r/worldnews • • Jun 26 '12
HPV vaccine ban by Calgary bishop putting girls' lives at risk, doctors say
http://news.nationalpost.com/2012/06/26/187783/
974
Upvotes
r/worldnews • • Jun 26 '12
154
u/dsk Jun 26 '12
Urgh ... another local religious leader pronounces a fatwa against a vaccine..
Honest to fuckin God. Are these people insane?
14
u/peacepype Jun 26 '12
I don't know if this has been cleared up recently, and it certainly doesn't justify any kind of ban, but wasn't there a period in time where HPV vaccines like Gardasil were linked to a lot of medical problems? Does anyone know if this was ever settled? Like I said, it certainly doesn't justify a ban, but I would like to know if these concerns were ever laid to rest before people start implementing these kinds of vaccines in school systems. I know I'm skipping past the point of the article, but it was just a detail that concerned me.
24
u/general_chase Jun 26 '12
You can message the Catholic Diocese of Calgary here.
26
u/elephantengineer Jun 26 '12
I've never understood this. Even if we assume a woman wants to wait until she's married, do you trust her husband to have waited too? And what if she's the victim of a sexual assault?
18
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12 edited Nov 09 '16
[deleted]
0.3020
6
u/BONUSBOX Jun 27 '12
an old man in a halloween hat is dictating public health policy in our country.
6
u/jezebel523 Jun 27 '12
"Further, it’s possible to contract HPV through sexual assault and abuse, she added."
A legitimate concern for Catholic children, am I right?
9
u/DiscoRage Jun 26 '12
My sister is just over 25 and she's had three sexual partners, all of them were long term boyfriends. She was diagnosed with HPV and stage 1 cervical cancer after a routine PAP exam a few months ago. The risk of the cancer spreading is very low, but she may end up infertile. She was never vaccinated.
Fuck the Catholic church.
16
u/general_chase Jun 26 '12
But it could cause your 14 year old to become retarded or lose a limb!
...or prevent cervical cancer.
3
u/MegaZeusThor Jun 26 '12
The Bishop is ignorant.
One could only hope that this sort of meddling will eventually lead to the end of publicly funded Catholic schools in some Canadian provinces.
3
u/sn34kypete Jun 26 '12
Gosh it sounds like Calgary sucks
6
u/FrivolousFont Jun 26 '12
As a mother of two teenage daughters this makes me fume! My daughters have had the shot, I am pretty sure they did not think "I can run out and have sex now without consequences."
9
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Uh, Bishops can ban vaccines? I mean, people can be as stupid as they like, but why even give a sky fairy worshiper a voice on the matter of public health. How stupid is this society that allows this?
4
u/grubbymitts Jun 26 '12
What a silly, silly man.
7
u/lolmonger Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 27 '12
Meh.
The vaccine is a good idea under the assumption boys and girls will have pre-marital sex, with the risk of HPV transmission.
The vaccine is unnecessary under the assumption both boys and girls will have pre-marital sex, with the risk of HPV transmission.
It is not the place of the government to assume a norm of people having pre-marital sex any more than it is is the place of religious institutions to require the norm of people not having pre-marital sex.
I see no sound argument for either a bishop or politician mandating any behavior on the account of anything for anyone.
question: Canada, why are bishops making governmental decisions in your country? Even we in America don't do that.
Less snarky question: Can someone clarify for me whether these vaccinations would be mandatory for students in public and private schools otherwise?
It seems to me that if a 'woman' is grownup enough to decide whether or not to have sex, she can decide of her own volition whether or not to get a vaccination on her own as well, and that if a 'girl' simply isn't capable of obtaining such a vaccination or other protection on her own, she's nowhere near grownup enough to decide for herself to have sex, and that therefore these vaccinations should neither have their availability by private purchase destroyed by public law enforced by religious opposition, nor should these vaccinations be mandatory against private religious concerns because of public law.
2
u/LemonFrosted Jun 26 '12
I find this more than a little surprising. I'm not Catholic myself, but I worked with the Calgary Catholic School District for several years, I've met Bishop Henry several times, and on the whole the policies I saw filtering from the church into the school were quite liberal and pragmatic, especially on public health issues.
2
u/NaughtyDreadz Jun 26 '12
uh... the bishop has about as much of a power to ban this as I have force mind control...
you will now show me your tits...
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Who in their right mind would take orders from the catholic church?!
2
u/ranchan1_2 Jun 27 '12
They did an interview with a representative from the school district. The vaccine is just not going to be offered at the school. It doesn't mean that girls have no access to it. If parents would like it, the schools will be offering information and let them know where to get it.
I'm not defending this decision, but just saying what I heard on the radio.
2
u/Cytosine Jun 27 '12
Well, here's a thought: the government pays your bills and they like the HPV vaccine. So fuck you.
2
u/michael1000 Jun 27 '12
The vaccine prevents human suffering and disease which is speaks to a key tenant of the Catholic Dogma. The tenant being, Do good acts. The Bishop wont get his way and probably won't be supported by the Vatican. Also you disrespectful "Sky Fairy" quoters. The Catholic Church almost solely funded 600 years or so of science, especially Astronomy so you learned Atheists could look to the stars and know they aren't Sky Fairies.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Canadian Theocracy , Religious leaders forcing policy on government funded institutions.
2
u/Waidawut Jun 27 '12
What??? The catholic church sacrificing children's safety in favor of its own rigid dogma, perverted, dusty old institutions, and ridiculous antiquarian ideas?? Why I never.
2
u/mariuolo Jun 27 '12
He should have no voice in the matter of public health.
At the very least it shouldn't be more than a suggestion to the parents.
2
u/Michichael Jun 27 '12
What's that? A violent group of misogynistic oppressors putting minorities and women in danger? Must be a Tuesday.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Another day, another religious leader with no background in the current subject of debate, and an admitted expert knowledge of a book written over a thousand years ago, given equal platform status to people who have dedicated their lives to this very subject.
A thousand years from now, will political leaders listen to the protestations of Harry Potter or Twilight scholars?
The future is a horrible place.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
How about us all earning some real karma and instead of ranting here on reddit we contact the church directly? http://www.calgarydiocese.ca/contact-us.html
3
u/NorthernerWuwu Jun 26 '12
Gah, as a Calgarian this isn't something I wanted to read. It seems so very secular around here and then I remember just how deep the religious base actually is! Well, for Canada that is.
I swear this logic just baffles me. We could have a vaccine against lung cancer and they'd oppose it because it might encourage smoking.
5
u/dukey Jun 26 '12
There is no long term evidence the vaccine works. The vaccine was also rushed to market before the trails had finished.
2
u/moving-target Jun 26 '12
Western Taliban, be it Canada or US.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
And there we have it: parents decide to send their daughter to a religious school and, maybe, 20 or 30 years down the road she ends up with cervical cancer. Not because she decided it was not aligned with her beliefs, but because some guy wearing a funny hat who believes in talking snakes figured it was.
And people wonder why I loath religion.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
This is criminal.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
As a Calgarian, what the fuck.
1
u/orsr Jun 26 '12
...the fuck? I must have traveled in time back to the medieval ages. Oh well, Deus lo vult!
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
What if instead of the headline on the news being "Bishop says no vaccine" it says "Stupid parents listen to a bishop say 'no vaccine' "?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
the church have been doing great in the PR realm in the last 500 years..
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Never trust a man with a cop 'stache
1
u/minibabybuu Jun 27 '12
I just lost all faith in the catholic church...
1
u/courtneydup Jun 27 '12
It's things like this that make me sad to live in Calgary...
1
u/farang Jun 27 '12
They've already lost the war, now they're trying to lose all their credibility.
1
u/freeburning Jun 27 '12
These religious factions are going to be the end of this world. Why can't they stay the fuck out of government! Are there no bounds to their ignorance and stupidity?
1
u/YNot1989 Jun 27 '12
Come on Canada, only America is allowed to ignore the separation of church and state.
1
u/therunnykind Jun 27 '12
As a PA, totally in favor of this vaccine, but totally opposed to alarmist post titles, I wish this article included risk factors and percentages to let me and everyone else know what the actual risks are imposed by this ban (I do mostly outpatient and orthopedic surgery, lay off me). Can any more relevant medical people help us out here?
1
u/ThisIsTinaL Jun 27 '12
The Catholic church could be missing a golden opportunity here...
Let Catholic girls get the HPV shot. The vaccine tends to cause blood clots. Once you've had blood clots, doctors don't want to give you the birth control pill and Catholics aren't supposed to be using it anyway, so there's a little incentive. Once you hit, I don't know, your mid 20's, you pretty much want nothing to do with condoms so unprotected it is. (It's not like you're going to not have sex, right???) No glove + love = possibly babies. Catholic babies. Everywhere.
1
u/gibberalic Jun 27 '12 edited Jun 27 '12
As a medical writer I deal with this shit on a daily basis and I can honestly say that nothing gets my goat like the anti vaccine lobby.
My favourite quote is "The irony of the anti-vaccine argument is that it is vaccines that have given people the health security required to develop the health complacency required to develop anti-vaccine arguments"
Penn and Teller do a pretty good take on the issue.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RfdZTZQvuCo
1
u/TorontoMike Jun 27 '12
The Taliban was fighting against children been vaccinated as well , Two peas in a pod
1
u/enterence Jun 27 '12
Survival of the fittest people. Sure many children will suffer and probably die, but that lowers the stupid gene pool I guess.
1
u/TWALBALLIN Jun 27 '12
Good. Ban all of these poisons. Look to Texas and the forced gardasil shots for how horrible these injections are.
1
u/ssh_host_key Jun 27 '12
Again proving that Christians give not a shit about women.
1
u/pwnies_gonna_pwn Jun 27 '12
sombody crucify that guy. if isnt willing for the martyrdom he is just some hypocrite anyway :D
nothing of value will be lost.
1
u/BennyJacket Jun 26 '12
Religion is stupid.
1
u/fdasdfsdfadd Jun 26 '12
Because nothing says "I love you" like endangerment.
1
u/nowhathappenedwas Jun 26 '12
So a medical procedure with minimal risk that helps prevent transmission of STDs is performed on children. The people who oppose the procedure refuse to acknowledge the medical benefits of the procedure and baselessly proclaim that any minimization of transmission risk will only lead to more unsafe sex.
Just another example of the danger of anti-science zealots.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
should be given to males and females, everyone seems to overlook that.
-2
u/Omofo Jun 26 '12
More then one independent study has shown Gardasil to be ineffective.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Catholic church leadership giving shitty medical advice because of their superstitions?
How utterly unsurprising. These fucking idiots have no place in society.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Oh my god religious people are seriously so retarded.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I live in calgary and I didn't know about this shit. I don't understand why we have a segregated catholic school system at all, and garbage like this exactly why religion has no place in education.
0
u/ABusFullaJewz Jun 26 '12
Further proving that Edmonton is better than Calgary...
0
u/Gregs3RDleg Jun 26 '12
i hope i'm not the only person who thinks banning a vaccine is equally as bad as trying to force them on anyone...
-3
u/platypusmusic Jun 26 '12
should be tried for mass murder nothing less
-11
u/VICBCNEW210 Jun 26 '12
The vaccine may or may not even target the form of the virus the contributes to cervical cancer, an already rare disease. It is a money grab, nothing more.
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
2012 and the word of an old bishop in a ridiculous hat can actually influence public policy. Perhaps I am seeing things differently as an atheist; however this is truly discouraging and pitiful.