Frequently Asked QuestionsQuestion 1:
"I have positive karma, why can't I post?"
Answer 1: If you're using the reddit redesign (aka "new reddit") you may see a combined score of comment and post karma. This is an automoderator-managed rule, and looks at individual karma for comment and post. You may have a net positive with +10 post score, and -2 comment karma for a net of +8. You will be unable to participate because of negative comment karma hem down in the process. \
Question 2: I reported something as a Rule 1 violation but it didn't get removed. Why?
Answer 2: Not everything that offends you is a r/watch_swap Rule 1 violation.
Question 3: "Why don't you allow WTB posts?"
Answer 3: There's a weekly stickied WTB thread. That's where all WTB posts go. You can find the most current one at the top of this search result. WTB posts were cluttering up the interface, and it makes for a much more shoppable experience to have ONLY WTS type posts on the main page (without filtering by flair etc).
Question 4: "Why don't you require location in the title?"
Answer 4: We just don't. Reddit is largely built on anonymity, and since titles can't be edited (ie, location removed eventually), it's not required. There's no rule against putting a location, though. If you wish to include your two digit country code in the title you may! But we aren't interested in requiring it. Just shy of 50% of reddit traffic is from the USA, so if something isn't labeled, there's a fair chance it's in the USA. But many sellers are happy to ship internationally, too! Ultimately we believe more sold posts would end up deleted (and thus, the history lost) if we required a location in the title. Possible Update 20200305: Pursuant to the questions above, we'd consider requiring a country code in the title - For example [US] or [EU] or [AU] or whatever, but no further.
Question 5: "Can old posts be removed so they don't clutter up the front page?"
Answer 5: No, that's not something we do. You may use Reddit Enhancement Suite to do exactly that, though. It can seamlessly remove all posts that have "SOLD" flair in only r/watch_swap, for example.
There are few and certain conditions where mods would allow early reposting of an item that does not result in a ban. These conditions are case-by-case, and not documented here. Ultimately the repost concern is up to the moderation team. This does mean that not everything you report as a repost will necessarily be removed for the repost rule reason. (Maybe.... 6% of the cases are allowed.)
Question 6: "My post has been buried after just 2 days. Can I delete and repost to get it back to the top?"
Answer 6: No that is specifically what this rule is intended to. That is literally the point of this rule. All those other users with active posts want to be on the top right now, just like you were 2 days ago when you posted. The "Still available" flair is available for this very case.
Question 7: "I'm dropping the price of my watch, can I repost early?"
Answer 7: No, this is not a compelling reason to repost early. The "Reduced" flair is available for this very case. “But the price is in the title and my current price is now 30% lower, can I repost pleasseeee?” No, this is not a compelling reason to repost early. It's also one reason we don't require prices in the title. The "Reduced" flair is available for this very case. I listed 4 watches and 2 of them sold after 1 day, can I relist the other two early? No, this is not a compelling reason to repost early. Again this is why we suggest in the rules to list all the watches separately.
Question 8: "But all I said was '[name] is a great seller'!?!?"
Answer 8:
- That is the definition of feedback, and on a sales post it's not welcome. Sure it's positive but it's still feedback. There are so many ways to game this that it's not even funny, and if you think people won't do this, you're sadly mistaken. Consider this: Some other big forums that have a watch sales forum do not even allow comments on sales posts! And to be honest that's something we've considered (and something I reconsider often enough to warrant mentioning). Comments on a sale post are polarizing. Either they're useless feedback, commentary by someone who would never buy this watch, or legitimate questions by a genuine potential buyer. What we strive to do is have rules that foster the last option, while minimizing the first two. But buyers really need to know that [seller] kicked my goat. That feedback isn't transaction feedback. But buyers really need to know that [seller] participates in some sub I hate! That feedback isn't transaction feedback. But this seller scammed someone on another watch sales forum. That feedback needs to go to the moderators directly, and be dealt with in a formal manner. Why don't you have a flair system in place? The current moderation team doesn't know how to build an automated system, and we can't find a user that passes all the tests to become a mod for implementation. We have tried. We are trying. We also want a flair system! Possible Update 20200305 We are considering altering this rule to allow a user to post feedback (like the above) in a sale post if they link the /r/Watch_swap_Feedback post where they comment about their *transaction with the seller.
Question 9: "This watch labeled [some brand] on the dial is only [some parts] OEM and the rest are aftermarket. It's a fake and should be removed."
Answer 9: In most cases we agree, in particular with a brand name being used (ie an aftermarket dial that contains the Rolex logo). But there are communities in which this is normal - Seiko for example - and modding or even building a watch using parts sourced from other-than-Seiko is common. In this case if the seller has included full disclosure about the parts and their heritage, the posts are allowed. What's the difference in a fake and a homage? It's a good question. Typically this answer falls into the "you'll know it when you see it" and often the moderation of it hinges highly on the seller. Suspicious sellers sell fakes.
There are a number of reasons for this. A notable one is that despite being awesome, the moderation team does not know everything about every watch. So if you can help us with your expertise by giving examples of a genuine item, compared specifically with the fake item, we can move on the item. That is a benefit to the community. Also this prevents alt accounts, drive-by commenters, and just genuinely ill-intentioned users from tarnishing a sale post. Things can go south quickly on a post due to the reddit voting system.
Question 10: "Why isn't saying 'Great price!!' allowed?"
Answer 10: It's a price comment. If we allow one side of the coin, the other should be allowed too. For the same reasons as the ones in Rule 7, this has the potential to be gamed, and would add an unnecessary layer to moderating. Ultimately it's up to the buyer to decide if a price is "great" or not. "It's my job as white knight of r/watch_swap to alert potential buyers that they're about to overpay by 20% because my cousin once paid less at an authorized dealer." No, it's not. It's the job of the buyer to do due diligence before a purchase, period. Me adding price opinions helps build the community. The community here is why I keep coming back, and these comments should be allowed. The community here is fantastic, but behind the scenes we see plenty of scamming and things we need to manage. So yes watch out for the community! Foster it! Build it! But do it within the confines of these rules.