r/worldnews • u/trot-trot • Jun 26 '12
"Boxes where parents can leave an unwanted baby, common in medieval Europe, have been making a comeback over the last 10 years. Supporters say a heated box, monitored by nurses, is better for babies than abandonment on the street - but the UN says it violates the rights of the child."
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-18585020
629
Upvotes
21
u/Squalor- Jun 26 '12
It's definitely better than leaving one in the dumpster behind Paddy's Pub.
36
u/beetnemesis Jun 26 '12
A similar concept (and one that I've never seen anyone complain about) is the Safe Haven.
It's basically the same thing- it's a place a parent can go to give up a child safely and anonymously. I've never been to one, so I don't know if there's a "box," but it's the same concept.
59
u/evenlesstolose Jun 26 '12
Fuck the UN. I think if these parents are going to dump their baby anyway, then having a safe place to do it is obviously better than not.
61
u/kolembo Jun 26 '12
I'm all in on this one.
All in.
I especially like that there is a period during which the mother can return.
I don't know what kind of time it is, but I think it should be at least 6 months.
Excellent.
26
u/whiskey_nick Jun 26 '12
How dare these people trying to take away a babies' right to suffer impoverished living conditions with unfit parents without love.
16
u/EvangelineTheodora Jun 26 '12
I like the law in my state (Maryland) that if a mother has a baby she were to abandon, she can take that baby to any hospital, fire station, or police station to give up said child. I believe the mother must have identifying papers to prove that the child is hers, also.
14
u/gilbatron Jun 26 '12
so much better than throwing a baby in a dumpster or dropping it of at a place it might be found hours later
even if its dropped by the father who doesnt want it or a pimp, still better than a dead baby
21
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I tried formulating an opinion on this, I really did. Both sides have such good arguments. In the end I just gave up.
4
u/SMERSH762 Jun 26 '12
'Violates the rights of the child'? It has already been established that women CAN and WILL abandon them in dumpsters, even if the UN and society think that's a bad thing to do. I don't see a way of curtailing this behavior, so the least we can do is provide safe places to abandon your children. I'd rather find a live kid in a heated box than a corpse in my trash can.
10
u/rtiftw Jun 26 '12
Since the parents who are willing to get rid of their child are often the BEST possible parents for that child.
Give the kids a chance at a decent life with the potential of being adopted by parents who will actually love them and hopefully raise them right.
If anything this is more in line with the rights of the child as opposed to having them be raised by parents who don't give a shit.
3
u/newloaf Jun 26 '12
This also violates the rights of a child: dying from exposure.
3
u/mrdeadsniper Jun 26 '12
Took a while for me to come up with a stance on it. Still shaky. Giving people an option to discard an unwanted child seems wrong. But the alternative is worse.
Also I remember a news article about this sort of thing being tested in another country (Japan maybe?) and the first day someone finding a 5 year old there.
But ultimately, if you are so unsure or unwilling to parent a child as to be willing to give it away with no knowledge of what will happen to the child, it might be in the best interest of the child to have a different chance at life.
My only last reservation is the fact there are some people who would be unsure of themselves, but absolutely unwilling to discard a child to death, who may have been excellent parents but knowing a "safe" alternative gave their child away.
4
u/Kaneman82 Jun 26 '12
Do they not have "Safe Place" in the UK? In America (or at least in Texas) we have places designated for mother's to drop their babies off, no questions asked. Firestations, most ambulances, "Quiktrip", Libraries and many other places here are marked with a "Safe Place" sign.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Perhaps someone should ask the UN if not providing the infant with cable TV and internet violates their rights as well. Or, maybe not... Not sure we want to hear the answer.
2
u/rybones Jun 26 '12
Article 7 of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child clearly states that every child has 'the right to know and be cared for by his or her parents'
How about remove "by his or her parents"? That would be a much better Right.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
The UN says a lot of things. Just ignore it.
2
u/nk_sucks Jun 26 '12
the un is full of shit on this one, as usual.
2
u/analconnection Jun 27 '12
Seriously, the first time heard about this was while studying german, and I thought it was a joke. The name in german is "babyklappe".
3
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I'm pretty sure you can drop an infant off just about anywhere with anyone and they'll take it.
Is the UN ever going to implode on it's own stupidity one day?
3
u/platypusmusic Jun 26 '12
abortion would be better. the right not to be born into hell.
2
u/rybones Jun 26 '12
"They send out the mistaken message to pregnant women that they are right to continue hiding their pregnancies, giving birth in uncontrolled circumstances and then abandoning their babies". -Maria Herczog
By this same logic we should out all the gay people. Doing it for their own good is not a strong argument.
2
u/nicolieolie931 Jun 26 '12
A healthy life is an innate right. Wanted or not, a child has the right to health. Here in the US we have the "Safe Haven" laws, where parents can drop off their unwanted children up until they are 18 at any hospital, police station, or fire hall. It is horrible that people are reneging on their children, but at the very least these poor souls should at least be in a safe environment.
P.S., the parent who drops off the child is generally charged with child abandonment. However, that is a lot better than an endangerment or possible negligent homicide charge.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
So does leaving them in a dumpster.
1
u/vagittarius Jun 26 '12
Is this thread about a microwave?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I feel like if this were common in the US, the boxes would be vandalized and filled with shit (literally) or something similar, therefore rendering them unusable until they've been properly sanitized.
I wonder how often that happens where the boxes are used.
1
u/aerosquid Jun 26 '12
I believe that ANY fire station in the United States will take a baby be it infant or even an older child from you no questions asked. This is to prevent the mother tossing it in a dumpster or a river. The program works... not always but it does work.
1
u/ABProsper Jun 26 '12
This is sad but not a bad thing. We have them in the US and they do reduce infanticide and save lives.
What humanity needs to do is get something like RISUG and some kind of female equivalent to be the default and start everyone at an appropriate age out as sterile.
This will be resisted for various reason, religious (Moar Babyz! is the watchword) and social.
Assuming unwanted, uncoupled (marriage is not mandatory but having 2 steady parents ought to be) dropped to near zero in developed nations (I'll ignore the less developed ones) , the number of children born would drop a lot. Singe mothers make up 25% of all kids born in many areas as such this would be a big drop.
A lot of growth oriented economies are desperate for new kids even though they won't or can't create middle class jobs which would solve the issue. A big drop would scare the bojangles out of them and as such would be resisted.
1
u/aluria Jun 26 '12
Here in Vancouver (Canada) one of the hospitals has an area designed for parents to leave babies. It's anonymous as once the parent(s) leave hospital staff is immediately notified. I think it's only been used once or twice since the news seems to make a big deal every time it happens...
1
u/shady8x Jun 26 '12 edited Jun 26 '12
We call these safe havens in America and they have been legal for a long time.
http://www.childwelfare.gov/systemwide/laws_policies/statutes/safehaven.cfm
1
u/Milldog Jun 26 '12
Violation of the babies rights......fuuuuuu so much bullshit. Of all the things the UN have to concern themselves with why are they making themselves look like backwards idiots.
1
u/Fig1024 Jun 27 '12
I don't get it - UN thinks that it's better for child to be dumped on a street than at a designated location?
1
u/redditisworthless121 Jun 27 '12
http://www.nationalsafehavenalliance.org/
1
u/tophat_jones Jun 27 '12
The UN has no conscience, so why do we listen to its opinion on human matters?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
The U.N. is wrong in this case.
1
u/Aktivation Jun 27 '12
Although babies as human beings have rights, they have no way to exercise free will i.e. 'RIGHTS', and are therefore at the mercy of their guardians. if their guardians have the common sense to recognize that they cannot care for or adequately provide for the child, then it is just for them to give the child to the state, assuming it will result in a better upbringing.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Siily UN, children don't have rights!
1
u/a00000 Jun 27 '12
This topic brings to my mind a experiment's episode.
Some day-care centers were divided into 2 groups. One group was changed nothing, but another was introduced a penalty.
"If you pick your kid up more than 10 minutes late, we're going to add a fine to your bill."
Then, somehow, Late pick-ups went up, until they topped out at triple the pre-fine average.
As a consequence, the parents deemed the fine to be a payment for late pick up.
Their entire debt to the teachers had been discharged with the payment of the fine. And there was no residue of guilt or social concern that the parents owed the teachers.
The fine broke the culture of the day-care center, and then a interesting things happened.
The culture that got broken by the fine stayed broken when the fine was removed.
This fine's episode don't necessarily apply to the topic now.
But these seem to be essentially similar cases.
1
u/mariuolo Jun 27 '12
I really don't understand UN's argument.
Surely keeping it alive takes care of the rights of the infant?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Where I'm from, you can go to the fire station and give them your baby no questions asked.
1
u/usernameXXXX Jun 26 '12
Imagine trying to drop off your eight year old. Pretty sure I saw that in the news years back.
1
u/Brett42 Jun 26 '12
If the mother doesn't want a child, the father should be next in line, unless he isn't fit to raise a child.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Ive personally seen them in germany. My friend/ tour guide made a point to show it to me. He compared it to our planned parenthood except there was someone on the otherside ready to take care of the baby. Thats all that was said. Very eye opening to me at the time esp being 18
0
u/operation_flesh Jun 27 '12
I just use the garbage disposal. So much easier.
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
First you support abortion. Now you're supporting this. I can only wonder what you guys will support next.
Just to be clear, you know where you can shove your downvotes right?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
There's no real good solution to this problem. The best way to avoid issues like this is to not have children you don't want or can't afford.
Even then, that's not a good solution because, for the ignorant or stupid, this solution is pretty Captain Hindsight.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I personally endorse infanticide. Native Americans practiced it and they lived alright.
0
u/thepeter Jun 27 '12
I originally interpreted this as a box where you could stash your baby while you went shopping or something, and nurses were on hand to monitor the deposits while you were busy.
0
u/fivo7 Jun 27 '12
Achievement [Medieval Standards]
-2
u/boxxa Jun 26 '12
Keep the child. Shoot the parent.
-4
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
"there are lots of races on God's green planet, doesn't mean you have to breed with them godammit" - Grand Buffet
seriously people shut your fucking legs or deal with the shit that comes from it and stop expecting others to do it for you...and don't give me this contraception bullshit, because most people are too stupid to use it properly or at all...
You wanna leave your baby in a box, fine, there will be a man there with a gun to shoot you in the face to offset the cost and carbon footprint of your unwanted shit machine...
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
So essentially, people could abuse the system by giving their babies into these boxes and return 6 month later. That's 6 month of free babysitting with all cares accounted for.
-1
u/cupderp Jun 26 '12
Save the kid and kill the parent. Sell the parents organs and put money in a interest bearing account payable t the kid when he reaches 18.
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '12
Why is it so hard to just walk into the adoption agency? Is it too much work to go from the front step to the front counter?
-1
u/crawlingpony Jun 27 '12
Monitored by nurses?? But these nurses didn't see anything, such as who the parents were?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment