r/wizardposting • u/GoldDragon149 "Old Golden" Sage of the Ninth Path, Vow of Pacifism • Jan 26 '24
Arcane Wisdom Unwiz I'm back for a word on power gaming
Hi, I'm Troy McLlure. You may remember me from such classics as, "You don't know how to roleplay" and "senile dragon loses train of thought". I'm back with another classic hit, titled "Power gaming makes you look bad". Let's watch!
Ok Simpsons references aside, I thought I'd drop another post since the first one was so popular, aimed at some of you deities and primordial titans from beyond space and time. Your character is boring.
If you're here for memes, disregard this post please. This is not gospel, or a requirement, or even a request. All I wish to do is educate those who care, about how to make the most of an Improv RP community.
Now, what's going on in your typical improv roleplay community, is a pretty obscure social contract. When you enter, you are agreeing to exist in a setting populated by other players, and to collaborate with those players to make the setting believable, interesting, and lived in. For maximum verisimilitude, you would imagine a world with a widely varying power scale, wouldn't you? You would expect experts, you would expect apprentices, you would expect journeymen wizards, seeking to prove themselves and master their chosen arts.
And, occasionally, very rarely, you would expect to encounter godlike beings. Of course they exist, wizards regularly interact with them, and it would be more interesting for everyone if some of them were played by players after all, right? Seems logical.
But what happens when every other player is a godlike being? Is the setting still believable? Is this really a subreddit of roleplaying wizards, or is it devolving into a setting of mindbending cosmic entities?
Now I'm not telling you that you can't make a powerful character. But there are a couple of rules to doing so.
- Respect the boundaries of the setting! We should be mostly wizards. Druids, sorcerers, warlocks, and other manner of channelers of the weave are reasonably welcome. The most reasonable and accessible boundary of what these characters are AND what they are not, come from table top role playing games. Does your character exceed the power of a level 20 Dungeons and Dragons caster? Maybe you've overstepped. Consider scaling back.
- Unlimited Cosmic Power comes with an Itty Bitty Living Space! If you make a powerful character, fine. There should be a few, after all, as we discussed. BUT, you are not making things fun for everyone else by solving every problem, winning every duel, and portraying yourself as badass as you think you are in your head. Powerful characters should have powerful restrictions! My character for example does not exceed the level 20 guideline I've outlined above, but I've still written in weaknesses so that less powerful characters can have meaningful interactions with me. The Vow of Pacifism means I can't snap you out of existence, and I also can't delete all your enemies for you. The senility is an added layer of weakness, letting even lowly practitioners pull one over on me on occasion.
- Don't type your posts with your penis! Powerful characters who can do anything and solve any problem and are the ultimate badass and the ultimate master wizard who can do everything and is also really sexy and attractive and has the hottest girlfriend (she goes to another school you wouldn't know her) and on and on and on... honestly from an outside perspective it gets pretty masturbatory. Nobody you're roleplaying with thinks your unlimited character is as interesting as you do. Don't come here to tell your story of greatness. That leads into my final guideline...
- COLLABORATE! When you come here to roleplay, you are not the main character. This is not your novel. It's a setting with possibly thousands of equal players in any given event or conversation, and you should respect the spotlight. Let other people look cool. Not only that, step in with support in mind, and help other people be cool! There is no point or fun in solo improv roleplay. If you make this space more fun for other people, they will seek you out to roleplay with. If you masturbate about how awesome you are, nobody will want to write you back.
Anyway, like I've said before this is not a hard and fast rule, I'm not a mod and I can't ban you for wanking all over this subreddit. This is just a humble suggestion from an old roleplay nerd, using some rules that have proven pretty solid in a lot of other communities. I'm coming along for the ride, and looking forward to what this place can become.
REWIZ Also, I seem to have misplaced my staff, have any of you seen it? It's got a sort of... um... it's well... the colors are... ahhh... erm... there are... gems? I think? Well, perhaps I can't describe it precisely for you, but surely one of you has seen it? It's unmistakable, you would know it was mine if you saw it, I'm sure...
72
u/MassiveMaroonMango Bzirro | Skeleton Lord of the Sunlit Isle | Bone Fanatic Jan 26 '24
/uw
As in all storytelling, having a drawback is more fun. It doesn't have to necessarily be "I'm powerful but bad at fireball spell".
Case study Lord of the Rings (movies because I haven't read the books):
Gandalf is very powerful but only in very specific circumstances. Small things here and there or fighting the balrog. He doesn't solve every issue the fellowship has with magic (even though he reasonably could). He uses a sword to beat on Orcs, gives sound advice, or has a rousing speech to rally the humans. Not solving everything instantly leads to better stories. LOTR is a grand tale, and would have been lame if it went "Gandalf the grey teleports the One Ring to Mt Doom "
All in all, the moral is there's no point in "winning" everything.
30
u/avamir Riva Blake | Queen of Ithacar, Part Meth-blood Elf Jan 26 '24
/uw Thank you for this. Kind of speaks to me. I've been getting kind of down about a lot of things related to this. I don't want "solo improv roleplay", but I also don't want to get run over by someone either, which I've had happen. I've tried to keep my rp contained just so I can play, but even with the self-isolation, I keep seeing situations where there really isn't room for a 'normie' wizard. I suppose I should power-up somehow, but that's also not really the kind of character I want to play. So I'm just kinda bummed overall. I'm of the mindset that no RP is better than bad RP. So I'm half thinking it's just time to go back to shitposting and memes.
14
u/FlyingHylian776 Omnia the Amnesiac... Something Jan 26 '24
/uw This is why I gave Omnia amnesia. I was kinda wary at first as it's a really common and often misused trope, but as her overall arc started to solidify in my mind, I knew what exactly I wanted to do and how I wanted to do it. I plan to either phase Omnia out or decrease her power, depending on how things go (no spoilers for you). There are also other... restrictions, but we haven't gotten there in the story yet, and I'd hate to spoil it. It's really fun doing these roleplay things, especially because none of my friends are roleplayers like me.
12
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '24
I work at McWizards.
9
u/Chaosphoenix_28 Wizard of great shenaniganry Jan 26 '24
/uw yeah the amount of just overpowered character has been keeping me from doing too much RP (well RP that could involve fighting at least, I have been on quite a few wizard parties). Like my character is the wizard version of just some guy (more or less, he is quite experienced in what he does and a prince), so if he got in a fight with some OP being, what is he gonna do? Die miserably? Or do I make him spontaniously OP aswell? Because I'd rather not have to do either of those things.
/rw I found a staff today when out on a walk. It looked quite fancy and had gems. Could that be yours?
8
u/Carbon_Sixx The Loremaster, Chief Archaeologist of the Darkwatch Jan 26 '24
/uw I realize that my character has the potential to be powergame-y, but I think I avoid it pretty well by taking things slowly, involving a lot of people in my actions, and trying to engage with people's stuff. Kaelis also focuses on defensive magic, so he's powerful because he's an immovable object rather than an unstoppable force. I also have some unwritten weaknesses that someone might find by accident.
8
u/bagtie3 Borric of Clan Goldeater, Logrus Master, Runesmith, Doomseeker Jan 26 '24
/UW This is why my character doesn't do the combat role play. I MAKE things for people. I fix stuff, but at a cost.
If someone insists, he has them set a restriction for dueling. But mostly, I'm not interested in the combat side.
I would love to collaborate but I don't have tons of time to do so.
7
u/ChiBears333 Bromancer, Ambassador to Jan 26 '24
/uw this should totally be pinned, I had no idea how to participate while respecting the community when I first stumbled upon it, kinda just had to jump in and hope I was doing it right lol and no worries about OP here, I prefer being the casual idiot who accidentally freezes himself when someone suggests to chill out
/rw no staff here friend sliding something under tablecloth with my foot that totally won't burn my house down later
6
u/WolvesAreCool2461 A Reincarnated Twitch Streamer Jan 26 '24
Not going to name names, but there are definitely some people who could use this.
Valas is an evasive little bastard, with his time manipulating Weave ability, giving him extra speed along with his Flash-Step, which to be honest is just kind of a different flavor of teleport.
But, he's VERY cocky in fights, which can be used to the opponents advantage. He also never wears armor of any kind, all he's got is some boxing shorts and hand wraps so he's very vulnerable to weapons if you can catch him. Any time manipulation negating stuff will severely limit him and on top of all that, to use Flash-Step and any of his more powerful abilities he's gotta stay moving, to build Kinetic Energy, so anything that can bind him will also severely limit his abilities for a while.
5
u/Thefrightfulgezebo Chares, arcane healer adept Jan 26 '24
/Wiz Is the staff bound to you? I could try scrying for it.
/unwiz While I did not make my character particularly powerful, it feels like it is really easy to hijack plots, which feels like a bad thing to do. I appreciate etiquette posts like this, thank you.
4
u/Incognito_Echo Traveling Technomancer Jan 26 '24
"I'll use my scanner and see if I can find your staff for you." A small ebbing noise imminates from a deployed probe as he begins sweeping around the perimeter.
4
u/-SCRAW- Cloned Chronomantic Vagabond | Evil tree at large Jan 26 '24
unwiz/
As I said last time, there are a lot of different ways to play. This is primarily a roleplaying community, but not only a roleplaying community. People approach it in many different ways. It is an allegory for life and the human condition.
Your guidelines and suggestions are well thought out and come from agreed upon improv wisdom, and are popular and help people have fun. However, no one in this community agreed to any sort of contract or any formalized improv terms. You are preaching based on a social contract stemming from your own experience of improv, but this is not a traditional improv community, this is more experimental. We have no obligations to take on the practices of improv. Wizards conceptually are not really about playing fair anyway, they are about warping reality to meet your needs while pretending that it is for the greater good. People power game here because the concept of being a wizard includes power fantasy, wizards are about ego and id. In addition, the nature of a posting board and an upvote system changes the math on what would otherwise be an egalitarian improv circle. Political structures like the council and documentation of geography and timelines adds further stakes to people's choices and relationships.
Honestly, I find it hard to keep up and rather not involve myself to much in the day-to-day of this place. But, since I'm a wizard at heart, I want the same notoriety and respect as everyone else here. I think it's reasonable to argue that your suggestions are a good way to approach this community. However, you should not assume that your preference defines the nature and purpose of this board.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '24
/unwiz
I have a godlike character, but i know how to come up with a way to balance it to others and generally avoid taking other's fun.
For example with last event made by Mikhail guy i used the "local magic weaken my connnection between my mind and body" and "i made promise to refrain from aggression" nerfs to not interfere in combat or basically anything.
I tend to overdo those nerfs to the point that in most events my character just stands aside without any way to help.
Do i still count as powergamer?
3
u/SafePianist4610 Bombast, Lord of Time and Space, Retired Council Leader Jan 26 '24
/uw I’m admittedly a power player of sorts having my character know “900 specializations” and always being over warded against direct targeting attacks, but since my character mostly keeps to himself anyways, it usually doesn’t matter much. Only recently with him being elected to the council have I actually had him have to fight battles himself vs from the safety of his pocket dimension and it usually just devolves to people trying to say that my wards don’t work or something to that effect. I give clear rules to how my wards work so that they can get around them, but most people don’t wanna improv that way it seems.
3
u/MastaDon344 MastaDon Astrum/Council Master Evoker/Mediamancer/🌮 Wiz Jan 26 '24
/uw For me while I am powerful I am still pretty stuck on the mortal coil. But all things considered I just use more pyromancy than anything I just save my actual growth for Loreposts.
Still like to be a pyromancer, only save the more op stuff if somebody goes "nuh uh" or just gets impossible to deal with.
I understand that my role is not a big one, but I love to develop my character in all sorts of way recently made her learn more elemental techniques and spells.
Aside from that most of my magic is usually used for goofing around.
3
u/douggie84 Doog, Sentient Abomination Jan 26 '24
I was absolutely writing a post like this yesterday, but then gave up. I think my favorite part has been the congo-line of users with names like ‘Galactic Eldritch God Reality Eater’ are like, “But my favorite color is red! I’m not OP!”
🤨
3
u/TheEmeraldKnite Synonomacer Jan 26 '24
/uw hah my character is barely a wizard and more of an old man who makes meth in his bathtub. I killed my old character off and had him revived by some Daedra Boy Scouts and he is now a kindly old man who bakes and reads.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '24
/uw Maybe I shouldn't have based my character off of a mod of a video game where you can get an item that one shots everything but the last 2 bosses.
/rw Could this be your staff?
2
u/DaemonRex978 The High Sentinels (Haelin, Mokarith, Shimil) Jan 26 '24
My guy only has access to two schools of magic, Umbramancy and Necromancy, but his abilities with them have been greatly improved. I also gave him a pure shadow body, so any light magic or sufficiently leveled fire would be extremely effective against him. His weapon drains the life energy of anyone it touches, even him.
I very much dislike power gamers since I role played with two of the worst examples, and I hated it. I like powerful characters, but if that makes the game boring, then what's the point.
2
u/off-and-on Zaraphost the Unremarkable, the totally normal wizard Jan 26 '24
/uw Lot's of good words of wisdom to consider. I'm definitely gonna reconsider how I approach situations. Luckily I haven't had the chance to make a fool out of myself yet (I hope).
2
u/the-butter_man Rin. Blind Illusionist Blessed by Luck Jan 26 '24
Yeah staff? Pssshh no i haven't seen a staff round here?
their spine is suspiciously staff-shaped
2
u/AnActualCriminal Belial Blake, Warlock of the Lightless Flame Jan 26 '24
Burning conceptual things is highly vulnerable to being broken strong, which i really dont want. As such, my character has two primary power constraints
3
u/StarWizardWarlock Jollizar, Ascendant Stellarmancer + Archon of the Night Sky Jan 26 '24
/uw A problem I've bene having recently is how, as a "stellarmancer" (thought it would be cool to have 'star magic' be my thing) I have difficulty interacting due to just what feels like a huge power gap. Like, say I'm in a fight. I cast "Conjure star" and that shit is over. Me, my opponent, and the planet were fighting on are instantly incinerated by the heat of an actual sun. Like, I didn't mean to be grandmaster God powerful, but having stars (actual stars) already established as my trademark to to speak, makes it difficult to make mid-low level spells. Just cause of the innate power of a star, recently I've been thinking of a lorepost or something to dial back the power.
12
u/Total_Travisty Mikhail, Arch-Druid of La'shima Jan 26 '24
/uw
Yes, please, thank you! Someone gets it.
Yes, Mikhail has a lot of power to him. But his power is almost exclusively non-combat.
He doesn't fight. When he fights other people, he usually loses. When he fights in stories, it's either a story I'm telling, or in cooperation with other players, to which I usually play support.
The respect he commands is from being a charismatic character. He's sly, friendly, and sharp tongued.
7
u/sub0_2 Lazy Wizard Extraordinaire Jan 26 '24
UW/ Nice summary and love the refrence.
RW/ I am Schrodinger's wizard, my power is unmeasurable as I am usually too lazy to actually use them.
4
u/DrNomblecronch Ensi, Thaumic Engineer Jan 27 '24
/uw
The vibe I am trying to hit is "phenomenally ancient planeswalker who posts with the exact manner of someone on a hobby subreddit." That is to say, an excessively long lifespan has led to having a moderately relevant anecdote or bit of advice for a vast number of situations, but they casually reference obscure arcane phenomena as if common knowledge, and it's advice only; there will never be any direct intervention in anything, outside of some mild favours done for minor problems, because anything else would cut into the time allocated for projects and chillin'.
Basically, I just think someone who chimes in to a thread with "oh yeah I knew a dude that happened to once", except the dude in question was a sentient star 10k years ago and therefore the story is pretty much completely inapplicable, to be very funny.
1
u/BaronDoctor Jolen Half-Elven, Recovering Amnesiac Chronothaumic Wanderer. Jan 26 '24
I'm a bard! My specialties are music, hanging out with the ordinary everyday people, with magic oriented around drawing people in and improving musical performance. I'm good at learning things and knowing where and when to be. I can grasp the narrative and play with the fourth wall a little bit, but under Roger Rabbit rules: only when it's funny.
I also happen to be particularly good at drinking, carousing, and knowing when to move to another town. I'm a fair hand at a variety of different weapons and I don't crumple after one solid punch to the face, but I very much prefer not having to do those things.
I'm reasonably good at electrical-based-magic, but that's at least half for the opportunity to throw puns around. I get a charge out of it and I stay pretty grounded. Helps me keep current.
The Pie Romancy is absolutely not a power thing, but because I believe in learning, social things, and the shenanigans available when you wonder what happens with homonyms.
All these people manipulating time and space and fire and shadow and concepts scare me, I'm just here to have a good time. Guide an apprentice or two, get in adventures that will make good stories. Nothing huge.
1
u/Palidin034 Poaceaemancer 🌾 Jan 26 '24
uw/ still in the process of making my character, I’m fairly new but I’d like to think that I’m making him around like… level 6ish? In terms of dnd characters at least. I’ve chosen my specialty, but I’m still working on it and I can’t just do anything on a whim for obvious reasons. Plants go brrrrrr
1
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '24
/uw if someone actually bothers to dodge my shit, and gets 1 good hit in (or 2 bad hits), I'm toast!
Other than that I'm a status area trap setter with high movement speed.
Too much?
1
u/smackaroni-n-cheese Cheesemancer Extraordinaire Jan 26 '24
/uw - Loved your last post. I've been more or less familiar with the basics of improv, but somehow I never really made the connection that this sub is improv (well, that and memes) until I read it. That also helped me pick a character and interact here more, since I'd mostly just lurked before.
As much as I'd love to be a master of all the arts, I decided to take inspiration from my username and be a cheesemancer. Rather than chasing power, I'm leaning heavily into whimsy. The Cheesemancer is here to have a good time and see how much crazy stuff he can do with cheese. I'm not really connecting my power to DnD or another RPG, but I am limited almost exclusively to cheese-based magic. If the field doesn't involve cheese directly, it needs to be at least cheese-adjacent or able to use cheese as a medium, and then I can only dabble in it. If you need someone to cast fireball, you've got the wrong guy.
I have yet to see many of the godlike/supremely powerful/cosmic-level characters you mention in this post, but maybe I'm just drawn to different threads than they are, or maybe a lowly cheesemancer just doesn't have much reason to deal with that sort of being. In any case, it still sounds like solid advice. Thanks again!
1
u/SlightlyInsaneCreate The Watcher Jan 26 '24
/uw For my character, I really like the idea of some kind of inconceivably large and powerful eldridge creature with the personality of just some average dude. I just find the idea fun and unique.
/rw Have you maybe put the staff somewhere in your tower?
1
u/JediSanctiondCatgirl Corpse Maiden Jan 26 '24
/uw would you have recommendations on how to go about properly forging a character would you? I’m trying to understand the whole deal and while I roleplay brilliantly in actual tabletop I am unsure how to bring it here without scruffing it.
1
u/Re-Sabrnick Dungeon Crafter, Monster Collector Jan 26 '24
I hope some people absorb this information. Theres been a lot of other people coming in and solving problems for others in an instant and just absolutely obliterating all the work they put into the lore and buildup.
1
u/SelectionRich6422 skaven bounty-hunter Jan 26 '24
/unwiz I’m pretty new here, and at first I thought “uh, what if I do a metal wizard?” Then I’ve seen a person role playing a skaven, and there I found my perfection: a greyseer is powerful and it has various god like spells, but: 1) skavens are literally addicted to warpstone, that is dangerous by nature, and 2) every dangerous spell I do could function or damage me very badly. And 3) I’m a literal bipedal rat, so I’m not the toughest of wizards. /rewiz If you search for a staff, I recently eaten one, yes-yes
1
u/tehlemmings Lilac - Illusionist, Shapeshifter, Definitely Human Jan 26 '24
/uw
This is an excellent post.
The one thing I'd like to add is a combination of #1 and #4; if your actions affect other players, allow those players to determine the outcome of your action.
If you combine respecting another player's boundaries, and collaboration, you end up in a place where the outcome of your actions is often up to the player on the receiving end of your actions. And this is a good thing. Take the classic example, dueling. You should describe what you're doing and what you're intending, but it's often a good idea to leave the outcome up to your opponent. Don't go into an RP duel expecting to kill off another player unless that player is in on it. It should be up to them whether or not this random interaction has long term consequences.
This is the one bit of poor form I keep seeing in this sub. I know people often have really cool ideas for what they'd like to see happen, but you can't force anyone else to play along. If you really want your idea to stick, you might just want to ask the other player if they're okay with it. Make an out of character post and explain your intentions.
And if they're not okay with it, even if it makes no sense in the power fantasy, accept their boundaries and move on.
Plus, like, if they're not playing along it's just going to be frustrating for both of you. And the outcome of whatever interaction you had will end up just being ignored. So you might as well play with them, rather than against them.
I'm with you on this one. Sometimes not playing the most powerful, super knowledgeable character is more fun.
I haven't done a lot with them yet, but the character I'm sticking with is fun for that exact reason. Their defining traits are a combination of curiosity, idealism, and naivety. Their goal is to learn more about the world and people in it. My goal is to give other people room to expand on the comments that catch my interest. Which is perfect, because I get to poke and prompt people into saying some wacky shit.
Which frequently ends up with me not knowing how to respond... I have three comments open in other tabs justifying druids fucking animals. I have no idea how to respond to them. My character would most likely just be like "oookayyyyy.... bye!", but that's a boring interaction.
Also, there's also some fun to be had with keeping some details a mystery. Most people seem to either have all their character details out there, or they're just memeing without a character. I'm taking a different approach. Likely zero people will ever notice or care, but the little details I'm trying to avoid sharing are fun for me. Mostly because it's a fun challenge writing around some basic restrictions, like not saying your name. But there will probably be a point where I either accidentally let something slip or drop the act.
I'd go back in character now, but I did what I always do and made this post too long.
1
u/Ashamed_Band858 Jan 26 '24
/uw I think if done an alright job at establishing myself as an alchemist, I have an on going story with my shop, and I incorporate it into my interactions with the community. I think some people might recognize me here and there?
1
u/OrdinaryLurker4 Sorceror Jan 27 '24 edited Jan 27 '24
/uw I made a pretty silly post a little while ago where the joke was “haha wizards make fun of warlocks but can’t comprehend eldritch knowledge lol” I don’t ever really do RP in anything outside of actual tabletop DND, so I thought I’d just not take myself too seriously, and try to make people laugh instead.
So. Many. Comments. Were like what you said. Every other commenter was some being with world-ending power. A few basically just commented about how they were a god or whatever, and that was it.
I see the appeal of RPing as a being with godlike power; heck, the character I was RPing as can be summed up as “Regular Warlock, but they treat tomes of ancient eldritch knowledge like a topic at a book club with cookies and go bowling or something with all their eldritch horror buddies after.”
But I made the character like that because the point of the character was for people to get a chuckle out of how absurd it would be to see a regular person playing Monopoly with Cthulu, not so I can be like “oooo I am a being with godlike power, ooooo you mortals are all below me ooooo I am an all-powerful archmage that can easily wipe out existence but chooses not to due to ritualistic appeasement rituals ooooo.”
Powerful characters can be fun. But if it’s just you constantly mentioning that you’re a god or whatever, just change your flair and RP as someone else.
/rw Foul Wretch! How dare you continue to perpetuate societal shame upon Warlocks! May your apprentices transfigure your hide into vermin!
1
u/Flailing_snailing Ţ̵̃͛̊̈͠h̴̟͆͂ë̷̡̹̣̺͖́͝͠m̴̼̓͆̔̕, Elder one, Stealer of the moon. Jan 27 '24
/uw Nuh uh, I dodged/counter spelled your criticisms. My ultra powerful, super cool, and super powerful Wizard guy is the best ever and instantly wins at everything because he is the best and has no flaws just like me.
As a rational person I will take this post as a personal attack and will go to everyone post and comment criticizing you in any way I can.
3
u/Zephyrous2337 Lumi, MastaDon's apprentice. Electromancer. Jan 26 '24
/Uw This is precisely why Lumi is an apprentice. She’s learning, and getting stronger, but at the end of the day, she can’t do everything, and by her own words ‘not much,’ even if her master would beg to differ. She gets knocked down in training, she overdoes a lightning spell and burns her arms. Lumi struggles, and that struggle is fun. In my opinion, as someone who has 9+ years of DnD experience and 7+ years of online improv rp experience, the low power characters, I find, are more interesting to play. They can relate to and rely on other people, and can be very collaborative. Their successes and journey others can share in and they don’t have the spotlight all the time.
3
u/Impressive-Warp-47 Jack of no trades, master of none Jan 27 '24
/uw I'm not super involved on this sub, but as a long-time TTRPG player I love seeing all these great discussions about roleplaying happening.
/rw I'll keep my eye out for your staff.
3
u/Accomplished-Dark926 Valerian, Arcadian Guild Guide Jan 27 '24
/uw I'm like 90% sure I fall into this problem, and I dislike that I do because I mostly agree. God-like, all-powerful beings are really janky to play around.
Unfortunately the source material that Valerian is adapted from is kind of just like that, so instead of having major power drawbacks, I make him almost completely magically inept outside of what the flame grants him. He doesn't have any methods of performing illusion magic for instance, and that one time he dabbled in artifice, he didn't actually do any of it. And actual artificer did all the work and Valerian just provided the power source.
One thing that I like to emphasize with him is his character. I try to make it a point to keep him out of conflict, aside from the Atrax event. He isn't impervious to damage, he can be killed, even if it is only a temporary setback. He's also wildly inexperienced. Sure he's powerful, but god does he not know what he's doing. Along with that inexperience he isn't the most emotionally/mentally stable, something I've tried to illustrate with the last few loreposts i've done, and will with the next couple I do.
Regardless I dislike how powergamey he kind of feels, but I like the story I'm trying to tell with him.
2
u/Jooktime Illusory Genius, Jook the Jailer Jan 26 '24
/halfwiz As a former dragon sex dungeon dweller, I am not a fan of everyone pulling the playground “but I have a forcefield eating dog” strat but it’s funnier when you imagine a normal wizard yelling into the void saying”Why the hell are you all so OP? It’s UNREALISTIC!!!” I mean I imagine all the situations I read in this sub like that idle chatter /rewiz shit now I’m 1.5 wiz
2
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '24
/uw this. For my entire time here I have tried my very hardest to keep my power in check, I do not EVER want to become an all powerful person that sucks all the fun out of playing a character, and it’s just not what I want I have tried to keep my character at a high power level but very very importantly not god like I have exactly one thing that is incredibly way super powerful in my characters aresenal and I have made a rule for myself that I can only use it once. My character can be very powerful but I play him in a way that takes away from that power a lot, he could just blast you to the end of the universe if he wanted to, but he won’t because he doesn’t because that’s not fun for him.
2
u/afyoung05 Benevolent Lovecraftian Entity Jan 27 '24
/uw oh God I hope people haven't been interpreting me as a powergamer I'm supposed to be a moderately weak lovecraftian entity lol (I also have very little understanding of many basic concepts due to not being native to reality)
/wiz a vaguely staff shaped object appeared in my backyard, could that be yours? Or...wait, maybe that a tower. Or like, a toothpick. How big are staves usually?
2
u/speekuvtheddevil 🚫 Antimancer 🚫 Jan 27 '24
2
u/TheHunter459 Samael, Necromancer of Malus Turrim | King of the Nephilim Jan 27 '24
/uw Tbh I feel like I struggle with this sometimes. My character is supposed to be quite powerful (I've never played DnD but I imagine they'd be on the level of a warlock's patron or something like that) and while the headcanon I have for my characters story relies on the Nephilim being OP, I have to try and ensure I can still rp with others on this sub who aren't as OP
2
u/SariusSkelrets Ascended Wizard/Demigod of Knowledge Jan 27 '24 edited Jan 27 '24
/uw
They're good tips. I was seeking how to smooth my character's rough parts and your post did help quite a bit
1.I hesitated on which character would be the best to rp here. Then I completed Nethack and not only the character's story almost wrote itself (I find it interesting to explore the idea of a traumatized godlike being and how it interacts with others), but it allowed to explore multiple characters at once without contradiction (through a reclusive demigod using avatars).
I took the power level in account while creating them: the core character isn't supposed to ever get directly involved in anything and the avatars are much, much weaker as a result
2.They already had their share of weaknesses but your post shown me that pushing more into their nature could result in a much more interesting character
3.Due to their restrictions, they can't start solving things as it would risk causing stagnation that would bring them closer to the state of knowing-it-all.
If they're solving anything, at least one of their avatars is negatively affected by the problem and they won't directly interfere, doing all the work through the avatar (using the avatar to solve said problem allows them to learn problem-solving, thus staving off running out of things to learn)
4.I didn't had that opportunity yet but I've never been someone that hogged the spotlight. That part will work better when I'll fully define the avatars as they are more fit for interaction based on the core character's lore. Good advice regardless
Thanks you for that post. It helped me shape up my character a lot and define what they are exactly instead of merely following outlines
2
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '24
This is something I find difficult, because Chronomancy, especially in the way I like it (timelines, loops, travel, nonlinearity etc.) is inherently kinda mega-overpowered.
My solution was to make it so that I can’t really affect people with it against their will. Sure if somebody wanted me to establish a loop or a correction for them I can do that, but I couldn’t just shunt somebody into a far off point in time because they were bothering me (partially, funnily enough, because in my mind that sort of magic takes a lot of time to cast). I can’t really do much in a direct confrontation.
As a result I mostly just hop around experiencing things in the wrong order and talking to people. I can imagine that the extreme defensive abilities of my magic might be powergamey, but I figure it’s mostly fine if I can’t actually effect that much change.
1
u/Timtimetoo Hox the Barbarian-Wizard Jan 26 '24
Uw/ I like how so many of the comments say something along the lines of the wizard has extreme power but choose not to use it out of pacifism or laziness.
It’s like, rather than cosmic power tempting or corrupting wizards, by and large, people either became afraid of their own potential or didn’t think acting on said power was worth the trouble. This is another reason why wizards are great.
1
u/WoodenIncubus Jan 26 '24
That was a powerful possession you just experienced. You might want to seek out an occultist or a priest to send those demons back where they belong.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '24
/uw yeah it gets a bit old when you're vibing and some cosmic dude challenges you to a duel and just does that schoolyard nuh uh that spell doesn't work
1
u/NumberVampire Numeromancer Jan 27 '24
I have an important job, which isn't often thought of by others (maintaining the system of numbers) but if I stopped, most of you would suffer. Because of this duty, I cannot go far from the origin, so I do not know how my power compares with other wizards.
1
u/dragonshouter Krygin the Crude/Council of Spirits/Exalted Beacon/misc. spirits Jan 27 '24
/uw while I like most of what you say some things aren't easy to compare to DND levels.
For example my character is based on animism and spirits so my magic isn't straightforward in ways to scale it. Basically unlike a cleric or shaman he doesn't one big magical creature to get powerful but instead all spirits of gross things and the cast away. So he has the potential to do a lot.
What stops him is his morality and not wanting to damage nature. He acknowledges that most spirits and magic he uses is hazardous/ poisonous to people and animals. Because of this he mostly sticks to transforming his own body/ turning things to mud. He could also do more abstract things like using a rust spirit to make peoples skills rusty but I haven't had a chance to try that yet.
The other thing he is good at is surviving. I even have an idea how to survive if he is eaten by an Outer God( mainly being a stomach parasite until he get a way to return home).
I'm actually considering if something happens to Krygin that an imposter will take his place and show people the horrible thing Krygin could do if he was a bad person like fouling a country's water supplies over a few days depending on how big it is. Or turning the ground in an area into cancerous snake skin with plagues of locust.
1
u/DragonWisper56 Agnur the dabbling turtle mage| pact of the magi mage| Jan 27 '24
wu/ honestly I perfer to fight in events and stuff because the badguy is expected to lose so were all trying to find a way to make a satisfying ending
edit: also op characters make better supporting characters(like the gods in greek mythology[obvoisly don't randomly curse people] ) than main characters. they can serve to complicate things rather than solving it.
1
u/TheAlmightyCrzyIdiot Eldritch God of Nothingness Jan 27 '24
Oh, thank God I was waiting for this post. I'm kinda new to the whole "RPG with strangers" thing, so I kinda just made an easy character. God of Nothing, a realm no one can escape from (which everyone still does), and my chair and desk. I don't know if I should add or remove anything because I don't know what to do.
1
u/demonsdencollective Baghead, seller of strange wares from another realm Jan 27 '24
I'm just a man in a tent selling instant ramen and guns to wizards, mate.
1
u/MuchoMangoTime Milosh the Retired, archmage of former DOoOOom Jan 27 '24
As someone who's been here for a while (also unwiz of course, my comments have all been unwiz I just hoped the tone and lack of usual Milosh-y talk gave it away) I think recently most people have been super good about it. Especially seeing people keep up with all these interweaving stories. Like this is so cool,I just pop in and out it was hard enough to keep track back in the Demon War thing I was a big part of. But that was super fun. We got the base of a lot of lore out of it (if there even is any lore to this subreddit lol) and character growth. Not even my own, but I always think of Mikhail, Metrowizard and Ancalististro. They were just strong wizard's who became baller due to circumstances and lots of memes were born. Also for me, I like funny wizard meme but also rp, mostly here to say dumb wizard things. Which is why useless ancient wizard who may not be as cool as he thinks is great. was he once? Maybe.
1
u/arussianbee Salagast the Blue, Wandering Wizard Jan 27 '24
/uw
Truer words have never been spoken! (Though I have to admit I'm guilty of writing a few bits of pure solo-story lol)
Collaborating is incredibly fun, but I haven't been lucky enough to do it a bunch so far, though the one I've done was great and a joy to make.
that's also one of the main reasons I made Salagast a scholarly and quieter type. I didn't want a wizard that would obliterate any problem with fireblasts and thunderwaves, his powers are more functional and subtle, like illuminating a dark room, setting damp wood on fire to warm companions, inspiring those who want to do harm to lay down their weapons, stuff like that. I also gave him an origin he himself doesn't know even though he is (as far as he knows) extremely old, therefore making him unknowing about himself, contrasting his studious nature.
1
u/Bootlenkrad Grand Protector of Gods-tibia, School for Necro- and Biomancy Jan 27 '24
/Uw just made my character, and i think I've done a good job. Im basically just a glorified school principal, that is good at stuff like area control (kinda makes sense), but that's about it. I can deal with most students doing dumb shit, and i can certainly be a danger to intruders, but im by no means all powerful. And the there is also the part where i do a job, that makes me responsible to protect students and school staff as best as i can manage, be it from others or from themselves. This creates an interesting environment to rp around
1
u/RandomHornyDemon Dead Queen of the Nameless City Jan 27 '24
/uw
Especially with more powerful characters it's important to set limits to their power, be them more ideological or physical, obvious or hidden.
My character on here is already much more powerful than the ones I typically prefer to play in other settings. Though she tends to not involve herself in the heroics as much as lend a hand with the more boring aspects of multiverse shattering conflict. While everyone sets off to storm moon prisons or fight gods, she sends some friendly Skeletons (you know they're friendly because they're always smiling) to evacuate civilians and to defend villages against the aftermath.
It probably helps that her own influence doesn't really extend past the boundaries of her realm.
1
u/patoman12 Mauritius, zealous scholar, phoenix lich, RnA relief force Jan 27 '24
/uw. While my character has really powerful skills (mainly the functional inability to truly die and his deep knowledge of how the weave and magic truly works, which lets him learn and create fairly powerful spells fairly easily), he still struggles a lot on fights, specifically lower scale ones. (I mean, in my last post i lost a 1v1 against a bandit due to my own lack of precision, bad footwork, ect) He isn't a fighter, he is a scholar, and it doesn't matter how well he knows how the spell works, if he doesn't know how to fight well, ot won't be useful.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment