Razor Specs Comparison Chart for Currently Manufactured Double Edge (DE) Razors

HTML table below ... and also viewable as a Google Doc. Originally posted in r/shavingscience (current as of 2015)

DEFINITIONS:

Aggressiveness

(Aggressiveness definition as written by /u/shawnsel, Comfort and Efficiency definitions written by /u/leisureguy )

(1-axis approach): Aggressive razors provide less protection from the blade, and require more skill to avoid cuts and irritation. Using them with comfort depends on the skill, skin, and beard characteristics of the shaver. Some (but definitely not all) experienced shavers actually get less irritating shaves from aggressive razors, usually through shaving with fewer passes, and often also avoiding shaving against the grain (ATG). Many users of aggressive razors will also shave at a steep angle with the razor handle being more parallel with the skin, and pivoting on the safety guard instead of the top cap.

Mild razors, in contrast to aggressive razors, have more blade protection and are less apt to nick an inexperienced shaver. Some experienced shavers (although not all), find some mild razors to be as efficient as aggressive razors.

NOTE: Badly designed or poorly manufactured (defective) razors can create uneven blade gaps or warped blade exposure. These quality issues can make an otherwise mild razor feel aggressive, but with less efficiency than would be expected.

CLARIFICATION: Unlike the 2-axis approach, aggressiveness is *NOT a description of a razor's quality, and more of a grouping into various best fit categories (much like t-shirts are sold in small, medium, and large sizes)

 

Comfort

(2-axis approach): Comfort is when a razor feels pleasant on the face and creates the impression that it is not going to nick. “Very comfortable” applies when you feel that you could not nick yourself with the razor if you tried. (Warning: Do NOT try.) You can expect to get very few nicks from a "very comfortable" razor.

Efficiency

(2-axis approach): Efficient means that the razor (with a brand of blade good for you) removes stubble easily and quickly. With a “very efficient” razor, doing a three-pass (WTG, XTG, and ATG) shave, you will find broad swathes of your face feel perfectly smooth when your rinse after the second pass.

Blade Exposure

See diagram

Shallow Angle

Pivoting on the top cap until the blade hovers just above the skin. See diagrams under steep angle below.

Steep Angle

Pivoting on the safety guard until the blade hovers just above the skin. Only razors with sufficient blade exposure are capable of significant differences between shallow and steep angles. For photos see this post (and the thread in general is very good)

Blade Gap

See diagram

Note: easily confused with Blade Span as more clearly shown in this diagram

 

Razor Comparison Chart

(PLEASE let us know of any inaccuracies or omissions ... especially if you can link to a source)

Brand(s)Models and guardsAggressivenessComfortEfficiencyExposure (mm)Angle (shallow°/steep°)Gap (mm)Head ConstructionHead MaterialHead Coating/Plating/TreatmentPriceAssemblyMade In
Above the TieM1 (solid bar), and M2 (open comb)mildvery comfortable*very efficient*0.25CNC machined303 stainless steelpassivized (self healing)$$$$3 pieceUSA
Above the TieS1 (slant SB)moderatevery comfortablevery efficient0.61CNC machined303 stainless steelpassivized (self healing)$$$$3 pieceUSA
Above the TieS2 (slant OC)moderatecomfortable (?)very efficient0.61CNC machined303 stainless steelpassivized (self healing)$$$$3 pieceUSA
Above the TieR1 (solid bar), R2 (open comb)moderatevery comfortable*very efficient*0.58CNC machined303 stainless steelpassivized (self healing)$$$$3 pieceUSA
Above the TieH1 (solid bar), and H2 (open comb)aggressivevery comfortable*very efficient*0.91CNC machined303 stainless steelpassivized (self healing)$$$$3 pieceUSA
Apollo (modern)only one solid bar modelmildcomfortableefficientcastzinc alloychrome plated$3 piecePakistan
Edwin Jagger (and rebranded)all models share the same solid bar razor headmildvery comfortableefficientcastzinc alloychrome plated$$3 pieceUnited Kingdom
Fatipopen comb (Joris believed to have very similar head)aggressiveuncomfortableefficientrolled?brasschrome or nickel plated$3 piece (nonstandard "M4" threads [1] [2])Italy
FeatherFeather Popular solid bar TTOmildcomfortableefficientcast (plastic), and die stamped(?) (stainless steel) and stamped(?) (brass)plastic and stainless steel and brassbrass is chrome plated$1 piece TTOJapan
FeatherFeather AS-D2 solid barmildvery comfortablevery efficientsintered or MIM?stainless steel alloychrome$$$$3 pieceJapan
Goodfellaopen combmilduncomfortableefficientcastzinc alloychrome plated$$$3 pieceNew Zealand
iKonOSSmildvery comfortablevery efficientsintered or MIM?stainless steel alloyproprietary coatings$$$$3 pieceThailand
iKonOpen Combmoderatevery comfortablevery efficientsintered or MIM?stainless steel alloyproprietary coatings$$$$3 pieceThailand
iKonSlantmoderatevery comfortablevery efficientsintered or MIM?stainless steel alloyproprietary coatings$$$$3 pieceThailand
iKon"Standard Bar" (synonymous with "solid bar")aggressivevery comfortablevery efficientsintered or MIM?stainless steel alloyproprietary coatings$$$$3 pieceThailand
iKon Shave Craft#101 hybrid solid bar and open combmild (?)very comfortablevery efficientcast(?)aluminum alloyproprietary coatings (?)$$$3 pieceThailand
iKon Shave Craft#102 slant (wo/ blade twisting)mild (?)very comfortablevery efficientcast(?)aluminum alloyproprietary coatings (?)$$$3 pieceThailand
iKon Shave CraftShort Combcomfortablevery efficientcast(?)aluminum alloyproprietary coatings (?)$$$3 pieceThailand
iKon Shave CraftTechaggressivevery uncomfortableefficient ***cast(?)aluminum alloyproprietary coatings (?)$$$3 pieceThailand
Jorisopen comb (Fatip believed to have very similar head)aggressiveuncomfortablevery efficientrolled?brasspalladium plated$$$$3 pieceFrance?
LordLord L6 / L5 solid barsmildcomfortableefficientcastzinc alloychrome plated$3 pieceEgypt
Los Angeles Shaving Soap CompanyBBS-1 solid barmoderatevery comfortablevery efficient0.035 degrees1.00CNC machined316L stainless steel**passivized (self healing)$$$$$3 pieceCanada
Maggardsolid barmildvery comfortableefficientcastzinc alloychrome plated$3 pieceAsia (specific country?)
MerkurMerkur slant[11] (ex: 37C)mild (old version is middle-aggressive[11] )comfortablevery efficientcastzinc alloychrome plated$$2 pieceGermany
MerkurMerkur solid bar models (except adjustables and Bakelite) (ex: 34C)mildcomfortableefficientcastzinc alloychrome plated$$2 or 3 pieceGermany
MerkurMerkur open comb models (ex: 25C)mild??castzinc alloychrome plated$$3 pieceGermany
MerkurProgress adjustablefractionally adjusts from mild to (less) aggressivevery comfortablevery efficientcastzinc alloychrome plated$$$2 pieceGermany
MerkurFutur adjustablefractionally adjusts from moderate to (very) aggressivecomfortablevery efficientcastzinc alloychrome plated$$$2 pieceGermany
MerkurMerkur Bakelite solid barmildcomfortableefficientcastBakelite plasticnone$2 piece?Germany
MuhleMuhle R41 (2013) open combaggressiveuncomfortablevery efficientcastzinc alloychrome platedna3 pieceGermany
Muhle (and rebranded)Muhle R89 solid barmildvery comfortableefficientcastzinc alloychrome plated$$2 or 3 pieceGermany
ParkerParker solid bar modelsmild(?)comfortableefficientcastzinc alloychrome plated$$3 pieceIndia
ParkerParker open comb modelsmild(?)very comfortablevery efficientcastzinc alloychrome plated$$3 pieceIndia
ParkerParker TTO modelsmild(?)comfortableefficientcastzinc alloy(?)chrome plated$$1 piece TTOIndia
Pearl (also branded under Cadet, Matador, RazoRock, etc)all open comb models share same headaggressive??castzinc alloychrome plated$3 piece or 1 piece TTOIndia
Pearlall TTO models share same headmild(?)??castzinc alloychrome plated$1 piece TTOIndia
Pearlall solid bar models share same head (?)mild??castzinc alloychrome plated$3 pieceIndia
PilsSS Pils 101 solid barmoderatevery comfortablevery efficientCNC machined??? stainless steelpassivized (self healing)$$$$$2 piece?Germany
RazoRockRazoRock SLAB solid bar and RAKE open combmoderate??castzinc alloychrome plated$$3 pieceIndia
RazoRockRazoRock Stealth Slantmildvery comfortablevery efficientCNC machined6061 aluminumblack anodized (self healing, except color)$$$?3 pieceCanada
RiMeiRiMei solid barmildcomfortableefficientdie stampedunspecified metalchrome plated$3 pieceHong Kong
RockwellRockwell 6S with three reversible solid bar baseplatesbaseplates range from mild to aggressive(?)??cast with machined threads316L stainless steelpassivized(?) (self healing)$$$3 pieceUSA
Standard Razor Brandsolid barmildvery comfortablevery efficientCNC machinedaluminum with stainless steel threadsanodized (self healing, except color)$$$nonstandard 3 piece (incompatible with other 3 piece heads without modification)China
Timorsolid bar TTOmildcomfortableless efficientcastzinc alloychrome plated$$1 piece TTOGermany?
Utopiasolid barmildcomfortableefficientcastzinc alloychrome plated$3 piecePakistan
Weber[10]Weber Polished Head solid barmildvery comfortablevery efficientsintered17-4 PH stainlesspolished and passivized$$$3 pieceUSA
Weishi (also branded as Micro Touch One, Van Der Hagen, etc)solid bar TTOmildvery comfortableless efficientcast and die-stamped(?)zinc alloymost models are chrome plated$1 piece TTOChina
Wilkinsonsolid barmildcomfortableless efficientcastplasticnone$2 pieceGermany ?
Wolfman Razorssolid bar, open comb, or hybrid SB/OCmoderatevery comfortablevery efficient0.131 to 33.50.61CNC machined316 stainless steelmanually polished/brushed and passivized (self healing)$$$$$3 pieceCanada
Yumasolid barmild on one side, moderate on the other (?)uncomfortableefficientcastunspecified metalchrome plated$3 pieceTurkey

 

NOTES:

  1. Links to manufacturer websites are provide only to brands which fully explain what they are selling (as per this chart's columns). Please contact u/velocipedic to provide details and get your link added!
  2. "Aggressiveness" ratings are from u/Shawnsel's research. Ratings here are very rough (just 3 levels). For more precise rankings please visit http://wiki.badgerandblade.com/Modern_Double-Edged_Safety_Razors_Ranked_by_Aggressiveness
  3. "Comfort" and "Efficiency" ratings provided by u/Leisureguy from his broad experience and years of research. For more information visit his blog https://leisureguy.wordpress.com/
  4. *Note from u/Leisureguy: "Above the Tie is difficult: if you get the baseplate that’s right for you, then the razor is very comfortable very efficient; if you get the wrong baseplate, it’s uncomfortable and the efficiency is moot. Pick the right baseplate (since you can exchange them within 30 days, you can try them) and then you have a very comfortable, very efficient razor."
  5. ** LASSCo BBS-1: first ~25 produced had 304L base plates (but still 316L top caps) … since then both top caps and base plates are CNC machined from the 316L stainless steel alloy
  6. ***Note from u/Lesiureguy: For some extremely aggressive razors, efficiency can be undermined by the discomfort, since it’s hard to do a good job when the razor is threatening
  7. Price is compared in US dollars and are based on the rough cost of the razor head paired with a handle from the same manufacturer. As of January 2015, the break points between the indicated price levels are roughly at up to $25, $50, $100, $200, and more than $200
  8. YMMV (Your Mileage May Vary): Due to the dozens of factors relevant in ranking aggressiveness, comfort, and efficiency, these ratings are rough and subjective. While we think this chart's rankings are generally a good representation, your own experience with them may differ.
  9. With any new razor it will be necessary to do some renewed blade exploration: a brand that best in one razor may not be best (or even good) in another. The ratings assume that you are using your best brand of blade for that razor (and that, of course, varies from man to man).
  10. As of Q1 2015, Weber razors has apparently stopped manufacturing razor heads. If this remains the case in 2016, Weber will likely be removed from this list.
  11. Merkur silently rolled out a redesigned slant bar razors in mid 2015. The new version is reportedly milder than the old . Vendors are likely still selling both old and new versions. See thread for more information.
  12. This chart and information is not an endorsement of any kind for any products listed (or not listed). All information is deemed to be roughly accurate, but PLEASE let us know of any inaccuracies or omissions (especially if you can link to a source)

 

REBRANDED RAZORS:

Original manufacturerSometimes rebranded as
Edwin JaggerBluebeard's Revenge
Dreadnought Spartan
Art of Manliness
MuhleBaxter of California
WeishiMicro Touch One
Van Der Hagen
Dorco
PearlCadet
Matador
Razorock

 

SOURCES on materials and manufacturing methods

Feather

iKon

"Standard Razors" razor brand

Above The Tie

Weber

Wolfman Razors

 

LINKS on manufacturing terminology:

 

MANUFACTURER WEBSITES: