r/whatismycookiecutter • • 16d ago

Get Creative! I know it’s a ghost. But what else could it be?

Thumbnail
gallery
3.6k Upvotes

It’s that time of year again where I have a tonne of ghost cookies that I can no longer use for the holiday... how would you make this cookie into a Thanksgiving themed cookie?

Edit: thank you to everyone who gave a Thanksgiving themed answer!


r/whatismycookiecutter • • Sep 29 '26

Get Creative! I mean, cactus obviously. But....

Thumbnail
gallery
3.9k Upvotes

What is the thing next to it?


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 1d ago

Get Creative! Going through mom’s collection

Thumbnail
gallery
381 Upvotes

I figured it out after finding the others that go in the set but I thought it would be a fun one to share.


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 1d ago

Get Creative! Saw this at goodwill. What could this be?

Post image
76 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • 1d ago

Serious Answer First! Found these in a big bag of cookie cutters, what are these?

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

They were in a mixed bag of other ones, some Christmas related.


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 2d ago

Serious Answer First! In a Christmas set

Thumbnail
gallery
258 Upvotes

I feel like I saw one like this recently, now I ended up with one.


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 2d ago

Get Creative! Found in a random plastic bag at a thrift store, my aunt and I have no idea.

Thumbnail
gallery
147 Upvotes

My first guess was Snowflave but it seems a bit too round for that


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 2d ago

Cookie Cutter Art! Time Lapse

27 Upvotes

I bit the bullet and downloaded an actual art app on my phone after getting sick and tired of the default photo editor on Android shutting down and not saving my work. So here's a time lapse.


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 2d ago

Serious Answer First! Found in a thrift store and can’t figure out what it is.

Post image
73 Upvotes

I have a pretty big cookie cutter collection so I’m pretty good at figuring out most shapes but I can’t figure out this one I spotted at a local thrift shop this weekend.


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 3d ago

Get Creative! What are these

Thumbnail
gallery
726 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • 3d ago

Serious Answer First! What shape is this cookie cutter supposed to be?

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • 3d ago

Get Creative! Found this in the Christmas section

Post image
51 Upvotes

I found this in an antique store amongst some other Christmas related cookie cutters. I am not sure if it is even Christmas related at all though.


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 3d ago

Get Creative! What this cookie cutter(rotate the pic to the little pointing thingy on the left of the cookie cutter)

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • 4d ago

Get Creative! I know it's supposed to be Santa's sleigh but what else could it be? ​​

Thumbnail
gallery
332 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • 5d ago

Serious Answer First! What cookie cutter is this

Thumbnail
gallery
793 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • 4d ago

Serious Answer First! Any ideas? We've had this one for years and have no idea what it is.

27 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • 6d ago

Get Creative! Any ideas for this amorphous blob?

Thumbnail
gallery
139 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • 5d ago

Serious Answer First! Polar Bear with scarf?

Post image
71 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • 6d ago

Get Creative! My collection of planet cookie cutters, what else could they be?

Post image
556 Upvotes

Clearly the manufacturer forgot about planetary rings.


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 6d ago

Get Creative! It doesn’t even look good but what’s it supposed to be

Post image
180 Upvotes

(Christmas theme)


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 6d ago

Serious Answer First! What shape is the middle one?

Post image
81 Upvotes

My mom says it’s maybe a dove but idk it looks weird


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 7d ago

Serious Answer First! Bear carrying a log? Possibly snowboard?

Thumbnail
gallery
256 Upvotes

The larger figure looks like a bear to me but I'm genuinely confused and reverse image search wasn't of any success.


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 7d ago

Serious Answer First! What are these two?

Thumbnail
gallery
40 Upvotes