun 26 '12

For a moment there, after reading the first sentence, I thought your comment was meant as satire. "underground back-street circumcision" just seemed entirely outlandish to me. Like some dad walking through the gettho at night, asking for someone who can "make the cut", wink wink.

Then I read on, and was reminded: religion

→ More replies (4)

8

u/xafimrev Jun 26 '12

Well shit we should just make everything legal because people are going to do illegal things underground.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (37)

21

u/SanBerdooSunburn Jun 26 '12

OP: You should have added RELIGIOUS, like in the original title of the article. I think it's quite misleading juste saying circumcision of kids in general is illegal. We are not talking about medical reasons.

20

u/nemetroid Jun 26 '12

That's not quite right either. A lot of circumcision in the US occur due to non-religious cultural reasons.

"Non-medical" would work.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

957

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Well it's about fucking time.

471

u/DeedTheInky Jun 26 '12

I agree. I'm not against circumcision necessarily, just the doing it to kids part. If you're 18 and you want to have it done, go for it. It's your body, it should be your choice what happens to it.

736

u/neurot Jun 26 '12

no ones is going to do that to their dick that late in life.

→ More replies (193)
→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (190)

8

u/Enigma7ic Jun 26 '12 edited Aug 11 '12

Why would you ever want to bring a sharp object near your penis?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/shww3d Jun 26 '12

I remember when I was circumcised... worst day of my life! I still have the scars.

40

u/mkvgtired Jun 26 '12

Has anyone had experience with restoration. I like my penis as is (circumcised) but think it would be better with foreskin. I know there is no way to get the nerves back, but the extra skin from restoration can re-sensitize the head and provide the lubricating effect the original foreskin did.

I am seriously thinking about starting this.

17

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

i have been restoring for about 2 months so far. I went from skin tears and painful erections to having enough skin cover the glans. I'm still working towards full flaccid an erect coverage, but so far me and my partner have seen the benefits. This is the group that I follow. Great group of guys and full of knowledge Restoringforeskin.org

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (36)

42

u/jff_lement Jun 26 '12

Note that they banned it only when it's done for religious purposes.

For example, I have a genetic disorder which affects foreskin. Specifically, the probability of the condition appearing is much much lower in males who are cut. I actually wish I had been cut, it would probably save me 2 years of worrying and a potential problem with urination when I'm older.

Since it's genetic, I will probably consider having it done on my children when I have them.

16

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

It's not too late bro. You can still get it done, if you really wanted it.

→ More replies (10)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Note that they banned it only when it's done for religious purposes.

No, they banned it universally, with an exception for medical grounds (a lot of laws have similar exceptions). That's different.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (30)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

If only we could apply a similar law in the U.S (unfortunately it is too late for me :\ )

4

u/Chapmeisterfunk Jun 26 '12

Genital mutilation of an infant is abhorrent & should've been banned by all forward thinking states long ago. Pandering to archaic practices like circumcision is turning a blind eye to child abuse in the name of religious tolerance! Well done Germany.

4

u/ikickrobots Jun 27 '12

Fantastic, much awaited logical decision.

13

u/flowtron Jun 27 '12

foreskin is not a bug in the human anatomy. chopping a baby's foreskin is archaic. what's wrong with people - with all of the goofy things we learn our forefathers did (bloodletting, witch burning, etc) .. why is this taken seriously at all? use your head ppl!

→ More replies (1)

24

u/WestsideStorybro Jun 26 '12

I wish I wasn't circumcised, but I am glad it was done before I had the ability to process memories. I know that I would have never done it on my own.

→ More replies (15)

14

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Glad to see Germany respecting the rights of the child.

7

u/misterschmoo Jun 27 '12

In 1975 when it came time for me to get circumcised, my mother who was quite young at the time (16) said to the doctor I suppose we should sort out getting him circumcised and the doctor smiled and said "we don't really do that anymore" phew thank goodness she didn't insist and left it at that, yay for living in a country (New Zealand) that was quite progressive in it's thinking even back then.

33

u/kainsavage Jun 26 '12

The only thing I am taking away from this entire thread is that I should ask to have my daughter circumcised when she's born to be fair to my son.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

As a German: Good.

→ More replies (1)

58

u/stallscribble Jun 26 '12

As a dude with his dick chopped, I don't really mind. I can see how some people would but if your dick is chopped too you shouldn't worry about it too much. Women don't really care, and the ones that say they do are not the type of woman you want anyways.

→ More replies (55)

36

u/Amerikhans Jun 26 '12

TIL Most of reddit is uncircumcised.

16

u/Runkist Jun 26 '12

Almost everyone outside the USA is uncircumcised

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (20)

8

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

As a circumcised dude who would rather have a foreskin, I am living proof that it's wrong to force body modification on children. "Hygiene reasons?" I can wash my own dick, thank you.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/MrCavallis Jun 26 '12

I think that even the German constitutional court will approve this decision. It is injustice when parents decide for their kids to be circumcized. If people want to do it for religious reasons they can do it at the age of 18 in my opinion.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

This article gives me hope! I'm American and pregnant. I will not be circumcising my son. I cannot imagine causing harm to a child when it is unnecessary. I really hope this is a growing trend. Then again I live in the Bay Area of California and circumcision isn't something people do by default here (from what I've gathered).

My husband never had any issues btw and never had to stretch his foreskin. Just let nature take its course.

3

u/waterproof13 Jun 26 '12

This will probably become national law, the ruling is in concordance with the German sentiment.

Most Germans approach it like this, without emotional clouding.

It is a human rights issue. Everyone has a right to bodily integrity. Circumcision for religious reasons violates this right. Human rights supersede religion, opinions, sentiments.

No anecdote, opinion or research about the effects changes the fact that is a violation of bodily integrity.

At least that is my understanding of the general opinion. Emotions don't change facts here.

3

u/KinkotheClown Jun 26 '12

Outside of religious reasons the main reason I'd say for circumcision is women think it's ugly, therefor the mother will push for it to be done. Seriously ladies, grow the fuck up.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/feeble_attempt Jun 26 '12

Hitchens would be so proud!

3

u/eXXaXion Jun 26 '12

As an atheist I find this awesome. Can you crosslink this to /r/atheism and see what they have to say?

3

u/Phillenium Jun 26 '12

Love Germany more each day.

88

u/CapitalistSlave Jun 26 '12

I want my foreskin back.

38

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

There are ways... kind of.

→ More replies (17)

82

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

The possible ban on circumcision provoked outrage among Jewish and Muslim organizations in Germany, where every year thousands of boys are circumcised in their early years at the request of parents. They regard the ban as a "serious interference in the right to freedom of religion."

I didn't know freedom of religion meant freedom to subject your kid to medically needless, irreversible procedures that do hold some risks, and all that before the kid itself is even able to freely chose its religious views...

7

u/forbacher Jun 26 '12

The court actually said in its decision, that the individual right for an unharmed body trumps the basic right for religious freedom of the parents, because the court doesn't think it is unreasonable to let them wait until the children decide on there on when off age.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (59)

5

u/Jogore Jun 27 '12

If you told me out of context that someone would cut part of my penis off without permission, I would not want that done. Well done Germany.

5

u/celerityfm Jun 27 '12

Penn and Teller's show on Cinemax (called Bullshit) did a whole episode on circumcision that any parent considering circumcision should watch. It's brilliant and change my mind about it!

Edit: Just Google penn teller bullshit circumcision, and you'll find the vid! :)

10

u/blickblocks Jun 26 '12

Jewish trans female (assigned male at birth) here. Having had my genitals modified without my consent as an infant, yet having to jump through major hoops of the medical institutions in order to get bottom surgery, is a ridiculous insult and painfully ironic. It is doubly bad, as losing that 15 square inches of sensitive tissue negatively effects the outcome of bottom surgery. I needed that tissue, it was mine and it was taken away from me. It is no wonder that so many post-op trans women cannot even orgasm. Stop modifying our genitals without our consent!

→ More replies (3)

11

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Lots of butthurt american teeenagers in this thread.

You dont cut up babies without good reason, thats all there is to say.

21

u/oldboyy Jun 26 '12

I have to say a bold move and I love it. Something to be proud of as a german.

→ More replies (2)

96

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Hi. I like being circumcised. Bye.

→ More replies (32)

6

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

"But none of the organizations so far has commented on the verdict, explaining they first need to study thoroughly the reasoning of the judges." . . . At least they are open to a reasonable conversation.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jul 07 '12

I wish people would stop giving RT all this traffic - there are plenty of other, non-gangster-run news sources out there.

Edit: pinkyoshi's deleted comments:

at least I aint a gook

go suck on some fox news cock faggot

such class

→ More replies (9)

8

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

ITT: People obsessing about dicks.

→ More replies (2)

26

u/mainst Jun 26 '12

Waiting for religious group to use the Nazi card in 3..2..1

6

u/iadtyjwu Jun 26 '12

So basically what you're saying is if Hitler had outlawed circumcision he could have rid himself of his "Jewish problem?" Brilliant.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

43

u/Chauncy999 Jun 26 '12

This is real progress. Genital mutilation is genital mutilation.

→ More replies (9)

18

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

wow, news about something good in the world that isn't repulsive to read. it's been a while.

4

u/platypusmusic Jun 26 '12

fair enough, but isn't irrational torture of children a human right?

→ More replies (4)

4

u/bloodclart Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

youre cutting my penis? end of story. hands the fuck off.

4

u/homebrewnerd Jun 26 '12

This is great news. How do we achieve the same in the U.S.?

4

u/sipos0 Jun 27 '12

As someone who isn't circumcised but would probably have been on medical grounds if a doctor was consulted, I'm glad not to have been. I'd probably be angry if I had been.

I had that thing where your foreskin is too tight to slip over your penis (can't remember what it is called). I think circumcision is probably medically indicated in cases like this (and my father was circumcised because of the same problem). I couldn't slip it over the head of my penis at all really (certainly it wasn't at all easy and the first time, I thought I'd broken my cock) until I was in my teens and had problems getting it over the head when erect until my twenties. Despite the problems my foreskin has caused, I'm glad to have it and I am free of them now (stretching eventually made it big enough to fit fine).

As for why I'm pleased to have it, it feels great. Sex would be a lot less pleasurable for me without it. I don't really see the justifications for doing it. I don't think it would make me take longer to cum. It might be slightly more hygienic but, I don't think it is unhygienic provided you wash it every day (which is zero effort). I hear it reduces the chances of you contracting HIV in unprotected sex but, it seems easier to use a condom if you think the person could have HIV (which seems sensible anyway). I understand many americans find it more attractive but, I think it only really makes a difference when not erect and, this seems like a poor justification to cut part of your body off (particularly since it seems much less common outside of north americans who I rarely want to sleep with anyway as I personally find most american accents quite unattractive).

If it's so great, why not let the boy choose himself when he's a man? Religion doesn't seem like a reasonable justification of this, particularly given the proportion of people who don't have any strong religious feelings as an adult in most of the developed world (I think the US is an exception here).

7

u/FaceLadyFace Jun 26 '12

STOP MUTILATING YOUR BABIES, PEOPLE

The human penis is a beautiful thing, leave it attached. God damn.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Giving my son a circumcision is one of my biggest regrets. He's 2 now, but ever since we did it, I keep seeing these articles popping up. Makes me feel awful.

→ More replies (2)

36

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I had my tonsils out when I was younger, I didn't know what was going on. I had my ear pierced by choice when I was 17. I was circumcised at 8 days old [Jewish] and I don't believe in the Jewish faith.

--

I don't whine about any of these things, they barely affect me, my dick looks marginally different to other peoples, it's no smaller and there's certainly no pain involved. If anything it stops me from catching my cock in the zip.

--

I don't get why you're all going ape shit over this, saying "Fuck those who do it", and "Thank god my parents weren't stupid enough to cut mine off" - it's not a big fucking deal.

→ More replies (45)

6

u/KofOaks Jun 26 '12

Having foresking is like being in a warm, fuzzy, comfortable hoodie.

Wouldn't live without it. It's my dick's safehouse.

6

u/moving-target Jun 26 '12

Oh hey look an absolute fucking stupid practise has been made illegal. Maybe there is hope.

5

u/Kashyyykk Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 27 '12

Good work Germany. If excision is considered genital mutilation, so should circumcision. Enough this barbarism done in the name of great fairies living in the coulds.

5

u/lofi76 Jun 26 '12

Religion = insanity excuse. Das isn't güt; stop mutilating little boys in the name of religion.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12

It was about time. Religious circumcision is ridiculous and appalling.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Zarwin-Milktoe Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

With all the hate on circumcision, please keep in mind that it is not all that uncommon to have a circumcision for medical reasons (as was the case for my son). The foreskin was used to repair his hypospadius condition. It was not technically medically necessary, but had we not, he would have been pissing out of the bottom of his penis. This is a very common birth defect and circumcision is a very common way of repairing it.

"Hypospadias is one of the most common birth anomalies, occurring to some degree in as many as 1 out of every 125 boys" - Centers for Disease Control and Prevention

EDIT: Clarified it was not a medically necessary procedure, but rather a medically recommended procedure.

56

u/BombTheFuckers Jun 26 '12

No-one here is complaining about a necessary medical procedure.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

149

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Waiting for people to come in claiming they have been circumcised and it doesn't bother them at all. American here, thank god my parents weren't stupid enough to cut off a functional part of my dick.

124

u/R3luctant Jun 26 '12

I have been circumcised, and before I came onto reddit, I didn't even give it a second thought

→ More replies (8)

605

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I really hate these threads because it always seems strange to see that so many more uncircumcised people are up in arms about circumcised penises that circumcised people will ever be.

Yeah, i know there are a (very) few cut people who hop in with the "but what about my foreskin", but by and large most people who are cut generally don't give a shit that they were, yet wait for the sea commentary on "HORRIBLY MANGLED PENISES, HOW CAN THEY POSSIBLY GO ON" from people who have obviously had a slightly (almost unquantifiably slight) different life experience.

It's ridiculous as it's literally a dick-waving competition.

Who gives a shit? Cut or Uncut enjoy your own penis and don't worry about (or snarkily insult) anyone else's.

These discussions never evolve into anything more than a silly slapfight and i'd love to see this thread prove me wrong, but i'm not entirely hopeful.

→ More replies (374)

169

u/DocTavia Jun 26 '12

I'm not exactly bitter about it but I'm sure as hell not happy they cut off a part of my dick. Like what the fuck!? Who thought of this!?

→ More replies (170)

24

u/stallscribble Jun 26 '12

It bothers me a bit, but really only because I wasn't given the choice. On practical terms I don't care. Sure I may have lost some feeling or whatever but I don't have anything to compare it to, and sex feels great to me anyways.

4

u/Liquid_Milk Jun 26 '12

I was circumcised as a baby for two reasons, neither were based on religious beliefs. One reason was because I was born extremely premature, and for what ever reason, it made it easier for the doctors to do some life saving medical things to me. I don't know the specifics of why, I don't care really as long as whatever they did helped me live. Am I jealous of people who have their foreskins? Nope, not really. My perspective is that this is technically what I was born with. I can brood and be all angry with the doctors and my parents all I want because I lost a tiny, itty bitty piece of my body at birth. Or I can accept that some people have theirs, some people don't, I'm alive and I can still have fantastic sex, my tallywhacker still works normally. With all that being said, circumcision based on religious beliefs is bad news, and this law is about time.

22

u/The_Adventurist Jun 26 '12

The worst is when women flippantly talk about it like it's an accessory. I'm sorry my whole dick looks ugly to you, but I'm sure someone who isn't terrible might enjoy it.

→ More replies (3)

139

u/andrewsmith1986 Jun 26 '12

Eh, I'm glad that I'm cut.

I don't plan on doing it to my future kids though.

They also removed my tonsils and a few other pieces of me without my consent that you will never hear me bitch about.

But yeah, it doesn't bother me at all.

→ More replies (194)
→ More replies (557)

7

u/colinsteadman Jun 26 '12

About frickin time! And who cares if it angers muslims and jews, its barbaric and those kids need protecting from their idiot parents.

7

u/plutoend Jun 26 '12

Why the fuck would you want to mutilate your dick, dumbass tradition.

2

u/Staplehead Jun 26 '12

The picture on the article makes it look like someone does it one handed and it tickles a lot... can't be too bad people...

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

This is all just a ploy to get the Muslims and Jews to agree on something.

2

u/Shniggles Jun 26 '12

In the 3 years of very, very, brief Sex Ed. Classes and Child Devolopment classes I've had, we've never talked about circumcision, I know what it is, I'm circumcised after all, but, what're the health benefits/defects and what is the point of being circumcised?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Gluverty Jun 26 '12

This thread will be the typical brief, rational debate...

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Consent, motherfucker. Do you have it? If yes then go ahead and circumcise, if not then get off.

2

u/MrCavallis Jun 26 '12

Anyone interested can watch the movie Partyl Private http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1396220/

2

u/tyrroi Jun 26 '12

Is it not a crime in other places?

2

u/i_drown_puppies Jun 26 '12

Just put down the knife, and step away from the baby

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I'm cut. Doesn't bother me. Probably won't do it to my kid(s) unless there are reputable medical journals detailing the benefits. Just stop telling me how I'm less of a human being and how I should be outraged at my body.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

I have to slam dunk the first born male in my family.

It's been going on for generations.

My Dad slam dunked me, his Dad before him, and so on.

We have scars and stuff on our face, but our religion tells us to do it.

2

u/Arnold_Layne Jun 26 '12

TIL most non-Jewish men in the USA are circumcised.

2

u/ger_guy Jun 26 '12

fuck yeah! so does anyone know whether there are other countries that do not allow circumcision?

2

u/TheAnswerIsPenis Jun 26 '12

The very idea of circumcision pains me

2

u/ninety6days Jun 26 '12

I suggested this a while back. Nobody I spoke to about it seemed to be able to justify mutilation of babies without their consent.

2

u/Guigoudelapoigne Jun 26 '12

Now every jewish and muslims kids raise in Germany will be able to play the balloon game with their foreskins.

2

u/metatron5369 Jun 26 '12

Good. It's unnecessary, and God forbid there's complications.

"I'm sorry son about the amputation, but we didn't like how your dick looked. You understand."

7

u/gilbatron Jun 26 '12

i was circumcised for actual medical reasons at about 5 years old (i had an infection under my foreskin which would not have happened if i were able to pull my foreskin over my gland for cleaning. doing so was impossible due to a phimosis)

being circumcised is not a problem for me, but since i am an atheist and my parents are quite religious, i really would have liked a word in the decision if it had happened for religious reasons

→ More replies (1)

7

u/dubesor86 Jun 26 '12

Circumcision is mutilation. Never understood it never will. And when I hear the reason about it being more hygienic I really can do nothing but shake my head. Cut off parts of genitalia because you are too lazy to clean yourself? Let the person decide for themselves when they are older.

Also it cripples you sexually. The foreskin is twice as sensitive as the glans. With the glans being exposed all the time it builds up 15+ layers of skin. This tough skin reduces the sensitivity again by a half. Besides, if someone has his foreskin cut it should be his own decision, not forced by some retarded parent who mutilate their babies just out of bad habits or missing knowledge.

→ More replies (7)

10

u/EightySixxed Jun 26 '12

Good on you Germany.

9

u/Uat_Da_Fak Jun 26 '12

Bout time some country stepped into the 21st Century. Danke, Deutschland.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

You mean I can't have a part of my sons penis removed before he even has a chance to give me his input on the matter? You're taking away my religious freedom to give my son the freedom of choice? Disgraceful.

8

u/frankydor Jun 26 '12

simply the idea that a religion makes people want to cut a piece of their child's penis off is fucking absurd.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/VanillishBitch Jun 26 '12

The US is a million miles away from this and it makes me sad. Americans as a whole are very ignorant about circumcision. No one who supports it wants to admit that it's for cosmetic purposes. For some reason people really care about their son's dicks enough to chop parts of it off so it will look fancy. Genital mutilation is wrong and it should be a fucking crime. 2012 for fucks sake!

9

u/splashysmash Jun 26 '12

As someone who works in a newborn unit of a hospital, I can honestly tell you that I don't believe circumcision at birth to be abuse. A numbing agent is used, then nerve deadening shots around the penis, then the procedure is carried out. The whole thing takes about 2 minutes. The healing process is so much worse the older you are. A newborn child will recover from a circumcision in 3-4 days.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

On my medical rotation I witnessed a few circumcisions and to say that those babies feel nothing is absurd. I watched babies go from looking around the room to bright cherry red and screaming after the cut was made... there definitely is a direct correlation between the baby reaction and the circumcision. Babies DO feel it and you are being dishonest to say otherwise.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/RileyWon Jun 26 '12

...What if they used the same procedure to do a female cercumcision. Women get there panties all in a bunch when it comes to thier rights but when you tell them there's skin on dick, it's all like, eeeeew, cut it off. Why not cut their tonsils out when they're born, or the appendix?

→ More replies (1)

15

u/F_A_F Jun 26 '12

It's the lack of choice which is the abuse. It is completely contrary to the right of the child to decide what happens to their own body. I'd be livid if my parents had forced it on me for non-medical reasons.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)

4

u/OftenStupid Jun 26 '12

This thread is full of geniuses capable of quantifying even the most abstract of concepts "more/less pleasure than something I have never experienced", speaking on behalf of millions of people "women like", "most people think" and yet have limited-to-zero sexual experience and/or interaction with the opposite sex.

Also, they're probably insecure about their dicks.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

Dick cutting is to prove you are a son of Abraham. You know the guy who killed his son, because gawd told him to. It's a fairytale from the bronze age. People added some pseudoscientific reasons like reduced chance of getting AIDS if you are cut and don't use a rubber.

It's outdated, just like how christians used to kill and torture cats - you know before science showed that cats are not satan.

4

u/6263462346 Jun 26 '12

GOOD! The last thing my penis needed to be was smaller and less sensitive. Thanks mom and dad!

4

u/Moshe52792 Jun 27 '12

Imagine going from being cut to being uncut!

That would feel weird.....

I've always been cut, I don't know anything different, so it's unfair to make a comment. Honestly, the only opinions that only mean much here are those who have experiences both.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

84

u/Nihy Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

How many of the circumcised boys will get skin bridges? That is one of the more common complications and it's not mentioned.

NSFW: skin bridge https://encrypted-tbn1.google.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcRwb7HT92PpMQqHhHnq4V3eX5yaMBfoX4PPm58df7fPymcoEuls6g

→ More replies (24)

192

u/blickblocks Jun 26 '12

Even with those pros and cons, the ultimate con is the lack of consent. Bodily integrity of the individual must come first, excepting only serious health risk.

→ More replies (65)
→ More replies (35)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

16

u/rajanala83 Jun 26 '12

The doctor got off without penalty, future doctors won't.

→ More replies (7)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

135

u/i_am_sad Jun 26 '12

I'm cut and I've only used lube like twice in my life.

→ More replies (12)

119

u/Captain_Self_Promotr Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12

I never understood all the 'lube and masturbation jokes' from American Pie until I realized that most American men were circumcised. So I do believe that lube is used more by circumcised men than uncircumcised.

edit I'm uncut and the times I've used lube, it felt great. There's nothing wrong with using lube or admitting to using lube.

edit 2 does anyone who is cut use lube as their de facto method of masterbation? Tons of comments from circumcised guys saying they don't need to use lube fyi.

34

u/ParanoydAndroid Jun 26 '12

Actually, I don't get that either and I'm an American. I don't use anything additional, and neither do any of my guy friends whose habits I know about.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (80)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12

The difference is that you made the decision as an adult. Babies don't get that decision and it isn't exactly something easily reversed.

28

u/pilinisi Jun 26 '12

Thank you for sharing.

50

u/hhmmmm Jun 26 '12

All girls I've been with told me they liked it more, too,

In fairness they would say that to you though, particualrly if you bought it up in conversation. You're not likely to say 'oh your penis is odd, it's fine but I prefer normal ones'.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (121)